Halo 2 Spartans & Elites Have A Creepy Detail You Probably Never Noticed

[@Generalkidd]

Just a quick clarification/correction, the Spartan 1st person arms actually aren't limited strictly to multiplayer. Master chief in campaign uses the same arms as multiplayer Spartans do. The elite arms are indeed multiplayer only though.

[@goose4781]

@@epsilon383 begging for your comment to get pinned is really pathetic

[@zachtowny3857]

What does it look like in anniversary graphics?

[@davidhubbard8353]

So I've actually had instances where my game lagged while I was playing Halo 2 multiplayer as an elite. When I looked down, the leg models in the pelvis area looked like it had some flesh and bone too, can you look into this as well? This might most definitely be related. I don't know if there's anything with the leg model of the spartan. I don't think so, but I might be remembering incorrectly. Might be worth a look.

[@GGG_gaming]

think it has to do with how the limbs are animated they left interior "walls" inside the arms as join points of models and used those as animation points, as to whey its textured the way it is 1. it was a random texture they had on hand they could use as a place holder so they could visibly see the animation spot 2. they made it just so they can differentiate the connect points 3. inside joke?

[@garretthuff6228]

Hey I have a question for u man. On the first level of Halo Reach when u drop off the chopper, if u sprint down on the right side you’ll see an invisible elite. U can shoot at it and drain it’s shields, but can u kill it?

[@woee3w-if30-2-ejbananasandwich]

Looks like they might've intended to implement dismemberment, but cut it early on like some other things in Halo 2

[@aceskeletonne7446]

Brutes were originally going to tear marines limb from limb so it might be left over from that

[@andrewwhite8734]

They CUT it early.

[@mstrcheef420]

Correct. The muscle/bone textures are leftover details from a time in Halo 2’s development when bungie planned to include dismemberment and gore within the campaign and multiplayer. Ultimately, before launch, they determined that gore might be too violent for the game’s target audience.

[@DizRupTnz]

Probably a ratings decision.

[@masturch33f66]

@Fuck da rest N0 u

[@Isgonesomewhere]

4:02 an inside joke lol, I guess it didn't meat their expectations and ended up being cut from the body of the project. Now it exists as a bonafide exhibition of bungie's ambitions.

[@lordjeremetrius]

Nice

[@xarsf.w.3884]

You sir deserve a gold medal...

[@fvcklunacy]

ew

[@commanderblargh6300]

10/10

[@itisfreak]

You win

[@hivoltage2616]

Bungie: We're out of time, we need to launch the game! Also Bungie: *Arm meat*

[@Marinealver]

To be fair the game a was rather good and ground breaking

[@TheDirvish]

Im gussing they were going to have a dismemberment mechanic and pulled it last minute

[@infernaldaedra]

@@Marinealver This game so such a game changer its how we ended up with Mountain Dew and Doritos

[@scareditymays6yearsago477]

@@infernaldaedra wait really

[@infernaldaedra]

@@scareditymays6yearsago477 Yes. Halo 2 had insane amounts of promotion the biggest of which was mtn dew and Doritos. That why when Halo 3 launched mountain dew launched Halo 3 Game Fuel arguably the best flavor they ever made.

[@NotusDuckus]

I love how years latter somehow we will find some type of secret

[@yeehawj248]

@Fuck da rest why should they? All they did was make a comment. Relax

[@24halonerd]

@Fuck da rest joe

[@BrownieDoesGames]

Fuck da rest Shut up, let the man speak. lol

[@jelly_is_thicc4872]

@@BrownieDoesGames shut the fuck UP weeb

[@A_Bag_of_Potatoes]

@Fuck da rest Are you mental mate?

[@james_kimpel]

Are they the same limbs used by infected elites? because their arms can actually come off and you can see meat and such

[@Espartanica]

No, when the Elite becomes infected, they change their model rather than using a different version of the same model.

[@GGG_gaming]

well the art style is completely different even if that was the case

[@Espartanica]

@@GGG_gaming It's the same art style.

[@GGG_gaming]

@@Espartanica it doesnt appear so to me, the flood textures are darker have a green tint and i dont recall there being any bones

[@GGG_gaming]

@@Espartanica i cant say for sure for the human arm but the elite is 100% not flood related for those reasons

[@RonaldMcDonald519]

Related fact: In Destiny they modeled the interior of the “Rat King” skull with sinuses and all even though you can never see it. Bungie’s attention to detail is absolutely world-class.

