Game Theory: The Mystery of Minecraft's Haunted Discs (Minecraft)

Get Your New Back To School Theory Wear Here!! ► creatorink.co/tw-yt
Today Theorists, I aim to solve another one of the many mysteries of Minecraft. We've explored a lot already, but with a game this big, there is always more to find. Take the music discs, which are the objects you find randomly throughout the game when you do certain things. Except, there are two discs in particular that peaked my interest - Disc 11 and Disc 13. The two "corrupted" discs that, when you play them, sound like something from a horror game rather than Minecraft. What is going on with Discs 11 and 13? Let's find out!
SUBSCRIBE for More Theories! ► bit.ly/1qV8fd6
Get the game here ►► www.minecraft.net/
Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ► share.epidemicsound.com/MatPat
SUBSCRIBE for Every Theory! ►► bit.ly/1qV8fd6
Hang out with us on GTLive! ► bit.ly/1LkSBnz
#Minecraft #Enderman #Disc11 #Disc13 #Corrupted #Haunted #MinecraftTheory #Theory #GameTheory
More THEORIES:
The TRUTH About MINECRAFT’s World! ►► goo.gl/XySv1N
The END of Princess Peach! ► bit.ly/2CJuYbm
Minecraft's Ending, DECODED! ►► bit.ly/2d5o2Ky
Mario Kart 8, Mario's SCARIEST Game? ► bit.ly/2wyeell
What's Diamond Armor Worth IRL? ►► bit.ly/1Q5xhmM
Credits:
Writers: Matthew Patrick
Editors: BanditRants, Tyler Mascola, Dan "Cybert" Seibert, and Alex "Sedge" Sedgwick
Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman
Sources:
minecraft.gamepedia.com/Music...
www.minecraft-france.fr/le-se...
minecraft.gamepedia.com/Ambience
minecraft.gamepedia.com/Timel...
www.minecraft.net/es-es/artic...

[@gaydes1012]

and who would've known that the sweet tunes I was cranking in my epic base held so much hidden lore

[@dinghyval]

Matpat: Uncovering creepy, disturbing, dark lore that destroys my childhood, burning it into a fine ash and burying it deep underground to rot and wither and eviserate and die in a fiery inferno, never to be seen again as I feel my soul being ripped from the seams and following my childhood to the depths of the earth, screaming, shrieking, as it get's dragged down to the dark, destructive unknown. ...but yeah.

[@mrrobertthomas3903]

timeroller 😂

[@undercovertunnel8262]

timeroller if you were cranking disc 13, you have to have problems lol

[@undercovertunnel8262]

scorched_mango 62 lmao yeah

[@itsdrizzy-_-9391]

Aww man

[@sarahlarose2997]

pewdiepie: *minecraft* jack: *minecraft* matpat: *minecraft* internet: *minecraft* markiplier: *heavy sweating*

[@slendreraffy5441]

Markiplier is now onto rolbox REEEE

[@justacomenter9735]

Roblox!

[@bertoandon9681]

Roblox

[@fanciernessa]

Mark: roblox it is

[@mathiasj8182]

ROBLOOOOOOOX

[@SiriusRise]

Disc 11... Is litteraly the embodiment of fear Parrots: so anyway, I started dancing

[@thereporterofroblox294]

🆇🅳

[@obi-wankenobi2851]

Lol

[@metalhead1790]

They're G R O O V I N

[@hero-scout9397]

Proof that parrots are demons

[@obi-wankenobi2851]

@@hero-scout9397 yes

[@hyperspacestorm]

13: ok a little weird, aside from cave sounds and someone running from a creeper. 11: slightly broken disk that gives off creepy vibes 5: completely shattered and sounds VERY frightening

[@Marilynn_1275]

It does, and as to where we find the disc fragments? The Ancient City.

[@hyperspacestorm]

@@Marilynn_1275 I was too caught up on the disc itself that I never made the connection. Slightly embarrassing

[@jr7762]

Matpat: “After all discs can’t be crafted.” Disc 5: Hold my beer

[@kitkatpita6703]

69 likes heck yea

[@the_seer_0421]

@@blossomicblossom7 I'm sure they knew that

[@Dr.STorch]

Mate yer a wee bit late on that one

[@whoasked6696]

Well.. Disc 5 is kinda weird bc you’re not crafting it by putting other items like stick + iron + wood. You’re just combining the disc itself

[@trebleclef9844]

@@whoasked6696 true, its just fragments of the disc which you repair

[@natechavez2069]

kids these days dont know just how terrifying herobrine was

[@Bartholomew3]

Oh I do

[@Bartholomew3]

😬

[@lake7381]

Building the spawner and deleting the world right after lmao

[@dravyn4124]

I fckin know righhttttt

[@colors1653]

Bro they’ve removed him like 15 times and he still in 😳

[@starridreams4653]

Herobrine? *Puffs smoke* I haven’t heard that name in years.

