Goa Inquisition : Lest We Forget | Shefali Vaidya |

[@sidharthmohanty6434]

"Those who forget history are condemned to repeat it " Never forget your history , it will be a bigger crime than the inquisition .

[@vivacristorey4728]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rquQq5hnpZh1m8U

[@shakyajitmaulik5579]

@@vivacristorey4728 Don't support such fraud channel. They spread lies about Hinduism. Someday they will say British were messengers of Christ who came to save us from Hinduism.

[@aldrintoscano]

The Inquisition only killed 120 people

[@keeganthambiran1375]

@@aldrintoscano that's a lot

[@aldrintoscano]

@@keeganthambiran1375 in 451 years, that's a tiny amount.

[@shrishti..]

I am from Goa and this video is what I was looking for. It really hurts when fellow Indians (some) misunderstand our Goan culture and see it in an unpleasant way.

[@neanderthal7969]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rquQq5hnpZh1m8U

[@parthapaul1249]

🥺

[@lifearoundwesternghats]

Yess myself goan I always have this question why they don't teach this things in our history book ....we learn history to learn from it ...nobody even discusses ...Christian never say anything about it because it wil bring bad name to Christianity

[@utubesanjay]

Thank you Shefali for opening our eyes. I am a Christian and as a tribute to my ancestors, will be reverting back to Hinduism once I get back to India. Vande Mataram.

[@prabhashankar1633]

Very nice to hear that

[@vritraharata3222]

Welcome back to freedom and liberation.

[@rami3999]

Are you reconverted to hindu??

[@Sharani262]

Are you a Hindu now? You don’t need to wait to be a Hindu again if you haven’t already (?)

[@savitakumari2734]

Kindly watch the videos of Esther Dhanraj as well.

[@ashutoshhegde7290]

I am a konkani gsb from karkala, karnataka (udipi district). Kuldev is in zambaulim, goa and aryadurga, ankola. This story is 100%. The zambaulim temple was in madgaon ( present place where the holy Spirit church) and the ruins of the aryadurga temple is found in the anjadiv islands ( originally called aryadweep islands). Great work Shefali Ma'am.

[@lifearoundwesternghats]

Yess but problem with Hindus is we doent share this things with other nobody knows about it

[@nishiketubhayakar5870]

I'm a Chitrapur saraswat brahmin our ancestors ran frm kashmir to Goa to Karnataka Mangeshi is my Kuldevta i was shocked to hear that was also destroyed 😞

[@ketankulkarni6297]

What I don't understand is why did Goans move to Karnataka instead of Maharashtra? Especially since our languages are similar?

[@zdimension01]

I recently found my Kul Devi. In year 2018😮

[@rajmandrekar9166]

​@@nishiketubhayakar5870 GSB bamon and their hypocrisy at its peak. @AAA-ul8rq most of the catholic in Goa are converted Muslims from adil shah regime and elite GSB bamon who helped Portuguese to invade goa and grabbed majority of land in Goa by becoming bhatkars. They also gained top education and position in Portuguese regime. And helped Portuguese to convert few lowercast people of Goa . This GSB bamon can go to any extent to have superiority over bhahujans . This also grabbed majority of temples using Portuguese Mahajan act . They also insisted to keep most of the Portuguese law in Goa after liberation too. So that it can helped them to retain their power.

[@VinayakKudvaG]

Unfortunately, current situation seems to be kind of similar to what the portuguese managed to achieve in Goa. Being Hindu seems to be a reason for attracting attention and discrimination.. Ex : RTE act inherently targeting "non-minority" schools only, Interference in Temple management, taking away the offerings made to the deity and using it for all kinds of non-temple causes, Courts actively taking up PILs on matters related to Hindu traditions, festivals and encouraging reform but deferring similar movements in non-majority populations. Looks like we have not learnt from history. This talk should help all right thinking individuals to introspect and draw conclusions from the scary parallels that seem to be emerging. Thanks to Shefali Vaidya ji and Srijan foundation for organizing and sharing this.

[@kdcruz75]

Vinayak Gokuldas Kudva There is a tradition in kerala ..were they hurt children with hooks in their skin..after starving them for days..this happens in the pongala festival.. This ritual is a modern rendition of child sacrifice that used to take place before.. And rightfilly the state put a stop this barbaric child abuse..after doctors complained children were coming in with wounds that went septic.. Do u accept child abuse or tradition that condones it..

[@rohanraghav9943]

truthdemon more bullshit propaganda from Hindu haters . You'll do anything to bad mouth Hinduism won't you? Islam and Christianity are the worst religions and Have caused far more genocides and pain globally! Hindusim hasn't caused even one hundredth of the mayhem these two monotheistic cults have!

[@rohanraghav9943]

truthdemon and he talks about government intrusion in temple affairs and discrimination against Hindu run schools. Why did you not address that you Abrahamic ghoul? Instead you started your anti Hindu rant.

[@VinayakKudvaG]

it might be part of some atrocity literature selectively compiled and documented by initial colonials.. This kind of literature was used to justify colonial rule over "barbaric natives". Like mentioned in the video, same pattern of sanitizing and eventually secularizing all festivals and rituals.

[@kdcruz75]

Akash Sasidharan indianexpress.com/article/india/kerala-prisons-chief-r-sreelekha-minor-boys-attukal-temple-5081667/ Google : pongala trivandrum child abuse.. As far as im concerned their are only two religions in the world .. Those who seek truth to rid ignorance and the other is idiocy.. Which one do u fall into ..considering ur reply to me...

[@shrigadi]

Very good talk by Ms. Vaidya. Thank you for putting the facts straight. My ancestors were from Goa. Having faced the brunt of atrocities committed by the portuguese church, they migrated down south to Karnataka for survival. Still in this day and age, we pay a visit to Goa ocaasionally and pay our respects and seek blessings of our Kuladevata. Memories can not be erased. Still awaiting for the church to offer apologies for their terrorist activities against humanity. World over, the church has committed similar atrocities in the name of religion.

[@incarnation8187]

@shrinivas Gadiyar can relate to you as even our family is one of them. Our deity is still in Goa Mhalshi. So much attrociries, so much hatred our ancestors had to go through just churns my stomach. And today we have forgotten it all.

[@bhavendrajyoti1655]

What purpose will be served by the Catholic church offering fake apology if its intention is to knight its holocauster footsoldiers and lieutenants ? The Pope of the Vatican has conferred honours upon the Croatian mastermind and kingpin of the holocaust wreaked on hundreds of thousands of Indian Roma Gypsies in Croatia, Bosnia and Slovenia by fanatic Catholics at the behest of the Catholic church in the 20 th century.

[@rajmandrekar9166]

Why to apologise? @AAA-ul8rq most of the catholic in Goa are converted Muslims from adil shah regime and elite GSB bamon who helped Portuguese to invade goa and grabbed majority of land in Goa by becoming bhatkars. They also gained top education and position in Portuguese regime. And helped Portuguese to convert few lowercast people of Goa . This GSB bamon can go to any extent to have superiority over bhahujans . This also grabbed majority of temples using Portuguese Mahajan act . They also insisted to keep most of the Portuguese law in Goa after liberation too. So that it can helped them to retain their power

[@roshanchachane142]

Nowadays, these same Christians teach us about Human Rights and equality.

[@जितेन्द्रगुप्ता-छ4न]

they feel weaker to us and fear till they regain strength.

[@kashis3357]

@@samuelfernandes8554 he's probably a dumb Bhakt northie

[@tiken855]

you are right christianty is no better than islam.

[@tiken855]

@@kashis3357 he is right.

