Goofs in Percy Takes the Plunge

[@Salty_notthediesel]

I have a theory that this episode takes place before bill and ben were purchased because henry would not have said "this shed is for the fat controller's engines".

[@ha.yanited26]

Thank you for carrying on with these goof videos! This is exactly like GWR's videos.

[@nascarfan5493]

Thats because hes the copy

[@AdelandCrew]

@@nascarfan5493 He didn’t copy he’s continuing the goof series because GWR studios quit thomas and friends

[@AmusedAnimatorYT]

​​@@nascarfan5493 Gwr Quit and is doing trash car videos

[@creppruby]

1:54 Actually Bill and Ben are privately owned by the China Clay Company, thus making them technically not the Fat Controller's Engines

[@baxter22071990]

does that mean mavis isn't either, cause she has ffarqhuar quarries on her sides

[@creppruby]

@@baxter22071990 yeah she is also privately owned

[@TheNintendoNerd-wd7bv]

That's only in the Railway Series. The Fat Controller owns them in the show.

[@HamidHamid-je9jz]

6:02 from the real xbox nerd

[@leewooboi]

@@TheNintendoNerd-wd7bv actually, no, they are privately owned until the episode where the quarry collapses, which is when the fat controller buys them.

[@DUBMANS]

Thanks for reviving the series. GWR stopped on the run away.

[@jamesleopard8518]

6:15: Henry's eyes jittered, and the audience cheered him on the show, and got excited that he switch the train remote control power up

[@jamesleopard8518]

4:18 Percy's eyes are wonky and David Mitton was so excited that he played around with the train model remote switch around, and the audience cheered them on

[@Lm-gj1wx]

Your so smart

[@jamesleopard8518]

1:37 Henry's tender bounced, and the art director was so excited for the show that he forgot to connect the toy model train track the right way

[@ThomasFan222-o1x]

6:02 DON'T CALL ME DIRTY PERCY

[@jamesleopard8518]

4:00 The freight cars started pushing Percy, and David Mitton put the train model power on extremely fast

[@Mskart109]

In vhs version for bill and ben when they are puffing away it was fixed

[@jamesleopard8518]

1:27 We could see a piece of sticky tak on the toy model of Percy, and the art director was in a rush to start the show that he accidently put one drop of glue on it

[@mort9437]

6:02 this made me laugh so hard!

[@travisbeeks6036]

The narrator says that Percy ran off to the harbour singing, but he is already at the harbour. When the camera pans down on Thomas, several trucks in the background are derailed. When Henry asks Percy “Did you like the water?” his eyes are wonky. Before Percy plunges into the sea, the shot of him sliding down the quayside is placed before the shot of him sliding past the sign. Because of this, his facial expression also changes from shocked to smiling. In the restored version, Bill and Ben's whistles and chuffing sounds are still heard after they leave. Just as Percy plunges into the sea, two of his trucks become derailed, and one of them bounces. When Percy is lifted out of the water, a workman appears to have some blu-tak on his neck. When Henry enters the shed, his tender bounces. During Percy's trip to the harbour, his brake van changes. Additionally, his left cylinder is hanging off. Ben's nameplate is peeling off when Henry puffs in. In the close-up of Percy being pushed, a reflection of a hand can be seen in the water pushing the train. Additionally, Percy's eyes are wonky. Before Percy goes straight into the water, his brakes are applied despite his driver and fireman having jumped out. Then right about when he falls into the water, his wheels are moving again. Percy looks cross when he chuckles about his driver not knowing his plan. When Percy is hanging from the cranes, he is not dirty, but when he is placed on the flatbed, he is. Also, his face is dirty when he is sitting on Thomas' flatbed, but when he is sitting on Henry's flatbed, his face is not dirty. In all three English dubs, "One Day" is spoken by Percy instead of the narrators.

[@ruthreeves3014]

You missed a goof at 2:04 in the background henry is sitting there

[@christopherpluto3192]

He moved to the shed

[@Guido007official]

2:16 chains in the background are moving for some reason

[@yeheygaming_53]

ALL HAIL THE NEW GWR STUDIOS!!!

