हाइड्रोपोनिक तकनीक द्वारा चारा उत्पादन - फायदा या नुकसान Hydroponic Fodder Production

हाइड्रोपोनिक तकनीक द्वारा चारा उत्पादन कि पद्धिति आजकल बहुत चर्चा में है, इसको एक कृषि क्रांति कि तरह देखा जा रहा है जो सभी समस्याओं का हल हो. हाइड्रोपोनिक तकनीक भले ही कितनी अच्छी हो परन्तु चारा उत्पादन के लिए ये आर्थिक रूप से कारगर और संभव नहीं है. क्योंकि इस तकनीक में ये कहा जाता है कि यह 7 दिनों में अनाज को 7 से 8 गुना बढ़ा देती है. परन्तु वास्तव में ये अनाज (बीज) के शुष्क पदार्थ यानि dry matter में भारी कमी कर देती है. इस विडियो में हमने इसी तथ्य को वैज्ञानिक आधार पर समझाया है ताकि हमारे किसान भाई इसके तकनिकी ज्ञान से अवगत होकर ही कोई फैसला लें.
The popularity of hydroponics fodder production system is increasing day by day, it is seen as a revolution in the field of agriculture and fodder production. But it must be noted that in hydroponics there is a serious reduction in dry matter content of fodder. In this video, we scientifically demonstrate the facts that hydroponics is not economically feasible for livestock production.

[@nirbalutthaan4572]

अली भाई मैं 42 साल का हो गया हूँ मैंने बहुत कुछ सिखा और पढ़ा है, विज्ञान में रूचि रखता हूँ, लेकिन जो जानकारी आज आपसे मिली है उसका मैं तह ए दिल से आभारी रहूँगा, यह एक ज्ञानवर्धक है ! धन्यवाद !

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

thanks for such nice compliment

[@vikramchahal9571]

NIRBAL UTTHAAN Ji ! Aap great ho . salute sir

[@mustafahasan9958]

Ali bhai apne naam ki izzat rakh rahe ho aap dua karta hun ki aliul azeem apke ilm main or izafa kare. Ameen

[@shivendrasingh6612]

Ali Bhai. Never seen anybody so detailed like you in India. Keep working hard and educating the people. Long way to go.

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

Thank You so much

[@nagesketkar2424]

All other chanels, you Tubers are providing Fake information without having any knowledge of the subject. Sir you saved Lakhs of Rupees of people which is going to be invested unnecessarily Thanks again sir ji

[@Vishnudatt4826]

For fodder use hydroponic is expensive due to seeds because in soil we can take 3-4 cuts but in hydroponic we take single cut... second in soil fodder grow fully 4 times more large comparatively hydroponic fodder...but hydroponic is substitute where anyone has not land for soil fodder...Thanks for good information

[@nagesketkar2424]

No one is giving such type of analysis. very truthful source of information from your chanel thank you very much sir ji

[@rameshchaaran8267]

कुलमिलाकर हाइड्रोपोनिक चारे के साथ सूखा चारा,भूसा,बढ़िया क्वालिटी का पशु आहार भी देना आवश्यक होता है।

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

yes

[@MrGYPSYSPADE]

here is a research done in dapoli kokan area. it concluded this: finger millet straw + hydroponic fodder (maize 8 days sprouts) at 60:40 daily intake was good for weight gain as well as cost to benefit ratio (2.6). A study conducted came with these results. It also mentioned 6+ kg weight gain in the 97 days trial.

[@sameermayt]

Ali bhai shukriya aap ne to hamari aankh hi khol di🌹🌹🌹

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

welcome

[@danielreuben8847]

You are right about reduction of dry matter in transaction from seeds to sprouts . However; It may be okay to feed "birds" with seeds; but seeds are 'not the food for ruminant animals'; there are 100s of disadvantages in feeding grain to the animals (probably exception of pigs - pigs do not ruminante). Losses of dry matters can fulfilled by dry feed given to them as filling fodder. It is essential the ruminant animals get chlorophyll filled feed to maintain their digestive system. Green feed is not available round the year especially in India; so the alternative is Hydroponics.

