國外聲樂老師點評 單依純《永不失聯的愛》Vocal Coach Reaction to Shan Yichun's initial stage on The Voice of China

[@terrylee4542]

單依純是近期除了周深之外，唯一讓我關注的歌手，那種娓娓道來的細膩情感，真的很難相信當時她才18歲，前途不可限量。

[@林停雲]

我也是。从好声音就喜欢她了

[@答案-s4y]

这两个人的共通点，自带鼻子伴奏，音准，清唱好听，会的风格多，戏曲，美声。

[@ckck4141]

那最近有个综艺节目你要看了，这个节目包含了他们两个人

[@flylai4835]

近十年最驚艷我的兩個聲音 周深 单依純 希望老師能多做她的視頻 例如別問很可怕

[@lawranceto168]

單依純的歌值得慢慢聽 我認為，她不是爆發型的，是耐聽的，走的遠的。 她選歌跟唱歌都滿有品味的!

[@317greenleaf]

好美的聲音... 好乾淨 輕柔的同時又有厚度 不會很單薄 同時又很放鬆 聽起來很舒服 抖音轉音真假音轉換都很漂亮 紮實的基本功搭配有層次的變化 超羨慕能有這樣的技巧🥲

[@lotusTV555]

單依純是目前這十幾年來聽到最棒的女聲，乾淨、純粹、情感豐富。

[@nathaliechien5564]

真的

[@jksiajksia981]

我也是刚刚注意到这位小女生。唱功、细腻度、诠释能力，都属于上乘。希望往后有属于她自己的代表作。

[@HuiyiXi]

这唱功无敌

[@leo78915]

那是剛好挑的這首歌還算好聽!挑到難聽的歌再會唱的人都無法挽救!她的聲音唱功都算不錯!可是有一個致命傷，她的聲音美歸美，但缺少辯識度!太多網紅歌唱都屬於這種聲線的!妳的歌聲跟大家放在一起大家不太有印象!再來就是挑選的作品能不能給大家察覺到一個很明顯屬於妳自己特色的記憶點!大家能不能對妳唱的東西起共鳴!而且這樣的共鳴必須很一致性!這樣妳才有可能紅的起來

[@chowjiayi1644]

@@leo78915 那你可以看她的作品，其实旋律简单但是很难唱的像她那么细腻，他比赛是唱冷门的歌曲都可以那么动听其实不容易

[@jingzhang9825]

终于等到了 好紧张 像听老师给自己的女儿打分 纯纯得了A！我会庆祝的！ 谢谢老师 谢谢助理！

[@adriannelcy710]

歌聽得舒服😊 老師真的很實誠的人，喜歡不喜歡，有疑問，有驚喜，全在臉上，太可愛了！！❤

[@luislee8364]

非常同意 我也是被她的第一句打動 超越年齡的感染力 very impressive～ she won the champion bc she sings from the heart and expresses true emotion~ she has rich techniques in her toolbox but touches my heart in a raw & natural way~~ 她是天賦異稟的音樂生 成長中的新聲代主力歌手 並擁有無限可能～❤️

[@hemmahoable]

還有她那個正在尋找的眼神

[@cheerios4canaries]

She has an ethereal beauty to her face and her voice matches this quality ❤ it’s surreal she’s only 21 😊

[@caroljing0419]

老師~你說的 我懂 不張揚 沉穩 不炫技 乾淨 淡然 但情感超豐富的讓人真的好喜歡 單 真的是我聽過華語聲音理面 少數幾個音色就帶著感情的

[@promotionhk]

終於等到最愛的單依純，說真的之前來來去去都是周深、JJ演出，我以為這頻道就主力只說這兩個

[@張益桓]

單依純少是因為之前為了學業不是很專注於經營事業，近期畢業了才開始投入事業，像是這種比較值得去評論的演出沒有那麼多（這頻道注重的是歌手對細節的處理、歌手的唱功、歌手的情感表達），現在出道後也就出了一首《純妹妹》，但這首歌就是純粹的炫技歌，評論是可以，但是去評論的價值不高，不是貶低這首歌，是因為這首歌本身就是單依純在展現自己的唱功，營銷自己的特點，不算是個代表作（而且我個人認為曲做的洗腦沒錯，但詞真的糞…主歌硬塞文言文秀文彩，給人一種很硬要的感覺，副歌不予置評，但這是作詞人的鍋，單依純把這首炫技歌完成的很完美，完美的展現出自己優秀的唱功），你提到的兩個，JJ不用說，在華語樂壇如今也算是前輩了，周深出道有挺長一段時間了，兩人也都是實力派代表，老師最喜歡他們這種類型的歌手，當然他們的點評就會多