[@pprinter]

Yeah same, especially with this stupid hold to spam your weapon feature.

[@braxtongeorge8038]

I remember those videos where you would be able to spawn Herobrine. I was always sad when it didn't work.

[@sourcherry5619]

He’s the reason why I was scared to play in survival

[@mafkarr1892]

Mr. Dragon Master you shouldn’t smoke in front of kids

[@supersentaikyoryuger5744]

Herobrine isn’t real it’s put in as a joke

[@mehsayori]

Fun fact: While 13 is the same in the game as it is in the OST, 11 is completely different. Instead of being the horror that it is in the game, it's actually a nice and relaxing track in the OST.

[@sharkshrek4154]

it's like Greenland and Iceland

[@Chaosh21]

Potential theory, in the game, disc 11 is broken, snapped and ruined, in the out we hear what the disc sounds Iike when not broken

[@alchemysaga3745]

​@@Chaosh21In that scenario, the version of 11 _could_ hypothetically be the person overwriting the old version of disk 11, in order to record what is going on. Now that we know the caver would have been an Ancient Builder, that's an option.

[@Hero-pw7wp]

Everyone: Disc 11 and 13 are terrifying Disc 5: Hold my random Item sounds

[@fatuadedipe4589]

And the fact that the parrots still dance to them is out of my knowledge.

[@Some-oz6gh]

"Disc 11 and 13 is the most disturbing discs in game" Parrots: *MUSIC IS MUSIC*

[@LowYummy]

Benjamin Wilcox no it would be MCCU, MineCraft Cinematic Universe.

[@fleckster6903]

@Benjamin Wilcox totally

[@ezekiyam3827]

Lol good one

[@bellalalala3327]

@@LowYummy ooh smartie

[@zephyrash]

@@LowYummy We already have a MCCU, It's not too well known though. It's the Marvel Cinematic Cat Universe. Some people have a hard time drawing humans, they created the MCCU so they could still enjoy creating Marvel content.

[@orbit7486]

You left out two details that I picked up through the discs. When he finishes coughing, you can hear a “shh” in the background. It’s not a creeper sound, meaning that it was possibly a SECOND person telling him to be quiet. It was too late, however, and the monsters found them. Then you can only hear one person’s footsteps, meaning that one of them could have gotten killed. When the arrow supposedly “hits it’s target” it could be killing one of the two people. I know I’m late but I wanted to put this idea out there.

[@caprisuncatcaller6994]

woah

[@anon515]

yoooo thats actually so good

[@firestarwaca8336]

I thought I also heard an enderman...

[@hoodiekid9356]

I heard that too!

[@ayyo238]

Dude ur so smart props to u king

[@timothyeichstaedt8007]

After hearing this, disc 11 and 13 are the events that occur when the player is escaping and when they hit the water. Once they hit the water, a form of trauma from the fall causes a delayed form of amnesia that occurs while they are traveling. This results in the player “spawning” in a new area with no previous knowledge

[@joseph_soseph9611]

That actually makes a lot of sense. My first thought was that the creator of the discs is a different survivor descended from the old civilisation who eventually died or disappeared, but your hypothesis also explains why the player, who is depicted as an adult, wakes up in a hostile world without any items in their possession and no prior memories. This wouldn't make sense if it were not for the events on the discs, making them lose their memories and possessions.

[@GoblinGaiety]

I'm gonna need an in-depth analysis of where the new music disc "5" that is coming in 1.19 ties into this STAT. PLEASE. Although if you want to wait until 1.19 comes out so we have a better understanding of ancient cities (and namely what the center structure is), I understand. But yay the lore continues!

[@Jawed-24]

As for my theory, I think that disc 5 comes before disc 11. When we hear disc 5, we notice that the character is walking inside caves towards the ancient cities and trying to open a portal, but he encounters the warden and tries to escape from him through the portal .... and here begins the story of disc 11 inside the portal

[@elliswebster7041]

@@Jawed-24 wow 😲 5 comes before 11? Who would’ve thought

[@bruuuuuhhhhhhh]

@@Jawed-24 Yk what’s cool, if you use the discs 5, 11 and 13 exactly those seconds apart, so 5 at 5 secs, 11 at 11 and 13 at 13 they tell a story, I’ll link a video for it, but you can try it yourself Video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/l4DFY6emnqebd5Y

[@dialupdude]

Disk 11 plays Players: Omg this is so creepy Parrots: *Dancing Happily*

[@bonifacio-garcialuigi1635]

Can someone tell me the name of the song in 1:50 ??? Thankyou

[@caionakamura3745]

@@bonifacio-garcialuigi1635 try to out the audio in google

[@bonifacio-garcialuigi1635]

@@caionakamura3745 im using phone so i cant do it

[@andotus7637]

The parrots work for satan

[@matthewlockhart7804]

There groovin

[@biq5743]

this man has the special ability to remember his shower thoughts

[@caleblewis8169]

He probably keeps a water proof laptop in his shower to record them obviously.