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

you are absolutely right and get the main point... I never said that this technique is wrong or incorrect but simply I am trying to say that it is not suitable for dairy (if someone tries to solely rely on this for green fodder production) and of course in India DM concerns are huge // you can feed it to birds (simple stomach animals) but care should be taken while feeding because it is extremely good source of salmonellosis and mycotoxins... green fodder alternative is silage and its proper planning

[@mohitparwal7124]

I want to ask that are the people from maharashta and kvk fools who are using and teaching this technique

[@vibhordube8240]

Brilliant research with quite useful information. Although, the video is misleading where the Hydroponics fodder is clearly been declared a villain. Hydroponics fodder, when given in proper proportion with enough roughage(read hay), works miraculously. Been there, done that. Again, kudos to you for such a brilliant study, but please show us both the sides of coin from next time. Thanks.

[@elasfarcom]

Vibhor Dube true need high quality roughage with it ,

[@SufiKabeer]

Can you suggest for one buffalo how much dey matter (bhoosa or pural) with 7-8 kg of this fodder ??

[@alimusaji88]

Hello sir. Dont judge this process on the basis of dry matters only. Isko aap practically animals ko khila ke dekhe. Logo ko gumraah na kare. Hamaare yaha dairy hai,goatry hai,or rabbitry hai.lakin hum sabhi ko sirf hydroponics wheatgrass hi khilaate hai.or dusro ke compare me hum bohot zyada munaafa kamaate hai. So basically go for the real fact whether it works on the animals or no. Nothing can be judged on this paper datas or theoretical informations.

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

even after seeing so much scientific references you are saying ki gumraah na kare?? If this technology is so smart for fodder production than you need not to advocate this.. only those people are advocating this who have to sell these machines// apke yahan dairy goatry rabbit honge aur aap khilate bhi honge and we know all economics and munafa in livestock enterprises .. People are not blind ki 4 lakh rupay ki machine lagayein aur usme roz 20 rupay kilo ki 50 kilo makka dalein 7 din baad pani lene ke liye//

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

It is not theoretical -- this data is produced by a steering committee formed in Australia after repeated experiments .. review your farm activities in the light of this document. blogs.cornell.edu/organicdairyinitiative/files/2014/05/Hydroponicfodder-article-11wpnm0.pdf

[@syedahmedshirazi8410]

Aliakbar Musaji Bro... Where are you from??? please contact me 9284131900

[@Zabiulla1]

Dear Ali Akbar Musaji, where is your Farm located ? even i'm going to start a cattle farm. Hence need to know that whether the milk production goes down after opting for Hydroponic grass rather than the traditional one ??? and exactly how much total quantity of feed you give to a cow per day ??? my contact no : 7899648778

[@amanullanadaf3637]

Aliakbar Musaji sahi kaha bhai

[@arun.rajput92]

Very informative ❤

[@spandeeradi64]

The best video on hydroponics fodder cultvation

[@zpschool.shivnagar2653]

एक तकनीकी कैसे सायन्स की मदद से समझाया जा सकता है इसका एक अप्रतिम उदाहरण हैं।

[@MUNTAJIBCIMTmuntajibcimt]

Assalamalaikum r.w. wrb. Ali bhai, Excellent, appreciate your work, Thanks for the best message, May God gives your good health and wealth. Have a nice day.

[@ashoksingh4879]

Keep on making such videos of indepth knowledge. Great work 👌👌👌

[@MrGYPSYSPADE]

okay more research required. the digestibility factor of grains vs ground grains vs sprouts/fodder

[@sagormoybanerjee8054]

Excellent rendition, summarised all the reports so far scattered in the net in a very interesting way, Thank you, for this useful analysis.

[@manaharsinhchavda5893]

Good information

[@prakashshirasath1911]

Foder ke liye Hydroponics thik nahi hai. Thank's for informative article.