[@shadowspike74infobitsnolon3]

2:15 this goof is actually exclusive to the restored version. The original on vhs and dvd before 2012 did not have this issue. The dubbing track was slightly off from the footage they grabbed from the original and retaken film masters. As some scenes use the original master footage that syncs up. While others like here, for example, used new masters. For the footage. But the editors of the restored version cut the scene too early. Which ended up coming out like this. Unluckytug explained this in his restored comparison video.

[@mclarenfan34]

5:44 THE FUNNIEST GOOF I CAN LAUGH XDDDDDDDDDD😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@owendinostudios1200]

Agreed!

[@ThomasFan222-o1x]

6:02

[@mclarenfan34]

@@ThomasFan222-o1xDoNt cAlL Me dIrTy pErCy!!!

[@mclarenfan34]

1:22 he not clever

[@MasonSoloMcFly]

3:31 - MLG Percy 6:02 - DoN't CaLl Me DIRTY PERCY!!

[@marioelimunoz5678]

Why is everyone making the same comment

[@jamesleopard8518]

2:39 Percy's eyes are wonky, and David Mitton fiddled around with the train model remote control switch around it

[@jamesleopard8518]

3:37 The art director had already added down the toy model train track ramp to the ocean on the Thomas and Friends layout table for the Thomas and Friends show

[@johnsplayworld2402]

Maybe the reason why henry shouts at bill and ben because henry never met them before because thats his first time meeting them

[@jamesleopard8518]

5:55 There are sticky-tak on the toy model Workmen, and the art director had too much in his hands that he accidently dropped them into the glue before the show started

[@jamesleopard8518]

3:22 The light of a studio 🎙️ reflector is close to the toy model of Thomas The Tank Engine, and Terry Permane got too close to it

[@jamesleopard8518]

3:55 David Mitton got so excited that he put the train model power on very fast

[@S1LLY_F1RE_ALARM_L0V3R]

6:02 funny part

[@jamesleopard8518]

3:48 David Mitton put the train power on very fast for Percy and the freight cars

[@jamesleopard8518]

3:13 Percy's cylinder is on the lose, and the art director was overexcited for the show that he accidently dropped the toy model of Percy The Small Engine

[@phillipmeyer4059]

I love how the Fat Controller just happens to be watching him in the boat right after the crash

[@jamesleopard8518]

2:58 The toy model freight cars are derailed, and Robert Gauld the art director didn't put them on the rails the right way

[@jamesleopard8518]

4:50 If Percy passed the Danger ⚡ sign ☢️🛑 board 🛹 again previously, David Mitton moved it for Robert Gauld the art director which is called plagiarism

[@jamesleopard8518]

3:28 Thomas' smile was not painted white, and the art director got so nervous for the show show that he forgot to paint Thomas' smile white 🤍🐻‍❄️

[@YimYum911]

Awesome intro

[@gregkiteos1936]

Also, why is steam coming out of Percy's rear end at 5:06? His cylinders are at the front! That should be a goof.

[@masongullett74]

I think that may have been the sea water putting out percy's fire

[@gregkiteos1936]

@@masongullett74 Percy doesn't go that far into the water.

[@jamesleopard8518]

5:44 Diesel The Black New Naughty Diesel Engine is at the background, and he is not introduced yet. Robert Gauld the art director made another silly mistake by adding him on.

[@AndreiPopescu]

I don't think that is the case here. Diesel is introduced in the next episode. He was probably delivered that night but the Fat Controller only introduced him to the other engines the next morning.

[@ReeceWilliams-vu8sn]

5:43 It is possible Diesel's cameo appearance is him arriving on Sodor for a trail foreshadowing the next episode ''Pop Goes The Diesel''.

[@starhunter1269]

there a goof in 5:38 Percy cab wall is opened

[@jamesleopard8518]

5:03 The freight cars derailed themselves before the crash while Percy slipped to the ocean 🌊, and David Mitton got the train model power on extremely fast before

[@amandawalsh3641]

Bill and Ben aren’t supposed to debut in this episode, there supposed to debut in The Diseasel

[@P42_foamer]

3:31 MLG Percy 6:02 DON'T CALL ME DIRTY PERCY!!!

[@marioelimunoz5678]

You made the comment twice

[@darkknight5541]

1:24 Actually, Percy's Promise was originally going to be a Season 2 episode, but got pushed back for one reason or another. I'm assuming they didn't push this one back because they needed to fill 26 episodes.

