GREENVILLE vs ER:LC vs SOUTHWEST FLORIDA! (THE ULTIMATE COMPARISON)

[@toddaustin449]

The thing with SouthWest Florida, it's pretty much accurate to the Southwest part of Florida, was down in Cape Coral for the summer(wasn't great timing b/c of a tropical storm), minus the lack of gun shops and legal U-turn signs

[@russianguylul3877]

Greenville is accurate to greenville.

[@RandomHibee1875]

@@russianguylul3877 yeah it id

[@formality_26]

@i frozon it actually does

[@thedarkknight5239]

@i frozon Greenville is in South Carolina too

[@HoldenBTW]

Same I was just down 5erefor chirstmas

[@Slayyyter_bitxh]

Honestly erlc is forever my favorite as the community and the server customization is just outstanding along with all of the rp physics

[@riyamykid6795]

same

[@erikwoods2298]

^

[@LiIAxe]

Just wish I could play it on mobile so now I have to stick with Greenville

[@dk4kja8]

@@LiIAxe Guess what? They released it for mobile!!!

[@gvxswfl9555]

I like how ERLC partners with GV like merging cars so since gv started supporting erlc i now play erlc!

[@chrisjensen9121]

It is so much more confusing to me. Cause I am used to cars in general.

[@cranapplegemz]

You look like regular beluga. Well…. Your profile pic dpes

[@Shauny12]

Are you talking about how er lc uses the Greenville car names

[@BLASTCREDULITY]

@@Shauny12 they partnerd

[@role_f1]

@@chrisjensen9121 its not that confusing if your OG YOU should know a car name right when you see it the popular ones if your OG

[@Jay-wv2pm]

I think southwest Florida and Greenville are kinda the same. It’s one of those games that are realistic

[@connercooper141]

greenville is so much better

[@voidy_yt]

@@connercooper141 nah swf gets a big fat w

[@connercooper141]

@@voidy_yt nnah nah nah

[@connercooper141]

@@voidy_yt im not saying its bad

[@Nil3107]

Southwest Florida its map is kinda easy but the way you have to find them is not easy and vehicle physics are dumb still in 2022 but Greenville is my favorite and the fact is that Greenville's map is almost the same as the real Greenville in SC.

[@fruityhangout5940]

ER:LC is my favourite because it’s the first one out of these that I’ve played. Also, I feel like it’s easy to get use to and I like the map style.

[@Jackplays269]

Same

[@EpicGamer53YT]

I agree

[@PredictableCookie]

I was playing Greenville everyday for like a year but it got boring so I moved onto Liberty County, Greenville is a good game but in my opinion it needs more buildings on the highway and stuff like that. I don't really like how you have to press e and d to drive on SWFL and its needs more buildings, like I said for Greenville. I really like Liberty County's map size because it's tiny but there's a lot of things that you can do and I also like that there's not many jobs because it's less crowded.

[@marochamx]

Well the “e and d” thing is realistic gear shifting so idk what to say, however it’s just your opinion. I agree with the buildings though, Greenville and SWFL’s roads are just dead.

[@Justarandomchineseguy]

They're trying to match the real life counterpart but they should at least add the city of Appleton since the road to Appleton is empty

[@zachplayz5183]

Greenville gampasses trash

[@marochamx]

@@zachplayz5183 I’d just say overpriced. 500 robux for sport vehicles is a bit too much.

[@the.redditman1]

Greenvillle is like that bc greenville irl is like that

[@Sweet0nion]

Something I don’t like in erlc is that you can’t upgrade the engine of the style of the car. It only lets you paint and change the name and design of your license plate.

[@chasethecarguy]

You cant in any of the 3 games. They are fully stock. But the thing for me about the ER:LC community is that they are in general annoying. The game has good elements but the game could be redone, especially as the car sounds are literally unchanged.

