Guess the question! (YIAY

[@jacksfilms]

Did you get it?!

[@andreipopot815]

Not at all

[@trevorthepoop]

No

[@baseballguy3741]

Nope

[@uvolanis]

HAHA i managed to get here Now ill be immortalized forever here

[@chihuahua2878]

Not close

[@lucassalviano6943]

Blind YIAY: Jack doesn't choose the answers Guess the YIAY: Jack doesn't ask the question Bye Byiay: Jack is fucking gone, his mods record the videos

[@MCLooyverse]

"Bye Byaiy" actual lol, nice.

[@alphalax7747]

What if John was just a dream

[@Sam_Wich]

@Alpha Lax The real John was the friends we made along the way

[@Leaf._the_foliage_man]

@@alphalax7747 What if john Is dream?! *do do DOO do*

[@John_C_J]

VYIAY: Jack is replaced by Vtuber controlled entirely by the mods. YIAY bot: A bot just reads the answers aloud and play Jack's pre-recorded laugh track when needed.

[@epadilla8555]

Jack didn’t ask the question or collect the answers. His viewers truly do everything for him now

[@supersoupbro]

Truuuuuuueeee

[@Cecily_Smith4]

And we have fun doing it

[@anna3422]

Tbf he does edit... But fr yeah we do sm 😂😂

[@micro11.]

Butler

[@EMNstar]

Top Patreon patron gets to edit

[@johnnyjor562]

So jack is rapidly making other people doing his job. Soon he won't be reading the answers.

[@emmyjoi7156]

Soon Erin will take over the channel.

[@johnnyjor562]

@@emmyjoi7156 then it's her turn to enslave the discord mods

[@John_C_J]

"Do something completely on your own or draw 25"

[@zad_rasera]

@@emmyjoi7156 It is only a matter of time

[@barelyfunctioning3982]

Jack not knowing what “throw it back” means is the funniest thing ever

[@trvrshoe4518]

I was yelling at the screen the entire time lmao

[@n8tie]

I was dead 💀💀💀

[@sarceusalvarez]

I don’t get it, what’s that?

[@doghuman4270]

@@sarceusalvarez twerking my guy, twerking

[@v4nzz950]

@@doghuman4270 WHAT

[@mayac1105]

jack not knowing what “throwing it back” means is incredible

[@lukass.3627]

it's so innocent in some way

[@creeperhunterD]

Nobody over the age of 12 knows what that is

[@juicybutterriblydrab]

@@creeperhunterD I should hope the opposite is true considering what the action entails...

[@arielherman8373]

It means to swing your luscious cake around

[@brumm0m3ntum94]

Throw it back is also used in terms of fishing so there’s a non 0 chance that the guy giving the answer meant it in terms of throwing a fish back

[@aaronburton3289]

Just wanna point out how Jack doesn’t think sliding down to hell on a pole and giving Satan a lap dance is a punishment

[@Menno_3]

-You get to slide down a cool long pole -You get to meet satan -Never rains in hell I see this as an absolute win!

[@TiliaCordata]

@Joshua EdwinRoehl Stop promoting your own channel in the comments. It's obnoxious, unrelated and a bore. When you're promoting your own channel in the comments, well, it's not really a comment anymore. (...) And when you see someone promoting their own channel in the comments, mark as spam cos that's exactly what it is.

[@daspoopenfarten_]

He was being serious this time

[@rugbytimezone5480]

@Joshua EdwinRoehl shut

[@softserve2948]

@@TiliaCordata did you find every instance of this man in the comments, and then copy paste your reply on them all? Hats off

[@thelorddrinian]

“Give the devil a lap dance” “Some of these don’t seem like punishments”

[@knifetoucher]

Only if you're Montero

[@Logan-tz1ry]

No that just sounds like a good time though

[@TiliaCordata]

@Joshua EdwinRoehl Stop promoting your own channel in the comments. It's obnoxious, unrelated and a bore. When you're promoting your own channel in the comments, well, it's not really a comment anymore. (...) And when you see someone promoting their own channel in the comments, mark as spam cos that's exactly what it is.

[@jams4078]

I'm here at 666 likes

[@rugbytimezone5480]

@Joshua EdwinRoehl shut

[@timweigman4958]

"Slide down into hell and give the devil a lapdance" Jack: yeah some of these just dont scream punishment

[@Haris-bg4jy]

that's a privelage

[@a2shame797]

call me by your naaame

[@mitchpitch]

LMAOOO

[@grimreaper2680]

I was thinking the same thing, Jack that isn't a punishment for you? I feel that's pleasure for him instead of the punishment.

