國外聲樂老師點評龔琳娜神曲《忐忑》Vocal Coach Reaction to Gong Linna「Tan Te」

[@yong1137]

这位老师 评价和推测真是 大师级的准确

[@人鬼壬癸]

忐忑其實加上三個字就很好理解 忐忑練習曲龔大師把各種練習的吊嗓編成歌可以說就像小說中的口訣心法 是當之無愧的神曲

[@yokaxi1011]

这么难的练习曲，门槛有点高

[@齊天大聖-ho]

@@yokaxi1011她老公寫的專門寫的發音練習曲。

[@莎莎-m6z]

第一次聽到忐忑也是跟著笑，但是後來看了全能星戰之後完全愛上龔老師，龔老師真的是寶藏❤

[@DcDuck]

第一次聽忐忑的時候也不太懂， 本來是當作類似魔笛夜后有一段無歌詞純音的概念， 但因為小時候常在廟口看歌仔戲， 所以聽到那個「待待待」的瞬間， 腦中閃出馬蹄聲， 才發現應該是模擬戲曲的鑼鼓， 真的超酷！

[@jlds1949]

这首歌就是要演绎各种中华传统乐器和歌谱的调子而创作出来的。。。所以你没听错。。。

[@silascript]

有戏曲熏陶的人，音乐敏感性就是不同。不过更准确的是，这歌源自戏曲界的锣鼓经，这是戏曲中打击乐的使用口头记谱方式。你形容的歌仔戏的「待待待」应该是拟声词，跟锣鼓经这种记谱方式其核心原理一致--锣鼓经就是用一些跟锣啊鼓的声响相近的字去标识锣鼓点，如“空、匡、仓”是大小锣或䥽、“大、达、嘟”是鼓。 龚老师是真的热爱音乐，不但到处采风，还涉猎各种戏曲艺术，并非常大胆地推出各种试验音乐。可能她那些试验性质的音乐，不一定被大众接受，但她这种对音乐的热忱，足以让人尊敬！

[@5468621]

他是把傳統東方戲曲的元素抽象化以後表現 但是裡面就是太雜 所以可能你對什麼戲曲熟就覺得裡面有模仿某種戲曲 😂但說真的 某些地方我連日本傳統音樂那種味道都感覺到 😂就他喵的雜然後抽象化

[@lisalu9843]

当年听这歌，每次都笑到肚子疼

[@Woshi777]

想到了那个谁的表情包😂

[@5468621]

我是嚇到 因為這玩意太敢了 無歌詞 然後雜揉的東西太多

[@keiichilee]

這老師真的有料

[@shine9494]

龔老師真的很讚

[@MT-ub7eg]

There’s no word there as far as I know. She makes interesting sounds for an extended period of time 🤭🤣🤣🤭🤣

[@kianchen2593]

终于等到了！！！太期待了！！还有小河淌水

[@RyanFlyChannel]

第一次聽忐忑的時候沒有覺得好笑或奇葩 我聽到起雞皮疙瘩 這唱功絕對是藝術大師級別的! 但是我感覺很多人都是用看戲的心情在看待覺得好可惜 一般人就算會唱歌 光是單發音要跟上樂器的節奏就已經非常困難了 何況龔老師每個音都唱的神準! 她唱完我真的是站起來拍手 太屌了!!!!

[@超人李-u9i]

知音人跟普通人的分別😊

[@shannonchouhomes]

没错👍你是懂的人

[@amiladesilva1730]

我在上海上海听了她的离骚演唱会，惊为天人❤❤

[@WeiShen1107]

忐忑可以说是声乐发生技巧教科书级别的演唱。这首歌里有太多高难度和无比精准细腻的发声方式。

[@mizukisho94]