[@AdityaSharma6997]

@@kashis3357 stop your generalized shit

[@swapnilbhasi]

Silent Hindu Genocide nobody talks about...the end remarks tells the application of the same age-old acts in today's scenario

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

Happening all over west Bengal

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

BUMBLEBEE It has become hub of Bangladeshi Muslims

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

BUMBLEBEE No brother but equally concerned about Bengal like any other Hindu

[@ananyalal7950]

What I don't understand if they know they are converted through these horrible practices and not through their own free will, why can't they convert back. Some of them even know their Hindu last names. What is stopping them? Why not make the bones Inquisitioners turn in their graves...

[@ananyalal7950]

If we had no self pride, there wouldn't be Hindus in the world today. Every European country became Christian country in 15-50 years. But India is still majority Hindu. Don't yap for the sake of yapping. Give your ancestors some respect for fighting against all odds to preserve our ancient civilization.

[@bhojanshahibahadur7433]

My ansistors escaped and settled in Kerala. What a painful ride it must have been to leave everything and migrate to protect dharma. Next generation need to know to learn lessons from history. Thank you for the elaborate work and effort put in.

[@satyakiran1]

I am in tears.....When there is lot of blood stains in their hands...Now they are preaching peace ....This is the current state of xtianity

[@itxmeme7143]

Man it was done by Portuguese or British it is not about Christian. They used religion to conquer people and enslave them. Do u see any such things now?

[@smathias7840]

Had I lived in Palestine, in the days of Jesus of Nazareth, I would have washed his feet, not with my tears, but with my heart's blood! Swami Vivekananda If I, as an Oriental have to worship Jesus of Nazareth, there is only one way, that is, to worship him as God and nothing else Swami Vivekananda BIG Difference between Jesus and politics.

[@albertjose5615]

Portuguese was still better than the atrocities committed by locals

[@Welcome-he7hu]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/a3vZnKuMbc9rm6csi=kVJRFC1MFahR4njQ

[@vi11236]

​@@itxmeme7143man they did it in the name of Jesus ,do I see anything now off course i studied in a convent nd I was Ill treated my whole life..those bic sisters wud be nothing less than Hitler if there was no law nd order...no bindi, Bangle, kumkum ,payal,flower,if v ever wore kumkum they called us traffic lights..hit if we put mehndi for a special occasion..Christina was a goan teacher she made sure to pick on hindu children she even broke a nose of boy..guess what she called us aaay no addressing with names... Christian children were addressed child...I can go on nd on nd on

[@himanshusahoo6536]

Amazing talk! I am ashamed that I knew nothing about Goan history prior to this talk.

[@tysondacosta7802]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHi7gpKlZZqVl7M Watch this please to understand Inquisition a little better

[@rajmandrekar9166]

most of the catholic in Goa are converted Muslims from adil shah regime and elite GSB bamon who helped Portuguese to invade goa and grabbed majority of land in Goa by becoming bhatkars. They also gained top education and position in Portuguese regime. And helped Portuguese to convert few lowercast people of Goa . This GSB bamon can go to any extent to have superiority over bhahujans . This also grabbed majority of temples using Portuguese Mahajan act . They also insisted to keep most of the Portuguese law in Goa after liberation too. So that it can helped them to retain their power

[@antonettetebal963]

Why creating commotion in disturbing peace of Goa

[@BlensonPaul]

I am a mangalorean konkani christristian, I wanna reconnect with my ancestors of Goa,. 99.9% of the Christian have no idea of their history.. sadly they are not interested either..

[@Aakashputtur]

Nikulu konkani daye pateruni kudlad?

[@Jessica-ri4qv]

Right, 99.99 catholic have no idea, not interested eithe also refusing all are false

[@kalburry0954]

@@pakoochavo8696 only a dumb person does that who follow blind faith

[@mahabharat3977]

Come back to the fold of Dharma bro, a come back is required. I am in US connecting back to Dharma also helping fellow Latinos. Ciao

[@vinithacrispin]

I am very interested to know my history as an Indian Christian

[@arendrashukla8933]

never forget.... hindus plzzz unite

[@vivacristorey4728]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rquQq5hnpZh1m8U

[@joicejose4395]

To kill who?

[@ritesh3539]

@@joicejose4395 he is a kid ignore him

[@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz]

@@ritesh3539 and what are you? Stupid?

[@PrithaBhowmick-cb1cz]

@@joicejose4395 Hindus doesn't kills rather protect or defend themselves from converts .

[@vibhavenkataramu7135]

Truth Liberates - absolutely Shefali. The way you have researched on this topic deserves a big applause. Come out with more such lectures .

[@abantisarkar2055]

@Susmita Nath happy to see Hindus are coming to their senses

[@neanderthal7969]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rquQq5hnpZh1m8U

[@kaushik-cy6vo]

She doesn't need to research it is her families and ancestors personal and real story

[@lifearoundwesternghats]

In Goa everyone knows about it but nobody speak about it openly ...evn myself been goan hindu ..I cam to know through my grand mother and other old ladies from village ....whatever she said is true ...our many temples got destroyed almost all only one ancient temple surviving and many peopl from karantaka maharashra come in Goa to pay tribute to their family diety ....including Sachin Tendulkar and Lata mageshkar

[@rajmandrekar9166]

​@@lifearoundwesternghatsnot at all. most of the catholic in Goa are converted Muslims from adil shah regime and elite GSB bamon who helped Portuguese to invade goa and grabbed majority of land in Goa by becoming bhatkars. They also gained top education and position in Portuguese regime. And helped Portuguese to convert few lowercast people of Goa . This GSB bamon can go to any extent to have superiority over bhahujans . This also grabbed majority of temples using Portuguese Mahajan act . They also insisted to keep most of the Portuguese law in Goa after liberation too. So that it can helped them to retain their power.

[@dakupotato8074]

Thank you Shefali Vaidya for this excellent talk, recounting history as experienced by Indians. This is a powerful reminder that whether it is the oppression by the Muslims or oppression by the Christians, there is no difference at all. In today's India, we have strong Muslim and Christian lobbies who have once again incentivised NOT being Hindu, and rewarded the convertees. Your talk should serve as a powerful jolt to those people still imagining some sort of secular utopia when India is dominated by these murderous cults.

[@robertmitchell8630]

Daku Potato I agree So it high time us Hindus start doing more social service for our vulnerable Hindus like the dalits who are vulnerable and dehumanized by us Hindu Think ambedkar who publically renounced and denounced HINDUISIM

[@robertmitchell8630]

Che Guevara it's worth noting if a Christian become a Hindu all it means is Christianity got 1 less and HINDUISIM got 1 more however when a Hindu becomes a Christian the difference is HINDUISIM not got 1 more enemy

[@frozenlion331]

Most europeans are leaving christianity. Uk 71 percent of millineals(age 16 to 29) are atheist Czech 91 percent are atheist Estonia 81 percent are atheist Sweden 75 percent are atheist Netherlands 72 percent are atheist Hungary 67 are athesit Belgium 65 percent are atheist France 64 percent are atheist Finland 60 percent are atheist Denmark 60 percent are atheist Norway 59 percent are atheist Spain 55 percent are atheist Russia 49 percent are atheist. If you look at the number of people who go to church on sundays it is less than 10 percent (of all population not just millineals) in all of these countries. Bottomline is they are selling you a philosophy that is rejected by the west. www.theguardian.com/world/2018/mar/21/christianity-non-christian-europe-young-people-survey-religion?mc_cid=78e2abfee3&mc_eid=b5f1c39cdf

[@rohanraghav9943]

Che Guevara Christianity is no less a predator religion than Islam. It has destroyed pagan cultures and caused many a genocide (Rwandan genocide is the recent one). Both are monotheistic cults. Christianity is more sophisticated at it that's all

[@RajneeshKapil]

+Muthu Palaniappan jee have u read any book of budha if yes then you are still illitrare if no then please read

[@stephanieellison5668]

Sigh... What you went through to be able to speak about the Goa Inquisition is not fun at all. I had to go through this for my Cherokee Native American ancestors. It was really painful, because I did not get to know that part of my family, and my choice to live as my Cherokee ancestors did was taken away from me. I would have chosen to live this way rather than *this* white mess I've found myself in today. I am having a REALLY, REALLY difficult time getting myself back to reading the history of Christian and especially Islamic conquests of Bhāratavarṣa, because the saṃskāras from my ancestors are there (epigenetics). It is really hard! Look at the angry looks on the faces in the audience. I went through the same thing in the early part of life. Your people are still alive and moving forward. Mine are largely gone. Traditionalist Cherokees are reduced to maybe under 1-2%. Even then, their knowledge system was infiltrated with Jesus coming into the picture in 1955. Our fate was sealed, and we have become "museum-ized." Period... Which is why I want to move to Bhāratavarṣa. I commend you for taking this on and sharing this.