[@MrGYPSYSPADE]

the idea is to use this method to supplement feed in snowbound areas or in any other difficult times. But it is not for perpetual use. You are right. There is another way to use it and that is to sun dry it or shade dry it under airflow . Now when the moisture level in the wheat grass is .05 then you can use it. And that means it is dry feed and you would require 7 times or more to equal it in green wheatgrass volume. This way the cost does not come down but the feed is now very nutritious. green wheat grass could be used only for maintenance in drastic situations.

[@santoshsah5057]

Thankyou my brother you touch my heart

[@sulekhchand5987]

अली भाई बूहू अछी जान कारी मीली है धनेवाद

[@sandeepprabhu695]

Ali Bhai Azolla / Duckweed pe same video banaye na.

[@deependrakhanna8716]

To ali bhai ek video aisa bano jo chara 7 dino hara chara isi me kuch nutrition mila ke bana sake I think you suggest because you have in this field

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

ok, thanks for suggestion

[@rizkals5955]

Bhai. you have done really good job, you explain with reference it's really helpfull. 👍👍👍

[@1972pushpendra]

sir,very good, with proof aapne bataya ...thenks

[@laxminarayanrathi6177]

Bahut badhiya jankari hai vishesh ta sabhi proof diye hai

[@anirudhpratapsinghjodha7583]

well organised video... reference data are reliable... very good work by team... it enlighten the viewers. but everthing has pros & cons... people will choose what is beneficial to them.. and the term beneficial means depends on person to person

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

thank you.. you are right it depends on person's choice

[@narendersinghchauhan5222]

Ali sir esko animal ko sirf 50% hi provide karte hai...yah sirf summer me use karta hu.. thanks brother good information for hiydroponick.

[@adityashekhar5703]

achchha idea hai

[@aftabbaig9241]

HI good and real information provided thanks to support

[@anupamahuja5415]

Bhai very nice work You gave very deep knowledge Thank you

[@YadavYadav-ny2mb]

सर फरमेंटेड फीड मुर्गी के लिए फायदा या नुक्सान जनेकारी पर विडियो बनाये मै यादव दुबई से

[@1979SACH]

Sir this is one of the great explanation against using hydroponic. But sir then I have a serious question for u. I wish to start a goat farm business. I dont have any land to cultivate fodder. How I am suppose to start goat farm. Does that mean a land less person can not get into an animal husbandry?

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

if you don have land than dont worry you can buy dry subabul leaves and guar bhusa for feed. and also you can made your own silage. watch these videos and plan your business accordingly 10 steps in goat farming - kzbin.info/www/bejne/hWW8lWRslpKkjqc Silage planning for goats - kzbin.info/www/bejne/sHyQh52Na6d7p68 Silage production - kzbin.info/www/bejne/oqPPaJeFYtNkn6s

[@abdulaleem490]

bhai then use terrace for fodder set up.

[@shubh3690]

Cows are ruminant animal and digestion of grains which contain essentially starch is very poor ...some time cows dies due to excessive eating of grains. My question is why not we convert starch into other nutrients and increase grains digestibility ....and overall nutrients intake by cows ??? Also you are assuming farmer will rely 100% on hydrophonic system ...rather farmer will use 10-15% of overall fodder as hydrophonic...

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

Go ahead with hydroponics and share your experience

[@MeelanLimbuVlog23]

Thanks sir, it's a great information I like your way of explaining. By the was Ajola khilane me kya please koi explain kar sakte hai ya ko video bana sakte hai

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

Thanks .. azola adhik successful nahi hai

[@DrShantaramGaikwad]

Good information i have done lot of practical on this & 4 to5 years more than 100 farmers using it but in low cost

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

at low cost it is good, and never say against its nutritious value i only say that its not economical

[@DrShantaramGaikwad]

@@AlisVeterinaryWisdom Nice

[@jimmikalra]

Plz share your no on 9026677225

[@arvindkumar-mm7et]

Hydroponic fodder is just a replacement of green fodder, infact it is good as compair to the traditional green fodder. Other materials are also required.

