AMBER HEARD - STRONG EVIDENCE of PERJURY | Johnny Depp Vs Amber Heard Defamation Trial

[@littleangel18]

Kate Moss is everything AH wishes she was. Beautiful, iconic, decades long career, respected by Johnny and loved by the world.

[@minna457]

I agree and so is the mother of his two children Vanessa Paradis. I wonder where his mind was when he rushed into a relationship with this witch. I suppose he was blinded by her looks.

[@killereverb3928]

Little Angel - you’re so right. I’m not sure these two know who Laye Moss is - a legend of beauty class and distinction beloved the world over for decades. Lovely, elegant and positively enchanting. Beyond reproach scandal and lying.

[@jagilo9677]

Kate Moss has always been so delicate and feminine, very reserved and respectful to others. Naomi Campbell had always spoken highly of Kate Moss

[@maxchen9185]

and she came out and called Turd a liar for the whole world to see, what a legend.

[@eh-i1841]

I’ve never actually liked Kate Moss,but I very much respect her,for speaking up,and exposing that woman’s lies.

[@amandadougherty6615]

I am a trial attorney, and there is a concept in law of “false in one, false in all.” Which basically says that, as far as legal technical determinations of credibility, if an attorney can show that a witness told one lie, the case can be made, if a decision is appealed, that the fact-finder (here a jury, sometimes a judge), is justified in finding that they are just not credible overall. So…the point Jaby was making that she may only have lied 10 times in 1000, but we really don’t know, and it only takes a showing of one lie to really, really hurt her case.

[@Destyn2b]

I am not an attorney, but a therapist and I made that point in a comment last week. It's not just one thing, it's a number of consistently discredited things.

[@husseinfarah6885]

@@Destyn2b yes, the tapes of her abusing and admitting to hitting and punching him. Her going on TV and reported that she donated all the 7 million but she never did. Why even that lie? Then reporting he pushed Kate Mose down the stairs. Then all her reported abuse, being punched by a guy with so many rings and having a broken bottle shaved up her private parts but not having medical records of deviating injuries. But she goes around taking photos and videos JD sleeping and breaking things but none of her serious injuries. Then to top it off…she says “see if a jury would believe a male victim”. Man…this woman has PD…mostly likely she’s on the edge of being a psychopath.

[@hp5732]

i'M a TrIaL aTtoRnEy....well you can't be a very good one if you're hopping onto what is clearly a one sided smear campaign that no serious legal expert appears to endorse.

[@yianhinsaechao7898]

PEOPLE.... at the end of the day......... JD HAVE EVIDENCE AGAINST AMBER.TURD amber don't have any EVIDENCE AGAINST JD..!! AH is a VILE B***H

[@jadis3143]

Falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus.

[@anthonywoodsonsr.8334]

FYI: Camille didn’t have to straight up ask the TMZ witness if Amber Heard was the one who tipped them off or sent the video because it was implied. It was implied when she went through the motions of asking how long it takes to get a video out (with copyright) and he said the shortest is 15 minutes if they have all the info and copyright rights and longer if not. Then Camille goes on to ask how long it took to get that particular video out and he said 15 minutes so it had to have been sent by someone that owned the copyright (ie; Amber Heard).

[@jenicdarling9425]

Ya and I would imagine if her team got in contact with them and did it on her behalf it’s still her doing it, just like how she said she didn’t send the pictures to the magazine, she said something like I didn’t personally do it, how she only gave it to her team well that’s doing it herself then. Like she’s all no I didn’t do that…. Like yeah cause u had ur team do it for u. Like they wouldn’t do all that on their own and without asking or telling her they would, she would be calling the shots. If it wasn’t her personally making the calls and sending pics/videos then she had others doing it for her. She wants to look innocent and not lie committing perjury but just cause she didn’t do it personally herself doesn’t mean she wasn’t calling the shots and had her team do it, like she gave them the videos and pics for them to get it out there. Like if I had idk documents and I gave them to someone and told them to give them to someone, I gave them to them! Sorry I’m rambling and repeating myself

[@sallymascorro]

​ you're rambling is very correct right on you nailed it

[@josephdemartino6053]

Camille used this technique several times - she lays out a trail 9f clues, and lets the jury connect the dots themselves.

[@hadmadp1]

Bruh, at this point, you can't give her the benefit of the doubt any more. She's clearly guilty, how can some people not see that. 🤦‍♂️

[@jborrego2406]

@Ross she doesn’t need help she needs to go to jail if this was a man people wouldn’t say he he needs help he needs a psychology do you like throw his ass in jail

[@sallymascorro]

@HammadKhan EXACTLY 💯 👏 WELL SAID 💯 👏

[@shirleyrusaw5181]

Too bad they couldn't have got this guy to refute ambers testimony that would hav3 proven she lied again

[@higglety230]

The TMZ witness came forward voluntarily. There was a last minute motion from TMZ to stop his testimony which was debated while the jury was out of the courtroom. Ultimately the Judge overruled the motion. However, it was made very clear that if the former employee revealed TMZ's source that he could be sued for violating his non-disclosure agreement. Camille Vasquez's questioning allowed him to testify with an inference to the source rather than naming names. I think it was made very clear that the only way the video could have been posted in 15 minutes was if it had already been identified as coming directly from Amber Heard or her legal representative. Basically he told the court that Amber Heard lied without telling the court that Amber Heard lied. It will be up to the jury to connect the dots.

[@rosalainz2165]

Jury has to put the pieces together she did or her friend . Her sister one of those who one upon of they they were suckling the blood of Mr Depp living in his penthouses for free ..traveling for free .living la vida loca a expenses of him but stabbed him in the back in order to help that nasty woman and the hope all the gonna win 100 million .

[@rpoolcode]

Totally agree

[@RedStarSQD]

Great comment but i just want to emphasize the person has to own the copyright...so it could not even have been ah legal representation. It could only have been ah.

[@higglety230]

@@RedStarSQD I was thinking that it could have been her or her lawyer acting under her direction. It could not have been her sister or a friend. She would have to be involved in relinquishing her rights knowingly. I also didn't mention what else Morgan Tremaine did to non-verbally indicate that it was Amber. There was a very clear eye movement and nod when he mentions the "anonymous" dropbox.

[@hollybrooke322]

@@higglety230 he also looks at her when he says “and B just actors”.

[@BeyondTheJordan]

Y'all inadvertently skipped over the most important aspect of Kate's testimony, not only did she fall down the stairs and not get pushed, but he ran over to her and picked her up and took her to her room, called her a doctor and took care of her. All things a monster would NEVER do...it was some of the most compelling testimony of the entire day. Not only did he not hurt her, ever, but she was willing to testify today because she still thinks a great deal of him. As do most of his ex girlfriends and love interests. No monster.

[@WastedPo]

If it makes you feel any better, they likely watched the whole clip, but just edited parts out of their reaction so they could fit a whole compilation into this one video.

[@juliansanchezharris5773]

They mentioned they watch it all, but only shows clipped parts in this video

[@BeyondTheJordan]

@@WastedPo yeah, I get that. And I wasn't being critical, I was stating that was probably, of all that was said, the most important and worthy of comment.

[@jagilo9677]

I know! When she said JD picked her up and took her back to the room and got her medical attention it goes to show how empathic and caring he is. There’s a video of him helping a fan that’s being trampled and he gets his security to assist and then tells people to back off and makes sure the girl gets medical attention

[@BeyondTheJordan]

@@jagilo9677 yes! Whatever else he is, he's definitely compassionate and caring. The only thing Turd had on him was text messages. And to be honest, after all she'd done to him, I'd have said MUCH worse. Being accused of something he hadn't done and having his entire life and career TRASHED....good grief but she deserved much worse than what he said.

