Gjuhetari Aristotel Spiro: Jam studiues shqiptaro-grek, emocione nacionale nuk kam!

[@I_am_who_I_am_who_I_am]

Rrespektin me te madh per ju profesor Spiro. Ne keta kohera ku tensionet greko-shqiptare u rriten, ju si greko-shqiptar duke ju degjuar me zvogeluat zemerimin dhe frustracionin. Ju faleminderit.

[@shabansaiti5910]

Xhexhe përdoret nga shqiptarët e Maqedonisë akome dhe sot..jam vet nga Maqedonia

[@autochthonous3141]

A Gjegje gje, e perdorte gjyshi im nga Laberia ( jugu Shqiperise )

[@majlindahoxha1098]

Meshari i Gjon Buzukut kuptohet plotesisht nga shqiptaret e sotshem.

[@gur858]

Zoti M Nano - jeni i vecante ne llojin tuaj, KJO B.THELEPIRJE qe i bere grekeve e verteton plotesisht,

[@gluhaarbereshe3607]

me qe jemi te gjuha ta bejm nje blow job per te pasuruar gluhen

[@flyhighmcfree5755]

***** FREEDOM, NATIONAL AND HUMAN RIGHTS FOR NINE MILLION ETHNIC ALBANIANS IN “GREECE” ** *** Note: This Mr. Spiro, is totally wrong when saying that "Greek/Koine" is a language of 4 thousand years "old". "Greek/Koine" is an artificial language created by the Eastern Church of the Roman Empire (same as Latin language was artificially created by the Western church of the Roman Empire). "Greek/Koine" is NOT a language derived from an ethnic population, therefore it is not an ethnic language of a certain population. It is simply an administrative made-up language for ritual and religious purposes only. ----------------------------------------------------------------- Greece” will be soon excluded any participation and denied any and all voting rights in the European Union to any matters related to Albania. This because “Greece” has a flagrant, open and grave conflict of interest as a European Union member related to all matters concerning Albania in the European Union - starting with the Law of the Declaration of War against Albania, which is in effect in the present (i.e. Greece, currently, is in a state of war with Albania), and many other matters that constitute blatant conflict of interest of “Greece” in the European Union concerning Albania. Greece also has not yet paid the reparations of about 600 billion dollars to Albania - regarding the occupation through the Greek territory of Albania by Germany in 1943, and regarding the ethnocide and holocaust of Greece against Albanians in Albania (Chams and Albanians in southern Albania), and against its own citizens of Albanian descent (numbering over 9 million today in Greece). The vote of “Greece” in the European Union is the only thing left for this “Greece” to bully Albania related to all matters in the relations between this “Greece” and Albania. Albanian government should quickly set up a team of qualified attorneys to file a lawsuit with the European Commission to exclude Greece from any decision making in the European Commission regarding Albania. On the other hand, Albanian government should act as an equal and reciprocate - by immediately putting on the table its counter requirements that the European Union and European Commission must fulfill to open the road for the Albania joining the European Union in equal footing and as an equal partner and in parity. One of those non-negotiable requirements should be that “Greece” be excluded immediately from any decision making and vote regarding Albania and Albanian related matters in the European Union and European Commission. European Union and European Commission are not mafia type organizations, ”that will blindly do whatever a member of the mob organization would demand”. This “Greece” is acting like a member of the Camorra and/or a typical “Greek” mob underworld that can force its will on other mobsters by asking for other mob members total submission and obedience to its demands. Greece should also be expelled from the European Union and NATO - as a country that does not fulfill any and all criteria/requirements to be in the European Union and NATO, and because Greece is a dictatorship in the middle of Europe that does not recognize any rights at all for over 9 million Albanians/Arvanites and Chams in Greece. ------------------------------------------------- The so-called “Greece” is a made-up and fake country - made out of ethnic cleansing, racism, holocaust and ethnocide against Albanians (Arvanites and Chams) of Lower Albania. All (100%) leading and senior commanders of the 1821 revolution in the Lower Albania (called unjustly “Greece” today - a name without any factual and historical meaning), where Albanians (Chams and Arvanites). Up until 1832, all that region (called “Greece” today) spoke only Albanian. Out of 100% of the people living there in that region up until 1832, about 92-95% were Albanians (Arvanites and Chams), the rest were minorities. Albanians are the descendants of Pelasgians and Illyrians (since 10,000 years and more ago). Alexander the Great -was a Pelasgian King of Illyrian/Pelasgian Confederation of Macedonia, falsely presented as "Greek" by con and "planted" historians. The Trojan War - was a war between Pelasgians and Illyrians - both ancient Albanian kingdoms/confederations, falsely represented as “Greek” by con and planted “historians”. Homer's "Iliad and Odyssey" epic poems are Pelasgian era poems - falsely represented as "Greek" by con and planted "historians". The Thermopylae Battle - was a battle between Pelasgian army (Sparta - a Pelasgian city) and Persian army, falsely represented as "Greek" battle against Persians by con and planted "historians". The Koine/”Greek” language (a made-up religious language of Roman Empire times - same as Latin language was a religious language for the western part of the Roman Empire), was forced onto Albanians of that region (Arvanites and Chams) after 1832, through ethnic cleansing, holocaust and ethnocide by European powers (through racist Prince Otto of Germany), Russian Empire of that time, and the dangerous anti-Christian sect/cult called “Anadolli Orthodox Church”. There is no such thing as “Greece”. Greece is a scam country, artificially created by 1832, from the mafia type collusion of corrupt European powers of that time who brought Prince Otto of Germany to power in that region, Russian Empire of that time, and the dangerous anti-Christian sect/cult of so-called Anadolli Orthodox Church of that time (1832). This country so-called “Greece”, has gone entirely bankrupt and belly-up five times from 1832 through 2018, has changed the “official language” of the country two times, and has changed the national flag three times from 1832 through 2019. The latest and current national flag of this “Greece” being a blue-color replica of the East India Company flag (the British company who ruled and controlled all trade to and from India during the British rule in India). This is enough to tell all, who this made-up country really is - a country with no real and true national identity, a zombie country. If it was not for the free money from Germany, Russian Empire and European powers of that time (1832) and European Union now being poured every year to this “Greece” since 1832 through present, this kind of country would cease to exist tomorrow. And the big joke is, that this “Greece” is in a state of war with Albania today. This “Greece” has officially declared war against Albania since October 1940 - through the Law of the Declaration of War against Albania, approved by the “Greek” parliament and the foreign powers’ installed King for “Greece” on October 1940. Freedom and full human and national rights to 9 million Albanians of Lower Albania (called unjustly “Greece” today). Freedom to Albanians of Lower Albania (called unjustly “Greece” today). Albanian should be the official language of the Lower Albania, and the country should be officially called and internationally recognized as Lower Albania. Source: Brotherhood of Albanians/Arvanites and Chams of Kryekuq (Athens) and Region of Mani (Peloponnese) - January 2020, Lower Albania -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

