Grading the Entire 2024 NFL Draft First Round (One Year Later)

[@kylek1742]

Quinyon Mitchell getting a C is unbelievable lmao

[@mikelong2499]

Yeah like come on. Tell me you dont watch eagles games without telling me you dont watch eagles games

[@humaamsaid3282]

His coverage grades are really good too. "C" grade but he's 2nd in DROY odds...

[@TROOPJONESTV]

Same shit I said, C for Quinyonamo Bay is craazzyyy

[@AngelDay1101]

Can't even view the video with knowing that

[@MacTV303]

And his homie LB from Missouri, he gave a B+ or something and dude barely played 😂

[@Breezzee007]

this is a bad video , you clearly didn’t watch any film on most of the picks , quinyon is clearly the best corner in the draft and gonna be one of the best in the league, you stat watched and haven’t seen him play

[@Cdanto95]

No offense dude I usually love your videos but I’d delete this one lol

[@Matt-s6y]

This video must have been rushed or something. Take time to actually study the film, quality over quantity

[@neddyy7603]

Drake Maye is constantly getting praised for doing what hes doing with no help. I may be biased as a pats fan but he looks really good and would do amazing with actual weapons

[@tyleradams285]

Crazy how you'll say someone doesn't get playing time and they get a B minus grade and then the next player that doesn't get playing time is a letdown to get the C grade. The bias is crazy.

[@chanchoaf]

Facts

[@chopsgfx]

I love your content, but this one ain’t it. Almost ALL of these are completely wrong.

[@skolprod.]

Not even a Falcons fan but that Penix grade is terrible easily should be B+ He came into a situation out of nowhere and looked great, you’re just looking at the box score and not the film, 2 of the 3 picks were not his fault and he led multiple 2 minute drills to perfection. The deep ball was there too He put ATL in a position to win every game but their defense was terrible Please watch the film and reconsider this because he did all he could

[@KwongEdits204]

So true

[@jcruz8458]

I think penix isn’t bad but it’s everything that has to do with Atlantas management of the franchise. the fact that falcons drafted him didn’t even play him was bad He’s 24 year old rookie not 21 so him waiting behind to learn ball seems kinda dumb at this point in his development he should’ve just been playing. Add to the fact that Kirk cousins has a 4 year deal which negates the positive of a rookie qb contract. The falcons probably set their franchise back with that decision making of either drafting penix or signing Kirk. Or both honestly

[@gandalftheghetto1172]

Penix also didn't play a full season

[@cooperg332]

Exactly, he would’ve probably won all three games if the coaches could manage properly or if the coin toss went our way. Also, all 3 of the picks were not his fault; two were bobbled and one was the receiver running the wrong route on a spot throw.

[@jkjkISHIM]

Penix was far and away the worst rookie QB. Milton’s even better

[@gregfaller1814]

I hate to beat a dead horse, but there are a number of takes and statistics on here that are...not great, in my opinion. Giving such low grades to Drake Maye, Quinyon Mitchell, Terrion Arnold, Olu Fashanu, and Graham Barton kinda shows that you didn't watch any tape or games of them. Not gonna harp on this too much, but this definitely seemed a bit rushed. Still dig your content tho. PS: Terrion Arnold had 10 passes defended, not 8 :)

[@jd__9389]

With all due respect maye getting a C and Caleb getting a B is ABSURD

[@LionsWingsTigers]

Lions fan, but Quinyon should easily have a higher grade than Arnold right now.

[@AnthonyKingggg]

Lol scott I love you but stick to college football

[@toddwinegar7365]

I give Scott Fisher a D on this video! Lack of thorough study giving us mostly pro-focus grade and the box score as a way of grading, clearly just thrown together with no in depth analysis! This was a really good rookie class but way too early ! Always appreciate the content

[@IVORYSPANDEX]

No it was pretty spot on. You just salty your player didn't get graded higher

[@toddwinegar7365]

🤣🤣🤣 I don't have a ( guy )! So what now? Botox

[@crashdavis8431]

Bias eagles fan here but Quinyon was arguably one of the best CBs in the league.

[@Chris-hz3bt]

As a Rans fan Jared Verse was the steal of the draft.

[@tyjustforcoreyonsports9872]

He technically not because he a first round pick but I understand what you saying

[@gandalftheghetto1172]

A steal can't be a first round pick bro

[@laniack1232]

Ngl Scott your vids are normally great but this one ain’t it do some more research before you make a video like this it makes your ball knowledge look a little fraudulent

[@NorrisGOD]

Buddy really tried to talk as if he watched any tape on Penix lmao. “Didn’t play any better than Kirk did” “Offense wasn’t really suited for him”. What that offense thrived behind him and 2 of the 3 pick literally left out of the receivers hands into the defenders. And the 3 was miscommunication on the WR. Either way at most 1 is actually on him. And the way they lost both games…do your research before making a video sir. Do your journalistic due diligence

[@EandCsHouseofHorrors]

Yeah, the C grade for Quinyon tells me all I need to know. Bad video

[@masonaltman6227]

Scott, I’ve been watching your content for years and this would be the first video I would consider bad. It’s clear that some of these players you haven’t watched all year, especially Arnold and Mitchell. I do believe you will bounce back but maybe stat away from NFL content unless you’re going to put the research you put in for college football. Love your channel dude promise it’s all love!

[@mikelong2499]

Nate Wiggins was the third corner

[@jasonfox7308]

Brian Daboll was retained by the Giants, not fired

[@norfillyson]

Quinyon gets a C??? Are you CrazyyyYy?

