What if Carl Grimes SURVIVED! If Carl Grimes Lived in The Walking Dead Season 11 Rick Grimes Returns

[@GeorgeDrakeGD]

NEW VIDEO! What if Rick Grimes DIDN'T LEAVE!? kzbin.info/www/bejne/sIHQY4drYt6bm8k What if Glenn SURVIVED in The Walking Dead? kzbin.info/www/bejne/haqTaYOQg5l-f6c MAJOR CHARACTERS RETURN! This is who Carol said came back on the radio kzbin.info/www/bejne/f33cdomJjrGlras What if T-DOG SURVIVED in The Walking Dead! kzbin.info/www/bejne/poemmWWKlKiGZ5Y What do YOU think would happen if Carl lived? Who would YOU switch out for Carl? What other characters do you want to cross over like Morgan? Are you okay with what actually happened? Let me know what you think down below. Thanks for watching. I'll see you soon. Press the LIKE button on the video if you enjoyed it and subscribe if you're new, thank you for your support!

[@fiend2society]

Who would I switch out for Carl? Tara.

[@tomongvue6934]

This is a very unpopular opinion, but can you do Lori? She was the main leading lady until her death and she was not well liked. So can you give her a better character development and character arch with redeeming qualities?

[@usenamer3635]

@@fiend2society nah, judith

[@yousefelsamnoudy7624]

i would switch out probably michonne or edith

[@Lister-Nah-id-win]

Kid this is Minecraft you don't bury people with a shovel, you place it

[@JTMConceptions]

That would be such a poetic end. The series starts with Rick Grimes looking for his son. And the series ends with Carl Grimes looking for his father.

[@TheAmazingAdam]

In a perfect world we'd get this. Man, so disappointed in the show that they killed Carl off. I lost so much interest after that episode I just couldn't believe it.

[@Bluntman-J.P]

The thought of how perfect that would of been makes me sad now...cheers bud xD Mad how tone deaf writers and developers can be these days though heheh

[@writingjake6684]

Jesus saith unto him I am the way the truth and the life no man cometh unto the Father but by me John 14:6 Psalm 46:10 Be still and know that I am God. I will be exalted among the heathen. I will be exalted in the earth. For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son that whosoever believeth upon him shall not perish but have everlasting life. John 3:16 Matthew 16:24 King James Version 24 Then said Jesus unto his disciples, If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me. Jesus saith unto him I am the way the truth and the life no man cometh unto the Father but by me John 14:6 Psalm 46:10 Be still and know that I am God. I will be exalted among the heathen. I will be exalted in the earth. For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten son that whosoever believeth upon him shall not perish but have everlasting life. John 3:16 Matthew 16:24 King James Version 24 Then said Jesus unto his disciples, If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@hahacrackhead4100]

The Show ending with Carl saying. "I'm looking for my family " as he searches for michonne and rick. 😢

[@KevinZavala-g7f]

@@hahacrackhead4100 broooo stop 😔 it pisses me off to no end the missed opportunity

[@rexadex7269]

Keeping Carl in the show would have kept the soul of the show. And would probably felt more like the walking dead going forward

[@angelawhatley7298]

I really think if Carl survived, then losing Rick in season 9 wouldn't have been as devastating as it was. To have Carl and Judith together would have been really awesome! I would have loved that to have happened.

[@greenscreenmovieguy5582]

Honestly I wouldn’t even mind if they retcon it and it was a crazy dream Rick had

[@angelawhatley7298]

Same

[@X525Crossfire]

I think in "Rest in Peace", he totally would have been the one giving Judith a transfusion and then carrying her out, both like Rick did for him after he'd been shot in S2.

[@angelawhatley7298]

@@X525Crossfire Yass! I would have loved that! It would have been a surreal full circle moment

[@basically_boring]

@@greenscreenmovieguy5582 i think that would be the first time where a retcon that makes no sense would be acceptable

[@marshalmarshall2109]

This broke the show for me, mainly because Carl WAS supposed to be the man to carry on after Rick's passing, and he symbolized the hope for the future, idc what the show writers or even Chandler Riggs say, they shouldn't have killed Carl.