[@ZRY-up1rj]

很喜欢这位老师，人好而且专业❤

[@TalkingtotheMoon-sm5cy]

终于等到单依纯了 😭😭😭 未来一定会有更多小单的点评

[@OBAMAMYJ]

想看續寫

[@zexuan_97]

纯纯是我很欣赏的一位新声代女歌手❤❤

[@haogeorge1772]

she is a gifted singer. so almost all of her cover performances will blender the original singers singing breathing way。

[@chihyi62]

老師說的就是繪畫中的留白. 單依純絕對是不只唱功, 唱商也絕頂的歌手.

[@周宏毅-g9p]

單依純的轉音自然不做作 斷句妥當 主歌娓娓道來且順暢 高音時仍保有厚度 不刺耳 情緒上還有所保留 靜待爆發或是安然結束 詮釋方式很容易讓聽者帶入情緒 是天生的歌者 讓人妒忌的是 還長得有人緣😊 只是瘦了點😅 希望下次還能聽到老師對單小妹的講評😊😊😊 我還有點貪心 也想聽聽老師對黃霄雲的講評😊

[@luislee8364]

依純有乾淨漂亮有穿透力的高音 根據作品需要～ 比如今年為好萊塢大片The Little Mermaid演唱的主題曲「你的世界」及各重現插曲

[@emilyho7003]

點評中肯，依純唱的太棒了! 聲入人心 💖

[@chad8867]

她絕對是00後華語歌壇第一人

[@HuiyiXi]

这唱功无敌

[@福爺]

🎉❤

[@davidhwang9724]

哇！竟然可以看到老師React單依純！ 如果想讓老師看到她偏RnB的演唱風格 推薦以下兩首喔~ 1. 別問很可怕 2. 喂

[@haokegwt3477]

I agree

[@gohg80]

She was 18 year old then, first live audition. She eventually won the contest. Love this audition clip. ❤

[@rho-2023]

終於有單依純love it, 老師都好欣賞佢🥳

[@317greenleaf]

她的踮起腳尖愛也很棒❣️

[@林士宏-c4l]

單依純踮起腳尖愛唱得很棒，但我還是覺得原唱洪佩瑜的版本最強，在YT上沒MV只有一張照片6千多萬點閱率不是假的，原唱回歸後當初做影片的人把6千多萬點閱的影片刪除了(聽說因為原唱回歸他要把焦點還給原唱，這首是當屆超偶一人唱一首的合輯所以沒MV)，洪佩瑜有重新再錄一次，跟原本的不太一樣，多了這幾年不務正業的流浪的滄桑(她比賽後跑去外國繼續學舞，去日本打工換宿，演舞台劇)，單依純跟洪佩瑜音色差異很大，這首是蔡健雅寫給洪佩瑜唱的，在YT上看過蔡健雅自己的演唱會有拿回來，還是覺得這首歌最適合洪佩瑜，就像開頭第一句歌詞 舞鞋 穿了洞 裂了縫 預備迎接一個夢 OK 繃 遮住痛 要把蒼白都填充(洪佩瑜是台藝大舞蹈系當初2010年參賽還是大學生)

[@jeffk4710]

google translate is crazy it says tiptoe sex lol

[@福爺]

​@@jeffk4710😂😅

[@ocm0104]

老師很勵害，可以很巨體地，精準地，立刻指出單演出時，有那些出色的表現，聽力和反應也超神的。她是評審的話，一早己經轉身了😘❤️😊

[@zhigangwang-u3f]

老师说的太棒了，想和老师一起欣赏单依纯、姚贝娜的歌❤

[@richardlau4419]

I believe you will love "给电影人的情书-live" ,during this song, she had a sore throat and struggled throughout, emotional and I really love it.. well done to 单以纯。。

[@lesleyli595]

还有给电影人的情书，这首歌真的听到哭😢

[@kmpang9991]

終於等到單依純啦👏

[@Ava-kl8oj]

Please please react more to Shan Yichun, I love her and I appreciate your expertise comments on her voice ❤

[@DemihumanNFT8766]

好久沒有聽到那麼舒服，那麼觸動內心深處的歌聲了🥲 不需要技巧，不需要高亢，只需要柔柔的歌聲來療癒這世間許多受傷的心靈～

[@loada73]