[@Kirbylight2]

Seriously, how did we not know this for nearly 16 years?!?!

[@Connector7th]

Because tech and modding wasn't as advance and free

[@Connector7th]

@@fvcklunacy thanks

[@ThisBirdHasFlown]

@@Connector7th yes it was

[@Valkyries733]

I’ve known for a long time and I’m sure plenty of other people know. Heed just happened to make a video on it

[@Wishengrad]

@@fvcklunacy GeneralKidd makes tons of videos on stuff the modding community has known since the mid 2000s for CE and Halo 2.

[@orangeporridge1553]

17 years later we still finding new stuff dang

[@shane7051]

"between the hand and the arm" Wrist. You're talking about a wrist.

[@ReganFreeman]

Cut content remnant? Some sort of severed limb mechanic?

[@Ironclad1776]

Maybe..

[@emilycampbell6375]

i doubt it honestly, probably just an a modeller at bungie having a bit of fun

[@theanimeman97]

@@emilycampbell6375 I mean, it's not that much of a stretch, considering The Flood are dismembered.

[@vermillionreaper]

Yeah, i doesn't surprice me bc of the flood infested bodys have that mechanics, maybe they were trying to implement that on every character at some point.

[@gruntes11isttt]

Yup that's what it is some of the videos Bungie mentions it. Halo ce it was an idea but they decided to cut because they thought it actually might be to much for engine to handle/hard to implement, and halo 2 it was cut because of the reason why alot of things where cut, too little time to implement

[@trekker105]

After all the Triangle City and Nick Robinson vids I've binged recently, I am convinced the only reasonable next step is to track down the texture artist responsible and have a 3 hour interview with him about it.

[@PloKleenex]

Let's get him on it.

[@randomthe0ne]

google: flood bing:

[@jetpackdog3427]

... yes

[@LewdTuna]

Time to make another trip to japan

[@kanaka118446]

I've been binging Triangle City too

[@primusvsunicron1]

This probably why Bungie made the Energy Sword usable in Halo 2

[@Azure029]

probably flood related, but dismemberment would've been cool, like imagine cutting off a dude's arms in multiplayer with an energy sword or something

[@patrick_grundy]

Like that one move the jedi and sith use in star wars to cut off their opponent's hand

[@RezidueWithaZ]

@@patrick_grundy "slashing"?

[@kentreed2011]

They probably planned to add dismemberment but scrapped it due to age rating.

[@shadowmilk3742]

Knowing halo 2 they probably cut something such as dismemberment when shot by something like a sniper or something

[@axel.1358]

There's evan a Marathon symbol in the spartan meat lol peak Bungie right there

[@Banana-Boi]

The halo reach elites have the same thing in first person. Sometimes when you're glitching and look down you can see their intestines.

[@erasedalexxis]

any video related?

[@sentientmilkshake6059]

yes

[@supermario2044]

Intestines?

[@blindvalkyrie9352]

I noticed this whenever lagging in Firefight

[@picturebypicture3598]

@@sentientmilkshake6059 link?

[@rickyspanish9584]

Bungie: We didn't have time to add everything Meanwhile Bungie:

[@scareditymays6yearsago477]

In allí honestly that’s so true this is probably connected to some unfinished mechanic

[@DoomieGruntVentures]

Looking back, I spent a bit of time by myself in some of the multiplayer maps, and recently, while doing the same thing (no life, I know), there was a certain creepiness to Halo 2's atmosphere in particular. The feeling does dissipate a little bit in the maps that have more dynamic things happening, like Terminal & Backwash, but still, the creepy feeling is difficult to shake even when watching Red vs Blue. More secret stuff like this being discovered years later only makes things creepier.

[@elitedonut1089]

This is going to impact my life

[@branstone]

Say peanuts but without the T

[@elitedonut1089]

@@branstone no

[@branstone]

@@elitedonut1089 say it

[@elitedonut1089]

@@branstone no

[@branstone]

@@elitedonut1089 yes

[@TonyMontana-kb7vk]

Cool Edit: Change my mind wtf bungie

[@comicsamsthegreat]

Maybe a precursor to Halo 3's cut dismemberment

[@spiderz5145]

This was probably going to used with the flood at some point.