[@freshmjc1369]

Pretty sure they killed him off cuz he didn’t want to be on the show anymore

[@primenationgamer5710]

@@freshmjc1369 that’s not true they screwed him he even enrolled to a local college near the set but they change to script on him last minute decision like almost every time they kill a character off always a last minute decision , because since he got older they didn’t want to pay him the same amount as the other cast so they wrote him off . That’s fucked up

[@iammask1073]

@@freshmjc1369 Even if that was true they could have recasted him as that would be a much better choice than killing the character completely.

[@freshmjc1369]

Lord y’all realize you don’t have to all @ me and say the same thing 💀 I just said what I heard before but actually lost respect for waking dead directors after that

[@nathangallegos9304]

Sure the kid had to go to college. They could’ve gone his own separate way and have a new series beyond the walking dead and have Carl the age of Rick grimes

[@rexadex7269]

Also, the Morgan idea is brilliant. I remember watching the show when it first came out, afraid for Morgan because it made sense at the time for him to be killed. When Carl died it felt like I lost the show I was watching, not the character himself. Such a wild decision.

[@johnuhtred]

Morgan should have died. His character absolutely killed fear the walking dead.

[@sillygoose42069]

I would actually pay like 500k to see more Carl with Daryl and with Judith and with michonne and rick

[@jonathanpanetta]

Would’ve made the show better than it was

[@TheOneTrueClovehitch]

Honestly I doubt it. Season 9-11 were too dogshit for one character to save.

[@johnsimpson9859]

Even if they had to do a time, skip and replace the actors, I wish they would’ve kept Carl as part of the show

[@captain4318]

Disagreed. He was a decent child actor, but as he got older the acting got worse. Carl being dead on the show was a great thing for that reason alone. I cringe at the idea of Carl having the Negan story that Judith now had.

[@bigstevedzn2353]

@@TheOneTrueClovehitch what the fuck are you smoking. Seasons 9-11 were great. Just because they weren’t season 5/6 doesn’t mean they were dog shit. You people annoy me.

[@WASWAPgt]

Trueee

[@AfrimGjonbalaj]

Imagine the Season 2 Episode 12 scene with Rick and Carl in the barn playing in a world where Carl didn't die on the show. How powerful it would be for him to understand the lesson his father was trying to teach him. Especially after Rick blew up the bridge, or even if AMC chose to do the comic death... it cuts to Carl as a young man recalling the memory. "No more kid stuff. I wish you could have the childhood I had, but that's not gonna happen. People are gonna die. I'm gonna die. Mom. There's no way you can ever be ready for it. I try to be, but I can't. The best we can do now is avoid it as long as we can, keep one step ahead. I wish I had something better to say, something, something more profound. My father was good like that. But I'm tired, son. (Hold the gun out to Carl) Please take it." - Rick An adult Carl could have had a badass look too. His fathers Sheriff hat, slick back hair like Negan, an eye patch like the Governor, Alphas ouroboros belt buckle, the red machete, etc. I'm still a diehard, day one Walking Dead Universe fan but It's painful to think of the missed creative opportunities regarding Carl.

[@DanDeOndeugend]

Feel you bro. Fuck Gimple.

[@johnuhtred]

That's awesome, and I'm with. I often binge watch the waking dead, but everytime I get to the middle of season 6 after Carl gets shot and rick takes on the hoard, I know the show is coming close to transforming Carl into a cuckold. It's Pathetic what they did to his character and painful to watch.

[@wednesdaay_]

​@@johnuhtred This!

[@rexleroy]

Don't forget about Rick's murder jacket

[@HUNKMrDeath-lt7kq]

I’m honestly not surprised, there should atleast be some military faction left with a small enough portion of the government now effectively combatting both groups and zombies by the time Season 3 starts. For example, did you know Call Of Duty Ghosts has a shitty ass depiction of a actual U.S special forces group that exists (I think COD Ghosts was trying to depict them, that or they just chose the name Ghosts.) called Ghosts, their operations are so secretive that there’s only one unclassified file on one, the rest of their ops are completely classified. The military should adapt to Civil War tactics to, cease using vehicles, and using suppressed weapons to decrease the sound of their weapons firing, although this wouldn’t completely eliminate the noise of the gunshot, it would be quieter. Ontop of this while head shots realistically are WAY harder to land than shown in the show, these are decomposing corpses were talking about, the Military would realize only headshots work and advise the remaining units to take caution after gunning down a horde (The rounds depending on caliber and various things would likely be tearing off limbs and such.) any zombie that still has a head or a head with out a hole, soldiers would be advised to pike with a bayonet attached to their rifles.

