GARY BROOKER: IN HELD 'TWAS IN I, (FEAT. B.J.WILSON & ORCHESTRA), MUNICH, GERMANY, 1980

[@sammuniz5360]

I've always loved Procol Harum since the 60's when I was young and foolish. Now my only claim to wisdom is that I know nothing. But Procol Harum eases the pain of getting old.

[@alejandroizuzquiza2546]

You´re dead right, chap!

[@christineoosthuizen4388]

True!

[@alejandroizuzquiza2546]

Rest in peace, Gary! Send our very best regards to B.J. Thank you ever so much for decades of fantastic and so elegant rock music.

[@bobwaldeck631]

That song brings tears and chills, love PH and still can't believe he is gone but music last forever

[@jeffreybooth5129]

I totally agree

[@paolacimone4882]

Me too........❤❤❤❤❤

[@hschmitt3667]

A masterpiece of music history R.I.P. Gary

[@growinguppg]

What a masterpiece version! All the rock musicians on top of Gary and BJ are excellent too. Thanks a lot for posting!

[@P.DuncanMonk]

Gary Brooker and Barry Wilson at their finest. IMHO music does not get better than this. Thank you so much for this gem H.Braunschmidt.

[@leighgoldstein3119]

another one I missed. The conductor is hilarious fixing his pants! Thank you again for these posts. I love this piece so much. It has been with me my entire life.

[@SirCamsmorethanalot]

Gary carried the Bach/Mozart/Beethoven/Wagner gene and was an underappreciated genius.

[@maciejgajda1518]

Beatiful, never heard this recording before. Many thanks Hermann

[@kyriacosavraamides9861]

Imagine he was in his early twenties at the time He wrote and performed.Brilliant.RIP Gary Brooker

[@Geopholus]

Yeah, and don't forget this Album Side was a collaboration with Keith Reid Lyrics (monologue), and organ parts by Mathew Fisher, including unassailable original lead guitar parts by Robin Trower.

[@pjhgusto]

Actually Matthew Fisher wrote about half of this.Not just played organ. Including the insanely beautiful GrandFinale. Not to detract from Gary.

[@8trakmusic]

A masterpiece I fell in love with this composition in 1968 and it still movess me in 2022. Gary in suberb voice. The guitar player is excellent.

[@P.DuncanMonk]

Yes the guitar player was fantastic . I do not know who he was but he should have become their permanent guitarist .

[@Geopholus]

@@P.DuncanMonk , He would have made a superb regular,..Paul Vincent is the lead guitarist on this.

[@bertbecker7532]

B.J. was so underrated.

[@bertbecker7532]

John Giblin on bass, Morris Pert of Brand X, Mel Collins all great.

[@theesbband]

I wonder if this was the only time for this line-up? It’s incredibly good: Gary’s extraordinary voice is a thing of wonder, as always. Does anyone know how this line-up came about? Thanks for posting: this is real, difficult, satisfying music, extraordinarily well played. Judy brilliant.

[@h.braunschmidt214]

This is what I wrote on the Eberhard Schoener projects for BTP about 20 years ago: procolharum.com/99/hb_rmc1.htm, procolharum.com/99/hb2_rmc.htm, I hope this will answer most of your questions. Thank you for your interest !!

[@apostolosannis198]

Oh man! what a GEM!!!! - thank you so much. It really raises a question why on earth none of these are available officially and why PH. never bothered to release them throughout all these years...

[@ericvanhavelte1611]

Hé was 35.

[@musicplateau1]

Proud of you Gary, you carved songs out of the air.

[@dwaynewladyka577]

I love this performance, very much. May Gary Brooker rest in peace. Cheers! ✌️

[@Avrillo-gf7tx]

Gary Brookers vocals are incredibly beautiful. BJ Wilson sadly hidden mostly but you can hear him at least. I’ve always loved the 2nd side of their 2nd album, mostly for these epic tracks. I couldn’t stop crying when I first listened to “this” when I was 13 or 14. Their music touches hearts and souls. I feel this group saved me from deviancy, homelessness, and Kept me SANE! Oh wow Gary and BJ…..

[@parkinsonalzheimer]

A masterpiece for eternity

[@darrylbray6919]

Barry trying to imitate the harpsichord with his cymbals Amazing recording,Brooker vocal extrodonare as always

[@culturaglobal7875]

Sorprendido por la cantidad de joyas musicales que tiene este canal. Gracias por difundir. Nuevo suscriptor desde Caracas. Un abrazo.