[@nardi493]

I saw big numbers in your thesis and knowing that Greece's population is about 10 million people 9 million albanians and descendents it's too much. Also I saw many times people with a known arvanit background hating albanians and calling them turko-albanians denying their language and culture only for the orthodox belief. Also I didn't find anything of your quoted brotherhood on google, can you send me some links?

[@andreaandrea1247]

I agree with you. It is truth..

[@andreaandrea1247]

@@nardi493 truth , TRUTH TRUTH.

[@tonyalb3863]

Idra Religion does not give you ethniciti ! Todays Byzantine language has absolutely nothing to do with Ancient Greek Language thats a proven fact !

[@andreaandrea1247]

@@tonyalb3863 plisi qe e mbajme ne ne KOK . Si treva e Kosoves , Si takia Myzeqare , APO qylafi ,( qe e kane mbajtur ZOTAT e mitologjise me ne KRYE ZEUSIN .FUSTANELLAT E BARDHA e te TJERA.!!??.. jane tonat..

[@nerimlumi2637]

E kanë deklaruar vetë gjuhëtarët grekë se gjuha homerike flitet akoma në gegëri.

[@AniShtufi]

Futja pordhes o nerim. Nuk je aspak i nerum qysh po menon.

[@youtubearkiv7612]

1 gjuhëtar kishte gjuha shqipe, Petro Zheji

[@violetka1197]

...1)MINORITARET NUK KAN LIDHJE ME GREQIN..SE E DI GJITH BOTA ME DOKUMENTA QE ERDHEN NGA AZIA DHE PUNOSHIN TOKAT E BEJLERVET SHQIPTAR.........TANI PO KAPEM GREQIN.... NUK GJENDET VETEM NJI LIBER OSE DOKUMNET ORIGJINAL..LIVE... PER EKZISTENCEN E KOMBIT GREK NE ATHIN O GREQI NGA VITI 1000 DERI 1890.??....----(M PAS TE VE UN TY DIREKYT KTU NGA BIBLOTEKAT GREKE ..NJA 1000000000 LIBRA ORIGJINAL NE SHEKUJ..PER ATHINEN DHE GREQIN SHQIPTARE)...........

[@youtubearkiv7612]

@@violetka1197 Kur Bullgaria mori pavarsinë nga perandoria Osmane Vaso Pasha bëri shkrim në një gazetë të kohës (nuk më kujtohet se ku, ndoshta të gazeta e kolonisë shqiptare të Egjiptit) Ku kundërshtonte duke thënë se bullgarët janë popullsi e ardhur si bujq në tokat e Shqiptarve. Kur kam lexuar kanunin e Lekë Dukagjinit, në ligjin për bujqerit thotë: Bulgu (Sot thuhet bujku) ka të drejtë të një mdhese ku do të jetojë me familjen e tij(shtëpi pa themel) që i ndërtohet nga i zoti i tokës. Pagesa bëhet në dy mënyra. Ose pagë e të dhjeta të prodhimit që bën(10%) ose me rrogë. Pra shqiptarët i kanë dhënë emrin atyre se sot quhen bullgare ose bugarë. Jo të gjithë bujqerit ishin sllavë. E njëjta gjë edhe me minoritarët shqiptare, kanë qenë bujqer të bejlerëve dhe agallarëve shqiptar në luginën e Drinos dhe në fushën e Delvinës. Duke qenë se ishin ortodoksë u shpallën grekë. Ngjela ka një thënje: Greke nuk ka në Athinë, këta kërkojnë greke në Gjirokastër 😂😂😂

[@violetka1197]

@@youtubearkiv7612 thrakasit bullgaret...ishin ilir qe m von humben gjuhen...si e humben dakishten ILIRE ..rumunet e sotem..qe perdoren gjuhen amministrative te romes latinishten..populli n rom fliste shqip..ilir...familja kok bulgari n itali..t gjith librat e ncjerri nga epiri..grek o term shqiptar...greqia Duke pasur shum arvanit shqiptar..m 1922. U Bo ndrrimi i popullsis..ku largun me forc per m turqi..500.000 arvanit shqiptar..dhe erdhen 500.000 turq n greqi..Tani kta gabelet arixhinj..si si dhe kta minoritar jevgj..vetquhen grek....