即使文化不同有风格和唱腔的差异，老师不愧是专业的能听出里面的玄机，忐忑刚出来的时候我以为是来搞笑的….现在知道龚老师的优秀了，以前觉得民族乐京剧听不懂土土的。现在越来越喜欢传统音乐了。 期待下一期的小河淌水，到时候不知道老师会不会发现花海、忐忑、小河是同一个人。也期待老师更多了解忐忑以后的感想～

[@softbed9906]

老师看了十秒钟就已经比忐忑刚出的那段时间的百分之99的网友看的要透了。

[@Harry_SY]

真的专业。分析得太透了

[@亮孔-d6e]

他本来就是改编了一首日本的原创歌曲

[@cchh-mv9pr]

是中国戏曲唱腔练习

[@wieein]

老師好厲害，聽一次就能精準唱出 我好喜歡她❤

[@金艾莉絲]

忐忑是無字歌~用哼唱表現中國戲曲唱腔技巧的一首歌~唱功芸術!

[@lakeci9882]

是的，她唱的“抬、多”其实是京剧锣鼓谱

[@moonw3662]

解读的好❤

[@wu4240]

超愛龔老師！ 名場面 全能星戰版的小河淌水 我聽到哭！

[@黑水-m5k]

我也听哭了，尤其是背后的故事，唱的时候真的就很有代入感

[@slam7130]

我也超喜歡！

[@mizukisho94]

我也！过段时间就要去听听洗涤一下

[@wu4240]

@@黑水-m5k 而且畫面超美 龔老師超漂亮

[@ohhikaren9472]

我也是！第一次聽就鼻酸，太引人入勝了！！！

[@黑水-m5k]

既然讲到了龚琳娜老师，那就不得不提小河淌水了，老师真的厉害，听一遍马上复唱的这么准确！

[@anyway416]

推小河淌水!!!!!拜託老師一定要聽聽!!!

[@hot20241430]

如果可以 聽聽全能星戰的小河淌水❤個人覺得比歌手裡的更感動人

[@orange.studio7]

毕竟是声乐老师 对音色都很敏感，信手拈来😂

[@TRF1995]

小河淌水也是听着流泪的歌曲，怎么能唱得那么好听呢！

[@koolaid2028]

真绝了，我还以为只有我一个人有这种感觉😂😂😅

[@周湯包-p7n]

老師藝術家就是會讓人不懂 一般人只能做到歌手 龔琳娜是音樂藝術家😂🎉

[@北極熊0u0]

抓

[@12505nick]

我是覺得你要表達你的喜愛沒什麼問題，拉採就大可不必，根本就沒那麼神，吹那麼高你也不會因為誇獎她而雞犬升天。

[@peterwilliams7335]

The song with a fusion of Chinese folk song and new age music and was composed by German husband is also a musician. The lyric has not particular meaning. It is more about the technique, her comic facial expression and unique sound she created really amazed her audiences. Her unusual style of singing was shocking and entertaining at the same time to the audiences so got her instant popularity (in a fun way).

[@yuen0404]

Music is really an international language. Her analysis is spot on, esp when she talks about the twang, or the children sound

[@kaizi0530]

我以前小時候就聽過這首歌 只是覺得這個姨姨怎麼這麼奇怪 在唱什麼東西 但到現在我才知道這首歌原來是無歌詞的歌 更加厲害了 加上看乘風破浪 被老龔的真誠所感染到 她的唱功也是真的很厲害👏🏼👏🏼

[@kaizi0530]

而且以前覺得這個姨姨的裝造很奇怪 很誇張 直到乘風破浪才知道她其實很好看的🥰穿粉色超好看😎

[@yxi4176]

@@kaizi0530龚丽娜老师年轻时，绝对美女一枚 你可以找找他当年得全国第一个场比赛的视频

[@anniea2042]

Rozette 是看過最好的評論

[@aloejojoba8841]

聲樂老師好專業，評論客觀，竟然可以get到這首歌的點，好厲害。

[@geniusmrlai]

而且是第一次聽

[@blackcat515]

