Why Menuka Paudel Eliminated From Indian Idol 14? Vishal Dadhlani Angry Moment (Reaction)

[@santbyathit9578]

The sad thing here is that the judges who are supposed to judge the voice and singing accuracy gave priority to forgetting the words. I think the judges themselves will be sad that Menuka is out of Indian Idol.

[@koushik5437]

then again everyone who forgets the lines will be given harsh verdict ...it's the basic rule ....

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"It's disappointing to see that the judges, who should prioritize vocal talent and singing accuracy, chose to focus on Menuka forgetting the lyrics. Their decision seems to overlook her incredible ability and the journey she has taken to get here. I think the judges will eventually realize the impact of their decision and might even feel regret about Menuka's departure from Indian Idol. She represents not just talent but also resilience and inspiration for many. It’s a loss not just for her but for the show as well."

[@TARIT518371]

इस शो में जज अपनी जगह सही हैं, उनकी राय शो के नियमों के अनुसार है, इस आधार पर मेनुका को निकाला जाता है, यहाँ तक तो बात ठीक है लेकिन ऐसा कहना कि तुम ये मत सोचो कि यह शो तुम्हारे खूबसूरत प्रदर्शन की वजह से चल रहा है, यह बहुत गलत बात है जो एक प्रतियोगी के दिल को ठेस पहुँचाती है, हाँ, उससे गलती हुई है लेकिन प्यार से भी उसे निकाला जा सकता था, लेकिन इस तरह, इतने बत्तमीजि से बात नहीं करनी है

[@santbyathit9578]

In fact, Menuka Paudel was the most melodious singer in the competition. Everyone listened to her with great attention and even the judges praised her as the goddess of music.

[@ryuden8592]

She disrespected Shreya Ghoshal ,stopping her while she was singing. She got over confidence and pride gradually

[@Deepratan27]

ये सब judges जानपुछ कर करवाते हैं क्योंकि Menuka को बिना Indian Idol जीते ही फिल्म्स में singing के ऑफर मिल रहे है उसके लिये शो जीतना जरूरी नहीं है

[@goldkskr9853]

This is the same Vishal Dadlani who at Sa re ga ma pa 2010 said when one of the contestant from his show stopped singing, " I told my contestants that you can stop singing midway if you are not getting right sur and tune you can stop" .And when other judges reminded him that this is a competition..He threatened to leave the show..Hypocrisy at another level...

[@rabindrabhattarai8680]

Vishal is the worst face of corrupt makers. He gets mad at a most talented female singer. It is a planned scheme to take Menuka out. Even if we believe forgetting lines, he has no right to get angry. It is a misconduct and highly unprofessional. Vishal should publicly apologize for his unprofessional behavior to Menuka.

[@parmodsehijpaul3301]

I thinking it was star voice of India and contestant was Neeti Mohan

[@kantaphatchokphiphatmetha6863]

@@rabindrabhattarai8680 Vishal is the most upright judge. Giving opportunities to people must have limits so as not to infringe on the rights of others.

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"You're absolutely right. It's surprising to see Vishal Dadlani act so differently now compared to his stance on Sa Re Ga Ma Pa in 2010. Back then, he defended a contestant's decision to stop singing mid-performance, even threatening to leave the show now, with Menuka Poudel, a talented blind singer, he criticizes her for forgetting a line, calling it her third mistake. The inconsistency in his approach does seem like hypocrisy. Shouldn't the focus be on nurturing talent, especially for someone as inspiring as Menuka?"

[@padambahadurthapa6186]

Menuka Poudel ko ekbar ke liye chance dena chahiye

[@ಠಿಠಿ-ದ6ಗ]

3 baar ?

[@USAjaynepal]

प्यारा Menuka जैसा दुर्लभ और divine and extraordinarily outstanding singer को छोटीसी language mistake बजहपे cruelly eliminate करना SONY management और Judges का बचपन्ना और मुर्खता है। फिरसे popular show मे बुलाकर जनताकी पसन्द कायम रखके खुस करना चाहिए। क्षमा दान सबसे बढी चिज भी होती है। धन्यबाद।

[@HasanReels]

We know menuka is good singer but this time maybe not for menuka hope in future we will see her again

[@noorasesoria943]

i think that Menuka is the best....she must be the winner ! for me she is the best !

[@neenamarar7311]

It’s a pity that menuka has to be eliminated from this contest. But it is true what the judges said that she made mistakes 3 times. rules have to be applied to all contestants fairly.

[@HasanReels]

👏

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"It’s indeed a pity that Menuka has been eliminated from the contest. While it’s true that she made mistakes three times, and rules need to be applied fairly to all contestants, it’s also important to remember the unique challenges she faces as a blind singer. Her journey has been incredibly inspiring, and it’s unfortunate that her talent was overshadowed by a few mistakes. Hopefully, this experience will open up more opportunities for her in the future. She deserves to be recognized for her hard work and dedication."