[@BeavisT-800]

My thought also

[@Jeremy-jw6nn]

Bungie wanted to add dismemberment and gore to Halo 2 and also Halo 3. Ultimately in both games these ideas were scrapped due to the target audience at the time for the games. They thought dismemberment would be too much for the target audience. It sucks when thinking about it, how cool it would've been to see brutes rip the arms off of Marines, and possibly Chief on a player death cam. Whilst also seeing the energy sword slice elite limbs off, and possible Marine limbs as well. But hey well never truly know how awesome Halo 2 was going to be as it was indeed rushed. An amazing Halo game no doubt, but even bungie mentioned they did not have enough time for everything.

[@TheLivelovelaugh165]

I actually know why this exists. In older games models had a solid rigging system, not the unparent-at-joints like today to "gib" bodies. Since these models couldn't just detach the arms, the devs would fold the arms inside the body to hide them or make them invisible, then spawn in separate arm models to create the illusion they came off. It was common to use the FPPov limbs since they were already implemented then add extra texture/planes to complete the illusion. We can see this gibbing done with the Flood (which is a solid mechanic), but humans and other models were likely cut to save on time for the crunch release date

[@2.0_brittt]

I feel like your videos are a constant in the universe. Through the course of time, your videos have remained exactly the same, and probably will for years to come. It’s amazing

[@doootuz]

I totally forgot about this. I saw it when I used to mod halo 2 back in the day! Nice find!!

[@ThisBirdHasFlown]

This is one of those things I’m not going to be able to not think about now lol. Just like how in Thief the Dark Project your character model is a piece of tofu.

[@EasyTargetLP]

My best guess is that these arms left overs for when they were testing the flood and giving them the level of dismemberment they'd later have in Halo 3.

[@tiberiustheweaponsmaster4621]

When I was like 8 I remember playing OG Halo 2 with my grandpa and he used double needlers on me. It blew my spartan's arm off and everyone was kind of shocked.

[@BeTeLGeuZeX]

I knew it in my bones!!! Confirmation , I remember seeing similar texture back in day when the Burial Mounds glitch happens where you can see a huge version of a dead body

[@thomas4092]

According to the old halo 2 teasers in magazines dismemberment, destroyable environments, interactive cover, peaking, rolling, sprinting, blood splatter on your visor/arms (spartan/elite) When you got near fatally wounded/gibbed by explosives and even parkour and silent hand signals in MP since open Mic was going to be a thing were meant to be added but got cut along with the DLC maps which were added later. A scarab fight against the Gravemind, open world new Mombassa and high charity along with a level referred to as Forerunner Tank were all cut from production.

[@sx3708]

proof to all the kids saying chief was an ai or robot himself.

[@HeeeyTooom]

This was kinda neat. Keep it up, General.

[@NinjaCokeGaming]

16, almost 17 years later and we are still finding new things out.....amazing

[@2.0_brittt]

Something my friend and I noticed is that in halo combat evolved there is a different animation for when you jump and when you jump and crouch with a pistol

[@blackdragon5274]

This is why I love your channel

[@lilbroccole]

You could see something similar in halo reach if you were playing as an elite and the game started to have connection problems. You could look into your own torso and see a similar green guts texture at the hip.

[@NotAFed_]

Kinda crazy how he's still making vids, keep it up man

[@thevanillatoast]

my brain immediately goes to a possible de handing detail when two players fight with energy swords, thats the only thing i can think of not to mention them wanting to add a lot of ambition to halo 2 but obv the time crunch and tossing ideas out some making a comeback into halo 3 to fit it all in EDIT: didnt finish the video and you basically said this oopy doopy

[@xdetan7104]

The halo reach elites have a similar detail with the first person lower body

[@GoldsCovers]

It’s hard for me to get super involved into any franchise, I give you major props for sticking to this game and researching the secrets and nuances it has. And STILL discovering interesting facts!! Generalkidd 1337 af

[@wesleywheeler7891]

The fact that this only shows up in the first person models makes me wonder if they would have had special death animations under certain circumstances. MC losing a hand or the Arbiter losing an arm

[@icantthinkofaname3306]

The other week I was messing around in halo 3 slayer with my cousin, he threw a regeneration field and I threw down an energy drain, once we started shooting i heard very strange and kinda disturbing yells and screams coming from our Spartans, either I was losing it or this is real, maybe check it out.

[@ganonpork301]

you can see the elite arms on halo 2 project cartographer when you set the view to max and melee with some weapons i think its with the shotgun and sword

[@gasmaskguys4965]

Halo 2 had so many little extra details we are still finding them today

[@strikeone7803]

When you consider the dismemberment the Flood Combat forms go through when killed by shotguns/explosions, stuff like this really isn't that surprising. That being said I think it was for the better to not implement too much gore in the game, at least for marketing reasons considering how young the franchise was at the time.