[@laurettelaliberte8864]

btw, I do agree that Carl's death was one of the biggest missteps of the show. Should have never happened.

[@MHrickgrimes]

They knew that Rick needed motivation to keep Negan alive, and so Carl’s character arc and death was unfortunately pigeonholed to fit that narrative. It was a major Gimple misstep, if the many he’s made. And during the time jump, I could see Carl being more of a leader at Alexandria and allowing Negan to be out of prison briefly as a sort of work release in the garden - similar to his vision. And while agreeing with all you’ve said, I would differ on the ending and actually see Carl staying behind for Judith and RJ - especially since the rest of his family are gone, and Uncle Daryl is going off in search of Rick. Could see an ending where Carl is actually communicating via by radio, with Daryl and Carol and Maggie/ (even Morgan, who doesn’t have to die) - possibly turning radio on everyday at sunrise. And then you could have the ending monologue with Rick and Michonne, as it was. Followed by Carl, standing with Judith and RJ on the fence, saying the poetic lines of “We’re all out there looking for our family. Because we’re the ones who live.”

[@uchihaability]

Daryl and Carl were an underrated pair, too. When they went through the tombs in the prison after Lori died, the two of them had pretty good screen chemistry, even when Chandler Riggs was still very much a kid.

[@timmyturner8708]

Sometimes I feel like this is proof that there are multiple universes irl. There’s no way in hell they actually killed Carl in the original time line 😭

[@TheGrandWizardMan340]

Bring me to the original time line please😭🙏

[@dylanzlol7293]

Luckily, Shifting realities exists.

[@xXxPAYCHECKOxXx]

The fact that RJ is the main character of twd son, and we hardly see him, makes him one of the strangest characters in the show imo.

[@dragonballradiant2744]

He’s pretty young. I think the idea that he’s going to be trained by Judith way later. That’s why she put the hat on him.

[@dragonballradiant2744]

I wouldn’t want RJ out there until he fully trained right

[@xXxPAYCHECKOxXx]

@@dragonballradiant2744No, I definitely agree with that. Hes definitely to young to be put out fighting. But, imo he should have at least had more meaningful dialogue, instead of expecting the audience to care about him just because he's Ricks son. He could've have been better written, to sum it up.

[@thelegacyofgaming2928]

@@xXxPAYCHECKOxXx Actor was like 5 or 6, I don't think they could give him much. At least Carl and Judith were 11 when they started

[@cherryblossom7120]

That wasn't a character, that was a prop or placeholder.

[@Kyrious]

I think it’d have been cool to see Daryl being Carls right hand as he helps him rise to his new leader position. Carl was destined to lead the group after rick.

[@obsidiantrap_6900]

not really. it would be the other way around. daryl is a much more experienced leader than carl. it would kinda suck for us to see carl immediately become the most powerful person in the hierarchy. it would be really cool for him to prove himself instead of becoming the leader because of his father.

[@Kyrious]

​@@obsidiantrap_6900 He wouldn't immediately become the highest on the hierarchy that is what character arch's are for. Carl filling the role isn't because he was the son of the last leader. Like some kind of monarchy. But rather since his father was a leader, would inspire him strive to be one himself. Daryl would allow it to happen and continue being the right hand man, guiding him as he adapts to the role. Rather than taking that role for himself. Not everyone wants to be a leader, there is a lot of pressure, and a lot of responsibility. Only those who are willing to rise to the position get it. It's like Saints Row. The player character is the leader in SR2 because Johnny Gat didn't want it. He is just as qualified as the player, canonically he's slightly better than the player, and he was in the gang much longer.

