वर्णव्यवस्था और जाति अलग हैं - यह भ्रम है

[@Dr_Sayan]

जो सदैव शास्त्र सम्मत सत्य बोलते हैं, सूर्य के समान तेज रखते हैं, हिमालय के समान अटल हैं तथा सागर के समान ज्ञान की गहराई रखते हैं, ऐसे महान जगतगुरु शंकराचार्य भगवान को मैं बार-बार प्रणाम करता हूँ।

[@Heyy.D33pak]

@@Dr_Sayan gyaan bhi jatiwadd boliye maharaj or iska khamiyaza hindu samaaj bhugat raha hain

[@pandit-jee-bihar]

How many people noticed that the founder of Upword is asking the question ?

[@sachindubey7966]

जी Ashish Dhar ji hai।

[@shashi2331]

Exactly

[@appsssssss]

He is telling real Hinduism

[@beerusop820]

Chalo chalo jhaadu laga

[@fdshikshant6828]

Aryan come from uresia and destroy our culture😢😢😢 I hate brahmin😢😊

[@sarozkumar3939]

Yes

[@rajeshjaganathan224]

He is Half-Cooked. Non-Sense

[@Hitler-v1h]

​@@beerusop820 Kyu tere father reh geye karna ko ja khud laga le nikame

[@gyanyagya123]

शंकराचार्य जी आप को कोटि कोटि प्रणाम, आपने बहुत अच्छे से समझाया के जाति प्रथा ही सब चीजों का हाल है सब मुसीबतों का हल है, कई सालों से मेरे मन में यह प्रश्न घूम रहा था, इसका उत्तर आज मुझे समझ में आया.

[@fdshikshant6828]

Join science journey and learn ❤😂😂all spretual❤

[@rudraadityamandal6126]

​@@fdshikshant6828No need 👎

[@Heyy.D33pak]

@@rudraadityamandal6126 kyonki Satya sunne ki ability honi chahiye aakh mundh kr kisi ki baaton me aa jana bhi ek mental gulami hain aage aapka niji jivan hai mujhe usse ko Lena Dena nhi lekin Satya se jitna jaldi avgata hi jao utna achaa 🙏

[@advaitdarshan18]

ॠग्वेदीय पूर्वाम्नाय गौवर्धन मठ पुरी पीठाधीश्वर श्री मज्जगद्गुरू शंकराचार्य भगवत्पाद गुरुदेव महाराज जी के श्री चरणों में कोटि कोटि प्रणाम I हर हर महादेव 🙏🏻

[@pawanKumar-wb4bk]

Can any one please answer that if cast bhramhan is better than artificially made bhramhan. Then why the children of bhramhan are not bhramhan by quality. Now a days we find that cast bhramhan are having no qualities of bhramhan

[@meenu999]

Better bother abut whatever your own varna is!

[@ujjwalyadav3783]

​@@meenu999and who is deciding varna?

[@meenu999]

@@ujjwalyadav3783 ask your sampradaya guru!! You Tube is certainly not the place with all its propaganda!

[@Light_yagami777]

Every brahman has brahmin quality. It's your misconception.

[@michaelll-n5j]

@@Light_yagami777 😝

[@thedyingwizard4029]

Every dalit should watch it, it might help them come out of their nostalgia of Hinduism. Atleast this guy accept things the way they are.

[@Govindkumar-ij8ox]

I agree

[@jyotivyas9286]

16।00 to the point.👌💐😊जय शंकराचार्य जी। 🎉🎉😊कोटि कोटि वन्दन।

[@मोहितयादव-झ7ब]

समाज के बिघटन और समाज में द्वेष जातिवाद उंच नीच का भेद बढ़ाने का प्रमुख कारण यही लोग हैं

[@prasoonpandey835]

You are talking like a idiot. Brahmins have to live most difficult life live in forest do tapasya and had no right to collect money even in teaching profession and had to live in bhiksha given by others and kshtriya have to shed their bloods in order to protect the society. And shudras were not tortured or being killed by per NCERT propoganda shudras too had enough money to live their livelihood and craftsmen who made marvellous temples, murtis belong to shudra varna .Do you think they were uneducated?So first understand the concept then speak problem with people like you is that you want position and respect but can't see sacrifices one has to make to obtain that position. Meet someone who family is serving in army for a long time their children will automatically have Sanskar and thinking like a army person and will surely wanted to serve in army or serve the country because they will have patriotism as they have that kind of Sanskar.

[@princepoddar2840]

@@prasoonpandey835 ye problem nahi hai bhai , problem hai ki sudra ka beta kshatriya ya brahman nahi ban sakta

[@sarozkumar3939]

Correct

[@BabuLal-pm3ny]

अब आप समझ सकते हो ईनका धर्म से कोई लेना देना नहीं राम मंन्दिर कि तारीख पुछने मंन्दिर का विरोध करने,,, इस्कोन के लोकप्रिय का विरोध करने ये सब साबित करता है

[@sudhirboos429]

इनलोगो का आज भी यही एजेंडा है, संविधान से शंकराचार्यों को दर्द होता है वे मनुविधान चाहते हैं

[@samarsinghbaghel7015]

🚩ॐ नमः शिवाय 🙏🏻 हर हर महादेव 🚩 🚩ॐ त्र्यम्बकं यजामहे सुगन्धिं पुष्टिवर्धनम्। उर्वारुकमिव बन्धनान् मृत्योर्मुक्षीय मामृतात्।।🚩 🚩सानन्दमानन्द वने वसन्तं आनन्दकन्दं हतपापवृन्दम्। वाराणसीनाथ मनाथनाथं श्री विश्वनाथं शरणं प्रपद्ये।।🚩 🚩शंकरं शंकराचार्यं केशवं वादरायणं। सूत्रभाष्यकृतौ वन्दे भगवन्तौ पुनः पुनः।।🚩 🚩 श्री श्री 1008 श्री जगद्गुरु भगवान शंकराचार्य जी के श्री चरणों में कोटि - कोटि दंडवत प्रणाम 🚩 🚩💐🌹🌺🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@appsssssss]

I am chamar I was a proud hindu But i will not die as a hindu I will leave Hinduism It is a sick religion Which means a servant son can only become a servant Human have no choices

[@kk-vx5ty]

Buddy would u listen to me once?

[@kk-vx5ty]

Hello?

[@rohankamti3659]

Tu or tere Ambedkar jo karrahe hai wo kalki puran mei kai saalo pehle likha tha..

[@alok9307]

Read Ambedkar! Convert yourself

[@rrr1592-f3g]

@@rohankamti3659 jab insan ke pass khudki kuch choice nahi hogi ।। Usko kebal janm ke adhar par धिक्कारा जाएगा तब यही होगा लोग धर्म त्याग देंगे।। इस हिसाब से to Jain aur buddh dharm jyada sahi he।। Kam se kam bhed to nahi karte

[@samratbarman756]

4:04 well said🙏 modern schools charge heavy fees and take longer time to provide training but they fail to pass Sanskar which is only possible through the practice of Varna vyavastha.

[@ritabanmajumder7616]

Doesn't the modern Pundits charge high?? 😂😂

[@shrutisarangi8387]

Abe gnwar thoda science pdh le fir kuch bol Iski gapod me koi fact nhi😂

[@0112johnjohn]

​@@ritabanmajumder7616that's what dumbass everything got corrupt as everyone including pandit is insecure of uncertainty of livelihood.. Hence everyone is just focusing on livelihood not on actual karma... That is dharma. ❤ Everyone at losing

[@ratnakartiwari5918]

Har har mahadev !

[@ramchandraoke]

नमस्कार भगवान 🙏🙏🙏। सत्य समझाने के लिए ।🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹👏👏

[@sanjaykumarguptagupta3499]

आप की इन्हीं नीति यो के कारण हमारा देश सैकड़ों साल तक गुलाम रहा .

