Reaction, Doctor Who, 6x05, The Rebel Flesh, Gallifrey Gals Get Wibbly Wobbly! S6Ep5

[@kenj0418]

"What if there was another Paula and Katrina" Me: (Glances nervously at other Doctor Who tab from the old channel)

[@Dasharr]

You said "chips" in the British sense of the word! 100% genuine Whovians for sure.

[@ianpark1805]

They did, didn’t they!

[@MarieAnne.]

They also said fries.

[@MrMaster7112765]

Wow, there are a lot of hints towards the end of the next episode that I never caught before

[@zemoxian]

It just occurred to me that Rory might have a special affinity to the gangers’ situation since he did live 2000 years as a plastic Nestene duplicate. It’s never stated though.

[@zemoxian]

“I’ve seen whole worlds turn inside out in an hour. A lot can go wrong in an hour.” I’ve heard this might be an inside or 4th wall joke as a typical episode is an hour. So he’s describing a typical Who episode there. Though this is a two parter so in this case it takes two hours to go wrong and put it back together, I guess. Spoiler? (Can’t remember if a similar joke occurred before or after this....) There was a similar joke about not landing on Sunday because Sundays are boring. At the time the show aired on Saturdays.

[@Doctor_Who_Rocks]

But a typical episode isn't an hour! It's 45 minutes, which is ¾ hour. Or in the Chibnall and Whittaker era It's 50 minutes. Adverts might make it an hour abroad. But no adverts on the BBC, so 45 + 0 = 45 & 50 + 0 = 50. So that theory you heard doesn't make much sense.

[@Forbidaxe]

Oh dear, Paula is about to be shooketh.

[@bemasaberwyn55]

The biggest WITAF since his 2nd(or 3rdish) regeneration in the New era

[@cargo71]

In the wise words of David Tennant: OH, YES!!!

[@ihateunicorns867]

In the UK, we don’t get that “I’m Amy Pond” bit at the start of the credits (Because everyone here knows what Doctor Who is).

[@waz207]

Those episodes where it’s a small crew in a confined area is known as a “base under siege” story...they became super popular during the 2nd Doctors era, as they were a good majority of his stories...Matt Smith was a huge fan of the 2nd Doctor and thus, enjoyed these type of stories

[@caitlin329]

I think "huge fan" is slightly overstating it -he didn't even remember Jamie's name once lol. He watched and enjoyed Tomb of the Cybermen when preparing for the role.

[@DerekHartley]

Technically they're bottle episodes.

[@alextrill5829]

@@DerekHartley bottle episodes are also kinda light on SFX and props usually. This one isn't.

[@caitlin329]

@@DerekHartley It's less of a bottle episode because it uses different settings. Base under siege is specific for people trapped (usually on a base) and under attack from a threat. A bottle episode is an episode which is usually particularly low budget and relies on 1 or 2 sets and usually just the main cast/a limited cast.

[@michaelccozens]

Could probably also be described as "haunted house" episodes.

[@LuckDragonLair]

I can see it now... The Katrina Ganger then drags Katrina Prime into watching the new show she just watched... and the whole thing starts all over again... :)

[@jamesjohngarner]

A small group of people working in a confined space, and there are imposters Among Us!

[@iaincollins5743]

This episode was a deeply disturbing experience for a lot of us. It was shot at a disused experimental nuclear site, by the way.... I got to stand in as the Doc's 'ganger for the rehearsal and reaction shots.

[@lesterbottomley7641]

So you (almost) legitimately say you've played The Doctor. Talk about bragging rights.

[@Dasharr]

The "small crews of people," thing is carried over from classic Who. Back in the day that kind of story was a regular occurrence because it's cheap and quick to make - not a lot of sets or locations, not a lot of actors to cast. It started out as a production convenience but it works out quite nicely to make tight focused stories.

[@DaleRibbons]

I believe the trope name is 'Base Under Siege'.

[@caitlin329]

It also provides a great environment for character development of the ones in the story, actually. It was always much easier in Classic Who for obvious reasons, but I feel like you get a bit of that in this 2 parter.

[@DaleRibbons]

"I feel like bad things are going to happen". In a Doctor Who story? That's unheard of! :-) Sarah Smart has been in a LOT of shows. The first thing i remember her from was 'At Home With The Breathwaites', where Peter Davison (The 5th Doctor) played her father.