[@jamesleopard8518]

4:20 The crew member's hand 🧤 is reflecting in the water on the Thomas and Friends layout train table, and Terry Permane got the camera 📷📸 close to it.

[@bacongaming-t1w]

wtf are you talking about? and why have you commented on this numerous times?

[@wolfzillaproductions4563]

5:48 *WAAOOO-* 6:02 *DON’T CALL ME DIRTY PERCY!!!*

[@carriematthews7344]

6:02 DoNt CaLl Me DiRtY pErCy

[@Gordonjamesheneryproductions]

Beelp

[@jakemartin2274]

Calm down Percy!

[@S1LLY_F1RE_ALARM_L0V3R]

Percy: ok, sorry

[@justacell2208]

You missed a goof. At around 5:28, you can see the front left corner of percys' cab is cracked.

[@howtodostuff3225]

4:10 percy and the trucks passed the buffers 2x

[@davidfarmer2193]

If Donald and Douglas were going to talk to Percy in the beginning what if Bill and Ben rescued Thomas from the Stationmaster's house in "Thomas comes to Breakfast"?

[@gregkiteos1936]

They wouldn't have been strong enough to do that.

[@davidfarmer2193]

@@gregkiteos1936 Well Thomas was strong enough to rescue Duck from the Barbers in "A Close Shave".

[@gregkiteos1936]

@@davidfarmer2193 Thomas is bigger than Bill and Ben and he has six driving wheels.

[@PapaMater97]

When Percy was in the sea, you missed a goof where his cab was separated

[@davidfarmer2193]

You've missed a goof, 3:50 the front truck has a face and at 3:53 the truck's face has gone.

[@donaldthescottishtwin4748]

I saw that too

[@Gordonjamesheneryproductions]

Oh just probably just stock footage

[@TheEnterpriseStudios]

I think I know why diesel is right there because a close shave and when diesel arrived Percy Takes the plunge was a time where diesel was leaving Sodor forever until he came back

[@tomaszsobczak1253]

Dirrty percy

[@ThomasFan222-o1x]

DoN't CaLl Me DIRTY PERCY!!

[@engine26]

at the part that percy met thomas, i can see a track at the top right was derailed.

[@sarahhockey02]

I never noticed they used the large scale topham hat in the scene were he is on the boat

[@jamesleopard8518]

4:15 David Mitton put the train model power on very faster that the freight cars can bump into each other and Percy

[@devontaschannel803]

What about grandpuf

[@BadgerWhisper]

Percy is angry when he chuckles of the driver not knowing his plan when he should be wearing his chuckling face. Unless if it's stock footage from another episode, then I don't know.

[@Sir2Edward]

Nice new editing skills!!

[@donaldthescottishtwin4748]

You again…

[@Sir2Edward]

@@donaldthescottishtwin4748 ?

[@thebluejintythomasthetanke587]

What ¿

[@owendinostudios1200]

Hello

[@sirejonesk591]

Please keep the intro music I love it

[@Admm744]

Why does Percy have a brakevan while pulling annie and clarabel GOOF

[@jamesleopard8518]

4:53 Percy slipped to the ocean 🌊, since David Mitton put on the train model power on very fast and more fast before

[@easternncrailfan7594]

This is one of the first thomas episodes I watched, its also the first dvd I had

[@bigmacsama]

That was very good

[@DaveyMichael]

0:47 percy is wonky

[@USER-LlewisTLDB]

The same thing that happened with diesel in this episode happened to Salty in the adventure begins salty made a cameo in the adventure begins when he wasn't supposed to appear yet

[@jamesleopard8518]

4:30 Robert Gauld the art director made a silly mistake for putting Percy's happy face mask while sliding on the slippery ramp to the water 💧💦 , and he should of put a scared face mask on Percy to do that.

[@thatoneguythatlikesship]

3:16 fun fact,this board is used in the pilot version of down the mine

[@amtrak2026]

When there is 4 goofs Henrys eyes are wonky

[@diegotheyoutuber3523]

2:26 there's a goof Percy has a gap in his eyes 3:58 and her cylinder is broken

[@Noogelman]

***Edward whistles***

[@mclarenfan34]

He so angry

[@the_williamano1897]

4:59 I thought it was the docks

[@charlescirino8918]

What does the word disobedient mean?