[@vvanamali6286]

Here is an extract from "Christianity in India: The Hindutva Perspective" by Ashok V. Chowgule: ( www.scribd.com/document/25716910/Christianity-in-India-the-Hindutva-Perspective ) [Enrique] Dussel ("A History of the Church in Latin America", Grant Rapids, Eerdmans, 1981) gives a sophisticated analysis of the clash of cultures which followed the Spanish conquest of America. Its unambiguous result was that “the Hispanic civilisation virtually annihilated the Amerindian civilisations in America. The indigenous political and military organisations were obliterated,and the Amerindian elite and their institutions of education and culture were destroyed. What was left of the Indian community after being decimated in part by epidemics, wars, and inhumane treatment was totally unhinged from the ancient context which the norms and the organisation of the Amerindian cultures provided.

[@g2s2m19]

Have searched a lot for the Native Americans culture, what you are suffering is really painful, I don't have words to express my pain.

[@MichElle-sd6gj]

so why wait & enjoy the privileges of North America but praise pagan Hinduism?

[@yeshwant5875]

@@MichElle-sd6gj because those lands of north america are hers. You're no one to lecture her

[@silverbullet3939]

Is there any effort being made to revive the Cherokee traditions?

[@47atim]

I AM PROUD TO BE A HINDU. AND WILL ESPOUSE THE HINDU CAUSE AS LONG AS I LIVE AND TO MY LAST BREATH.. JAI HIND.

[@stanleyvonne]

And so you should. But be clear about what you mean by "Hindu cause". It shouldn't be the neo-xenophobia that is galloping into our society. That was never Hinduism. Don't confuse Hindutva with Hunduism.

[@stanleyvonne]

@Rahul Hari send me your email address

[@siddarthshah1773]

Stanley Pinto ohh common burthurt rice bag crying.. u have already sold ur soul to congress and u ppl r still converting our tribal ppl and u r teaching us what we should do

[@lakshyasehgal4097]

these rice bag communities have converted and radicalized whole of nagaland to a extend that they are now demanding libration from god knows what but still they come to lecture us and call us intolerants and diverted.

[@ambasta5912]

@@stanleyvonne the one who can't be of their ancestors can never be of the nation!! You 2nd hand convert don't teach us..what is hindutva and Hinduism Long live hindu resistance!!

[@AshvinPatelUSA]

Shefali Vaidya, thank you for sharing information. This is the first time I came across genuine account of atrocities done by foreign invaders in Bharat. My father once visited Goa and he heard about this from local people which he told me. Since then I was curious about it. Finally I got the actual account of their horrific destruction in Goa. It's chilling just by listening. We have lot of work ahead of us to repair the damage they have done.

[@tysondacosta7802]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHi7gpKlZZqVl7M Watch this please to understand Inquisition a little better

[@Johnny-pi1vk]

Most of satav was done by Bammans for thousands of years towards the Sc St obc people and treated them like kachra

[@sunilmallya007]

We the Gowd Saraswat Brahmins were major victims of this inquisition. We are now scattered all over the west coast of south India.

[@Nimmie111]

Hope you're still practicing Hinduism

[@Godiyavaishnav12]

I'm a Brahmin of dadra nagar haveli

[@rajumodiofficial4675]

Because you forget Lord PARSHURAAM

[@alwaysajaymahale3442]

Same bro I too

[@snaik9141]

Only GSBs???? U forgot Naiks Dessais Marathas Bhandaris and Gauds

[@kermeey]

The situation in Ceylon (Sri Lanka) during the Portuguese Colonial rule from 1505 to 1640 was no different. So sad, indeed!

[@golupawring]

Ya bcoz every invders were destoying india

[@tysondacosta7802]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHi7gpKlZZqVl7M Watch this please to understand Inquisition a little better

[@svtvda7008]

Shefaliji.. I was made to feel inferior because I'm a hindu around the time of 1988. And i went to a convent school wich was the only school in d village. I'm a daughter of a respectable doctor in the village!!! That behaviour of the nuns still kept popping in my mind.. now I have an answer. Thankyou. Thankyou for making me more proud of my heritage.

[@BeautifulGoa-z5i]

There are many convent schools accross India where countless children from all religions have studied and have become good Indian citizens and have great relations with their teachers and schools. Also many Christian kids who studies in non-Christian schools. You must’ve felt inferior because of your own issues. If the schools were bad then they would surely have been shut down

[@marcossilvadasilveira4879]

Excellent lecture. Really enjoyed. Here In Brazil there was also an inquisition, between 1560 and 1775, but there were never any "autos de fé." The Church appropriated the property of converted Jews and settlers accused of practicing sodomy and witchcraft. It generated, however, a mentality that still exists today, of whistleblowing, of gossip, the idea that power can naturally be cruel to those who do not follow its rules. Many people complain about these characteristics of Brazilian culture, but they cannot relate them to the inheritance of the Inquisition. Your talk helped me to understand this relationship better.

[@rahulm2827]

thank you for this speech. specially the the goan folk song "i want to cross the river" made me cry.

[@tysondacosta7802]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHi7gpKlZZqVl7M Watch this please to understand Inquisition a little better

[@singhs2817]

In today's India North East is a majority christian states...they don't allow Hindus to own land...in Nagaland one Hindu Bengali was shot dead when he stoop for Municipal poll election..Hindu temples, tribal customs ppl are discriminated and forced converted even today..

[@Hari_prasad1996]

Singh's In southern india , muslims do the same.They don't allow hindus to own lands in muslim dominated areas.They weaken hindu businessmen and merchants by establishing their own bigger markets with the funding from mosques and outside(saudi, for instance) countries.Muslims only buy from merchants from their community, but blind hindus doesn't care . We have to stay united against this. They also multiply like jackrabbits.While the birth rate(child per woman) of hindus and christians is around 2 to 2.1, that of muslims is 3 to 3.1. Recently, these assholes went on a rampage against hindus in the fake pretext of demanding justice for asifa bano.Many hindus were injured, our institutions destroyed, and temple walls defiled with their agenda posters.Even houses of hindus were targeted, and women and children were molested.

[@Rus-bw2oq]

In India a minority wants to dictate how the majority does and does not .

[@srini612]

Not really. They dont even allow other Christians to own land. This is not true of all north eastern states. The loyalties are more along tribal lines than religion. FOr example, A Hindu Bodo may get along better with a Christian Garo than a Hindu Jaintia. Moreover, nowadays most people get along.

[@akgbkc]

Dear Shefaliji, An eye opener, heart shattering talk. I could see the pain you were going through as you delivered it. I admire your courage of conviction in bringing the shadowy era to light. We need to know the truth , even if inconvenient , if fact more so if inconvenient. Thanks.