[@azizziza5945]

violet ka Qa lidhje ka qe bahesh rraciste, jevgj e gabel ka plot edhe ne shqipri . On jevg jam po noshta e dua shqiprin ma shum se ti. Pranej mas u ban rraciste se sasht mir.

[@violetka1197]

@@azizziza5945 nuk je shqiptar .shko n mongolin tate ..Ca' Bo n shqipri..?

[@kurtifm6466]

Shqipja eshte 5 mije vjecare, greqishtja eshte 50 vjeçare

[@famos8309]

6000 vjeqare ne fakt te pakten Austriakt e kta tjert deri ne 9000 vjeqare mendojn e Suedezt mos gabofsha 10000 vjeq thojn

[@neshathykavideos]

Nje bisede me shume vlere.Bravo Aristotel qofte per qartesine e pergjigjeve qofte edhe per realizmin e tyre.Shume dakord kur thua qe njerezit ne kushtet tuaja jane dhe duhen pare si vlera.Jane ura komunikimi te shkelqyera.Si kolege i yti por edhe si shqiptare me vjen mire qe nuk ke ndjere diskrinim dhe eshte e vertet se nuk ka pasur nje te tille, te pakten ne jeten studentore dhe akademike shqiptare. Te uroj suksese te metejshme

[@leoneleone1386]

Shum i drejtë për drejtë ' Spiro 'jo urrejtje në mes të popullve ' vetëm respekt' dhe mirësi në mes të popullve ' urrejtja ska vëndë në mendjet e shëndosha normale'

[@g.v1234]

Ky spiro shum i sakt qenka,! Dhe realist.

[@clirimhoxhaj216]

Nuk ka lidhje midis greqishtes se vjeter dhe greqishtes se re. Jane krejte ndryshe. Shqipja eshte nena e gjuheve dhe celesi qe hap portat e antikitetit.

[@landiperolli4445]

Por as shqipja e somme me te vjetren as anglishtja as gjetmanoshtja dhe te gjitha gjuhet e somme kan shume ndryshim

[@dritanloka9457]

Shum Respekte per ty Professor

[@ypsoma7316]

Vetem rrespekt dhe adhurim per prof.Spiro-n! Njeri qe me dijet,kulturen dhe profesionalizmin e tij te percjell heshtazi se si duhet te jemi ne perditshmerine tone. Biseda me te ishte nje oaz i qete,ne zhurmen qe i shoqeron shpesh debatet televizive.

[@violetka1197]

DEGJO IDIOT.......1)MINORITARET NUK KAN LIDHJE ME GREQIN..SE E DI GJITH BOTA QE ERDHEN NGA AZIA DHE PUNOSHIN TOKAT E BEJLERVET SHQIPTAR.........TANI PO KAPEM GREQIN.... TI M GJEN VETEM NJI LIBER OSE DOKUMNET ORIGJINAL..LIVE... PER EKZISTENCEN E KOMBIT GREK NE ATHIN O GREQI NGA VITI 1000 DERI 1890.??.....PO E GJETE SILLE------(M PAS TE VE UN TY DIREKYT KTU NGA BIBLOTEKAT GREKE ..NJA 1000000000 LIBRA ORIGJINAL NE SHEKUJ..PER ATHINEN DHE GREQIN SHQIPTARE)............PO PRES LIBRIN TAT ORIGJINAL...

[@ypsoma7316]

@@violetka1197 ...kaq shume je deshperuar,sa qe ke humbur etiken ne komunikim, me vjen keq per katandisjen. Lere historine per pak kohe dhe meru me....... gjera me te "veshtira" per ty:- Edukaten dhe sjelljen!!!!!

[@violetka1197]

@@ypsoma7316 cke ti ..se ta mson komunikimin ty ..universiteti i athines..per greqin dhe athinen shqiptare......degjoje jevg aziatik minoritar...........kzbin.info/www/bejne/rqOXmnSsYsyMrJo

[@violetka1197]

@@ypsoma7316 he se ta mson komunikimin universiteti i athines...minoritar aziatik argat ne shqipri.....athina me 8000 shpi shqiptare....They needed a new center for the Hellenic civilization and build it over the Athene then just an Albanian town......kzbin.info/www/bejne/rGLToqCDqNOGitE

[@ypsoma7316]

@@violetka1197 .....mesohen ne shtepi keto gjera,universitetet jane per shkence dhe dije,jo per EDUKATEN e familjes, as kaq gje nuk je ne gjendje te kuptosh?????

[@kosova-pv5lu]

Këtij ti themi studiues😜😜

[@moisiguri1077]

Tani o shqiptar o grekë, se të dyja nuk mundesh.

