Gatsby Shoes Review, Are They Legit?

[@j1nx3d5]

I saw a FB ad for these shoes and decided to look them up. While googling these shoes I found your yt video and find the exact same range of shoes for sale on Temu with the same stock photos except on Temu the material is advertised as PU. Great review video btw. I won't be getting any.

[@TheDadBod]

Glad I could help!

[@glennelliott4989]

I don’t watch fashion content much but I’m subscribing to you. I like your vibe, my man!

[@TheDadBod]

Thanks!

[@ExecuMutant]

Thank you for your review; these shoes get a hard pass from me because of the lack of cushioning/support, cheap materials, and sketchy claims.

[@RoadsideRC]

Thanks for sharing! Saved me some headaches!

[@TheDadBod]

Glad to help

[@tropicalstarburst7364]

Very helpful, thank you. You pulled me back from gambling on a pair of these.

[@cms7479]

My "everyday" shoe is a pair of Rockport Oxford slip ons. My $80 and looks good with jeans or slacks. Plus all the comfort in the world.

[@TheDadBod]

I might have to try them out

[@timhick6]

Just ordered a pair today

[@chrisholland8226]

I would tend to agree with everything in the review about the quality of the shoes and the expectations for the price. I wouldn’t agree at all that the style is something that isn’t “formal enough” for weddings, court, or board meetings. Maybe in 1950 that was true, but in 2024 this is a natural evolution in style. The company I work for had 1.3 Billion in revenue last year and our 72 year old President & CEO along with many other board members in their 50’s and 60’s wear stylish dress shoes like these. The days of the boring old man stuffy shoes are gone.

[@CredibleHulk10]

Own a pair. They are great, as long as you get the better soles... The standard are paper thin.

[@robind5387]

My son ordered these shoes, waited 4 weeks for them to arrive and the soles separated within 3 months. Not worth the money for that short amount of time. 3:17. I have pics but can't figure out how to add them.

[@TheDadBod]

Wow

[@solidale21]

I wish i had seen this video before i bought my pair. I bought a pair of "Gatsby" shoes from Amazon because they were cheaper. I understand why now. I figured it was just a knock off and bought from the actual website. Now I'm waiting on the new pair to arrive but going based off of this review I have a bad feeling. They also are trying hard to get me to affiliate market the shoe 😂 idk if i could stand behind this if they are just as bad.

[@tinmoths]

I assumed 'orthopedic' was a reference to the fact that the insoles were removable - you can put your own orthopedic insoles in

[@nejinaji]

They did the classic talking too much to make the lie convincing. I wasn't suspicious of them until they tried putting so many positive Facebook posts about them and so many "reviews" with pictures

[@TheDadBod]

Yup

[@rickclark4714]

What are the go-to suits under $500, or even $400, now in 2024 for fellow Dadbods?

[@TheDadBod]

I did a couple videos on my suit tailor. Might be what you’re looking for.

[@OCBev]

Absolutely horrid customer service. Not based on the looks. The sizing is not true to American sizing. Not even close. Off by MULTIPLE sizes. They will not stand by their product and want the customer to pay for returns($20+) PLUS they tack on extra fees for credit card fees, “administration” fee and who knows what else there will be. Definitely a Buyer Beware.

[@TheDadBod]

Already donated mine.

[@lifetimeskills]

Rubbish shoes. And they are not refunding. the sole fell off.

[@TheDadBod]

I dropped mine off with a bunch of clothes at the VA.

[@bsampson5192]

Crap

[@TheDadBod]

Yup

[@saulmarquez3604]

Hello sir, I like your video review very much. This helped me and Informed alot from these products. But I like to ask, if you have any chance to review this new product called “Head & Shoulders Pyrithone zinc dandruff shampoo 🧴 Bare minimal ingredient shampoo (soothing hydration)” I was thinking of buying it but I’m not sure if this will make my dandruff worse or is it require a conditioner…. But this will help me understand if is a good product for me or for others. Hope you have a good day and I’ll wait on you to make this new content idea 😁 keep on the great 👍🏻 work

[@TheDadBod]

I haven’t. I guess I’m a bit overdue for a followup to my dandruff shampoo and my underwear video. I’ll try to get something on the schedule.