[@camillemayers103]

Camille strategized with that TMZ guy beautifully. They both understood the assignment and turned it in for gold stars!🤗

[@kherikeyfoo]

The whole lack of evidence backing anything she claimed is overwhelming and she incriminates herself over and over

[@gregorturner9421]

@@landy952 she didn't thank god, i don't think many picked it up but during the jury deliberations, the day before the verdict they aske a question re question 3... that meant they had already answered yes to question one meaning she had defamed johnny and gave away the verdict.

[@dianawatton7570]

Yet nothing has been done about it???

[@Favouredz]

There's a difference between being objective and clearly choosing to ignore factual evidence that she's outright lying under oath. To be objective you would have to at least acknowledge that.

[@TheDigitalThreat]

^^^^^^^^

[@chris5947]

^^^^^^^^^

[@elonmusket6178]

Yeah, and the reality is if it was Johnny that was lying like Amber would they be hunting for a defense for him?

[@cristhianbecerra5458]

I understand Jaby, the benefit of the doubt before anything else, but there is a point at which the evidence does its job and removes the doubt

[@HopefulInterventions]

Exactly, my point.

[@barbarakangas3255]

Many of us have been following this case for years. For myself, I watched every posting of Incredibly Average which is what That Umbrella Guy used to watch. Since Incredibly Average stopped posting and The Umbrella Guy picked up the baton, I've been following him. You might have heard of him during this trial because Amber's team has been trying to stop him. At any rate, many of us started watching this trial already knowing the truth and hoping to see Johnny Depp freed from this horror show.

[@vedantgoswami5788]

Thats what i have been thinking its clear at this point that amber has been caught lying on multiple ocassions and if you are a sane person you would be on depps side.

[@streamingwithaswin]

Exactly , how diplomatic you need to be or afraid to voice your direct opinion that after nearly 99% evidence against her still saying benefit of doubt I mean common everything she said is a lie hence proved she is the abuser or lier or deserves jail . Can we for once directly support a man who is a victim Just wondering if these evidences against Johnny the world would have pounced on him

[@skrocks23]

I don't think so. We are neither the judge nor the jury who only looks at the evidences and facts, we are normal people and we can speculate what might have been the reason behind the said action and if the said words have been taken out of context. The lawyers are responsible for questioning the witnesses in such a way that will help the jury form an opinion about it, but it is entirely possible that the opinion may not be 100 percent accurate. So, I think, that it is fair to give the benefit of the doubt to anyone...

[@wizilante1501]

You missed out 2 good parts from today: 1. The TMZ guy’s clap back at Amber’s lawyer during cross 2. Johnny being sassy/done with Rottenborn

[@soulpotaetoe2726]

Add the judge pulling the joke on johnnys lawyer when she called mr Ben “you’re just a snarky guy” & the whole courtroom couldn’t stop laughing 😂 😂👌🏽👏🏼

[@yashikasingh6463]

Yess

[@Pack-Man199]

Also the pictures being altered

[@toufiqahmedshaikh]

Yes ! I wish they reacted how the TMZ guy clapped back 😂😂

[@AshleyJade1]

She doesn’t have PTSD. She tried to ACT like she does but the expert found that to be not true.

[@TheDarkness1]

BPD and HPD is more fitting. It's something that develops in childhood and was at the hands of her father. What she didn't share is how abusive her father was. I wouldn't be surprised if she's repeating stories that happened from her father but inserting Johnny as the abuser because of her daddy issues.

[@abhiram6536]

@@TheDarkness1 daddy issues 😂

[@merykhan97]

@@TheDarkness1 was her father actually abusive?

[@TheDarkness1]

@@merykhan97 Very much so. After Johnny stopped paying his way, he threw out death threats. Very few people dig beyond the surface to find where the real problem started.

[@EffervescentSunflower]

She sure has LTHT Lying Thru Her Teef

[@TheCanadianGuy56]

45:13 I think he had no idea, he probably believed her back then, and now with everything that came to light, is holding himself accountable for his mistake, and doing everything in his power to save a man he almost helped bury. Takes a lot of courage to come out and basically say "I helped an abuser lie to the world" even if he had the "wool pulled over his eyes"

[@SteamPoweredSmurfette]

This was so well stated I took a screenshot to keep as ammunition for future arguments 😅

[@stevenman3443]

Well said! Justice for Johnny ❤️

[@aswaswasw2323]

I am a person who has physically manipulated and handled wood before. Timber is a hardwood, which is extremely difficult to manipulate. In order to do what was done in her testimony, yes she would have had to use a sharp object. Hardwood grains are so tight that they use it in building! Just think about that, timber wood building, so you can't tell me a boot could chip the edge as such. If anyone is feeling otherwise, go to Lowe's and feel and touch timber wood for yourself. Ask a representative about the strength of timber who is unbiased.

[@Allexstrasza]

JD would have to have superhuman strength to make that damage with his feet alone. Wood like that gets even stronger the shorter it has been cut and harder to manipulate with strength alone.

[@aswaswasw2323]

@@Allexstrasza man's would have had to be superman to do that lol

[@joshymcdaniel9233]

I agree with u I’m a woodworker but I disagree with the 2nd half u say’ Hardwood is not used to “build houses” it’s pine/ spruce which is a soft wood’ Regardless unless that was under 1/2” plywood for the bed frame etc then yes it was done with a knife And ironically wouldn’t u know Theres a knife rite in the bed I think she forgot knife was there being so excited thinking “yah I did good on this staged photo”

[@aswaswasw2323]

@@joshymcdaniel9233 timber wood is used in building. Usually in mountain areas, it burns very slow due to density. It's called heavy timber construction. The typical homes we use everyday is pine like u said, but heavy timber construction has a high fire rating and is used certain climate and building zones as a required building component.

[@olatundeakala152]

I think what your audience is trying to say is being skeptical when the evidence clearly contradicts her statements is just......weird!!!

[@865style]

Yup. Being skeptical is great. But being skeptical after it's clear that something is what it is is a different story. That's being delusional. What happens if he sees a video of amber heard admitting the lies. He'd say well maybe she was forced to lie. Maybe she said it on accident and meant something else other then from what she said lol. You can always find something to feed your delusion.

[@MinatoNamikaze-ff9dj]

Agreed!!!!

[@Yen-jw1ls]

​@@865style he might have felt bad being called a misogynist and prob unconsciously (maybe forced too) himself to speak more sceptically than usual.

[@HopefulInterventions]

@@865style Exactly! Skepticism and cynicism are two different meanings.

[@HopefulInterventions]

Yes 🙌

[@elroymartinezjr]

She's been lying, smirking and and showing all the signs that I just can't side with. Before this case I took no sides, but once I've been watching and seeing both sides well it's pretty obvious she's no good.

[@Sytrylt]

those smirks... she made me feel so bad ! I never liked her as an actress, before JD, before everything, I always thought she had something that made me uncomfortable. I didn't knew what. Couldn't point to it, but I never watched a movie she was in ! NONE ! I remember at first I mistakened her for Teresa Palmer (wich I saw in number four), then when I saw her in a few events on tv etc... She made me cringe, so much ! And I never mistaked her for Teresa after that... oO Now that all of this as come to light... I know what i felt back then ! She made me feel uncomfortable because of her, her personality, the way it transpires in her face ! She is not a good actress in my opinion and she can't hide her true colors for long. The smirks, the laughts, even her smug faces... for me it looks like she is a bad person. She feels 'natural' like that ! Like she loves beeing the center of attention, as much as she loves hurting people ! I mean, whoooooooo smirks and laught when their alleged abuser is on the stand, talking about various serious and horrible things ? WHOOOOOO ? (And we are not talking about one little smirk that stays one second on the lips like JD's when he hear something ! NOOOO ! I'm talking of a smirk that stayed at least one minute on her face as she was staring at him ! That's creepy ! Veryyyyyyyyy creepy and disturbing !) I can't trust anything she says ! Because of the evidence, and because of my instincts, that never felt so right, than they're feeling right now !