[@ATP2555ify]

16 years later and we're just finding this.

[@glaciiz]

The meat texture looks like an elite head for the spartan and looks like guilty spark for the elites.

[@christianbrown635]

The elites torso in reach is also fleshy like that while the Spartans are just silver lines

[@Lancealot3553]

That's amazing!!! They must have been planning on doing some type of explosion when you get killed in first person. They were ahead of their time for sure.

[@redeye4516]

With the elite arms, they probably were planning on adding dismemberment to the game, both to multiplayer and campaign. The flood dismemberment stuff was probably the only part of that to make it in the final game. Also, it's interesting that it's under the Spartan hands, because they're basically all just Master Chief with different color options for multiplayer. Perhaps it was originally just meant for the campaign, and Chief was supposed to lose his hand or something in the story. It may have been something to do with the technical part of the game as to why it wouldn't work, maybe they couldn't limit the weapons you could use in that case or sufficiently change the animations for one-handed gameplay. Or maybe they just changed their minds, I dunno.

[@Joey856721]

In the making of Vidoc of Halo 3 or making of for DVD of Halo 2 LCE, they showed human marine dismemberment which was put in the cutting room floor for how brutes would rip off whole arms off the marine and show lots of gore that bungie for some unknown reason cut out most likely was too violent or something for their tastes. And yes even though they showed marines I can imagine they had thought about or definitely planned the same for Spartans and Elites. I like to think that gameplay element would’ve been very interesting or eccentric for gameplay. Nice coverage video on this nonetheless.

[@sbizeus2395]

Either they intended to implement dismemberment because of the Energy Sword or those are details added for flood combat forms when they get destroyed

[@JohnathanTisdale]

More than likely its for reference. Animators and modelers need to keep in mind the anatomical restrictions of bodies; how much limbs and joints could move with that bone structure.

[@TheDevilDucker]

This actually happens in H3 too, this is noticeable now with the new arm pieces, which aren't visible in the First person View, It still shows the Mark 6 arms

[@derekk.2263]

Oh fuck man, they intended you to be able to cut off limbs with the energy sword.

[@yolocrayolod6668]

It would be cool if halo have some gore, Kat and Emile fits so good on gears 5

[@greengoblin99999]

You guys are so great at finding secrets in halo

[@pododododoehoh3550]

I wonder if maybe once upon a time they were toying with the idea of adding gore and dismemberment like they added to the flood in halo 3

[@SogenOkami]

Bungie wanted to continue an age old tradition of gibbing.

[@roflzwafflez117]

I'm trying to find which Vidoc included it but I remember a cut creature called a 'Keelbug' that would've cut up dead bodies and fly away with them. Maybe this is where the dismemberment feature would've been seen in game. kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4DdkouelMhrfKs Skip to the 2:38 mark.

[@cmboverlordoperation6704]

Bungie is the best, Halo is awesome

[@Void_Wars]

No I like the 343 games a lot more. Since they have more community support.

[@cmboverlordoperation6704]

@@Void_Wars it's not about community support. it's about how much you enjoy it

[@WonderMePartyStrip]

@@Void_Wars "community support", but they still fucking up everything they touch.

[@TheHorror123456789]

A breakthrough into the anatomy oh the universes most peculiar creature, great work the advances in medical procedings for the covenant will be staggering, but also we can now create weapons to specifically eliminate these alien bastards in a more intimate way

[@MisterJohnDoe]

Reminds me of that Halo Reach picture where an elite’s body is sliced in half but we never see it in the game.

[@WereWhusky]

Which picture?

[@MisterJohnDoe]

@@WereWhusky I don’t know but I remember seeing an image a long while back where there’s an elite’s dismembered body on the ground in Reach.

[@jonathanschenck8154]

Jackels, Grunts, Brutes all have desided to arm-ressle you. No Prophets & drowns are going shake them hands.

[@menmouzumaki7951]

OH this is also true about the elite's 3rd person legs in Halo Reach

[@entity9742]

During the early days they were gonna have a small bug come in that would cut the body to peices and carry the peices away while on the halo ring but there wasn't enough time to get it right so they scrapped it

[@TheOneEpicplayer]

I actually found this several months ago before knowing if anyone else had found it, I wonder if this spread by word of mouth lol.