[@binglese]

Alternative title: jack accidentally thinks of good questions for 10 minutes

[@szendeti]

oooh, that's how he should brainstorm them, when he doesn't have any left and asks us to give him more :O

[@TiliaCordata]

@Joshua EdwinRoehl Stop promoting your own channel in the comments. It's obnoxious, unrelated and a bore. When you're promoting your own channel in the comments, well, it's not really a comment anymore. (...) And when you see someone promoting their own channel in the comments, mark as spam cos that's exactly what it is.

[@nathanstarkey743]

@@TiliaCordata but you're a bot too

[@TiliaCordata]

@@nathanstarkey743 Wrong. I'm three bots in a trenchcoat.

[@nathanstarkey743]

@@TiliaCordata Little Rascals style eh? I can respect the hustle.

[@rulingdiesout]

YIAY is just gonna get more and more "blind" until it becomes 10 minutes of Jack stumbling around in the dark

[@Faramik2000]

CCTV footage of Jack in a stray jacket blindfolded and mumbling YIAY answers

[@AnimatedTerror]

@@Faramik2000 antsantsantsantsants-

[@DXNE_XIII]

erin takes jacks fucking eyes

[@whiteface513abandonedchann8]

These replies are a fucking goldmine

[@Natalie-101]

@@Faramik2000 in love with the phrase "stray jacket"

[@Baglets]

Jack should become a detective. That was just straight up impressive.

[@awkwardbloom2728]

Indeed

[@cryopex9976]

badef

[@milktea6676]

Indeed Also first furry

[@maxdrags3115]

TBF, he made a lot of guesses...

[@zhewaxen3047]

@@maxdrags3115 But he only made one final guess, which was right. All of the previous guesses were basically Jack thinking what it could be.

[@glynnL]

Jack looked like he was having a lot of fun with this. So proud of himself too. It’s fun watching the rollercoaster of emotion.

[@sprocketdaken8610]

There’s no one

[@gottalivehappy]

why there 1,500 likes and only 1 reply

[@randomprimary]

hello tangerine themed account.

[@glynnL]

@@randomprimary hello

[@sugukui]

LOVE jacks complete confusion surrounding the phrase “throw it back”

[@AV_Action]

It really exaggerated his withering flesh and decrepit bones

[@mr.stuffdoer8483]

@@AV_Action nah, it exaggerates how stupid modern lingo is

[@parximew]

@@mr.stuffdoer8483 sounds like you also have withering flesh and decrepit bones

[@YourJapanic]

@@mr.stuffdoer8483I think it exaggerates both

[@dirk-stridrogen-monoxide]

⁠@@YourJapanicStupid flesh and decrepit lingo

[@KingsleyIII]

"How should Jack punish himself if he doesn't get this question right?" is now a question I want the mods to ask, us to answer, and for him to guess. If Jack does get it wrong, he must randomly do one punishment.

[@SapphireDragon357]

But he's prepared now. It'll have to be a long way off when he's forgotten this whole experience.

[@YehudiNimol]

EAT THAT BUTTER STRAIGHT FROM THE TUB YEAA

[@worstusernameintheworld9871]

@@YehudiNimol me who does that: :0

[@T0XIIK.R0T]

@@SapphireDragon357 you mean like now?

[@SapphireDragon357]

@@T0XIIK.R0T **steeples fingers** Yesssss. The time has come.

[@nervousdorito3696]

I honestly think this is one of the best segments he’s had, seeing Jack’s thought process is super interesting lol

[@csturgis]

you know his name's John, right? lol

[@codymarrott5720]

@@csturgis you know it doesn’t matter right? lol

[@HerculesBallsInc]

@@csturgis Strangely, 'Jack' is a common nickname for John. Don't look at me - I don't make the rules.

[@joinzi7708]

He has outsourced his questions and answers. Jack has everyone make content for him. Truly a genius.

[@gabrielpraslin9576]

I'm surprised he doesn't get an editor at this point

[@VideoJames1019]

He essentially became his own Fiverr editor

[@PeachysMom]

Yeah to do that and still be funny takes creativity.

