Guitar Gear: When to Buy and When to Sell

[@RickBeato]

I think my favorite video of yours. Someone said you are a guitar therapist. That nails it.Excellent Hypes!

[@doctiberius2717]

Serious self help groups apply here.... click click 🤐

[@tomahoks]

Yo, The Rick, hi

[@hkguitar1984]

Spot on Rick. Keith's videos really do seem to challenge some of my accepted Dogmas concerning music/gear. I find myself thinking and rethinking many aspects from a new perspective/point of view. It seems to me that these videos are much more productive than 45 minutes with a Therapist. Now I am challenging myself, need more gear because the more I learn the farther the "Goal Posts" move concerning that "Tone" I'm searching for! Great work Keith, please don't stop what you're doing.

[@thesteelstrummer2307]

This deserves a heart!

[@andrelousada]

I agree!

[@edwardwagner4447]

I recently sold an amplifier on Reverb. In a small world type of thing, a former college professor of mine bought it. As I watched this video for at least the 5th time, I realized that chatting with him when he came to pick it up actually brought me more joy than the amp ever did.

[@fivewattworld]

That’s great. Excellent story.

[@michaeleaster1815]

Can we celebrate the "Used with permission" on the BoBeats clip. A tiny nuance that exemplifies how thoughtful this channel is, in the large. Great stuff...

[@strumminronin]

"Feeling safe" vs "Musicianship" The Truth, has been spoken. Thank you!

[@brianpublow329]

This is hands down my favorite guitar channel on KZbin, and that's saying something given how many great guitar channels are here. I appreciate you taking the time to so thoroughly and thoughtfully address these common struggles and I find that the thinking applied to gear acquisition and usage can also be applied to my other hobbies and interests.

[@fivewattworld]

That's great to hear Brian! Yeah, it applies to lots of corners of my own life to, sort of a "serial obsessive" myself. But hey you have to dive deep then come back up for air right? It took me a long time to realize that I started doing this to play music, mostly with other people, and now how much stuff I could fit in the extra bedroom. Thanks for watching,. Keith

[@cruzthree8883]

Darn it, you are right. I think I'm going cry now. Then I'll buy a new piece of gear to make me feel better.

[@fivewattworld]

That’s the spirit!

[@hmarkison]

"Don't buy gear to become productive." If I had heard that a long time ago it would have saved me a ton of money. And everything else in this vid is right on. Great insights. This could save a lot of money on therapy too.

[@blakevanhouten1672]

This is one of the most important videos for guitar players. What stuck out to me most. “Don’t buy gear unless you’re already being productive.” I often will fall into the trap, “if I have this piece of gear I’ll be able to do ....” will be coming back to this video for reminders from time to time. Thank you thank you.

[@TheDunateen77]

This is without a doubt the best guitar channel on KZbin,no agendas no bs just straight honest advice and wisdom,I've learned a lot from this channel!

[@justharry2190]

buy gear - when you can afford instant noodles sell gear - when you need money for instant noodles

[@jean-philippemorin1176]

Instant noodle is the key.

[@anthonynonya]

Came for a gear video, and got a psychology lesson. And I needed it, thank you.

[@digitalbrand5510]

I figured out how come I don’t sell my gear. People criticize the instruments as an effort to get a reduction in price while trying them out. I had a 50’s Martin and a 60’s Camaro viewing this week, they are in amazing condition. The potential buyers wore me out and I took them off the market, I was really not asking top market value anyway. This content and information is really helpful right now. You are a thoughtful and practical fella!

[@Blueguitar007]

Exactly my experience. They offer nothing for amps claiming it will someday need maintenance. With guitars they eyeball like a painting bought for the museum. It's too stressful and exhausting to sell my good stuff. Other cheaper things., pedals or PA stuff I just price ridiculously low to get rid of it.

[@philsmith3019]

Buyers just wanna low-ball you, sellers wanna rip you off for a profit.

[@cgrovespsyd]

I’m a psychologist, and I can tell you that you’re spot on. Although I can also tell you that these have been my thoughts for many years, my quest for gear took the place of actually playing. If I used the same amount time practicing or playing with other people, as opposed to researching gear, I would be much, much better than I am now (and much, much happier). As I always say, “Here, take my advice, I’m not using it!”

[@doctiberius2717]

Yeah but every time I do a gig guys want to play my guitar and use my gear so I must be doing something right. Right? Like you I did all the hard work putting it all together I'm the only one who should enjoy playing it. If I sell it to anyone who asks then I will need to start over. Right?

[@doctiberius2717]

Excuse me I got some serious GAS going on!

[@cgrovespsyd]

Doc Tiberius My wife should make out pretty well when I croak. I buy high end used but get a good deal so it should sell for at least what I pay for it!

[@doogdoogdoogdoogdoogdoog]

I love how much clarity both your message and your delivery have, so enjoyable.

[@fivewattworld]

Thanks Doog!

[@fivewattworld]

Yeah I just wanted to be able to say "Doog". Great nickname!

[@doogdoogdoogdoogdoogdoog]

@@fivewattworld _why, thank y'all_

[@frankscutari9516]

Once again I can't believe how well thought-out and level-headed your responses are. It's five watt World from a hundred-watt brain, excellent job keep up the good work!

