(G)I-DLE ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from LATATA to I WANT THAT]

[@davidk6269]

It is extremely rare (and impressive) that a non-Korean like Minnie has the most accumulated overall lines. This really shows speaks to how incredibly talented Minnie is!

[@slavakaripova2172]

That's happening with Lisa . Lisa and Minnie are expceptanions because they are rich and talented.

[@lem5959]

Ofc She is the first non Korean main vocal 🙂

[@davidk6269]

@@lem5959 isn't Miyeon the main vocalist in (G)I-dle?

[@lem5959]

@@davidk6269 they both are gidle has 2 main vocalists originally it was only Minnie but when miyeon joined 11 months before debut they immediately add her in lineup as main vocal as well

[@davidk6269]

@@lem5959 Thanks, that is very interesting that (G)I-dle has 2 main vocalists! I think that Miyeon has better technique and breath support, but I do love Minnie's vocals--she is unique!

[@chaerryu0]

yuqi need more lines, i luv her voice

[@lushies]

Finally, someone who says that

[@thisischris246]

6:05 everyone else : 📈📉📈📉📈📉📈📉📈📉 Shuhua : 👁👄👁 Edit 1 : 100 likes, TY!!!

[@paradisekiss888]

HELP

[@philip0w0hoang]

Average Line Distribution per song Minnie: 33.4 | 21.1% (-1.8%) Soyeon: 31.1 | 19.6% (-1.8%) Miyeon: 28.1 | 17.7% (-1.6%) Soojin (+2): 26.5 | 16.7% (+7.3%) Yuqi (-1): 23.6 | 14.9% (-1.3%) Shuhua (-1): 15.8 | 10% (-0.8%) Variation: 23.5% (-2.8%) When calculating the variation, former members will not be included when calculating the variation for the line distribution overall. Former members will still be included when calculating the average line distribution and when determining the comparison of all the members’ percentages from overall to average individually but not when calculating the variation for the line distribution overall. This is because K-STAT doesn’t include the percentage for former members on the meter and when doing the fairest all songs line distribution, K-STAT puts up the members on who has the most and least lines and they don’t include former members.

[@matmic0326]

OMG! Shuha for the first time ever is 1st in a song!!!

[@kpopbroughtmehere]

i would have loved to see, at the end, also the total ot5 distribution. because last time you put that too, and miyeon was unfortunately 4. i would have loved to see if she got higher thanks to the last album

[@Ij_ld]

I bet not since 3rd was yuqi

[@eli67146]

Miyeon is first in the total line distribution of their latest album :)

[@kpopbroughtmehere]

@@eli67146 yeah but i would love for her to be at least 3rd in the total

[@kpopbroughtmehere]

@@Ij_ld yeah but the difference wasn't that high so i was curious

[@БориславАмов-ю8е]

Minnie ❤😊

[@KpopFactstopia]

3:10 Yeahhhh, im crying...

[@Love1006-lq1wf]

Yuqi deserves more

[@vampp1e]

For people that are saying that shuhua needs more lines, don't worry,she already said that she agreed with having less lines in the musics (anyway,this still touching me cuz that mean she don't have confidence in her korean/vocal skills :( )

[@czekoladoweniebo6207]

MINNIE 😻😻😻

[@Geminitayforthewin]

Miyeon has more lines!!!!

[@pumpkinnnn2047]

Question: Who's your fav (g)i-dle member? me: ALL ❤❤

[@I_Love_Spiderman374]

A lot of people say that Soyeon has the most lines, but Minnie has

[@kwanyinlau1150]

Love Yuqi and Soyeon the most❤

[@moonchild_1503]

Shuhua needs more lines😭

[@ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM]

She did say to Soyeon that she doesn’t want many lines because she isn’t confident in her Korean and singing abilities 😢

[@user-mizhan]

I think that she got last lines because she is sub vocal and she have more focus on visual

[@ZIMZALABIMZIMZIMZALABIMZIMZIM]

@@user-mizhan I do feel like she’s getting more lines now because Soojin

[@loading..Nebobut2cle2wis1]

슈화는 현재 수진의 대부분의 가사를 부르게 됐기에 부르는 가사의 양이 우기와 비슷하거나 더 많을 거예요.