[@weganmerner7014]

@@PeachysMom I think it works so well for him but he is generally funny and light hearted. I couldn't imagine other creators pulling this type of content off the way he has it formated.

[@SoftTangerineDreams]

@@weganmerner7014 He is so consistently funny too. The fact that he doesn't have more subscribers in 2021 is absolutely baffling.

[@JackWatts017]

Prolly would be my favorite YIAY of all time. I like seeing Jack challenge himself, and in turn, I think too. This is honestly pretty fun.

[@TiliaCordata]

@Joshua EdwinRoehl Stop promoting your own channel in the comments. It's obnoxious, unrelated and a bore. When you're promoting your own channel in the comments, well, it's not really a comment anymore. (...) And when you see someone promoting their own channel in the comments, mark as spam cos that's exactly what it is.

[@TiliaCordata]

It was great! Really entertaining!

[@noegiard494]

comment: specifically asks for Valjean's Soliloquy Jack: sings One Day More an edgelord

[@lillianward2810]

His Colm is pretty solid.

[@Viscidsquare040]

I can’t get over how he pronounced ‘monke’ like ‘monk’

[@brokoblin6284]

Yeah it's monk-eh

[@Letsreviewsomething]

Monks don't use technology. It wasn't the fucking meme you 12 year old. GOD!

[@memethanYT]

@@Letsreviewsomething Except Jack typed out the work ‘monke’. Bruh.

[@supremechaosbeing2696]

AND HE SPELT WOOZY LIKE WOOZIE

[@nathanstarkey743]

That's how it's pronounced tho.

[@jagamerboii6208]

"Look into a mirror..." "How to scare the shit outta myself?" I've never felt a more "same" moment before

[@djcatslovebacon]

Hello

[@jagamerboii6208]

@@djcatslovebacon hello there

[@djcatslovebacon]

@@jagamerboii6208 I was surprised to see someone liked my comment besides jack(John).

[@jagamerboii6208]

@@djcatslovebacon lmao, I didnt see your comment, sorry bro.

[@lucy9180]

jack is so old he doesn’t even know what throwing it back means

[@dame-ur1ql]

E

[@sol.f]

@@dame-ur1ql what does it mean

[@Mashu_achbard]

@@sol.f I'm pretty sure it means twerking that ass

[@dame-ur1ql]

@@sol.f E

[@datdamndog389]

Im 13 and i dont even know what it means!

[@olliequeen2127]

This is the Jacksfilmaissance y’all and we’re just living in it

[@spoopyscaryskelebones3846]

Right??? Jack’s having a blast, and so are we! :D

[@EEEEEEEE]

E‎‎‎‎

[@caoilte8097]

It all feels a bit off

[@KingOfGaymes]

@@caoilte8097 you do not believe then

[@caoilte8097]

@@KingOfGaymes don’t you talk to me with your gay flag

[@BigR.O.B.]

it absolutely SENDS me that jack has no clue what "throw it back" means

[@sk3tch156]

seriously how is nobody else commenting about this

[@thebookgoddess7380]

it’s SO funny

[@mayamoon8281]

Came here to comment that too

[@zachpike1773]

Wait what does it mean

[@purplewine7362]

What does it mean?

[@laszlopados3350]

These blind/Jacksfilms council questions made a new Renaissance to Jack and the channel. He seems livelier and happier and laughing more than ever. Me me big like.

[@patriarchofthebugsnaxfamily]

After the success of Blind YIAY, there was only one thing Johnmovies could do to up his game: *Blinder YIAY*

[@TiliaCordata]

@Joshua EdwinRoehl Stop promoting your own channel in the comments. It's obnoxious, unrelated and a bore. When you're promoting your own channel in the comments, well, it's not really a comment anymore. (...) And when you see someone promoting their own channel in the comments, mark as spam cos that's exactly what it is.

[@youknowitsmadison]

johnmovies should not be making me laugh this hard

[@discountfreddie7023]

a double blind experiment is even better than a single blind

[@daspoopenfarten_]

He did reverse YIAY. Now he's going for a REVERSER YIAY.

[@uygarkoparal7130]

And then he looks at the comments that didnt make it into yiay for a *BLINDEST YIAY*

[@bullyp]

Jack doesn’t submit the answers, he doesn’t select the answers, and now he doesn’t even make the questions. Jack, this is a new level of using your fans for content.

[@John_C_J]

Peak "work smarter, not harder".