[@dmyalagudri9618]

Menuka's voice marvelous ❤

[@AmanSingh-ll9pi]

Show has already fixed mindset who has to be winner and whom to be eliminated.. Menuka paudel eliminated because she is not from India and shows name itself is Indian idol not Nepal idol 😅 this is the only reason why she has been eliminated and if we talk about right judgement then every contestants should have similarities in basic things she is blind and to rote 2 or 3 song in 6 days is a big challenge in itself.... So if she forgot lyrics she should had to be given favour... How many of you are here who has been learn hisor her favourite song completely by only listening???? If anyone has doneb it then honestly tell since how many times you were listening that song???

[@HasanReels]

Yes we know bahoot bura hua but kya Kare show must be go on.

[@paldenlepcha4010]

Charm of Indian Idol 14 has faded away after menuka 's elimination. She is differently abled person that point to be thoroughly evaluated by the judges.

[@abelkumar7547]

I too feel this is not right. Indian Idol is the platform to present melodious voice, rather than words.

[@swponroy5272]

Miss you menuka 😢

[@k.inderjitsingh4893]

These judges do not know how difficult it is to sing when you're blind. They should try putting a blind over their eyes and see whether or not it's easy to sing. They should have shown some compassion. What's going to happen to future participants who are handicapped if this is how they are going to be treated?

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"It's shocking how these judges seem oblivious to the struggles that blind singers like Menuka face. They should try singing with a blindfold on and see if they can perform flawlessly-it's a whole different ballgame! A little compassion would go a long way. If this is how they treat someone with such talent and resilience, what hope do future participants with disabilities have? We need judges who not only focus on technicalities but also understand the heart and determination behind each performance. It’s time for a shift in perspective!"

[@parvatigiri]

Menuka Ji Ke Bina Indian Idol14 Ko Dekhna Apna Samay Barbaad Karna Hai...

[@mollyrigby8799]

Without Menuka Indian idol is not the same

[@zafarali8569]

Bilkul

[@S.n146]

Right

[@zafarali8569]

Menuka genuine pure singer

[@rabindrabhattarai8680]

Shame on, you, Vishal, and other judges. We know maker's and you judges schemed to take Menuka out. Either did not give her time to practice or harresing tactics. I don't believe a professional singer will make such a mistake😮

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"Really disappointing to see how the judges treated Menuka. It feels like there was some behind-the-scenes strategy to push her out. Did they even give her enough time to prepare? I can't imagine a professional singer making such mistakes without feeling immense pressure. This is not just about talent; it's about support and understanding. Menuka deserves a fair chance, and the way she was handled is simply unfair."

[@AmarendraDeka-j1c]

She forgot the lyrics, that might be due to her health abnormality . But her singing was praiseworthy

[@ArjunShekhawat-f1k]

Menuka is the best singer

[@ysatyadevsatya3740]

Very unfair judgement

[@janukanepal7940]

Heart touching 😢

[@advpandeyshivprakash]

मेनुका वास्तव में जज से भी आगे निकल रही थी ये सब सोच समझ कर किया गया

[@ConfusedKoi-pv7ks]

Menuka ke voice ke wajah se idian idol dekhte they hum

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

It’s truly disheartening to see Menuka being eliminated from Indian Idol, especially when her exceptional voice has the power to touch hearts. She deserved a fair chance, not because she is blind, but because her vocal talent is extraordinary and deserves recognition. The focus should be on her ability to sing beautifully, conveying emotion and depth, rather than penalizing her for a few mistakes. As a blind person myself, I understand the unique challenges that come with this condition, but I also know that talent transcends those challenges. Many people today claim that blind individuals can do everything that sighted individuals can, and while this is a noble sentiment, it often ignores the specific obstacles we face. If we were truly treated as "normal," then why are we labeled as blind? Why do we need canes to navigate our surroundings? Menuka’s situation highlights the importance of recognizing talent over the physical conditions of a contestant. Her ability to perform should be judged on her voice and artistry, not on the challenges she faces due to her blindness. It's a reminder that while we strive for equality and inclusion, we must also appreciate the extraordinary effort it takes for someone like her to stand on that stage and share her gift with the world. Platforms like Indian Idol should be champions of talent, providing opportunities for all artists, regardless of their background. Menuka’s voice is a gift that deserves to be heard and celebrated, and her elimination based on a few mistakes is a disservice not only to her but to the spirit of the competition. In the end, it’s not just about being “normal”; it’s about recognizing and celebrating the diverse abilities that individuals bring to the table. Menuka's journey is a testament to resilience and talent, and she should be given the chance to showcase that to the world. Thank you for considering my perspective.

[@ahmedizyan5287]

Vishal said the true 3 times she did the same mistake she has to be eliminated

[@advpandeyshivprakash]

मैं menuka के कारण शो देखता था अब नही देखता 😢

[@bhaskarupadhyaya7308]

Elimintion of Menuka is not fair

[@dilraj24]

Judges are Rgt here. It's compitision Not Compromising Show. Baaki Menuka is great singer she will be solve it as soon 🔜 as.