[@rajmandrekar9166]

It's not a eye open but eye wash buy this GSB Brahmin lady . most of the catholic in Goa are converted Muslims from adil shah regime and elite GSB Brahmin who helped Portuguese to invade goa and grabbed majority of land in Goa by becoming bhatkars.and keeping lower caste people as mundakars. They also gained top education and position in Portuguese regime. And helped Portuguese to convert few lowercast people of Goa . This GSB Brahmin can go to any extent to have superiority over bhahujans . This also grabbed majority of temples using Portuguese Mahajan act . They also insisted to keep most of the Portuguese law in Goa after liberation too. So that it can helped them to retain their power

[@birendra03]

Birendra K Jha : An emotional talk. I have great respect for the Saraswat Brahman. Every Hindu should listen this talk. Tears rolled down my cheeks. Thank you Shefali Vaidya. Excellent talk.

[@Silly132]

I am proud to b a Goan Hindu thanks to my encestors, they never fell for their rice bags

[@neanderthal7969]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rquQq5hnpZh1m8U

[@mariamalhotra8228]

Rice bags are used by Protestant evangelicals, not Catholics.

[@fikru3759]

@@neanderthal7969 he may be urs dhruv rati but we don't belive this idiot on yt.

[@us-du44fx4u]

Rice bag is their current modus operandi. Earlier they used to use only violence. Now since violence is out of table, they target poor people through rice bags.

[@traveljunkieleonardo3679]

Kumar isn't a Goan hindu surname 🙄🙄

[@itsmeravikiran]

Shefaliji, I had no idea about goan history. This is an incredible talk. Is this taught in any syllabus in any part of goa or India ?

[@mxxmauuhan3597]

Ravi Kiran Christianity is worst then Islam. If we study the death and destruction brought upon humanity and civilization by Christians then Muslims are saints.

[@mistery4437]

I agree with you all but the 'saints' part. Chrisitianity is the evilest of all but Islam - by virtue of the doctrine - is not far behind.

[@mxxmauuhan3597]

ferzy09 All religion can be bad but some are worst whether you put them in public or in mind. Christianity and Islam comes in worst category whether you confine it in mind or put in practice in public.

[@frozenlion331]

Most europeans are leaving christianity. Uk 71 percent of millineals(age 16 to 29) are atheist Czech 91 percent are atheist Estonia 81 percent are atheist Sweden 75 percent are atheist Netherlands 72 percent are atheist Hungary 67 are athesit Belgium 65 percent are atheist France 64 percent are atheist Finland 60 percent are atheist Denmark 60 percent are atheist Norway 59 percent are atheist Spain 55 percent are atheist Russia 49 percent are atheist. If you look at the number of people who go to church on sundays it is less than 10 percent (of all population not just millineals) in all of these countries. Bottomline is they are selling you a philosophy that is rejected by the west. www.theguardian.com/world/2018/mar/21/christianity-non-christian-europe-young-people-survey-religion?mc_cid=78e2abfee3&mc_eid=b5f1c39cdf

[@thecommonman5616]

@UtechS You need the support of the Jews and the Christian nations to fight China and Pakistan. Do you think you can do it alone without America, France, Russia and Israel?

[@jbiswas5762]

Islam carries a sword openly in its hands, The Church carries it hidden in his sleeve. Both want to overcome us.

[@gamvivo565]

J Biswal brilliantly said

[@ajay191024]

Mr Viswas please Rajiv Melhotra's video then you will know that christiandom has hidden ageda

[@rsudhakaranpai6480]

@biju joze Portuguese just didn't do some wrong... they burnt more than 16000.thousand Hindus....and your ancestors are Hindus. It is a big crime.... not just some petty theft...

[@sriramkrishnan4439]

@biju joze History is history. First and foremost we needn't slander anyone in any form. However an introspection is paramount. If you take world history, the Church (and hence Christian rulers) has been the most violent. It's only in context of the Indian subcontinent and Asia at large that Islam and Islamic rulers have been the most violent. So let us not shy away from that fact.

[@saaamaak]

Christianity came to India, from Israel, centuries before it landed in the shores of Europe or America. St Thomas (one of 12 apostles of Jesus) himself a convert from jewism, converted Hindus in 13 AD by faith alone, not by sword. What is wrong in sharing ones best religious practices? and conversion by self-will of the person wishing to convert, isn't a crime So calling Christianity a western religion, and that it was thrust on Hindus everywhere in India isn't true.

[@NitinSingh-xr7ft]

Awesome lecture, ma'm. I have been living in Goa for 15 years. I have been to Tambdi Surla many times. One of the most beautiful temples sites, right in the middle of the western ghats. I was always curious as to why most temples in Goa are in a small radius in and around Ponda. Also, the culture of Ponda is rich and Indic. Now, everything makes sense.

[@gglm1]

Hi Shefali. Thank you for your detailed talk. I speak for myself and am probably a converted Christian from the past, but I am so happy that I have embraced Christianity and believe in a God who loves and cares for me and who I can hope in!

[@VIWA1]

It’s blind faith brother

[@FranciscoDaCosta]

Ms Vaidya has done an excellent job chronically exposing to those that care and have their heart in the right place - the atrocities committed by the Catholic Church and the missionaries - converting the Hindus my ancestors to the Christian faith. This period of the Inquisition has tarnished the name of the Jesuits - and leading the way to form the Inquisition and execute the atrocities - St Francisco Xavier. One Hindu remarked - why are there not more Christians - commenting on this page - the reason is simple - they have not heard the truth - and more they are not concerned about the situation in hand. A Cherokee has commented his tribe was treated the same way as Ms Vaidya explains to us - all. I lived in Goa and know a lot about what Ms Vaidya is talking about. Some Christians who have studied for their Masters and higher the History of Goa and the role of the Inquisition. The shame of this action is known to many Goan Catholics - however, after all these years - hundreds of years many of the so called converts have not be comfortable with their conversation. So many simple have abandoned the Church and more after learning about the atrocities. The ancient books recited by heart by the Brahmin priests and other commentaries written is Sanskrit - now translated reveal more - and in this digital world - as we see with the KZbin presentation - many will now support a revolution - to stand tall and represent - more, with one's heart in the right place. A documentary must be made and distributed to all the libraries, colleges, universities, temples, discussion and forums held and light shed - where there is abject darkness. Near Ponda I met some Buddhist monks way back in 1968 and learned about these monks and how they travelled from Goa to Siri Lanka and beyond. Of interest in the make up of a Goan - in music, as teachers, as judges, as leaders, as stellar workers in Government - all over the world - they have accomplished a lot and are respected. When I lived in Goa - I gravitated to the " thali " and love to chicken xacuti prepared by the Hindus. I encouraged the Hindus to play field hockey, and cricket - noticed most loved football aka soccer - women and men. The Jesuits can be mandated to create an institution to showcase the Inquisition - let the truth be told. Of interest the DNA sample can be taken from the remains of St Francisco Xavier from Spain - a Basque - and reveal if the remain are his or that of a Buddhist monk. I would often visit the temples in Goa - the Brahmin priests would stick to the mundane - and not engage on topics - such as the forced conversation - and many were intimated that I was interested in such a topic. I have travelled all over the world - and Goans - be they from any denomination - are more united outside Goa than inside Goa. The Chief Minister of Goa the very first one - was my friend - and encouraged me to play cricket for his team. When Chief Minister Dyanda Bandodkar ( I may not have his name correctly spelled) most of Goa - was sad. His cremation took place at the Mir-a-Mar beach - a ritual that would never have happened if the Portuguese were ruling Goa. My family have a few revolutionaries who fought the Portuguese - some had to flee - and others stayed back until they passed away. I normally do not like to debate on such a topic as the Inquisition, forced conversion, torture, rape, stealing property and a host of other nefarious activities - conducted with intent by the Portuguese. Paradoxically - the President of Portugal today is a Goan - he even visited his village - and seems to be open. It is time to send him a brief - chronologically stating what Ms Vaidya has revealed - and set the record - straight. The United Nations, the Court in The Hague, many Foundations that have taken the cause of genocide up - around the world - must at least know the facts. I knew some of the facts - my parents were open to the Hindus - and we had many good Hindus friends. However, this history is one of pain, trauma, guilt, nightmares, trials nd tribulation - fleeing from one's ancestral home - to some temporary safe haven. Those that fled men and women - were willing to die - for their faith - and their culture - going back thousands of years. Today - we have educated people ready to listen and more to right the wrong. We must continue to have forums - to discuss the content - a documentary should set the standard - with vetted facts. Facts stated by Ms Vaidya. Brahmin priests, scholars, historians of repute - on the subject of Inquisition and Goa's dark history - all vetted by a team of experts. More HIndus and if an exception is made - consensus from the team of experts - taken into account for inclusion. I was told at least in Bardez - those Catholic Churches - built by the river - Moira, Aldona, Mapsa, Panjim, Margao and so on - once on those very sites stood temples. This history and a vetted curricula must be introduced in the schools - the truth told - light shed - where there is abject darkness.