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

Yes but other ingredients are also needed to make complete feed

[@arvindkumar-mm7et]

@@AlisVeterinaryWisdom same thinking here

[@vivekmahajan4999]

Very good information, thanks.

[@SatyamYadav-nm4db]

Kya bat hai bhai fantastic presentation

[@ashutiwari5038]

Jai shri ram 🚩🚩🕉️🇮🇳 jai hind Bhai jaan

[@hinalruhanicutiepies2.1m10]

sir kya m apni buffalo ko bhuse k sath milakr de skta hu or sath me dusra hra chara jse brsim ..fr koi nuksan to nhi ..pls details me btaye

[@hardikgohil2211]

Very nice information

[@jsfishwala]

Very good information,sir🤗

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

Keep watching

[@onlyislam3770]

Ibne ali bhai ek video distilled barley, wheat, rice as a feed for cattle pr bhi banao

[@syedahmedshirazi8410]

Very Deep information with Keen observation... Allah Bless you Bro

[@ajitsinhsonofsadashivbabak6455]

Ali bhai bole to bahot informative video hai mai cattale feed ka manufacturing karna chahata hu to mai soch rahatha ki hydroponics mai karu ya dry feed banane ki machinery lagake cattale feed banau lekin esmye machinery structure milake investment bahot lagta hai to aapki kya ray hai.

[@adeeljavaid706]

We give dry matter to our cattles separately and as well as as provide them green fodder too. In the case if we replace green fodder with hydroponic fodder, is it still not a good option? Bcs we can get hydroponic fodder on cheaper price compare to green fodder ( as we dont grow green fodder but purchase it regularly). What i am interested to know is to compare normal green fodder with hydroponic green?

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

Bhai agar ye video dekhne ke baad bhi apka sawal ye hai to maaf kijiye main samjha nahi paunga. Dry feed alag chez hoti hai aur dry matter alag.

[@adeeljavaid706]

@@AlisVeterinaryWisdom Shukria aap k jawab ka Ye to aap ki video dekhnay k baad me ne kaafi aur videos dekhen aur samjha k dry matter aur dry feed me farq hy. Lekan abhi bhi comfuse hu k ham ne green feed to deni hoti hy. Aur green feed me dry matter wese bhi 20% hi hota hy. Maanta hu wo hydroponic fodder me bhi kam hota hy lekan green me wese hi kam hota hy na. To Hydroponoc fodder ko agar green feed se replace kia jaey to dry matter ka itna farq to nahi hy na? Me sach me samajhna chah raha h.

[@deepakyadav-bo3ox]

@@AlisVeterinaryWisdom sir aap se kaise baat ho sakti hai

[@sharadghuli3269]

Kya machine mein hydroponic fodder bana sakte hai kya is pr ek video banao

[@vijaytechknow_today7964]

rumanthi's digestive system most favorable for sprout rather than grains

[@tuncaysoyal6724]

Mein Freund sehr gute information bestimmt ,ich werde das bei ein Freund übersetzen lassen

[@FormulapracticalLearnfree]

Nice info bro ... if we grow seeds in pots and fill with soil and decompose cow dunk ratio of 3:1 and grow as hydroponic system it will give us good nutritions and vitamins sources also increase dry mater ??? Reply as early as possible

[@sqannaqvi3061]

hello sir you are great man natural search so nice you are a great

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

Thanks

[@drkurhade]

Good information before wrong investment on hydroponic

[@desiswag9148]

Bohot hi jabardast Bhai..

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

thanks

[@nagesketkar2424]

Sir please give information on Azola feeding of animals its utility and economics if possible

[@arshishamsi2308]

Good video dr. Sahab.. can hydroponics (germinated Maize) can be used for desi birds...

[@rajkumarranga1698]

Sir can we replace concentrate by this hydroponic specially in horse?