[@HasanReels]

Yes 👌

[@dilraj24]

Thanks Hasan bhai

[@deepadutta5252]

सच बात तो ये है की, ये जो जज है, ये चाहते नही है की, मेनुका आगे बड़े, वरना इन सभी की दाल रोटी बंद हो जाएगी,,,, जिसको केजीएफ, सलार जैसे मूवी का टाइटल सॉन्ग मिल जाय,,,, क्या उसकी आवाज और बीच में भूल जाना गलत है, जिस इंसान का आंख सही होता है, उन इंसान को न्यूरो की भी बीमारी होती है,,,, लेकिन ये इंडियन आइडल के जज क्या जाने,

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

सच में, इन जजों का तो कुछ और ही मकसद लग रहा है। ऐसा लगता है कि वे नहीं चाहते कि मेनूका आगे बढ़े 😂 जब किसी को केजीएफ या सलार जैसे बड़े प्रोजेक्ट्स के लिए टाइटल सॉन्ग गाने का मौका मिले, तो एक छोटी सी भूल के लिए उसे बाहर करना तो बहुत ही नाइंसाफी है। लेकिन क्या इन इंडियन आइडल के जजों को ये बात समझ में आती है? शायद नहीं, क्योंकि वे तो बस कुर्सियों पर बैठे-बैठे फैसले लेते हैं, जैसे ये कोई खेल हो। कला की असली पहचान तो दिल से होती है, और सिंगिंग में भी भावनाओं का होना बहुत ज़रूरी है।

[@a.kumarsharma7092]

Ab aisa lag raha hai wo contestants finale me bhi ho aur jeet bhi Jaye. Kyonki upar se jab bamboo hai kuchh kar bhi nahi sakte. But Shreya ji hope thi ki wo fair deceion....but......

[@rockhard216]

Vishal is a fake judge!! He should be eliminated. He does not deserve to share the same stage with Shreya and Kumar Sanu! He is not in their league!

[@HasanReels]

He is a Music Director, composer, playback singer, he have so much knowledge about music 🎶 why you think he don't deserve?

[@shirosunam7681]

It is a COMPETITION menuka cannot get all the advantages just because she is differently abled. Just look at the way she disrespected Shreya by interrupting while she was just trying to help menuka not to lose her confidence

[@Art_Ka-Pitara]

Bhaii vishal sirr ko music ka bohot gyan hai or jo bola vishal sir ne wo sai bola baar baar usko support karenge to Baaki contestants ke saath unfair competition hoga

[@nandinisaric1641]

Nur weil sie blind ist oder sieht anderes aus. Das ist nicht korrekt. Vishal hat keine recht weil sie ist anders als andere. Was Vishal. Grosse Unrecht gemacht. Ich sage dir eine gibst GOT und er bekommt seine Karma. Er muss raus egal wie er alt ist. Menuka ist perfekt.

[@mparjara]

Wrong decision this rule is draconian I am of the opinion that every singer must have a note with him to avoid such situation In case the singer is blind judges must help Even a great orator has a note with him to avoid breaking Of chains of thoughts

[@СалимаУмирзакова-у7ж]

Brewo.menuko..yzdekiston.❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@zafarali8569]

Menuka k bina ab kbhi indian idol hum nhi dekhein gy

[@Rawatjikevlogss]

Unko ghanta farak nhi hai tere dekhne ya na dekhne se 😂

[@mparjara]

All three judges were harsh upon the singer They did not consider that she is blind due to neurological problem No singer will ever like to forget the lyrics Intentionally In first song in. Which She missed one line adjudged Lit instead of hit In other song she Complained of vocal cord and heart-beat but she was forced to sing In third case she was now not Allowed to sing from Antra You may judge how these judges were harsh upon her Great Injustice to music committed by so called Judges

[@mparjara]

Singer should not be overburdened Not more than two songs be given to sing Singing is not easy it affects the heart and throat

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"I completely agree that singers should not be overburdened. Expecting them to perform multiple songs in a single round can be overwhelming. Singing is an art that requires not just talent but also emotional and physical stamina. It can take a toll on the heart and throat, especially for those who are already navigating challenges like Menuka. We need to recognize that each artist has their own limits, and the pressure of performing too many songs can hinder their ability to showcase their true talent. It's essential for platforms like Indian Idol to prioritize the well-being of their contestants and create an environment where they can perform at their best without the added stress. As other contestants have pointed out, the competition should focus on quality rather than quantity. By allowing each singer to concentrate on one or two songs, we can truly appreciate their artistry and emotional expression. This approach not only supports the contestants but also enhances the overall experience for the audience."

[@mparjara]

Inspite of these facts she was overburdened She was asked to sing more than two songs at a time

[@muhammadsajidhasan5220]

Bhool jana oak alg bat hai lekin us ki awaz mind blowing hai yr😅😅😅😅

[@SaneetanganAlipurduar]

Koi baat nhi aisa hota hai,,,menuka ekdin bohut aage jayegi for sure👍👍kyu ki inki gayeki mein lata ji ehsaas hoti hai mujhe jo isse pehle koi bhi female artist pe mujhe nhi dekhne ko mila...