[@role_f1]

and also whats the point it would just make you faster and would be like the amount of a cheap car in erlc

[@sybsygstgstsgysg5330]

@@chasethecarguy and the Greenville community is made up of brats who complain when they don’t get a new update everyday. And the erlc community was angry about the car names changing because of copyright. Everybody else made the change a year before they did and nobody cared, but apparently they are more important then everybody else and can’t make the change so there gonna quit

[@M120_r1ing]

bruh exactly they should add one like the acceleration turbo and a spoiler designs and exhausts I don't know if they're gonna add it soon in the future Edit: They should add more like the engine sounds and the car sounds Ik they changed it for the GTR and the corvette idk what else since I have those they changed the buggati engine sounds aswell

[@Imbored__2921]

Now you can upgrade in southwest Florida

[@quoteus8006]

The thing about Greenville and southwest Florida is that southwest Florida doesn't have different trims let's say you want to buy a charger you can only get the hellcat version but in Greenville you can get all kinds of charger trims like real life.

[@SSquidFishh0]

Here's my opinions on the games. I've played a lot of each. Southwest. Pros: - the map is a nice size, although some of it is sort of repetitive. - the cars have really nice sounds for the most part. - the robberies are pretty easy and sort of fun. - there's a nice selection of cars, and none of them cost robux, which is nice. - there is a lot of jobs, though some are more popular than others. - the cars actually feel different to drive, and look fairly realistic. Cons: - the AI cars are very low quality - the bushes, "trees", etc are very low quality - there is a lot of fail roleplayers in a roleplay based game Overall rating: 7/10 Greenville. Pros: - there is very high quality cars ( AI aswell) map, buildings, etc. - there is TONS of cars. - the map is huge. - there is a lot of good roleplayers (for the most part) (Theres more but I'm too lazy to add them) Cons: - some jobs are a bit repetitive, even interactable ones. - the map is big but has too much extra space. - the game is a bit dead. Overall rating: 9/10 Lastly, ERLC pros: - the jobs feel very well thought out and realistic - there can be pretty fun rps sometimes. - robberies are a bit difficult, making it more realistic. Cons: - tons of fail rps, no matter what server you're in. - the game gets very boring after a while since there's not really anything special to do. - the map is extremely small - the cars aren't the best quality imo. Overall rating: 8/10. I love all these games, all for different reasons, but I have to say Greenville is my favourite. I apologize for how long this comment is lol.

[@arliemoncrieff]

I agree

[@pickleboi5548]

The update quantity isn't that bad for erlc. They update every 2 weeks.

[@iramsheheryar6704]

Agreed the updates are pretty big and in my opinion its not the quantity of the updates that matter but the quality. Erlc's updates are always very high quality and I like that a lot.

[@nikhilrishi.s6820]

Southwest florida is also updated every 2 weeks and it's nice too. I agree that

[@Makon112]

The GV updates are ok I guess they go for quality over quantity bc the last update was 56 new cars which is INSANE and the updates are really high quality

[@Ow3nW]

@@iramsheheryar6704 this didn't age well

[@dorianjf07]

Greenville was recently updated with phase 1 of interactive jobs like 2 days after this video came out.

[@PemnaGaming]

The thing with Greenville is that is is based off of a real town in Wisconsin called well, Greenville andit is pretty on point from Google maps/earth from what i can see.

[@isaaccollazo2874]

Yeah greenville players like realism thats why they play the game

[@aidenjoel6147]

Amazing!

[@zzainz]

This is really really relatable! For Greenville, I thought I was the only one not knowing where the map is and all that type of stuff so now after watching your video I feel like I am a normal dude. lol

[@Fabbe_labbe_]

But grenville added 52 cars recently. And we had a Huge update! With first person view in cabriolet. And we have 3d wheels at the tires + and you can now work interactive jobs

[@zadok1427]

I feel like the map size being small is actually pretty good because of the roleplay and if I was to make it bigger I would only make it like 1.5x bigger that's why I perfer erlc over SW Florida because in SWF you need like friends for roleplays because you would barely see anyone because of the map size and I don't have any friends so I just join roleplay servers on erlc

[@coastercloudy]

I like a amaller map i can rp traffic

[@sybsygstgstsgysg5330]

The old swfl map was great it was a perfect size and the plants could actually be detailed. But they revamped the map to make it look like real life

[@charlie1793]

I love the map size

[@greenpill86]

Yeah, or just make it a 100 player server

[@sybsygstgstsgysg5330]

@@greenpill86 imagine the lag

[@coolcat-nq4mj]

5:27 that's no roblox issue, it's the devs made it so it can run smoothly, if the whole map is loaded then it's unplayable

[@ms55_]

Finally someone who understands

[@OurLifePillsbury]

ERLC, Southwest Florida then Greenville and all are my favorites but this is them in order in my opinion

[@S0M30N31_y]

My opinion My favorite: Greenville Sec favorite:ERLC I dont like:SWFL cause for me the map takes 3-4 hours to load im not even lying

[@Ryder___mus]

@@S0M30N31_y maby it is your internet?