[@tonis3504]

Emisioni Besoj duhet të jetë Humoristik, se pyetjet janë: Çfar ngjyre ka, Kali bardh i Napolonit?!!!

[@maliqveseli3469]

Humor i mire " cfar ngjyre ka kali i Bardh i ....." hs ha ha se bsrdh sikur nuk eshte ngjyre. Prishtinalia

[@AniShtufi]

Ti je i interesuar per perralla or zotni, të dhemb koka te degjosh njerez te mençur.

[@Flavor88]

Zoti gjuhetar Spiroz hera e pare qe degjoj qe paska dokuemnt ne gjuhen greke te shkruar 5000 vjecare. Mundet te na iluminoni pakez se ku e mbeshtesni kete informacion dhe si mundemi ta lexojme kete veper kaq unike?

[@margaritisgjoka8170]

Urime Aristotel. Gjithmone i sakte.

[@dougpiranha3230]

Do të ishte mirë të bëheshin debate televizive ndërmjet gjuhëtarëve dhe historianëve nacionalistë dhe atyre mbi-nacionalë, si z. Spiro, që t'i afrohemi sadopak të vërtetës shkencore dhe ta vëme në pyetje ndikimin e emocionit nacionalist që është tepër i pranishëm në media.

[@freedomseeker4165]

****** THE PLACE CALLED GREECE NEVER EXISTED BEFORE AS WE KNOW IT TODAY **** ------------------------------ Second Part ---------------------------------------------------------- By the way, Fallmerayer, is a banned figure and historian by the dictatorial klepto-theocracy regime in what is called "Greece" today. Through a thorough fact finding mission and field observations during the same time (of Prince Otto's installation to power in the region called "Greece" today), another world-renowned German historian, subject-matter expert and scientist of that time, Prof. Hans Heidenauer, came to the conclusion and reported back to German royal authorities that - “there are no ‘Greeks’ whatsoever in the region, they don't exist - there are only people and a population who speak a language called Arvanite/Albanian and the people call themselves Arvanites/Albanians”. Another earlier government fact-finding mission about the Albanian inhabited regions in Europe, commissioned by Napoleon Bonaparte (Emperor of France) around the year 1800, confirmed that, Albanian regions extended from Mediterranean Sea and Peloponnese up to Dalmatia and Danube river, and eastward beyond Vardar (Dardhar) river bordering Aegean Sea. By the way, Germany is still paying for the Otto's racist and ignorance blunder, even today. It has gotten stuck with the country so called "Greece". It is now forced to pour free money, even today, out of Germany's pocket (through European Union as well) year after year to keep it alive and going, as this "Greece" cannot stand on its own. It is an artificial creation of Prince Otto's ill-conceived fantasy and the malevolent aims of then Russian Empire and the dangerous religious cult/sect called "Orthodox" Church - a "zombie", “fake”, “scam” and a “plagiarized” country so to speak, and the new generations of the Germans and Europeans are continuing to pay the price for it. To illustrate, during its existence since 1832, this so-called country of 'Greece" has changed twice its official language and three times its national flag. Moreover, what Prince Otto did back then, is tantamount to a silent ethnic cleansing by alteration (followed later on by mass murder, pogroms, holocaust, and ethnocide by succeeding "Greek" governments). He forced inhabitants of a whole region/place (called "Greece" today) to change by force their culture, language, national and ethnic identity to something else that those people were not, so they could artificially change in order to look modern and civilized (like artificial ancient "Greeks" in Otto's personal view) and possibly be united. And of course, Arvanites and Chams (as the majority population in the region) suffered mostly from this ethnic cleansing - which was later on followed even with mass killings, ethnocide, holocaust, and mass expulsions of Arvanites and Chams (who refused to change and trade their Arvanite/Albanian language for a Koine "zombie" language), by zombie and dwarf “Greek” governments and regimes that followed into the 20th century. All this revelation, informs another major and mission critical nodal point: history taught about what is called “Greece” today, it appears to be taught wrong. People are wrongly taught in schools that today's “Greece” and its people are the direct descendants of “ancient Greeks”. “Greece and Greeks” of today, to some extent, also falsely think they are superior to others just because they are called "Greeks" and their country "Greece" by decree (not by the virtue of the truth). They also seem to falsely believe for some reason, they are entitled to the German and European money being handed out to them - as, it seems, they are unable to create any value-added contribution to the European economy, culture, art, business, science and technology. The school textbooks and historiography should change, telling people the truth as it is. And with this, will come many other changes, in the way we see relations with the country called "Greece" today. ------------------------------------------------ End ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Young Albanian-American Scientists New York, June 2018 ================================================================================================

[@VD27401]

Burimi i fjales 'AUTOKTON' ose 'αυτόχθων', i thote te gjitha...

[@mike-dp3lv]

@Pasanik Cerriku ahahahah cfare koqe

[@ypsoma7316]

@Pasanik Cerriku .....çfare spjegimi "infantil".....

[@ypsoma7316]

@Pasanik Cerriku Sistemet e referimit,ose etalonet, jane prej kohesh te percaktuara me marveshje midis "kokave" te seciles fushe dhe vlejne me hir ose "pahir" edhe per........ ty!!!! Hypotezat e tua shikojne te verteten nga poshte,si dhelpra rrushin!!!!! -o cerik pasanik,........dhe mos fol dokra!!!!!!!! se as mbivleresova dhe as nevleresova asgje!!!!! E ke qejf trillimin,por zbatoje tek vehtja ose tek gjindja jote!!!!!!!-kuptove???!!!