[@DerekHartley]

3:52 Well, technically yes. He literally lived 2000 years of English history.

[@johna5635]

Raquel Cassidy who played Cleaves had previously appeared in a BBC political drama called "Party Animals"... with a guy called Matt Smith!... She went on to appear in an excellent BBC Sitcom called "Lead Balloon" with Jack Dee... and Tony Gardiner - who went on to appear in Doctor Who as well! Bizarrely, the pilot episode for that series also featured an actress called Michelle Gomez!

[@Mrazmatmahmood]

Since this is the first part of a two parter, I'll leave my overall thoughts on this story for the next episode...

[@themiIes]

Just found your Who Reactions on the old channel and LOVED them! Then I saw its only til S04 and panicked. Glad you guys keep doing them here! New Sub!

[@JERBYTUBE]

this 2 parter disturbed me so much as a kid

[@booradley8895]

Two Paulas and two Katrinas,I can't tell you what I am thinking right now

[@cargo71]

You took the words right out of my mouth...

[@ryanakers1372]

What are they gonna do with 2 doctors? Well a certain quote from Captain Jack comes to mind. 😉

[@Gingerprince521]

Paula finally clicking on to the reoccurring base under siege theme, actually made me smile.

[@Mr.-Roybot]

This is a lead up to one of my favorite episodes and I'm all about it!

[@zartig09]

I just realised Night Terrors is episode 83 of 165, so when you get to that episode you can celebrate Paula seeing half of New Who episodes. Almost there.

[@caitlin329]

Wow, strange to think that that's halfway through now

[@cargo71]

And that´s how Voldemort arrived to Doctor Who... I love these episodes, where the most dangerous monsters are us...

[@jamesgreen9480]

Can I suggest life on Mars and ashes to ashes as a new show. Brilliant bits of British TV. The master is in it too

[@jamesgreen9480]

@Grimsby Reapers John simm I think

[@IDidntSetAHandle]

6:20 - Just to help up the Whovian credentials; this type of story format is referred to as 'base under seige', and has been around since the Classic era.

[@zemoxian]

After watching the Doctor’s Wife, might give you an idea of why the TARDIS would land at the location of a future acid sinkhole. Coincidence? Unlikely!

[@airmaildolphin7013]

The Flesh avatars are from the peak of the Uncanny Valley! That's why they are creepy.

[@inspectorhound7931]

At minute seven or so I realized that we've got the woodwind solo that seem strangely familiar. Oh yeah, Blink. Another episode with a mysterious ancient building.

[@FortoFight]

Urgh, now I wanna know what TNG episode Paula is thinking of. The premise of doppelgangers reminds me of the Voyager episode "Course: Oblivion" though.

[@inspectorhound7931]

It's coming up. Sorry, can't tell you the title for spoilery reasons. I will say that sometimes TNG took stands that make me question the Federation's moral compass.

[@Dannydarko27]

Man I was trying to wait to watch the two parts together but I caaant wait no more

[@talgoren2246]

Your conversation reminded me of a David Brin book called "Kiln People". where people constantly use a technology very similar to the one in this episode, except the double are purposely independent, they know the are not real and they only last for 24 hours. at the end of their existence, their memories can be downloaded back to the real person. people basically use that technology to improve their work load, the real person stay at home and have fun, while the double goes to work/school.

[@ianpark1805]

When Katrina said “Love cats” did everybody else get The Cure going “Do d‘ do do do d’ do... in their heads? No? Just me then? 😂😂

[@caitlin329]

It's constantly in my head on a loop with Close to Me anyway tbh

[@joshuaoehler5796]

It's called a "base under siege" story. Happens throughout the history of Doctor Who.

[@1nelsondj]

This one reminds me of a Star Trek: Voyager episode.

[@bemasaberwyn55]

The demon planet?

[@hornist34]

Waiting? Seems appropriate.

[@bemasaberwyn55]

When I started this episode, I had no idea what I was getting into

[@sylvn1988]

Two doctors huh? "I can't tell you what I'm thinking right now"

[@NoelNole1221]

Always found this a very interesting 2 parter . Not my favorite but still very good and really enjoy what it leads into, already looking forward to the next reaction! 🤓

[@Mr.-Roybot]

Oh my god! I think I know the episode of TNG that Paula is talking about!! And now that I think about it, _yes_ !