[@stevenmorrison2953]

@#JohnnyDeppIsRacist If Johnny Depp is a racist . Then why do we see these racist Amber heard texts ? Lololololll ok Tomorrow is Johnny Depp day by US presidential decree !

[@winstongordon9694]

She sure wasn't smirking on the day of the verdict 😂😂😂😂

[@ernamaceira5591]

" SHE SHOULD BE ARRESTED!!" Absolutely , Without a blink of hesitance !!!! JusticeForJohnny!💐❤🙏❤🤘

[@rpoolcode]

I think "must be arrested" is more deserving.

[@melaniehoilman2663]

It should Def be illegal to produce fake evidence in a court proceeding.

[@maryannsmith5411]

they will not arrest her . we all should now that. Remewmber O.J. and Casey Anthony.

[@TJMalana]

That’s not going to happen.

[@lindaarrington9397]

Agree 👍

[@mefford67]

Amber is *NOT* a victim of domestic violence, period. 🤷🏻‍♀️ I can still appreciate people having an open mind, to a point!

[@Tenchi707]

Here being objective would be to see Amber is not a victim but the actual abuser

[@tanyacarbajal3597]

The fact that Amber took a picture of the bed and left out the pillows, then said that there was blood on the pillow, shows that she fabricated some photos, but then added to her story later and couldn't go back and fabricate more photos because the apartment was sold by then.

[@NovaScotianMel]

You should also rewatch the closing statements when Camille mentions the blood on the pillows. You can see Amber make a face and kind of look at the attorney table behind her. And then her face completely changes back. I think she literally forgot she mentioned the blood on the pillows and thought it was funny and stupid that Camilla said something about it. Then remembered she actually said it. Haha.

[@jmeryllman]

Camille was protecting the TMZ guy by not pressing for a name. TMZ argued that they want to protect their policy of keeping sources confidential. By not pressing for a name, the TMZ will less likely to sue this guy for breach of NDA. But the implication is clear. AH owned the copyright and it was released to TMZ. AH is the only person that could legally do this. It was processed for only 15 minutes so there were no other copyright owner between AH & TMZ. If the video was passed on to another person, it would have taken a lot longer. Also, during testimony, it is curious that AH said she does not know the "process" of sending video to TMZ. Well, she knew there was a "process". It was not just emailing TMZ the video file. She new there would be verification and negotiation. There is a process.

[@eddiek8179]

Yup. She also said if she wanted to, she could have exposed it in a much bigger and better way while only moments before claiming she didn't know how to do stuff like exposing and leaking to the media. She contradicted herself in almost the same sentence.

[@honeyholly001]

Did she say she wouldnt know how?

[@eddiek8179]

@@honeyholly001 Yes. She testified she doesn't know how to contact and release the tape to TMZ and then seconds later, in anger, say that why would she do that when could easily do a bigger and better exposure and damage to Depp via media. It just makes no sense.

[@honeyholly001]

@@eddiek8179 she said "I didnt do that, I dont know how to do that" she doesnt mention "process" kzbin.info/www/bejne/hIm9gIKMrq52e5Y

[@user-qi3nb8dz8w]

AH twice said she wouldn't know how to leak stuff to TMZ & the like. She also twice said if she wanted to she could have done a better job of it. TWICE. ON TWO SEPARATE OCCASIONS WHILE ON THE STAND.

[@angiehull5518]

If I were on that jury I would dismiss all Amber's testimony for lack of creditable.

[@polivepea]

Same

[@danielledaniel1900]

Law & lumber and Runkle of the Bailey have been on court to see how the jury's are reacting. They have no care for amber and have show sympathy to johnny

[@karunasrecipes5177]

That's why you are not the jury;)

[@Gaming_Sparky58]

Well yeah If I hears someone Lie that much on stand there testimony is effectively useless.

[@CptAngelKGaming]

@@karunasrecipes5177 Jury is random folks selected not specialists.. It literally takes nothing to be on a jury..

[@rook9653]

It doesn't matter the outcome of this case is Johnny did what he wanted to. Now at least now we know the truth.

[@itskashkashi]

Coming from a coms background, this trial is the most brilliant PR tactic I've ever seen #justiceforjohnny

[@rolandphapha3339]

The outcome matters

[@LarryLovesTech]

I think it does matter because if he wins it proves that in relationships females aren’t the only ones that suffer abuse. It can happen to guys too

[@itzzzwiz7420]

@@rolandphapha3339 as far as I have heard, only one jury needs to be in support of amber and the trial will be on favor of her.. so there is a lot of chances of amber winning the case😕

[@jackviner5181]

@@itzzzwiz7420 I’m not doubting it, but don’t jury’s have to come to a unanimous decision? Why is this case different? Genuinely curious because I didn’t know it could work like that? If so, that is fucked ☹️☹️☹️

[@beverlygherardi4883]

The problem here, Amber Heard thinks she is above the law. So in her mind when she said she didn't do anything to the pictures is correct. But in reality, she had someone do it for her.

[@Pedgo1986]

She is psychopath that what it is. She have no empathy she is willing do destroy man by any means claiming all sort of heinous acts and the she giggle in court when they talk about them. She is violent and dangerous and she should be locked up in mental asylum.

[@luminaratano3935]

Elaine and her objections... omg it's so hilarious! I imagine that in her head she's like: "I need to stop this. I'm gonna save the day!" and then she's go with "a aaa aa a I think he's about to reveal hearsay" lol

[@maryannsmith5411]

i dot know how old Elaine is,and I am trying not to be cruel. Does she have the starting of dementia? She just does not seem put together. It almost like she is just starting out as an attorney. Hard to explain. she is supposed to be a seasoned lawyer.

[@ashifaction]

It's weird how much evidence has to be presented when everything is so clear in this case. And in some other cases some innocent person serves for life based only on someones false testimony.

[@varadsalunkhe9008]

Its defamation case and those are hard to win cause you have to prove malicious intent And no one is mind reader unfortunately its still hard for him to win this wouldnt be surprised if he loses

[@jeebanjeeban87]

IKR - JD had tons of proof, evidence, yet lost in UK. He can pay millions for his law team, his family has millions, his friends have millions - what if its just simple man who had nothing but a simple job? What are the possibilities that someone accused - who's already in prison is actually innocent all because he angered a narc-partner? its scary

[@Allexstrasza]

@@jeebanjeeban87 Only if that narc partner is a woman. If it was the other way around JD wouldn't have had to go to such lengths to get justice

[@sallymascorro]

​@@AllexstraszaPERFECTLY SAID

[@frenchfry14595]

That is not how repressed memories work. Usually, when a traumatic event occurs, if it is so traumatizing that your brain cannot handle the input, you will block out the ENTIRE memory, or most of it. You don't have "convenient" memory loss.

[@aishaarshadalam3412]

Yeah and sometimes it is repressed for years and then randomly some small thing may trigger it which then can lead to a panic attack/anxiety attack. The memory loss trauma she was describing is very much the Hollywood version.

[@itsjustmaddisen]

@@aishaarshadalam3412 That’s exactly what happened to me. I repressed the entire thing for about a decade and then my memory was triggered. I just remembered hyperventilating and crying then an ambulance being called.