[@theillyriansarecomingback3653]

Ku ka pas grek ndonjeher more rrot😉

[@linihaxhi8354]

O muc pyete per emrin qe i ke vene emosionit tend

[@lela8405]

O flori,po ki Muçua,,e ka emrin enkas tua hedh shqiptarëve,,me të futur,, për tjetër punon,,.....

[@janyjany1099]

Po gjuha shqipe Nga erdh 🧐??? - dhe pse ne shkollat Greek gjuha e vjeter mesoohet me kollaj nga nxensit shqiptar qe flasin shqipe , Dhe jo ata Greek ?????

[@elbasanarifi5196]

Ky eshte futur kesaj pune si gjentil e ne anen tjeter mundohet te na fus preshen, po kote! Gjuha shqipe eshte gjuha baze e gjuheve indoevropiane. Keshtu jane eshe serbët behen gjentil deri te qellimi pastaj kur arrin qellimin te destabilizojnë cdo gje deri ne akte te kryer, ateher behen kuçedra! Rrepekt

[@enrikrushan3470]

Pyetje me vent

[@greatalexander404]

Perse mos te bashkohen te dyja shtetetne nje te vetme pasi jane pothuajse nje komb eshte mundesi qe mund te arrihet por do vullnet nga te dy anet e kufirit sic u mundua rigz fereos per ta bere por deshtoi para shume vitesh do ishte fantastike

[@enrikrushan3470]

Jo se greket jane shum raca e perzjere nuk munt te bashkohen

[@MusicOfEpirus]

Greqishtja s’ka dialekte... ka thekse të popujvë që ka aneksuar. Kur flet Shqiptari greqishten me theks shqiptari, quhet Ipirotika. Kur flet bullgari greqisht më theks bullgar, quhet thrakiotika. Kur flet Armeni, quhet pontiaka... Edhe Arbërishten e quajnë dialekt.

[@ec8186]

Cfare thote ky???? Jam nga jugu i Shqiperise qe flitet greqisht......Po pse nuk thua hapur qe flet me frike ....mua me jep ke te pershtypje qe nuk je i ballancuar me cfare tregon....

[@kurtifm6466]

Mashtrues.mashtrus.. mashtrus

[@dalidaliu1161]

a ka dialekte gjuha greke?

[@ghittymusical672]

E ku i gjeti dialektet!!!!!!

[@metigame1450]

Nuk e Di

[@orrushi.]

Nuk ka kjo tregon se eshte gjuhe falco e aplikuar nga viti 1800

[@enrikrushan3470]

Ka

[@bishenbashen4477]

E keni gabim për vijimësinë.Helenishtja,ilirishtja dhe keltishtja janë dialekte të së njëjtës gjuhë.Kjo vërtetohet në shqip nga shumë fjalë nga koha e Homerit.Grekët e dëmtuan pak vijimësinë në shek.6 kur vendosën një greqishte bizantine.

[@gjonbicaj1608]

Përse emisioni titullohet PROVOKACIJA në gjuhen serbe dhe jo PROVOKACION në gjuhën shqipe.

[@ΓιωργοςΚεραμιτζης]

Te njejten pyetje e kam bere edhe une para ca kohe po ne kete emision dhe pergjigje nuk kam mare kure.mendoj se kanalet tona i dretojne gazetare te paguar nga te huajt.

[@classicflooring4218]

Dhe ju qe beni keto komente degjoheni me kujdes dhe mos u beni ????????

[@hauzihosi1475]

Kur lexoj komentet,harris dhe më shum të kuptoj dhe të vlerësoj të madhin Spiro...

[@Nelos-ox4rp]

Declaron qe nuk e njeh mire greqishten e vjeter, dhe nga ana tjeter eshte i bindur per vazhdimesine e pa diskutueshme me greqishten moderne ... ???

[@agimkalemi1967]

I keni vjellur te gjitha

[@enrikrushan200]

Po ku fliet ne jug greqishtja perdorin ca delle ca fjale dhe ju duket sikur dine

[@epigilgameshit4930]

Ky eshte nje emision i persosur, disa nga argumentet qe sjell profesor Spiro i kam hasur ne faqen Albanian Dictionary. Urime per punen shkencore te intelektualeve minoritare!

[@classicflooring4218]

Je i pari qe thot te vertetn

[@bledihila4280]

Pirdh pirdh spiridhon

[@ilirian187]

A ka dialekte gjuha Greke sic kane gjithe gjuhet e tjera te botes.

[@nimetbeqo2270]

Po

[@ghittymusical672]

Jo se nuk ka patur kohe per tu krijuar

[@vinujk2405]

Ky mund te jete shume i zoti, por ato informacione qe tha Spiro mund te gjehen ne Wikipedia

[@rremshtufi1245]

Profesor pirdh pirdh se lirohesh

[@mark72.]

ABC tv shkronjën ë e lini pa pikat dhe bëni emision për gjuhën?!!!!!

[@johnpali5894]

Administrator doja te dija nese komentet i fshin dikush per interesa personale?