終於等到單依純的,希望以後有更多她的reaction,這首絕對不是她最好的首歌❤

[@胡雨沁-m2z]

好好聽啊😍老師說轉就對了

[@rictusjas1014]

这个老师可以轻松到位的模仿任何一位歌手的特色处理方法，真的太厉害了

[@mrcloudhsiao]

只有李玟 她模仿不來

[@bbaa6710]

不知道這位老師能不能點評台語歌手呢，應該會很精彩🎉

[@jamesho5660]

@@mrcloudhsiao why 模仿李玟, she is far better than 李玟

[@zrrailgun4288]

應該只是再說特殊唱法沒有辦法模仿 不是在說遜色於李玟 =_=

[@CK-gd3lb]

除了騰格爾，影片標題甚至用欣賞而非點評

[@pure-heart-3339]

依纯唱的超棒，她还有很多好听的歌！💖💕

[@echeng5271]

She has a very beautiful voice. Perhaps the most beautiful voice of the young generation I've heard so far in China.

[@adafee381]

好声音五强抢位战，单依纯那首《像风一样》惊为天人❤❤❤

[@stanleychan6428]

To me she's probably the best voice among Chinese female singers in the last few years, and I do believe she'll be best of the best in many years to come.

[@hkgoodman888]

not probably. she IS the best.

[@ocm0104]

Agree, it is so enjoyable to listen to her songs 😊😊😊

[@HanY-gf3sx]

She dominated the competition.

[@虎斑貓-v4p]

看到下雨天 就想到ALin，好希望也聽聽老師分析ALin啊!!

[@jjz8454]

i love Shan Yi Chun too ❤❤❤

[@shunchengtrading28]

期待老师点评依纯的总决赛Live版🎉

[@alvissaso]

+1+1 敲碗

[@bingxiong7469]

真正的实力表现，音准完美，吓死个人。

[@ivanlin9120]

她正一步一步走向天后

[@jingzhang9825]

纯纯版的“想你时风起” “爱与痛的边缘” 以及她cover Tori Kelly的 "Language" 和 "Paper hearts"

[@東東-m9z]

單依純真的值得老師多認識!!

[@HanY-gf3sx]

Her hands rising up and down during chorus melody is so cute

[@williamtong7285]

react more to this singer plz!!! she is so so so so talented!!!!

[@waiholeung8705]

本來以為單依純的風格不會是老師喜歡的類型，等待影片發佈這幾天一直很忐忑🥺 沒想到老師居然以「完美無暇」來形容單依純的初舞台（超感動）😭 期待以後能看到更多單依純的點評！🥹

[@dppr2692]

我对单的信心很足，我觉得会很容易受到老师的认可，林志炫的那个其实略有意外，但也明白，林的确不是老师的菜

[@waiholeung8705]

本來以為林志炫那種磅礡型的歌手更會得到聲樂老師青睞呢🤣 結果真的有點出乎意料

[@breath-so4gl]

看來老師喜歡類似JJ這種風格的

[@kimutaku2046hk]

​@@dppr2692老師喜歡新一點的唱法, 林比較老派

[@yilinjin1570]

@@waiholeung8705林志炫那场感觉选歌不太行，毕竟原唱几乎是不可超越的存在，又是老师非常熟悉的歌手，作为男歌手翻唱最多也就是拿个唱的还不错的评价

[@Patrick99977]

🥰🥰💪💪YiChun👍👍💪💪The Best of the best 😁😁

[@yuenjoey6954]

She was not a real singer at that time, but a contestant in a singing competition. She could sing so beautifully. I really admire her.

[@mikel2729]

Pure and Artist singer ,let people fall in love,so good!This song is sentimental and touching!

[@llengun]

单依纯歌声情感真的很干净纯洁

[@alvissaso]

終於等到小單了 真的太開心了 想推薦小單的單曲 "喂" 裡面的轉音感覺老師會很喜歡

[@EllaBilly]

Yep she’s really good.

[@gccco]

老師的點評真的非常立體層次，也很精準快速，即使不是聲樂領域的也可以從老師的評論裡得到一些啟發！非常感謝❤

[@young9169]

Thanks for the reaction, Yichun is my fav singer and she's so great! 💖💖

[@holohulolo]

"Tender and delicate" is exactly how I would describe everything about that performance, her singing, her voice, and even how she looks. I think this was her audition, while I did watch that season, I remember finding that she has 2 audition songs, so I dont know what the reason was and this song wasn't his official audition, but ironically it's my favourite performance of her that entire season. It's a popular song original sung by Eric chou, male singer, and I actually like her version more. I remember listening it on repeat so many times after I heard it. I think every time a cover managed to make me want to keep listening to it more, instead of immediately thinking the original is better and I probably won't listen to it again, is a successful cover.