[@shivajiugar4463]

Hatsoff to u sir, for speaking truth.

[@Jenvlogs404]

We have ancient sectors of Syr & Nasarani St Thomas that should be respected, when you go from spiritual to a “path”, the sectors turn on themselves too.

[@aaron7960]

Do you know who is Antonio Costa just a liar Prime Minister of Portugal. Already the Temples where rebuilt by the Portuguese in Goa since 1770 during the reigns of Marques de Pombal . Just 3 days Sudin Dhavalikar himself has clarified this about the Temples in Mangueshi , Nagueshi , Mardol and Kundaim

[@aaron7960]

@Jai Bholenath जय भोलेनाथ many temples with the linga from Salcete relocated to Gokarna , Kumta , Karwar and places in Karnataka. The unfortunate thing was that the inquisition planned against Moors in Spain initially afterwards had it's effects in Portugal in 1498 and then in 1568 in Goa on religious temples.

[@lifearoundwesternghats]

I m goan hindu and u have spoken bitter truth wch many catholic don't evn want to discuss

[@akankshasingh1863]

Never forget , never forgive .

[@TamilArjun4090]

akanksha singh We have to restore ours and clean up unwanted

[@sm1111]

You can’t keep the hatred burning.

[@akankshasingh1863]

Sofia M , hatered was started by you , and we will end it by our hatered .

[@sm1111]

akanksha singh Hatred has to be stopped by all. I don’t identify myself with my past history. I had no role in it. I can only be responsible for my present. I have a mind of my own and am dispassionate in my views. The issue is human activity is mostly driven by greed, power hunger and ‘ religion’ serves as a useful tool to control the masses. Very few people follow their respective religions in their true essence. They cherry pick to serve their own interests. You will just repeat history if you keep the hatred going. This was an informative talk.

[@akankshasingh1863]

Sofia M , i understand your concern , that you dont want more hatered , you want to live with peace . But christians , as now , they are doing the same thing in nagaland .and now they are demanding a seperate north east just because they are christians .

[@ashwaninirvan4041]

Just do some Google search and see for yourself. Pope has been routinely apologizing for atrocities committed by church on indigenous people across globe. But they have never apologized to people of India

[@personaldove]

Well Hindus haven't apologized to the Dalits either.

[@Hari_prasad1996]

AugustanFinn Define dalits by the context of any authentic hindu scriptures.If that can be done, an apology is on the way.

[@roshin2008]

Please explain Dalits as per Hindu texts .

[@SaurabhSingh-yq3mc]

@@Hari_prasad1996 Ye sale chutiya hain. History nahi pata par dalit dalit karte rahte hain

[@deepakbaidya4244]

@@personaldove I'm Hindu Shudra. We were traditional Baida(doctor) and Birwa(Archer or teacher). We can be Poojary(priest) and people accepted us as priest though we were NON-VEGETARIAN. No one discriminated us as low caste. Mangalore Gokarnanatheshwara Temple one of the example. This is my perspective on the caste system

[@imamhumble3204]

My ancestors faced big trouble during the inquisition they lived in and around Pernem and had to flee. Those who reached Kolhapur and settled there remain Hindus. Some of them reached and settled in Bijapur became Muslims.

[@sameerjalnapurkar]

This is a touching comment. Some of your ancestors, who fled Portuguese atrocities, could retain their identity. Those ancestors who settled in the Adil Shahi capital became Muslims. Those ancestors who stayed back must have been forced into Christianity. Now you find yourself a Muslim. This is the tragic story of India. Hope we can all go back to our Dharmic roots, some day.

[@mauktikkul6845]

Imam Humble 😢😢😢 Very sad to hear , Christian churches should apologize

[@silverbullet3939]

I'm so sorry to hear about your ancestors; how does it make you feel now?

[@naanuunkownu]

Every hindu shld frget caste otherwise we will be exploaited...

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

mani champ Brother caste was imposed by British in India after revolt of 1857 by a man called Lord Riseley . He was sent from England to impose caste on India . He created a heiarchy of castes in India . Caste comes from Portugese word costos . There is no such thing as upper caste lower caste scheduled caste etc , all this was created by the British .

[@MihirS84]

Siddharth Siddharth what a load of rubbish. Caste and caste based discrimination has been present in India since thousands of years. There plenty of instances of it even in the Mahabharata! We need to recognize our flaws and correct them instead of blaming everything on the Brits.

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

Mihir Shetty You are talking of discrimination . Why does every one confuse , caste jati Varna and discrimination . Do people understand the difference ? Caste in india was goven by british in 1872 when lord riseley did caste based census and created a heiarchy of castes in india . Social proble,s present in india today are a result of that . You need to read the book Academic Hindu Phobia . In our country the deciding factor has been the society not the authority figure .

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

Mihir Shetty Read Breaking India

[@siddharthsiddharth7106]

You are right we will throw caste out of India .

[@frankly.speaking]

As a Mangalorean, believer in Christ, it was truly shocking, chilling, unbearable and sickening to hear this undeniable truth of destruction, torture, humiliation and atrocities our ancestors faced for centuries all of it sadly in the name of Christ. No amount of apologies and compensation by the Pope of Rome, King or the countrymen of Portugal can ever help forget, forgive or wipe the slate clean.

[@AAA-ul8rq]

I think the bigger question is who helped them ?

[@Sameer-wy7cy]

Read ur bible,old testament ,new testament.thy did wt ur scriptures say

[@frankly.speaking]

That Biblical narrative that your referring to was for a particular people, time and place and got nothing to do with portugal or the brits or other invaders occupiers or the land of india. No Christian justifies their conquest with the Biblical history, Secondly that Biblical history is of the Jewish people of Israel not Christians.

[@frankly.speaking]

@@Sameer-wy7cy in the new Testament, lakhs of Christians were hunted, imprisoned, persecuted, severely tortured burnt alive fed to lions, heads chopped off etc by Romans and the enemies of Christianity, then came the muslims did the same burnt and destroyed churches, killed Christians, converted some and drove out the rest of them out of their lands

[@Sameer-wy7cy]

@@frankly.speaking tht biblical narrative was literally followed untill 70 years back.church became smart nd left violence bec it would show the real face of xtianity .ur book nd its teachings are the reason brits nd other european nations went on to looting spree to heathen nations committing horrible crimes across the world.thy looted india nd turned this golden nation to beggar state.over 100 mill indians died in brits rule just bec of starvation.ur god burns people in hell just for not worshipping him nd tht same hate is in his followers for heathens.xtianity have completly wiped out native religions nd gods of 100 nations including tht of europe using brut force,war,torture etc,.neither ur god s peacefull nor ur religion is. Nd thts the reality

[@QuestionTag-k8o]

We dont seek any vengeance against those atrocities but we hindus must be aware of these things.