[@englishonlineclasse.o.cins4545]

Sir maize ka seeds lagega ya sirf maize se bhi Uga sakte hai Pls reply me I am confused

[@vaibhav3946]

agar kisike pass land nahi hai....toh hydroponic khilaye ghar pe banake....ya fir green fodder kharid ke khilaye......thoda detail mein batayiye please..

[@FormulapracticalLearnfree]

I am sohail ahmed from mirpur azad kashmir using both method hydroponic and with soil & decompose cow dunk mixture in pots i dont have space to grow but i am trying to grow little bit space of 8*2 feet space

[@mrNitishwithcriket]

What is your opinion Hum hydroponics ka istemal Kare Ya Na Kare?

[@jagjitsingh7105]

Nice information

[@vishnushankhdhar6166]

What do u think about other hydroponic products for human consumption?

[@pradeeprawat9342]

Thanks for information

[@munmunhazarika5247]

U should compare the cost of getting 1000 kg green fodder by manual labour to the cost of 1000kg by hydroponics...... 16 % loss of dry matter can be compensated by extra production..... U got stuck with dry matter.....

[@kaluram9647]

Animals kaa nukshAn ApnA hee nuksaan h bhaiii nhiii krenge ye growww i hate these ideas but you're video is informative thax you

[@vishalswami142]

Very nice video. Sir is hydroponic good and profitable for commercial veges production in indian cities like mumbai , pune?

[@VivekSharma-by4cj]

thanks for such good information,sir I want to know ur concern is production cost,or quality content

[@thebadpoliticianroast1361]

respected sir, nice video 😃😊. please clear my doubt. maye goat farm shuru Karne me interested hu. hamare pass jjada jagah nahi Hai mushkil se 6-7 gunta. to me goat farm shuru Karte vact hydroponics water grass system ka upyoag karna chahta Tha/hu. maye bahoot confused ho gaya hu q ki research ke liye KZbin thekta hu to her channel pe allag Salah meelti Hai koyi Bolta Hai Hydroponics water grass bahoot hi jaada kifayeti or bakriyoke liye aacha Hai Hydroponics water grass me hum bakriyoko paata , beej or roots sab ek saat khane dete hai to unki shehat banti Hai . or aaj aapka video dekha to aalag saalah meeli . jime aapne kaha ki Hydroponics pe pure tarah depend ho nahi sakte . Kya is system ke upyoga see 100% nuksan hoga . fuangas ka kitna nuksan hoga. please reply me.....!!!!!

[@madhukarshirole4924]

Very very nice.

[@rafiqmohammed1001]

Good information provided

[@solomonroy8779]

Thanks you vayya..

[@bibhishannale1710]

Very good bro...

[@eduzoom3476]

Azola green fodder animals ke liye kesa rehta hai iske bare mai batai

[@deepsinghjat]

Dear सर क्या सिर्फ पानी ही बहोत है इसको उगाने के लिए??कुछ और डालने की जरूरत नही जैसे देसी खाद वगैराह???

[@vijaytechknow_today7964]

on the bases of DM u r right sir bt on the behalf of cost of hydroponic produce nd green fodder n ration cost ....hydroponic produce is much cheeper than.........

[@amarchudasama1142]

Very good information ajola ke bare me bhi viedo bnaye

[@SumanKumar-zm4mi]

Sir, will it be feasible if the diet comprises 15kgs of hydroponics 10kgs corn silage, 8kgs of paddy straw and the rest is concentrate, and the selling price of the milk is 40rupees per liter?

[@samsulsabnaz6420]

Sir Do you recommend fermentation feed for sonali chicken?? plz reply sir

[@e1Pr0f3ss0r]

Assalam alikum Bhai isko dry chaara k Saath mix Kar k khila sakte hai kya? Aur isme poshakta badhane Ka koi aur technique ho to plz batao.