[@johnuhtred]

@@Kyrious more then that, it was the message both Rick and Neagan said. Rick said in the barn before the storm on the way to Virginia that he thought it was tough for kids to grow up that way because childhood is getting use to the world. So for Carl the world would be easier to deal with as an adult then it was for the rest of the group. And Neagan said in season 8 after he blew up Alexandria that Carl was built for this shit.

[@joel5135]

​@@johnuhtred negan even Said that Carl was the Future. Even negan wanted to built him up as the next "Top Guy". The fkn Villain 😂 If Carl would have survived, they all would immediatly look at him and would want to know what to do

[@SepRus19]

I don’t care what anyone says killing Carl was the dumbest decision the walking dead ever made, he would’ve carried with Daryl after rick left

[@basically_boring]

No argument to be made there. Carl's death was the last nail in the coffin for the show, him being killed off was the worst decision they could have made. It's made even worse by the fact that Chandler Riggs switched colleges, bought a place closer to the film sets, and openly stated that he wanted to continue the show all for him to be fired because AMC didn't want to pay him an adult rate now that he was 18.

[@lukeg4992]

Looking back on the show as a whole, I really wish they kept Merle, Tyreese, and Abraham alive to fight in the All Out War arc. THAT would have been cool to watch. And yeah, killing off Carl will forever be a mistake in my eyes no matter what anyone says. Maybe if he had lived, Andy & Danai would have stayed on longer.

[@thelegacyofgaming2928]

I mean considering Andrew left right after Carl got killed, pretty sure that was why. Then Maggie and Michonne soon after

[@zeleeba8774]

@@thelegacyofgaming2928 Andrew would have left anyway, he wanted to spend time with his family in the UK. Danai also, she wanted go to Marvel.

[@jacobwhelan45]

@@zeleeba8774 honestly Carl stepping up as main character and Judith becoming the great side character she is would’ve made for much better story telling than we got. Would’ve made leaving Judith behind make more sense as she would still have Carl to look up to who would take care of RJ and her.

[@johnuhtred]

That's what happens when you have sadistic story tellers handling beloved characters.

[@basically_boring]

@@zeleeba8774 probably would have stayed a bit longer though, maybe long enough for Rick to see Judith as a kid instead of a toddler.

[@rickgrimes4998]

Carl should have taken the torch no matter what, for years & seasons they were setting up for him to be the last man standing. Even seeing a dark side of Carl Grimes where he slaughtered all the whisperers out of rage like his father

[@duk6897]

"she died and turned into XP for alden" is a beautiful line

[@lastrrr4134]

An interesting "What If" scenario If Carl had lived, the biggest impact is that Andrew Lincoln would have carried through on his original plans and would have left the show at some point, midway into Season 8. (It was only after finding out that Carl was being killed off that Andrew changed his plans and exited the show in Season 9) With Rick out of the picture, this would have forced some major changes. - Daryl would likely have taken his place in the final fight with Negan. They would have likely still needed a major character (Morgan or Carol) for Negan's life to be spared. However, Rick's disappearance/suspected death may have been used instead In season 9 the time jumps would have been much smaller, but enough so that they could use an older girl to play Judith. With Rick having left in season 8, there would be no RJ Carl would have taken back his Whisperer comic book story. As for pike victims, I would have had Ezekiel instead of Henry. As for other characters being used in crossovers. There are a few characters that I thought were (very) underutilized - namely, Jesus (plus Laura, Magna, and possibly Cyndie)

[@madsl9456]

I would have loved to see how negan would’ve reacted in this timeline. I think carl would have been very important to him and he would have tried to be something like a father or at least a protective person to Carl. There could have been a very interesting story between negan and carl

[@will8779]

It would have been amazing if the story had progressed with Carl, Edith, Lydia, Henry, etc. being the future. They remembered the world before, but truly only knew the apocalypse.

[@KingsNerdCave]

OMG that sounds so much better. Love Morgan but his death pushing Rick to spare Negan makes so much sense. Carl (whether you like him much or not) was the soul of the show. I don't think Carl would have saved the show but I think he'd have made it better. For me it didn't feel like there was lead after Rick, but with Carl around slowly learning to be the leader with Daryl helping him would have been awesome. Then either Enid or Lydia could have been better developed and become his love interest. And Carl, Negan, and Daryl vs Beta sounds awesome. I hated the ending of the show because how it doesn't end at all. With Carl there, coming full circle, he could have gotten a happy ending and been apart of the future like his dad wanted while still setting up everything else.