[@TARIT518371]

मैं इस स्थिति को समझता हूँ, मेनुका से हुई इस प्रदर्शन में गलतियों को शो के नियमों के अनुसार नजरअंदाज नहीं किया जा सकता है, इस आधार पर उन्हें बाहर किया जा सकता है, यहाँ तक तो सब ठीक है लेकिन ऐसा कहना कि शो आपके सुंदर प्रदर्शन के कारण चल रहा है, ये उचित नहीं है, एक जज को अपने शब्दों पर नियंत्रण रखना चाहिए, इस तरह से किसी भी प्रतियोगी को अपमानित नहीं किया जाना चाहिए, यह मेनुका के साथ बहुत गलत हुआ है, ऐसा कहकर जज ने बहुत बड़ा अन्याय किया है, हमें हर व्यक्ति से इज़ज़त से पेश आना चाहिए, जिन जजो ने उनका समर्थन किया था अगर वे ही इस तरह से कड़वी बात करते हैं, तो सुनने में बहुत बुरा लगता है। पर एक बात सत्य है कि उनकी सुर, मीठी स्वर, गायकी अदाएं प्रशंशनीय है, अतुलनीय हैं। इसे अस्वीकार नहीं किया जा सकता, ये लड़की अपनी आवाज़ के वज़ह से बहुत आगे जाएगी, इसे शो में प्रतिस्पर्धा करने की कोई आवश्यकता नहीं है

[@cbpjnv]

जिस कमी के होते हुए वो इस स्तर पर पहुंची है, अगर ईश्वर न करे बाकी को भी उसी संघर्ष से गुजरना होता तो मानता की सबके साथ नाइंसाफी हो रही है। गीत के बोल सुनकर याद करना, भावनाओं को केवल आवाज से महसूस कर लेना सबके बस की बात नहीं। मेनुका की आवाज अदभुत है।

[@geethapapa]

She was a very talented singer best of all. She got eliminated because she forgot the words. That is sad. I agree with the judges . In a competition you have to perform your best to win. But i dont agree the judges being so rude to her. I feel bad.

[@k.inderjitsingh4893]

I wonder how she had less votes when from what I can see from the comments she had many supporters. Once again I feel it is very important for the viewers to get to see (unbiasedly) the actual number of votes each participant is receiving. An independent body has to be formed to keep a check on these competitions that everything is as it is.

[@a.kumarsharma7092]

Jaisa Mr Vishal ji ne kaha ki other contestants ke fair nahi hoga , to be frankly Yeh competition fair ho raha hai kya ? Ek contestants below par performance ke baad bhi top 8 me hai.

[@nayramishra5798]

Bs isi karan s hmara desh axe talented kalakaro ko kho rha hai

[@sachinmagdum]

एहसास हमे हमारे पंच ज्ञान इंद्रियोंसे मिलनेवाले ज्ञान से सुरू होता है. मेनुका की आंखोकी कमी के कारण सर हो सकता है की जो चिजे समझना हमारे लिए आसान है उसके लिए न हो। जैसे रंग, रूप, चांद, सितारे उनके बारे मे गाये जाणे वाले गाणे… उसे भला एहसास कैसे कराएंगे?

[@virenkashyap1917]

Agar menuka ne naye gaane jada gaye hote toh unke stardom ko jada fhayda hota aaj ke time pe voice jada meter karti hai new songs main unki voice texture change hoti hai ya nahi yeh sab sapna he rhe gaya 🎉

[@santbyathit9578]

Also, the rules and criteria set for everyone in the competition should be the same, but the disabled, who were praised as Indian Idol's slogan "Ek Awaz Lakh Ahasas", would not be eliminated for forgetting the words.

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"Absolutely, the rules and criteria should be the same for all contestants. However, it's important to consider the message behind Indian Idol's slogan 'Ek Awaz Lakh Ahasas.' This slogan emphasizes the beauty of diverse voices and the unique experiences each contestant brings to the stage. For contestants with disabilities, like Menuka, who face additional challenges, forgetting the words should not be the sole reason for elimination. It's crucial that the competition recognizes the extraordinary effort and talent these individuals exhibit despite their difficulties. Eliminating someone like Menuka for a mistake overlooks the essence of the show, which is about celebrating talent in all its forms. If the platform truly values every voice, then the criteria should reflect an understanding of the unique challenges faced by all contestants, particularly those with disabilities. It's about fairness and compassion, not just strict adherence to rules."

[@jagchahal6849]

If you are a contestant then the platform for you and everyone is the same.

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"While it's true that the platform is the same for all contestants, it’s crucial to recognize that each individual has unique circumstances and challenges. Blind individuals should indeed be viewed as normal and capable, but it’s also important to understand that they face specific difficulties that others may not. Regarding the concern about Menuka making mistakes for the third time, while rules should apply equally to all, it’s essential to consider the context. Every contestant's journey is different, and true fairness means understanding the various challenges they face. In Menuka's case, her blindness adds layers of complexity to her performance, which may not be fully understood by those who haven't faced similar obstacles. Eliminating her on this basis not only undermines her talent but also raises questions about the overall fairness of the competition. If the focus is solely on rules without considering individual circumstances, then the spirit of the competition is compromised. We should celebrate each artist’s journey and also ensure that we’re supporting those who may need it more than others."