[@aniketbhagwat3830]

Vengeance will be served by the karma!

[@samnariman5554]

I had this burning desire to expose the atrocities of Missionaries in Goa , but you did it, I am really grateful

[@TLOIAcademy]

Reminds me of some lyrics of a song "Undo these chains, my friend I’ll show you the rage I’ve hidden Perish the Sacrament Swallow, but nothing’s forgiven You and I can’t decide Which of us was taken for granted Make amends Some of us are destined to be outlived"

[@notimportant1816]

Didn't think I'd see Slipknot on here

[@prabodhmalhotra375]

Proud to be a Hindu. Jai Shri Ram and Bharat Mata ki Jai Vande Matram and Gau Mata ki Jai

[@AAA-ul8rq]

What is your caste ?

[@RajendraNaik-i2b]

What is ur caste?😮

[@rudreshnaik1342]

I am from Goa and Shefali ji is 100% correct and all information here is true. Keep it up.

[@tysondacosta7802]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHi7gpKlZZqVl7M Watch this please to understand Inquisition a little better

[@rajmandrekar9166]

Not at all ..she is hiding facts to protect his GSB bamon community. most of the catholic in Goa are converted Muslims from adil shah regime and elite GSB bamon who helped Portuguese to invade goa and grabbed majority of land in Goa by becoming bhatkars. They also gained top education and position in Portuguese regime. And helped Portuguese to convert few lowercast people of Goa . This GSB bamon can go to any extent to have superiority over bhahujans . This also grabbed majority of temples using Portuguese Mahajan act . They also insisted to keep most of the Portuguese law in Goa after liberation too. So that it can helped them to retain their power

[@andreamessiasgomes7118]

They are taking out the comments ​@@rajmandrekar9166

[@du_boy]

Hindu India will rise again. The glorious Hindu Rashtra shall be our abode.

[@stanleyvonne]

Until then, stay under the rock that's your hiding place!

[@shekharreddy9716]

@@stanleyvonne : The rock has been broken (in 2014) now there is no question of hiding...

[@kamathmanoj]

@@stanleyvonne - Looks like you are the one hiding isnt it? Ha Ha Ha HA Ha!

[@kamathmanoj]

@@powervr - Why? Why would any Hindu people harm anyone? Stop trying to divert the topic away from the historical lesson that needs to be learnt. An Indian has an Indian identity that will not be washed away by religion, color or language - s/he will stay Indian until they depart this life. Anyone thinking otherwise can read Ivar's comments - that is how the world treats Indians of all hues. Stay united else be ready to be ruled by forigners for another 1000 years.

[@stanleyvonne]

Yikes! What a sad lot you are!

[@kaaravindakshan2255]

Conversion of Hindus are still going on mass level by the Christian Missionaries & Islamic Groups. The current condition of Kerala is alarming.

[@arvindvaz6816]

I won't believe in histories written by Goans out of fear that glorify the Portuguese but believe in histories written by Goans who left Goa and settled in distance land in North Konkan and south Konkan as Mangalore.

[@tysondacosta7802]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHi7gpKlZZqVl7M Watch this please to understand Inquisition a little better

[@khiladi4521]

Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it. - George Santayana

[@tysondacosta7802]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHi7gpKlZZqVl7M Watch this please to understand Inquisition a little better

[@singhs2817]

This should be shown to every christian in the world.. specially to Indian Christians and the so called European christian (who thinks they were not as bad as Muslims)

[@jimch]

Majority of Indian Christians have got nothing to do with Portuguese Inquisition. Remember the Portuguese/Spanish had done same, similar or worser even to their own people, to fellow Europeans.

[@kudalaMangalooru]

jimc ~ That's besides the point. islam & christianity are diametrically opposite to Sanatana Dharma with their dogmas and exclusivity. Their condescending & threatening activities are eating up Bharat like cancer, which is going on unabated even today. Yes, it doesn't have much to do with Portagees or Spanish, but that role has been taken over by christian NGOs, missionaries, jesuits, islamic organizations, madrassas funded by the petro-dollar rich middle-east, the powerful church institutions in the U.S and Europe.

[@vickrammangon8730]

themuslimissue.wordpress.com/2015/08/31/islamic-invasion-of-india-the-greatest-genocide-in-history/

[@vickrammangon8730]

Why the world owes India - JD Official kzbin.info/www/bejne/nIjNkHdvgdWAl7s

[@vickrammangon8730]

haribhakt.com/modern-inventions-stolen-from-vedas/#Why_Did_All_The_Discoveries_Happened_in_19th_Century

[@replymr9792]

I wept throughout listening to this talk..

[@amitkumarmeraman5191]

Definitely utterly helpless hindus...

[@DevBabu]

Jai Sri Ram My heart aches listening to this, I can't imagine even

[@amygdalatales8880]

I am so proud of my ancestors, no matter what they didn't convert and faced all atrocities.

[@sidh2128]

Hi Shefali tai, even I'm Saraswat Brahmin.. Although my village is in Karnataka, our Kuldaivat is in Goa.. Never understood why.. Thanks for sharing 🙏

[@nitikshasharma9263]

And we have schools & colleges in Francis Xavier's name. Such a shame.

[@dustingriffith7399]

Down with Francis Xavier's name everywhere, he is EVIL!

[@antoniosaldanha3294]

Don't apply for St Xavier colleges ..Ha ha ha ..Don't be fooled ..History is history ..Thinks moved on...In Goa we all Hindus muslim and christian lived peaceful and is still living peacefully ...Xavier college schools rather christian ran education institution have contributed much to India development ...Tell me when british ruled India there was some sort of exploitation ..So it's natural....Any religion ....God ...Etc etc is more harmful and dangerous to humanity ....Don't be too religious rather see video of Osho ..

[@neanderthal7969]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rquQq5hnpZh1m8U

[@Nikesh-x3o]

@@antoniosaldanha3294 why there is discrimination against non goans people..?

[@tysondacosta7802]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHi7gpKlZZqVl7M Watch this please to understand Inquisition a little better

[@jyotivyas9286]

I am a Dadheech Brahman. I am proud of Myself and My Each Ancestor. 🙏🙏🙏🕉️🕉️🕉️🔥🔥🔥🧘🏻‍♀️🧘🏻‍♀️🧘🏻‍♀️🤺🤺🤺🌳🔥🌳🔥🌳✌️✌️✌️😍😍😍😘😘😘from Bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🔥🕉️🌹💕

[@santoshkumarrai6705]

Madam, thank you for the lecture. It is right time to make " The Goa Files"

[@amitpawar6247]

all these abrahamic religions are all the same....Hinduisim the greatest

[@saurabhkatarey6818]

Mam I'm from Goa I watched this video full and I really liked it. I'll be downloading this video because it contains lot's of interesting historical knowledge about our motherland. Thank you very much mam.

[@SumanasKitchen]

I can see the pain writ large on her face when narrating those incidents

[@neanderthal7969]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rquQq5hnpZh1m8U

[@harmindersinghyadav9171]

Excellent talk

[@Tobveryhonest]

Thanx sir. But now I see many YADAVS are accepting Christianity

[@TheDeltathreat]

Thank you for the talk.. incredible..!! why hasn't all this even been taught in our schools?? I didn't knew any of this. I come from Bihar and my mother tongue is Maithili, a dying language. When I tell my fellow mithilianchalis that Maithili isn't written like Hindi (Devanagari) even they get surprised, such has been the destruction and opression of our society over the centuries. All this has been continued by Lalu and his cateist followers even after independence.

[@hemendrabhardwaj]

TheDeltathreat whitewash of crimes of minorities

[@maskyb3509]

as if BJP followers are not castists. and are they actually doing anything?