[@ABIGAIListhis95]

For that she needs more training.

[@babykatzchen]

everyone who keeps being annoying about miyeon is never happy about shuhua getting more lines.. like let this shit go this isnt called mistreatment they literally decide on the amount of lines together

[@gabrielavillarreal9318]

Desde que se fue soojin Shuhua tiene más líneas porque ella tomo una buena parte de esas líneas No es la que más canta pues es sub vocalista pero en teoría con sus nuevas líneas creo que en general tienen una buena distribución

[@toycity6417]

My Yuqiiiii😢😢

[@thundercloudss]

Watching this and realizing that I Burn really stands out of all their records 🔥 And I am kinda sad when Soojin was greyed out

[@briansmagicalfunland]

i thought the same thing

[@antoncutie]

miyeon the best singer 😍

[@no4528]

Facts 😍

[@ivansentosa7699]

Shes okay.. nothin nearing whitney houston s level i mean...so why the fuss about her from the get go ?

[@antoncutie]

@@ivansentosa7699 best singer in the group, are you stupid or what?

[@MeghaliDutta-yj2td]

I hope u know that Minnie was the first main vocalist before debut it's just that CUBE needed a Korean main vocalist so they held an audition and miyeon passed, so minnie was already a main vocalist even before miyeon came. This shows that Minnie has same amount of talent as miyeon. Digest this truth miyeon fans 💅💅💅💅

[@antoncutie]

@@MeghaliDutta-yj2td lmao yall are so salty whenever anyone praising miyeon, i didnt talk badly about minnie lmao... its a fact that miyeon is technically the best singer in the group and its not even up for a debate

[@denizyazgan5127]

I think now, Shuhua gets enough lines for a vocalist like her

[@FerryJoe-lh8ex]

Yes , as a Shuhua stan im happy.. she even got first place!! She used to be 6 all the time , peaking at 5 but now she reach 4 , 3 and 2

[@Levi-xz5xe]

​@@FerryJoe-lh8exthe sad part i guess it all happens after soojin's department.

[@Orangecat1314]

yuqi needs more lines////

[@CyberEJ]

I would have thought Miyeon and Minnie would trade places for 1st and 2nd, with Soyeon staying in third and occasionally moving upwards. At first I was kinda disappointed seeing Miyeon lower down but then I realised something: listen to the snapshot of each song played. It’s Miyeon voice you hear most. That shows she got either the most prominent role or the most memorable role in all those songs.

[@jwhippet8313]

Plus Soyeon is a rapper, so even though she has a lot of lines, they're delivered faster.

[@Jackie_1128]

Shuhua deserves more lines! She got 24 6th places?? That's a lot. 💕💕💕💕💕💕❤❤

[@oktellme239]

She personally asks for less lines.

[@MokuroRokudo]

No

[@oktellme239]

She isnt as confident in her korean, so she aks for less lines.@@MokuroRokudo

[@ZSleepingDragonZ]

Miyeon fans, don't be jealous of Minnie's amount of lines. Miyeon got tons of lines in her solo album. 👌

[@A3RU4Aa]

Fr

[@liz2859]

I'm sorry but like isn't miyeon supposed to have lines in her solo??

[@ZSleepingDragonZ]

@@liz2859 What I meant was that Miyeon already has her solo debut while Minnie has not. So don't be jealous of Minnie's amount of lines in group songs.

[@liz2859]

@@ZSleepingDragonZ ahhh okay!!

[@GarikArakelyan-ne3pv]

​@@ZSleepingDragonZWE CAN AND WE WILL BE..Minnie IS NOWHERE CLOSE TO MIYEON'S vocal level and its a fact that everyone knows.

[@cclime0205]

I thought the most songs line is Miyeon😱, because her singing voice is very recognizable...

