Hat "Trick" - Sherlock Holmes Deduction

What can you say, by observing a hat, about its owner?
Well, this is the answer (from 2'08'') to how some conclusions about the owner are inferred.
English audio, Greek subs,
See Also: Sherlock Holmes - The Art Of Deduction Part 2:
• Sherlock Holmes - The ...
And Part 1:
• Sherlock Holmes - The ...
Enjoy

[@Southenisland]

my deduction would run something like this: "Well... I can say that the man... is currently... not in possesion of this hat."

[@franciscasusilawatirimbaja2960]

The way he said, “You know my methods.” Oh my, Jeremy Brett. You were such a tease. 😉❤️

[@nutellablop]

I love how The Empty Hearse made a reference to this, with Sherlock making deductions about a hat based on its size (and Mycroft correcting him)

[@KC.45]

Steven Moffat really butchered that scene from the books, didn't he?

[@aaml05]

is it crazy that his voice is the EXACT same voice i hear when reading sherlock holmes?

[@goldensongs4547]

So true

[@ultraviolet128]

lol love it when he puts the hat on - his ears bend over :) love this episode and in my opinion JB is the best Holmes ever - not to mention the fact that he is beautiful :)

[@changingowl10]

@CallumJStewart He actually had corrective surgery when, I think, he was a teenager/young adult. He took eloqution(sp?) classes to help him. Just a little "fun fact". XD

[@NateSean]

With a possible exception of a few, every live actor who has portrayed Holmes has always impressed me. This leads me to believe that the director of each film and television portrayal that has done so must have also read and enjoyed the stories when he or she was a child. Ergo, it is possible to make a movie about a book character with complete and utter respect to the source material.

[@radogost7]

I know this dialogue by heart, that many times I saw it! And how I love his "R" when he says "reason" at 0:44 or "ribbed" at 2:34 :)

[@xxdrosexx]

Talk about flirting... christ...

[@scubasniper8550]

My teacher made me watch this

[@inesfreire9135]

Teacher of what?

[@DarthNaver1]

My Girlfriend, upon watching this clip, said that "He [Jeremy Brett] is a brilliant Holmes and his voice is liquid sex." I don't quite know what to make of this. Someone please deduce something from it.

[@blakeledger5385]

Watson's laugh at 1:55 gets me everytime..haha

[@ShawnaGraham50]

My favorite Holmes.

[@lovelierlex]

looking for a sherlock holmes deduction unaccompanied by greek subtitles tell me if you find

[@radogost7]

@LordHamlet99 Absolutely so! People seem to forget that it`s 19th century and keep reasoning from the point of view of 21st century scientific facts...

[@Hypochondriac1997]

Watson simply got fed up at the end xD

[@piratexcaptainxdanni]

No worries, darling. It's not just you. XD Love this clip! I giggle everytime I read it, too.

[@joecoyote42]

Brett and Rathbone, it matters not to me . It was the brilliant writing of Doyle that brings the man alive

[@TheValeyard92]

I can't read the subtitles. I need... Oh, I don't know... Some kind of interpreter, I suppose. 🤔

[@sherlockh.657]

Oh come on, everyone, it's 'abduction', not deduction. Do your research.

[@fanthy]

I just love it ! :)

[@Southenisland]

@changingowl10 But the task is to describe the owner, not the hat itself. But you might say the owner likes round... and... black hats.... with red linings.

[@theFishy70]

Technically he is not the master of induction or deduction but of abduction. However, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle Mistakenly used the term deduction to describe Holmes's method of reasoning.

[@SlickVoyager]

@ZEEECHET Actually technically it's more like abduction, inference to the best explanation. From the premise that a given hypothesis provides a better explanation for the evidence than any other hypothesis, you conclude that the hypothesis is true.

[@ssehe2007]

EXACTLY!!!!!!!! My thoughts exactly.

[@Quisyfrottesypique]

3:53 Well, you have an answer to everything.

[@jamesbaker8831]

do the greek subtitles contain a hidden message tacked on at the end? =D

[@legolasisagirl]

WITNESS THE MOISTURE

[@DarthNaver1]

@wootytootylemonfruit Ha ha! very funny. However My girlfriend's tastes tend exclusively toward the living. This I have ascertained via careful observation of her habits. And, since the brilliant Mr. Brett no longer fits within this category, it would seem highly dubious that she would dump me for him. Consider also that, while I lack a few of these items, I do possess more of them than any other who's company she keeps, and this possession includes the hat, the cane . . .