今天第一次看您的影片，老師的點評真的很厲害的，除了唱功技巧、音樂的藝術表現、歌手狀態等⋯不時地模仿發聲方式、舉例類似歌手，甚至在片尾拿出類似的曲風唱腔等，讓看影片觀眾容易理解與投入！ 在欣賞不同音樂時，又保持心態開放，即使有個人喜歡喜好也會盡量客觀地去點評分析，如JJ唱《領悟》那支影片，就特別點出 炫技多餘感情的感動。 真的是我在KZbin上看到很優秀的點評影片，可以感覺到老師是一位熱愛欣賞音樂的人，繼續支持❤

[@wting1988]

龔琳娜真的是很厲害 頂尖等級的聲樂家

[@xuechen9057]

也是顶尖艺术家

[@chh2972]

這首太高了，別說老外聽不懂，就連華人也很難懂的境界，忐忑大概就是如來神掌的概念

[@chonghenvui2553]

简直就是神掌如来了。

[@geniusmrlai]

受眾不是一般人啦

[@silascript]

因为大部分人都不知道锣鼓经这东西。如果知道了，就清楚，龚老师并不是在“乱唱”！

[@SimonChan-ym5dl]

歌聲可以扺擋六指琴魔。

[@jasonlee3093]

​@@silascript 😅😅😅人家走了一波流量！！只不过哗了众，没有取到宠，毕竟大众的审美能力太低下。

[@cdeadpooka1642]

有实力的歌手，别人就算是创作奇葩的歌曲来唱，专业的老师都一下能听得出别人唱功实力，也不需要所谓粉丝的支持评论和解析，路人都能明白，也都认同。某些所谓的明星，被老师说了不行，还要在那里诡辩说别人不尊重歌手什么的，要么就是在评论区写一大堆分析，好像大家都是傻子听不懂，就粉丝听得懂在那里逼逼赖赖，才能找到存在感来体现自家明星的优秀。像龚琳娜这种，只有奇葩作品，大多数人只知道一个忐忑，不需要专业解析，都一大片路人缘，大家都认可龚琳娜的实力，没有人喷什么。 你们自家所谓的明星，要作品作品没有，要唱功唱功没有，要路人缘路人缘没有，全是粉丝看着别人脸帅，会唱几个音就无脑狂舔，把别人带到不属于他的高度，就粉丝自high，还说被人不懂。你说大家不骂你们这些脑残骂谁？请某些明星的粉丝自己对号入座好吧

[@wanwanququ]

你倒是实在！🤣🤣🤣

[@spark-vison1801]

说得太好了！

[@oeildechat7295]

哈哈哈哈哈哈。不用说名字😂

[@JY-rx2ue]

This song doesn't have lyrics, just sounds. It has had a lot of critics over the time. But not many "professional" singers could complete this piece.

[@yixiguan6520]

This was originally her warm up practice. It has no words and real meaning. Becuase its so technically challenging and entertaining. She started to perform it and became very popular. Everyone in China knows it.

[@mx5274]

这位老师的评价太厉害了，也非常中肯！

[@黃龍-s3m]

“忐忑” ，歌名已道出了演唱的意思囉： 就是所有人類隨時隨地所經歷到的各種狀況而自身會引發的“驚嘆”+“情緒”。 類似於 “哎呀！那件事情太嚴重了！” or “天哪！已經遲到了我該怎辦呢？！” “什麼呀！這麼做如何收尾啦？！” or“哎唷糟了！明天債主就要上門啦還沒湊夠錢怎辦呢！” or也可以用在美好的事上，例如： “明天要上台領獎了但我禮服尚未準備好呢！哎呀呀！” or“呀~原來我真愛上他啦~臉紅心跳” 龔老師是以聲音唱出“當事情發生時的心態感受”，各種各樣的，好的或壞的“哎呀” “唉喲”。以及“急切的感受”。

[@jaczhen]

這也是殿堂級別的藝術家，即使沒有擁有狂熱的粉絲，但擁有忠實的耳朵。期待上線！繼續敲碗張靚穎的作品🥹

[@YUBALIU]

忐忑就是彷徨、焦虑、手足无措。国内乐评人说这首歌写的是婴儿的内心表达！

[@finley2249]

This song is really an one-of-a-kind artpiece. And Gong Lin-Na is undoubtedly a world-class artist. Only she can deliver this performance so well. Incredible. Amazing.