[@procash1968]

Sometimes in the late 60s or early 70s a movie was made depicting the Goan inquisition. It was a Black & White movie made in somewhat art movie style and I think it was in Tulu or Konkani Language. I also vaguely remember that the movie had won a national award or something like that. We need to revive such movies and make more such movies. Not just movies that depict the atrocities of the Christians, but also movies where they depict the absurdities in Xtianity as a religion. We need to show the truth and break the false "Perception" that Xitanity is the best religion and prove that it is worse than bull crap

[@sankyppp]

My maternal ancestors were Kadams (now Borade) of Kadamba.They had to migrate all the way to Pune. The village has a small section of Borades who are originally from Goa.

[@mohanb655]

Ok, from Kadamba Mayura Verma.

[@rahulm2827]

jai sanaatan dharam. being hindu in the 21st century is a matter of great pride!!! we have survived so many attempts of other people to kill us. 1000 years of invasions. different invaders with different degrees of brutality, different tactics of persecution and proselytization. its really ONLY the power of our ancient rishis and their vaani which is resonating as a protective layer on us. i believe that we hindus need to practise our faith and create this protective layer for our children. 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@tstanmoysamanta]

wow just superb speech.

[@theseeker3141]

Kudos Shefali ji for bringing out the facts from the past this will take off the covers that the perpetrators so dilligently tried to put over, to cover their misdeeds and tried to project themselves as our saviours. In the end truth prevails most Goans have the same understanding of the past ,which you have highlighted.

[@lifearoundwesternghats]

I m goan and agreee with her .... Wat she said was told to me by my grand mothrr....Who lived in Portuguese tim

[@leeoconnor123]

absolutely, we need to talk about this, my grandparents migrated to africa, then my mother came to the uk, and eventually had to bring my grandparents here too, all of my family are in lot's of different countries around the world, except goa. my family do not talk about the past, they never handed me a book about the inquisition, they are very strong in their catholic roots and i am the one asking these questions, buying the books and only at my age 45 am learning how ruthless the portuguese were to us and the jews. after all that was done to jesus, this is what the church did to convert? plus they hid their paedophile priests to face canon law, simply moving them from one country to another covering more crimes. there was a group in 2015 fighting for a public apology from the church for this inquisition, did this ever happen? i am so outraged, when i married, i wanted to keep my goan name because of my identity and goan culture as i married an irish and austrian person, but i cannot put my name to a religion that is responsible for mass torture or killing any more. i am already a vegan, actually, you can place blame on our current pope for that change, he was asked to go vegan for lent as he speaks up so much about climate change, a little girl asked him to do this and his response annoyed me so much, i thought ok let me go vegan if this man cannot do this for our creatures and climate change, it's now 2 years and i am still vegan, further to this a few things have led me to wanting to convert instead to jainism, i cannot pray to saints like francis xavier, having seen his letter to john iii, this is no small thing for me, my family are catholic fanatics who led me to believe the portuguese coming to goa was a good thing, for our education, our language etc..but how so? if all my family fled goa! i want to know who were we, what name did we have prior to taking a portuguese name, i will never find that out, we must encourage the truth about the portuguese catholics, doesn't matter it was long ago, just have to look at how many times the poor jewish people have been treated like this in almost every country they have tried to make a peaceful life in, it will continue unless we right the wrongs in these religious fanatics.

[@lxportugal9343]

" *my family are catholic fanatics who led me to believe the portuguese coming to goa was a good thing, for our education, our language etc..but how so?* " Do you think your parents are not smart? They were living in Goa when the Portuguese were their not you.... why they left Goa? *WHY a good percentage of Goans including non Christians left Goa after the annexation of Goa by India?* Where did a lot of these Goans go? I tell you, to Portuguese territories (Moçambique and Portugal itself) If Portugal was so bad to Goans why they went to Portuguese territories? Inquisition was a bad thing off course, in Goa on paper it was abolish in 1774 The reality was that after the Lisbon tsunami 1755 the Inquisition was decapitated by the Portugal prime-minister which made it powerless in Portugal and other territories for ever. What happened after king D. Jose death, was that in Goa it was created another type of "inquisition" in 1778, which had no power other then passing fines, and that made people return to Goa, because if I 'm not mistaken 40% of Goan population by the time India annexed Goa was non-christian. In Portugal the inquisition was even worse... but remember people were burning witches in other countries in Europe and they didn't have inquisition there. And let me ask you something: weren't Indians burning widows when the Portuguese arrived in India?

[@vivacristorey4728]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rquQq5hnpZh1m8U

[@neanderthal7969]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rquQq5hnpZh1m8U

[@wcronin7307]

Your ancestors were either Hindu, Muslim or Jews. The portuguese, like the catholic church may never acknowledge or apologize for past deeds.

[@rajmandrekar9166]

​@@wcronin7307 why will they? most of the catholic in Goa are converted Muslims from adil shah regime and elite GSB bamon who helped Portuguese to invade goa and grabbed majority of land in Goa by becoming bhatkars. They also gained top education and position in Portuguese regime. And helped Portuguese to convert few lowercast people of Goa . This GSB bamon can go to any extent to have superiority over bhahujans . This also grabbed majority of temples using Portuguese Mahajan act . They also insisted to keep most of the Portuguese law in Goa after liberation too. So that it can helped them to retain their power

[@RamdasIyer]

Shefaliji, I watched your KZbin video on Goa Inquisitions, while having lunch today. I was impressed how you could speak about it for 43 minutes without once breaking down. I wept unabashedly and left my lunch midway. Such a shockingly sad incident.

[@rajmandrekar9166]

Those are pure lies to hide their mistakes and and this lady as GSB Brahmin can go any extent to do that. most of the catholic in Goa are converted Muslims from adil shah regime and elite GSB Brahmin who helped Portuguese to invade goa and grabbed majority of land in Goa by becoming bhatkars.and keeping lower caste people as mundakars. They also gained top education and position in Portuguese regime. And helped Portuguese to convert few lowercast people of Goa . This GSB Brahmin can go to any extent to have superiority over bhahujans . This also grabbed majority of temples using Portuguese Mahajan act . They also insisted to keep most of the Portuguese law in Goa after liberation too. So that it can helped them to retain their power

[@showmustgoon5311]

Been reading a lot about Portuguese in India. This is very interesting to hear from your family’s perspective. Thank you.

[@ivarhakuse8572]

For some reason goans seem to be under the impression that Portuguese never lifted a finger but the conversation was purely peaceful.

[@riteshr9477]

Ivar Hakuse Same with all convertees....no one accepted that they beaten to pulp first before converting.

[@toboldstan6888]

This is not history that is taught in schools.

[@toboldstan6888]

Sergio Pinto : If your teachers haven't failed you so badly would have actually understood what I was saying. I will repeat it for you here ELI5 style. Rape is a crime that happens all around the world. If you take population into account India is a safer country than many of the the Western countries. You are a special kind of looser, who thinks of himself as white yet Indian. A Perfect Slave.

[@jithendranambiar7699]

Portuguese conversion was through coercion

[@KINGMJ1990]

@@sergiopinto4831 Sati wasn't practised in Goa in the 1500s. The practise of Sati was limited to certain pockets in North India. Don't speak bullshit if you don't know the facts. The Devadasi system that you call as Temple prostitution was a system where the Devadasis had high social regard, and their children were free to marry Brahmins and many did including India's greatest Carnatic singer M.S Subbulakshmi whose father was a Brahmin, and she married a Brahmin. Converts like you don't know real history of Hindu customs and what they resulted in. Daambar jaisa rang hai aur baatein badi badi. Sergio Pinto bc...lisbon me paida hua kya tu?

[@ivarhakuse8572]

Ajit Vadakayil has a great blog on the Goan inquisition. I also urge you [everyone who reads this] to be familiar with his blog on a Mrs Teresa the patron saint of poverty in Calcutta. Also Christopher Hitchens on you tube. We need to get out of this mindset that only Christians practice charity.

