Musicians react & review ♡ TXT - Eternally

[@breadppang]

" did they have this performed" lmao it's funny because we waited almost 2 years for a performance of this song and they finally performed it in their first online concert last sunday. it was eternally and it transitioned to FROST istg it was sooooo amazing

[@iamghost3602]

It was so insane I waited for it for almost two years and the way they transitioned it to Frost LIKE????? I NEVER THOUGHT OF THEM PERFORMING ETERNALLY AND FROST BACK TO BACK(had to make it all caps coz it's really mind blowing)

[@breadppang]

@@iamghost3602 i knowwww it was insane i gasped and went literally like 😲 speechless. plus that remix of cysm and puma before eternally 🤯 those 4 songs in order killed me

[@iamghost3602]

@@breadppang FR THEIR SETLIST WAS SO INSANE I CANT STOP TALKING ABOUT IT

[@azusa0421]

I call it the "ETERNAL FROST" .

[@hoyyu2107]

i literally turned into frost when i saw hueningkai say "i'm so shocked" 💀

[@mirovio]

TXT: *How much plot twist would you want?* MOA: *Yes?*

[@astraeanatsuki3231]

If bipolar personality was a song it would be eternally

[@jeanque2130]

ahahah you tell me 😅😅😅

[@gyusbrainrot7444]

For real lmfao

[@himyname7924]

Fr

[@Ariana-ju6rb]

"U cant do two compleely different genres and melodies one song- u just cant" TxT: yeah we did it

[@Ariana-ju6rb]

This song is literally human nature. like the constant switching of bipolarity

[@Ashley-dl5ln]

Eternally is truly a masterpiece! We missed you alot!! But I really think that you shouldn't watch the eternally mv first because you might get confused so much especially that it is part in their tu or their storyline! If you'd like to understand the mv, going back to the start is really recommended!

[@aasarashrestha]

The mv is part of their storyline called TU or star seekers. If you want to watch them it goes in the order of nap of a star-magic island-eternally and the dooms night

[@fatihahridi]

You NEED TO react to TXT "20CM" LIVE PERFORMANCE ON KBS TV and "FORCE" FIRST TAKE.

[@beomgyuslostsandhanitizer]

Yass plz 20cm is best

[@candiedpandie]

omg that first take.. they just never stop impressing me!

[@luxyang9742]

YES TO BOTH

[@persik3775]

3:02 that is the reaction of everyone listening to eternally😏

[@himyname7924]

Fr

[@Irs_moa]

Fr

[@Khushi-qx2tr]

Eternally is masterpiece its like a dream Vs nightmare

[@redpaprika6060]

Your reaction is so so relatable aha XD Eternally has only be performed two days ago on their first concert, held online, and only the first "heaven" part was performed (followed by an amazing transition to Frost). For the MV, it's very very impressive, but it's a huge part of their storyline, so watching Nap of a Star and Magic Island first will make more sense (followed by the animation short film The Doom's Night). It's also very true that TXT are unique in their songs, not one is like the other, so I really recommend everything for real... Maybe Dear Sputnik first, to show how amazing HueningKai and all of them are as producers

[@Forgotten_Moon]

13:10 You genius, you just describe the MV without watching it lol

[@mscellaneous7789]

Oh and Dear Sputnik and Maze in the Mirror are fantastic songs too… both written and produced by the TXT boys

[@GirlinReverie]

Hope you can check them more, they have a lot of amazing music, like maze in the mirror and fairy of shampoo

[@vj2191]

since u are exploring their music I reccomend Anti-romantic its very good.

[@avadorable_]

I’m literally rolling on the floor laughing on your reactions hahahahaha! I knew it when yeonjun came your reactions will be specific insaneeee you really never ever heard a kpop group that doing this kind of song, btw your reactions is also my reactions it’s a bit scaryyy for me but it’s so so sick!!! Well, YES! MOAs really smart and murderers. Anyways, Thank You for reacting TXT ETERNALLY!! Hopefully you will dig more to them! I recommended to you to react on PUMA MV! I will spill some tea yeonjun is making his own rap lyrics there so basically INSANEEEE TOO!!! Watch and listen carefully to the lyrics of PUMA!