[@STP5114]

我个人觉得龚琳娜老师的这首音乐，就是用观众能直观感受的高亢和低沉表现的是人内心的上上下下，

[@qyalexwen]

There are a lot of Chinese folk opera singing techniques integrated and demonstrated in this song. Also different styles and characters, such as male, female, young, old, etc. It's fantastic! And she's the only one who can sing all these styles.

[@qyalexwen]

And there are no lyrics at all, purely singing and performing styles!

[@bryantchang2905]

老龔❤️❤️❤️ 超棒的啦！

[@cityhunterhf]

As its name, this song describes a person's restless and anxious state of mind, implying their inner anxiety and uncertainty. The lyrics, melody, and emotional expression of the song may convey this feeling. 上 (up) 下 (down) 心 (heart) 心 (heart) =The word "忐忑" can be translated to English as "nervous" or "anxious." It refers to a state of uneasiness or restlessness, often accompanied by a sense of inner turmoil or uncertainty.， Chinese words are funy, right? 😁😁

[@pengjunsun3683]

Amazing translation!

[@BaianChenCountertenor]

And it's experimental!! What a brilliant performance, this is absolutely epic!! As a perfect example of human voice's extreme

[@maryding2272]

老师 你以为这首歌只有外国人听不懂吗？其实我们中国人也听不懂 😅

[@flyingBlank]

我懂

[@handly1223able]

我懂你懂他的不懂

[@wood008]

😂😂😂

[@圣斗士大妈]

哈哈哈哈哈 好你个嘴替

[@zhenfei9266]

😂😂😂😂老師學唱我就笑翻了，看到你的留言眼淚都被笑出來了

[@kylie3053]

推老師評論 笑之歌

[@mrna1508]

这首歌越听越棒，在中国很难被人接受，但我喜欢😅，龚琳娜老师不仅唱的没人能复制，表情也独一无二😂

[@何先生-j3e]

我也喜欢

[@raisin417]

啊？神曲是假的么，当年谁没被这个轰炸过，这还不能说接受么

[@yxi4176]

懂音乐的人惊叹，不懂的瞎起哄凑个热闹，谈不上不接受好吧

[@haoosc5017]

啥比，龚丽娜就因为忐忑火的，这叫不能接受？

[@ziangwang2637]

这首歌在当年太超前了，很多人无法欣赏只能嘲讽来掩饰自己。

[@Cloud-sister-is-me]

老師，關於這首忐忑，依據原唱介紹，此首歌並無歌詞，所以每次演唱都不一樣，都是即興發揮，《忐忑》這個歌名也是依原唱本人演唱這首歌「忽上忽下」的感受。

[@lorenzoxiong2611]

沒有歌詞才是真正的音樂

[@CK-gd3lb]

這是一首發聲練習曲，所以音調忽上忽下漸強漸弱不是即興而是要求

[@adriannelcy710]

呀！！！！！！！！期待！！！！！ 以為會有比較多分析唱法之類的內容，不過可能老師真不了解這種戲曲唱腔，難以評價。不過老師也表現出足夠的尊重。小河淌水可能會比較能明白一點。😊

[@natn41r]

I remember this song got viral because it was super weird. Pretty sure it's gibberish (except for the title.) Defo not Mandarin, at any rate. I actually learned how to "sing" it, because it really is such a fun song to vocalize.

