Ranking Best Catcher From Every MLB Team

[@christaylor3fan812]

The 12 days of MLB rankings is legitimately one of the main reasons I enjoy this time of year and straight up adds to Christmas joy for me 😭

[@Doctor_Wolverine]

Same

[@jacksonfliegler2869]

Fr

[@tinasinopoli8100]

Same

[@MICHAH6]

Same

[@bucbocboys6948]

Same

[@john670]

Bart at 25 after having a 120 OPS+ is pretty wild. Thats better than all but 2 guys on the list.

[@josthechair4]

trying to study for my midterm and marc drops this banger

[@Doctor_Wolverine]

Same

[@Cheneymlb]

Same :((((

[@gm2723]

Bro I have finals? What country are you from?

[@jesse8028]

MIDTERM?

[@jaimelannister1797]

I just finished finals how are you studying for a midterm

[@Bball_]

This video is just Brady singer getting lit up😂

[@jonmartin2913]

An we traded Jonathan India for him.. Hoping he proves me wrong

[@allthingssports4575]

If Salvador Perez and Patrick Bailey fused to one person that player may just become the best catcher of all time

[@AmpolBanana]

Or the worst if the fusion goes wrong😅

[@UTNatlChamps]

That catcher was Buster Posey.

[@brandondillman5841]

@@UTNatlChamps more like Johnny Bench. Posey didn't have that kind of pop.

[@Toast2005]

​@@brandondillman5841 Buster Posey is way better than fucking Johhny Bench 😂😂😂

[@blakebyom]

You couldn't have been more accurate on William Contreras at 1❤

[@anobsessedrangersfan_21]

LFG, We are SO BACK!!!! Biggest Rise: Austin Wells, 23 to 8 (15 spots) Biggest Drop: Luis Campusano 17 to 27 (10 spots) So hyped we are back and we’ll be back tomorrow for Day 2 (1B)

[@JustANormalBirb]

Oh we're back 🔥

[@LORDTONE]

So sooooo back!

[@BigMcFlips]

You did Tyler Stephenson dirty. He ranked 7th in MLB in fWAR and 10th in wRC+. I think he should have been higher than 18.

[@dashx1103]

That struck me too. Seemed a bit low.

[@DJ-mf6ft]

Even as a Mariners fan, I can still see why Big Dumper was #2. I want him to be #1 but he has to be more consistent at the plate.

[@wesleysteeleiv]

Typical Mariners, 2nd place which is a nice way of saying first place loser.

[@dominicanball2361]

​@@wesleysteeleiv As a Mariners fan, fr, couldn't be more real.

[@rashiroselin]

Might I suggest you rank the top 30 relievers overall rather than each teams top reliever. Kind of like what you do with starters.

[@andrewacosta9498]

And this is why Tomas nido is the best catcher in baseball

[@GiraffeNeckMarc]

Who is here early?

[@Doctor_Wolverine]

Me. Great pick on migggy

[@AnonymousBaseballFan29]

Me, love these rankings, been here since 2019, I do remember Saturday December 14 there too.

[@awhzemma]

me🔥

[@tinasinopoli8100]

Me

[@luckylandonyt]

Me

[@bradenmontiglio9483]

Love the respect for Wells. Always love looking forward to these vids when Christmas time comes around

[@SONICX1027]

I wholeheartedly agree with Connor Wong’s position in the rankings Marc. Spot on

[@josephpriano]

the joey bart disrespect is crazy

[@SugoSlugs]

Thanks for showing Bailey some love. Dude is an artist defensively. I know he's gonna work out the offensive kinks.

[@dirtydavis8308]

Oh man stoked! 12 days is here baby!! One of best Xmas gifts!!

[@zacharygamershoben9057]

Love this series that you do every year it’s my favorite keep doing a good job man. You’re my favorite on KZbin.

[@gm2723]

Something that stood out watching this is wells lack of games compared to yhe other top catchers. So I think wells should be higher, because none above him played fewer games and he should get that increased play time next year which with his 162 pace would definitely move him up. JT is close in games but he's old and gets hurt so i don't realistically know how many more games you can expect from the guy.

[@edflood520]

I've never been so excited for your left field 12 days of rankings as I am this year! Lfgm!

[@Hawkieidelson27]

i feel like ohoppe is a little low at 15, I feel like he is near 10th. also is Travis d not in this because he is also on the angels? Id love to know if you think he is better than danny jansen. Love this series and cant wait for the rest of the vids

[@tommym1466]

Austin wells💀 and the ohippe disrespect

[@NOBODYBEATSTHERIZZ]

Look at his WAR buddy

[@TheGoldenGreek21]

Always a great Christmas gift that keeps on giving. Long live this channel and the game of baseball!

[@anthams]

LETS GOOO The best series on the channel is back!

[@mickbutler4372]

White Sox fan here. I just came to see how Cory Lee was doing. Thanks for getting to him so soon. I got a feeling this is going to start a trend for my Sox players.