[@lela8405]

Mo na ha kohën e lirë nashi--pastaj,,

[@evjeniakota3741]

..mendje edhe shpirt ARHONDAS..NDIHEM KRENARE..QE KEMI TE TILLA MENDJE EDHE SHPIRTRA TE NDRYTURA...FLM..ARISTOTEL..FLM.. MUC NANO..

[@violetka1197]

DEGJO IDIOT.......1)MINORITARET NUK KAN LIDHJE ME GREQIN..SE E DI GJITH BOTA QE ERDHEN NGA AZIA DHE PUNOSHIN TOKAT E BEJLERVET SHQIPTAR.........TANI PO KAPEM GREQIN.... TI M GJEN VETEM NJI LIBER OSE DOKUMNET ORIGJINAL..LIVE... PER EKZISTENCEN E KOMBIT GREK NE ATHIN O GREQI NGA VITI 1000 DERI 1890.??.....PO E GJETE SILLE------(M PAS TE VE UN TY DIREKYT KTU NGA BIBLOTEKAT GREKE ..NJA 1000000000 LIBRA ORIGJINAL NE SHEKUJ..PER ATHINEN DHE GREQIN SHQIPTARE)............PO PRES LIBRIN TAT ORIGJINAL...

[@ypsoma7316]

Bravo per komentin,edhe pse me vonese! Diellin nuk e mbulon dot me shoshe,- thote nje fjale e urte shqiptare.

[@freedomseeker4165]

**** THE PLACE CALLED GREECE NEVER EXISTED BEFORE AS WE KNOW IT TODAY ****** -------------------------------------------- Start/First Part ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ The place called Greece never existed before as we know it today. The people who live in the so called Greece today used to be called "Romej" during Byzantine Empire and "Raja" during Ottoman Empire times (except the Arvanites and Chams who used to be called always by their name like "Albani", "Albanoi", etc.) and the name "Greece" never existed during Byzantine times. The people who live in the so called "Greece" today are NOT the descendants of ancient "Greece" (as the world history knows it - that civilization has been an Illyrian-Pelasgian civilization, intentionally misrepresented as "Greek" by con and planted "historians"). Regarding the religious language used in the eastern part of the Roman Empire (an invented/made-up language by Roman religious administrators called Koine/"Greek") - it fell out of use, and went extinct times ago (about 2000 yrs ago). Same happened with the Latin language (an invented/made-up language as well, which was spoken in the western part of the Roman Empire) - it fell out of use and went extinct, and is rarely spoken nowadays, except in few and certain official religious ceremonies in Vatican and for international medical terminology only. During Ottoman times in the Balkans, after the great powers pushed for an uprising in the place that today is called "Greece", an independent country was formed during 1821-1832. The majority of the population (around 92-95%) there was of Arvanites and Chameria (together with Albanian speaking regions of Follorina, Kosturi, Athens and Peloponez) stock. The rest of the minority population (around 5%) was of Aromanian, Slav, Turks, and Roma stock. The only language spoken up until 1821-1832, in the region that today is unjustly called "Greece", was Albanian. There were no "Greeks" whatsoever, they did not exist as ethnicity, population and language at all, up until 1821-1832 period in that region. Albanians also were the backbone of the uprising for independence from the Ottoman Empire - with 100% of the all senior leading commanders of the uprising for independence during 8121-1832, being of Albanian stock (Arvanites and Chams). The Arvanite Republic was the initial nucleus independent country established in the Morea/Peloponnese region by 1821. After the gain of independence, the region was divided, and with a prolonged civil war, therefore a united country could not be immediately established on the entire region. Fearing the disintegration of the region after Ottomans left (and the possibility of a return of the Ottomans), and in order to dominate the said region, Prince Otto of Germany was installed in by European powers and Russian Empire, in order to clear the mess and initiate nation - building there. He was proclaimed King of the region by great European powers and the Russian Empire of that time and given, at the same time, plenipotentiary powers to rule. The Prince Otto royal family in Germany (Bavarian dynasty) happen to be an admirer of the ancient civilizations, one of them being the extinct ancient “Greek” civilization, traces and archeological findings of which are also seen in that region called today "Greece" as well. Being an ancient history romantic and buff, "living in a bubble" and being completely out of touch with the realities of the Illyrian Peninsula at that time, Otto came up with the idea (in collusion also with the then Russian Empire and an anti-Christian dangerous religious cult in that region at that time - some self-proclaimed "Orthodox" Church), that the only way to keep the place together and for a chance to build a country there, was to adopt/impose some kind of neutral/foreign ancient language and culture for all people living in that place, that will make possible for the people to stick together under one language and culture imposed on them. Therefore, with a special royal decree, Otto proclaimed a version of the ancient artificial “Greek”/Koine language (the easier one to be taught and learned by people there in those times) as an official language of the place, and also came up with the new name for the place, calling it with a special royal decree "Greece" (a name without any historical and factual meaning). Everything else was banned, and the new "country" formed, was ordered to be rebuild anew in resemblance of the old romantic view of the ancient extinct "Greek" civilization, starting with the buildings, names of people, places, cities and villages, regions, mountains, fields and all were changed to made-up names borrowed from the ancient literature of an imaginary ancient “Greek” civilization. This of course was accompanied with money brought in by European powers to rebuild. The more people in that region agreed with the change of their true national and ethnic identity and declared themselves artificially "Greeks/Helenes" and adopted to the new order, the more money was to be pouring in. Naturally, the strongest resistance to this artificial and made-up solution, was made by the Arvanites (who consider themselves to be pure Albanians at the same time - contrary to the today's Greek governments laughable, nonsense, and desperate lying propaganda that falsely declares that "Arvanite of Greece speak Albanian but are not Albanians but Greeks") and Chams, but at no avail. It is legendary, the loss by one vote (the illegal vote of then French Ambassador) in the Price Otto's rigged Parliament of that time, of Arvanite and Chams proposal to have the Albanian (Arvanite) language as an official language of the place called 'Greece" today, and to name and call the new country "Arvanoi (Albania)" (instead of "Greece). There is overwhelming scientific and factual evidence, archival and historical documents, as well as studies and publications by major world-renowned authors and authorities in the field, about all of the above. One interesting fact here, is that one of the earlier German/Austrian well known historians and scientists of that time, Fallmerayer, alerted Prince Otto and others to this nonsense, of declaring a whole people and place by a name not belonging to them (so experimenting with them as they were guinea pigs), and injecting an extinct artificial language, culture and civilization on people who had no idea about it and did not belong to it at all. Well, Fallmerayer may have proven to be right. ---------------------------------------------------------------- End of First Part --------------------------------------------- Young Albanian-American Scientists New York, June 2018 ====================================================================================