[@小楼一夜听春雨-k5t]

Can try her first live performance of Cantonese song 爱与痛的边缘😃

[@SPEN-lw8tc]

推荐《别问很可怕》舞台，虽然是节目修音了但是很好体现了她的音乐审美、律动、转音甚至是一定的强声能力！

[@haokegwt3477]

是的

[@joker-xx9mg]

她翻唱 踮起腳尖愛 也不錯

[@SSean-f3h]

終於等到單依純演唱的獎評！大愛～～ 推薦老師講評，譚維維--烏蘭巴托的夜（我是歌手比賽版）！

[@Undercoverism1437]

Highly praised👏🏼😂

[@GA-rc2nl]

希望點評更多單依純的歌！！！！

[@haokegwt3477]

赞同

[@憨興興]

雖然JJ在我心裡是無可替代，但是也可以多聽一些單依純她真的超棒

[@HanY-gf3sx]

Her other songs on the competition are really good too.

[@HanY-gf3sx]

Actually the judges usually turn when the song is ending, so they can hear as blindly as possible. Also in this segment, each judges already have 5 students each (full), so shan yi chun is contesting for a spot of a student (judges already turned for). So each turn will result in a PK, and the winner takes the spot or (keeps his/her spot). So the judges usually take their time to deliberate.

[@eaglekuo]

好想聽老師評論LALA徐佳瑩，尤其是她那氣若游絲的氣音

[@藍淳瑋]

期待評LALA! 特別是她詮釋莉莉安

[@suckcockology]

推！

[@ppppanacea4996]

There IS a lot of editing in the show. But to be fair, she actually is good among young Chinese singers nowadays

[@adafee381]

哇喔真的盼来了🎉🎉🎉

[@lemonylils5548]

Shows like that almost always have some audio editing. However, Shan has proven again and again in other unedited clips that she didn't need much editing. Even though there's editing, I don't think the editing could've added the subtlety to her voice. The details in the song are all her work.

[@abelshen3617]

looking forward to this reaction.

[@ka-kc3248]

終於來了，點評新一代歌后！thank you for making this video.

[@stevechang5247]

好声音三个奇迹（周深，刀郎，单依纯）会师腾讯音乐榜TOP3，依纯的原唱《想你时风起》大火，期待她更多作品唱遍大街小巷👍

[@ponneyma4163]

麻烦你别再提刀郎了，你给这个老师看刀郎，只会自取其辱。

[@stevechang5247]

榜单只是反映听众选择，我说的是依纯，没有提议点评刀郎😊

[@ponneyma4163]

@@stevechang5247 刀郎的专辑，修音都修出电音来了。

[@憨憨Lu]

菜刀狼

[@bao4755]

終於等到了🎉🎉

[@nhf7170]

I knew she would win the second she opened her mouth.

[@silvervanilla2855]

Same

[@thomaschan507]

她參賽時已令我驚訝!很喜歡她的轉音和亨声，超自然美和順耳❤做几十年人，首次有這種感覺😅是否说的有点過了😂😂😂

[@tonystonehk]

Shan Yichun is an emotional story telling singer by the songs through her voice. Hope below lyrics in English can help Rozette to understand the story of the song and the emotion Yichun was delivering while singing. Unbreakable Love My love where are you hiding What is it that you can't let go of We always think too badly about life As if others won't allow our oddities Every unique cloud Needs to find the sky to exist We're used to wandering around But can't get used to being relied on You give me the love I never want to lose in this lifetime Believe the journey of love is in the sea of stars The beautiful plot will not change It's the best arrangement of destiny You give me the love I never want to lose in this lifetime What cruelty forces me to let go Please come back soon, I want to hear you say again Say you're still here I walked past the roof where I accompanied you to watch the meteor I endured the endless wait after losing you I'm so worried no one will understand your helplessness If you leave me who will treat you like a small child I think you will definitely miss me I'm afraid you'll be lost in a sea of people No matter, you can look back You'll find that I'm always here You give me the love I never want to lose in this lifetime Your every message is a heartbeat Every second I want to embrace you You're the cutest thing in the whole world You give me the love I never want to lose in this lifetime Even if your breath is a thousand mountains away Please believe the love I give Is worthy of your love lyricstranslate.com