[@MOA_Promise]

If you want to hear TXT sing live than both THE FIRST TAKE performances of CROWN (Japanese version) and FORCE are very impressive. This is a Japanese channel and the song is recorded in literally one take. Also WE LOST THE SUMMER (it is about the pandemic) and RUN AWAY are good songs.

[@ralflegacion4009]

This song made me a MOA right now. Like, FREAKING MOA

[@yanie5067]

guys, if you wanna listen to txt's soft songs, maybe you can listen to txt-love sight (ost of doom at your service drama) plus, you can explore their voices by listening to txt-force (at the first take channel) they sing it live there😉 I swear you will like it.

[@roselynnaga1111]

Eternally is simply a Masterpiece Its beautifully Progressive in a very dynamic way just Amazing... I want more people to know this song

[@yangsrightarm3767]

eternally is insane, one of my fave txt songs for sure! if you want other kpop artists with super unique discographies check out dreamcatcher - scream, silent night and black and white in particular have really unique production

[@itsfine_txt]

you guys need stopppp. my pride as a MOA keeps rising the more i watch your reactions. i feel like i need to be humbled soon or else lol. like i swear to god, all i need is to see your reactions to Can't You See Me by TXT and you could possibly become my favorite reactors of all time, and i might become the most self-assured kpop fan of all time lmao

[@HandsomeSausages]

Well we shall react and become your favorite then!!

[@itsfine_txt]

@@HandsomeSausages omg i was already really shocked that you not only saw but also replied to my other comment, and now it happened _again_ (and on a messier comment ㅠㅠ i really didn't expect you guys to see - much less _respond_ - to my comments) and you're gonna do my suggestion too?? now i'm so stupidly excited for it hsbahj thanks again for reacting to TXT and praising their and their staff's skill and hardwork!!

[@jescelkristinemosquete9174]

hahaha best comment

[@HandsomeSausages]

Hahaha ofc! Such a great comment why wouldn't we answer? Yeh eventually we're def gon get to Can't You See Me! Got some other stuff in line first ;)

[@Jjshlaa]

before you see the MV from eternally you should see the mv sequence for *TXT UNIVERS* so you don't get confused when you see it. this is the order for txt universes: 1. Nap Of Star 2. Magic Island 3. Eternaly 4. The doom's night (this is the official animation) I highly recommend you guys take a look at TXT UNIVERS, it's so crazy

[@vanitykeith]

Thanks for reacting! There're still a lot...Puma, Cant You See Me, Dear Sputnik...Anti-romantic..💙💙💙💙💙

[@plantbusiness6374]

And here we are 8 months after and they had a full performance of it in front of 11k moas for their first ever world tour for the first time. And everybody screamed their shit not only because of the song itself, but the whole choreography was insanity

[@yeonjun-ah4597]

Yeonjun rap is masterpiece 🦊🖤🖤🖤🖤

[@carolovesgyu005]

Hi! I Hope you can react to 'PUMA' , i think you will like that song, also i Hope you can react to 'Dear Sputnik' it's a song produced by hueningkai in the recent album

[@jellyn4218]

The first time I heard this song, on the first twist I was like "The song finished already?"

[@Forgotten_Moon]

When you say angelic I just realize that maybe it is a song about heaven and hell.... That's why it twist suddenly

[@luxyang9742]

OOOOOO! If y'all like the "soft,in the clouds" part, I recommend "Ghosting" and "Fairy of Shampoo" ! And "Puma" and "Can't you see me" for the switch up part. RECOMMEND ALL OF THEIR DISCOGRAPHY THO!!!!!

[@camilamessias4246]

Guys the boys did perform this song in TXT first show ACT:BOY, It was iconic and they also did perform Frost💖

[@shazt3388]

Eternally is a mood

[@katyateplizky708]

HAHAH your reactions are so amusing-- and honestly , when this album dropped we were all just like you hahaha hope you keep reacting to TXT!

[@3976ela]

when he said hes walking in clouds bruh i got goose bumps bcoz thats part on the mv

[@dear_sputnik4449]

TXT killin it

[@vfl4124]

One of the reasons why Eternally is one of my favorite songs 💜 I think you guys should react to a No Rules or Anti Romantic performance.