[@CrabOnABeach]

I have that ability too tho

[@lockthecageheshere1982]

Truly 3p1c it truly is amazing

[@TheEnderLeader1]

And also to just casually hit your nostalgia buttons and then just keep on talking like nothing happened.

[@jmorris207]

How Herobrine was born

[@jalapenobee]

The paper rustling could’ve also been someone reading as if he was trying to do a spell with the fire, or he was looking for something in the cave

[@Svnshine3_11]

I love how MatPat’s editors add edits that make me go back to updates after the videos come out and I’m like “Wait a minute… they added moss, and he said ‘Creepers are moss bombs’” And they added moss in 1.18 Now that may not sound like an edit but still, they added moss *MOSSBOMBS.*

[@guffythefluffy3013]

Peoples worsts fears in Minecraft. 1. Disc 13 2. Disc 11 3. Creepers with arms.

[@dlcforces8165]

4 creepers in my house

[@tippedjoshua6802]

Herobrine isn't a thing in mc

[@e_laz2620]

Listen man, cant forget those cave sounds

[@theinsaneone8975]

hell boy demonization

[@fyre_xd]

Aw man

[@elliebrown5990]

You guys remember when they used to put “herobrine has been removed” in like every game update

[@striver2180]

Yes

[@bananaraptor7747]

yee doggie

[@x-platainum-tattletail-x5536]

Yep

[@hmmnope9231]

Do you have any herobrine storiesnthat you or a friend experienced? I was alone in a world I had for a couple of weeks, had a small house with a basement carved out and a few chests and torches for light, far from collecting diamonds. But as I hover over my chest facing the outside of my house I see a name tag pop up like it would in multiplayer, like a little grey tag with no name as I had to get closer for the name to appear. And then I saw it shrink down like the player had crouched and the nametag disappeared. And suddenly in my 0 slot of the hotbar, a enchanted diamond sword appeared. I looked at its enchants and it was a "God sword" so I had to go see if whoever was out there was still there, and he wasnt. But I saw my nearby forrest on fire and strangely the fire only burned the leaves, and then went out on its own. This was on a single player server and has never been open to lan, so Im surprised I even have a story to tell.

[@russianinvader2560]

Lmao I never really knew what herobrine was but if they removed it it kept coming back or something.

[@TheGamingDoggo]

“They can’t be crafted or anything” The warden disk: “allow me to introduce myself”

[@jestfullgremblim8002]

@Spacetime dizq

[@Solrac34]

Your not really crafting it your repairing it

[@IrregularityRowan]

bbg this was posted in 2019.

[@coryjamieson3171]

Those music discs were so creepy and mysterious that even MatPat had to step in to explain these discs. I also loved how Monika from Doki Doki was featured in the intro, although she likely has nothing to do with Minecraft right?

[@mrpancake8023]

I think all of you are missing the biggest question Why the hell can't you craft a saddle

[@tripaloski_6971]

Yeah i mean it's leather with some string

[@raahilkhan1004]

@PanicingAnimal shame

[@Spineless-Lobster]

Chloe Wiggins I think you used too with leather and an iron ingot but the got ride of it.

[@tacmfd]

When my friend found that out he screamed so loud it scared me

[@Sirdeathvids]

Not sure, but they are easy enough to get if you go fishing enough

[@animatedmoomoo4080]

If you listen to disk 11 reversed at one point you can hear a distorted DONT DO IT like so matpat will see

[@finnormond9364]

Animated Moomoo we need to get this to his attention then!

[@julianoabi-samaramagalhaes3294]

0 0 -

[@buddybud_bud]

Also at the end of disk 11 I hear like an enderman sound or something

[@MrOrzech1]

Is there any video showing this?

[@animatedmoomoo4080]

MrOrzech ya by a channel named zaff box I think I didn’t hear it at first but someone mentioned it in the comments

[@nimblejarl7635]

I absolutely did listen to it as a kid but instead of being scared, I was intrigued and thus here I am as a theorist. Finally glad someone solved this, thanks.

[@AnnFlandermeyerKirwin]

11:39 I was at 13% battery when I saw this😂😂😂

[@unparamount]

AND THERE IS 13MIL VIEWS HOW THE FUUUU

[@AnnFlandermeyerKirwin]

@@unparamount 13 seption😳😳😳😳

[@averagemushroom]

Let's get this to 13 likes

[@AnnFlandermeyerKirwin]

Yes!