[@frenchfry14595]

@@aishaarshadalam3412 Yes, this is how it went for me too. I didn't remember any of it until I started college. Then it just was back in my memory as quickly as it was gone.

[@juliansanchezharris5773]

Yeah... and then it suddenly hits u at the most random moment 😕😞

[@user-qi3nb8dz8w]

Unless your name begins with A and surname begins with H.

[@jgbio328]

You miss the best part of the TMZ guy. When he respond to the provocation of AH lawyer.

[@b.u.l.1734]

That guy was based AF.

[@NemysisPrime]

He clapped her back as much as a witness can without ryling up the others.... "so the AH's team is representing her so that they can have their 15 minutes of fame...".... 😂😂🤣

[@Kkat201]

He was brilliant absolutely brilliant to watch

[@StellaRaeVon]

The knife on the bed, the "bruise kit" next to a melting ice cream holding Depp on the couch....is this even possible?! It seems unbelievable that she could be that friggin sloppy! But then again, if she is an ESTP personality type, she _acts_ before she _thinks._ We have seen her sloppy photo editing and tipping off TMZ, etc. So I think that _proves_ she's not a very smart criminal, despite what she thinks. 🐕🐾🐝😫

[@moonlitskylight5740]

I don't she thought she'd have to fake evidence. So, she did it like those of us who procrastinated until the last night. And did what she could.

[@jborrego2406]

And even with the ice cream photo which is clearly stage you would think she at least put the spoon next to him instead on the table next to her bruise kit

[@jenicdarling9425]

Seriously like she had all these “bruises” saying how she had been punched by Johnny while he was wearing all these huge rings and punched so many times she lost count (and think she said she passed out?) and yet every time the day after she has no sort of markings or swelling and ice does cause swelling doesn’t go away 100% overnight, and make up doesn’t erase a badly cut lip that “bleeds every time she talked or moved her lips” yet James corden had nothing. she would also be seen bare face with no makeup on too day of or after a “brutal attack”! Like the day after she was photographed at court with bruises and next day laughing with friends barefaced with no bruising or any thing!

[@CherryPi314]

I’m loving how you creators are all in cahoots and supporting & learning from each other. I think it’s awesome ✌🏽

[@Navin4061]

The fact the producer's testimony is even damning is because that was Walter Hamada, he was like the DC equivalent of Kevin Kiege for Warner Bros at the time. So if anyone knows what's up, it's him.

[@LarryLovesTech]

Exactly!

[@kieranhewitt786]

He still is the head of DC based films. Dude seems pretty down to earth. Shame we don’t hear more about him

[@huntboy4448]

Not only did kate moss say she fell she said when she fell and screamed Johnny came running to make sure she was ok, picked her up and carried her to her room and immediately sought medical attention. Now you have more facts that discredit ms. Heards testimony you can see what actually everyone else had said that he is a good guy. The part about this is that had amber never even said her name in her testimony Depps team couldn't have brought her in to testify. Because her story is everchanging for sure her lawyers knew that they could bring her in and probably told her not to say her name. She did that to herself also the point the lumber guy was also making was that during that testimony was there was a pocket knife on the bed.

[@88feji]

Wonder why anyone is still living inside Amber's house of lies ... there are huge cracks everywhere and the roof's on fire right now ....

[@Mashangi]

Key word as well was running "back" to help her. Meaning he was in front of her and no way he could have pushed her.

[@urbanlady1.]

@@Mashangi words are important and that one word makes a big difference.

[@lisettewicev7598]

Once Amber mentions Kate at all that is when Depp's team allowed to bring Kate Moss. Essentially, Amber opened the door for that witness and that's why the Judge let Kate come in as a witness.

[@annabanana7659]

And what's funny was that when confronted with this, Heard's statement was that it was a rampant rumor and she believed it for the longest time and came to her mind when JD was 'beating' her and tried to kill her sister (where their stories don't even match). IF it was a rampant rumor, JD would've been called out for that a long time ago and no one would've wanted to date him.

[@atlus6412]

I really can't imagine.... How much Johnny Depp suffered these years..... Hollywood boycotted him.... Media shamed him......... And Amber was laughing and enjoying it. That's not all even now big Enterprises haven't terminated Amber's contract... She hasn't loose anything yet........ This is really INSANE and UNFAIR.

[@utopia998]

Be patient my guy, karma is finding its way sooon. Very very soon..

[@streamingwithaswin]

Yes buddy , and after all this a few people are still being diplomatic that may b there is a different side and both may be wrong .. I mean common can we directly accept the man was the victim here all the lies of amber has been exposed I mean jhonny has proved everything if still we are in doubt and amber turd doesn’t loose this case then we are seriously in the worst world.. also very very disappointed with people like jaby that after so many truths evidences still afraid to directly admit the truth … being double sided always doesn’t look good

[@aliciagaboury997]

I can only imagine how insane it must be to sit across from someone telling horrendous lies. Lies that ruin your life. Let alone….someone you loved.

[@Awarenessss85]

@@utopia998 ohh yeah so far Amber is not looking good in this case so far, ofc it’s probably both sides of toxicity but Amber is looking so bad in the case

[@utopia998]

@@Awarenessss85 We are talking bout domestic violence and the amount of shit that Amber gave to Johnny for this whole duration. This is far beyond the scope of being a toxic couple.

[@kattastrophe7240]

Watching Rob (Law&Lumber) listen to her describe this incident and go over the bed picture live on LegalBytes panel was a sight to behold. In real time, I watched him get MAD. He actually got red because he got so worked up over it. That part of Amber’s testimony is what sparked him actually making his first ever KZbin video.

[@kattastrophe7240]

Additionally, there was a whole big to-do from TMZ (they sent a lawyer to interject) about stopping Morgan Tremain from testifying because he’d be violating the policy of “protecting/not identifying a source”. They were scared shitless that he’d actually say the name, but he essentially revealed the source without explicitly naming them when he said it took 15mins from receiving the video to publishing it on TMZ’s website. Additionally, Amber’s team fought to keep him from taking the stand because they should have been made aware of Tremain’s testifying during the discovery process. There were several witnesses who took the stand in Johnny’s rebuttal case that were never initially listed because they didn’t know about what was going to happen in this trial. They came forward of their own volition. Tremain did not anticipate having to take the stand, Morgan Night (Hicksville property manager) did not expect to get called in, the Seattle airport security/officer actually testified to not knowing why she *wasn’t* called to testify & was a literal last second witness. A lot of these eleventh hour witnesses that came in only came forward because they could corroborate Johnny’s side OR because they could truthfully debunk things Amber claimed or denied. And it’s all because this trial got live broadcasted and people in their circles alerted them to what was happening. It’s wild. Johnny got far more of a fair shot in this trial than what he was able to in the UK. And now we have to hope the jury can see through the muck and deliver the justice that has been needed for the past four years since that op-ed was published. He never lost work after the initial accusations, only after.

[@grazareth]

Btw, Rob from Law and Lumber actually practices law in that court in Fairfax, Virginia and has been in trials with the judge in this trial (Judge Azcarate). He's really given some interesting insights throughout lawtube.

[@demarnelson1463]

Amber's lawyer is hilarious, she was objecting to the tmz guy before he said actual hearsay. You gotta wait until the person does the offense then object

[@pranjalmehtani1729]

I pity Amber's lawyer and I can't wait for depp to win this case however I must say that anticipating a heresay and objecting just before it arrives is appropriate because that's how the jury is remained ineffective to anything the heresay was about to disclose. It also alerts the judge to the fact that what is about to come might be heresay so they can stop it from coming out and damaging the jury's ability to judge only based on the facts and not heresay. However,.I do agree Elain is a worthless piece of lawyer 🤣🤣

[@Psykoged]

You can object if the question posed calls for hearsay as well. We also haven't heard everything the lawyers have discussed with the judge beforehand, and we can't know what lines of questioning they can reasonably anticipate calls for hearsay. All that being said, in this specific instance, Elaine was full of shit. And she is in general. Her reputation as a lawyer is absolutely ruined now.