[@gorelal6365]

Amerika kyu gulam bna cheen kyu gulam bna ye bta bahut gyani bn rha hai to vha to in logo ne jati nhi failayi

[@Fhjkkkkgfddffgh]

​@@gorelal6365 kitne saal America aur chin ghulam raha?

[@Heyy.D33pak]

@@Fhjkkkkgfddffgh per we log tumse phel aajaad ho gaye or devloped bhi or waha bhi jaatiwadi hain lekin wo colour dekh ke krte hai lekin ek leader nenson Mandela ji ki entry ke baad wo puri tarah khatam ho gaya hai thoda padh liya kr whatsapp wale,😂☝️

[@Heyy.D33pak]

@@gorelal6365 hn toh colour based casteism waha bhi hoga hai lodee thoda pad le whatsapp group wala hain aisa hi lagata hai 😂☠️

[@shankarlalpanwar8099]

अधूरे ज्ञान की चट्पति चटनी खाने मे किसी किसी को स्वादिष्ट लगेगी लेकिन मानवता के लिए सदा दुखदाई रही है और रहेगी ये मनुष्यों का वर्गीकरण भगवत गीता को और अच्छी तरह से समझने की जरूरत है जय श्री कृष्णा 🙏

[@RoushanKumar-rk6jc]

Shankarlal Panwar ap smjho apna dimag shi kro ap dimag apka khrab h

[@krishnammagaru]

To "The Premium Speeches". See my responses to everyone , even to my own Gurus. Badari Jyotirmaṭha Pitham and Puri Govardhanmaṭha Pitham . Please refer to all cases lodged in Supreme Court. Also please see if the grace to the institution(s) to be restored as against sending threatening mesages to me for disagreements. My ID is public. Secondly , go thru the complete speech . See what each Shankarachaya spoke in different contexts . Last but not the least, if you post publicly, then expect public disagreement againt partcular person. read my articles.

[@mahaveermalav9377]

Pujaya Shri Sankaracharya G ke charno Mera sadar Naman

[@shrirambhandari1463]

I have heard everything that the respected Swamiji has said , however 2 things I don't agree, 1st thing is that he told about difficulty of making a Kshatriya or Brahmana, that it costs more , and they won't have those proper manners, however it is not necessary that a person born in a certain family will have interest in that job . So job matching one's interest is what is important , which actually is not happening with the Varna Vyavastha as told by him nor is it happening in the modern times . So people are not choosing careers due to their inner calling or inner nature in both systems . Another point he brings out clearly is this , the olden days this was brought out and we made the best society possible, true however are we completely sure that this will work , as people's thinking also changes . Would this still serve people ? The main reason for people to go for various jobs in monetary insecurity , once that is taken care of , people will naturally pursue what they are naturally inclined to . This is a common sense argument I would use .

[@karthikeyakumar3241]

Pujya sri shankaracharya ji said truth .. you mentioned about one's like or interest as imp and please know that shastras r not run by any one's likes r dislikes and human likes and interests are nothing against universal flow anything done against it will face it's results too and by parasara smriti the authenticated rules book for Kaliyuga says that a person who lives as and how he likes without caring other beings and universe is a chandaal a great sinner

[@vladimirputin6530]

jagadguru pe question 😜 Ak b sabda nehni he jis ka mulya abhi ka biswa mein sab se mulyaban he, Baranasrama ak su sangathit parampara he. mlechho mat bano jay hindurastram

[@Abhi5harma]

He is not hindu if he try to do others work. If kshatriyas start pooja paath. Becouse this is clearly mentioned in geeta that Karma is created and divided according to varna by god. Every bodypart have his own work. Not other part can do others. We are body parts of him. If people think their work is for living, not they live for their work, then they try to choose career.

[@Abhi5harma]

Shastras not give you option to do anything what you want, You only want to follow what are vedic principals and that is called humanity. Humanity is sanatan dharma. I'm studying all Shastras since I'm 7 years old.

[@peace5417]

@@Abhi5harma 6 Billion people are living without SHASTRAS and they are doing whatever they want, some thriving a lot more than Indians. Lol.

[@rush-me]

Yes there is different/difference in nature and so in Hindu/mankind. But it is important to understand that artha and gyan ke durupyog ho gaye already because of various invasions and jati-varn-kul dushit kiye gayen already many areas mein. Aisi awastha mein Kya Karen? Shastra kuch upay batati hai? In other words if people from different parts of globe want to be in Hinduism how will jaati-varn-kul be established for them? Is there a way to establish/re-establish the wyawastha?

[@MrAbhinav123]

is this you Bala Subramanium sir?

[@meenu999]

Sanatana Dharma applies to people whose ancestors are from Kashmir to Kanyakumari and this geographical area is explicitly mentioned in many places in the scriptures..one can be born in Hinduism and we have no concept of proselytizing or into conversion. All our rituals are confined to our subcontinent and this is why it is very difficult to continue our rituals overseas..hindus are those only who have ancestors going back all the way..this is not a political or social issue..only religious and only our dharmashastras have authority to decide this.

[@rush-me]

@@meenu999 That is definition of "Hindu". Sanatan Dharma is one who follows varn ashram vyawastha and purusharth.

[@meenu999]

@@rush-me what i meant was Hinduism is confined to people with ancestors and gothra from Aryavart only . Thanks to a thoroughly botched up Independence and 70 years thereafter, we have overwhelming problems within india itself. The preoccupation with trying to gain converts like the Abrahamics is unnecessary once we get our own here itself- back into Sanatana fold in a real way, not just cultural. Besides Mlechchas are taking undue advantage of the hindu servile approach to white people and want to take away Sanatana from here. I have spoken to several such who are simply waiting for the right time. We need to underline the sacred geography of Bharath for Sanatana instead of talking about its lack of rigidity to invite foreigners..pl reflect.. as it can’t be detailed more in comments

[@kmcyasaswi2512]

If you want to be a hindu then you have to be born in it. If you are interested in hinduism then you can practice on your own,there is no need to convert

[@Jaihind699]

पूज्य गुरुस्वरूप शंकराचार्य जी को कोटि कोटि प्रणाम ... उनकी वाणी के अनुसार स्पष्ट है कि ... वर्ण एवम जाति अलग नहीं है ... अत: जातियों की संख्या भी वर्णों की भांति 4 ही होगी ...

[@mandipsingh2740]

pahli baar itse satik uttar suna aapki bato se purn santusti milti h Sare sanka ka samadhan kr dete h aap , bhagwan jagannath aako lambi aayi de taki hme labh ho

[@panditji8152]

U r devoid of true knowledge I hate being called a brahmin I believe in equality for all I hate caste system

[@Shreshth76]

Please expound True Knowledge Dubey Ji.

[@ankushrajput5331]

Fun fact :- you are not dubey 🤣

[@gudmonke-1082]

Caste system is bad and it cannot return. If any one of us utter that word again the whole india will collapse. Muslims will reign over us

[@gam3827]

Bharat was rich in everyway because of varnavyavastha. Fools are those who believe the prachar of foreigners that this is bad. Proof is in the pudding. Because of economic well-being only the number of various castes (population percentage) and the antyas remained high. Otherwise they would have dwindled. Angrezis worked against this system to bring down India economically. Now the foreigners are chanting vedas and are trying to become new Raakshasic kshatriya vaishya and brahmanas. And we are all slaving for them in MNCs, having sold our precious lands, houses, cows , gold and even our ancestral knowledge, to slave for them. United we win again. (Else we will continue this down-spiral and eat each other for basic needs such as water - food is already poisoned)We can stay united only if we share and distribute work and discipline, with respect for dharma and satyam. A disciplined family that shares the work according to an established well-analyzed system succeeds. Woman has the natural ability to be a mother, doctor of family, cook, etc etc. She does not have the natural ability to go out and earn money. This is a misuse or abuse of women-power and also loss of mother at home. With that change in womens role,so many traditional knowledge, physical abilities, and health of all in family is lost. Similar is the case with varnashrama vyavastha , only on a very large scale. Entire humanity is going fast towards extinction because of this loss. If one aspires for a different role in life, we have the option to do tapas for that and follow the discipline required in that role, so we will be born in a body and family that will be conducive to that desired role. As we inherit genetic diseases, so does our body inherit the ability to do upavasa, learn and retain, pronounce vedas flawlessly, fight the wrongs, manage wealth etc etc. The loss of cows and brahmanas (in original form) in the scale it has happened in last few decades is very detrimental to not just hindus but entire humanity. Let us think well and understand and not incur the sin of doing nindaa of this saint. Only brahma-jnanis will have this kind of courage to speak for truth no matter what.