[@Ahmad--Edits]

We're at 8

[@RomiiPringle]

MatPat: "The comments had loads of theorys." The comments: *Did Mat mine grass with an axe?*

[@Dr.ShadowC]

Lol

[@robloxplayer-xt7oc]

I love you

[@ninjajulian1884]

Best comment by far.

[@pokelordomega1701]

Yes

[@2_loser]

Me: NANI?!?

[@nightshine_]

“They’re not made by Endermen. They’re made by men. Menmen. Humens.” Yes, Matthew.

[@aezzil3536]

Feminist: Say sike right now

[@stracklyshot]

Mmmm yes, the floor is made out of floor

[@1Vivi007]

You speak the language of the Gods

[@maxwell7223]

MICROWAVE MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM

[@maestronomus7695]

Yeah its big Brain time

[@meevalshine157]

Can’t wait till you make a video about music disc 5!

[@pokeling2225]

this was my first ever video i've watched on game theory. Thank you matpat for letting me flex my minecraft knowledge.

[@ShayTheValiant]

Everyone's gangsta until the ambient cave noises play.

[@skate4986]

True

[@bop9132]

So true

[@annemirfakhraee6587]

Sometimes you crap sometimes you dont

[@cooliedudeo6551]

The cave noises freak me out

[@maximlachap958]

As a young kid I didn't ever go mining in single player because of that.

[@kiwithechillbirb7594]

People: “Why do parrots dance to dance to disc 11 and 13 they are so creepy?” Parrots: “ *MUSIC IS MUSIC* “

[@jpoy16]

69th like

[@Passalobr]

RARE wubbox your scary too you are KEEP saying LER MONSTERS OUT TRUST IT OVERFLOW LOWER THE VOLUME

[@wowiehatestohru7273]

MUSIC

[@kiwithechillbirb7594]

@@Passalobr I’m not rare wubbox I’m Undead Gamer

[@dinonugert]

lol super true

[@michew5451]

With the new-ish deep dark, the two discs may have come from that biome, giving off clues such as the warden screaming in 11 and the adventurer making too much noise, leading to his death.

[@burna.k.a.turtleonalog4327]

Disc 5 is a new one, but you have to reassemble the disc to make it and it has marching, cuts off in the middle, and has running, heavy breathing, and coughing, and a strange lullaby in the middle

[@mcredcreep]

Disc 11 or 13: *plays* Players: *scared shitless* Parrots: they're groovin

[@Vergil38]

True xD

[@jmpap1094]

Ik right

[@jmpap1094]

Parrots are like immune to the 11 and 13 disc's

[@the_pug_of_doom398]

I’m dead

[@Stryker_VII]

Ye

[@Chakar04]

*Disk 11 is just Steve smoking weed and running away from the cops*

[@logeannesbrio691]

Haha! 😂 That One Made From Scary To Funny Now!

[@user-kx8pu6ys5i]

@Adam Aboushady *what do you mean?*

[@TC127_]

@Adam Aboushady *like this*

[@F0rever_zer0]

Hello

[@Chakar04]

@@F0rever_zer0 sup

[@saltinecrackerss]

The fact that he just solved an unsolved mystery makes me wonder if he could solve the Old Root ARG

[@tuxedeoboi9155]

Me when watching fnaf videos: great, I understand less now Me when watching minecraft theory videos: oh yeah, it's all coming together

[@cyruss6536]

Real

[@Johnsmith-pw3rn]

“What happened to the civilization?” “Gone, reduced to Endermen.”

[@shork3954]

Why the thanos reference 🤣 lmao

[@BonniebossGaming]

There are ender dragon heads in the end city so they killed the dragon

[@bigboyrob9946]

Perfection right there pal

[@MagmaBombe]

Bonnie boss Gaming who says they arent fake?

[@hypnoticdude]

@@BonniebossGaming r/wooooosh?

[@jahjahbinks8069]

Everybody gangsta till the parrots start dancing to disc 11 Edit: thanking people for likes is gay no cap

[@prajaktadandekar9297]

Nick Gurr Oh fu*k. you are right

[@pipikyyy625]

Just imagine parrots eyes started glowing and hes starts to ascend As He dances to 11

[@chuwucate5751]

@@pipikyyy625 then megalovania

[@JustJum]

@Kimo De Groote completely unrelated.

[@pipikyyy625]

@@chuwucate5751 i would shid my pants

[@draugr905]

Idk who else feels this way but even obviously hearing a creeper is scary because of the impending doom, the sort lighting of the fuse sound it makes at the beginning I find to be really really satisfying. 9:50

[@GlitchyTSP]

Something that came to mind. If creepers are supposedly artificial in some way, what if the disk dropping is related to some sort of recordplayer-esque timing? Bit of a stretch but hey!