[@feeldoxA-ee8wm]

shuhua other songs : i'm on my way~~ flip it : I'M THE WINNER WINNER WINNER

[@Tzuhee_Bae]

Miyeon need more lines as shes the main vocalist

[@avut2001]

Sigh, they have two main singers and one main rapper, all equally important vocal roles, and all three are top three - so why the fuss? Miyeon and Shuhua are not complaining but their respective fandoms - the negative Nellys of Neverland - sure make it difficult to like them.

[@balbabbear]

@@avut2001no,Miyeon deserves because she have better support and vocals that minnie

[@avut2001]

Sigh, why does it bother you so much? Is your life going to improve if she gets a few more lines? I doubt she's losing sleep about it, probably finds it a silly thing to get worked up about, so why the fuss? In the end, there are no proficient vocalists in Gidle, so you're basically fighting over who sucks the least. Technique has never been the most important aspect of pop music, and it certainly not the case in kpop.

[@Ash-ir1td]

​@@avut2001u ate

[@jichhuu]

@@avut2001 fake neverland

[@ЯнаДроздова-к6ы]

Shuhua is at first place with Flip it🥹🎉💖

[@SeohuiCho]

Shuhua now received most of Sujin’s parts,, There will also be changes to her part in the video😢

[@KpopFactstopia]

6:50 What r u waiting for, my Cherry??

[@souadabouelkhier3557]

I love voice yuqi💜 in all songs❤❤

[@notlove1219]

my shushu💔

[@alfonnn]

Es impresionante ver q Shuhua recien en el album I Feel pudo superar la cantidad de lineas q tenia Soojin, realmente se le extraña

[@lucasmillward5310]

honestly hann alone in winter dahlia and maze are some of my face b sides

[@liar9950]

Miyeon is first in Tall trees

[@JIHYO.Y.Y]

Yes

[@woneshot]

Хотя у Шухуа меньше вскго строк, именно она всегда поет легендарные lala lala lala lalalalala в tomboy

[@d_3_ty]

Minnie is the third in i want that cuz she has confirmed that the bridge highnote is hers

[@БориславАмов-ю8е]

Fr

[@mochiiiii7453]

I genuinely believe that Shuhua is a good vocalist. It's just she still struggles A LOT woth korean which stops her from having more lines because have y'all seen where she would sing in chinese? or sing a korean song with easy lines and she's very very familiar with? her vocal skills are crazyyyy

[@rdpa4019]

? but shes not. just watch ANY live stage and its clear that she lacks technique. a lot.

[@hikaru-93]

No - I am a Taiwanese, and I know that she really lacks basic musicality. Her pitch and rhythm are really bad, even worse than many amateur singers. She is born with a beautiful voice and tone but she is just not a good singer…..

[@yenyenmmm]

I always waiting for variance of line distribution at the end of video, why you didn't put it again ??

[@estebancruces9652]

Yuqi in "senorita" XD

[@monamee3248]

Now who will say that Soyeon gets most line?

[@briansmagicalfunland]

idk if this is a unpopular opinion but i burn and i trust are just undefeated THIS IS JUST MY OPINION!!!

[@nemu13741]

To be honest Shuhua really have to improve her rhythm. From the behind recording we can tell she is always struggling with rhythm and pronunciation And she don’t have confidence to sing lyrics out loud That make her pitch kinda lose control sometimes. BUT she’s not even that bad! Guys! I mean! Shuhua is actually good when it comes to Chinese song!!! Yuqi told her to sing confidently but she got too many pressure. We can tell she improve her dance and stage performance so much in last two years. And she try her best to give out all of her energy on variety show. She definitely not a genius who born to be an idol .(except beauty😆) But she work really hard and I know she will keep improving! I’m proud of her🥹🥹 So let Shushu take her time❤️Fighting!!💕

[@林林-u1d4b]

Miyeon need more line❤❤❤

[@Yusril25]

Next All Song Line Distribution Secret Number (Who dis? To Love Bye) pliss

[@michituamor6306]

Creo que HEAT es la era de Shuhua, shuhua te amo

[@leoandreidoria1365]

U put 2 at minnie at number of place on 5th that must be 3😂

[@LeoDoria-yf9hx]

Yeah

[@hikaru-93]

Miyeon deserves more line. Her vocal skills are still the best in the group.