[@blahooper]

or when they made his profile photo for free

[@danieljudahcastillo9185]

@Bobcat out of all the languages you decided to speak, you decided to speak facts.

[@darkray5662]

Watching Jack slowly descend into insanity, doubting all of his previous thoughts with every new answer and gaslighting himself at every turn is what I live for

[@tinnamchoi]

First guess: What's the worst crime against humanity? Second guess: How to die? Third guess: How to reach nirvana?

[@gabrielgeorge7039]

The fact that jack doesn’t know what “throw it back” means just shows he’s becoming an out of touch boomer

[@andrewprahst2529]

I'm 20 years old and I had to look it up. I assumed it was the verb form of #tbt

[@rugvedkulkarni1593]

What does it mean?

[@strawberryqueen0382]

@@rugvedkulkarni1593 It’s a TikTok dance

[@elcappital]

He cant hide the fact that he is a Millenial

[@pixeleric_]

I thought it was a reference to the cha cha slide lmao

[@killerkatzfoolz]

When Jack "threw" something over his shoulder, all I could think was, honey, no.

[@VanillaTried]

This Should become a different serie honestly. I fucking love this.

[@sethblack7413]

Now Jack doesn’t even make the questions anymore.

[@zviad97]

Society ☔️

[@EEEEEEEE]

Johnmovies

[@bumsicle27]

@@zviad97 socYIAYety

[@charcharbug]

this is just his idea-making process but recorded

[@jasono3679]

@@zviad97 we live in one 😔

[@Soulbeastian]

You should do this again but instead it's answers from a previous YIAY that really happened and you try to figure out/recall what YIAY it is

[@prashuchipandey5033]

I actually thought thats what he was gonna do before I watched the entire video lol

[@Soulbeastian]

Yeah same

[@simplebutpowerful]

For the first 200 YIAYs the answers are all the same (A Lightswitch, Me Me Big Boy, Jack's forehead) so it'd be impossible lol

[@alyssacooper6553]

+

[@realadriamo]

me me big boy wasn’t around for the first 200 yiays

[@mattpharois9719]

Next week on YIAY: Jack doesn’t know the question, the answers, the time, where he is, or that he’s being filmed.

[@davidagainyt4776]

Next on yiay: we're going to shoot, edit, and upload the video

[@gandalforchidea4999]

Underrated answer

[@mattpharois9719]

@@kingmankingboy8743 thanks, but how is this relevant?

[@carson9252]

A Joe Biden feature???

[@dave_is_in_hell3559]

It's just him on a couch

[@supermariostupidshow]

8:32 “eat butter strait from the tub” maybe that’s a clue” this is matpat level of theory

[@meg5323]

Day 500 of blind Jacksfilms videos: John doesn't even know when he's being recorded, the camera switches on at random. The mods are tired.

[@NinjaPastry]

Ludwig laughs maniacally in the background, Erin is drunk

[@pantrovert-x8921]

"Pole dance to hell and then give the devil a lap dance" "See not all of them are punishments" John is there something you want to tell us?

[@highdefinition450]

How is that a punishment?

[@thekingoffailure9967]

I'd sell my soul for such an experience

[@tago3860]

Exactly how is that a punishment

[@RichConnerGMN]

nice pfp

[@malonmido7675]

Wait isn’t that heaven?

[@Pixelcraftian]

He had to use his forehead for this.

[@R0man.Geck0]

What’s up checkmark

[@PocketRocket360]

What's up checkmark

[@trill-xyz]

Why you everywhere?

[@S1lv3r1]

"How should jack punish himself if he can't guess the question" would've been way better in my opinion

[@zoinks8367]

I thought it was gonna be “what’s Jack’s punishment when he goes to hell” or something like that. Anyway this was a lot of fun definitely do this again!!

[@meelo42]

i like thats its when jack goes to hell not if

[@CairnOwl]

@@meelo42 It was all the KidzBop that did him in.

[@arliebunn]

You know jack is in thinky mode when he puts his hand on the wall

[@eliezeraltshul8550]

First blind YIAY answers and now blind YIAY answers and questions. At this rate, Jack is actually going to become blind. I am worried.

[@ryzikx]

next yiay: guessing the answers AND question

[@mutecryptid]

This mans job is the internet and he doesn’t know what throw it back means 😂

[@NoNTr1v1aL]

This just proves that Jack has always been a genius.