[@audreyperson9221]

"Who's Herobrine mum.?" "Where did you hear that name?" "It was in my recommended in youtube. " "Take a seat, Alex. Today i'm going to tell you a story."

[@giovannimassa8881]

Herobrine, haven't herd that name in a long, long time.

[@jessicakitchens2113]

Lol

[@whydoineedthisB]

*You close your eyes in order to imagine what is being said* *Then you open your eyes...* *intro to skyrim*

[@joshuasimpson4021]

ɹɐǝʍs I ǝƃɐssǝɯ ʇǝɹɔǝs ɐ ʇoN _Hey you. You're finally awake._

[@mirai9242]

@@joshuasimpson4021 lol

[@rwade9664]

Matpat: running from a creeper then falling into water Me: having fallen kingdom flashbacks

[@chairking2759]

R Wade not to mention that in the fallen kingdom music video a skeleton shoots 3 arrows at the king before the scene where a creeper blows up the bridge and he jumps into the water.

[@viva6235]

OH MY GOD! I'M GONNA PISS MYSELF

[@Ze_Internet_Man]

anyone getting revenge flashbacks?

[@foxykj1987]

R Wade why did you have to remind me of that sadness ;-;

[@actualgarbage8549]

@@Ze_Internet_Man no

[@venom6909]

my theory: there was a species before the ancient builders who made the discs. but when the ancient builders arrived, they saw how scary the disc sound was. so then they decided to smash it and that made the evolution of disc 13 into disc 11.

[@harmtiemens9079]

Disc 11 sounds like someone building a nether portal and lighting it, then goes through, checking a book and running over (black)stone and then netherrack. Or exiting the nether for that matter

[@tovuu]

*so are we not gonna talk about the thumbnail and the creeper having arms?*

[@Erw9296]

Omg ur right

[@KasaiBuru]

Nubs :()

[@bluegloop8023]

Creepers with arms... Now they can grab you then explode

[@bluegloop8023]

@Eldrich Mario David wut? Are you think something you shouldn't? Tsk tsk tsk Dirty mind

[@symphora4454]

Creeper

[@hellointernet2276]

Beginning: HeRoBrInE aNd EnDeRmEn Ending: so it’s actually just some guy in a cave

[@SPADE-de1wk]

Actually its multiples of people

[@rep-vile]

I think that Herobrine very likely was part of the old tribe that built the stronghold and made the end portal and all that. What did he do and what happened to him then? I'm not too sure.

[@FUNKYZUNK]

I’m getting some serious deja vu

[@SPADE-de1wk]

Maybe a certain mob changed the human herobrine to the now herobrine

[@iamdying9339]

It can be herobrian he WAS a human I mean

[@paulhawes8629]

"nearly died today. A zombie tried to eat me so i took a bite out of them instead." thats what it says in the journal. bruh.

[@Gh0stData27]

Hope he soon talks about disc 5, 11, and 13 being played together.

[@hannasoffan1120]

Me: *Sees Herobrine* 10 year old me: *Heavy sweating*

[@theskullboy8700]

Aaaaayyyyyy the seizure eyed bastard was a jerk

[@Korotan_]

Ikr I’ve personally seen him while playing mc on Xbox when I was young

[@deanpai7787]

My sister: Why don’t you play Minecraft anymore? Me after hearing disk 11: That game can change a man...

[@Banksran]

EAT THIS!

[@lovexdeath1636]

The sister: but brother I want you to teach me how I’m a noob at it DeanPai 778: sis let show your why I did play it Her after hearing 13: Okay my childhood is ruined

[@codenameasura]

Yeah

[@midnightsparrow1071]

Lol not me do

[@tinamarvin9851]

WHAT DID YOU DO TO DEKU!!!!

[@goldminecrafter]

TGT: "After all, they can't be crafted..." Minecraft: Adds Disc 5

[@keramkeramovich8699]

minor detail: the arrow sounds in 13 are actually the old arrow firing sounds, you can check on the "Removed Features" (Java Edition) page on the wiki

[@tryhard007]

Play disc 11 and 13 at the same time they go together

[@kleptophrenia4125]

I was waiting for this. Hope he sees this.

[@oldgreenknees1205]

Wtf make a 17 minute KZbin video about this and have merch please

[@ltdatboi6374]

yea boi

[@markmartin2204]

He did

[@tryhard007]

@@markmartin2204 did he realy when

[@randomkidonline294]

Notch watching this video: *“Huh, i never thought of that”*

[@grantjenkins01]

I was just thinking that. There's no way there's lore this deep in Minecraft.