[@sumit_45v]

No doubt she is one of the brilliant singer in the show but vishal was also correct...if she forgot her line 3 times then its mistake and ignoring this mistake repeatedly is totally unfair to other contestents

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"While I respect Vishal’s perspective, I believe it’s essential to consider the bigger picture. Yes, she made mistakes by forgetting her lines, but eliminating her for that feels overly harsh, especially given her incredible talent. Singing is not just about hitting the right notes; it’s also about conveying emotion and connecting with the audience. Repeatedly penalizing her for forgetting a line doesn’t take into account the unique challenges she faces, particularly as a blind singer. It's important to recognize that mistakes can happen, and they shouldn't overshadow her overall performance or contributions to the show. Instead of focusing solely on those mistakes, we should appreciate her journey and the effort she puts into each performance. The competition should be about celebrating talent and growth, not just rigidly enforcing rules. It feels unfair to prioritize a technical mistake over her undeniable artistry and the joy she brings to the audience."

[@mparjara]

Due to this draconian rule Lata Mangeshkar stopped singing for 6 month This rule must be changed😊

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"It’s truly disheartening to see how draconian rules can impact talented artists. I’ve heard that even the legendary Lata Mangeshkar stopped singing for six months because of similar pressures. This shows just how detrimental such rules can be-not only to performances but to the mental well-being of artists who pour their hearts into their craft. I’m a huge fan of Shreya Ghoshal; her voice is nothing short of magical! She has this incredible ability to convey deep emotions through her singing, which is what makes her so special to me. While I may not fully understand why Lata Ji made her decision, it’s clear that every artist deserves the freedom to express themselves without the fear of harsh penalties for mistakes. I believe it’s time for a change in these rules to foster a more supportive environment, where artists can thrive and share their gifts without unnecessary pressure. After all, music is meant to be a celebration of talent and emotion, not a source of stress."

[@deepadutta5252]

सब कुछ राजनीति है,,,, सच तो यही है की, जो जो विजेता, इंडियन आइडल के मंच जीता है, वो विजेता अभी भी घंटा ही बजा रहा है,,,, कुछ कर नहीं पा रहा है,,,, लेकिन मेनूका को जो, प्यार मिला, वो समझो, सलार जैसे मूवी का टाइटल ट्रैक गाना,,,, कितने बॉलीवुड के गायक हैं जो गया है, केजीएफ़ जैसे मूवी में गाना

[@sashas5840]

Its a show and she has been given 3 chances. Its not a normal show

[@k.inderjitsingh4893]

These competitions should also reveal the number of votes received by each participant if they are going to justify each elimination. Otherwise it looks very suspicious. If they can do that for elections why can't they do the same for such competitions?

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

yes "I truly believe that these competitions should be transparent about the voting process, especially when eliminations are involved. If they are justifying each elimination based on votes, it would make sense to reveal the number of votes each participant receives. This lack of transparency can create a sense of suspicion among fans and viewers, making it hard to trust the process. It's disheartening to see talented individuals like Menuka leave the competition without a clear understanding of why. If voting results can be made public in elections, why can’t they be shared in talent shows? Knowing the voting numbers would not only bring clarity but also validate the hard work and dedication that each contestant puts in. As fans, we invest our emotions and support into these artists, and we want to believe in the fairness of the competition. Transparency would help build that trust and show that every voice matters. Ultimately, we all want to celebrate talent in a fair and open manner, honoring the dreams and aspirations of every participant."

[@rajeshharsora5806]

Vo to. Menuka ko. Bhagwan. Manta tha. Aab mistake. Nikal ta he. Ek divyango. Kitna. Bina. Dekhe. Gana muskil hota he

[@mparjara]

If a singer forgets the lyrics or complains of vocal cord or heart beat he she be given another. Chance

[@shirosunam7681]

When Shreya ma'am tried to help her by continuing the song Menuka interrupted her, she did not even think thst Shreya ma'am is a judge and more experienced than her. She should've respected her efforts of cheering her up. Carrying ego but not correcting her own mistake is where she was wrong. Maybe she can get another chance if she knows what's right to do in such situations

[@HasanReels]

👏

[@Troy746]

No she did not know she was helping her out.

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"Yes, I completely agree; that moment was quite telling. When Shreya ma'am stepped in to help Menuka by continuing the song, it was a beautiful gesture coming from someone with so much experience. Instead of appreciating that support, Menuka interrupted her, which showed a lack of awareness and respect for Shreya's efforts. In a competitive environment like this, it’s crucial for artists to remain humble and open to guidance, especially from seasoned professionals. It's easy to let ego get in the way, but acknowledging and accepting help is part of growing as an artist. If Menuka had embraced Shreya’s encouragement instead of pushing it away, it could have made a significant difference in her performance and her experience on the show. We all make mistakes, and it’s how we learn from them that truly matters. Perhaps this situation serves as a lesson for Menuka. If she can recognize the importance of humility and respect for her peers and mentors, she might find herself with another opportunity to showcase her immense talent. Artists grow not just through their successes, but also through their ability to learn from their experiences and interactions with others. I hope this experience helps her reflect on what it means to be a part of a supportive artistic community."