[@Kpop_LineDistribution]

Miyeon losing her main vocalist treatment 😭

[@illegaluser69]

Outdated. Did you even listen to this album?

[@sweetpim]

not this album

[@CJDM310]

@@sweetpim Not in any album

[@ivansentosa7699]

She inadvertantly has become the least fav of em all..just well kniwn of her visuals and sharp nose... nothin more .....even .right below shuhua.. thats why cube decided to cut off her part as the vocalist for the consequence unfortunately

[@MeghaliDutta-yj2td]

I hope u know that Minnie was the first main vocalist before debut it's just that CUBE needed a Korean main vocalist so they held an audition and miyeon passed, so minnie was already a main vocalist even before miyeon came. This shows that Minnie has same amount of talent as miyeon. Digest this truth miyeon fans 💅💅💅💅

[@hectorestebanrios2666]

miyeon only five 1st places??? wtf this is HORRIBLE

[@liar9950]

Actually six times because she's first in Tall trees

[@agirlinpark1018]

right especially as one of the main vocalists and the strongest vocalist in gidle

[@balbabbear]

fr she’s is literally the better vocalist in the group

[@dti_cilly]

I miss Soojin unnie

[@DollysDollS]

PLEASE SOYEON MAKE MORE LINE TO SHUHUA

[@_GRAY_10]

I hated seeing Soojin's bar go grey 😭

[@NDA_Winter]

The tall trees one is wrong

[@ak_studio85]

First❤

[@sripenseubsakwong5520]

❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@Beef_1010]

I just see sy dancing at the end lmao💀💀

[@julesfoury9240]

how do you turn grey Soojin bar please ?

[@Jing.lun._]

Soojin 😢😢

[@xinnss]

please do x:in 🙏🙏

[@krisbrolove]

суджин...

[@jennieemkk3595]

สงสารชูจิน

[@AlexCatable]

Does Cube hold a grudge on Miyeon?

[@SNOOOPYYYYY405]

How Shuhua only got a little more lines than Soojin even after she left after Hwaa😢

[@dee.5975]

But i really love shuhua 😭🤍

[@kokomkar]

shuhua((

[@maykololo]

Sonjin ya no está en (g)i-dle

[@kimbunnyx]

Where is Senorita and I want that

[@CaRaTT_n_STaa_4_Ipen_nd_TuBaTu]

0:58 Senorita 5:34 I want that

[@its_abbyyz]

What about queencard?

[@CaRaTT_n_STaa_4_Ipen_nd_TuBaTu]

4:45 Queencard

[@MYNAMEGIRL789]

Shuhu

[@elifchamzy2928]

Yuqi needs more lines😢😔😭😭

[@DinaHesham-r8b]

Miyeon is a better vocalist than Minnie she HAS to be with the most lines😭😭😢😘

[@MeghaliDutta-yj2td]

Minnie fits lines more and they are both main. And how can you say Miyeon is better when minnie literally did that highnote in I want that, if miyeon was better minnie why would soyeon give that highnote to minnie?? OBVIOUSLY because minnie improved a lot from latata lol Miyeon fans it's not about who is a better vocalist they are both equal it's about who fits the songs better

[@MeghaliDutta-yj2td]

I hope u know that Minnie was the first main vocalist before debut it's just that CUBE needed a Korean main vocalist so they held an audition and miyeon passed, so minnie was already a main vocalist even before miyeon came. This shows that Minnie has same amount of talent as miyeon. Digest this truth miyeon fans 💅💅💅💅

[@DinaHesham-r8b]

@@MeghaliDutta-yj2td nooo I rlly like her vocals miyeon first then Minnie second of rlly like her vocals😘

[@Pitr-b]

Yuqi Is best

[@sweetpim]

how is soyeon first in fall trees?