[@notphoenix7086]

Korey Lee has the best pop time in baseball so there’s hope in him being a good defensive catcher. He’s had good stretches with hitting so he’s got potential he’s just on the worst team of all time

[@olliebaseball]

Love to see the 12 day of MLB rankings back in Oder! ❤

[@TheOneAndOnlyMan28]

The 12 days are back! Hyped for the return of the series

[@Zackfaria14]

Shea langeliers is just modern day salvy. I get it it’s only one good year but he should be wayyyy higher considering where salvy is

[@fntrush9645]

i love these vids bro, i wait every year.

[@robit2775]

Let’s go Marc,love the 12 day series.

[@ericb2282]

12 days of rankings is back. Let’s go

[@BryceHarper3.]

Pumped that this is back! No joke you make my holiday seasons more fun with these videos! Can’t believe this is already the 6th one! My boy JT has still got it though! Glad we’ll have him for at least one more year but I’m also afraid it might be his last.😔

[@King-03530]

12 days of mlb rankings lets gooooo! Love this series

[@Jrg44]

Baileys bat falls off so bad after like June , if he keeps his first half production into the 2half of the year he’ll be way higher up the list

[@JoZoneCa]

I think both years he dealt with concussions around his fall off. Wonder if that is a possible factor

[@ethan_od29]

Absolute banger. These videos are absolutely dope

[@Braves_goat13]

yay I love this series

[@ambzsh]

O’Hoppe will be atleast #5 next year

[@dashx1103]

He’ll also be a big hit at all those combination “St. Patrick’s Day / Easter Parties” that have become so popular lately.

[@ambzsh]

@ loll

[@markg5562]

I look forward to these! LFG!

[@neymarKing-o3n]

Been waiting for this days

[@DavidWillard-ge8sp]

It isnt Christmas without these rankings videos 🔥

[@charlesmcbride6751]

Solid List! like it

[@colonelcallaway]

Love this series💪

[@java8619]

As much as I hate some of your takes, this series is one of the best parts of this season for me

[@ChaseGrote64]

Big Dumper is the best overall catcher and it’s not close. Platinum glove, 34 bombs, framed the best pitching staff in the league. Struck out because he was the Ms only offense. Continues to get better every year.

[@TheoBresnahan-vk4wp]

Him being the only good offense on the mariners does not excuse a lot of strikeouts

[@olliverklozov2789]

@TheoBresnahan-vk4wp so you know nothing about the batters eye problem in seattle

[@gm2723]

Ops+ and war say otherwise, not arguing with you just saying why the listing is what it is.

[@avocadomusic]

Been waiting for this since October

[@JesseHoffman-f2m]

My birthday is on Monday. I guess that means we’re gonna see the 2nd base tierlist that day. My favorite team is also the diamondbacks, and we happen to have the best 2nd baseman in the league. Gonna see him at #1. Awesome

[@crystalgouge6546]

Good list, Marc.

[@VrixFR]

That time of year! 12 days!

[@nahitsthekid6858]

Until what?

[@Pren999]

the best time of the year!! THE 13 DAYS OF RANKMAS

[@wildalaskanbrothers611]

I’m so happy the 12 days of mlb rankings 😊

[@seplays2280]

Love to see the yearly special

[@AndrewMcCauleysPC]

why was Higgy not mentioned???

[@DoubleA3403]

Thanks for not penalizing Murph too bad. I think he will be back in 2025. I’m pretty sure that injury was still bothering him even when he came back.

[@NONOBOY-zd7ud]

This is why Francisco Alvarez is the number 1 catcher in baseball

[@Harrisonlucero]

best series on youtube

[@LORDTONE]

I’m with this 👏🏼 I see where you are going. Dodgers still better than your Mets. Curious to all of these rankings!!!!!

[@apoxdapodxd6534]

O'hoppe disrespect

[@williamfischer3990]

As a Phils fan this is uncommon for Free Agency signings but JT has been worth every penny. He’s going into his walk year so I don’t know if Philly is going to bring him back but great signing.

[@WIBLUECREW]

Could not agree with you more on the #1!

[@Dylan-f6p9t]

Hi I love your videos❤

[@matthewdavis8872]

As a guy that owns a Keibert Ruiz jersey...28 feels high. I had so much excitement for him as a prospect when the Nats traded Trea and Scherzer. Feeling more and more like a poverty franchise over here

[@pckmovies253]

When the 12 days oh rankings start, you know it’s Christmas time

[@richardwrask497]

First time watching you, wanted to know if I liked you. I really like your insight so I subscribed.

[@GoFeverGo]

I think ur sleeping on Kirk, he's one of the best in baseball defensively, not just solid

[@RyanMariners]

Honestly, I'm a-okay with Big Dumper as runnerup. He was the best catcher in the AL.

[@f1naliz3d]

As a Red sox fan, I wasn't screaming that Connor Wong was too low, I was surprised he was even that high to begin with.