[@Ahegaoblunt]

Maybe when they were making the next Halo they probably thought of making it gory but decided against it

[@thomaselvidge]

Bungie probably were thinking of adding some form of Gibbing system, maybe when you get exploded or something. Halo 2 has a lot of unfinished concepts that were planned but scrapped.

[@BuonoTorta]

The meat texturing was most likely from a prototype gibbing system that wasn't added as meat parts flying off non-floods isn't Halo's style really. The separate arms are actually a common practice in video games to insure the arms from the 3rd person model don't clip the camera; so the 3rd person arms are hidden from the camera while a pair of 1st person arms are "stuck" to the camera's movements.

[@lewatoaofair2522]

“Decapitation” means severing the head. The term you’re looking for that includes limbs is “amputation”.

[@blindvalkyrie9352]

In Halo Reach when the game is lagging if you're an Elite and look down you can see organs, some even look like kidney's

[@VXGaming]

Well... Imagine multiplayer with body parts being blown apart.

[@Winchester-xw8uy]

Eventually we will decipher the texts in sandtrap

[@nickjfv6304]

I remember when halo reach would lag (like really bad lag), if you died as an elite you could move the camera into the dead body and see it’s guts textured underneath the suit

[@kainey]

First person death in which an elite or flood cuts your hand off

[@PinkSpaceDinosaur]

Arm gun. That’s a new one

[@wolfder6661]

Have you thought about the reason why they animated the Flesh and Bone into the arms is because of the flood when you blow off flood limbs you can see there insides aswell maybe it was a reused asset

[@Tydusis1]

Knowing Bungie makes all kinds of pop culture references, I wouldn't be surprised if this is a subtle Star Wars empire strikes back reference. Second halo game has usable energy swords. Star wars has light sabers. Second star wars movie has Luke (arguably main character) lose a hand. Vader (arguably the main bad guy) had been implied to have lost whole arm. Spartans good guys, elites bad guys. Maybe this is midnight crackpot theory, but I like it.

[@alexmaffei7386]

I remember seeing this in the textures years ago and never thought anything about it. maybe it’s a cut dismemberment mechanic?

[@Zachary.S]

Imagine surving a battle but you cant do anything because youre arms are gone

[@wordlesslfiddling]

It might be a blood source in the arm when you get shot there there might be other parts like that to cause blood

[@anomaly9548]

Halo Community: We need Halo Infinite to make more video ideas. GeneralHeed:

[@kanden27]

I think they did have the idea for decapitation. Because in Halo 3 dev videos. There’s a clip of a brute ripping off arms of a soldier.

[@Endermania6526]

This makes me wonder! I bet you that they were toying with the idea of shooting someone else's hand off to keep them from duel wielding!

[@k0n158]

Dismemberment in Halo would have been badass. However, if there was any Halo game that it would have belonged in, then it's definitely going to be Halo Reach, since it has such a gritty and realistic atmosphere.

[@ryanjohansen7079]

They did have plans, in Halo 2, for gory kills especially when a brute kills something.

[@bigbossgameing5982]

In my theory i think bungie was gonna add a limb explosion when u shot then with a rocket or hit them with a energy sword they were probably gonna pop off and such like gears of war with the gnasher. If u shot them with it they blow up and all the limbs fly off. So i can see that added. But to them to gory.

[@playoyelnat8642]

with high enough FOV on cartographer you can see the elite meat when meleeing with certain stuff

[@erasedalexxis]

I remember some cut scripted animations, dunno if it was mean to be for Halo 2 or 3, there was a limb dismemerment animation of a marine.

[@realpagliaccio]

Oh my God, that's really gross.

[@ViolaDragon621]

i think this has something to do with the elite flood forms, most likely. maybe a flood infected spartan was originally intended sometime in development

[@zealotking67]

A lot of people don't know this but Bungie did try to implement prerendered organs and the game would have looked a little more like Gears of War as far as game play goes. If you load up Flood Gate the Elites have textures for different organs

[@virtee]

ngl 343 should release a book of the anatomy of the many species in the covenant with halo infinite, maybe a special edition of infinite

[@billtree52]

Maybe a leftover from a dismemberment feature that got 'cut' early on?

[@Turtle3000]

I’ve always wished that Halo had gore along with its crazy ragdoll

[@CardboardGnat]

My best guess is gibbing ,like tf2 Gibs when a character explode

[@Exeternal_Beyonder_Of_Doomsday]

Hey that's what I was thinking too as well with the Swords

[@ethanperez2325]

What are these old glory hounds of super-soldiers hiding?