[@bozzutoman]

It's almost like she _knew_ that if he stated that bit of "hearsay" it would be extremely damning...

[@cobra8888]

Reminded me of Dr.Evil: "Even before you start. That was a preemptive "shh". Just know I have a whole bag of "shh" with your name on it."

[@natb9919]

She thought he was gonna say where he got the video from and Elaine didn't want the jury to hear that it came from Amber so she tried to cut it off before he said it lol because even if the judge strikes it after, you can't unhear something. AH's team have been using that to their advantage the whole time but now it's a problem lol

[@BareBandSubscription]

Call me crazy, but if someone is willing to commit perjury on one occasion, I can only assume they’re willing to commit perjury on many more occasions.

[@Pack-Man199]

She’s done that yes

[@alpha-mk6ig]

That's not crazy , if depp's team prove perjury in any 1 act. then amber heard looses all her credibility.

[@crazyaskpop7111]

crazy

[@franjaworski1147]

They have to keep lieing to keep the story straight!

[@nancygallantclough7623]

A liar always a liar, right?

[@lovelykagome14]

For clarification, the former TMZ producer came forward to Depp's team a week ago, Last night TMZ actually sent a motion to block his testimony ( you can see TMZ lawyer present the motion to the court earlier in the day, the Judge blocked it so the testimony went through). Also watch the Cross examination its hilarious.

[@MrBrock314]

Undoubtedly, TMZ doesn't want people (read: celebrities) to know that any video they get must be from the original source. In other words, those random heated arguments on TMZ are either 1) staged or 2) sold by employees who took the video on their phones.

[@MsGilly]

I love Runkle and Rob! They have great jury reaction breakdowns. :)

[@CameronJamesPhillips]

I will say, in regards to James Wan being "cautiously optimistic" I would be surprised to ever meet a director that didn't feel that or straight up fear. Because it's always the scariest thing before your movie releases and it's like you can't breathe until after that opening night the reactions come in to either confirm your fear or give you instant relief

[@sj4iy]

I was abused as a child. Honestly, I only remember some specific events of abuse that happened and the rest of it just blends in with each other because you live like this day to day it becomes your normal. I have a really good memory (and there's no memory loss in my case) and I can tell you I've never once recalled the dirt on the floor or the breath on the window when recalling the abuse. One thing she never ever mentions is that living with an abuser you are constantly walking on eggshells around them and that's one of the main reasons I don't trust her side of the story. I remember what it felt like even that long ago.

[@elizabethfoulks3764]

Amber tipped them off

[@elizabethfoulks3764]

That came out today in court

Yes, and that’s a thing she clearly don’t do. On the contrary, she laughs at him and jokes with him calling him weak, she provokes him in the records, etc. No real victim would ever do that! She is clearly a liar and the real abuser!

[@diannedearriel5213]

👁👁. A ME TOO scenario, starting at 4 yo - before starting kindergarten. My father would hurt my mother’s handicapped arm... day or night❗️ Always on the look-out - I would march my small ox-blood colored sandals to tips of his work shoes & look him in eyes with all the HATE in my soul❗️ I was back-handed against walls BUT I distracted him away from Mom. (Divorced when I was in high school) I am 79 yo this May 2022) He died nearly 20 years before Mom... I remember saying 🙏 “” I hope it was a long slow & very painful death “” ‼️🔥 ‼️🔥 ‼️🔥 ‼️🔥 ‼️

[@jax6501]

I agree I was always very careful with what I did and said around my abuser. I definitely never even thought about insulting them or arguing with him. I never would have openly filmed him breaking things or done anything to set him off.

[@valyriantime910]

Why would the bed break with Johnny being on top of her ? I mean, aren't beds specifically made to support people being "on top of each other", in quite rambunctious scenarios? C'mon Amber! Put a little thought in your... whatever it is you're telling.

[@HeartlessPhoenix]

She's not suggesting the bed frame broke due to the weight. Her story is that while he was on her his foot (wearing boots) was on the outer base part and that is what caused the splintering in the picture. The video was refuting that, given the type of wood and construction it would take a sharp object, like a knife, to cut into the wood.

[@valyriantime910]

@@HeartlessPhoenix well, neither of her suggestions is believable anyway, be it due to body weight or boots' notch. I did see the demonstration afterward. I just made my comment prior, just in the beginning of the video when all I heard her saying that far was that the damage on the bed was due to Johnny sort of crushing her on it.

[@valyriantime910]

@@HeartlessPhoenix my comment stands in substance : she needs to lie better, or go for the truth for a change.

[@eduardocruz4341]

@@HeartlessPhoenix even if the bed frame edge was a sharp 90 angle, it is possible but the splinter would not be that big by a boot. It would be more like toothpick type splinters or slightly bigger than several toothpick sizes at worse but not that big of a splinter that was shown

[@erme0213]

And there was not even a boot print on the white sheets. Haha.

[@jaellep9833]

The TMZ guy was prepared because he was taking a big risk coming and testified so he had to be very careful. He might all get sued

[@AbcDef-xxxx]

I guess he won’t be. The judge overruled the intervention of TMZ’s attorney

[@saurabhraj2690]

@@AbcDef-xxxx The judge said that in case he violates the NDA, that's the case for a different court.

[@AbcDef-xxxx]

@@saurabhraj2690 I don’t think he violated anything as he didn’t specifically named AmberTurd sent the video link.

[@jaellep9833]

@@AbcDef-xxxx the court literally said that not her business the guy choose to come on his own whatever that lawyer was trying n do he would have to do it with the guy and not the court.

[@jaellep9833]

@@AbcDef-xxxx but we don’t know for sure what his contract said but yea he didn’t say who it was but if you put 2 and 2 together you will know who it was lol

[@JustAlyx]

Oh, don't get me wrong, Jaby. You do you. I'm all for examining the possibilities, especially in a court setting when you're proving someone is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. I think we all just feel the evidence is way too strong to not see Amber Heard fabricating a lie against Johnny Depp.

[@MrBrock314]

The issue is that liars can be abused. So Jaby being cautious about jumping to conclusions is fair. Amber Heard could be a pathological liar. But even pathological liars can be victims of abuse - at least potentially.

[@JustAlyx]

@@MrBrock314 So are you arguing there should be no consequence for someone being a pathological liar and ruining a man's life? Abuse is never ok. I agree. But public shame is a fair consequence for putting someone through the amount of hell she put Johnny through.

[@sallymascorro]

​@@JustAlyxEXACTLY 💯 👏 EXCELLENT COMMENT 👏

[@terrylaguardia6838]

The fact that they knew she’d pose for the photo implicates her definitively. There’s no way now to make the argument that her PR team arranged that on their own.

[@nikhilnagaraj]

Guys, you missed the best part of the TMZ guy’s testimony. The cross examination of him by AH’s lawyer. Watch that if you get a chance for a killer mic drop moment. Better yet, react to it and post it here. I was waiting for you to get to that part, but looks like your source video ended before.

[@Just-Saiyan]

Yes I was thinking the same thing

[@stalsha881]

Loved his mic drop no I'm not looking for 15 mins of fame I can say the same about you taking Amber as a client 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@SalZephyr]

I'm so glad you did a reaction video on this .. About entering with a bias, I think most of us entered with an open mind but at various moments had enough of the BS and developed a bias. It's just as you say, if you lie at 10 places where you really shouldn't have, it seriously nullifies the credibility of whatever else that might have been true.