[@macsarcule]

I’ve rewatched this probably 4 times since you first released it and I hope I continue rewatching it, because it always makes me rethink what I’m doing and what makes me happy when I play guitar. I’ve not been a gigging musician for decades, but sincerely enjoy the physical activity of playing guitar. The sound, the feel of the resonance, and the instruments themselves in my hands. This video makes me zero-in on what guitars really bring me that joy. And even if I should keep my beloved custom Collings I-35 Deluxe that I lusted after, finally got, and like so many premium gear purchases, would struggle to live up to the expectations I created in my mind. It’s a beauty and plays well, but when your mind is turning something into magic, what could live up to one’s imagination. 🙂 The same thing happened to me with a vintage Gibson 335 I bought in the early 2000s - it was so exciting to finally get what I thought was my dream guitar, but as anyone who’s dabbled in vintage gear knows, there’s always some baggage that comes with the wear and tear of vintage gear. It couldn’t really live up to the expectations I had, and maybe more importantly, the fit, finish, and performance of even affordably-priced new gear. This video made me decide to get a very good professional setup done on the Collings, see if there’s anything special there beyond my other 335 style guitars (a natural finish Heritage & a green Ibanez that’s always punched way above its weight as a ‘budget guitar’ - it’s truly amazing how good that guitar is), and if the setup doesn’t make a big difference, probably sell the Collings. After I mull it over for a year, of course. 🙂 Knowing what you love about playing and maybe why you love it, is everything to prioritizing what to keep. Your channel helps keep me as sane as a gear hungry guitarist can be. Love this channel and the community you’ve created here. I don’t participate with comments in your livestreams, but I’m also the guy who would hang out at the local guitar shops just to quietly listen to the conversation everyone else is having and consider it for my own decisions. That’s an important value in community too. Maybe I’m a lurker, but I think of myself more as a listener who really appreciates the comments of everyone else in this community. 🙂 Thanks for excellent videos like these, Keith, that never stop being valuable. That’s some really good stuff and your hard work is so helpful! ✌️😌🎸

[@laughingdaffodils5450]

"the only thing you can't replace is a drummer who doesn't overplay." :D

[@ballsrgrossnugly]

Or a Bassist with a rock solid tempo lock.

[@markranalli4994]

Amen to that. You couldnt be more right!!

[@seamanjive]

Does such a drummer even exist?

[@joebowles06]

@@seamanjive Yep. It's called the Digitech SDRUM.

[@woohooo9984]

The best drummer is the one that doesn’t use cymbal

[@bikeguy247]

Sentimental first guitar, played in Chicago late 60’s band...eventually life and lack of use leads to sale...many, many years later, the search for ‘That’ guitar comes true over Reverb. Story of love lost and found.

[@PanDownTiltLeft]

Nice video. In over 40 years of playing I have never sold a single item. I still have the first guitar I ever bought. It's rare when I make a purchase but it's always well researched and I take the time to ensure there will not be any buyer's remorse. For me, buyer's remorse tends to occur mostly when a purchase decision is emotionally based.

[@shawnadams1693]

Same here! The only things I’ve ever sold are a bass and bass amp, after keeping them for 20+ years and not using them. I used that money to gut and upgrade my first guitar from tip to tip.

[@matthewkelly8039]

Yes, yes, and yes you nailed it again. You have a great way of putting together complex thoughts and emotions, and making them easy to digest and understand. I truly believe that videos like this are your best work. And , I would love to see and hear more from you about music and music making. Thank you, I will reply this often to remind me what gear I really “need.”

[@yestoES355]

These recent vids have been simply amazing. Absolutely amazing content and knowledge.

[@jsantos1104]

Gear Acquisition Syndrome (G. A. S. ) is a real thing, and I think we all suffer from it. I just came to a realization about sentimental value. Thanks to you, I’ve just been inspired to take inventory of all my gear that continues to collect dust. Great video as always, keep it up!

[@tomp538]

Word! I don't play and have never owned a guitar, or other musical instrument. But substitute motorcycles and I'm right there. Really enjoy your insights...

[@fivewattworld]

Yeah man. Should I do the video about my years of building and riding my Duc at track days (also now sold off a few years back.) So I hear you brother.

[@philipkeohane2652]

For Sale: 2002 Triumph Daytona 1999 Triumph Legend TT 2001 Ducati 900 SS (+ track skins, transponder, tire warmers) 1971 Moto Guzzi California CHP (basket case retirement project) 1973 Moto Guzzi Eldorado (sidecar host; its the dog’s bike) 2006 Ducati 999R (living room model/exercise bike; if it goes I’ll have more room for guitars and amps! The other six I’m keeping; 1 for each day of the week. I came within millimeters of pulling the trigger on a Fender 57’ Champ reissue to/yesterday; support my habits, buy my bikes! ....will also consider trades for vintage watches, guns, Scandinavian home furnishings, and audioPHILe equipment. ....at least they all have support groups. 😔

[@nickbricks57]

11:48 the comment about realising that the memory of the instrument is not attached to it to me was really important. this is what lead to me selling my first electric and first acoustic guitars because even though I don't have them anymore I realised that I'll always remember the time I played that acoustic for my grandma when she was bedridden, and when I picked it out in the shop. and the Jazzmaster, well I'll always remember my first ever live show where they tweaked the amp during the performance and gave me too much gain. this is what I needed to keep in mind and it might contribute to me selling my Ibanez in the coming months.