[@Dkckvisld]

Ikr miyeon is first soyeon is 2nd soyeon has 4secs less than her

[@liar9950]

Yeah, Miyeon is first in Tall trees

[@K-CHART]

K-stat biased dark x file miyeon is 4th and soyeon is 5th

[@AnGeL_larin]

No yuqi is win

[@joy19948]

honestly it should be a 4 member group with equal line distribution considering my, mn, yq and sy have very distinct and unique voices that cover a wide range of sounds and styles and are all very strong in their department

[@luviemha7442]

Honestly Shuhua having less lines then the other members doesn’t bother me, but the fact that the difference between her and Minnie’s lines is over 1000 seconds is crazy. I get that the other members are more fluent in Korean, and I get that they should have more lines since Shuhua is a sub vocalist, but 1000 seconds is insane. And it’s not like her screen time in music videos makes up for it either. She’s the visual with Miyeon but doesn’t get much screen time either. I would hope she at least gets more time on screen along with miyeon as the visuals of the group.

[@SicaRun]

She's far away vocally from everybody in the group, she has huge issues with pitch, she get more than enough lines nowadays, shes also the only member which offen lip sync even if others sing live so she can't handle more lines

[@hamstereatingcarrots4152]

true, shua debuted too early and needs more training. I'm pretty sure soyeon knows what she's doing and is giving shua though little lines but still has an impact on the overall group performance. Don't get me wrong, shua improved sooooo muchhh since soojin left, maybe she'll get more lines in their next comeback

[@thomolivanvar8176]

As the main vocal,miyeon should get more lines.

[@thomolivanvar8176]

@@lushies I guess I know why you are saying that

[@azerhatabahş]

The rest of the members: almost get treated as their position Meanwhile Miyeon: gets treated as a sub vocalist but is the main vocalist Please tell me is their line distributions very equal, quite equal, average, quite unequal or very unequal

[@CJDM310]

Miyeon has never been treated as a subvocalist

[@Ash-ir1td]

​@@CJDM310Right

[@azerhatabahş]

​​@@CJDM310 I meant she didn't get the lines that a main vocalist deserves🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

[@Eugeneman18yes]

​@@azerhatabahşI think it's because sometimes Miyeon's voice doesn't fit the concept they have (Nxde, Tomboy, Oh my God etc), I'm not saying she doesn't fit it, I'm just saying that her voice suits into songs that are more like I do, Queendom, I want that, Latata, Hwaa, Hann etc, so they give most to Minnie when the concept is dark, regardless, their voices are unique

[@MeghaliDutta-yj2td]

minnie is also a main vocalist and soyeon writes all the songs miyeon being third is ok

[@fs_lo2]

Мне жаль Шухуа, почему ее недооценивают 😢??

[@malbi1585]

Вроде Шухуа сама просит мало партий

[@CaRaTT_n_STaa_4_Ipen_nd_TuBaTu]

Yeah so sad 😢 My shushu

[@newnathans]

Last dance was soojins literal last dance 😢

[@kvdhyt]

shuhua.... fighting.....

[@defpeaches]

Celebrating Shuhua's first #1

[@imonlyhuman6674]

Im shuhua im okeyyy

[@balbabbear]

Miyeon deserves more she’s literally the best vocalist in the group but idk why they always give all of the lines to Minnie

[@avut2001]

They, including Miyeon, obviously don't have a problem with it, so why the fuss?

[@jungwoniz]

Because they're both main vocalists and Minnie fits the lines more

[@cacchoipepe4580]

Bcuz both are main vocalist wdym

[@MeghaliDutta-yj2td]

I hope u know that Minnie was the first main vocalist before debut it's just that CUBE needed a Korean main vocalist so they held an audition and miyeon passed, so minnie was already a main vocalist even before miyeon came. This shows that Minnie has same amount of talent as miyeon. Digest this truth miyeon fans 💅💅💅💅

[@jungwoniz]

@@MeghaliDutta-yj2td Minnie is more for versatility or tone. She has a loved vocal tone and she fits concepts. The reason she gets lines is how well her voice fits anything. But she's technically lower or tied with Yuqi, so she's the 3rd best in the group.