[@AnkitVerma-ez5fh]

Is he Ashish dhar of UpWard who is asking the question?

[@DharmicAdit]

Looks like

[@mrityunjaypratapsingh3531]

Yes

[@meenu999]

Why is the questioner so relevant and not the question itself? Just diverting attention?

[@ramprakashpandey8466]

परम पूज्य गुरु जी साष्टांग सादर प्रणाम

[@gyan9368]

श्रीमान जी अगर ब्रिटेन में वर्ण व्यवस्था नहीं है तो या वहाँ वैकल्पिक वर्ण व्यवस्था ही है तो क्या कारण है कि आज वह हमसे प्रत्येक मामले में आगे है उसने हम पर लंबे समय तक शासन किया है. अगर जाति व्यवस्था अच्छी है तो क्या कारण है कि उस देश ने हमको जीतकर हमपर शासन किया और आज हमसे हर मामले में आगे है जिसमें जाति व्यवस्था नहीं है?

[@pradeepp6850]

Arey Britain ne toh hampe sirf 300 yrs rajya kiya tha. Britain bhi maanta hai ki pichle 3000 saal mein bharat ki GDP duniya mein sabse zyada tha. Paiyya upar tha phir niche gaya ab toh firse upar aaraha hai Swamiji ki krupa se

[@meenu999]

Gyan- ye agyaan ki baat kyo kar rahe hain? Shankaracharyaji unke desh ke dharmk character ki baat kar rae hain na ki samaj, aarthik, rajanitik 🙄

[@5minutecalms]

@@pradeepp6850 Bharat ka GDP was high during Mughal period as far as I know.

[@pradeepp6850]

@@5minutecalms there was no mughal period. What they thought you as history in school was just nonsense

[@ajeetpandey1]

भाई साहब हम गुलाम कब हुए जब क्षत्रियों को हिंसा के नाम पर उनकी तलवार रखवा दी गई उसके पूर्व हमारी क्या संपन्नता थी ये तो आपको पता ही होगा

[@m_vaub737]

Afaik the person asking this question is ashish dhar from upword

[@ShubhamRasikajivrindavan]

जय हो सद्गुरु देव जी भगवान कोटि कोटि नमन सत्य वचन है

[@rrr1592-f3g]

Is prakar se dharm ka nash hona स्वाभाविक है।। देखते जाए १०० साल की ही बात ही या तो ये वर्ण जातिवाद खत्म हो जाएगा या फिर हिंदू धर्म की ७० ८० % आबादी हिंदू धर्म छोड़ देगी।। आप सच में अधर्मी ही गुरु।। अगर नर्क होगा तो आपको जरूर वहा ही स्थान मिलेगा।

[@sarozkumar3939]

Correct 👌 और यही होना चाहिए इस तरह के गुरू घंटालों से मुक्ति के लिए।

[@BabuLal-pm3ny]

ईनको जाती का संत समझो हिंन्दु ओं का नहीं क्योंकि नेहरू जी ने सभी संगठनों में अपने लोगों को बिठाया काम भी तो उस हिसाब से करेंगे जोड़ने का केसे करेंगे

[@kundankmishra3151]

हिंदू धर्म छोड़ कर भाग वेश्या पुत्र। तुम जैसों की आवश्यकता नहीं। हमारे ऊपर कृपा कर के छोड़ दो। 🙏

[@parijatmathur8489]

If Varna & JAti are exactly the same thing, DhrtarAshtra/PAndu being biological children of VyAsa should be BrAhmana by Varna(& so PAndava/Kaurava should also be BrAhmana Varna). But their Varna is classified as Kshatriya. So premise that Varna=JAti is refuted.

[@nagendrachemuturi9145]

Please read anusaasanika parva to get clarity on this. Clarity is also provided in Manu Smriti. A person can be considered a Kshatriya if born to a Kshatriya man and Kshatriya woman or if born to a Brahmin father and Kshatriya woman. Same info can be found in Manusmriti. When Kshatriyas were killed by Parashuraama, it was through the Saptarshis that the Kshatriyas were repopulated.

[@parijatmathur8489]

@@nagendrachemuturi9145 For क्षेत्रज children, the जाति of nonbiological Father is carried forward.

[@archianand986]

@@parijatmathur8489 Jati denotes "birth", birth is a biological quality, there's no such thing called a "nonbiological father" !

[@parijatmathur8489]

@@archianand986 Read about औरस & क्षेत्रज पुत्र.

[@destroyer620]

@@parijatmathur8489 In hinduism, the biggest problem is myth if some book gives a particular concept at the same time,there exist some exception like in Chemistry (inorganic specially) and nonone could explain this.Noone have the power to cross ques these big dharma guru aur leaders.Some how this problem comes in Islam also, different people will give different different logic and verses.

[@rashtrawadi171]

Leave brahmism and join arya samaj

[@roshan990909]

I'm little confused with this... Yes there are certain karma that are intrinsic with birth like birds can fly, most animals can run fast in four legs, humans can run in two legs... . One may try hard to copy the unnatural karmas but they will not be as smooth or efficient as the naturally defined karmas... like we may fly but it's not as conscious as it's for birds. Any karma as such which are intrinsic are manifested by that creature if left in it's own nature... But how can we expand this to the nature of work that we have created for society and say this artificial karma is determined from birth. What is natural will take it's normal course of action if left in nature, so shouldn't we let each human take their own natural path and whatever socially defined job they settle in with joy as their natural karma? Guruji, please kindly correct my misunderstanding of karma.

[@barkhakarakoti4199]

Unhone btaya video me.. ki sanskaar matter krte hain. Sanskaar in the sense.. ki jese kshatriyo k andr lakho saal se ek particular sanskaar chle aa rhe hain.. so isliye they will be perfect to be in a position to protect a nation. Agar sab mix ho jaega..sanskar vgerah.. like aaj ka time.. mainly in foreign countries.. to society ko best level par chala pana would become difficult. Just like today's time.. jese vikalp Brahmins..vikalp kshatriyas.. vikalp vaishaya..vikalp shudra.. all these people are not doing their work properly and creating problems for the society.. doing exploitation. Meko jitna smjh aya.. i explained. 🙏

[@roshan990909]

@@barkhakarakoti4199 : Thank you so much for your reply. I have so many questions and as long as one have questions, one does not have knowledge... So I consider myself agyaani... Thus I request for forgiveness if my questions if offensive in any way.. But if it is sanskaar that instills the karma then if a brahmin is raised in the ksyatria family, then will the child be ksyatria due to the ksyatria sanskar he/she received? So as long as the karma sanskaar is maintained in family, it will be preserved irrespective of the caste of the family? Just like there are schools or mattths which keep up one book of veda and keep the essence of that veda alive and vibrant.

[@doorvam.7619]

@@barkhakarakoti4199 Esa hota to Muglo aur Britishers ka gulam bnke rehna na pada hota. Also, there are so many educational institutes are run by different caste people. All of them are corrupt. They only want your money. Even brahmins are toppers in corruption. Can you explain me why this is happening?

[@nagendrachemuturi9145]

@@roshan990909 the response to yourpoint here is in Manu smriti and other pramaans like MahaBhaarata. Which varna can pursue which professions, and under what consitions or scenarios, is given in these works. Please do read them if possible. Focus on Anusaasanika parva of MahaBhaarata for it has answers to a lot of questions like these. Hari om.