[@MinivanMegafun100]

I hadn't broken a string in like, 10 years. I decided to go to a gig without the backup guitar. What happens? String broke.

[@dainhuston]

At a Jr. Brown show great line " Mey ! No reason to stop the party it's only one string "

[@theprismaticsystem2833]

Unless it's a floating trem without a stabilizer, then the whole instrument is out of tune, lol.

[@SnowyFinland]

Truer words have seldom been said. My fondest band-related memories were had via this ragtag rig: Ibanez 59er through Marshall Lead 12 as preamp for JC120 through some old horn-loaded 2-12 PA cabs with cerwin vegas.

[@bleikrsound6127]

About 30 years ago Brian May told me a guitar is like a lover - best to find that 'one' and play it forever. Every guitar in Brian's on stage line-up is a temp, until his tech can restring (or whatever), and return his Red back to him.

[@johnsmith-bk4ps]

Have you heard the tone of his guitar? I,l stick with my own convictions!

[@robertpratt8196]

I look at my collection and think, "I should sell some of these," but I know the minute I do I'll think, "Dang, I wish I still had my SG, 335, tele, PRS, etc."

[@albertomartinez2479]

A friend was talking about guitars. He mentioned that in the early 70s he sold a 1963 Fender Jazz Master for $150, $150!

[@doctiberius2717]

@@albertomartinez2479 shoot!

[@longlivegarybusey6409]

Only guitar I've ever sold was an olympic white john mayer signature strat I purchased new for $1600 one night when I was black out drunk. I had to call the company the next day and ask them what I'd purchased after seeing the invoice. I played metal at the time and didn't appreciate how amazing of a strat this actually was, especially if you were going to own just one. I needed rent money and never played it so I sold it on ebay to a guy for $1100 with the case and all of the accessories. Few years later John left Fender for PRS and they now go used for $2500-$3000. I've purchased/built dozens of strats since then trying to convince myself that I don't need it, that I can build a better one that is more personalized to me....doesn't work. Every time I see one pop up on reverb I feel sick to my stomach.

[@dkpitt3912]

Do you know Keith, listening to this right now as opposed to a long time ago when it came out makes it really poignant. Playing with people. Everything about being with people. Great insight!

[@fivewattworld]

Thanks DK. I’m feeling this as well.

[@Kahunaeducation]

Nice. I think you've articulated that nagging suspicion most of us have about shopping/hoarding, getting distracted from the job at hand, which is playing music with people.

[@James-zy5lh]

I fell into the hoarding trap when I was younger. At one point, between guitars and basses, I owned around 21-22 instruments. It was awesome to walk into the room that housed all of them, but I began to find myself spending more time trying to choose which to play than time spent actually playing them. In the end, I kept the 4 that actually saw the most use. I became far more productive, and I enjoyed the process of playing much more. Occasionally, I still find myself listing after new gear, and I have gone through the process of selling off gear to buy new pieces, but I am always cognizant of the KISS method and not overdoing it with anything. Great video and great channel. This is like music therapy!

[@fivewattworld]

Thanks James! Yeah I was the first in line for the “therapy” the rest is just sharing stories. Thanks for watching. Keith

[@johnsmith-bk4ps]

22 instruments is fine if they are well chosen. A ric 12,a dobro,a 335,a martin d18 , les Paul, strat ,tele, travis bean, bellzouki, guild 12. Silvertone. Many instruments but each one has its own sound. It's not hoarding its variety

[@cockysonuvaB]

@@johnsmith-bk4ps Sounds like you need help! 🎸😃

[@marsattacks7071]

As always, great comments Keith ! Everybody is over buying all sort of stuff... Sometimes, it takes a few years to realize that we have that kind of addiction. I was part of that problem too then, I rolled over a huge bump in my life and money was simply not there anymore. Back to the basics, to the roots ! I'm happy to be back on the ground and not only concerning musical instruments or hifi equipment (...) but as a general behavior. I'm 54 now. It takes time to get a little bit ''intelligent'' on that matter. Most of the people won't get there since I believe it takes a drama in your life to start appreciating the small things alone. Thanks for the video and keep on doing them ! There's a lot to learn with your words. Cheers !

[@j_freed]

I think our best guitar is the one we just try and unexpectedly buy, as opposed to thinking we need *this* exact spec of Strat or whatever and *chasing the elusive guitar we're SO sure we need.* The truth is *we don't know what we have to buy beforehand, that's just an idea in our head. Then a guitar finds us.* So now I just play a Tele with a big soft V neck on it, impeccably set up by a pro thanks to the fellow who sold it to me. He tweaked it well. It was just not HIS guitar after all, and many guitars have to pass through a few hands to find their owner so it found ME. . Perhaps owning dozens of guitars is fun but gets in the way more than accomplish anything. Having said that - *DO own some guitars. I think it's better to a) enjoy them at while and sell them at a loss* than b) never try them or c) hoard them like dead capital. Allow yourself to buy and sell - and have a life.

[@johnsmith-bk4ps]

I buy vintage. I've never sold for a loss. And I have hangers. Guitars are easy to grab and play and they are never in the way.