[@eddy1118]

這首歌把古代秦曲怒音發揮得淋漓盡致。

[@Magicamera]

这是出自她先生创作的一首颇具实验性的音乐，她的先生老锣是一位在中国生活的德国作曲家，这个歌的名称“忐忑”，means “Perturbed”没有歌词，即兴发挥，结合了中国戏曲和类似电影配乐般的音乐元素，这首曲风怪异的歌在网络上引发热议，龚琳娜也因为可爱的性格也因此收获大量fans。此曲获得2009年度欧洲举办的“聆听世界音乐”演唱大奖

[@cclin6225]

龔琳娜老師來了。 這之後如果再上龔琳娜老師和深深的「笑之歌」reaction應該是很有意思呢！

[@ruilong0702yt]

推一個

[@wongjoan346]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oWiUpXSEi62op5Y

[@ianlo7315]

極力推薦react「笑之歌」，高手過招 🎉

[@simonong3628]

No words….all sound expressions

[@sheenz10822]

龔琳娜氣場太強了，連這首我都可以聽到哭😂😂

[@shannonchouhomes]

是的！我也会想哭！有种大地母神显灵的感觉！

[@sheenz10822]

@@shannonchouhomes 你懂你懂！！

[@nanqi8583]

她是中国民族音乐歌唱家，功底深厚，他把中国戏曲的一些花腔融合成一个歌曲，确实了不起

[@darksunchen7133]

0:52 其實我也聽不懂忐忑哈哈哈哈哈 但真的很多人都說很厲害，說是神曲等級 (然後看了浪姐，真的覺得龔老師超溫柔超暖心超圈粉 1:04 這就是專業跟凡人的差距嗎🤣🤣🤣 凡人如我：聽不懂 老師：聽得出來技巧很好，而且音準精確

[@wei770702]

凡人如我：知道是一首歌，聽得我很忐忑…

[@tangpz]

The title of Gong Lina's song is "Tan te," which means an unsettled or anxious state of mind. It is like a musical experiment where the song incorporates elements of Chinese classical opera rhythms, but none of the syllables have actual meanings. Her costume and appearance also imitate Chinese classical opera, but they are not complete. The audience in the audience cannot comprehend this piece of music and simply finds it amusing and perplexing. This song has sparked significant controversy in China. The meaningless lyrics and strange attire led ordinary viewers to perceive it as a comedic act, akin to a clown performance. However, professional singers can discern Gong Lina's exceptional musical skills and admire the concept behind this song.

[@fionafu9860]

I cannot agree more with this comments! It explains better than I could!

[@lewismoore9765]

Gong Linna is formally trained in Being opera at the China Conservatory of Music. Tan Te, which was composed by her husband Lao Lou, is a sampler of Bejing Opera voicing techniques. The song has no lyrics, only vocal sounds chosen to demonstrate the various voicings.

[@Truth2011sg]

First came across this professional artist from the song Song of Laughters in which she sang with zhou shen. She is popular and good in her ability to rapid singing and changing of pitch. I would say this song entertaing and supposedly artistic. Fun listening. Can see that Coach Rozette makes great effort in finding words to describe her observation. Thank you.

[@Truth2011sg]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oWiUpXSEi62op5Y Song of Laughter. Top class entertaining performance.

[@leannchen6091]

太精準了！❤這解析

[@didoyang2207]

实验音乐，确实比较怪，但她有很正常的音乐作品，类似毕加索，传统经典的演唱技术走到极致之后，开发自己的实验性、创新性的作品。

[@NicoleChen-r7x]

很期待老师对于龚琳娜老师的分析解读，忐忑在当年超级火的，一开始只当神曲听，后来听了国内某乐评人分析才懂了一点门道。龚老师的名场面太多了，我觉得她与吴碧霞老师都是天籁中的天籁。

[@lzyshaman]

U reviewed her once. She's the partner to the Japanese singer at the Chinese show, sister who make wave. They sang 花海

[@tingshare]

up可以给老师解释下，和老师猜测的一样，歌词确实是在模仿一个乐器，是京剧的锣鼓点。

[@vichikaru]

懂的人太小

[@zhiwenyao6440]

外行都在看热闹和笑 真的懂的才知道各种技巧和内涵🙈

[@youngyoung4612]

我感受到是京劇裡的各種唱腔

[@CK-gd3lb]

@@youngyoung4612 詞是鑼鼓點，腔是模仿生旦淨末丑的唱腔

[@kcmann8708]

Looks like Rozette does not recognize this singer was the one she reacted to about 2 weeks ago. The song was "Sea of flower", duet with the Japanese singer/dancer.