[@catherineto]

So accurate. You are great commentator. I am Chinese and understand the lyric. But your comment is exactly what I heard from her too

[@mililanikaamilo7482]

Her voice sounds so soft and beautiful, love her, love her. One of the best Chinese singers ever

[@pingpingliu2106]

这位老师点评得太好了。

[@rolandzhang9077]

老师厉害！Great coach

[@kankanzhou6820]

感谢老师对我们这种外行人的启发，受益匪浅🤪😝😝😝

[@dec101102]

The reason the judges hesitate to "Press" is because they were all 'full" (# of student they allowed to select). If they "Press" and get her, they will have to eliminate one they already have thru internal competition.

[@stevechang5247]

Or the judges simply didn’t want to interfere with her singing in order to leave a perfect version of the song :)

[@gigicheng9404]

这么好听的声音 为啥不转 急死了

[@vincentvincent3423]

这老师太牛了，每句差不多都能有针对性的点评😂

[@kendrictan8209]

希望Rozette老师也可以反应依纯的《别问很可怕》～！

[@无名仕-h9c]

太喜欢单依纯了😊

[@梓安-x4k]

期待期待

[@chrislakatos5309]

Could consider her “more raw” school assignment performances “Sorry Would Go A Long Way”.

[@Sam_Lin_0203]

單依純唱的永不失聯的愛我可以一直循環聽.

[@hemmahoable]

片尾的「下雨天」。期待！！！

[@hicohicohk]

單依純真的唱的好，本來很擔心老師會批評她😂

[@pure-heart-3339]

老师很喜欢她💖

[@ckck4141]

我就不担心这个，毕竟单依纯自出道以来，得到过很多很高的评价，不但内地，连港圈不少前辈都对她赞叹有加，李克勤甚至称她为新生代最强没有之一，叶倩文都足足看了依纯八个礼拜的节目，就知道依纯水平多强，本人频道就有各前辈对依纯的评价视频

[@hicohicohk]

@@pure-heart-3339 下一首是下雨天，期待

[@emilyho7003]

@@ckck4141 看來了解依純的人都知道前輩是多麼欣賞她😀

[@stirfriedfrog]

@@ckck4141李克勤评价单依纯最强的话，那周深呢😂

[@youqingzhou9037]

哈哈哈老师说“高音”和“长音”的时候，我的注意力完全被你的指甲吸引了哈哈哈

[@95w76]

最喜欢她 她是很多声乐学习者梦寐以求的偶像吧

[@emilyho7003]

是的，音樂老師們的範本，音樂生們的榜樣😀

[@Sam-us6ds]

蠻喜歡單的！ ［［以下許願］］ 也想聽聽老師評張靚穎在「夢想的聲音」時期的演出；還有張的「第五元素」演出，想知道這種比較非流行樂演出的表現，在老師的視角會是怎麼樣？

[@jialbai]

A small suggestion: For Chinese songs that have always valued lyrics, reactions that focus solely on vocal techniques will miss half of the original song's essence. A good example is Joe Creator's reaction. He can almost feel the emotions that only native Chinese speakers can experience by combining it with translated lyrics.

[@awang3139]

She's a vocal coach. Not "how does that song make you feel" coach :)

[@stevechang5247]

@@awang3139 Make sense to me but language / culture does matter in conveying emotions..

[@HanY-gf3sx]

@@awang3139 no harm adding lyrics to let listener understand more. And its related to vocal coaching, vocal coaching involves conveying emotions through the voice, so that's the "feel" part. Understanding the lyrics lets the vocal coach understand how to sing or people should sing to convey the emotions or why the singer chose to do a certain way. :)

[@chrislakatos5309]

This one is a little short.. should have combined with “像風一样”

[@elaine2262]

很喜歡單依純的聲音

[@cheongnicholas3891]

终于！！！！

[@小楼一夜听春雨-k5t]

Can review some of the wonderful songs that she performed live at 剧好好听的歌-萱花草，最长的旅途，踮起脚尖爱，让她降落…

[@Ethan-vh1kw]

單依純《想你時風起》也超級好聽

[@emilyho7003]

那首歌現在很火

[@binghan4587]

@@emilyho7003 今天QQ音乐，实时在线收听3万

[@铭-w8u]

想看老师评价不同版本的《如愿》 有单依纯，王菲，郁可唯，张韶涵/刘惜君，杨丞琳，周深，孙楠，谭维维