[@bhuvanc4992]

@@barkhakarakoti4199 I would pick the vaikalpik kshatriya Shivaji or Baji Rao any day over the likes of the sanskari ones who became vassals of the Mughals.

[@bhuvanc4992]

If in all of the humongous Vedic corpus, the varna vyavastha is mentioned only in one place in the Purusha Sukta, does it not show that it was not a big deal at that time, and only later it developed into something that came to be considered integral to Hinduism?

[@archianand986]

The term "varna" or "dwija" is mentioned at several places in the Vedas, be it in the Samhita, Brahamana, Arayanka or Upanishads, even the names of the 4 jatis have been mentioned separately in Shruti (Veda) as well as Smritis, you are simply not being honest with yourself.

[@bhuvanc4992]

@@archianand986 To clarify, the point I was making was that slowly over time it became an integral part of the Indian society but it wasn't such a big deal to begin with. The Rig Veda is our oldest Veda and its books were composed over many centuries and yet it is only the Purush Sukta that occurs in a later book that talks of the Varna Vyavastha explicitly, ie, calling out the four varnas specifically with their assigned roles. The Rig Veda shows how the clan of the Bharatas gained prominence and brought their Gods and their religion, in other words the Vedic dharma, into the mainstream over India. Over time, their Varna Vyavastha that came as part of the package, started becoming more rigid instead of a loose classification of the functions in society depending on an individual's temperament, as it initially was. This is why we find verses talking about different professions followed by different members of the same family etc in the older books. The picture becomes more clear when one looks over events and scripture chronologically, and the references you give only support this. As an aside, varna has many meanings and dvija simply means twice born etc....those points are not germane to my contention.

[@archianand986]

@@bhuvanc4992 The idea that Vedas were composed over several centuries by initially propagated by Max Muller, who didn't even know anything about the Indian culture apart from what he had read from the accounts of fellow Britishers who had spent some time during their colonial campaigns in Bharatvarsh. People who lived in India knew even before the Islamic invasions happened that the whole Vedic corpus was essentially one and had a history of oral transmission spanning millions of years before they were finally divided into 4 different parts by the avatar of Narayana, Sri Veda Vyasa. Any person who has knowledge of Vedic Sanskrit, knows that it is different from Laukika Sanskrit used in the Puranas. Learning proper Sanskrit, epistemology and study of the evidences requires 12 years in gurukula, thus people who are not authorised in these disciplines are not permitted to even comment upon any simple shastra let alone the Vedas. Each of the Vedas is itself divided into 4 parts- Samhita, Brahmana, Arayanka & Upanishad, moreover there were 1131 samhitas in the past of which only 13 are extant now. You are trying to make a conclusion about something which takes years to be able to understand but your opinions have got no place in the academic order because they are not based upon facts, because you are only repeating the same statements which historians who based researched on the history textbooks of James Mill, Max Muller and H.M. Elliot have disseminated over the years.

[@bhuvanc4992]

@@archianand986 I have not taken names of any of these folks but you seem intent on name calling and guilt by association. The fact that the Vedas were composed over centuries is proved by the difference in the sanskrit of the ten books of the rig Veda itself. And millions of years? Humans themselves migrated out of Africa only 100000 years ago. And lastly, do you have the qualifications that you point out, and do you know anything about genetics and other fields, all of which have a bearing on study of ancestry. Thank you, not interested in further comments.

[@archianand986]

@@bhuvanc4992 What you do not realise is that whatever you have written until now can be traced back in academic historical chronology to only 300 years ago, whereas to be able to comment upon the use and differences in Sanskrit language one needs to have complete knowledge of the Laukika and Vedika sanskrit which takes years to master, how can a historian with no formal gurukul education know the difference in language when he is not an expert on the linguistic front? Do they know Sanskrit better than authorised Sanskrit Acharyas, Upadhyayas and Mahamahopadhyayas in Bharat?

[@RoushanKumar-rk6jc]

Puri trah se sach

[@balaji7hari569]

गुरुदेव इतना सब कुछ होने के बाद में भी भारत देश गुलाम कैसे हुआ

[@MM-dh3wr]

Then at the bottom of the Brahmin hierarchy and the “untouchable” but most essential among the Brahmins are those who perform funeral ceremonies and partake of funeral meals and accept post-mortem gifts - they are known as the Apara-prayogis or Mahā-pātras - and they are shunned even by the Dalits!

[@RehanAhmad1]

Shankaracharya Ji ko sunkar lagta hai ki sahi lagah time spend kar rahe hain sunne seekhne mein kuch naya..

[@meenu999]

Aap to apne mulle maulvi mein hi khush rahiye…Shankaracharyaji se aap ka koi matlab nahi…doosron ke samaaj mein mat jhaankiye…

[@Ruhansh-yu5zl]

​​@@meenu999ye kya battamizi hai hindutav or sanatan koi samaj nahi hai par muslim samaj hai. Sanatan vishw ke kalyan ke liye hai kisi samaj ka nahi hai kisi ke samaj ka apman karna sanatan ka hissa nahi hai. Apka ye vachan shoba nahi deta apko isse aap ka mansik star jhalakta hai.

[@Ruhansh-yu5zl]

Mai iski taraf se mafi mangta hu. hindutav or sanatan koi samaj nahi hai par muslim samaj hai. Sanatan eik vichardhara hai Sanatan vishw ke kalyan ke liye hai kisi samaj ka nahi hai kisi ke samaj ka apman karna sanatan ka hissa nahi hai. Aap bilkul muslim reh ke bhi jo vichar islam or sanatan mai same hai unka palan kar sakte hai. Sanatan to principle of universe hai.

[@Sahebmere]

शूद्रों को ग़ुलाम बनाकर उसे शिक्षा से वंचित किया! पानी से वंचित किया! क्या मुग़लों ने ये लागू किया?😂 ग़ज़ब! अब शूद्र पढ़ रहा है! सबका भेद खुल रहा है।

[@hridaynarayangupta7212]

मंगल ग्रह से आए हो का ,? महात्मा विदुर से बड़ा कोई आज तक नीतिज्ञ पूरे भारत के इतिहास में नहीं हुआ, बिना शिक्षा और विद्या के ही वह इतने बड़े महात्मा हो गए क्या। भगवान रामचंद्र जी के परम मित्र निषादराज उनके साथ गुरुकुल में ही पढ़ते थे । महर्षि वशिष्ठ जैसे ब्रह्म ऋषि निषादराज को स्वयं शिक्षा देते थे। सनातन धर्म एक मंदिर है और चारों वर्ण उसके चार स्तंभ है ,इसको तोड़ने का प्रयास ना करो धुर्तों के बहकावे में आकर इससे आपका अपना ही नाश होगा । क्योंकि सनातन धर्म बढ़िया सिद्धांत पूरे विश्व में कोई नहीं लदे सकता है। क्योंकि यह सिद्धांत स्वयं भगवान द्वारा ही प्रदत्त है।

[@mtrs598]

@@hridaynarayangupta7212 jatiwad ke evidence hai or aaj bhi samaj me jatiwad hai. Par aaj tak ramayan mahabharat sirf mythology me hi ati hai. Kathaye hai reality nahi.

[@vishalprabhulawande6527]

@@mtrs598 evidence de dijiye ji. Preferably some book which I can read.

[@kiranenterprises5656]

Sujeet Bhai Mai Vashya samaj se hu, mere bahut se Dost Harijan Biradari se hai aur bahut he prem milta hai unke parivar se, Kripya maan me aisi durbhavna na pale, aap hamare Bhai hai aur bahut he priya hai.