[@JameyMcQueen]

"This just proves we're all stupid"

[@punkipatchmusic]

Big forehead big brain joke

[@Troixix]

The funniest wrong answer I'd guessed was "What's the first thing you do when you wake up in the morning?" "Become Amish"

[@galaxypedestalfan]

I too become Amish every morning

[@amariboxill9033]

I love that Jack got partly screwed over by not knowing what “throw it back” means

[@RafidW9]

Boomer moment

[@maxwell7678]

I can't believe nobody stopped him from leaving it in the video. it didn't even occur to him that he might not know what it meant. truly humiliating.

[@maestrofeli4259]

@@kaljamaha22 im 16 and I don't know

[@babbybobabs8701]

@@maestrofeli4259 It means twerk lol

[@thedp17]

Jack not knowing what "throw it back" means is straight up hilarious

[@stonkhistory3658]

“How to approach the void” *Eat cereal with water* *Become Amish*

[@coler4084]

yeah

[@keviran4079]

*throw it back*

[@galaxypedestalfan]

The Amish aren’t welcome in the void. Not after the incident.

[@hakonboen]

Comment: Do a sincere cover of Valjean's Soliloquy from Les Misérables. Jack: *Goes on to sing 'One Day More' instead*

[@HyperfixationStation]

he's a little confused but he got the spirit! XD

[@raulviii60]

Theater nerd here, I was so moved by his sincere attempt

[@Cecily_Smith4]

I want him to sing either

[@daddymememaster5432]

I want him to sing neither

[@RichardX1]

He did a pretty good job though

[@DanBalan1]

"donate blood, like 10 pints, that should do it." Immediately made me think "blood for the blood god! Wash away the sins!" That's what I knew the question

[@theaceofspades8619]

If they continue this series they should add in a Red herring answer and jack must also try and guess what the fake answer is!

[@drumpf7721]

Shoutout to that fly for making John Movies stop talking for a few seconds

[@Kdot6_16]

Best fans in the world

[@enbyishimaru]

"chugging is a punishment" 2 minutes later: "give up drinking?? Never!"

[@LivPC]

You could chug water or something, idk

[@soyeahsauce]

drinking is not chugging

[@Megabide]

Jack didn’t know what “throw it back” means, I’m dying

[@mellowthebear]

What does it mean?

[@practicallynobody5058]

@@mellowthebear it means to pay, because you throw the bill back on the plate when you pay. Say it to a waiter next time you’re at a restaurant: “Could i throw it back please?”

[@scoopishere7881]

The fact that John does not know what throwing it back means it mind boggling.

[@Itretiak05]

Jack not knowing what “throw it back” is made my day

[@saifuusuri]

"They all sound like punishments." Yeah that's usually how people pay for their sins. That's the whole point of Hell.

[@whiteface513abandonedchann8]

Yeah but he didn't know what the question was

[@edude8033]

this is single handedly the greatest video idea ever (look at replies for E)

[@EEEEEEEE]

E‎‎‎‎‎

[@davida5053]

E

[@christianmckee3614]

E

[@ccchhhaaassseee_2609]

E

[@goodnessgracious9166]

E

[@royceaxle5749]

“How do I get rid of sin?” “Throw it back”

[@framboosmatroos9392]

2020: YIAY but with blind answers 2021: YIAY but with blind answers and question 2022: YIAY but no YIAY

[@tusharlakshminarayanan3776]

Jack really doing the “what’s your angry word” YIAY again that he claims he’s so ashamed of

[@MidiMaze178]

i finally got into YIAY! mine was “gouge out both of his eyes, that way his blind videos will truly be blind”, thanks mods :)

[@jibbyjizz]

Very epic

[@DeltaGaiya]

Fitting for the character in your pfp

[@Andux]

@@DeltaGaiya Not really, if it was a neck snap joke yeah.

[@MammalianCreature]

Good one Ethan.

[@limesandlemons1367]

@@Anduxit does fit if you're counting natsukis blank blank eyes

[@Tralfazz74]

"How should Jack atone for his sins?" OMG VERBATIM 2nd to last question

[@Geck0GC]

Verbatim means he would've guessed it word for word. He didn't so it wasn't verbatim.

[@Tralfazz74]

@@Geck0GC I got it Verbatim, tho

[@Geck0GC]

@@Tralfazz74 oh I see, I thought you were talking about Jack and was very confused.