[@Troy746]

@@PatelJiya-gr9fc you got it all wrong. Watch it carefully she can not see and she was so lost in her singing that she could not realize that Shreya is trying to help her. No doubt Shreya is all time favourite of all of us I am just tying to tell you the truth. She could have continued singing if she actually heard that Shreya is trying to help her.

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

@@Troy746 "It’s hard to believe that anyone could become so engrossed in their singing that they completely miss the judgment and support from others. In a competitive setting, especially on a platform like Indian Idol, awareness of one’s surroundings is crucial. Regardless of whether someone is blind or not, it’s essential to remain attentive to the feedback and encouragement from those around us. Respect is a crucial part of any performance or competition. Acknowledging the support and guidance from experienced judges, like Shreya, is equally important. In a high-pressure environment where everyone is striving to do their best, it's vital for each contestant to show respect not only to the judges but also to their fellow competitors. While I appreciate Menuka’s undeniable talent and passion for singing, I believe that being aware of the support provided by others can lead to a more enriching experience. Ignoring help in such a situation could create misunderstandings and missed opportunities. Ultimately, fostering an atmosphere of respect and collaboration can enhance the overall quality of the competition."

[@zafarali8569]

Menuka k bina indian idol is rubbish

[@Gulfamonihadi]

❤

[@MDJamalHossain-tp5mb]

Ya mujhe bilkul phacand nehi hai Ki menuka ko nikal dieya Ya kumar Sanu shreya or vishal ka technic hai Esliya ki menuka ko awoas lata g jasha hai Why not the promotion of the three of them will decrease

[@surajbahadur9410]

Jan bujhkar Menuka ko bola gya tha ki aap words vul Jana taki aapko eliminate kar sake q ki aapko to film me mouka mil gya hai200%

[@HasanReels]

Aisa Nahi Hai ji

[@subhajitdutta3323]

aisa hi hai bro@@HasanReels

[@subhajitdutta3323]

same happened with saumya chakraborty of indian idol earleir

[@sreenivasd6609]

Mujhe bhi vohi lag raha hai. Pehle vo is se bhi kadhin gane theek se ga rahi thi. Daal me kuch kaala zaroor hai

[@HusnainAsr]

Minuka is the best singer baqi sb bchche hain

[@abhijitroy2192]

Menuka is the best singer than any other

[@mparjara]

This is draconian law

[@BirendraKumar-db7tz]

यह वीडियो बहुत अच्छा लगा क्योंकि नियम नियम होता है कानून कानून होता है यह तो दया का दान नहीं है ना और भूल नहीं सुधार आएगा तो अच्छा सिंगरभी नहीं बन पाएगा ऐसे तो मेनू का मॉडल बहुत अच्छा सिंगर है और सुरीली है एक बार उसको निकल गया तो फिर से कोशिश करिए उसके पास हम लोग हैं अर्जुन भैया लोग वीडियो बनाते हैं बनाते हुए बहुत अच्छा लगा

[@Indiansvocal]

Niyam ye kahta hai ki singing ke tym bas song yaad rakh kar aap idol nahi ban sakte singing singing quality bahut jaruri hai mistake unse bhi hota hai jo kurshi par baith hai 1000 misteks hota hai mai gala fad kar bol raha hu menuka me jo quality hai wo another singer Mr nahi hai is liye niyam ki baat na kare to bahtar hoga Mai chala jau Indian idol m apna gala fadne bas lyrics yaad rakhar idol ban jaunga bolo kya bolte ho

[@Indiansvocal]

Is liye niyam apni jagah hai or performing quality apni jagah ji ki menuka m bhar bhar kar hai bahi mai ek chota sa student hu singing Sikh Raha hu lekin itna pata hai ki ek aur wale ko o besure ke ware me bata sakta hu mistake whole life hoti hai kabhi bhi ho sakti hai kisi s bhi mistakes ko thik kiya ja sakt hai unko mauka de kar ek recording pr wo jo kurshi pr baithe hain wo khud Kai ghanti lagate hain tab song complete karte hain or baat kar rahe ho Kursi ki value samjho kala ko samjho pahle khud sikho jaj log fir kisi or ko jaj karna. Kya bigad jata 3rd winner hi banaa dete menuka ko ananya se bhi acha gati hai menuka mai ghatiya Manta hu season 14th ko usme menuka ke liye kiya gaya decision ko nihayat ghatiya hai usko bichari ko kaam dena ke bajay show se nikala 😬😬😬