[@meenu999]

Paani se agar vanchit kiya jaata to aaj ek bhi shudra aur ati shudra jeevit nahi hota🤣🤣🤣

[@MukeshKumar-pr8zz]

reality of Brahman

[@sarozkumar3939]

Reality of guru ghantal

[@Ayush_Upadhyay571]

Proud of it😂 You shudra convert into buddhism

[@tonmoysarkar7814]

जन्मना जायते शूद्रः संस्कारात् द्विज उच्यते। शापानुग्रहसामर्थ्यं तथा क्रोधः प्रसन्नता ।|31-34|| 🙏🙏🙏🚩🚩🚩 Everyone is born a Shudra (ignorant of the path to spiritual knowledge), until the travails of samsara motivates the person to seek it. Only someone who seeks the path to spiritual knowledge is called a Brahmin. You cannot become a Brahmin by birth.

[@v1.commander108]

Mr, Sarkar, your religious understanding is minuscule just like any average Bengali. All the 4 varnas are by birth and karmas of previous life..... The shloka that you are quoting is indicating that the dwijas(twice born) ,i.e, Brahmin, Kshatriya and Vaishya after upanayana can do the yajnas and karmas ascribed to their respective Varna.

[@tonmoysarkar7814]

​@@v1.commander108 and They have to follow chaturashram system, reality is varnas were died with chaturashram, distortion of the Manusmriti was a disaster for Bharat,

[@v1.commander108]

@@tonmoysarkar7814 🤦

[@harajyoti_kar88]

This time I am totally convinced.

[@Skeletorr24]

he is preaching it totally wrong. Lord krishna cant be wrong.

[@harajyoti_kar88]

@@Skeletorr24 he read krishna more than you 🙄

[@Skeletorr24]

@@harajyoti_kar88 casteist hai ye

[@truthtruth8950]

shankrachry is total right

[@Desi.Superman]

@@Skeletorr24 aap string ki video kam dekhe. Voh apna agenda chala rhe hai. Shankracharya ne sab padha hai, shankracharya sabse uchha pad hota hai.

[@deshmukhbalraj]

जाती ही वर्ण है जबतक sc st Obc खुद कों हिंदू मानेंगे तबतक जाती जायेगी नहीं जाती और जातीगत उच्च निच्च रहेगा सोचना दलित बंधूओ कों है रहना क्या.........................

[@mahakaal766]

😁😁sanatan toh hai hee woh isme kya kar lega tu

[@deshmukhbalraj]

@@mahakaal766 मुझे कुछ करणा नहीं बे करणा तो एस सी एस टी के लोगो कों है

[@mahakaal766]

@@deshmukhbalraj toh tumhe kahe chanune kaat rahe ..

[@sarozkumar3939]

बौद्ध संप्रदाय की ओर चलो सभी एसटी एसएसी और ओबीसी वर्ग। 😮

[@designerjournalist7258]

क्या ही कहे,पूज्य आदमी है सबको बुरा लग जायेगा जाने देते है।

[@sarozkumar3939]

ये पूज्य नहीं, अपूज्य ही है ये गुरू घंटाल

[@Ayush_Upadhyay571]

​@@sarozkumar3939chammar 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😅

[@mohammedakbaruddin4525]

लक्षण न्यायदर्शनकार गौतम मुनि जी लिखते हैं, ‘‘आकृतिरितिलिाख्या’’ (न्याय.२.२६८) इस पर वात्स्यायन मुनि भाष्य में कहते हैं। ‘यथा जाति जाति लिन्गानि च प्रत्याख्यायन्ते तामाकृतिं विद्यात्’ जिससे जाति और जाति के चिह्न बताये जाते हैं उसे आकृति कहते हैं। अब स्वभाविक रुप से प्रश्न उठता है कि जाति किसे कहते हैं? तो उत्तर में कहा गया है- समानप्रसवात्मिका जातिः(न्या. २/२/१९) इस पर भी वात्स्यायन मुनि भाष्य में कहते हैं- या समानां बुद्धिम प्रसूते भिन्नेष्वधिकरणेषु,यया बहूनीतरेतरतो न व्यावर्तन्ते, योऽर्थोऽनेकत्र प्रत्ययानुवृत्तिनिमित्तं तत् सामान्यम्। यच्च केषाघिद भेदं कुतश्चिद्भेदं करोति तत् सामान्य विशषा जातिरिति।’’ अर्थात् भिन्न-भिन्न वस्तुओं में समानता उत्पन्न करने वाली जाति है। इस जाति के आधार पर अनेक वस्तुएँ आपस में पृथक् पृथक’ नहीं होतीं अर्थात्-एक ही नाम से बोली जाती हैं। जैसे गौएँ पृथक् कितनी भी हो तो भी सबको गौ कहते हैं। यह एकता जाति के कारण ही उत्पन्न हुई जाति भी दो प्रकार की होती है-एक सामान्य दूसरी सामान्य-विशेष जो अनेक वस्तुओं में एक आकार की प्रतीत होती है वह सामान्य जाति है, जैसे पशु जाति सामान्य है। यह पशुत्व गौ, भैंस, घोड़े आदि में सामान्य (एक जैसा) है। जो किसी से भेद और किसी से अभेद कराती है वह सामान्य विशेष जाति है जैसे गौ। गौ की प्रतीति सब गौओं में एक-जैसी होती है, यह तो हुआ अभेद पर घोड़े को गौ नहीं समझ सकते यह हुआ भेद, तो इसका नाम सामान्य विशेष जाति है। उक्त दोनों जातियों में से मनुष्य सामान्य जाति है। मनुष्यत्व की दृष्टि से सभी वर्ण मनुष्य हैं, न उनमें कोई ज्येष्ठ है और न कनिष्ठ। ज्येष्ठता और कनिष्ठता वाले तो गुण होते हैं। मनुष्य योनि क्योंकि कर्म और भोग दोनों योनि हैं, अतः इसमें गुणों के साथ कर्म पर भी ध्यान देना अनिवार्य है। अतः ब्राहमणादि वर्णों का निर्णय गुणों और कर्मों के आधार पर होने के कारण ही वर्णों का नाम वर्ण पड़ा, क्योंकि वर्ण शब्द का अर्थ गुण और कर्म हैं- क्रमशः..

[@atishsingh1989]

Profound insights 🙏

[@manojjoshi3937]

Good knowledge

[@rama15111988]

Akbar Mohd chutiye ...tum apne daadi badathe rahe

[@hrkvid]

You have very good insights. Hinduism/India/Whatever you call it is so ancient, old, backward, forward, and so many things at the same time, so it is very difficult to decipher what the hell is going on, how was it 1000s of years ago and how it should be moving forward. I believe in progress and leaving the old which is not fair or right. You seem to have a good knack for research on history. So keep it going. Good job. The focus should be on truth, that's all.

[@deepakraghuvanshe4714]

Ati sundar

[@princesinha354]

baba jee se ek sawal..jo sudra jaise ki sc,st aur kayastha jo padh likh kar engineer doctor ban jaate hain to unke liye sastra ka kya adesh hai..kripya marga darshan karen.

[@Rrrtau]

Doctor aur engineer shudra Varna ke andar hi ata hai

[@roshanmishra3868]

There should be proper education system and exam process to become sankracharya Otherwise illiterate like him destroy sanatan dharma 🤣

[@harerampathak8653]

Did u know about him he written many books on mathematics and discovered many formulas. What you done other than passing judgement. Did you know about shastas If you are fool and not understand the word then why are you blaming others for that

[@harerampathak8653]

And remove mishra title from your name I know you are fake.

[@roshanmishra3868]

@@harerampathak8653 Pathak ji main janm se hi nahi karm se bhi brahman hu Teaching in worlds one of top university Please give me reference of his written formulas and book Vaise india me to koi Kuchh bhi likh deta hai , maths formula should be published in any international journal

[@roshanmishra3868]

@@harerampathak8653 agar free ka KZbin na use kar rahe ho to you can. Check my geographical location 🤣 And get an idea about my education

[@shubhankardasgupta4777]

@@roshanmishra3868 Absolutely sir.. I agree on you... The existence of our reality comes from our parents... And so our parent's occupation is the determinal factor of our jaati??? Dharma is righteousness, and right to know consciousness is the soul right of every living thing.

[@saiteja-ww4vl]

Plz add English subtittles

[@शतपथी]

He is Ashish Dhar Bhai right? Can anyone confirm this?

