I've made a similar-ish decision to you in that instead of making my usual annual Erin Condren purchase for my main planner (I've bought a 7x9 standard vertical on and off for years), I've gone back to Tilly Journals for this year. In the same vein as this haul, I've bought the planner, stickers and accessories for virtually the same price as I'd have paid as just the planner and one accessory plus US shipping & taxes. It's hard to part with what you're familiar with, but ultimately it makes more financial sense!!