[@upload2352]

Great issue to address. My rationalized justification for excess gear - trying to figure out what I want to focus on. I'm a late starter, more money than experience/talent and too little time left on the planet to make mistakes - I've heard a lot of experienced players say they wished they'd never gotten rid of this or that, or that they'd known about this or that back when they started, they wasted time on the wrong neck size, etc. I love 6 string guitar - all of it - classical, acoustic, electric. But what to get? There are so many variables, and no time to waste, so get it all. 1 3/4" neck, 1 11/16", too. "C" and "D" and "V" profiles, HBs, singles/P90s, strat style and tele and LP, scale lengths, etc. Cheap guitars, some expensive. Acoustic tonewoods? Sure - get spruce, cedar and mahogany, but in what body sizes? After a couple of mistakes, that one's solved - I like GC size. I also prefer 1 11/16 necks, now, but what about "later," when I become proficient in fingerstyle? "Everyone" says 1 3/4 or wider is best to do it right, so I got those, but they feel awkward compared to the 1 11/16 at this early level of experience. If I sell my awesome 1 3/4" necks, will I have regret at letting go of that beautiful Taylor12 fret LTD (1 of 50) spruce/walnut w/maple binding/inlays to die for (oh, yeah, I've got 14 and 12 fret, GC and parlor)? That Recording King with the 1 13/16 and 2 5/16 is gnarly wide for me today, but "someday" it *might* be exactly what I need/want, so no sense getting rid of it, right? It was cheap. Les Paul is not a great lap guitar (I have 2 - "real" and an Agile with 1 3/4 neck) - keep or kill if I currently seem to prefer the tele body and play sitting down? But LPs are iconic! The handmade boutique strat is heavy and big, but sounds/plays great and is beautiful - anybody else would kill for it, but I have to remind myself it's there (and happy when I do), so that's not good. Still, everyone should have a strat, right? Semi-hollow, fully hollow, solid body? Yes. Wait, did I mention bound vs. unbound necks (I'm leaning toward unbound)? Full HBs vs. mini HBs? That's how I ended up with 22 guitars since starting guitar 2+ years ago. Too much time on gear, too little on playing, I'm afraid. Before I get into the "amps" portion of my program (yes, I have multiple low-end S/S and 1 cheap tube, but, thankfully, no pedals), I'll just say "great series" that's hitting a lot of my pressure points. A lot of this is FOMO, I know, but I also don't want to dump a bunch of gear now to feel cleansed, only to have take the time/money later to reacquire stuff if/when needs/wants actually change! I don't need the $ from the gear, but would like to focus more on learning than the gear. Thanks for helping me work through it.

[@Bliggick]

The time to sell that amp that keeps breaking down: when it's working.

[@joeyfarley9916]

Love your channel Rick was right a year ago, your a guitar therapist, you seriously have helped me see through all the hype of gear and really focus in on what I will really use and now I have an excellent rig that will last me for years to come.

[@fivewattworld]

That’s excellent Joey!

[@ThorneyedWT]

At first I wanted to argue with something, but then you just made really good points. Not that I never knew it, just maybe didn't want to admit. To be specific, I want to arrange same sort of band jamming room myself, but currently I don't have anyone to jam with =/

[@fivewattworld]

Thorneyed I hear you. We moved this summer and I’m still getting a sense of the scene here, finding people to play etc. Have you looked at “meet up”, someone recommended it to me when we lived way out in the mountains.

[@ThorneyedWT]

@@fivewattworld thank you for advice, but seems like that app is not really popular in our country =( Well, I meet people who like music, but really few who like it enough to progress after learning cowboy chords, and everyone I know so far already has own band or has no time to play. I could actually go and play bass, but I am much worse on it than on guitar and don't really want to switch. Anyway, thanks to you I have some things to think about.

[@Nb0ssProductions]

Having some enforced quiet time lying in a hospital bed and stumbled across this channel. These are wise words and made me realise some home truths. For years of my adult life I collected expensive gear that I could not have afforded as a teenager (when I did play in a band). I never played much, being wrapped up with work and family for decades. I had the opportunity in my late forties to join a local rock academy to get ready for a corporate battle of the bands I had bravely signed up for. That experience got me involved in a vibrant local music scene and I have been able to spend time playing music "with other humans" in local venues (and occasionally being paid a few bucks). This is what it is about. I still collect gear but I am trying to limit it to support "being productive". I recently cleared out my collection of stuff, for example, having admitted I was never going to actually use my National Resolectric , no matter how beautiful it looked. Please keep up the good work

[@fivewattworld]

Hey Nick, laying in a hospital bed gave me time to think about this as well. Best wishes brother. Let me know if I can do anything for you. Keith

[@DanPeacock]

Something I heard on the Wampler "Chasing Tone" video: "More Mel Bay and less eBay".

[@fivewattworld]

Ha! That's so great! Was that Brian? That sounds like him.

[@DanPeacock]

Travis :)

[@zachallthetime7228]

Before coming across your channel I rage purged/minimized my gear down to two guitars (a 20 year old seagull cedar solid top and a Fender Mexi strat, two of the first guitars I ever bought), 2 cables, 2 pedals, and 1 of those smart type practice amps. My playing has advanced more in the last two weeks then in the last 10 years. This because everything you have said in this video is absolutely true. I will be rewatching this video as reinforcement of this new mentality and am really pleased to have found your channel!

[@fivewattworld]

Nice to have you as a part of five watt world Zachary. I rewatch this video on occasion myself. Its why I made it really, to remind myself. :)

[@msenecal]

You have put into words what has been rattling around in my head. Just don't expect Guitar Center to offer you a position as a marketing executive.