[@sachindubey7966]

Yes he is Ashish Dhar from UPword।

[@Ruhansh-yu5zl]

Everyone should proud of their casts. I liked this concept.

[@vchandrashekar3653]

" Sab ko phal ka barabar adhikar hai". This is just a platitude. Will the Sankaracharya therefore prescribe equal salary from M. D. to sweeper in any organization? And if not, what is the harm in someone from a sweepers family taking up a higher paying position if he has the capability? Have there not been great saints as well from so-called lower castes? Due respect to his wide reading and knowledge.

[@meenu999]

Don’t you even know that a Shankaracharya is not concerned about activities done for economic benefits? When he is talking about phal he means karma phal that a human receives after death…🙄🙄🙄🙄

[@Abhi-un9lk]

He's talking about karmaphal which is after death. As far as economic/financial freedom goes a street sweeper will earn more than a brahmin

[@akashekhar]

A chappal sewer shudra made more money than most Brahmins back in the day.

[@meenu999]

When sweeper and MD do the same work and shoulder the same responsibilities that day they may get same pay. Can’t you understand even this simple thing that pay is always according to the value given to what a person does or produces??

[@karshnivikaspandit3229]

परम पूज्य महाराज श्री की जय

[@beerusop820]

Tera kam free saaf kam karna hai

[@aek12]

We can automate everything now.

[@dipanshuagrawal6659]

Sanatan dharm ki red aise hi thodi Mari hai, Sanskar janm se thodi aate h, In English it impression, conditioning, it has nothing to do with birth. Swami chinmayanand who directed UPANISHAD GANGA ,. was also an advait vedanti, he gave such a beautiful episode about varn.

[@jyotivyas9286]

यह तो वो हैं। काश्मीर से। नाम याद नही आ रहा। 😮

[@SunilSharma-hb1vc]

हे प्रभु आप धर्म Samrat Swamiji Shri karpatri Ji Maharaj की तरह आंदोलन करीये हम आप के साथ हैं

[@indumundra335]

Sunil Sharma aasha hai aap jaise pujya Shankaracharya ke samman hi aapke uttaradhikari hon 🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@Peer.dan.charan]

❤ श्री गुरुदेव शरणम् गंगा गीता गायत्री गौ माता भारत माता की जय जय जय जय जय जय जय जय जय जय जय भारत

[@TarunKumar-sp2ls]

Aa gaya asli chahra manuvadiyon ka.

[@aloksingh5821]

Kaun si problem ka saamna kar rahe america aur Britain. Said at 10:10

[@moodyguy8635]

Apni arguments ko justify karne ke liye kuch bhi bol rhe hai. Norway, denmark are the most developed countries aur unme aisa koi system nhi hai, they are majority atheists. I have a sincere feeling that this system was started by Brahmins to keep themselves in power.

[@Ironman007-v4p]

Denmark Norway destroy their family life

[@5minutecalms]

@@moodyguy8635 sahi kaha

[@akashekhar]

@@moodyguy8635 You are just seeing the world through the lens of materialism. They are “developed” in material sense, and you think that they are satisfied with their lives? Why do these so called developed nations have the highest amount of mental illness and pop the highest amount of anti-depressant pills? Don’t just believe whatever is fed to you through the mass media.

[@धर्म_रक्षक]

​@@moodyguy8635Look at what is happening in USA, children getting killed in schools. Minors getting their gender changed. They are individualistic people, they do not care for family. Sky high divorce rates, single parent childrens suffer.

[@jyotivyas9286]

यह पूछ रहे एक नही हिन्दू। पर वो जाति से नही हो सकता।

[@sureshtiwari4169]

Vaikalpik banana pudega puri baat suno tub bolo

[@harshittandon4356]

ashish dhar great effort upword is a wonderful venture

[@jyotidaradi243]

Bhagavad Gita me Arjun ne pucha tha Jati or kul ke bare me jiska answer Bhagavan ne diya tha. Iska matlab ye nehi hota ki Bhagavad Gita me Jatibaad hain. Scriptures ko samajh ne ke liye sad Guru chahiye khud se nehi samjha ja sakta hain. Inke hisaab se Vaikalpit Brahmin kon hain jara naam sunaye un logo ka ?? History agar dekhe to Mithila, Nabadwip , Mathura me institute tha scripture(veda/purana) padane ke liye . Agar janm se hi koi Brahmin hota hain to institute keu hain ? Aap ki pathsala me agar Brahmin nehi hota to hum kiya karen ?

[@অরুণাভদাস]

जाति व्यवस्था में कोई बुराई नहीं थी। जब जाति व्यवस्था थी तब बेरोज़गारी की कोई समस्या नहीं होती थी। मुझे जाति के आधार पर दुराचार करने में आपत्ति है, परन्तु व्यवस्था में कोई त्रुटि नहीं है।

[@jyotimeena7191]

लेकिन देश तो ग़ुलाम था

[@suryaprakashsharma8739]

7।। वंदे महापुरुष ते चरणार विंदम।। Shri pujaniya Gurudev Shri Anant vibhushith purvanamay rigvediya Goverdhan math Puri pithadhishwar Shrimad Jagadguru Shankaracharya ji Mahabhag ke Shri Kamal caharon mein dandwat vandan. Hindu Nagar Shivganj, Rajasthan, Bharat. ।। चैत्र शुक्ल 6,सम्वत 2081।। तद्नुसार रविवार,14.04.2024. 7.50 ए एम।। ।।जय श्री गौआता।। ।। जय श्री सनातन धर्म।। ।।जय श्री सनातन संस्कृति।। ।। जय श्री सनातन धरा।। ।।जय श्री सनातन राष्ट्र।। ।।जय श्री मां भारती।। ।। ॐ ॐ ॐ ॐ ॐ।। ।। जय श्री सनातन धर्म।।

[@kuldeepchaubey2282]

Jai adi guru Shankaracharya ❤❤❤

[@RajeshKumar-oo7fr]

कटु सत्य👁️💐🙏🇮🇳🏹

[@chooseaname-ki6yh]

सनातन धर्म को कोटि कोटि प्रणाम। हम सभी इस दिशा में प्रयासरत हो की हिन्दुओं को शक्तिहीन बनाने की इस योजना को विफल करें। सवर्ण स्वयं आगे आकर कहें कि उन्हें विवाह हेतु दलित वर वधु चाहिए। हम सभी सवर्ण - दलित विवाह को प्रोत्साहित करें। जैसे जैसे सवर्ण कन्याएँ दलितों के परिवार में वधु बनकर जाएंगी वैसे वैसे ये हिन्दू-विरोधी षड़यंत्र निष्फल होता जाएगा।

[@shrutisarangi8387]

Agr aise gnwar shankaracharya bn gye h, to dharma sankat me h... Na isko ved-upanishad ka bodh h na geeta ka

[@7-ashokkumarsuman661]

लोग भाग भोतिक फल के पीछे भग रहे हे आध्यात्मिक फल को भुलते जा रहे। वर्ण कर्तव्य हे बाक़ी सब समान हे।

[@mandipsingh2740]

es vaky ka prachar prasar karna chahiye taki murkho ko samajh aaye,bahut achhe tariko se aapne samjhaya h

[@adigaurbrahman6859]

जगतगुरु शंकराचार्य भगवान की जय 🙏🏻🌸

[@beerusop820]

Chal bhai tera kam nala shaph karna chal kar

[@subratamukherjee5043]

Universal truth,, app vogban ho..

