The Evenstar: Arwen and the Phial of Galadriel Explained

[@spicybag22]

I can't honestly explain why but I was moved to tears as I was listening to this video. You told these stories beautifully.

[@zz445-r1v]

It was the same for me.

[@tomkuzik7]

🙏🙌

[@ZephyrOptional]

I often try to explain to people what it means to be transported to the Perilous Realm of Faerie when reading (or listening to well read) Tolkien. I’m pretty sure that’s what you’re experiencing. If read with the love and care you can clearly hear on this vid, you can sit back and enjoy the tears of sorrow and joy. Powerful and unique stuff… ever listen to Martin Rombreg’s ‘A Elbereth Gilthoniel’ hymn? Lump in the throat every time I hear it.

[@djcdouble07]

This channel is just amazing. The way its told and the artwork is unreal.

[@positivefandom9066]

The presentation in this channel is stellar. What an accomplishment for this group from the dictation to the lovely music and illustrations I’m completely mesmerized. It truly is a thing of beauty. Thank you very much for taking so much care in making these videos 😊💎

[@suzidoe]

I wept over such a well told summary of light, love, joy death. My Da read the books to me when I was young. Tonight I could hear his voice, long silenced and missed telling me such great tales as I fell asleep. Much gratitude for that warmth.

[@originalsainthood]

Ahhh…. What an unexpected treat this was! I sat like a 1st grader in front of my tv and didn’t move for the entire video - loved it

[@crabbuckets7506]

I'll just say your channel is like a breath of fresh air. I like to escape from all the drama the TV series has caused in the community, and you are one of the few that aren't milking views from it good or bad. Keep up the excellent work it's well worth the watch.

[@lyndazema94]

Beautifully told. Well done❤

[@Cardinal_Hordriss]

Another superb video. I'd quite like to see a video comparing and contrasting the elves of Lothlorien, Rivendell and Mirkwood, explaining how their cultures differ.

[@aravindkr]

This is an absolute masterpiece of a narrative. Thank you!

[@kennyglod7]

Again, simply amazing! Can't get enough of this channel!

[@darkspark5770]

This is such an amazing retelling of some of the best stories ever wrought from the mind of a mere mortal, Tolkien. Well spoken, beautiful and a rare stunning epic so few could imagine!

[@positivefandom9066]

Hi. I keep listening to this over and over again the way a child listens to their favorite story on a record. Wish we could get a movie for this one. 😊💎❤️

[@MadMods4u]

Excellent video... Thank you for sharing this with us 😌

[@lukezitlofsky5286]

You outdid yourself with this video. Amazing work!

[@cptswann]

I can really feel the love in the way you compile these legends for us 🥰 Your videos are uplifting and refreshing 🌞✨️ Thank You

[@samwisegamgee8318]

This is literally so amazing. This channel is truly the greatest LOTR channel on youtube, and that's not throwing shade at any of the fantastic creators - it's just a testament to how incredibly hard you work to make this perfect.

[@skepticalsmurf]

l missed you,the return of the King 😊

[@jmitterii2]

This was among the best video yet. Loved the quotes from the various writings and letters from Tolkien himself; very well edited and just glorious and beautiful.

[@christineford9231]

Fabulous storytelling. Loved it!! Looking forward to the next story.

[@backgroundnoise9310]

You have returned!

[@TheRakakaa]

Your videos are absolutely beautiful and your scripts are wonderful. Your passion for this created world shines as bright as the star of Eärendil!

[@willydoesminecraft]

Your videos are amazing. You’re like the Vati channel but for Tolkien. There are a lot of Tolkien lore channels out there, but your channel is a gem amongst them. The style, art, music and voice is all perfect for representing the Tolkien Legendarium.

[@logicnot3939]

You certainly have given me back the true depth of my love for Tolkiens work. Something that was overshadowed by the mighty force of movies and series and my desire to be entertained. With your help I have regained what was lost: the light and darkness of my imagination being a child reading Tolkiens works for the first time. I can't thank you enough!

[@TarMody]

In Tolkien's astrology, the positions and movements of the constellations in the sky allow for predictions about the future. Gil-Estel, as a star, affects the future with his positions relative to these constellations. This reminds me of the interaction between the song of the Ainur and the song of the Children of Ilúvatar, which is added to the music by Eru in the Music of the Ainur.