[@Blaketheyoungpug]

5:28 how does percy speak so clearly with his mouth in the water

[@WillowLikesTrainz2024]

why do you update like every hour?

[@P42_foamer]

6:02 D O N ' T C A L L M E D I R T Y P E R C Y ! ! !

[@mastermaker352]

Percy could have been referring to a similar situation entirely

[@mrchomikguy]

Can you do all the goofs in edward,henry,gordon next ?

[@ThomasandfriendsRULES]

Greetings to Slovakia. I heard Ringo Starr clicking his tongue at 4:15

[@shinycharizard6981]

Since ya mention it, I didn't know that, and when I listen to it I did hear his tongue clicking and it was like 0.3 sec left before the next scene change that was probably the hardest goof you've found nice one

[@ppheard1254]

3:18 that's the same sign from down the mine 3:23 missing toothisis 1:43 back of eye 5:59 He made himself a Dirty Percy Percy: 😠😡🤬DOn'T CaLL ME DIrTY PErCY!!!

[@Isaiah_57]

Just 21 goofs that's alot! and also idk why do they keep putting sticky tacks

[@P42_foamer]

3:31 MLG Percy 6:02 DON'T CALL ME DIRTY PERCY

[@marioelimunoz5678]

You made the comment twice

[@PaintballGargoyle]

You forget one! bill and Ben have black tape above the 1 & 2 on their Smoke box..

[@Toysonicandfriends2]

I think Percy doesn’t like his nickname’s Dirty Percy And green Caterpillar with red stripes

[@maiyo8518]

In 2:35 Percy’s eye brows are completely different so that is a goof

[@Oscar-xj1nd]

In season 2 they wernt owned by sth they were in season 3 tho

[@howtodostuff3225]

there is this wire that goes over the trucks in the previos seane their was on wire

[@Jef2017Offical]

Lemme say this not saying that the goof is wrong but I think Percy had his brakes on when he stopped next to the board

[@sonicwith3dglasses70]

3:46 this scene is from percy and Harold

[@MrDiaz-nz1cb]

Percy's promise was going to be in the 2nd series but it was pushed to the 3rd series for no reason.

[@jamestulloch-knight7252]

That not actually a goof, because in the books Percy's Promise came for before Percy Takes The Plunge.

[@johnsplayworld2402]

Deja vu percy just told bill and ben a prediction that percy i going to go to the rain with annie amd clarabel

[@_juqeo]

4:58 Percy had his breaks applied but his wheels were still moving

[@worldbiggestfan1]

Percy and henry have little gaps on their eyes

[@mastermaker352]

My guess is that Bill and Ben were owned by the Mainland at the time

[@Killugon12]

DON'T CALL ME DIRTY PERCY 😆

[@OldEngine_25]

maan look at that red cargo ship in the background. It looks modernized

[@danielapirisi6243]

You miss a goof:are talk of bill and Ben some episodes later

[@shinycharizard6981]

Thank you so much for carrying the goofs videos means a lot to me and also ya miss a few goofs I spotted At 1:44 at the left side of Henry ya can see the rope or chain whatever is not moving but in the next scene at 1:47 the left side of Henry the rope or chain is moving for some weird reason 2:27 Percy’s eye to the right has a gap 3:17 Same post from Down The Mines EP 3:21 Thomas Lamp is broken 4:24 Percy’s Wheels isn’t moving And the last goof, at 6:28 look at the pole next to Henry, Henry is slightly above the pole but in the next scene at 6:31 Henry is somehow moved back slightly and not above the pole anymore am I the only one who notice that hard goof?!

[@jamesleopard8518]

6:01 Robert Gauld the art director made the toy model of a dirty Percy after he fell down into the ocean 🌊 on the Thomas and Friends layout table, while the young children sneeze and cough and throw something in it

[@P42_foamer]

D O N ' T C A L L M E D I R T Y P E R C Y ! ! !

[@michaelstokes199]

The reason why in the railway series was one and then was too

[@tristanlanier316]

You basically forgot about The Buffers at The end of The key that leads to the ocean. This is why The crew should have done the same situation with The episode "Off The Rails".

[@pwsthetankengine3259]

In the second last scene, the back of Henry's eye can be seen.

[@livinginjamiesworld7158]

Diesel was chuffing because idk