[@JiuWei_Mic]

Lol

[@aarontheperson6867]

@Papi Oof I think it's referencing how he used to own it, and how he's the one that added these discs and stuff. (I know he didn't make them tho lol)

[@thisismyaccount9048]

If he came back to this now with the discovery of how 5, 11, and 13 sync he'd have a field day

[@ProwlinThruDaPraries]

I just remember discovering the disc and freaking out in a panic because I heard the running and was so scared because obviously nobody but a player running makes that sound effect

[@pokemonfanclub4907]

Disk 11 is actually MatPat running in and copying Scott Cawthons new lore notes

[@TheFlamingManiac1100]

Gosh damnit

[@Georgialeaxx]

Lol what a great meme belongs on meme review

[@harrylane4]

@@Georgialeaxxmatpat is enough of a POS without being on a racist channel lmao

[@boydvalli9191]

I'm still a kid!!

[@boydvalli9191]

I'm 8

[@InstaFiz]

“You don’t even have hands, how can you hold this in the first place?” It gets more ridiculous. They can climb ladders.

[@shadelight320]

Strong legs

[@jackofalltrades8412]

Lol

[@moonbearman8231]

Telekinetic powers

[@purevessel6026]

Excuse me

[@looneyllama]

You have 69 likes

[@noahvonstrandmann5158]

Theory: the enderman were the ancient builders. They can pick up blocks and inhabit every dimension

[@thesweatychild]

I just realized something: When you kill an evoker, they don't pop the totem, but when you kill it it drops it, so maybe the reason the illagers do raids is for souls that in turn are used for totems that would give them immortality. like this so matpat can see

[@JUDASOFFlCIAL]

everybody gangsta until someone plays disc 11

[@jeffjeff6160]

disk 13 is the worst

[@Light_3209]

@Sweet Cake Shy Its creepy!

[@ori-onyxvyntarz3276]

They never really scared me. I don't know why. I liked the fact that 11 seemed to tell a story.

[@alastorthedemonslayer4257]

Try playing them at the same time at night in a cave

[@sarahtwitt]

When i was a new player, my friend renamed disc 13 "chirp" (my favorite disc at the time) and gave it to me... I had a heart attack

[@spudlord7743]

There is nothing more terrifying than the cave ambiance sounds

[@sir_rodent]

I remember I was playing once, I had just watched a video about herobrine and I had just loaded up a new world, as soon. As I spawn I hear a cave noise on the surface and delete the world

[@senoevil8085]

OMG YES. Agreed!

[@willowwilt691]

*Shudders

[@urielbudy2498]

*pickaxe surprisingly breaks in a dark place*

[@Buggular]

sirrodent AKA Jonny Foster Same thing happened to me except I didn't touch Minecraft for a whole two months after that I was terrified

[@itstime9023]

i know it is kinda late to say but.... i never thought i would love back-to-school merch so much with such a smooth transition

[@averyblurryduck749]

excited to see where the heck disc 5 goes into all this, the wild update is rly keeping with the name right now

[@gdmobilerobtop6661]

8 year old me when something strange happens in minecraft: "HEROBRINE"

[@ArgS_T_]

Yasss just amazing have you ever thought I'd Minecraft story mode was part of this

[@redwolf8581]

When i had heard about Herobrine on a video when i first started playing Minecraft i wouldn’t play for about a day

[@PBM24]

Dinkleberg...

[@gdmobilerobtop6661]

@Mike Kimel noones even using pusab

[@marcelinatavarez4159]

Creep er AWW MAN mat you should have said that

[@zgjimrrahimi8286]

Mojang: *watches this* hmmm... I never thought about that

[@cytard]

MOJANG: write that down

[@gundom3445]

Well if they didnt think about they wouldnt have added the two disks and released the lost journals book

[@firecracker8474]

Zgjim Rrahimi That’s The Exact Same Thing Scott Cawthon Did Lol.

[@vextea1503]

I thought about it and then conviced myself minecraft was a story the player wrote.

[@SeaFazzer]

I personally think he broke it himself (with a tool) so no one would have to hear the horror he found down in the caves. I'd have to listen to the full music disk myself but I highly doubt a creeper would have blown up that close to him, to a point where it blows up the disk but leaves him un-harmed.

[@AJpenguin712]

13:42 the book said: Day 1407 Nearly died today. A zombie tried to eat me so I took a bite out of them instead. Would not recommend. Day 1408 Nearly died again today. Starting to notice a recurring theme here...

[@amansaad360]

Disc 11 : literally the word "horror" itself Parrots : this is music to my ears

[@konamicodechinesehacker2405]

Idk

[@thegayone1911]

Parrots just think it’s music we’ve made and don’t want to make us feel bad. They don’t want to hurt our feelings by saying our music is bad. They are so cute

[@wendy790509]

Parrots = disc 11 = hell horror

[@WarmBreadBearBuddy]

Am I stupid for believeing that pigs would actually dance to Pigstep?