[@princeLurking]

Hey, good to see you again

[@athelas379]

Thank you! Your summary helped me understand The Silmarillion so much better.

[@jessica_in_japan]

This was such a nice telling of this story. Your videos like this are always so inspirational and moving. On a side note, how much pain and suffering could have been avoided if people just gave the Simarils back to Feanor's sons. Like, they all knew about the Oath.

[@JusShane]

Loved this video!!

[@zachkorinis3935]

Spot on.

[@inkaplir6945]

Thank you. I enjoy very much listening to you, especially reading the poems. Masterful.

[@yellowsmarties2]

This is perfect. Awesome narration & music ✨️

[@KeiPalace]

fantastic docu, thanks so much!

[@STMukr]

A Elbereth Gilthoniel...❤ Thk God you back❤

[@AlexisLopez-pb8ms]

I had to subscribe. Just found this channel. What an amazing documentary ❤❤

[@kramhorse]

Loved this. I will say one thing that I found it odd that you had Melkor creep in and steal the silmarils instead of having him kill Finwe and take them.

[@R.J.MacReady1982]

I love this channel. Really liking the new season of the show right now. You have given me a lot to anticipate.

[@acrylup]

How I wish I was loved by someone like Lúthien loved Beren, such a moving story.

[@DingbatToast]

Beautifully read.

[@caradhwen1976]

Well done, sir!

[@madyjules]

What a masterpiece!! truly cannot thank you enough for this beautifully created video. Just found your channel and immediately subbed. Thank you again for your excellent content!!

[@BLAZEREN101]

Where has all this concept art come from? It's spectacular!! Incredible narration my friend.

[@nerdanel7592]

This is beautifuL Thank you.

[@Michael_A_Lewis]

These videos are amazing!

[@veronicasiegfried2712]

Wonderful video!💖

[@c.antoniojohnson7114]

Love the Evenstar...Arwen,she looks just like Luthein.... I'm a Eveningstar myself(i was born before the sunrise).

[@SurnaturalM]

Looking at a comet that come around each 80,000 years near to earth while watching this. I thought it was the perfect scenery for such a narration.

[@amparoadams8967]

Felt like I am watching the movie foe the first time. Love love love

[@Tuatha_De_Gaming]

I just bought the History, legend, myth shirt from yall!

[@RealmsUnravelled]

Thanks for supporting the channel it's much appreciated ☺️

[@siobhanomalley1968]

Best one yet!! Also, where can we find the music from this video, it's so enchanting 😭

[@conniestone6251]

Recall : Tindómiel is actually the related name of the Morning star(s), kindled just before dawn. Therefore, the opposite of Undómiel, star of dusk, Evenstar. !

[@flxhr5855]

Nice first age content!

[@charliecrain1830]

You’re so awesome

[@GoldenHeartIncorporated]

Lady Arwen is my Halloween Costume ❤ my husband makes the perfect Aragorn as well - learning to forge my own ⚔️ have my replicas

[@dadsbarmy254]

beautiful

[@angelaoliver2750]

I think it is a wonderful story 😊

[@WeirderGuitar]

How do you do the voice in your videos? I love it, but I remember it being different. Is it a hired narrator? Is it you? I like both voices, but I was under the assumption this channel was run by one person yet, there is a lot of art and the narrator's voice changed drastically. I would not be surprised if whoever runs this channel pays for narration or art commissions or both. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that! These videos are amazing and are a perfect way to dive into Tolkien's world. I am but a curious fan, wishing to know more about the process.

[@simonaivancic]

Tolkien made a masterpiece fiction based and inspired on Godhead, His Ways and Bible. Love that He did. Also Lewis, but in different ways. Best things, thoughts and inspiration come from Him always ,all ways !!!.. Glory to You Lord

[@kerimrorschach2744]

super cool! which program do you use to animate the images? I like this parallax effect😊

[@stotraanubhav]

You're art is amazing mate, how did you learn to do it?

[@zackmendax8002]

Thank you loremaster. Narration worthy of a master bard.