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"आपकी बात सही है कि नियमों का पालन करना बहुत ज़रूरी है, लेकिन हमें यह भी समझना चाहिए कि कभी-कभी विशेष परिस्थितियों को ध्यान में लेना भी महत्वपूर्ण होता है। मेनूका की स्थिति में दया दिखाना और उसे एक और मौका देना एक अच्छा विचार हो सकता है। जैसा कि मैंने पहले कहा था, अगर हम केवल मेनूका की आवाज और उसकी प्रतिभा पर ध्यान दें, तो हमें यह समझना होगा कि एक भूल को बार-बार गंभीरता से लेना सही नहीं है। जब आप किसी कलाकार की मेहनत और समर्पण को देखते हैं, तो आपको यह समझना चाहिए कि हर कोई इंसान है और गलतियां कर सकता है। विशाल का यह कहना कि नियम सभी के लिए समान होने चाहिए, सही है, लेकिन क्या हम यह भी नहीं कह सकते कि हम सभी की यात्रा में उतार-चढ़ाव आते हैं? मेनूका ने जो हासिल किया है, वह उसकी कठिनाईयों और संघर्ष का परिणाम है। अगर हम सिर्फ एक बार की गलती के लिए किसी को बाहर कर देते हैं, तो इससे हमें यह संदेश नहीं मिलता कि हम अपने कलाकारों का समर्थन कर रहे हैं। हम सभी जानते हैं कि हर कलाकार की यात्रा में असफलताएं और सफलताएं होती हैं। मेनूका की आवाज की सुंदरता और उसकी प्रतिभा को एक और मौका मिलना चाहिए। उसे अपने अनुभव से सीखने का अवसर मिलना चाहिए, ताकि वह और बेहतर बन सके। यह एक बार की गलती को नकारने का समय नहीं है, बल्कि इसे एक मौके के रूप में देखना चाहिए, ताकि वह अपनी कला को और भी निखार सके। एक कलाकार को हमेशा अपना सर्वोत्तम देने का अवसर मिलना चाहिए, और हमें उनके साथ खड़ा रहना चाहिए, चाहे उनकी यात्रा कितनी भी कठिन क्यों न हो। मेनूका के जैसे प्रतिभाशाली कलाकारों को इस मंच पर रहने का हक है, और हमें उन्हें प्रोत्साहित करने की आवश्यकता है, ताकि वे अपने सपनों को पूरा कर सकें।"

[@uttamkarmakar8855]

Right decision

[@nitinyash4233]

मेनूका अच्छी singer है.... पर यहाँ वो गलत थी lines बार बार भूलना गलत है जबकि बार बार practice की गई होंगी मतलब कोई समझाये भी नई गलती बताये भी नई और जो ठीक गा रहे हैँ भूलते नहीं हैँ उनको बाहर कर दिया जाए. ये तो parchiality हुई ... हार जीत तो गेम का हिस्सा है जीतना तो एक को ही है जो लोग judges पे ऊँगली उठा रहे हैँ सबसे जाएदा मेनूका के सुपर telent की वो ही insult कर रहे हैँ आज अगर उसको अंधेपन की वजह से आगे बढ़ा दिया जाता तो लाइफ मे वो encouraged nai hoti wo telented है आगे भी बढ़ेगी पर बिना parchielity के

[@dharmowteebucktowar1766]

Menuka should have been given due to her visual impairment. She can't see and exposure to international audiences would have put Indian idol on a separate level

[@muhammadsajidhasan5220]

Very unfair with menuka 😢😢

[@mparjara]

I do not agree with judges I am poet when I go to the platform I keep a note with me to avoid such situation The judges are not only harning the .Music but disheartening the singers

[@zafarali8569]

Vishaal should b eliminated he is totaly fake

[@littlemusic6721]

Mai Manuka ki vajah se show dekhti thi.. now..koi vintner ho.. humne Manuka ko vinner man liya

[@RadhaSubba-t5h]

Menuka is already winner

[@syedyakhtar7642]

Menuka has disabelity , while all other contestants do not, so can not compare her with other contestants.

[@venkataramanmv7766]

It's very sad moment...but menuka has melodies voice...but here many factor and parameters in music which every musicians should follow it, bcoz it's a thumb rules of music. But I never saw any one pointed her mistake just everyone just shed tears and praised her which itself is diminishing others music career, if menuka mistake would have been pointed at right time she would have not come to elemenation stages itself....it's purely judges mistake and it's Indian idol why other national people are allowed and then being treated like this... first of all she is a blind and a poor girl didn't know what actually going around her... my sincere request to judges and organizers to point out the mistake and correct them on the spot... please judges and organizers don't fall pray for curse from any contestants this Impact will also ruin judges life bcoz karma will hit back people will forget but nature wont forgive....

[@advpandeyshivprakash]

Menuka is better singer than judges

[@sreenivasd6609]

Exactly ❤

[@jayandratamrakar4820]

All three judges are not experienced judges though they are best in their respective field. They or Indian idol team do not want to deserve the talented singers which is now proved by the winner of Indian idol season 14. This season is one of the worst season so far now. If such ridiculous decision continues for future seasons, I think the life of Indian idol could end badly.