[@In_cold_blood]

Honestly with Carl being older. People can diagree but I believe henry should still keep the lydia and whipser story while carl takes a more older brother to judith storyline. also being henry protector like daryl was, while the storyline between rick leader ship and someone of the dwight and jesus scene could be shared with Daryl and carl

[@zeleeba8774]

I agree, Carl would be too old for Lydia.

[@ksyvi]

@@zeleeba8774 they're the same age

[@zeleeba8774]

@@ksyvi During season 8 he was 15 years old, when at that time Lydia was 9 years old, after a 7-year timeskip, Carl would have become 22 years old, Lydia would have 16 years old. They have a big age difference.

[@magiccookies420]

@@zeleeba8774 that only happened because of changes due to Carl’s death and the 6 year timejump. In the comics Lydia and Carl are the same age.

[@alexxandra-]

@@zeleeba8774 i think the writers messed up her timeline though? in her backstory of the beginning of the apocalypse, shes the same age as Carl, then fast forward shes around the same age as Henry. I think Enid replaced Sophia? Then they couldve followed the comics storyline. Henry wasnt even in the comics and was created to carry out Carls storyline. it just shows how greedy AMC is in killing off major characters or under-utilizing them so they dont have to pay them.

[@justsomeguy708]

this sounds so much better than what we got and carl and daryl would be a sick duo

[@paulwatson5083]

DO MORE OF THIS I'd love to see an in-depth version of if Shane survived along with the group or if Rick died in season 4 against the Governor

[@Kenny6852]

Or if the Governor joined Rick

[@johnuhtred]

Be better if Rick and his group just took Woodbury and lived happily ever after.

[@Jmak]

Carl should have never died. He was the prime example of a broken kid and physically destroyed, but still a good heart.

[@ThatFoxJD]

I always liked Carl as the POV character, seeing everything through his eyes...erm eye in the comics just worked.

[@WolfHembrick]

0:14 that "dreeet" took me by surprise lmao

[@rulerjayohenn3161]

Thr thing about Judith being the one to pass down the story is that she has no memory of what the world was before the end. She would never be able to give a full scope on what was lost

[@hxrryhpz]

my brother, good to have you back. fucking amazing video.

[@Arkanyte]

I do like your alternative version, except for Henry, him dying in the pikes was more impactful because the season revolved around his storyline. And him dying basically left Lydia isolated. Death by jealousy would just make his death frustrating, what I'd do is make him either close friends with Carl, and as his friend, he and Daryl went with Carl to rescue Lydia just like Daryl and Henry did in the show, to Carol's dismay, and then as punishment, Alpha would have him in the pikes, and that would carry a lot of weight. Overall though, your alternative is very solid.

[@dragonballradiant2744]

I would feel sad for Michonne if there was no RJ. She basically got a second chance. Because of Rick. I don’t really mind her leaving them to search for Rick. Because I know all of the communities and Gabriel is there. Also Carol is there she’s like a whole army

[@thelegacyofgaming2928]

Her leaving honestly didn't make sense. But I understand there wasn't much they could do since she wanted to leave.

[@johnsimpson9859]

Hell, in the new show, they could’ve added RJ too and that wouldn’t of hurt my feelings because I think it was awesome that Rick got with Michonne. Especially with the bond Karl and Michonne built in the story.

[@reannasheehy4602]

Well, I honestly feel like her second chance was Carl, because he became her son, and Judith, who became her baby in a way. Then at the very, very end they could've had RJ.

[@therkiller4682]

If you hadn't noticed they tried to make people like Judith but they failed the reason why they failed is because Carl had a decade long character development and many good moments that made him likeable for example his moments with Enid. The fact that Carl died is what destroyed season 9,10 and 11 if forget the bad writing that is (at least for me). In my humble opinion i believe that we need a remake of season 8,9,10 and 11. Even without Rick if Carl had taken his place then maybe the last few seasons wouldn't be like this.