[@jdsjunkdrawer]

I love that Noah Guthrie track you used on the into Keith! That group is seriously under rated. Love the content dude keep it up!

[@jessemarkovitz1549]

Please do a video on the AC 10!!! I’d love to see how you run it or if you’ve done any mods!

[@mustakissa2221]

What about AC4, 4 Watt World?

[@joshuacondon1]

This is one of the best guitar channels on this platform, you guys are doing a great job

[@fivewattworld]

Thanks. But “you guys” is pretty much me…along w the friends I beg to come along. :)

[@JeeWeeDonkers]

"The only thing you can't replace us a drummer that doesn't overplay." Now that is wisdom!

[@barbmelle3136]

From Leo: Good subject, good observations. If I lose interest in a guitar, I'll store it a year and try it again. If I still cannot bond with it, it goes away. If I cannot get a good price for it, I save it until some kid at church is really trying his best but really needs a better guitar or amp. I get a lot more out of giving it away to a good home than taking 25 or 30 cents on the dollar as a trade. Of course you have to be ready to see your mint condition natural flame maple top guitar painted flat black and wearing stickers sometimes, but it is good to see it being loved.

[@doctiberius2717]

Hahaha... Bless you!

[@themusicindustrialcomplex]

Some priceless wisdom. Thanks!

[@troyoswald5683]

Thank you Keith.The way you set this up and explained it; perfection. How lucky we are.

[@earthprisoner]

Hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way...thought I'd something more to say...

[@pmac3025]

This was definitely a good YT video loaded with great informations. I’ve changed my way of thinking and using guitar or music gear after many years of breaking the bank. I fell down the rabbit hole of boutique gear and also seeking the holy grail of guitar tone. Even thought I still have GAS for some new fresh gear, especially pedals. In the last few years if I have any intentions of buying new gear it means some gear as to go to finance it. Any unused gear also as to go. To conclude let’s not forget the most important part of it all. You should learn how to use and get the most out of the gear you already own. Buying the newest and hyped gear won’t make you a better player. Cheers, and thanks for taking some of your precious time to share your own experience with the rest of the world on KZbin.

[@duffypratt]

There are dopamine rushes both from shopping for something and, more so, from buying it. Thus, while buying the guitar may not lead to any long term happiness, it definitely provides a short term rush. And that’s what addicts are after. Somewhere, Paul Reed Smith called pedals “crack for guitar players.” A corollary to your first guitar principle is first in a new style. If you decide you want to play John Fahey stuff and you only have an LP, then you might need another guitar. Or Fernando Sor. But this is an area where people fool themselves a lot, and use the style difference as an excuse. As a personal example, I’m toying with some gypsy jazz, and would love to get a Selmer copy. But is it really that big a difference over my Archtop played acoustically? Truthful answer is that I don’t know, and I am not even sure that I need to know.

[@bassrun101]

This is Garry not Linda. I'm trying to remember who it was that idolized van Halen. They got to play a show with them one time and Eddie let him play his rig. He said wow, this is my chance to sound just like Eddie van Halen. He said he started to play and he didn't sound like him at all. What came out of the system sounded just like his own playing. It isn't the instrument, the rig or anything else it's how it's played. No matter what you do, you'll always sound like you. Make it the best you can.

[@rushrulz65]

That was very well done. Glad Beato and Shull led me to 5 watt world. You really have a brilliant channel.

[@paulspencer2892]

I know people who sold their Les Paul 20yrs ago and really regret it!!! I should sell a couple of cheap ones I have

[@SpiderStratagemVI]

I wish for one day I could have also the guitars, basses, other instruments I had at one time and sold or traded...

[@mjplanet2902]

it is great that you reflect over this so openly - I can follow every single statement you made - I have run through several stages of "addictive" behavior until I decided that learning to play well is more important and more satisfying than buying new gear or always following the new developments of the industry. I am making great progress in plyning now and mostly end my time with my guitar with a smile on my face or just peace in mind. And yet there are days that the beast of must have crowls out of his cage and whispers what I need - and sometimes its still gets me - but one think has changed - my descision process has become more profund and my descision for gear are just better - I like what you say - great stuff.

[@fivewattworld]

You’re a good writer Michael, very vivid. Thanks for watching and thanks for commenting.

[@corneliuscrewe8165]

What is this “sell” you speak of? 😁😂

[@jaywhy91]

Wow I wasn't expecting so much wisdom in a video about guitar gear. Hedonic adaptation, fomo, playing with other humans, sentimental attachment, all great stuff! I actually just made a big purchase on an amp today, and so much of what you said applies to me.

[@funnyfarmband4410]

This may sound rare, but recently I toyed with the idea of selling one of my guitars. My wife would not allow it.

[@jts3339]

Cameron Taylor: Either you married a winner or she’s overwhelmed with guilt about something she bought that you don’t know about yet.

[@marktheshark99]

Same thing happened to me. I think guys just play up the whole wife thing a bit to be funny.

[@funnyfarmband4410]

She said that they are all a part of me and each have their own story and that one day one of our kids may want to have one to have a part of that story and a part of me.

[@jts3339]

Cameron Taylor: I think my wife might have said something like that 18 years and 3 kids ago. If you’re not a newlywed and she’s still like that she is an exceptional and loving wife. Cheers to both of you!