[@RealmsUnravelled]

Wow thank you for your generous support for the channel and the kind words! It's very much appreciated 😊

[@robertomarquez5170]

that was awesome

[@erikriggiola6780]

No mention,even In passing, of the first kinslaying and theft and burning of the Teleri ships?

[@aliali-ce3yf]

Arwen is so beautiful

[@c.antoniojohnson7114]

I love Elbereth Gilthoniel.....Varda herself.

[@robertgreen1286]

You're wrong, he didn't bring just evlfes he also brought the ents.

[@XC0r3]

This is my. Come and see

[@caroline7557]

Maybe this is a niche complaint but so many LOTR channels on this hellsite go out of their way to pronounce the more complicated names/words and they put on almost an elvish accent. It's so jarring to me when they do that and this channel is a breath of fresh air! You pronounce everything correctly without making it too show-y

[@craigmusa2254]

There was no evenstar in Tolkien

[@craigmusa2254]

@@SH-tc7np lol no ... the evenstar was not a thing in Tolkien it was created by Peter Jackson. You're thinking of different stars but ultimately Tolkien never wrote about the Evenstar

[@craigmusa2254]

@@SH-tc7np literally Google "did Tolkien write about the evenstar" or "is the evenstar in the books".... the answer is No. Peter Jackson invented the Evenstar. I feel like you don't understand what gaslighting is. You & a bunch of Tolkien needs have gaslit yourselves so much you can't distinguish the books from the films. Next you'll say Isildur defeated Sauron when it was the high elf king and his father who took out Sauron. It's really simple to just Google

[@craigmusa2254]

@@SH-tc7np just Google it

[@craigmusa2254]

@@SH-tc7np the silmaril is not the evenstar because the evenstar star was invented by Peter Jackson

[@jmitterii2]

You're right; Toklien never outright calls our Venus or evening star or even star those names. The point is Tolkien's inspiration from Tolkien himself was to describe myth of Elwing carrying the Silmaril as a great white bird and landing the the ship with Eärendil. Then later Eärendil becoming something like that of Venus. Tolkien liked to think the lore was some past mythology that actually existed and is part of our own world, that we're in the 7th age... in later writings. Tolkien did not outwardly say in the the various books that the Star of Eärendil also called Gil-Estel, the Star of High Hope, was exactly like that of our Venus, the "morning star" or "evenstar or evening star", but it illudes to it. Even the quote in the video from one of Tolkien's letters himself explains where he came up with his own character Eärendil from the Anglo Saxon Earendel which was the name of the morning star ie Venus. So he did. Tolkien's own letter states where he came up with the very character who would traverse the skies as a star coming from our evenstar. Tolkien doesn't call it that, he calls it other names in his mythology; Gil-Estel or Star of Eärendil. And he doesn't mention the periods in which Gil-Estel is either always found at dusk or in the morning; as our Venus has periods in which it is the morning or the evening star depending on the the orbits. Instead, since Tolkien's version is Eärendil riding on a ship with a Silmaril glowing brightly, it maybe found each day both at dusk and in the morning. And sometimes in other places. So Tolkien's version of the Evenstar, Venus, is not exactly as we would expect it to behave necessarily. But he illudes to Star Eärendil being inspired and being like and later a myth origin to our own Venus. Again, Tolkien liked to think of his saga as being inspired by ancient peoples of our own earth and time; he later wrote how he considered we would be in the same story in the 6th or 7th age of it. This illusion toward our own evening star as being Star of Eärendil is not a fiction of Peter Jackson. It's actually Tolkien's own doing. He even says so. And JRR Tolkien's own thoughts or quoted in this video about it.

[@littleteme78]

Technically Elrond and Elros are not half elves. They have one man grandfather but their father was half elf who married a full elf. Just saying. They should be 75% Eldar.

[@jmitterii2]

Yeah, but they're both called half elven per the stories written by Tolkien.

[@jpr3665]

Ardderchog

[@the26thhour57]

Enough of the absurd munga/W.o.W ears on the Tolken Elves. They're supposed to be elegant & petite, not orcish.

[@liternix]

Man who the hell watches this shi 😂😂

[@jmitterii2]

I do. And apparently so did you.

[@liternix]

@@jmitterii2 Nah bro wth even is this

[@Matser666777]

music is irritating

[@jmitterii2]

Music was good.