[@shivajighadigaonkar52]

Of Christian practice charity but with interior motive even to-date to convert you.

[@ivarhakuse8572]

@@shivajighadigaonkar52 Absolutely, with ulterior motive.

[@akshatadarsh8204]

Now we r proud of being product of "St. Xaviers School/College" 😂

[@shivajighadigaonkar52]

What an irony ?

[@neanderthal7969]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rquQq5hnpZh1m8U

[@Just_so_simple]

Sad but truth bro

[@ravip9891]

Truths are always bitter..St xavir did mascre angst hindus and also newly converted chrstns also..Plz read about Spanish Inquisition also.

[@joedias7946]

There were about 1000 universities in India before the Europeans arrived here. The Europeans made every effort to destroy this centres of learning. Students from Arabia ,China Siam, Indonesia had to stay on waiting list to Gain entrance to these universities. Many disciplines Were taught at the universities in India.

[@rajt8343]

Dear Shefali- Thank you and glad to listen in . In so many years on Facebook since 2009/10, first time hearing your Voice- so far only in writings and FB post .Good wishes and Success ahead, kind Regards from TR Chennai

[@someshheble1204]

Thank you for this very informative talk! I always had a vague idea about this before but now I know so much more . My ancestors resettled in Karnataka on account of this. When I was very young I too went to the Basilica of Bom Jesus and bowed my head in reverence and awe of the relics, not knowing the true character of the 'saint'. This is a shameful and painful part of our history that gets largely ignored or watered down by quoting the passage of time as an excuse.

[@devdattamanjrekar3655]

Shefali ji 🙏🚩 You made us aware of this untold horrific History of “The Goa Inquisition” as your ancestors being a part of it and…..by using Excellent source of authentic Information. People out there must know about this missing History Sooner or later Truth always surfaces” 🙏🙏🚩🚩

[@kumar7359]

The famous Kapaleeswara temple in Mylapore in Chennai originally stood at Santhome. The Portugese destroyed it and built a Cathedral. The current temple was later built at Mylapore.

[@Parasiyerji]

Shefali you brought to light so much of hidden history. Thks Srijan Foundation. Say how I can be supporting you .

[@12440jayjay]

Part of the problem why Hindus were and are suffering is because they have not learned t o protect them selves and their way of life. I strongly feel that even today every one in India should have compulsory military service and should be ready to defend whenever a need arise. Remember the world has not changed much.

[@jayasreetummala5123]

Now I'm ashamed for studying in a missionary school!!!

[@unknown-tl3cu]

They stole 45$ trillion from Hindu

[@bindulalit7033]

Shocking past but unfortunately similar prosecution of Hindu's is still happening and goes unchecked or unprotested because we don't know our correct history. Thanks Shefali Ji.

[@rishi.girdhar]

This is such an eye opener. Thank you Shefali Ji. Portuguese were ruthless. They have created the conditions for conversions. All Christians of Goa must revert back to their roots.

[@viveknsharma]

"Christian Brahmins"... This is strange...

[@eldoncoutinho4133]

VIVEK N SHARMA Sharma there are also brahmin dalit sikhs

[@maskyb3509]

Genetically most brahmins have a shit load of European DNA.

[@hrishikeshananth8996]

@@maskyb3509 Stop spread fake news you commie bastard

[@sodiiumCHLORIDE]

@@hrishikeshananth8996 Liberal Hindus ,jihadis ,missionary will cook up abt brahminism, Aryan theory to divide the Hindus and politicise... Now no true Hindus found themself divided ..only librandus keep injecting such venoms among people's..

[@GajananJog9]

Thanks a lot. You have Done a dutiful task to all

[@madankumarsivaraman2918]

It was painful for Hindu like me to hear this well researched account .I haven't heard this before but I believe it very close to the truth.She also mentions that many slaves of Hindus and Muslims adopted Christianity to liberate themselves from slavery.I feel ashamed to know that Hindus also had slaves .We Hindus are so divided that it should be our endeavour to bring them together and that is the only way to save our faith.Let us learn from the past and be alert and let these things not repeat again.

[@vishalsinghbaghel]

Arab Invaders brought slave culture in India

[@GauravSingh-uu7qw]

Very valuable addition to understanding of medival India.

[@IceQeen1011]

Why is this never taught??? Excellent talk Ms.Shefali. I wish to do what you do in the future and bring awareness to the hindu masses

[@VidyadharOkeDr]

I salute your candidness and bravery ! JAY HIND !!

[@aksh2510]

My heart breaks after hearing real meaning and historical background behind the song 'he he he saiba poltodi vaita' !!! Shout out to Konkani culture, traditions and people !!!

[@PMishra41]

just a little correction 2:50, its portuguese not Britishers.

[@billnazareth3449]

Shefali thank you very much for this video. Have you written a book on this topic. I would be interested in having a copy.

[@tysondacosta7802]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHi7gpKlZZqVl7M Watch this please to understand Inquisition a little better

[@madhusingh6266]

2 Thumbs up to you for telling the story of survival of Hinduism in such nice manner.

[@indirasharma7199]

O god we HV bn hearing the song but never thought is concept behind that, thank you Shefali it's eye opening

[@ashish2184]

thankfully never studied in a christian school or college and will make sure none of kids in my family goes to any St Stephen St Paul or any christian school/ college ever.

[@stanleyvonne]

Pity. Their loss. Not least because they too are likely to write grammatically-pathetic sentences like "none of kids in my family goes to . . ."

[@swarnadeepsen9123]

@@stanleyvonne They cannot fathom about any sort of cultural enrichment coming from Latinate sources.

[@stanleyvonne]

I can't figure out what you are trying to convey, Mr Sen. It's another example of unintelligible gobbledegook.

[@mel1076]

@@abhijay_ Your ancestors were Hindu when they learnt to cook?

[@mel1076]

@@abhijay_ Your ancestors were Hindu when they learnt to cook?

[@pra_jwal4316]

OMG this actually made me feel very sad 😭 This history has to be taught to everyone

[@lifearoundwesternghats]

Mam you are so true ...I heared all this stories from old people whose age is 90 yr now Your are very courageous and fearlesss

[@krantiwithshruti]

Found this video today and shared it with the world !!!! I think I did my bit .. Kudos to Shefali ma'am and Sangam Talks !!!!

[@bhavendrajyoti1655]

In the colonial days, The swarms of jingoistic Portuguese women who thronged the bazaars of occupied Goa, lashing out their acrobatic tongues to showcase their sex-appeal was a most repugnant sight. This was the jealous Portuguese feminine way of getting even with local Konkani women by outraging the latters' modesty. Portuguese women were feeling cheated because Portuguese men had become addicted to greeting konkani women on the streets by forcibly locking lips and tongue with the latter. Onlookers described the obnoxious spectacle of लपलपाती जीभ presented by the overzealous Portuguese feminists as resembling ताड़का and सुरसा. Singuella averred that spiritual purification of Konkani society would remain incomplete without tongue rape of every adult Konkani.

[@kevinjohn2243]

Thank you Maam..for all the insights you have given...appreciate you efforts...

[@Silly132]

👏👏👏you talked out what was deep in my heart. Thank you so much. Thiscwas needed at this hour. As Goans catholics (ricebagconverts) become more communal these days, which is sickening.

[@nishantverma4361]

We are with you you're doing a great job

[@mailsuyal]

Thanks I am so pained to know all this. The plight of hindus , our ancestors sacrifices. You have truly given a tribute to them. Thank you once again.

[@SuryaTheProudSanatani]

Always love to hear shefali madam but it also brings tears and anger with lot of knowledge. Jai Shriram🙏🚩