[@funnyfarmband4410]

jts3339 just had our 5 year anniversary. Thank you

[@rconcha3]

I swear your videos are like watching an introspection of my life. This one may be my favorite...so far.

[@jamesthe-doctor8981]

"Hedonic adaptation." Cool. Knowing this isn't at all likely to affect my lifelong pattern of buying instruments, gear, and many things I've known for decades won't make me happy or change anything in my life in any important way...but at least I now know what to call it. 😂

[@zackguitar07]

Fantastic video, Keith! I second what others have already said about your videos being therapeutic and the antithesis of every other gear channel out there. I both followed and ignored the advice about "fear of missing out" and "sell what you don't play" because I lusted after a limited edition thinline Tele. I've dreamed of having a Tele for years and happened to have an Epiphone double neck for 14 years that I played less than 14 times total and sold it towards the Tele. One of the best gear decisions I've ever made.

[@TheVirginianRambler]

“The only thing you can’t replace is a drummer who doesn’t overplay” - Keith Williams

[@jts3339]

How about an endlessly noodling bass player?

[@doctiberius2717]

@@jts3339 he can be replaced LoL It has been said that most bass players are frustrated lead guitarists. If that's the case and your not into Jazzy shiz, you must get rid..... hahaha!

[@jts3339]

Doc Tiberius: Thanks for validating my feelings about this noodling jackass. At the next band meeting he agrees to stand quietly between songs from now on or suffer your consequences!

[@TheVirginianRambler]

jts3339 did my comment just get a bass player kicked out of a band???

[@fivewattworld]

Ha! You’ve got to be careful out there. Besides, bass players are scarce up here in the north.

[@B_rendan_G]

I straight up needed this. It made me think, laugh, and learn. Appreciate all you do.

[@powertuber3.047]

"the only thing you can't replace is a drummer who doesn't overplay." You mean like Keith Moon? ;-)

[@fivewattworld]

Ha! No, I've played in some jazz settings that brought that forward. And of course it's a joke. I love the great fusion drummers. Probably the definition of overplay really. Are you a drummer? Just asking. :)

[@albionseed4866]

Well, if Max Roach was my drummer I would keep my mouth shut. Instead I'll keep mumbling 'behing the beat' and several curse words. 😊😊

[@gunsandguitars6678]

when I go out I set up a full stack with a two-tier pedalboard in front I do that because I want the visual of a big band I still have my first amp. I smile everytime I look at it 1973 Sun 190L 5 foot tall I taught a lot of girls how to play guitar on that amp^ and it still works. I thought about selling an old pedal then my band broke up started another band and they wanted to do Robin Trower and I was happy I still had my rotovibe been thinking about buying a 212 combo amp instead of lugging a full stack on stage but I can't get myself to do it ¿ love the vids keep rocking ☆

[@leoburke8466]

I heard Guitar Center and Sam Ash put a hit out on you. The truth will set you free!

[@fivewattworld]

Oh I’m still a good customer, well if average my entire life together with now.

[@golfhound]

Dear Keith. great video, great advice. A method I use to keep from buying tons of stuff is I have a music budget/piggy bank. After having acquired my setup, I only use money for new equipment from gig revenue or selling stuff I don't need. Unfortunately, we guitarists suffer from too much GAS (guitar acquiring syndrome). But need is far different than want. And the internet makes the "want" very easy. I like your one year rule.

[@rillloudmother]

If somebody sucks at playing guitar, do they really need a delay pedal? lol

[@joebowles06]

No. How do I know? I suck and own a delay pedal that I have no business owning.

[@rillloudmother]

@@joebowles06 it was a rhetorical question...

[@hamiltonmays4256]

@@rillloudmother Of course it was , but what a great bonus answer from joebowles06. Thanks, Joe. That was amusing af.

[@rillloudmother]

@@hamiltonmays4256 you are easily amused

[@hamiltonmays4256]

@@rillloudmother Yes. Yes I am. And I like it like that.

[@greglivo]

Another wonderful philosophical video. I've never sold a guitar but do regret selling several amps. However when I think about the amps, every one of them I traded in was for a better amp or an upgrade guitar. There was one Peavey cabinet that I sold because I was moving and didn't have room but that doesn't really count (and seriously, who would miss a Peavey cabinet anyway?) A lot of the concepts in this video apply to collecting. One of my other hobbies is collecting antique Lionel toy trains. I would constantly go to swap meets, hobby shops, or on ebay and buy more stuff for my collection. There would be this great adrenaline rush when I would leave the swap meet with my bag full of new additions to my collection, or when my ebay purchase arrived in the mail. I would look over each piece, maybe do a little cleaning or repair, and then add it to my collection. After several years of this I realized I was just "putting them on the pile". They sat in boxes and didn't bring me much joy other than occasionally digging through them and rediscovering what I had. I decided that I had enough trains and stopped buying them for the most part. It follows your comment in another video that you don't have to own everything that you think is beautiful. Thanks again for another deep thinking video about guitars, and well actually life. You seem like a super cool dude.

[@rnemchev]

I have a simple rule: I buy when I want it and when I can afford it. Just simple as like that.

[@doctiberius2717]

Simples!

[@BollocksUtwat]

Probably works well with people who have the discipline to make "When I can afford it" a rational state of mind.