[@donovanjones4838]

Nate Wiggins gets an A for me as a ravens fan. Hasn’t given up many big plays and we don’t have to worry about him as a liability. He makes big time plays, tackles well and cover very well. Our only liability on defense is Brandon Stephen the veteran CB on the other side of Nate. That says a lot considering he’s a rookie. The whole NFL targets Stephans and not Wiggins and Humphrey

[@BiggieAEnjoyer69]

He’s been solid and shut down in run d but has been toasted a few times defo at least a B

[@donovanjones4838]

@ dBs are gonna get beat, it’s about how often and how bad. He did very well for his rookie season

[@wondermcthunder8835]

This video confirms Scott is actually just A.I.

[@rogp2208]

Caleb Williams getting a B is beyond laughable

[@flameosaurus1832]

He was a C- at best

[@dishantithomas4198]

While being on a worse team his and Jayden Daniels stats are pretty much identical. Given him anything less than a B is disingenuous at best and stupid at worst

[@jasonj5292]

@@dishantithomas4198 Caleb has all the help a rookie qb could ask for. He's just not that insane.

[@Hbdowntown]

@@jasonj5292except an oline

[@dishantithomas4198]

​@@jasonj5292The bears definitely have a worse o line while they aren't outright terrible. They have the highest sack rate in the league for a reason . They had a bottom six or even a bottom eight defense They also probably had the the worst Head coach in the league. Before someone brings it up, I am neither a bears fan nor a Williams fan, but it is DISINGENUOUS to give him anything below a B/B- given his circumstance, especially when his numbers are identical to the man who's probably going to win rookie of the Year

[@ripdippy6964]

Scott these might be some of the weirdest takes in a video I’ve seen you have

[@mattswormstedt7346]

Did you watch any Patriots football?!?!

[@grayharris672]

Wiggins did get a pick 6 in the playoffs

[@labsports2943]

Brandon Stephen’s is who you think Nate Wiggins has been

[@justinsaehoon]

This objectively bad

[@hannibalsmith-zu3vq]

When did the Giants fire their coach?

[@Chris-hz3bt]

After tonight's game Sam Darnold is gone!!

[@JohnORatcliffe]

Your take on Harrison Jr is awful. He's on a team that actually has other weapons. My God you're take is trash

[@gandalftheghetto1172]

There aren't any high end weapons on Arizona's roster

[@laniack1232]

I get what your saying but that’s not the reason he underperformed it’s because the Cardinals were running the ball significantly more than passing it

[@MichSlam]

Do a what happened to Agiye Hall Video he went from playing in the playoffs as a true freshman at Alabama to playing in the FCS

[@itsquan10k]

Great video!!!

[@vanderbiltalexsingleton2041]

You never gave JC a grade

[@bingobongo8701]

When you gave drake maye a c i immediately knew you looked at stats and dont watch games, i like your channel but this is a really bad video, same with the quinyon Mitchell rating

[@Ifukyobish]

I disagree with Quinyon Mitchell he should atleast get a B or A cus without him the Eagles D would get lit up … but almost everybody get a B .. if it wasn’t for Jared verse he would got RDOPY 😂😂😂

[@IVORYSPANDEX]

Jayden Daniels ROTY by far

[@damar9892]

Bro you don’t watch any film wtf Nate Wiggins did pretty good for his rookie year

[@corrupt-9534]

Yeahhh, no.

[@the1magageneral323]

Caleb Williams C- he is inaccurate as Bill Belichick has said.

[@davidrichardson3582]

Stats for btj are wrong buddy 😮

[@Dizzy_Hotwheelz]

Yeah stick to college buddy you aint ready for the big leagues yet young blud

[@Calinons]

Drake Maye C? Do some research.

[@Zot8kk]

Stick to college bro 😂🙏🏾

[@derektremblay794]

you deserve all the hate in the world for this video, just say you dont know ball, drake maye is an easy A

[@robertstandley8580]

I have been around football for over sixty years. Normally I agree with you, but on this video I think your grades were very inconsistent. Especially in the lower half of the draft, I am old and this is just my opinion.😊😊😊😮😮😊😊😊😊😊

[@jaymoskey2145]

Nah bro this ain’t it

[@josephmedlin6734]

Joe alt played 16 games dude all but one, not a good video at all stick to college

[@the1magageneral323]

Caleb Williams is a major problem and why the OL looks bad(68 sacks yes I did the math again). As the video shows that 1, 2,3 plus Kmett wide open on the play and can’t hit Kmett for the 1st down. So how is that a bot move because I don’t go along with the corporate press psyop narrative to protect the black QB hype Fields and Caleb. This mess as Joneth Piptne stated “the Bears will regret getting rid of Tribusky. I am not soft, nor is anyone here even Mister Truth because that last game ever since firing the head coach mid season has been on a lot of people at the top even Caleb which I think was the point of his video. Do you have any video or articles about the training camps because nobody else, but you knew about the Caleb Sweat drama. A lot of players hate this drama queen Caleb.

[@notyahir2186]

stick to college football buddy

[@pjconlan4580]

Terrible analysis

[@haywoodalexander8733]

Yeah bro this your worst vid

[@dillavedderx5959]

I'm a Bears fan and I gave him a B too, kid took a beating some mistakes his but a lot of everything else wrong around him. He gotta use his god-given gifts more.... his legs!!!! His legs would have taken that pressure away. 👊🐻👇

[@popjibbletz]

No He was much worse than a B. Dude had a better offense than every other rookie QB and played the worst out of all of them.

[@melterrell5724]

I think Ladd McConkey is better than Malik Nabers

[@gandalftheghetto1172]

He's not but why do you think that

[@laniack1232]

If Malik had Justin Herbert he’d be second in receiving yards

[@EMLeth]

I feel like anyone could show to be better than someome on the giants right now

[@Dizzy_Hotwheelz]

Troll