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

yes isko dry bhusa chara ke sath de sakte hain isme dairy feed milane se poshakta badh jati hai

[@BhushanPatil-tm1ot]

Ha Sir Maine bhi install kiya hai apane jo janakari di wo sab sahi hai........ Lekin 50% Dry chara aur 50% Hydrophonic chara hum de sakte hai...... Dry chare ki cost kam karne ke liye

[@suryapratapmishradmlt3682]

What if one use mineral rich water instead of plain tap water after 5th day till 10-12th day? Will it increase the nutritional value of the fodder, just asking out of curiosity?

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

Sir, it is not about the nutritional value of hydroponic fodder, it's about its cost which does not allow it to be fodder of choice at least in India.

[@vijayanms4544]

6

[@sujiagent47]

Excellent presentation on an equally good topic. Thanks for taking the time to research. This depth of information issues not easily available. Can you do a similar video on Azolla / duckweed. Thanks again

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

thanks, people don't understand the science and data, most of the people still thinks that i am against hydroponics fodder, but my point is that it is not at all economical to feed (and this thing is said by ICAR also), nutrition is not my point// nutritious to kaju badaam bhi hain lekin wo to nahi khilaye ja sakte na

[@liyakatfunsupkar1210]

​​@@AlisVeterinaryWisdomRespected sir very deeply details se aap ne samjhaya hai isse tarah se Azzola or Duckweed and silage also or silage banane ka asaan Tarika per full scientific proof details deeply please provide kare jisse kissan ko zyada fayda hasil ho Request hai.....

[@sabrichickencenternadeemqu9384]

तो आप क्या कहना चाहते हैं कि यह चारा न खिलाएं

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

agar ap iska khilana afford kar sakte hain to zarur khilaiye

[@sajjanshukla2826]

100%सही !

[@laxmansinghrawatlaxmansing5799]

Thanks

[@SANTONSANTO]

Very informative but my question is it possible to flatten cow by maize hydroponic grass fodder only?

[@satyambhasker8547]

Thanks sir

[@jashpalsingh5450]

Sir toh Jo poly farming ho rahi hai wo bhi avoid karana Chahiye badi badi company ussey Kar rahi hai Yaha tak ki Japan bhi issey badhawa de Raha hai, kindly clear this topic,

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

hydroponics technique me koi kami nahi hai lekin isse jo chara paida hota hai uski cost bazar se milne wale chare ya khet me ugaye chare se zyada hoti hai isliye livestock farming ke liye thik nahi hai ,, isse apka production mehnga tayyar hoga

[@hemantverma1065]

aap sahi boal rahay hay sir

[@itsfunnn205]

Heifer bachdi ko bhi khila sakte hai kya yeh

[@MeherjaanBegum-lj9rr]

Sir, maize aur wheat ke grass DESI MURGI kliye kare to kaisa rahega???

[@az99abdulaziz93]

Nice video

[@dadajibhakti4199]

What about green wheat grass used for better health

[@SunilPatel-rt5bm]

sir apne jo b explain kiya wo may b sahi ho sakta he, but jinko hf cows ka dairy farm he unko to reproductivity me he sub se bada loss he, aur hydroponically fodder isme behtar kaam karta he, to unko to acha hi lagega na, ohk kya aap muje hydoponically vegetables k baare me kuch jankari de sakte he

[@khalidbhaikhani7303]

सर जी अगर सूखा चारा ओर खेत का हरा चारा गाय को दे और 4 kg एक टाइम हाइड्रोपोनिक दे और 1 kg उसकी दाना दे जैसे खल बिनोला या दलिया तो कैसा रहेगा

[@nimar8990]

8 kg green fodder produce more no of microbial protein in rumen of animals as compare to 1 kg of seed. in this way seed can be utilized during green fodder deficiency.

[@Asifkhan-do1mw]

Sir agar poultry farming me 2000 desi bird ka stock hai agar uske liye hydroponics ka use profitable hai

[@cryptobruno3696]

can we use it in desi chicks poultry for protine?

[@premyadav2380]

Good job bro but I think natural is great Everything is included ..sun light etc

[@AlisVeterinaryWisdom]

yes, right