[@thomasgreen8532]

Good word. I have a couple of Banjo I acquired more than 40 years ago. Thinking if the right person comes along I would break it out and play them again. It never happened. My wife is learning to play a mandolin. I may finally have someone to play with.

[@FreddyFuFu]

buy carefully, almost never sell.

[@mrjohnp555]

Very good observations, and you are spot on that playing is the thing, not collecting and messing with gear. I have known deep inside that these things are true, but I never noticed before that GAS is at its most insidious when you are stressed in life- as you've pointed out.

[@mikeellis8385]

Stop. Don't watch this. Go buy more gear. Enjoy Life. Jam out, Rock on!

[@AllTheCoolNamesAreTaken84]

This was really eye opening for me. I’ve been accumulating gear in the hopes of forming or joining a band in the future. Feel like I just have to stop procrastinating and get down to it. I have an Orange head going into a 1x12 cab with a Celestion V30 speaker, a pedalboard with 7 pedals, an acoustic and 5 different styles of electric guitar. I feel like that’s enough to at least get started, but I never TRULY feel that way. This video really helped to change my way of thinking. Thank you!

[@philfrank5601]

Every guitarist needs to hear this message. Even if I may never get there myself, it's really the truth.

[@davidaylsworth8964]

This is the best video I’ve watched in more than a year. It applies to more than guitar equipment. Along with my guitars, I’ve got telescopes and cameras and other stuff coming out the wazoo, most of which I rarely use. After watching this video I’ve concluded that I could (and should) sell it all to fund that lusted for next thing. Your descriptions of some of the thought and emotional factors really draws a sharp focus on facets of my behaviour that I’d never before considered. Thanks for the eye-opener Keith.

[@fivewattworld]

Thanks David. These are me wrestling with the problem of too many years of chasing "stuff" when I started to do all of this to play music (of course). Glad it resonated and that you enjoyed it. Keith

[@13Hangfire]

Wow! This is one of the best equipment videos I've ever seen! You actually put things into prospective in a way that even musicians will understand!

[@JordanPurcell92]

This video gave me many hard looks at myself, and a perspective I don't think I will ever forget. Thanks for sharing this wisdom!

[@fivewattworld]

Thanks Jordan

[@zazoomatt]

Spent A lot of time watching "Bo Beats" on KZbin...........taught me a LOT. Thank You Keith Williams.................ALL Good.

[@stiqsify]

I have needed to hear this. I came to the determination that I don't need the 18 guitars I have. I decided I would significantly cut back. I struggled with everything you talk about here. The last holdout is sentimental value. I am determined to cut back. Thanks for the inspiration

[@lueyteledeluxe7457]

I just got back into guitars a little under a year ago - after a 15 year hiatus. In this short time, I have acquired 4 guitars, 2 amps, and half a dozen pedals. Plus paraphenalia. I had no idea that I was falling headlong for the oldest trap in the book. Thanks for getting me hip to this, Keith - I just wish you had intercepted me on my first trip to the guitar store...!!

[@nathanmielke1977]

These videos are the greatest reality check. My wife loves you... for better for worse... But it really does give me a reflection on my own personal gear journey. Only buy gear when you're already productive. Word to live by. I really do take a focused approach on my rig. I try and only buy (and sell) the items that are necessary (or lack usefulness). 5 Watt World is my conscience.

[@suriyakodeswaran1353]

I really appreciated some of the philosophical concepts your presented. This video is more than just about guitars.

[@apeshkhanal6773]

I have been playing guitar for 2 years in this coming August. I'm 18 and I have one strat 10 watt amp and i borrow acoustic from my friend. I have one multi effect. That's all i want to if you're satisfied by your stuff then you can live with it.

[@HeadHunterJujujaja]

Darn, I think you hit the point every single time. About a year ago I had a conversation in which I discussed selling all my guitars (22) and amps (6) and getting a really good rig. Well sold 16 guitars and five amps. I got an amazing rig and could not be happier.

[@fivewattworld]

Nice! I’m in a similar place. Feels great. Keith

[@Okla_Soft]

Couldn’t say it any better myself, this channel is up there with the very best on KZbin, gear, philosophy, history and entertainment all wrapped up in a smart , enjoyable package. Bravo...I leave this playing on my TV on sundays and just enjoy.

[@fivewattworld]

Thanks Nick!

[@k-ondoomer]

You quelled the hardest case of gas I've ever had. I was about to just go and buy an hss strat when I I came across this video. Settled my ass down quick and left me thinking. Thanks

[@briandamagespg3728]

Great video! I’ve been having this urge to buy new gear recently, a few things I’ve found helpful: - When I lose interest in a guitar I own, I put it in the cupboard for a month or two, and then pull it out and see if it still has the right feel to it. - I like to invest in bringing a bit of love back to my existing collection - restringing, buying new straps and cleaning out the electronics. By showing the guitars a bit of love, it reminds me of what I first liked about them. - When I want to buy a new guitar, I do a bit of research first and then sit on it for a few weeks. Chances are I’ll totally forget about it after two weeks. - I try to avoid going to play one in a shop until I’m definitely ready to buy, it’s too easy to get caught up in the moment. - I try to look into why I’m getting the urge. Am I just bored, do I need to find a new hobby or do something new, why do I just resort to buying things to fill the void? I have friends that churn a lot of secondhand gear and it works great for them, but I’ve always tended to buy new gear and get too attached to it to pass it on.