[@S0M30N31_y]

@@Ryder___mus no, it's very fast but swfl doesn't load

[@Ryder___mus]

@@S0M30N31_y oh ok 😃

[@S0M30N31_y]

@@Ryder___mus have a great rest of day or night

[@iramsheheryar6704]

YES I was waiting for something like this from my favorite youtuber. Great video amaze even though you are an ER:LC youtuber and you like that game very much you still told all the faults of the game with complete honesty. I really enjoyed this. Thank you amaze for this great video. BTW I hope you can get to 50K subscribers by the end of this month you really deserve it.

[@Shauny12]

Greenville: Nah 0/10 Southwest Florida: eh 9.5/10 ER:LC: YES BOII 100/10

[@kodygamer2126]

I just like to say that I love these 3 games because it's awesome, it's fun and it's epik

[@nickicash4454]

I am a HD for SWF and thank you for how we can update the game. We really appreciate when content creates and youtube give us opinions on how we can make SWF a better game.

[@bcscodecatcher]

i love ur game

[@LiIAxe]

No your not lmao

[@Astrogamezz]

Bruh maybe if u had actual grammar we would believe u, but your spelling is equivalent to a 9yr old..

[@arandomuser102]

@@LiIAxehow would you know

[@dozensofeggs1608]

I remember when I first joined Greenville a year ago I thought the map was hard to learn but then I figured it out in like a week.

[@IMX383]

Same

[@ghostx6514]

Same

[@bizi4097]

In my opinion, yes the 3D wheels are AMAZING on ERLC however I would say the car designs look really “robloxy” unlike southwest florida. They just don’t look realistic aswell.

[@Michyosef]

My favorite Is Erlc, i play it for the longest time, i love the police team on it and in second place is southwest Florida, third is greenville

[@HelloItzJah]

Good video for people that are new and are trying to find role play games

[@kiwitripreportsofficial]

18:13 how long would it take if you followed all the road rules and speed limits and actually stopped at stop signs?

[@Michyosef]

1-3 minutes

[@pickle690]

Too long because I swear, the traffic lights hate me

[@russianguylul3877]

Dude how long would it take you to follow every rule in gv?

[@Pikiks]

I follow all road rules in ER:LC

[@Wolfwarrior-xs9fh]

@@Pikiks When I'm a cop, you are my kind of guy lol

[@collateral622]

I wish ERLC added small things like brake lights or backup lights.

[@role_f1]

yeah it would be a small cool feature

[@cheez1012]

Idk if map size is good for all players... before the revamped the southwest, the map was relatively compact (how I liked it) and now, its too big (imo, and pair that with relatively large server sizes don't help at all) and really laggy for lower end devices, so for me, that isn't really a good thing ._. Maybe mention things about car detail, suspension, radio, car customization and other minor details too?

[@Moon-tr4zk]

Sounds like. A. You. Problem😂😂💀💀💀 I’m JOKING 🙃

[@Charlie-fg4fq]

Hey I love your vids I just joined. Your Roblox group and bought the new merch you AMAZEing

[@TrendyBanana]

Amaze: Trying to explain ER:LC`s good aspects The whole fricking server for some reason: CHAOS

[@fadedzerox]

Amaze there is one game that u need to check out. It’s called Pacifico 2 it has litterly great animations and many RP jobs

[@jakethesnakelovesbikes5048]

Hi amze ur the best utuber love ur content always keep ur head up

[@marochamx]