[@seanguyinhong3847]

真的非常喜欢这个频道 真心感觉到 好的音乐可以跨越语言和文化的界限 某种意义上达到心灵的交流 非常支持这个频道 另外想推荐一些歌手 比如更走心的 谭维维(乌兰巴托的夜) 及 谭晶(苍狼大地)

[@葉不飛]

You felt very right about this song.

[@grazewong1457]

心態，是在演繹一個女人心中忐忑的心境，聲樂也可以成為樂器，無詞勝有詞

[@keshen297]

额，龚琳娜老师没有人支持吗....这可是大神啊。我来先顶一下吧。

[@ten7026]

........

[@Mefocus777]

🙅😊🎉

[@slam7130]

忐忑真的很上頭，越聽越好聽。

[@tfimperfectangel]

马来西亚支持者

[@sssl226]

這首歌寫得很好，很準碓出歌名《忐忑》的感覺

[@bouncingseal9651]

音乐一响，老师头一歪，发现事情并不简单

[@EricLeung-hk]

She is a professional singer with strong China style opera backgrounds. She mixed up several Chinese traditional opera style used for man woman and kid, also young and old and various emotions. Using her voice as musical instruments

[@charmaxim]

she（龔琳娜、龚琳娜）sings and performs to mimic the Jing opera (京劇、京剧), but most of the melody and lyrics (though these words cannot be meaningful sentences...) of the song “Tan Te (忐忑)” comes from elements of Chinese popular songs…… hence, all of these elements turn into a new style of Chinese popular song, by a bizarre but rather amusing way.

[@johnlin6121]

高超的专业性，开放欣赏的心态，细腻入微的音感

[@nh6870]

There’s no words in this music. It sounded interesting to me but it fascinated the Chinese people so became quite popular years ago. Most people don’t sing it so I Don’t think she has a large fan base but this music certainly made her famous in China. It was just a fad. She can sing in the high range. Chinese people are quite embracing of interesting music that makes people laugh.

[@孫榮弘]

這首其實跟哈薩克族蒙古那邊的跑馬調很類似，只是馬頭琴換成了大提，加上不是用呼麥，會比較聽不出來這是很民族色彩的曲子。 嘿嘿，可以推薦您喜歡的周深跟龔琳娜合唱過的笑之歌，這首跟周杰倫費玉清的千里之外一樣都是分錄再合製的，這種方式很考驗歌者的準確度。

[@ryukadesu]

期待

[@黃曉曉-r2m]

期待小河淌水的講評

[@orange.studio7]

0:15 老师表情定格好可爱哈哈，喜欢这老师的发色，好高级😂

[@jackylau1995]

The singer is Chinese. This is a funny song. When we listened to this song at the first time, we all laughed out. It is a special song as there are no lyrics at all.

[@leeice2716]

我上次听一个大拿说忐忑有些类似锣鼓经。锣鼓经可以看作是古代戏曲用汉字发音记录的乐器乐谱。 例如得锵得锵，就描述了锣和鼓点的节奏。 龚琳娜的发音和乐器演奏确实配合的完美无缝。 所以rozette猜测说龚琳娜在模仿一种乐器， 这个直觉应该说相当准

[@Bufferytherisa]

this one surely will blow our mind. looking fwd to it.