[@WarmBreadBearBuddy]

@@wendy790509 it’s H E double toothpicks, keep it family friendly.

[@chxrlies.angels]

Mojang: H-He’s figuring us out... h-how Scott: First time?

[@lunaevergreen3117]

Charlie Lamphere honestly😂😂😂

[@plus_cosplays]

Omg I love this 😂

[@vukovii]

XD lol

[@mizee6917]

lmao

[@marley9800]

Scott is figuring matpat out

[@rottenroads1982]

4:12. Heavy: “I fear No Man. But That … Thing. *It Scares Me.* “

[@reanaa]

Well done, sound reasoning, and the pace is perfect.

[@markdieeyeguy3569]

Game theory: *releases new Minecraft theory* Microsoft: WRITE THAT DOWN WRITE THAT DOWN

[@shrikeyman5156]

MarkDieEye Guy haha yeah lol I don’t think mojang intended minecraft to have much lore

[@enricovangelderen6464]

hoi

[@crusadertsakos4638]

If there was a realistic minecraft version, singleplayer would have been a horror game.

[@aliyahplays]

CrusaderTsakos soul sand...

[@fabiotacconi9230]

i'ts already one now that i saw this video

[@peterjohnDuenassparta_88]

Isnt it already though? Skeleton, Zombie, Silent motherfucking creepers, Endermen Pigmen. Even with the simple graphics, They're very scary and Bone Chilling

[@phillysapphire603]

@@aliyahplays Tell MatPat I want to see if this ties in

[@benjaminhazell9417]

SPARTA_88 nah you’re just a wuss.

[@applejuice5162]

What if the scrambled book language from enchantments was just their language and they were so advanced that they could fit a whole book into one little page

[@jangajdos1693]

And now we have the Disc 5 awaiting a theory…

[@darthyoda4934]

NEIN NEIN NEIN GESCHLAFEN NEIN NEIN NEIN NEIN AHHH DUDUUDUD DOOOÖF?

[@jangajdos1693]

@@darthyoda4934 I’m afraid I don’t speak the language of your tribe Lord Yoda… please use the Google translator and enlighten me with your wise words.

[@darthyoda4934]

@@jangajdos1693 oh sorry about that the translation is “ yes yes yes I very much agree yes yes yes “

[@calethni]

*My therapist:* Creepers with hands doesn't exists *Game Theorist Thumbnail:* Creeper with hands

[@yellowdeeemond8099]

BartekQ8905 game therapist

[@friedtoads13]

BartekQ8905 I was gonna comment the same thing lmao

[@user-wv2rz1xj8x]

If you put a space in between the e and r in "therapist" it makes "the rapist". What has been seen cannot be unseen, you're welcome

[@spicy8182]

Day 1407 Nearly died today. A zombie tried to eat me so I took a bite out of them instead. Would not recommend. Day 1408 Nearly died again today. Starting to notice a recurring theme here...

[@301davo]

4// itchy tasty.

[@captain_noo]

dont know what's the point of this since we can just pause it but ok

[@delinamackay3709]

666 likes

[@Deadmau195]

When the creeper blows up, it could destroy any important lore hidden in the discs in the explosion. How convenient...

[@THEkillerking000]

Heres something no one mentioned, how were the music disks recorded? Because you dont just use the disk as the actual recorder and there doesnt seem to be any traces of technology that can record sound in the game

[@jamnraquel]

*Minecraft: Rated E for Everyone* *Game Theorists: no, we don’t do that here.*

[@flippyfrogman]

Raquel Nieto-Tyler it’s actually E10+

[@tulikachatterjee8787]

Lol

[@pbroshhh1349]

galaxy star124 e

[@spungbopscarepans]

Save me I am scared 8|

[@pandasforlife434]

Yeah just listen to cave sound 17

[@toastgaming7892]

Fun fact: not only did disc 11 end at 1 minute and 11 seconds,it also ended at 111 miliseconds.

[@CallmeEno]

Pog

[@Yumi_-mv3kl]

wtf- *_That's_* why it's named 11!

[@susdj]

People who actually take care to listen to disc 11 through an audio editor

[@toastgaming7892]

@@Yumi_-mv3kl Right!

[@gearbxcket9589]

EA why ur Making emeralds so cheap and games expensive

[@Azarilh]

Also, the disc cat is the first disc added, together with 13, and you could get it only from creepers. Which are connected with cats as you know, which is a curious connection.

[@ThatDigitalDemon]

"It can't be crafted after all." Disk 5: *hold my beer*

[@fireballme1153]

(puts 13 in jukebox) Parrots: THIS IS MY JAM

[@NICK-zk6tk]

CREEPER

[@jpinello8258]

Awww man

[@ikealoki1509]

J Pinello So we back in the mine!