[@Tralfazz74]

@@Geck0GC Same-- I read your comment and was super confused as to what you were correcting me on. I even rewatched the end of the video to see what he said.

[@thespeedyyoshi]

NICE

[@stealthlock6634]

Right as you were factoring together “I’ll remove em for ya” and the punishment theory, I figured out both “sins” and “atone”. I am 4 parallel universes ahead of you

[@joegoodboy7183]

I had “repent” rather than “atone” so maybe I’m only 3 parallel universes ahead.

[@yamsdev]

I got it about then as well. Damn this was a fun episode.

[@yamsdev]

I got it about then as well. Damn this was a fun episode.

[@Shashu_the_little_Voidling]

How tf do you even get Atone? I don't think I've heard that word more than 5 times in my life.

[@stealthlock6634]

@@Shashu_the_little_Voidling I’m a Christian and I’m familiar with like, people using it for extra dramatic religious effect, as a meme or played straight, plus it’s a verb, for a sinner to nullify sins (get rid of them by being punished).

[@maxwellwinters5792]

Stage 1. Jack chooses the topic. The audience makes jokes for him. Jack selects them. Jack hosts the episode. Jack edits the footage. Stage 2. Jack chooses the topic. The audience makes jokes for him. Jack's mods select the jokes. Jack hosts the episode. Jack edits the footage. Stage 3. Jack's mods choose the topic. The audience makes jokes for him. Jack's mods select the jokes. Jack hosts the episode. Jack edits the footage. Stage 4. Jack's mods choose the topic. The audience makes jokes for him. Jack's mods select the jokes. Chipwich hosts the episode. Jack edits the footage. Stage 5. Jack's mods choose the topic. The audience makes jokes for him. Jack's mods select the jokes. Chipwich hosts the episode. The audience edits the footage.

[@MimiMadness94]

I’m liking your idea of chipwhich hosting

[@ashley-i3f]

You missed the very first stage, where Jack made the jokes. I don't blame you though, it was a while ago.

[@cQunc]

He already had the audience edit the footage a few times.

[@simplebutpowerful]

@@ashley-i3f that was #OldSchoolJacksfilms i.e. PMS

[@theraccoon1246]

Stage 6: some random ass dude from the streets hosts the entire thing

[@kiermacdonald9951]

He put the audio out of sync while he read the “put the audio out of sync” question lmaoo

[@randomstranger623]

5:19 for the gamers.

[@ryanbrueckner6581]

jack: “sing valjean’s soliloquy from les miserables” jack: sings one day more instead

[@MusicDecomposer]

#YIAYmad “You frickin’ fricks! When will you learn? When will you learn that your actions have consequences!?”

[@DumbDelusionalDude]

N E V E R

[@vigga5375]

OVER MY DEAD BODY

[@hahanamegobrrr6667]

this is a certified sammyclassicsonicfan moment

[@DumbDelusionalDude]

@Joshua EdwinRoehl promo reply?

[@TiliaCordata]

@Joshua EdwinRoehl Stop promoting your own channel in the comments. It's obnoxious, unrelated and a bore. When you're promoting your own channel in the comments, well, it's not really a comment anymore. (...) And when you see someone promoting their own channel in the comments, mark as spam cos that's exactly what it is.

[@MickNix]

Doesn’t know what “throw it back” means definitely a boomer.

[@Loifey]

I am a young boomer then

[@highdefinition450]

Boomer in spirit only

[@megaaizul7353]

i love how he doesnt understand the meaning of "throw it back" and it kinda threw him off lmao

[@KimballTho]

"By singing Valjean's soliloquy" [sings Valjean's part from One Day More instead of the actual solo number called Valjean's Soliloquy]

[@emeryshye9920]

This is definitely one of my favorite formats already. It was funny, captivating, and interactive for Jack and the audience. 10/10 video

[@spiltmilk0204]

i love how genuinely happy he was when he got it right lol, he’s enjoying this new layout

[@reversepsycho]

Jack not knowing what “throw it back” means speaks volumes

[@bloomabybubble]

That physically hurt to watch

[@idislikemints]

He's a boomer. Leave this poor old man alone!

[@absp2006]

I'm a boomer, too. Explain

[@batouttahell24]

@@absp2006 It’s slang for “shake that ass” or “twerk that ass”. Throwing it back is throwing your ass back.