[@BLACKPINK_Baemon0808]

TMZ representative actually spoke during opening to stop the exTMZ Employee to be a witness, however it was denied. The witness is probably releasing limited details regarding the source to avoid heavy legal implications toward him invthe future

[@rosalainz2165]

But at least now we know she did some how direct or indirect with her nasty sister and friend one off t hem tipoed the unprofessional TMZ

[@Anitacollins363]

In a round about way he admitted they got it from her. Apparently tmz post things they only own the copyright on. In order for them to receive the copyright they have to be contacted by the copyright holder or the one that recorded the video. It takes 15 minutes to get the copyright if the video comes directly from the source or the person that recorded the video. She sold and was paid off by TMZ all in 15 minutes.

[@Castkett4ever]

For the timber comment about it not being the same force since it's a hand and not a foot pushing: it doesn't matter at all because even a person weighing 250lbs using their boot would not be able to break the bed in the manner described. Like Rob said only a blade or something very sharp and narrow can break the bed, splintering it. But I think it's a good remark to make, as for other demonstrations such a difference could have had a very important impact.

[@k8marlowe]

⚠️The fact that Johnny was immediately removed from Fantastic Beasts, while Amber’s role in Aquaman remained unaffected goes right to heart of the matter in this case. She took advantage of the Me Too movement to further her career. ⭐️She was believed without question. Johnny was ruined without due process.⭐️ Let us never make that mistake again.

[@jigsaw632]

Someone tell JD team that one of the text JD is accused with is an *incoming message* not outgoing. He didn't send it. The one he denied he has written. Also it was a group chat

[@itskashkashi]

Send TUG a message!

[@roseyrosita]

bingo

[@angelaclark129]

Top call. Send it to TUG!!

[@darkcloudultimate4047]

Also anyone want to know where the quote that Johnny couldn't remember him saying is from drum role please!! It was in a 1995 issue of rolling stones where rolling stones wanted bad boys in that era they wanted fighters. Also his name on the cover was Johnny dangerous!

[@tracyrasmussen8117]

As another atty reported regarding all this, is was it's playing dirty pool by her atty's. They're going for a hail Mary. Unfortunately, the layperson (jury) may not realize that. However, there's so much bad about Amber, and so much good about Johnny. I can't see these texts changing all that.

[@higglety230]

The photographs were brought in today and verified that all of them had been edited. It's impossible to say how they were edited or who did it. Theoretically they could have been resized innocently, but because of how they were presented to the court it is now impossible to verify any of them, who took them, when, and how they were edited.

[@honestbarsteward]

The colour editing could not have been innocent though.

[@higglety230]

@@honestbarsteward Right of course. I was trying to limit myself to what was proven by testimony. For some reason, the expert had been barred from saying anything about color or chroma or pantone scales. But we (and the jury) can see what we see. The saturation was clearly manipulated to make the pictures redder. I would not be surprised if even more had been manipulated, but the expert wasn't allowed to testify to certain details. I would be interested to know why that was. There was also the implication that the photos had been intentionally turned in in a format that would make it impossible to trace what had been done, when, and by whom.

[@archforge]

The sad truth is this, as it seems that Johnny Depp apparently did not deserve the condemnation that occurred. He still will have to do business with Warner Brothers or Walt Disney in the future as they are some of the few companies that can pay out the money that he deserves for his talent. If the Jury does side with Johnny Depp we know that Amber Heard will not be able to pay the 50 million if that is what is ordered. We also know that the amount of money he lost in this entirety can never really be recovered. Plus in order to ply is craft he would need to work for the very companies that threw him under the bus and sided with Amber Heard. That doesn't include all the actual victims of domestic violence that will have the cast of doubt over them because of this incident.

[@MandatoryFruit]

Not necessarily. There are still quite a few huge companies that would absolutely love to get their hands on Johnny. Universal, Sony, Paramount, MGM, Lionsgate. All huge companies not owned by Disney who Johnny could make bank off of. Though it can definitely be argued that Johnny will never be a part of a franchise as big as Pirates was ever again.

[@tracyrasmussen8117]

There's ppl projecting that if he wins he'll be granted 7 mill (the amt he paid to terd in divorce) and that he'll donate that to San Diego Children's Hospital. Plus Johnny has his own production company, maybe that business will take off after this case? I truly believe no matter the verdict, that Johnny has reclaimed his name and credibility. Even if the jury sides with him, they'll still be nay sayers.

[@Pack-Man199]

Depp doesn’t have a problem with Warner Bros he said he left Fantastic Beasts respectfully

[@M24071]

I think dior sauvage is the only company and brand that actually stayed with Johnny even when everyone else dropped him and for that I respect them and going to be buying their products even more now

[@rp1ten]

@@MandatoryFruit Good points you have there. If I may add, if JD does win big, do you think that JD will sue both Disney and WB? Just a thought!

[@frankgunner8967]

If she gets away with this charade my faith in justice will be gone completely.

[@rutvi6537]

The bestest moment of this entire case is when this TMZ witness claps back at the AH lawyer. It was sooo pristine. I would say it's the best TV moment after Dakota Johnson's 'thats not the truth Ellen'.

[@artisan09]

I think the judge is done with heards legal team's shenanigans.

[@lynn2574]

Especially since AH’s lawyers misrepresented Evidence again today. Those two texts that JD said he didn’t send? They were marked ‘incoming’. He didn’t write them.

[@veronicat6841]

💯 agree. Judge A. Has put up with ALOT from Heards Team & now you can see she’s had enough & I don’t blame her. Judge A. Is a BOSS

[@gwendolynkaren5933]

@@veronicat6841 it was not very encouraging when the judge dismissed for lunch and told Johnny not to break anything on the way out the last day he was on the stand

[@torialbrecht2000]

@@gwendolynkaren5933 everyone was laughing lol it was because of an instance with mic (hit and I think he thought he broke it but was trying to set it back up right) in his last testimony. If the court and jury cant pick up on the bigger picture of that interaction (actually favorable for Johnny) we got bigger problems

[@gwendolynkaren5933]

@@torialbrecht2000 aha that is funny

[@TMAnimate1]

On the edited photos, an expert witness in digital photography and videography debunked these yesterday. It was confirmed these photos were edited. The cross examination that Amber's lawyer tried to pull was painful to watch. They made themselves look like idiots!

[@diannedearriel5213]

👁👁. You forgot‼️ Turd’s NIGHTMARE of a mr🤡, ms🤡 DREAM TEAM came out of the Bull Pen🐮, acting like idiots - NOT acting like attorneys❗️ ❤️ 🙆‍♀️ Dianne from Arizona 🌵🌵🌵🌵🌵🌵🌵🌵🌵🌵🌵🌵

[@angeloterrones9789]

She is guilty we all know it.

[@Pack-Man199]

At least us sane folk know it. She still has some sympathisers out there

[@jamesjarrait5926]

This beautiful the guy who did the video about the wood knows it's so specifically that he can identify it and replicate it to almost near perfection with nothing more than a mock-up of the same sort of thing.

[@sly7390]

What I got from the WB Executive’s testimony was THANKS to AH’s counter suit and JD’s team as a defense for JD subpoenaed him to testify that AH (1) had no chemistry so that called for several reshoots of scenes which takes time and $, (2) AH made claims that were false and dragged them (the company) into a world wide court law suit being televised, 3) made it known she may sue ANY FUTURE PRODUCTION COMPANIES who MAY hire or sign contracts with her if she becomes upset or misunderstood anything. Amber Heard made herself a liability for future roles. She destroyed her reputation and I believe her career even if she wins.