[@thea1271]

i would love to see you guys react to can't you see me! its the title track of this album

[@aleczohanne6704]

Im reaaallly looking forward to more of your Tomorrow x Together reactions

[@just_a_saeu88]

I love this track too! It was so unexpected the duality in their vocals to sing thr soft parts then follow it up with this aggressive almost death metal vocals! Also pls check out their older tracks later on... esp Puma and Blue Hour to show their amazing duality

[@GirlinReverie]

OMYGOOD THANK YOU FOR THIS. REALLY LOVE WATCHING YOUR REACTIONS

[@wannursyakirahwanbukhari5280]

I suggest FAIRY OF SHAMPOO... TXT do the remake... same album with eternally... I want to hear your opinion how it's different with the popular original one, musically... I think by band called salt.. right?

[@astraeanatsuki3231]

You should reacting to TXT’s Ghosting, it’s pretty interesting too

[@janeniks8645]

i was actually legit abt to cry when i read the first lines of the song, but when the song changed i felt like my tears dried up

[@isabellafreitas3303]

You should react to Dear Sputnik, it's a song produced by Hueningkai and it's really good I think you'll like i!!

[@janinecruzatpineda-vb2yu]

BRO IT'S THE YEONJUN EFFECT

[@reaanatm]

AHAHAHA I AM LAUGHING SO HARD AT YOUR REACTION 🤣🤣🤣 its same actually when i first listen to this song

[@sintachan23]

Eternally is masterpiece💘

[@elygan4085]

Can you react to TXT ost song - Love Sight? You will love txt angelic vocals.

[@staytyuned9746]

Check out Blue Hour! It's an insanely different sound as well

[@staytyuned9746]

And Force as well (the first take)

[@staytyuned9746]

Actually yk what check out their whole discography 😭

[@shizuko7366]

i was waiting for this! moas are murderers lmaoo enjoyed you guys' reaction again^^

[@snowpiercer7735]

pls react to Dear Sputnik. FORCE ( World Trigger OST) on One Take live performance. and 20cm (R&B ) Live performance

[@miyamina2913]

the legendary song🙇‍♀️

[@milkakendek1354]

The hight note taehyun it's a wow like aa, Haaa very soft and be polite to one's ears when one hears💙

[@sheena9243]

pls react to txts runaway next

[@iamghost3602]

Fun fact(actually not if you've been into them for so long): Eternally was released a year before Frost. Eternally is one of their bsides from The Dream Chapter: Eternity album and honestly this album is ahead of it's time. When we got to hear that txt could try this type of genre which is experimental and hyperpop(my guess), seeing that they did so well with Eternally, them trying Frost is like a no brainer. The real fun fact would be that in their entire discography, there is one bside that would connect to their storyline from each album. And their titles would connect to the album title. These are the bsides for their storyline each album The Dream Chapter: Star- Nap of a Star The Dream Chapter: Magic- Magic Island The Dream Chapter: Eternity- Eternally The Chaos Chapter: Freeze- Frost they had one album that is kinda exempted for this it's Minisode 1: Blue Hour. The album is like the transition from the dream chapter to the chaos chapter. It's also abt them expressing their feelings during this pandemic. There's a lot of good bsides from them that covers different types of genre too

[@donnasarza6462]

Eternally is a roller coaster ride 🤣 its one of my favorite!

[@txtbeomgyuu2672]

THANK YOU FOR REACTING TO TXT!💙💙

[@mscellaneous7789]

Awh I want to see you guys react to Nap of the Star and the music Video for the artistic side. Also 20cm for the vocals.

[@pandoranora223]

LOVE THE REACTION GUYS! 💙 Imma subscribe to u guys ♡ TXT never failed to amaze me! Their discographies are unrivaled! They're so amazing! Please react to them more! Please watch Nap of a Star first tho. Cuz if u dont, u guys are gonna be so confuse. React these mvs in order: Nap of a Star mv Magic Island mv Eternally mv The Dooms Night (txt animation)

[@samysmago8658]

Realmente tienen que reaccionar a todas las canciones de TXT! Especialmente los b-sides! A mi me encanta "Wish list" (creo que así se escribía)

[@rainycould9232]

In the "hell part" , it's not only yeonjun's part but it's also Hueningkai's part too :D