[@KingOfGaymes]

Millennial boomer

[@real_lampcap]

We definitely need another ep of this. I loved this.

[@eu4um]

After 1st answer: What are signs someone is a psychopath? 5th questions: You just found out you’re a psychopath: what do you do? 10th: Ok it’s just Jack related.

[@akkysb]

I'm a fan of this new editing style: the subtle camera shakes, the quick zooms, etc.

[@spencerdokes6056]

Jack always be like "let's try something DIFFERENT" Can't imagine what his sex life is like

[@WhisperUK]

Sit down, breathe deeply. Now clear your mind.... you've successfully imagined it in full.

[@maestrofeli4259]

@@WhisperUK roasted

[@gedehahsen429]

nonexistent

[@MammalianCreature]

Pegged.

[@MammalianCreature]

Gotta be _pegging_

[@realityreimaginedyt]

This whole episode is just Jack finding who asked

[@ApatiteSupernova46]

I thought it was specifically "How should Jack pay for my sins?" Because that would explain why most of them were punishments, as well as why some near the end became more religious and would better explain the five dollars question- you would be literally *paying* for your sins.

[@gillesrosseel1500]

This is some kind of reverse YIAY, he should name it YAIY.

[@ryanjamesj44]

You Asked I Yesterday ;D

[@Starlightnova111]

ouY deksA I yadretseY

[@maestrofeli4259]

ouY I deksA yadretseY

[@luisguerra8852]

I love how he didn't know what "throw it back" means 💀

[@ohwoah4324]

i didn't what it meant either

[@fernandazurita2936]

@@ohwoah4324 just urban dictionary

[@andrewprahst2529]

I'm 20 and I incorrectly thought it meant to basically #tbt

[@ohwoah4324]

@@fernandazurita2936 i thought they meant it literally

[@imwithpluto]

Never figured it out, thought you were right the moment you said "what should Jack do if he gets the question wrong." This was awesome, would absolutely watch 7 more of these.

[@gunjandua4028]

He did it boys. A new series has started

[@cactus6604]

Jack's mind palace of yiay answers was amazing, he certainly has potential to be in the next Sherlock show.

[@PstrywBerryVids]

Holy shit. That was more hype than most e-sports. I need this to be a series

[@tsukikoamagiri]

I've been watching him for years but damn, his content hasn't changed that much but it feels so refreshing for some reason

[@Josh.Pointer]

Yea, we have to thank blind Yiay for that. Such a good idea

[@maxallen218]

Try a red haring edition, one of the answers is to a different question, in addition to finding the question, find the answer to the answer that doesn't belong

[@Nulono]

My guess was "What's the secret to immortality?" for a while.

[@ironicappreciation4374]

I guessed “how should Jack atone for his sins” after the first hell-based answer, around the video’s halfway mark. I feel prouder than I should

[@sillygoosetaur]

I got it around “start by saying he’s sowwy (emotional)”

[@eduardo_moya]

Ah, nice. I got it at mimite 8, so you beat me by a bit. Nice

[@irritatedengineer9654]

somehow it clicked when he said “five dollars and I’ll remove them from you directly”

[@spacebinoculars]

This is my new favourite reaction channel

[@lordmggordon]

using this comment as a feedback like the Lord intended: this video was straight up the funniest one you did lately, the idea is fantastic and I truly hope that you'll do it again

[@janban9148]

Agree, would love to see him do this again sometime

[@ayellowpapercrown6750]

Same it was very funny, I love to see Jack be confused, and he seemed to really have fun, which in turn is fun to watch. I did feel like it went on for a bit too long though. 5-6 minutes would have been a more appropriate length for the concept imo.

[@joeldaniel6186]

The Jackinator would be a suitable name for this

[@eye41see92]

The question is “how should jack be forgiven for his sins”

[@laylover7621]

Genius

[@snow4478]

this has got to be one of my favorite episodes of yiay !! definitely joining the discord now !! hope you do this again, genuinely such a fun concept.

[@araw_buwan]

Seeing the growth of this channel makes me so happy

[@Sohaib72742ify]

Jacksfilms on his wedding night: I'm going in very blind

[@iMdwag]

My guess: What’s Jack’s punishment for his creation of Jack to the Future.

[@andriwilliam7474]

This show should be called YTAY (Yesterday, They Ask You) because you're not the one who's asking us the question

[@pineconesnowstorm]

YTAY: You're The Asshole Yes