[@winstongordon9694]

And even before the trial started a lot of producers were saying they wanted nothing to do with her because she is a pathological liar

[@bolladeen]

Untill she is charged with perjury, she can sit there smiling..insulting the court and public with her idiotic lies. She got away for being abusive, she have to faced the consequences of her wrongful doing. Or the will be more n more AH within the society..

[@zero-to-hero7330]

There already is lots of women like her.. it's just men don't speak up. We all know how society/ court treats men. So lots of regular folks just deal with it or run away..

[@MrBrock314]

Based on the psychologists diagnosis, she has personality disorders brought on by a rough childhood. Which means as a society, it's not a catchable problem. Give children better childhoods, get less Amber Heards.

[@itzzzwiz7420]

You guys should have also reacted to his response to Amber's lawyer.... That was badass

[@Pack-Man199]

I was waiting for that and they got this half assed version of the video

[@c.campbell1963]

I would LOVE to see you guys react to the video discussing the differences between Amber and her sister Whitney's description of the stairs incident from the Body Language Guy!!!

[@merykhan97]

Too bad you didn't react to the TMZ guy calling Elaine on her BS . That was the highlight of the day. Also the Airport staff testifying that she did abuse her ex-wife because she literally broke off the fight . Also Johnny saying he called the Warner bros just after the audition because she asked him to and that's how she got the role.

[@tanyaabram8336]

I've been following Law&Lumber and Runkel of the Bailey since the beginning of the Depp v Heard trial, they are both excellent Attorneys and produce fascinating and educational content. Well worth checking them both out

[@Pretzils1031]

This was the most productive court day we've had all week.

[@865style]

We've learned what we already know. That she lies, and lies, and lies and lies. Over and over. Then she not only lies about things she actually makes them up and lies about that.

[@Destyn2b]

@GetJaby I am the queen of questions and a pessimist by nature, HOWEVER, it's very clear she is making all of this stuff up. I grew up in a house full of family violence and honestly still have some PTSD symptoms so I'm inclined to believe the victim. I am also a therapist so I clearly see her borderline traits. It was a seriously toxic relationship and they both need help, but she was clearly the aggressor and manipulative. I seriously want her to get the help she needs.

[@ronyagpd]

Intelligent debate much less histrionic than so many. Thank you.

[@ArianeEvangelina]

My trauma response is forgetting, and I obviously can’t speak for everyone, but personally, what Amber is depicting in her testimonies is not forgetting traumatic events. At most what she is describing is her memory getting fuzzy after he supposedly starts hitting. Most of the time I only have a vague recollection of moments that happened because my brain kind of just skips over that moment. It’s almost like my day is just shorter or that I was doing something that I remembered earlier in the day for a longer period of time than what I could recall. My brother was with me throughout most of my traumatic experiences (as we both went through it together but had different ways of coping with it) and was thankfully able to fill in the gaps for me later on in my life when I could handle it. Another way I would “forget” instances was by replacing it with another negative experience. For instance, if I was both neglected that day and yelled at, I would only remember the neglect (ie. my dad leaving us alone at home all day and only coming back around dinner time). I would take another negative instance that I didn’t consider as as bad as the other instance and replace the one I couldn’t handle. That way I could explain why I still felt awful that day but wouldn’t have to remember any parts that I couldn’t mentally or physically handle. Never once would I focus on exterior details. So I’m not saying that her version of forgetting trauma doesn’t exist, but that it is definitely not anything similar to my experience. Not to mention that my trauma response caused me to have major issues with my memory and time perception in general since it made me doubt my own memory and how I interacted with other people.

[@nadeeml9276]

To answer Achara's question, the former TMZ guy was asked why he came forward, and he, basically, said he saw a little bit of the trial, especially the part about the video where Depp is slamming kitchen cabinets, and said he wanted to help out for the timeline or fill in some blanks - he had no intention of being on the stand. Elaine asked him if he's out for his 15 minutes of fame, and he responded that being on the stand might make him a target for TMZ, a highly litigious organization. Interesting clip, i suggest watching it

[@beca6910]

Elaine and crew had NOTHING...

[@CzarinaHarris]

He volunteered to be there, too. They gave him a subpoena after the fact for legal reasons. But he offered up the information himself.

[@nadeeml9276]

@@CzarinaHarris ahh thank you for the info

[@speccollector9740]

I can't see how you can be "Neutral" after watching all the evidence. I started out as neutral.....but quickly turned due to "common sense"

[@geminia]

I'm in the same boat as you. I tried to believe AH, but as trial goes on, I just cant.

[@speccollector9740]

@@geminia Agreed. After everything we've see....I can't believe this lady fears ANY man.

[@pliny8308]

A metadata expert testified today that NONE of the thousands of photos in AH phone, which is where all these photos originated could be authenticated because they were run through editing software.

[@jillikoivivre]

She didn’t turn them over. There was a motion to compel filed to try to force her to turn her phone over and still has not. None of her digital evidence was verified

[@nieserz7]

I will say (as a 20+ year therapist/Licensed Clinical Social Worker): that trauma survivors remember exceptionally detailed aspects like smells, views, moments, flashes of a visual aspects WITHOUT recalling every single detail of the hour before, during, or after. That being said, I'm not agreeing or disagreeing with either party. I do know that the jury is not seeing all of the arguments online "proving" either side's stories, which will make the decisions difficult.

[@barbiesvet1-3-18]

I have PTSD BAD and I remember EVERY DETAIL.. and you wake up with night terrors and nightmares from the trauma or I do.. I hate that someone could make up something that clearly didn’t happen the way she describes.. so sad for Johnny her laugh in the one audio gave me chills so scary..

[@wrathg]

It is amazing to see you guys react to lawtubers who I have been watching this whole trial and some of these lawtubers are more reliable than traditional media coverage of the trial.

[@dhwriter0724]

You should look at the text messages they said johnny sent. It says "incoming" instead of "outgoing ". Also, with the photos l, they had an expert come in and sho that all the photos where changed in either Photos 3.0 or Photos 1.5.

[@andreaxclement]

If she accepted a few of her blunders maybe, just maybe we could try to be neutral about this whole situation but she just loves throwing people under the bus including her own team who I'm assuming are trying their absolute best to defend an indefensible client. She's not owned up to any of her bullshit and it's annoying! She has made allegations on anyone just to favor her lies and has fabricated the truth so much. I guess Amber doesn't know that, The Truth, It Always Comes Out!

[@FabiolaRVela]

Yes! That’s the most annoying thing to me!! If she accepted some of these things which are clearly lies, people would respect her so much more. Because it was clearly a toxic relationship, but she’s on a completely different level of fuckery. But it seems like she’s incapable of accepting any faults..

[@HopefulInterventions]

Exactly! That’s what people were trying to say to Jaby. That there’s a fine line between skepticism’s and cynicism.

[@tracyrasmussen8117]

I truly believe she's just switching the names to when she actually abused Johnny! Think about that, it'd be easier for her to recall those times (they really happened, to Johnny, by her) . She's got a lot of abuse 'stories' that would be hard to recall her lies after all these years. So maybe?

[@fukufukugolfer]

I was absolutely disgusted when she claimed that she had tons of more photos of her injuries and handed them over to her lawyers but THEY didn’t use them. Her narcissistic spinal reflex response was to throw them under the bus, when she could have easily said that the other photos were not allowed into evidence for reasons she did not know.