[@Tedroy]

I love that you built a space and had no band. You're awesome! I recently sold off a rather spendy Fender Jazz Bass and bought 2 Sire basses for the same money. A 5 fret bass and a 4 Fretless. I've always wanted a proper fretless and the 5 works in the reggae band I'm with. So I'm pretty happy with the move.

[@FrancisFurtak]

So true! Although i wish I still had all of those guitars that I got rid of in the 60's. Funny thing is I was going through my guitars in their cases and discover one that I totally forgot that I had.

[@phuxmusic7538]

truth has been spoken - thank you for the great work you do on this channel for us all to enjoy

[@fivewattworld]

Thanks man!

[@JordanSeal]

I found this video -- let's be honest, the algorithm made the match -- at exactly the right time. I connected with a lot of your points, but the brightest lightbulb was your point about FOMO. Thank you for attaching that word to that feeling I get when I'm shopping for gear that I'm never going to use... but that I would use if I was "more serious" about my art (or some variation of self-bullying commentary). Those aspirational purchases rarely work out for me, and maybe this will help me slow them.

[@fivewattworld]

Thanks for this Jordan

[@crubenbauer1]

Quick story of my Aquisitions. I had purchased a 1963 Epiphone FT-90 El Dorado at a Pawn Shop in New Haven Connecticut. The one with the Tune-O-Matic bridge inside the Rosewood Bridge. It was a Meracha. By the way, In my Band, the Esquires, we covered the J.P. Richardson tune, "White Lightning", and the Epiphone case had a Painted-On White Lightning Bolt on the Top cover. It was meant to be. Or so I thought. Anyway, All the of the Bracing was either loose, or soon to be loose. I carried it up to Fretted Instrument Workshop in Amherst, Massachusetts for a Professional Repair and Set up. Several Months later, the FT-90 was ready. Again.. I drove to Amherst. The Guitar was exactly what i wanted, although, in my Band, there was no room for an Acoustic Instrument. As, My main stable was a Telecaster ( early 52' reissue, and a 64 Vibrolux Amp) . Blues-A-Billy Band. Anyway, The Epiphone was played for several years around the House. Until the dreaded day, I lost a Saddle when a string broke. Those early bridges, did not have the retaining wire. So the Saddles would fall out. Needless to say, the Epiphone was in Semi-Retirement until I found that Saddle. I always find lost items, when I stop looking for them. Let's skip a few years.... There was some gear I wanted, so I decided to sell the Epiphone, to finance the "New" gear. Can't remember what it was I so lusted after. Anyway, as my fate would have it, a few days after selling my only Acoustic, and it was a good one. I received a call for a Acoustic Gig, and I found the runaway Saddle the same day. I immediately called the Dealer to whom I had sold it to.. And whatya know? He also loved the Guitar and refused to sell it back to me. The moral of this story is, If I sell an Instrument, I always end up needing it soon after. The silver lining was, since I couldn't get the Epiphone back, I drove to Westerly, Rhode Island, with a pocket full of $20's) in search of a decent Guild Acoustic, which I found at Zak's (Frets) on High Street. There I found my 1998 DV-52 i Sunburst. If your going to buy a Guild, why not drive to where they were born? I still have my Tone-Canon today. This one is a " Going to my Grave with me" guitar. Thanks for your great videos. Ciao'

[@sheppardrj]

Great vid! Another related rabbit hole is mods...investing more and more to get your instrument or amp to “that spec”. I’m there with right now with a Blues Deluxe that I’ve coughed up far too much on to almost achieve that. Now I’m at the cutting my losses and selling to upgrade place. Gear plays mind games on you.

[@pdavis122]

Pure gold! Perhaps you'll understand this message later, if not now, based on my 40 years of guitar love.

[@fivewattworld]

Thanks man! Keith

[@georgesb1]

Thank you for this video! Great for both musicianship and mental health. Lately, I've been practicing scales and patterns on my Tele and if I get obsessive about tweaking tone, I just play with the amp turned off, and it helps.

[@andrewkoastephens210]

I’m really enjoying this channel. Something I’ve recently wrestled with is that I’m not a professional, touring musician anymore. I haven’t been for years and I’m on a path that will not lead me to being on the road again. There is no handbook on how a rocker ages gracefully. I still play music and even sometimes play with friends but I have no practical use for backup guitars, and the Ovation Deacon (because it’s so distinct in that one song I recorded!), suitcases of pedals, the vintage Vox continental (just for the studio, the Nord C-1 is for touring!) and a pile of other stuff. We all know instruments aren’t alive but we also know that when an instrument doesn’t get the chance to come out and play it makes them very depressed. In that light, instrument hoarding is just kinda cruel. And also, I won’t pretend I wasn’t hoping this video was going to tell me what time of year I could find bargains and what months are best for selling gear. Haha!

[@jamespardee6103]

What your bicycle building friend will probably concur with is that the value of something is largely in the maintenance level. Upgrading and modifying to your needs, and keeping in tip-top maintenance will be better than spending too much on too many things, all of which could benefit from the aforementioned.

[@buzzawuzza3743]

you make the best gear videos, can't say it simpler than that

[@christopherprice3226]

I agree with Mr. Beato best video yet. IM a gear addict 21 synths 3 amps 1 bass and 13 guitars. Im ready to let go. Thank you.