I also like southwest Florida because it’s not hard to get a lot of money, and the cars can be pretty affordable. Greenville’s map is a bit too big and there are a ton of unused parts of the map, but the vehicle customization before you buy and after is really good. Erlc isn’t too realistic, but it makes it easier to drive for beginners. If you were to combine Southwest Florida’s ways of money earning, car names, getting gas, job selection, map size, detail, graphics, and combine it with ERLC’s teams, traffic cameras, rp jobs, gun selections, and call signs, and add it with Greenville’s cruise control, wheel customization (as well as swfl’s), License plate state customization with names, and the settings, You get the perfect game. Great video

[@PTJStudios18]

Southwest Florida’s detail sucks except for cars which don’t look the best and the map sucks

[@the.redditman1]

Southwest florida's map is about the same size as greenville's though

[@PTJStudios18]

@@the.redditman1 yes but I do think Greenville did better then southwest Florida with detail but erlc has the best detail

[@the.redditman1]

@@PTJStudios18 I've only ever played erlc once

[@PTJStudios18]

@@the.redditman1 and do I care

[@isaaccollazo2874]

Erlc map looks like if a child made it is just tic-tac-toe lines

[@robloxlad8544]

When he said really nice fires for ERLC I was like WHAT for a second and then I realised what he meant

[@samanthamilam6027]

Southwest florida it really good i think it may be the best because they stillmput a lot of detail while you can play it on mobile or pc the updates the map size also i live in florida and looks like florida the license plates are the same but also how cheap gamepasses are in southwest florida you also dont need gamepasses for cars you can play the game and still have fun with no gamepasses Ive been playing SWFL since revamp and i think its amazing

[@haydenburton584]

In Southwest Florida, I feel like there are not enough opportunities in jobs like firefighters. In ERLC, you can have a lot of fire trucks and a variety of calls, whereas with Southwest Florida ther is only structure fires and 3 to 4 fire vehicles.

[@rickrolled7877]

In southwest there is a fire like every 5 seconds XD

[@nerfnightwitch]

@@rickrolled7877 true.

[@AsianJP910]

For ERLC I feel like the RP is more serious which is very good if your into those

[@moh.reh__]

I wish There was a different island in erlc like a bridge over an ocean connecting all together it would be sooooo coooool

[@Boypogikami132]

Theory of Land Bridges?

[@HopperDylan_YT]

My favorite is emergency response liberty county

[@monster2230]

You always make amazing vid bro.

[@shitpostWJ]

Please do another video like this! Maybe it could include: FSRP Leon County, Berkley County, and Hillview County (or UK:RC Redwood county if you want), but once again please do another video like this! Also here is my opinion: 1. Emergency Response: Liberty County 2. Berkley County, Concord 3. Hillview County RP 4. Greenville 5. FSRP Leon County/Southwest Florida

[@theonepup8022]

The thing they can do to improve the map in erlc is if they surround the map with a a beach so it doesn’t look like a floating island

[@francisconahuel5996]

I like Greenville better, because in the Mobil version it doesn't weigh as much as Liberty County and Southwest Florida

[@ashfaqabbasi3874]

i think the good thing about er:lc is that, unlike greenville or swfl which have a main road which is very very commonly used, er:lc has twists and turn so there isn't one place other than spawn you can find people at, also swfl i am not sure but i think it gets a update about every week or 2

[@JoshuaMoran27]

I hate big maps because if the game dont have 100 players per server you will never find someone at the game

[@rodrigocorreia4958]

I just joined Southwest Florida and they added 15 new vehicles already. Anyways my favourite rp game is ERLC I also like Southwest Florida but yea. Nice video btw.

[@Pug46YT]

I played all the games and I think ERLC is the best but since it was made free a lot of little kids play the game and if you have played before it was free then you’d understand

[@TypicalYoutuber1]

So Greenville is actually better in July they remade the dealer added phones and they add more content now

[@Bossuncertified]

erlc is a more strict and serious rp game and even if you just random kill someone you will get banned

[@_coco_27]

Gv just had a huge update, and I think after it would raise it like 2 stars.

[@urfavouritelittlerat]

maybe 4

[@uh5382]

I think if you like play some game about police or emergency you can play ER:LC ,that did the good detail at the police car (for me)

[@marctugk2966]

Greenville deserve more points I love greenville I do love southwest florida too but greenville give some support it’s a nicely well made game

[@ChefMcToastEM]

Greenville is my favourite realism wise. There’s a lot of well coded physics.