[@wednesdaay_]

I love this so much you have no idea. Thank you for sharing. Carl dying is the reason I stopped watching the show. I desperately wanted him to have an arc on par with comic Carl and AMC destroying that broke my heart. Your alternate take is what I will happily let live in my mind as far as how the show 'actually ended' 🤠

[@shaunce]

Carl’s death is the biggest mistake ever made by the showrunners. It would’ve been awesome seeing an older Carl take the reigns. I do think it would be better if Carl was portrayed as an up and coming leader. I still would’ve gave Henry Carl’s storyline with the Whisperers and Carl would pick up Rick’s comic storyline. I could see Carl going there to find Henry and be shown the horde instead of Daryl. Then Daryl and Carl could carry the story through season 11. Imagine Carl giving the “We Are Not The Walking Dead” speech; a complete mirror of his fathers speech in the barn.

[@julius9346]

i like how some people never even liked carl AT ALL and even some of them will agree with the fact that he should’ve never died, seriously what were they cooking 😭

[@datpablo]

i just want a parallel of rick and carl reuniting from season 1 where carl all teary eyed yelling dad but this time its just quiet tears and relief on their faces finally being bought back together again.

[@jamesgaitley2409]

RJs actor always looks like he’s about to laugh

[@emeeleah9521]

i would have loved to see this all play out. carl's death always felt so off to me, and it was more confusing than sad because of how much they set him up to live until the end. seeing carl go through all of the things he went through just for him to die felt so meaningless and they really wasted him as a character. the writers really didnt know what to do with his character and it shows.

[@crimsoncreepermc1920]

4:50 You despawning RJ is the funniest shit. And I agree, Carl and Morgan totally should’ve swapped there. As much I liked Morgan. He left the show anyways. (I don’t count Fear.)

[@rexleroy]

So I'm pretty sure if carl survived that means he would have went with daryl at the end of the show.that means daryl's show wouldn't be about just him in France and it would've been about daryl and carl in France making the show titled the walking dead: raise the dead staring norman reedus and chandler riggs

[@SirIsaacClarke]

I hate Gimple's TWD because thanks to Carl's death, he made Shane right that Rick couldn't protect his family.

[@xnightx8467]

The spark for this whole series for me was the fact that Carl would survive in the end. Once they killed him off I kinda got super lost 😅 The shows today are cool but it still doesn’t feel the same.

[@dragonballradiant2744]

My favorite KZbinr is back 🥹🥹🥹🥹

[@arturs6519]

They need to make a what if episode or short mini series with Carl Grimes

[@mistysheppard9899]

The thumb nail yo chandler would look fire

[@grim4253]

I hope that we get a ‘what if’ like when michonne got hers, maybe in the finale, rick can talk about how “Carl should be here” and at least 5 second of future Carl

[@maryjaneblues7712]

This needed to be discussed! Thank u!

[@bigpoppabangs6244]

Carl's death really destroyed my interest in the show. I watched most of the episodes after, but the show just wasn't the same without him.

[@tycobrenton4792]

This is a fantastic video..but it causes so much pain thinking about what could have been. Smh. Carl's death absolutely ruined the show for me.

[@FellingDragons]

Don't know if it is true but I heard the reason they killed Carl was because Chandler was turning 18 and they would have had to pay him a lot more, and around that time he had expressed wanting to leave the show so he could attend college full time.

[@karolina.1039]

Actually Chandler said in an interview that he basically build his life around working on the show, bought a house near set and sign up for college there too. But hey, the more you know.

[@jacobusbryan4672]

If a What If story of The Walking Dead showing Carl survived and become the lead from TWD's season 9 onwards came true, that would be lit Also, the heads on pikes scene would make things more personal between Carl and Alpha and Carl would be the one to kill her And he would say "we are not the walking dead" in the end

[@jakesenpai1]

This is mostly what I always thought it would be the story if Carl survived through Season 8 and onwards. Great video.