[@minasanarigato8837]

Thank you for reacting to txt hope you will get 1k subscribers soon . Why your subscribers are so low you guys gonna be great reactor in the future fighting!!!! 💙

[@yawnjjn8583]

You should react to Runaway by txt :)

[@capvespiere]

06:28 exactly the mv are them walking on cloud 😭

[@sierralyn5693]

Please react to "Can't You See Me?" and "Ghosting" next ^^

[@yeonjuniee5046]

I always love Eternally reaction LMAO

[@page.3419]

Please, keep reacting to TXT. Honestly, there are a lot of interesting things about this group. And I love your videos because you give honest opinions. I'm a new viewer here btw and I'm thankful that I discovered your channel. ♡♡♡

[@MaryBerryMoa]

🤣🤣🤣 "Oh it's so nice and soft". I was just waiting 🤣🤣🤣

[@aleczohanne6704]

Blue Hour, Fairy of Shampoo, or 20cm by Tomorrow x Together please

[@feviagaringarao7448]

React to Hueningkai's cover Youngblood

[@jeniseclark3672]

Thank you for reacting to this. It is hard to find reactions on the song and not the videa

[@thea1271]

YESS ETERNALLY

[@abc-ye1ue]

I love ur reactions so mu h especially how u two genuinely praise txts music & talent Lastly wanna say Please react to blackpink too

[@jcbb9126]

react to TXT - Can't You See Me? or Blue Hour 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻💖💖💖💖

[@bbykai5204]

you guys should react to their interviews some time

[@abhishruti2789]

Really loved your reactions....pls could you react to their "Maze in the Mirror" from the same album The Dream Chapter Eternity......it was co-produced by Beomgyu and all the members participated in writing the lyrics.

[@elizabethluci28]

TXT IS THE BEST OF KPOP!!!

[@jescelkristinemosquete9174]

I kept coming back for your reactions hahaha😍

[@sarah-yj3ec]

i'm laughing so hard right now GGASJHSKSSH thank you

[@cheeyongtang7137]

run away!!!

[@bloodfire7641]

Enjoy your reaction and TXT’s song💗

[@hiyyihonmymind4162]

anti romantic next~

[@SunsamstansTXT]

TXT slayys!

[@vanesacarrasco246]

Jajajajaja I really love you guys ❤️, for more angelic voices maybe check out anti-romantic live 😉

[@yeonjuniee5046]

If y'all want a soft song I recommend Fairy of Shampoo 😍

[@lilsoob615]

the first video im watching of you two and I can tell, I already love your reactions XD

[@jerryle7550]

Wow this is the first video I've ever watched with literally NO DISLIKE omg its insane, like howwwww...???

[@BeAG00dHuman]

The way y'all paused was 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jaejaejoon5414]

You guys need to check txt cover F2020, Hueningkai-Youngblood and Taehyun-Let Me Plisss react thatt

[@melishanez6351]

20cm next please!😊

[@beomgyuslostsandhanitizer]

Yass plz

[@biaseverina7232]

Can you guys reaction to Wayv phantom MV for fist time PLEASE!!! it is so FUCKING AMAZING!!!💚💚

[@yanie5067]

react to dear sputnik please😝

[@BeAG00dHuman]

If bi-polar was a song, it would be eternally by Tomorrow X Together. As a new kpop fan who was getting into TXT when I first heard this song I was like who changed my music just for me to check my phone and BAMMMMM same song with a mad switch When it got to the final part brah I felt it when you clapped because this song is too good it felt like walking on clouds. My only issue is that Eternally really should have been eternally 🤧🤧🤧 BRAHHHH TXT ARE AMAZING I CAN'T EVEN EXPLAIN....

[@fulltimemoaparttimeastuden812]

I'm still waiting reaction for mv😭

[@LesEXO2012]

Lmfao The reaction 🤣

[@bellabell7080]

FORCE please 🥺 It's Japanese song. They perform it at The First Take Channel

[@moaarmy6623]

[@fairykepi6385]

Please react to their performance of Eternally x Frost! ❣️

[@curleyyfriies9774]

2:09 "My hairs are having an erection." HAHAHA I CAN'T WITH THIS DUDE LMAO

[@nandiputra634]

Fairy of shampo