[@mrmplayz696]

O’hoppe after the 2025 season will be top 10

[@bobnapier7407]

Didn’t expect to see Austin wells at #1 but I guess Marc knows ball

[@Qwerkybsbl]

ITS THE MOST WONDERFUL TIME OF THE YEEEAAAAARRRRR

[@yu-kuanhuang6267]

No it's not

[@Qwerkybsbl]

@ Scrooge

[@cire1867]

Even though Will Smith didn’t have an elite bat this year he surprised us with pop time and game calling

[@jacksontaylor9550]

love the contreras recognition

[@nhc7772]

Idk about other Red Sox fans but I’m completely fine with Wong at #20. He’s wasn’t bad, wasn’t great either. Decent is def what he is.

[@LARDGBS0521]

Love the vid

[@BigPat216]

Joey Bart was so good last year. Hope it’s not a flash in the pan.

[@jimv1983]

It's good to see him being successful with the Pirates. He was SO BAD on the Giants.

[@Le_JYT]

Best series in baseball- I’ve gone back to last years’ at least 3 or 4 times throughout the season. Pissed I’m an hour late

[@nicholascampbell7334]

I’m a cubs fan and I’m curious if this was done before or after they signed Carson Kelly and if you think he’s an upgrade or not.

[@ryanstellato5514]

Babe wake up, GiraffeNeckMarc’s busting out the 12 days of MLB rankings 😁

[@mtverv]

The fact that Freddy Fermin wasn’t on this list is kind of a bummer. I’d have put him in the late teens-early twenties myself.

[@andrewmandelbaum102]

Lfg 12 days of rankings we are SO back

[@haroldthefrog]

As a red sox fan, you will not hear me complain about putting connor wong low on the list. had a hot start to the year but omg if you watch him he's swiss cheese behind the plate and can't frame to save his life. Hoping Carlos Narvaez provides stability back there

[@hulkerino7699]

Would like to see a "Best of the Rest" segment in these vids. Take 30 seconds to mention 10 or so players who didn't quite make the cut.

[@thomaslott6314]

Great list. I know you always just include one player from each team, but where do you think Victor Caratini ranks if you count two? Also, if there's another backup I'm not thinking of tell me. Not trying to leave anyone out, just curious about Caratini.

[@Lithixleo342]

Let’s be honest you could legitimately flip flop Cal Raleigh and William Contreras as the top 2 catchers

[@Robert-m8n2s]

True

[@Zkhn828]

No Contreras is definitely better

[@carsonperrault7797]

It’s very very close

[@Zkhn828]

@@carsonperrault7797 no it’s not, Contreras’ ops was over 100 points higher for most of the year

[@druduns1]

I dunno Contreras is a monster and is clutch in playoffs

[@YoAsianLike]

Joey Bart had one of the highest ops+ on this list

[@cowhand6112]

Stallings and Bart should be closer to 10 than 30. Both had better WAR and OPS+ than a lot of the guys rated ahead of them.

[@cooltrainerhuffy2296]

I think Joey Bart is pretty low tbh. Only 80 games and putting up better counting numbers than like 6-7 other guys in front of him. I think Kirk is the first guy you could realistically argue is better than him. Definitely a top 20 guy.

[@dashx1103]

Rogers needs to be bumped up just based on his awesome mustache.

[@cooperthemeower]

"And this is why Luis Torrens is the greatest catcher in MLB history"

[@josthechair4]

there is no world where austin wells is top 10 best catcher in baseball

[@GiraffeNeckMarc]

Why

[@theywouldnthavetocensormei9231]

He had a slow start to the season, but in the 2nd half his slash line was among the top in the league for catchers, and his defense is solid. I think you have to grade him more by the end of the year than the beginning, because he was a rookie, he's more likely to continue to get better than worse.

[@josthechair4]

@@GiraffeNeckMarc dude had one good month and was terrible in october

[@YaBoyyJohnNBA]

@josthechair4 Austin Wells had 4 months with a wRC+ over 100 this season, and he's one of the best defensive catchers in baseball btw. June: 119 wRC+ July: 163 wRC+ August: 165 wRC+ and May: 113 wRC+

[@Le_JYT]

HOLY CRAP IT’S STARTINGGGGGG

[@samcochran29]

Dang Connor got shafted

[@amtrak981]

I think the starting catcher for the Rockies. Is either going to be Hunter Goodman or Drew Romo. Goodman did very well once Diaz was dfa off the roster.

[@PulseMetrics]

Rutschman ahead of JT is wild!!!

[@BigHarperFan3]

If Realmuto isn’t top 5 imma be disappointed. Ps. Commenting before watching

[@ahronr25]

And that’s why Francisco Alvarez is the best catcher in baseball

[@Maceball17]

I may be bias, but I personally think Stephenson should be top half of the league 15 or 14

[@jaimelannister1797]

Alvarez at 12 is some pure Mets bias

[@connerpeterson1119]

About Bailey, I don't know if it's fair to entirely count out his hitting. In his career, he has 109 games in the first half and 109 in the second half. In the first half, he is a career .288/.343/.454 hitter. In the second half, he is a .179/.238/.238 hitter. I don't think it's impossible for him to figure out how to hit in the second half.

[@toxic_redneck44]

Best part of the year every year

[@JustANormalBirb]

We are SO back