[@TorontoClimbs]

ummm no the physics part is terrible

[@Lucurious]

@@TorontoClimbs Which are?

[@TorontoClimbs]

@@Lucurious the crashing physics...

[@Lucurious]

@@TorontoClimbs None of those games have realistic crashing physics...

[@thomasdavis4334]

What keyboard do you have

[@chrisjensen9121]

This got me thinking to switch but I’m commander or Erlc so I’m staying

[@nicoleyvonneribbecksayles1627]

My favorite is ERLC!

[@akhileshbhardwaj2323]

Yo in fl beta we also can’t choose our gun there is no gun shop

[@ultra6139]

My favourite one is ERLC, I think it should be ranked as the best game of Roblox. Whatever it has a little map, (the map can be zoomed in ERLC, now) whatever it has a little amount of cars. I love this game.

[@Lukewrld0417]

E-R L-C is the worst in my opinion. I think your being very nice to ER-LC because you play it a lot.

[@thatmansam144]

You should play a Roblox game, almost like GV, called Ultimate Driving: Westover Islands, there are others like Delancy Gorge and Odessa but they don't get updated anymore, Delancy Gorge was my Favorite!

[@Roosevelt984]

In my opinion I would go southwest Florida, erlc, and then gv

[@TheBigEt20]

ERLC is just like GTA online but much more simpler and is inside of Roblox Lmao

[@undermix8283]

Southwest Florida has one thing that really stops me from playing it. That is the fact that emergency services are able to buy ordinary cars to use on patrol and/or responding to a fire. I'll be pulling some supercar over then they hop out of the car and act like they can't be pulled over because they're a cop. Half the police are just driving supercars around not actually policing until a robbery happens.

[@nerfnightwitch]

yeah. 90% of cops dont use their actual cop cars. its because they want to get money and dont actually rp as a cop.

[@role_f1]

@@nerfnightwitch well i go on police team mainly to RP as a civillian as i get money overtime but somestimes i do RP as a actua cop

[@Hambotty]

I just started southwest florida and do like it super much an afk grind for hours xD but yeh now its one of my fav games

[@ayden7382]

I bought your merch in roblox and its fireeeeeee

[@BassRab]

There are alot of cars in ERLC. Specialy the fact that al of them are highly detailed

[@KoolrunsJr]

Yeah, he kept going on about how SouthWest Florida got 17 new vehicles when there clearly lower quality & are based on a simpler chassis compared to the one in erlc

[@BassRab]

@@KoolrunsJr yeah

[@hypermusiic]

Something I like about ER:LC is the police lights, if you have them on full and have headlights on they change It’s just my opinion though :)

[@Name-bt6lu]

Greenville have the same feature.

[@maxwellchristopher1568]

PLEASE DO A REMAKE

[@reynjamesdelacruz8121]

Greenville has Good cars and more realistic chassis and alot of cars for people that say swfl and erlc is better because GV requires gamepass for supercars or other cars but its understandable Greenville requires gamepass for luxury cars because it isnt common to see supercars everywhere you go in a small town it also makes GV more realistic

[@role_f1]

yeah but then the non-gamepass cars are literally like cars from the 90s you dont see 90s cars in a mordern town do you?

[@Nexus104]

@@role_f1 theres like tons of new freepass cars like toyotas, hyundais, nissans, chrysler sedans, vws, some audis, some bmws,, some mercs, fords, etc

[@role_f1]

@@Nexus104 yeah but still they are like the old ones and in my opinion i dont really like the designs

[@Nexus104]

@@role_f1 i don't understand what you meant by "new onrd are like old ones" And for the designs, you asked for modern cars, those are modern cars

[@thefallenlettuce2797]

Greenville is a real place in Wisconsin. Those of you saying the map is unused should look it up. It's a country town and you cant just wish in more buildings.

[@rafiqstarline]

Greenvile have a map on the phone, but it wasn't released when this video was uploaded.

[@clowds7]

Did you make the outro music? Because i really like it can you send me a link to the full song? And your videos are the BEST.