[@pratikshajoshi6633]

🚩🙏Shrimad Jagadguru Shankaracharya mahabhaag🙏🚩

[@dipalisengupta5563]

JAISREE RADHEY KRSNA 🌹🌿 JAI GURUDEV Maharajji dandavat Pranam 🌹🌿

[@jagdishshrivastava5042]

जय जय श्री सीताराम महराज जी दंडवत प्रणाम मैं कायस्थ जाति का हूँ कृपया बताईये मैं किस वर्ण के अंतर्गत आऊंगा

[@vibhanshutripathi3863]

Aap *Thanks Bharat* ki videos dekhiye bhai

[@सौरभतिवारी-ख5स]

भाई जी,आप वैश्य वर्ण के अंतर्गत हैं।

[@ashishpatel4096]

शूद्र

[@ashishpatel4096]

कायस्थ शूद्र वर्ण में आते है

[@Lysao-p8v]

Satshudra

[@manishtyagi780]

Gol gol ghumane mein expert ho aap

[@abhishekchavhan2018]

Sahi bola bhai. Bhraman ka beta shudra ho sakta hai aur shudra ka beta bhraman ho sakta hai.

[@abhishekchavhan2018]

Sahi bola bhai. Bhraman ka beta shudra ho sakta hai aur shudra ka beta bhraman ho sakta hai.

[@RakeshGohil-qq8in]

🌹🌹🌹🙏🙏🙏

[@सूरजसूरज-फ9ज]

एक भी ब्राम्हण सन्त पर आरोप नही लग गया। आसाराम बापू रामदेव नित्यानंद राम रहीम ये लोग ब्राह्मण नही है।

[@सौरभतिवारी-ख5स]

भाई साहब जी ऐसा कोई निश्चित रूप से नहीं कहा जा सकता है। कोई भी ग़लत हो सकता है।

[@rrr1592-f3g]

Ravan balatkari tha.. aur bramhan bhu

[@ramanand8111]

Parshuram murderer tha

[@mohammedakbaruddin4525]

वरणीया वरितुमर्हा गुणकर्माणि च दृष्ट्वा यथायोग्यं व्रियन्ते ये ते वर्णाः। गुण और कर्म देखकर जो किसी समुदाय-विशेष के स्वीकार किये जावें, वे वर्ण कहलाते हैं। निरुक्त को वर्ण का अर्थ कर्म भी कहा गया है-वृतमिति कर्मनाम वृणोतीति सतः- यहाँ ‘‘वृज’’ धातु से बनने वाले वृत् शब्द का अर्थ स्पष्ट ही कर्म लिया है, और साथ ही हेतु दिया है- वृणोतीति सतः - क्योंकि शुभकर्म मनुष्य को ढक लेते हैं, अतः व्रत का अर्थ कर्म है। इसी प्रकार इसी धातु से निष्पन्न हुए वर्ण शब्द का अर्थ‘‘वर्णो वृणोते….’’ के आधार पर गुण और कर्म है। अतः सामान्य जाति का सामान्य विशेष जाति के साथ मिलान करना भारी भूल है। हाँ, जिस प्रकार आम्र में खट्टे-मीठे आदि गुणों का भेद होता है, वैसे तोते तोते में पढ़ने या न पढ़ने के गुण का भेद होता है। गौ-गौ में न्यून और अधिक दूध आदि देने के गुण का भेद होता है। इसी प्रकार मनुष्यों में अच्छे और बुरे गुणों और कर्मों के आधार पर भेद है। इसी को शास्त्र ने वर्ण कहा है। यदि सामान्य विशेष जाति पशु, वृक्ष, पक्षियों का-सा मनुष्य में भी भेद होता तो जिस प्रकार भिन्न-भिन्न पशुओं के झुण्ड में से गौ, भैंस आदि को पृथक्-पृथक् पहचान लेते हैं, वृक्षों और पक्षियों को पृथक्-पृथक् जानते हैं, इसी प्रकार मनुष्यों के समूह में से ब्राहमण, क्षत्रियादि को अलग से पहचान लेते, किन्तु कोई भी नहीं पहचान सकता। चार वर्ण हैं- ब्राहमण, क्षत्रिय, वैश्य और शूद्र।आजकल समाज में लोग जहाँ जन्म के अनुसार वर्ण मानते हैं वहाँ आर्यों का मत है गुण-कर्म-स्वभाव और जीविका के साधन के अनुसार वर्ण को स्वीकार करता है।जन्मपरक वर्ण व्यवस्था के नाम पर अतीतकाल में हिन्दू समाज में शूद्रों पर जो अत्याचार किये गए, उनकी कथा अत्यन्त हृदय-द्रावक है।शूद्रों को छूने तक में पाप समझा जाता था, फिर उनके साथ समानता के व्यवहार की आशा ही क्या की जाती?शूद्रों को विद्या और वेद पढ़ने के अधिकार से वंचित रखा गया और पराय के जैसा उनसे व्यवहार करते थे, तथा जबर्दस्ती उनसे सेवा वसूल करना अपना जन्म सिद्ध अधिकार समझते थे।किन्तु आर्य समाज का दृष्टिकोण इसके विपरीत है।आर्य समाज चारों वर्णों को समाज का अवश्य अंग मानता है और जीवन की मूलभूत आवश्यकताओं की प्राप्ति की दृष्टि से सबको समानता के स्तर पर रखता है, अर्थात् जहाँ तक रोटी-कपड़ा और मकान का सम्बन्ध है, वे ब्राहमण, क्षत्रिय, वैश्य और शूद्र सभी के लिए समान रूप से आवश्यक हैं और इनकी प्राप्ति में किसी के साथ भेदभाव नहीं किया जाना चाहिए।परन्तु जहाँ तक सामाजिक प्रतिष्ठा का सम्बन्ध है, वह सबसे अधिक मात्रा में उनलोगों को उपलब्ध होगी जो अपना सारा जीवन ज्ञान की उपसना में लगाएँगे, जितने भी कलाकार लेखक, अध्यापक, वैज्ञानिक और सरस्वती के साधक हैं और जो समाज के अज्ञान का निराकरण करते हैं वे सबके सब ब्राहमण कहलाएँगे, फिर चाहे उनका जन्म किसी कुल में क्यों न हो।सामाजिक प्रतिष्ठा में दूसरा स्थान होगा उन क्षत्रियों का जो बल की उपासना करते हैं और अन्याय का प्रतीकार अपने जीवन का लक्ष्य बनाते हैं। क्रमशः..

[@atishsingh1989]

Akbar Mohd Namaste - I am touched by your insights. How did you develop this understanding?

[@mohammedakbaruddin4525]

सत्यार्थ प्रकाश..

[@vish1146]

Pranaams 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@gyan9368]

17:25 श्रीमान जी वर्ण व्यवस्था से शरीर और आत्मा का क्या संबंध है?

[@meenu999]

जन्म जन्मांतर से शरीर द्वारा किए कर्मों के फल के अनुसार ही आने वाले जन्म में वर्ण की प्राप्ति होती है । इसीलिए वर्ण पूर्व कर्मों पर निर्भर है । वर्णाश्रम में जहां हम स्थित है वह हमारे पिछले कर्मों का सीधा परिणाम है! जब शूद्र एवं अन्य अवर्ण वर्तमान जन्म में बहुत सत्कर्म तथा अपने वर्ण धर्म को श्रद्धा एवं पूर्व ईश्वर समर्पण की भावना से करते हैं तब ईश्वर अगले जन्म में और ऊँचे वर्ण में उन्हें जन्म देते हैं ।

[@hennaworld6336]

@@meenu999 kya ucha varna nicha varna laga rakha hai .... Kahin bhi bhagwan ne ucha nicha kaha nahi hai ye sab ap logo ki banayi hun biktrit mansikta hai

[@brajabandhudash5930]

श्री श्री गुरु देब भगवान जी कि जय हो

[@ajaykumar-ss9he]

इतने महान थे तो तुर्को ने पेला कैसा?