[@iz723]

Which one

[@Mr.-Roybot]

@@iz723 the one with Thomas

[@iz723]

@@Mr.-Roybot who's that

[@iz723]

I actually think the ep that it reminds me of is the one where there's two Rikers

[@Mr.-Roybot]

@@iz723 That's the episode I'm talking about

[@firefly24601]

It's still weird to me to see Mark Bonnar playing a family guy just trying to get back home to his kid. I'm used to him playing either a serial cheater, or the stereotypical unhappily married man who fakes happiness for sake of appearances.

[@davidmckie7128]

Sorry Paula, but French Fries are Fench Fries and Chips are Chips. You should try a Chip Butty (two slices of buttered bread with Chips sandwiched between them. (with salt and vinegar). It doesn't work with French Fries.

[@jonathanross149]

Paula...get your revenge. Make her wait.

[@SebastianWeinberg]

DoppelDoctor or Doctorgänger. Both are acceptable.

[@arekschneyer3802]

Loved this reaction! I'm super excited for this season! and the next one!... and the next one... ok I'm basically just constantly excited now. that's fine. I will admit to missing TNG at the moment though. I've been re-watching season 3 and will Love it when I get to see your reactions to them! Stay safe, stay healthy, and enjoy yourself!

[@hothotheat3000]

Finally a side character takes a shine to Rory instead of Amy. His wife is so awful to him most of the time and I like to see him appreciated.

[@JustJames83]

Do you think they had cats on Gallifrey?

[@katearcher8514]

My mandatory recommendation to read David Brin's 'Kiln People'. Same ideas and topics, much deeper, longer and more profound.

[@christianwise637]

You know, if you ever get tired of reacting to stuff, you could just film your cats instead. It'll probably be way easier, and chances are you'll end up getting even more views by doing that. As the start of a two-parter, I think this episode is rather solid. It has a pretty creepy atmosphere, and has some lovely moments of gooey squelchy body horror. There's some nice moments with the companions (I love the fact that they wind down between adventures by playing darts and listening to Muse), especially Rory who gets to show off how kind and compassionate he is in his scenes with Jennifer. It isn't the most original story - as Paula mentioned it does feel very reminiscent of the Silurian story from last series - but it is a generally decent start to this story, complete with a pretty good cliffhanger

[@ptcarbonproductions2013]

Behold, the most boring episode of the Moffat Era until Mark Gatiss had a certain idea.

[@AlbionOfAvalon55]

why does this flesh people oddly familiar to what Cassandra was (End of the world) Paula look a like Isabella Blake-Thomas from Secret Society of Second-Born Royals

[@Richard_Ashton]

don't know - why does it?

[@seanred7681]

I'm kinda with Paula, I'm not really a fan of this story because the concept is just creepy - I guess it's appropriate with Halloween coming up. I have a feeling if there were two Katrinas and Paulas, we'd need the Doctor because something bad would happen, probably a war over custody of cats lol. ;)

[@Precise-Sight]

"Rebel Flesh".. i remember watching a porn with that name !! Don't ask details please.. !!

[@IggyStardust1967]

Oh, no.... you don't just drop a bombshell like that and NOT give details! Out with it!

[@bemasaberwyn55]

@@IggyStardust1967 damn beat me to it

[@jonathanross149]

Part of the Anna of Arendelle series or reactions.

[@Badusername2000]

again, one of those episodes where the only reason anything actually goes wrong is because someone had to act like a moron and try to kill something that didnt need killing

[@cassidyuk]

Ain't it just the Base under Siege episode? Anyway really am enjoying watching your reactions.

[@reynolds8960]

Can you get uk chip shop chips?

[@desoliver9712]

Where's star trek season 3.... I'm THUUUUUUUUURRRRRRSTY!

[@Richard_Jones]

Didn't like this episode when I originally saw it way back when. But I find it gets better with age, uklike myself.

[@Tyranniod]

I agree.

[@dodofren]

I don't know why but this two parter was just not my cup of tea. Always skip it on my rewatches.

[@iz723]

Same, good premise but a bit weird and drawn out

[@caitlin329]

It's grown on me I think, actually.

[@titomito2081]

Can you react to the vampire diaries?

[@samtheking25]

The new We Watch Who sucks so much