[@origamiforyou2046]

I think last dance has a meaning w soojin😢

[@Тёмнаястороналуны-п8в]

бедная шухуа

[@arjunnegi9416]

Oh gog I'm very sad for shuhua when it comes number of 5 and 6 places

[@Zero_Pkxd]

Miyeon dererves more lines

[@carrenoalexisignacio7087]

SOOJIN i miss you so much TT, i will always be OT6

[@YESHIROFOREVER]

Dahlia was her last song😢. Seo

[@opinionisopinion]

Horrible line distribution 😢

[@lachainedestrucsnulle1211]

Bruh wtf what's Horrible for you 💀

[@balbabbear]

fr

[@kasetteart]

There’s definitely worse out there. Take Everglow for example.

[@lachainedestrucsnulle1211]

@@kasetteart Sistar 🥰

[@faberry]

There’s worse out there, Loona and Everglow are good examples

[@kpop-e4s]

shuhua needs more line for real

[@urielhs4726]

She even can’t hold a note live, why the people is obsessed with it

[@sofkafurry]

​@@urielhs4726Shuhua is a very good vocalist, she just has problems with Korean and English. If you give lines of words that she knows very well, you will be crazy about her vocals, she is a very talented person!

[@kasetteart]

⁠@@sofkafurryI love Shuhua but let’s be for real… she’s tone deaf and she can’t sing well. she can’t hold a note. That part in NXDE of “How do I look?” that everyone praised? It’s heavily edited. That’s that. She’s improved but barely. Why give more lines to someone who can’t sing? Not to mention she’s a SUB vocalist. Of course she’ll get the least lines compared to 2 main vocalists, a lead vocalists, and a main rapper.

[@ΜουσικήΙδιοφυΐα]

​@@kasetteartAll her parts are heavily edited lol they take samples from other members' tones to edit her parts. She is the real talentless and I don't either understand what people found in her. She's a total failure and disappointment

[@urielhs4726]

@@sofkafurry Shuhua is an incredible celebrity and a beautiful person, but as an artist she lacks, she’s one of the most untalented idols ever. She can’t sing, the only thing that I recognize she’s good is at dancing.

[@yohanedescends4683]

yuqi will overtake miyeon with their next album. the producer line always give themselves the most lines so if miyeon doesn’t make her own songs then she’ll just be 4th in line distribution since her members dont know how to use her voice

[@liar9950]

i hope she can write songs now, so she can give herself good lines lmao

[@jasmineadams11ja]

Then she should write songs because it doesnt make sense for the people who write songs to give themselves the least amount of lines when they are working hard to create songs.

[@yohanedescends4683]

@@jasmineadams11ja no one said the producer line should give themselves the least lines. but none of them utilise miyeon's voice despite being objectively the best singer and aren't interested in experimenting with their sound too. fans got to hear different sides to miyeon in the english album than the korean ones

[@jasmineadams11ja]

@@yohanedescends4683 Miyeon's voice gets used very often and her voice fits the parts that she sings. So idk where yall get this idea from. She is also the only main vocalist to have a solo in the group. Its so weird when people say that she is being mistreated. On top of the fact that they also choose what lines they want. Yall are just weird. If miyeon has any complaints then she can voice that to the group but its clear that she is fine with what she gets just like all the other members. If yall feel like she deserves more than she needs to start helping in the process of songwriting and making the albums. Other than that the complaining from yall solo fans is getting weird.

[@ja-nk3ep]

Poor Soojin and Shuhua.

[@twicelandyx]

Miyeon is so underrated, she shloud be treated better

[@lushies]

she isn't underrated...

[@ak_studio85]

First❤