[@JenniKellogsbrand]

I really like this storyline you've created

[@archierobinson8445]

i always thought it was so stupid that they had to kill him off for the point they were trying to make, they literally couldve just made it seem like carl died, during a walker attack or he couldve been abandoned left for dead, they definitely shouldnt have killed him off

[@nightmarishcompositions4536]

Carl doesn't die in the comics and it has an awesome resolution for his character. Shame the show went a different route.

[@rayanemx2811]

We need a continuation mate it was great!!! Like the other part you did with love this mate

[@jimbojim7523]

9:58 first time watching your channel and these little edits you do to change stuff up are really funny

[@ami7mina]

They should have utilized Magna's group more. If Carl were still alive, I'd like him to help Maggie in the Reaper arc. Or Carl was lost in the way and he met and rescued Alicia. He would serve as the connection between FTWD and TWD.

[@zeleeba8774]

The FTWD and TWD crossover could have happened without Morgan, FTWD could have continued the plot with Proctros, but Rosita would have been in the crossover, she comes from Mexico, and we could have been shown Rosita's meeting with Abraham and Eugene, they are from Texas.

[@ami7mina]

@@zeleeba8774 interesting! I like that you included Rosita. Imagine if the people from the dam knew about her.

[@georgeb4425]

Rick & Morgan reuniting 🎉

[@Origin._.]

Thank you for making this, It’s slightly feels the hole in my heart that AMC dug out of me

[@karolclark791]

To be honest I would've much more preferred if Rick died instead. Rick always looked out for his son. When his wife died he went crazy for a while, when Carl got shot, Rick went full berserk. But when Carl died Rick was able to move on? I excepted him to never fully recover from this.

[@jacmenz4113]

bro you need to do more videos more its so good

[@j7sportvideo24]

This is the worse thing that happened to the show in my opinion. It was the real downfall. It made it easier for Andrew Lincoln to make his mind up and leave the show. This entire time it was Rick protecting his son. No son no reason to keep going.

[@oohwalker]

Wow man. That. Was. Something else. I’d have loved to seen this

[@TheREALMuad-dib]

Morgan is fully aware of the plot armor. He directly says over and over again "I DON'T DIE! EVERYONE ELSE DOES" and comes pretty close to breaking the fourth wall sometimes in FTWD.

[@DanVisuals]

I've been waiting for a video like this and this was exactly what I wanted. thank you this video is exactly how the show should've ended.

[@DaChristianYute]

I would have Rather they recast the Character rather than killing him off everybody would have rather that but Nope Scott Gimple thought “My mercy prevails over my Wrath” was something to look forward to, Rick and Carl Gone from the Show just made it Feel empty at least if Carl was still there that Void would have been Filled.

[@KingOlleyinc]

Carl & Enid deserved a happy ending same with Noah & Beth

[@jtcustoms4297]

Great video , honestly I would've had Carl live instead. About Morgan dying it would've changed Fear TWD. Like you said I hope Morgan survives

[@zeleeba8774]

The FTWD and TWD crossover could have happened without Morgan, FTWD could have continued the plot with Proctras, but Rosita would have been in the crossover, she comes from Mexico, and we could have been shown Rosita's meeting with Abraham and Eugene, they are from Texas.

[@iconic_bluebxrry2221]

If they did this I wouldn’t of stoped watching, love your video this is way better than the show!!!!

[@thelegacyofgaming2928]

We would've had an incredible whisperer arc

[@JakobPedersen-c8j]

I have like this idea of carl letting judith cut his hair since the last person who did it was their mom and i dont think carl would leave to go find rick since then he would basically leave judith to herself which i dont see him doing

[@crimsoncreepermc1920]

I’m gonna read through all the comics with the purpose of seeing what Carl could’ve been. From what I’ve seen in my opinion the show got worse as it went on and the comics got better as they went on. I sure hope the spin offs are able to do all the fan service and also make a good story.

[@lizzymayethebordercollie]

It would’ve been a better show. AMC are a bunch of idiots and evil for screwing Chandler out of his contract. Never felt the same after they killed him off

[@danelliott8548]

The story ended when they killed Carl, and off screen... Worst death in the show! they killed the graffic novel... And the show, in one move!

[@lynncollins5049]

They should have never killed Carl Grimes off the show. He was the whole purpose that Rick did everything. AMC the writers of The Walking Dead made a terrible mistake when they killed Carl. The show has never been quite right ever since. It lost its purpose. Rick Lost. his purpose.