[@cameronbleakley3882]

Wow love it

[@KamPlays]

pro

[@hiimsmrt9663]

My favourite is ERLC as it’s not as laggy as other 2

[@Diego_Gar]

Bruh, the controls of ERLC are so laggy

[@Diego_Gar]

If you're laggy in Greenville and Southwesth Florida is because your pc or phone is bad

[@hiimsmrt9663]

@@Diego_Gar ik, they are laggy on mobile. My ipad also lags.

[@hiimsmrt9663]

@@Diego_Gar I used to not lag but I start lagging after upgrading my software.

[@monkey_handler]

@@Diego_Gar I play on Xbox I lag on gv and on southwest Florida but it depends on if I switch cross play

[@jj.g233]

Amaze, you can still get money from jobs in Greenville you can get paychecks from jobs

[@NathansTransportCommuntiy]

In my personal opinion my most favourite role play game for roblox is Fallin Scotland aka Stirling Scotland

[@Wolfwarrior-xs9fh]

"Just like a real reporter, always getting in the way" Yep, news and DOT workers are the bane of my police existence in ERLC.

[@Prodby_m]

You've put these 3 together but you gotta do one with these 3 and Berkeley County

[@tuners_r]

Southwest Florida is more to civilian game. ERLC is more to police game. Greenville is more like Southwest Florida too but u have to pay BOBUX to buy the supercars gamepass, electric gamepass and more. I think the best game is Southwest Florida and ERLC

[@iramsheheryar6704]

I never enjoyed greenville but i really liked southwest florida and erlc

[@codmplayz7548]

Bugok

[@MarcusPig24]

The thing I don’t like about Southwest Florida is that when I was new,I keep getting lost and can’t even find the dealer when I’m police.

[@shadow-146]

To be honest the reason I think it tastes down for update or they don't really do more more stuff and update is because the amount of detail that have to put in which takes really really long for them to do it

[@TheLifeofLogan]

My order of favorite rp games is: Greenville, Southwest Floridia, and ERLC

[@electrodragonyt1217]

Please amaze Play Pilot training simulator You won't regret it please btw its a plane simulator technically theres a variety of planes and random things like blimps, parastrikes, and a hot air balloon and a walrus which is really really fast

[@trugamer8489]

The detail in the jobs in emergency response liberty is very detailed cops can pull people over give tickets arrest you name it dot have duties like clean up the road repair fix car tires tow cars you name it firefighters go out put out fires and even revive players although I feel like they should make firefighter and ambulance into 2 different classes only because it kinda throws the Emerson off imo like literally every job actually does what it says it is. Emergency response has 100/10 although map is small and it could use a bit more for the pvp area but I love this game overall.

[@wi1234ll]

Southwest Florida 8.5 / 10 Greenville 10 / 10 it’s incredible Emergency response liberty county 4 / 10 just weird you get police team for free why?

[@ghxst_j]

Here are mines opinion on the rate. THIS IS ONLY MY OPINION ty. SWFL:8.2 / 10 Greenville:6:4 / 10 Only reason is bc its like P2W ER:LC: 9.2 /10 good rp as in T3 servers and private Servers.

[@sniper_mike8739]

The car options are really good

[@panthonisz]

The thing I don’t like about Greenville is for the good, fun cars you have to buy a gamepass

[@Nexus104]

fun cars? all the cars are fine

[@urfavouritelittlerat]

i don't get you

[@InsightMotivation247]

‘A different place’ Erlc: How about a bank and restaurant

[@Recenthandle]

Nice video amaze I agree

[@SupremeStreams]

SWF all the way bro!!!

[@AaronsVlogTube]

Greenville is better for me like in the new update there is interactive jobs! Amazing for rp and also car interiors!!!! Also 56 new cars

[@grandelegends7637]

For SWFL the loctaion markers can help you sinse it is so big and if u press (crtl+c = free cam) and you do not have to be in a private server

[@WolfieSixteen]

1:53 kamplays: vans me: honda oddesy

[@-j1-_]

Nice Video! I wanna ask: What platform you have? Wheel? Console? Only these can do limited speed.

[@l_t_ry.z___k.6304]

I can't believe you said this before the greeville update

[@Recenthandle]

I agree with you but I can't play southwest Florida well on ipad cuz I'm laggy so I think erlc is best for me

[@sowsow6677]

I think southwest Florida has the biggest map, kinda like an big open city world feel, but erlc comes in first for me because of the code