[@sureshmanandhar7883]

3 Bad judges. Boycott Indian idol🤬🤬🤬

[@purankoiri2472]

Faltu baat h renuka to badhiya singgar h

[@charlesheadley358]

Then Muskan aur Utkarsh ko vi wapas lao

[@tsheringtobgyel5069]

Problem is pretest was not conducted on her for readiness for all singer

[@PatelJiya-gr9fc]

"It’s concerning that a proper pretest for readiness wasn’t conducted for all singers, including Menuka. Such assessments are crucial in determining whether contestants are adequately prepared for the competition's demands. Without this step, it’s unfair to expect them to perform at their best, especially in a high-pressure environment like Indian Idol. Every singer brings their own strengths and challenges, and a pretest could have provided valuable insights into their readiness to handle multiple performances. This oversight not only affects the contestants but also the integrity of the competition itself. It’s essential for platforms to implement thorough evaluations to ensure that all participants have the support they need to succeed. By prioritizing the well-being and readiness of each singer, the competition can create a more level playing field, allowing everyone to shine based on their true talent rather than the circumstances they face."

[@Amos12350]

Menuka is blind she can't read n seen the lyrics..without blind also some professional singers also they forget the lines...😮😮😮😮

[@charlesheadley358]

Bilkul sahi decision Menuka ko eliminate karna..

[@syedyakhtar7642]

This particular judge wants to display his authority over a disable contestant!!!!!!!

[@poornimaraikwar2596]

Pehli bat to 2 gaane gawane ki kya jarurat hai contestant se ek hi gana gawana chahiye yar yad karne me bhi muskil hota hai is liye bhup gyi bechari

[@samirdebbarma2357]

Yeh television show hey jha talent dikhya jta hey fhir tou koi v jake gaa dehh ek gaana

[@poornimaraikwar2596]

@@samirdebbarma2357 telent show hai sabko PTA hai lekin wo blind girl hai usko dikhta nhi hai to ek hi gana dena chahiye ye samjhane wali baat hai

[@Indiansvocal]

भाई आप लोगों को तहे दिल से बहुत-बहुत धन्यवाद। आपने जो यह रिएक्शन वीडियो शूट करा और जो भी अपने जनता को दिखाने की कोशिश की है, पर आप दोनों को इस चीज पर वीडियो भी बनानी चाहिए कि बाकी अदर कंटेस्टेंट्स भी है जो menuka से कई ज्यादा घटिया तरीके से गाना गाते हैं। वह कैसे आ सकते हैं। आगे यार आपको सोचना चाहिए कि मेनूका उनसे कई ज्यादा बैटर है और उनके बहुत से फंस सपोर्टेबल है मेनुका जिनको जनता ने चुना है। और भी कहीं ऐसे सिंगर से मैं उनका नाम क्लियर नहीं लेना चाहूंगा जिनको निकल जा सकता था

[@HasanReels]

Thank you 😊 🙏

[@nnsivaram]

Completely ridiculous decision!! The competition is not a test of memory but is of singing in sur and have a good voice. And Menuka was the best on both these aspects . Even Lata mangeshkar used written lyrics when she gave performances. And for heavens sake she is also blind! I repeat this is not a memory test.

[@gangadharmoghe6710]

Indian idol always eliminates the singers with pire voice same thing here in season 13 senjuti was eliminated and now the best singer menuka this is not at all fair i hate indian idol from now

[@saahotherebel2454]

In reaction videos vale channels walonko aur koi kaam nai he, khudka kuch bhi content nai he to iss tarah ke videos daalke views aajaye bas, par ese channels wale khudko KZbin creators bolten hem wah..

[@JitGURUNG-n4t]

Menuka ka kuchh promo nahi dikhaya sony wale ne us par ek bar mein 2,3 gane dekar bahot paresaan kar rahe the ye menuka ko bahar karne ka plan hai aur aaplog isse pahela koi reaction nahi kiya aaj achanak dekhai diya ,khana karke menuka ek mehanati aur imandaar ladki hai who koi bhi gana Aran se gasakti hai ye baat pahele se janti hun khair San khattam bina menuka idle dekhne no interest.

[@HasanReels]

Hum Jante Hai Menuka Is good singer for sure we also support menuka for her amazing voice, Par Hamne Pehle bhe reaction video banaya hai channel pe jake delkh lijiye.

[@Alenaalena-x5e]

Judges 💯👍

[@swativerma1959]

Vishal k baal kaise aa gye 😂

[@yashwantnayak4566]

Menika ke saath galt hua 😢😢😢

[@parmodsehijpaul3301]

She is behaving very strange and of course she looks unusually disoriented……. It is not too hard to understand and could easily happen in this film industry ……if you mix a little bit opium kind substance in food system of someone……which could easily affect body & memory and I could see that in her singing that day……

[@zafarali8569]

Politics involved

[@Moinagogoi-i7u]

Shayad judges ka common sense lena abvi vi baki hai! Sirf menu ke liey bollna para ...............

[@malamangre3125]

Baar baar song bhoolna.Yeh kya baath huwi?

[@gurungbijaya4677]

Indian idol dekhana vand kiya .. l

[@PuranGurung-es3li]

Golat

[@jaikishangehani4753]

Mujhe lagta Hain sab set up Hain, unko nikalna ek bahana bhi ho saktaa Hain. God Knows.

[@malamangre3125]

Nahi thik hai.Sab ko phir to vapas lawo