[@Kcube.YouTube]

Jo hona h so hoyega ram naam japo khush raho aajke samay koi bhi jati ho fark nhi padhta ❤

[@sahilxd11]

Yahi satya hain or isse jitni jaldi swikar karege ge utne raag dawesh se door raho ge 🙏🙏

[@shubhankardasgupta4777]

aree shrimant, Bhagwan Narayan ka rup, Shri Parshuram ji ek Brahmin -Kshtriya the.. jab bhagwan ne adharma ke khatir, dusre varna ka saar lekar paapi kstriyo ka naash kia ussi prakar aapko sirf aur sirf varna ki khasiyat par adyyan karna chahiye naaki aapke kul mein kyuki... Bhramin ka matlab hi ha.. Brahma ji ka vaas hona aur manna... aapka astatvah aapke parents ne dia hai jo materialistic power, Brahma ji ne dia hai.

[@anuradhagiri9425]

bhagwan mere liye aap sabse bade guru hain

[@Heyy.D33pak]

अरे बहन तर्क शक्ति का इस्तेमाल कर इसके जो सिद्धांत है वो अगर वास्तिविक दुनिया में लगाएगी तोह गली के अलावा कुछ नी मिलेगा 😂❤

[@suwalalsinwasia8718]

अंग्रेजो को धन्यवाद , कि इस कंलकित वर्ण- जाति व्यवस्था का नाश कर शोषण एवं वर्णवाद एवं जातिवाद के आंतक को भी नष्ट करने में महत्ती भूमिका है। बौद्ध धर्म में सभी को समानता के अधिकार थे ।

[@AyushYadav-ss6ds]

Bauddh dharm main bhi caste hoti hain, isiliye ambedkar ne khud ka version bana lia tha buddhism ka jiski authority poore world main koi nahin maanta, thervada aur mahayana buddhism hi sahi hain aur unki authority bhi maani jaati hai.

[@Hitler-v1h]

​@@AyushYadav-ss6ds buddhium mai jativad ho jaha ne ho us cheez se tere ghatiya dhram se jativad khtam nahi hogi aur sun dalia lama dr anbedkar ko great mante hai unko koi dikkat nahi unki buddhium se tumlog kya dikkat hai vaise bhi atleast anbedkar vala buddhium mai itna pakand nahi jitna Tibetan Buddhist log mai hai aur vaise bhi chritianity sabse zyda manu jana vala relgion ha kyoki esa chamatkar kahaniyan vala relgion zyda chalte hai tabhi Tibetan Buddhist hinyan se zyda hai😊

[@NishantKumar-ry9rp]

बौद्ध मत में समानता का अधिकार ? 🤣क्या मजाक है !😂एक बार सनातन समीक्षा पर आओ कभी , तुम्हे दिखाते है कि बौद्ध मत में कितनी समानता है । बौद्ध मत में जितना महिलाओं , शुद्रो और वैश्यों को नीचा दिखाया गया है उतना तुमने कहीं नहीं देखने मिलेगा ।

[@NishantKumar-ry9rp]

​@@Hitler-v1hबौद्ध मत में जातिवाद और महिला विरोध ठूस -ठूस कर भरा हुआ है । कभी बौद्ध ग्रंथों को पढ़ना तब पता चलेगा ।

[@mouneshgowda3045]

Jai gurudev 🚩🚩

[@gyan9368]

20:20 श्रीमान जी अगर कई पीढ़ी से कोई ज्योतिषी है तो वह किस आधार पर सम्मान का पात्र माना जायेगा? 5 पीढ़ी का महाराज अगर गंदा खाना बनाये तो क्या आप खायेंगे?

[@bhanurajtiwari8711]

श्रीमान जी उस समय तुलना हो रही है और वह जन स्वभावतः सम्मान का पात्र होगा ,यदि उसका प्रतिद्वंदी नया हो तो । वह कमजोर माना जायेगा। और 5 पीढ़ी का महाराज गंदा खाना कैसे बनाएगा क्योंकि उसका संस्कार सर्वाधिक श्रेष्ठ होगा अन्य की तुलना में क्योंकि उसे उसका ज्ञान परम्परा से प्राप्त है। आप दैनिक जीवन में भी तो किसी खानदानी कर्मकार से करवाएं या अभी अभी सीखे से (जब तुलना हो तब)

[@lawlearner2835]

आपके हिसाब से यदि शुद्र विद्या अर्जन नहिं कर सकता तो वह अपनी आरक्षित रोजी से कमाया धन गिनेगा कैसे ?

[@avinashs7571]

But jati/varna/caste is not at all practical now. It's not the era of dharma where people will readily accept and respect pre made norms and will be able to uphold the responsibility well. This will make people dependents on others who know the job well which is a double edged sword. Example is mass killing of Kshatriya by Parshuram. Accepting that exception doesn't make the rules but such system is direct slap to such excellent exceptions. Any solution for this? Lineage based work only increases the percentage of efficiency but never promises 100percent effectiveness. The main problem is mentality stupid people who call them brahmin and kshatriya will claim their superiority in almost everything...until and unless dharma is reclaimed on land varna system will most likely hold the land back.

[@gamer-ff6mh]

This channel is good for textbook knowledge, not for practical stuff. But one can always unlearn hatred and re learn love. Take the good, forget rhe bad.

[@akashekhar]

So stupid people cannot become ministers in democracy and claim their superiority? Your argument doesn’t make any sense.

[@unusualbug1113]

​@@gamer-ff6mhagreed, The ideas espoused here can no longer be even implemented considering how society is. Just because someone is born to a sweeper doesn't mean he is a sweeper, they go on their way to become businessmen, soldiers etc.

[@education198]

Odisha ke paika kon si barna me aati he???

[@VijayPartap-oc3dt]

Shankaracharya ji ye bataye yadi koi dusre dharam see Hindu dharam apnata hai to wo kis jati Mai hoga aap me Ghar wapài ke taste hi band Kar site satj hijo log Hindu banana chahye hài unhe aap ki jati system rok Raha hai

[@sintishukla7446]

Bhaisahab farji santo ka toh pta nai pr agar parampara prapt sant jaise maharaj ji agar kisi ko sanatani banayenge toh unka varna panchva hoga vo shoodro ke neeche ayenge.

[@meenu999]

Mlechch aur yavano ko kabhi bhi sanatani nahi ho sakte kyonki unka koi rishi gotra nahi.. Sanatana keval jambudveep bhukhand ke liye hai..aur aise log avarna hi rahenge...

[@sarozkumar3939]

​@@sintishukla7446चल बे मूर्ख

[@benjaminnetanyahu8582]

​@@sintishukla7446 han isiliye angrez tumahre sar pe myt k gye hai 😂

[@harshsrivastava656]

हर हर महादेव🙏🙏

[@ipsnamansinha4601]

❤❤❤

[@Vatsalya-df5xn]

वही प्रश्न करूंगा जो उस चांडाल (महादेव) ने आदि शंकराचार्य से किया था ! " आप किसे हटने के लिए कह रहे है? मेरे इस भौतिक शरीर को या मेरे अंदर जो जीवात्मा है उसे? " जब सबके अंदर जो जीवात्मा है वो ईश्वर मे सम्मिलित होने वाली है; जिसमे ईश्वर भी भेदभाव नहीं करते, तो आप कौन होते है भेदभाव करने वाले? एक सनातनी होते हुए लज्जा आती है की आप जैसा व्यक्ति शंकराचार्य के पवित्र पद पर विराजमान है ! यह उस पद की गरिमा का अपमान है ! अगर आप जैसी सोच रखने वालों के हाथों मे सनातन धर्म की कमान है तो एक शंकराचार्य होते हुए भी आप इस धर्म को बचा नहीं पाएंगे ! और आपका ये घमंड एक दिन आपको ले डूबेगा ये याद रखना !

[@kantiprakashjaiswal7264]

Har Har Mahadev Guru Ji 🙏🙏

[@nikhiltiwari268]

Pranaam gurudev ji

[@dinanathdixit4906]

फिर भी मनुष्यो में तो भेद ईश्वर ने नही बनाया है।सभी मनुष्य एक जैसे बने है जबकि अन्य भेद ईश्वर ने बनाए है।

[@uuserwxyz]

हर हर शंकर जय जय शंकर

[@RoushanKumar-rk6jc]

Ekdum shi

[@rakaghosh5780]

Confusing.... outdated