[@backlawa7527]

I would still be watching the show

[@jasonlewis9240]

Having Daryl and Carl looking for Rick would’ve been way better. Having him be the leader would’ve great to. AMC sucks

[@DeadX2]

Yeah I'd love if Carl and Daryl actually were like a duo and Carl took over after his father supposly died

[@karmitdafruge1]

I enjoyed carl alot, i knew glenn would die, it hurt but I kept watching, then carl died and he is gone, morgan is on fear and rick leaves the show. I miss rick but i think carl should've lived its ricks story but its told by carl.

[@EthanHolmes-gr6mg]

Carl could have made the speech daryl made in season 11 "we are not the walking dead"

[@zeleeba8774]

Daryl uttered this phrase in season 5, it's purely Daryl's phrase.

[@derrheinlander]

Just imagine if they did a „What if?“ show. Then Carl Grimes wpuld deserfe a whole season for himselfe

[@SolidSnake_Official]

Cant wait to hear your take on the season premiere of fear

[@chaserred4155]

Cooooral. You're still kickin', Cooooral.

[@GiuseppeDeRosa2001]

Make more what ifs!!!!!

[@AgentStone5]

i actually would've loved how to see carl would handle negan

[@hobbz4921]

scott gimple single handedly ruined this show... when Carl died, it was the death of this show... including all spin-offs (for me at least).

[@SusanPalmer-o5q]

I think Carl should have survived, he was just starting to become what could have been a good leader, how it would have played out with Negan we will never know would he have spared him again we will never know as he was taken too early, I loved Carl and think he should have been there to the end ❤❤

[@KryptonianBMW]

Your editing is spectacular. Tweet. Haha

[@zackcroteau1211]

The show would’ve been had much higher ratings and wouldn’t have fell off as much as it did.

[@Sharkfowl]

I don't think Andrew Lincoln would have left had Carl survived. Still, a cool plot you have here, though.

[@BLACK_FORTYFIVE]

It took me so long to realized you switched the character names on purpose I was so confused

[@ilikewater1575]

I remember I stopped watching when Glen died. I chose to rewatch the show and keep going after Glens death. I stopped watching when Carl died too…

[@basically_boring]

This is a near perfect alternative to what happened in the show. Carl lives and takes the lead, Morgan dies at a time that is right. The only thing that I would change, is for Carl and Enid to stick together. This would better allow to not only expand on their relationship, but also Enid herself as an individual character. I know that the Carl and Lydia thing might make more sense to keep the alternate timeline as close to canon as possible, and because of the comics, but the show already has established itself to be separate from the comics no matter how similar they sometimes are. I also think that it just kinda makes more sense, Carl and Enid have been affiliated with each other since they were introduced and while maybe Lydia would pique Carl's interest a little, I'd prefer if he just stuck with Enid. Don't get mad at me over this, I'm sharing my opinion and you can share yours just don't get mad at me because we might think differently.

[@isaiasreynajr.2432]

G- Drake I’m surprised You haven’t done any videos on the Rick & Michonne show! 😮

[@rayvon_13]

u gon post dead city videos? first 2 eps were great 💯

[@MatthewK122]

I agree Carl should be alive with Sophia

[@5starkosmics]

its crazy cause we lost 4 or 5 main characters in the time span of 2 seasons

[@j.blackwood1818]

Ugh...seeing Carl with Judith and RJ 😢would have been so sweet.

[@oldjarhead386]

Carl aiming a pistol with no eye. Good luck with that!

[@PerSixPlus]

idk I think Carl's death was as good as it was bad, like a 50/50. In terms of story telling, it was a great character death (although executed pretty poorly, by that I mean the "random death", as he just suddenly got bit and that was that), but, as a viewer, I really wanted to see Carl survive longer and see him living in the post-Commonwealth world. Personally, if I was the writer, I couldn't have killed this character just because of the actor, Chandler Riggs played him so well that I would just feel so bad for that. It felt like the TWD universe lost a lot of "life" when Carl died, it made the world feel so much emptier.