[@POTCLUVR337]

Wow. . . Just wow. . .

[@changingowl10]

@Southenisland Ah, of course. I had kinda forgotten that little fact. And I would have still been worse at it. XD Thanks.

[@changingowl10]

@Southenisland LOL! I would be worse at it than that. "Ummmmm, it's... round...and...black...and has a red lining." XDDDD

[@zat04]

Τα επεισόδια (30+) τα έδινε η ελευθεροτυπία πριν μερικά χρόνια.. Αν θέλει κανείς ΙΣΩΣ λοιπόν να βρει τη σειρά από εκεί. Αλλιώς, υπάρχει και το youtube, αρκεί προφανώς να κάνει κάποιος upload με ελληνικούς υπότιτλους..

[@DarthNaver1]

. . . and the quick wits (I do not number modesty among the virtues). Therefore, despite stray considerations to the contrary I deduce that I will never leave the house with an unbrushed hat, and I will entertain said notion as a working hypothesis. P.S. How was that? :)

[@xcdi7848]

What does he say in the min 3:20?

[@JvSalinger]

!00% inductive reasoning. Not an ounce of deduction.

[@KC.45]

It is easier for readers and tv audiences to call them "deductions".

[@slandersir7255]

It's not a trick!

[@NathanRichan]

@DarthNaver1 In your shoes, I'd acquire: British accent Monocle Hat Cane Money Quick Wits And a nifty can of that 'Liquid Sex' stuff, I hear the kids these days are raving about it... Otherwise, there's a more than slight chance she's dumping you for Mr Brett. Or, someone with the aforementioned items. . .

[@OldMacFlai]

re file,mhpws 8a mporoyses na ta kaneis upload kapoy,kapws me kapoio tropo? psaxnomai poly me arthur connan doyle kai eidika ayth h seira einai apisteyth.

[@TruBeliever4Life]

@gerald01 nope its not. but how about those rare episodes where his are isnt neat and tidy. i think it makes him look cute

[@Parnasian]

This deduction, on a simple hat, is creepy! Sherlock Holmes was the Devil himself!

[@Nemoxgirl]

Which episode does the clip come from?

[@legolasisagirl]

@REdsmusic666 Did you see the "come hither" eyes!?!? DID YOU SEE THEM!!

[@OldMacFlai]

φιλε την εχεις με ελληνικους υποτιτλουσ? pls apanta moy, thnx

[@rahmiaksu]

I am certain that your comment may be a mistake as well :)

[@bobjones-rk3lz]

I was tricked into thinking i would see a trick.

[@lovelierlex]

@Southenisland lmao!!!!!

[@eileenschmelcher7350]

Anyone here a Greek Interpreter?

[@changingowl10]

@thepropmonkey *glares* Lucky... XDD

[@MrPouczar]

The master of induction you mean

[@matthewscorner2990]

I don't think I understand the last point. What was the point about gas in a house? And how do candle stains prove whatever it is?

[@ssehe2007]

If he had a gas system laid out he could illuminate his home at night using gas lights. Repeated candle stains indicates that he instead depends on candle light.

[@3rdEarlRussell]

I am a Holmes fan, however this particular abduction by Holmes (certainly not a deduction, except for some parts), is certainly rather bad. There are many equally suitable explanations for many of the features of the hat, and at least one of the inferences is rather bad. For instance, there is no sound scientific evidence linking the size of a man's head to his intellect; even though, at the level of species, there is some evidence that the skull-body ratio tells something about intellect.

[@ssehe2007]

This was the 19th century. Phrenology was a thing.

[@Shadders2010]

Hogwash. The hat might have been an expensive gift, and the goose may have been for his sister. Or other affectionate relative. And a head size does not correlate with intellectual curiosity.

[@Mrgaunt1]

I doubt the sister would be "Mrs. Henry Baker".

[@ElizabethWestphal]

What is the name of the film this scene takes place in?

[@ElizabethWestphal]

Thanks. :)

[@xcdi7848]

+Elizabeth Westphal What does he say in the min 3:20?

[@ElizabethWestphal]

***** "Obviously a free perspirer. Therefore not in the best of training."