[@tylerirons3984]

Swinging my pickaxe from side to side

[@halofan0064]

Side side to side

[@thetruebaloney117]

Mat pat: * still talking about Minecraft * Me: * waiting for game theory theme song *

[@tesalanthealmightypasalan5545]

Games? Then theories

[@camilothechameleon7758]

WHERES THE THEME

[@aaronaaron9492]

666 likes... OOPS

[@timtomas6109]

I know I am late by a few years but in Minecraft: the island the main character is blown up by a creeper and launched into a water pool, than gets out out and hides behind a patch of dirt. I find that that little odd detail seems to parallel disc 13. I cannot remember if he was struck by an arrow or not as my books were destroyed in a flood but I think he may have been as there were multiple mobs down there. In disc 11 you can hear flint and steel lighting a fire and paper rustling, and in the island he mines a few blocks and finds coal as well as it being revealed later that what you are reading is a journal left behind by him. From what I can remember is what I have pieced together and I may have missed a lot of detailed.

[@ericamerson9473]

You can always leave it to theorists to make the lore for you.

[@dying_ken]

Matpat: “WHAT IS THE SECRET ABOUT THE DISCS?!?!” Notch in Dream's video: “Oh, yeah, I forgot the lore of that discs.”

[@Llamacorn87]

Ohhh Dream

[@blackpanther300.]

Where did he say that in his video?

[@shalinchada5940]

Ohhhhhhhhhhh geeeeeeeeeooooooorrrrrrrrgggeeeeeeee

[@luda.chrisotzz]

lmaooo frr i was finna say that rn

[@Name-bk1oy]

Lol

[@yuriwashere_1385]

I swear he could talk about people eating donuts and I’d be scared af

[@theouterlimits1]

Underrated comment

[@mayia_rat9469]

You should watch Food Theory then 🥲 some of them are pretty spooky

[@Zyokanin77]

You must be a scaredy-cat then

[@aoife.e.d.927]

BUT THATS JUST A THEORY, A FOOD THEORY!!

[@axlr8deathpls294]

@2024 student7 Trueeeeee except this only applies to me when I am scrolling around youtube at 4 o clock in the morning with my window closed on matpat's scratching sounds scaring the life out of me, honestly should just grind for burgh in pokemon blaze black 2 cuz this is way too spooky for me, I would rather fight a soul dew latios in gen 5 rather than having a creepy youtube video with scratching noises on my not very transparent window which also has a dark shadow covering it, yikes

[@priestofsyrinx6681]

I am three years late on this, but the sounds of the creeper explosion plus the arrows are the classic sounds (from when the disc was released) rather than the modern sounds that were included as comparison in this video.

[@calebanimates9525]

"Nearly died today, A zombie tried to eat me so i took a bite out of them instead"

[@abbiler3242]

developers: how complex do you want the lore to be notch: yes

[@Annvivian1]

Dicscy Dicscy gimme my whiskey Actually, Diamonds please

[@tashyboi]

9 year old me: *sees random cross* *scans surroundings* Me: *whispers* HEROBRINE...

[@albinofrog7347]

ME!!!😂

[@flyingace0075]

Bro sameeee

[@izzylevi.]

LMFAOOO why is that so me tho-

[@gogglez8012]

MEEEE

[@horrorbeats7858]

The cross in the ground means entity 303 not herobrine

[@StaryGalaxyGacha]

the last part changed so fast that my brain can't process with your speed

[@BrenToons2810]

11:00 “creeper” 13:00 “game analysis” I hope “creeper game analysis isn’t a secret MatPat

[@placeholderplaceholder6056]

You have to remember that back in alpha the creeper explosion was different then it is today. The sound back then was IDENTICAL to the sound heard in disc 13 Edit: Holy cow! This is the most likes I've ever gotten! Thnx guys!

[@user-wl3zk6kj3q]

and arrow sounds

[@Jordan-4554]

creepers and tnt.

[@midgetman2350]

Same with the arrows

[@tarrinmoore6460]

And the sound of players they would make oof

[@cyno_atlas]

Who still remembers those videos on how to spawn Herobrine? And who immediately deleted those worlds out of fear?

[@cookzy]

Miss Chocolate LMAO I REMEMBER DOING THESE THINGS WHEN I WAS 9

[@cyno_atlas]

@@cookzy XDD ikr

[@Monahearts]

I remember watching my brother trying to do it, and I cried.

[@ari5101]

I do

[@civil9404]

I once was so scared as I kept hear someone building one block sometimes, found out it were my sheep's eating grass

[@chicken4699]

Me:disc 11 and 13 is just the mobs in game nothing to fear about My brain:yes My brain at 2AM:the disc is about herobrine.