[@heloEdi]

Zoti Aristotel me vjen shume keq dhe doja tju thoja qe nuk jeni pergjigjur na as nje nga pytjet qe ju bene. Kam aq shume kundershtime te them por mbase me duhet me shume me teper ore sesa mbajti emisioni qe ju u ftuat. Si ka mundesi ti quash huazime sllave qe kishin arvanitet dhe e kaluan ne gjuhen Greke? Si thoni qe nuk ka patur levizje masive shqiptaresh, e cila nuk ishte nderrimi i popullise me Turqit sipas Grekeve, ose me qart ndjekja e cameve nga trojet e tyje? Cameri sipas grekeve nuk ka, po si spjegohet emri i valles came qe greket e quajne valle greke? Doja tju pyesja a e dini gjuhen e lasht greke apo jo? dhe po pergjigjem une per ju, se shof qe nuk e keni idene fare kur thoni qe nje Grek nuk e kupton mire gjuhen e lasht si ashtu Shqiptari nuk kupton mesharin. Me falni po keto qe dogjej me duken si rreshta fjalesh qe i mesuat dhe jo permbledhe shkencore me argumente dhe me fakte Ju thate she Greku nuk mundet te kuptoj 100% gjuhen antike, por edhe nese nuk kupton ndjen qe eshte dicka si gjuha e tij. Po per djelektin cakonisht ca ke per te thene? Greku moderrn apo shiptari ndjen sikur dogjon gjuhen e tij? Ju besoni se doktorata juaj qe bete ne universitetin Grek do kunershtohej? Me falni perseri por mbahem shume to mos qesh me keto qe thoni dhe do te doja shume te gjeja diku kete doktorat per te pere dhe vepren tuaj shkencore dhe te bisedonim prap ose zoti Nano tju ftonte prap per nje shpjegim shkencor te thenave tuaja. Nuk e keni idene se sa pyetje kam per tju bere te cilat nuk eshte as e mundur as serjoze te behen duke shkruajtur ne comente te youtubit

[@LulëzimMuçaj-c3d]

Na doli i mençur dhe Edi tani.

[@heloEdi]

I dashur @user neqofte se ju mendoni se kjo eshte pergjigje qe duker e keni menduar shume qe ta shkruani, atehere une po e ndryshoj stilin, se mbase keshtu ju pelqen dhe Edi i menqur thot se e hape puseten dhe nuk di cfare te komentosh. pershendetje zoti @user anonym

[@PaulGjekaj]

Është një intervistë e shëmtuar qe prezentohët me prapavija të orkestruara nga qëndra antishqiptare greko-sllave.

[@indkru4977]

Hahahahaha ca I thot nano thot dhe ky.... ca papagajsh grek jan te dy

[@nimetbeqo2270]

UNË NESËR DEKLAROJ Ç'TË DUA Ç'TË KEQE KA A NUK JAM QYTETAR I KËTIJ GLOBI PIKË PYETJE NUK VË SE PËR VETE JAM I BINDUR ...................................................... ATJE KU SKA KOMENTE DO TË THOTË SE VLEN TË STUDJOHET ËSHTË NJËSOJ SIKUR TË THUASH ATJE KU SKA SMER AS ZOTI ZOTI DIHET QË SËSHTË MATERIALIST

[@Energi-Sweden]

Shume gabim e ke gjuha e lashtë greke nuk ka lidhje me gjuhën e sotme greke....

[@ghittymusical672]

Sepse ishte ylliriane

[@enrikrushan3470]

Gjuha e vjeter greke u zhduk na perset dhe me shume anon ne persisht

[@MsElvisPc]

ba ba si jan bare keto pseo viriopiriotet

[@ypsoma7316]

....nuk mund te komentoni,ju,prof.qe ka studiuar gjuhe dhe letersi shqipe! Sepse, ju, nuk kini arritur te shkruani pa gabime gjuhen e nenes fatkeqesisht. Sipas jush -> Vorioepirotet, tani me nuk i perndjek origjina dhe gjuha,ata shprehin lirshem mendimet e tyre ashtu si cdo qytetar i lire i ketij vendi.