[@sydneytsai8338]

应该可以让老师听听周深和龚琳娜老师合唱的“笑之歌”，肯定又可以听到精彩的点评😂

[@NaruKousaka]

出了出了～～

[@pl1842]

期待！

[@RH-oz7oc]

听得我起鸡皮疙瘩。太厉害了。

[@hunterornot]

神曲加神级的reaction

[@嘉嘉-j5j]

Actually, she was singing some Chinese tranditional music. Nowaday, many young people don't listen to this kind of music anymore. So I believe the audiences were also finding it cool and interesting.

[@xxff3580]

内行看门道，外行看热闹！ 叨叨冯老师对《忐忑》解析的很有深度，推荐去听一下。

[@h4509173]

這是她老公幫他創作的 也是因緣際會 有點調皮的小因素 說唱起來心情很忐忑 所以就叫忐忑了

[@isaactan2270]

11 years ago, a male from Taiwan performed her song, 忐忑 对嘴 ～ 萧志伟。very funny

[@Yong-m3y]

This song has quite some meanings/behind the scenes despite having no lyrics at all (technically). 1.The original songwriter/composer (which is Gong Lin Na's husband) wrote this out for her as a compressed practice guideline on her Chinese opera singing. It's a care from her loving husband. 2. The name of the song means "Anxiousness". She aims to create a tension BGM vibe that brings out this feeling. In the "lyrics" there are alot of "A! Oh! Aiyo!" which are commonly used by Chinese (and also quite a bunch of Asians), same usage as "Holy shit! OMG!" 3. They also design the song to be sang just like coach rosette pointed out, mimicking the sounds of alot of instruments used in Chinese opera. The most prominent part is "dai-tak-ke-ti-ke-dai-tak-ke.......", mimicking a drum set sound used in opera, and the drum is mimicking voices of horse running in battlefield. (Quite alot of older Chinese opera have drama scenery about kingdom wars or battle of gods"

[@BonLa-eu4ns]

看了十秒鐘，已經看出老師忐忑的心情了😂😂😂😂😂

[@幻月飛虹]

真是一首讓全體都起乩的請神歌曲😂

[@mizukisho94]

终于！！忐忑要来了吗！期待老师对中国戏曲唱腔的反应，小河淌水希望安排上谢谢

[@mizukisho94]

说唱听我的2的 《huha向上》，《不忐忑》感觉也会很有意思

[@SimonChan-ym5dl]

不懂欣賞，只能說她的歌聲表達心中掙扎的情感，好厲害，不是一般歌手唱出來的。

[@Louis-bl8di]

She is vocalising fidget. The title of this piece directly translates to fidgety.

[@chomiyliu7618]

听了老师的点评，说出了我说不出的心里话，很怪，但是真的有趣

[@Zaphodteo]

This song was written by her husband and meant to be practise or training piece. Somehow recordings of it got viral and she shot to mainstream fame. She is already an acomplished classical vocalist before thst though.

[@mcl626]

老师可以reaction龚老师和周深的《笑之歌》

[@BruceMilpitas]

What a fascinating performance! Great commentary, too. Language is unimportant here.

[@KK-bi1ou]

This song started the era of parody in China, because no one could understand it. If she were an unknown singer, her career probably just ended at the time, because the performance was given in a big show. However, she was already well known, so the controversy brought her her career to a new stage.

[@rickylau1355]

OMG, someone please tell her no any word in this song. the song name meaning restless or apprehensive. please feel it.

[@tomtom7320]

This song is written by the singer's husband - a German. The singer is a Chinese. It has no lyrics. Just an artistic song but very difficult to sing. It would be a challenge for anyone to try this out.

[@vichikaru]

這好像是中樂的一種樂器譜法，專業老師能聽出真是音樂無疆界！

[@keshen297]

不明觉厉的神曲，哈哈。听个热闹。

[@d0910329002]

我想介紹給老師ㄧ首歌譚維維唱的烏蘭巴托的夜，希望老師能聽聽看🙏🙏🙏