[@marcuskeulertz5852]

Si,es cierto hay un monton de joyas Musicals en YT. Procol Harum es una de las bandas británicas exelentes. Me gusta desde mi juventud. Ahora tengo 52 años.

[@bertman316]

Gary. BJ. hat's good enough for me! Thanks for uncovering this hidden gem!

[@jeffreybooth5129]

Thank you so much for this.I have had the pleasure of seeing this performed live on two occasions (The Rainbow and the last concert at the London Palladium).This is certainly an epic Procol Harum song ,and Gary was well supported on this performance.

[@johnxjen]

At 2:47, the oboes come in way too early. That's the sole issue I have with this. Otherwise, fantastic work.

[@timriley4543]

Easily one of the greatest bands of all time.

[@michelallain1087]

Un grand moment à chaque fois que j'écoute cette magnifique cette magnifique composition ! Bravo Procol Harum !

[@massimomarchesin8708]

Capolavoro!!!!! Masterpiece GOOSEBUMPS WOW!!!!!!!! Fantastica performance live con orchestra!!!!!! Una pagina della grande musica moderna , brano IMMENSO consegnato alla STORIA della musica contemporanea!!!!!!!

[@patricklemeur4607]

oui, on est tous émerveillés , un fan .....magnifique ..

[@patricklemeur4607]

le son n'est pas très bon, mais GARY> est très grand, magnifique!!!

[@patricklemeur4607]

absolument fantastique , Gary Brooker estv un grand compositeur et chanteur , cette vidéo est un régal.......

[@michaelmakes1225]

Another video where B J is almost ignored....the fucking tuba player is getting more attention..😮

[@brucegelman5582]

Thank you, thank you, thank you for saving this from oblivion! DANKA!

[@FelixPando]

Amanzing ❤❤❤❤

[@LarryPennisi-vp6ue]

Always incredible

[@MothershipOracle]

an epic which will question the listener's very existence, if the listener has a mind to look deep enough.

[@ramonmacedo7036]

Pease ! would some person write the lyrics from " In held ´twas in I "

[@patreid100]

Goodness me ! 😮 How were you able to refrain from uploading this for 42 years ?! Fair dues.🙏

[@MegaCirse]

I just turned down the temperature in my house after hearing that; It's cold outside, it's cold here but maybe I don't want to be hot!

[@JohnnyTalia]

Not as tight as they were live at Edmonton in '69, but pretty close.

[@JackPonissi]

Hermann, you had me glued to the screen, thank you for this. Had no idea Gary ever did In Held outside Procol! This was from the original Rock Meet Classic concerts, right?

[@h.braunschmidt214]

yes, than called " Classic Rock night" . Not to be mistaken by the highly commercial belgian/dutch format established in the late 80s or early 90s. See the details here: procolharum.com/99/hb_rmc1.htm

[@Geopholus]

Jack Ponissi, No# 1 fan and great emulator of PH, nice to see You here. Hermann thanks SO MUCH for this video ! Brooker and B.J. rock out here with the fabulous support of the other musicians. Especially enjoy Paul Vincent on guitar . This is a very tight performance really considering the huge number of musicians. Missing Gary and Keith Reid. Saw them so long ago ,... but each time seems like just yesterday. Whatt an Amazing Album side, and epic performance. They were the 1st and last to do something like this, because they were unique!

[@JackPonissi]

@@Geopholus miss them indeed…I was playing some PH earlier today and still can’t believe there won’t be more

[@Geopholus]

@@JackPonissi , Pretty sure, you and I, will be keeping their flame burning as long as possible,... my son age 37 LOVES them equally.... for me the 1st three albums are the best , but plenty of good things in many of the later Albums... I can hardly believe they are gone, the world just feels like it is missing something.

[@JackPonissi]

@@Geopholus we will! Great to hear about more people my age liking PH, hopefully younger ones will come too

[@tbbb2]

I can hardly believe what I've just seen! I have waited about a half a century to see video of a live performance of this one with a full orchestra--------it was worth the wait!!! The people in that hall that night were, without a doubt, the very luckiest people on the planet that night! This is sensational....thanks to all those who finally got this performance on to a platform like this.