[@violetka1197]

@@ypsoma7316 DEGJO IDIOT.......1)MINORITARET NUK KAN LIDHJE ME GREQIN..SE E DI GJITH BOTA QE ERDHEN NGA AZIA DHE PUNOSHIN TOKAT E BEJLERVET SHQIPTAR.........TANI PO KAPEM GREQIN.... TI M GJEN VETEM NJI LIBER OSE DOKUMNET ORIGJINAL..LIVE... PER EKZISTENCEN E KOMBIT GREK NE ATHIN O GREQI NGA VITI 1000 DERI 1890.??.....PO E GJETE SILLE------(M PAS TE VE UN TY DIREKYT KTU NGA BIBLOTEKAT GREKE ..NJA 1000000000 LIBRA ORIGJINAL NE SHEKUJ..PER ATHINEN DHE GREQIN SHQIPTARE)............PO PRES LIBRIN TAT ORIGJINAL...

[@ypsoma7316]

@@violetka1197 Idiot je vete,meso te sillesh,pastaj na trego "nivelin superior te baltes" ku noton!

[@violetka1197]

@@ypsoma7316 ik o pontid minoritar azie...........I KE ME DOKUMENTA QE KENI ARDH NE ATO TOKA............IK TEK NONA JOTE MONGOLI..!!

[@gandiagandia7621]

More grekrit aty ishin,si ne kohen antike,ashtu dhe bizanti e,e otomane,por ishin shqiptare,por Roma i quqjti grek kete zone.,ndoshta kjo fjale munde te vij nga geg,dialekti i veriut te shqiperis

[@enrikrushan3470]

Per shum kohe u vet qojten romane greket pastaj mbajten vetem termin grek

[@bellimilano6577]

Ky do ket mar bonusin e janarit qe ka dal

[@maliqveseli3469]

Po ky shqiptar qenka betem ka frig nha greket mos te humb naj benefinicion qe ka . Prishtinalia

[@ypsoma7316]

Perceptim i gabuar qe vjen nga mosnjohja e rrealitetit! Ne bisede permendet pak nga jeta e prof.te nderuar Spiro! Asnje frike per origjinen e secilit,sidomos ne kohet e sotme !!!!!! Kombesia nuk varet nga perfitimet,por nga genet!!!!!!!

[@maliqveseli3469]

@@ypsoma7316 Ha ha E verteta dhemb ma shume se genjeshtra.Henetika e perzier ne e quejm Melez gjys shqiptar gjysma grek apo e kunderta ose ngryshe tac e pa definuar zotrote .i njohim edhe ata .

[@ypsoma7316]

@@maliqveseli3469 ...."Nuk ve ne dyshim njohjet e tua te thella"- te shtrembera fatkeqesisht,se i rrezon e verteta!!!por cilat jane faktet qe karakterizimin qe i ben njeriut ne fjale ,...besoj e ngateron me tjeter objektiv!!!! ....ke gabuar destinacion fatkeqesisht,rrilexo histori dhe do ta kuptosh.

[@maliqveseli3469]

@@ypsoma7316 Ne raste te tilla ske nevoj me njoht shume thell historin.Se populli thot " mos e vete se te kallxon vete" tek ka vendos me studjue gjuhen dhwipe flete mjsft ne trup ka genetik shqiptare. Po ku kish nje grek me i pelqye gjuha shqipe ata na urrejn se na jemi orgjinalja.Grek nuk ka ne Athin a kamo tjeter kune.Greket e vertet jan zhduk sot te vertetit e Antikes jan vetem shqiptaret E Kosoves Maqedonis Arvanitet dhe Arbreshet . Prishtinalia

[@maliqveseli3469]

@@ypsoma7316 Mos besofshi pyetnr Niko Stilon ne Dyseldorf .Une jame ne Bayern Mynchen Prishtinalia.

[@amarokdiesel1885]

Ktu u duht te jet edhe Elena Kocaqi

[@LulëzimMuçaj-c3d]

Jo mor zotni Kocaqin e ke për përralla. Në qoftë se do të flesh dhe nuk të zë gjumi dëgjo përrallat e saj.

[@unionchannel3327]

Bo bo car monstre qenka ky studiuesi....

[@bellimilano6577]

Po fol me agron dalipajn per etimologjin e gjuhes greke dhe shqiptare

[@LulëzimMuçaj-c3d]

Paske dhe ti trutë e gomarit që t'i ka dhënë kryegomari Dalipaj.

[@nardidauti9759]

Pirth tè Çfriesh o Spiro

[@miridragoi]

Nardi Dauti ti po flet si punonjës i bordellos.

[@nardidauti9759]

@@miridragoi ti se paske gojen vetem per te ngre e per te folur ben ke dhe pun te mira me ate goje jiote

[@adnansopa4656]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂mier shipria ne kon ka mbet shipria esht e smur pasket marr fun😮😮

[@LulëzimMuçaj-c3d]

Mëso të shkruash, o injorant se nuk kuptohet fare çfarë ke shkruar.