[@katiesaccount1]

The witness is an EX employee of TMZ and TMZ’s lawyer fought really hard for him not to testify live in the trial, at the end the judge told them that he is willing to testify and she can’t do anything about it and to deal with it later (as in sue him if you think is best after he testifies lmao) he can’t say who it was because he didn’t make the negotiation with the source he specifically says that it’s fast to obtain the copyright if the source confirms is their video and he let us know between the lines that it was AH or her team. BTW you missed the best part in cross examination lmao

[@BreannaDrummond]

I love watching your guys' reactions and I appreciate your genuine consideration to both sides-- BUT it drives me a little bit crazy that you ask questions that have been answered IN the trial lol. no shade at all, I just was waiting for you guys to mention that TMZ came and filed an emergency motion to stop that guy from testifying, which also explains why he couldn't say outright who it had come from, and then his explanation on cross about why he's doing it-- and it never came😩

[@jaiminsharma]

Being sceptical when evidence are clearly there... Is what's turning off your audience... Critical thinking is rarely critical at all lol...

[@alycry89]

As Johnny's said yesterday 'no matter how it goes, I told the truth' that was very important to him. After all these years....

[@clydapowers3987]

She also said that when she went into the bathroom she did not look in the mirror the first thing you do when you go into the bathroom if you've been abused is to look and see how bad it is how black-and-blue it is how swollen it is but she said that she didn't even look

[@PirateCommander]

Even more likely to if you're a narcissist possibly, so she doesn't stack up either way.

[@staceyrowell9023]

Exactly…. Just like blowing your nose and examining the contents.

[@PirateCommander]

@@staceyrowell9023 Well if it's swollen then, you can then use the mirror to apply ice and arnica and nobody will tell, it will look like you haven't even broken it ?

[@missygilly9917]

She didn’t need to look, because she lied about abuse! Just like those pictures she took in Australia when she purposely stayed “out” of the mirror image. Someone who had been allegedly beaten would want to take pictures of themselves. It’s so odd that she chose not to, indicting her version of events are lies!

[@lynettecummins2438]

I know I'm very late.....but I love this reaction. Especially the TMZ guy. 👍👍👍

[@leslie8743]

I think you have been very fair and balanced. I have never seen so many talented, ethical, and caring lawyers as the Depp Team.

[@lockcrimson4031]

All these witnesses gave clearer answers than Heard herself. Thats how you can tell, if someone is lying or saying the truth.

[@twohorsesinamancostume7606]

No. PTSD makes you remember everything in minute detail and plays it over and over and over and over in your head. That's what's so bad about it, your brain takes you back and replays the event in your head whether you like it or not. Amber Heard is full of shit.

[@hardybouy]

Underrated comment

[@twohorsesinamancostume7606]

@@hardybouy Just pisses me off. After I got out of the Marine Corps I struggled from it for years. I got to relive my buddies deaths over and over and over againn almost quit my air addiction over it. I know a lot of guys that did. Anyone faking it needs to be given something to actually have PTSD about.

[@marylanwi1136]

This 💯

[@abovewater6918]

How come Johnny had to submit his phone and texts for everyone to see when Amber refused her court order to submit her phone and texts? Kinda seems unfair.

[@saurabhraj2690]

She said that she smashed her phone

[@tashahollywood1]

@@saurabhraj2690 You can always order phone transcripts. I subpoena text history for opposing parties in my divorce and custody cases all of the time. You don’t need the physical phone.

[@PirateCommander]

@@saurabhraj2690 Data wouldn't be difficult to recover in most cases with account details unless she drove over it in a truck.

[@kasfiasabila2369]

@@saurabhraj2690 in most cases if you're are guilty then either your phone is broken or it gets stolen a few days ago

[@jborrego2406]

@@saurabhraj2690 A csi person or a computer person we still be able to find to data off that phone lol

[@shadow.banned]

A boot? In a massive $2000-5000 custom wooden bed frame? Don't be absurd. Literally physically impossible.

[@stefanocugini6379]

great work both of you! i was waiting for your reaction to the mic-drop moment when the TMZ dispatcher came hard at Elaine when she try to do destroy his credibility by saying he was looking for his 15 minutes of fame on TV. and his comeback was epic saying basically it was actually more harming and damaging to him for coming to court and testifying but he could also reverse the same theory and say Elaine is looking for her 15 minutes of fame as a defender of Amber Heard! classic 🎤 drop moment! keep the content coming!

[@CzarinaHarris]

It’s off-putting when you remain skeptical in spite of evidence. You’re more scared of the comments section than the risk that your mentality is exactly how women like Amber get away with stuff like this. It’s okay to call and thing a thing, Jaby. We aren’t the jury, it’s up to 7 people to make the decision here at the end of the day.

[@dasik84]

His alibism is so annoying, yeah.

[@HaitianBlackGinger11]

He’s alibistic behavior is tiring.

[@oduinn7948]

"Moss isn't assisting our case? GET HER THE FUCK OFF THE STAND!" Basically what her team said.

[@MadeInSeventyFour]

@@nursejessica5439 I think you misread the original comment.

[@BlasianGoddessTM77]

@@nursejessica5439 Um read the comment again 🤣 Relax

[@Destyn2b]

True! They knew they couldn't get anything out of her. Lol I also think they wanted to save the time for Dr. Curry and JD.

[@rayray6490]

@@nursejessica5439 …Amber’s team didn’t block anything. They simply declined to question because 1.) they knew Amber blurting out her name was a BS move 2.) they’re already low on time as is. To question a witness when they knew nothing happened would waste their precious minutes

[@Pack-Man199]

@@rayray6490 this is the correct response. They didn’t block anything, there’s nothing for them to dispute their like at all. It’ll be Elaine going “I’m trying, I’m trying” all over again.

[@itzzzwiz7420]

Team Johnny for sure... It's was so frustrating to see her smirking at him and kept staring at him with a evil smile on her face yesterday...

[@jamesdavis625]

I love how Elaine didn't win one objection during Camille's questioning of the TMZ reporter... She truly is terrible

[@leighhall2198]

So glad you have found 'lawtube' it's a very informative area of KZbin, keep being you and having your own opinions, I for one appreciate you both

[@dropshot8840]

If Amber's head was buried in the mattress face down with Johnny's knee on her back, how can she see or know where his foot was?

[@haridaspalleeri6765]

I think the comments are just pointing out that even though always being skeptical is really good, ignoring blatant evidence to be skeptical is just...weird

[@Pack-Man199]

If questioning God’s existence is the basis of his ongoing skepticism then he’s got some issues.

[@felixculpa3601]

Jaby, you have the freedom to share your honest thoughts regardless if anyone agrees or disagrees.

[@HopefulInterventions]

I think what people meant is that there’s a fine line between skepticism and cynicism!

[@felixculpa3601]

@@HopefulInterventions I'm unsure what you're referring to or why you chose to reply to my comment written directly to Jaby. I am simply encouraging him to share his honest thoughts, whatever they may be.

[@HopefulInterventions]

@@felixculpa3601 My apologies.

[@felixculpa3601]

@@HopefulInterventions thank you

[@irenethomson2033]

I wish the cameras had panned onto Amber's face at the point that Kate tells the court that she "slid" diwn the stairs. Her expression at that point would have been well worth seeing!

[@traceytaylor2706]

What I don't get is the fact that Heard lied on the stand - did she not realise that Johnny's team would've checked up on what she said and realise she was lying?

[@jk844100]

There’s 2 reasons they didn’t Cross Kate Moss and that’s because: 1) the defence is extremely low on time and they need to save it for more important witnesses. 2) it could open the door for Kate to testify the reason she’s here is because Amber has been spreading a false story that Johnny pushed her down the stairs. Which is what the defence objected to when Johnny’s lawyer said “why did you choose to testify today?” They don’t want her to explain Amber made it up, although I’m sure the Jury knows at this point.