[@paolacimone4882]

Sicuramente ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@ericvanhavelte1611]

Dit optreden was in 1980 voor mij de reden om een Betamax video recorder aan te schaffen. Nooit spijt van gehad.

[@aadrockt1957]

rip b.j wilson best drummer of all time...great song of the record shine on brightly....this song is never seen on dvd i believe to bad and rip gary brooker ofcourse

[@P.DuncanMonk]

His style could not and cannot be matched. I saw him play live 3 times. Each time I was totally gobsmacked.I have seen so many of the greatest drummers and B.J. has and always will be my favorite.

[@TecsPlusLLC]

Gorgeous!

[@predicationst405cp]

It's still a stunning piece of music... but the sound mix could be better. For more emotions play the edminton version.

[@carolward3105]

I miss you Gary Brooker!😭

[@karimebutte4852]

Cada versión de este tema es profundamente hermosa

[@alaincelos476]

The great Procol Brooker Fisher Wilson Trower and Knight one of my fave so wonderfull top playing of rocK scene

[@patricklemeur4607]

salut Alain , je reviens souvent sur cette vidéo, malgré un son pas très bon, vraiment BROOKER est une bête !!...le concert du Canada n'avait pas été filmé à l'époque, mais nous avons quand cette belle vidéo1980!!!

[@alaincelos476]

@@patricklemeur4607 salut Patrick .oui procol c est fini .Brooker était un super pianiste,compositeur et chanteur mais je préférais Matt Fisher qui avait un son et un professionnalisme unique ...j étais en contact avec Carol Fisher ...des gens simples .bonne journée.

[@franabreu7594]

I Liked. Very Good!

[@berndgruner8510]

Danke für .Das Konzert ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@dougmphilly]

Morris pert and BJ together??

[@andreaf.g.rascher5292]

Thank you very much for this gem

[@mikemolino1919]

Such an amazing song

[@patricklemeur4607]

la musique de PROCOL HARUM est puissance ....

[@gkdeppe]

Chills up my freakn' spine!

[@eisbaerbel]

Ich wußte nicht, daß es diese Aufnahmen gibt: Gary und B.J. im Jahre 1980 ! Tausend Dank fürs teilen, hoffentlich kommt noch mehr...

[@ВикторЛюлькин-ю8ь]

Gary Brooker Lord !!!!!

[@giuseppegiliberti2341]

Grande suite pop

[@rhuffkeys]

It's all so simple really, if you just look to your soul ☮️

[@berndgruner8510]

Ich Danke. Für. Das.Video ❤❤❤❤😂😂😂

[@parkinsonalzheimer]

Gorgeous

[@jowox]

Thanks for a rare upload!

[@patricklemeur4607]

GARY BROOKER est un compositeur , chanteur , musicien unique , un mec extraordinaire par sa musique......

[@paolacimone4882]

Senza dubbio ❤🎼❤️🎼❤️🎼❤️🎼❤️🎼❤️🎼

[@carolward3105]

Awesome footage! Thank you for your donation!

[@patricklemeur4607]

ok, merci!!

[@patricklemeur4607]

MAGNIFIQUE ::!!!....

[@radmilajevremovic1736]

Збогом драги и непоновљиви гари . . .

[@patricklemeur4607]

magistral ,!!!!ok! GARY ......

[@apostolosannis198]

Dear H. Braunschmidt, are there more songs of Gary Brooker from this performance? incredible...

[@h.braunschmidt214]

there'll be more !!!

[@apostolosannis198]

@@h.braunschmidt214 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙

[@bertusduiverman4743]

What a find! Thanks for posting!

[@gliedo]

Thanks a lot!! great

[@BH530711]

The historical significance of this performance cannot be denied. A true masterpiece in every sense of the word. Thanks so much for uploading this gem! 🙌🏻

[@minaton5242]

Vielen Dank! Der Ossi!

[@graziadesilvi4811]

❤️

[@joseantoniorios8182]

Can someome please confirm the lineup ??

[@h.braunschmidt214]

confirmed…..

[@joseantoniorios8182]

Hi Herman I meant who played in addition to Gary B and BJ Wilson tks

[@h.braunschmidt214]

@@joseantoniorios8182 please read the video description, all information supplied ! Best regards Hermann

[@joseantoniorios8182]

@@h.braunschmidt214 upps thanks !!