Have You Seen This Snail? Review [Spongey Bits]

I talk about an episode that is near and dear to many hearts... just not mine.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Patreon: / pieguyrulz
Twitter: / pieguyrulz
Twitch: / pieguyrulz
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thanks to the folks over at SpongeBuddy Mania's Forums
All art is made by Erin and myself.
Intro Music by Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com)
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0
creativecommons...
Outro Music: • Spongebob Tomfoolery r...

[@Fiddl3head]

Best Internet critic. No really, I mean it. You go into great detail when explaining your judgements, and one can tell that you put a great amount of effort into your videos.

[@Crazyreviewer123]

I agree

[@maryk7262]

and I love how he also keeps other people's opinions and perspectives in mind and even if he doesn't agree, he can still see where they're coming from. He never makes it feel like what he says is set in stone and if you think differently, you're wrong

[@poihpioakarp8845]

in terms of acual legit critisizing and analizing and al that jazz, yes, he is the best there is. in terms of my favorite, as in who l like the most, uh... it's some stiff competition with the Nostalgia Critic

[@maryk7262]

Roei Potash AKA Poihpio nostalgia critic is also pretty awesome

[@Astromontana]

I love the episode because of how much a person can relate to the plot. I personally know what it's like to lose a beloved pet and the sadness it can cause. It's a nice change of pace from Spongebob's usual antics that can't be replicated in real life. Yes I can see why it kind of fails as a drama, but it gives Spongebob more character and gives more variety to the series.

[@Oban2006]

I can't, never had a pet

[@SylentVoidkeeper]

Also, I consider the song fucking awesome

[@KidSnivy69]

That probably explains why I don't care, no pets

[@ShaggySimple]

Isn't that like saying you like "The Splinter" because you've had a splinter and can relate to the pain of having a splinter?

[@mrps2dvd2770]

the song still gets me to this day

[@gerawallstar3487]

I actually love "Have you seen this snail?" a.k.a "Where's Gary?", because this special does have a few decent jokes, and the story is well written. As what one of the reviewers in the video states that "SB is pretty annoying at times, but you can still relate and feel empathy for the character in episodes like this", It made me feel very emotional towards SB and makes you feel so sorry for him that he losts his pet. The song is also good and Well-written, unlike most of the other bad songs on the show like in "To love a Patty" for example. The song has a R&B feel to it, and it is quite catchy and emotional. The Jokes like Patrick's one-liners, and Squidward screaming theee times in the bathtub was hilarious. So yeah, this episode has a good storyline, and good humour too. It is a HUGE improvement over "Dumped."

[@gerawallstar3487]

I kinda agree with the reviews on the video.

[@Ashman-sw3be]

agreed

[@anonymusmysterious5401]

I think I am one of the few people who likes Dumped

[@mildcheddarpreston7291]

It is actually very funny in my opinion. Have you seen the Squidward scream bit?

[@gerawallstar3487]

@@mildcheddarpreston7291 yes. He sounds like a chicken bawking.

[@LaBoss47]

People found you giving this episode a meh controversial? I was far more shocked when you gave the first movie a meh. I personally enjoy this episode a lot due to the small bits of comedy from Patrick and relating to Spongebob's pain. As a kid, and still to this day I feel for Spongebob and the song makes me tear up a little. From the top of my head I think this is the only Spongebob episode to make me feel something more than joy, frustration, or boredom.

[@emanatingf]

@LaBoss47 I sometimes to often feel intrigue, relaxation, contemplation, melancholyness & indifference when I watch episodes.

[@SquidyStudios]

isn't that just your opinion or something

[@TotallyNotTony_]

I always like listening to your videos as audio when I'm doing other things.

[@onettaviator5396]

Same.

[@swishfish8858]

I put the Every Episode videos on when I play StarMade so I'm with ya. :D

[@goatprince1]

I listen to Pieguy's videos while I create random buildings in Sketchup that are designed in styles that were popular from the '50s to the '70s.

[@Ashman-sw3be]

same. when i play games i listen to his every sb episode reviewed series

[@coopierre.]

Same

[@imadmohamed841]

Anyone Who cried the first time watching This episode?

[@reservedmonky1602]

I was like 6 when i first saw it and same

[@mike_pogo]

ME

[@tylerjosephsukelele314]

I cried when I first watched this episode too

[@saikyocentral]

Me

[@Oban2006]

I cried after the show WAS NOT cancelled 😭

[@KingLaZrButBad]

"It's kind of a realistic portrayal of a pet running away" *That's the point*

[@zombies4evadude24]

🤦🏾‍♂️ PieGuyRulz is way too harsh on Season 4. Some episodes like this one, Whale Of A Birthday, and Patrick Smartpants got ripped off hard in this series. I don’t hate him as a person but I HATE his opinions on Season 4.

[@NickTheEnlightened]

@@zombies4evadude24 He gave Patrick Smartpants a good though...

[@NickTheEnlightened]

And that's fine. Not everyone has to 100% enjoy that type of plot however.

[@andrewbaillie5549]

​@@NickTheEnlightenedhe literally put the first movie of SpongeBob in meh meh is mediocre and I don't think the point was meh

[@andrewbaillie5549]

​@@NickTheEnlightenedI agree but I don't think that just because an episode isn't funny doesn't make it not good and Gary came back it's not like in a pal for Gary he abused his pet he's still looking and theirs are funny moments in-between that alone is enough to say it's a good episode and he didn't like driven to tears but because it was funny it's now good on earth.

[@iyoungblood2109]

Patrick seeing Gary at the hardware store is not all that different from him forgetting he saw spongebob's identity on his back in "Missing identity".

[@samgreenwell4672]

I loved this episode, but I haven't seen it in a while.

[@helencashwes]

Bob rosas

[@parforet]

+Loopis lazy pee The master of meep-morp.

[@ronswanson7371]

@@helencashwes Ross*

[@CaptainJZH]

That speech at the beginning was great :)

[@wraitsoth]

What about the "Who's this Lisa person?" joke? I found that part hysterical! I love the delivery and the other fish's reaction.

[@bradleycotton3237]

But that wasn’t enough to dry the tears after listening to the “Gary, Come Home” song.

[@ACUltra]

speaking of the squidward's bathroom scene, that's also very popular on the Internet (as well as the "I hate this channel" thing from squidvile")

[@alexanderklepp]

I'd like to share my own feelings about this. First, I can't agree about Gary's Song. It may be a bit schmaltzy, but I think it's sweet and touching and while yes, it may have been clear that SpongeBob will get Gary back, kids watching it for the first time (like myself) don't know better. Also, Patrick not remembering Gary didn't bug me because by that point the audience knows Gary has escaped so it's clear that Gary is safe and returning home. I understand why you think that way, but my feelings on SpongeBob in general are different than others. I don't do pre-movie and post-movie divide up and I feel that if I enjoy a certain episode and want to see it again, it's good. I personally don't divide the show season by season but rather as a whole. Simpsons is the same way for me. Family Guy, not so much, partially because I don't watch it. That to me is a more healthy way to look at a TV show, even one with no continuity. I just pick and choose what I like rather than change my views because it's popular to do so.

[@BrendanBarney]

This episode was alright to me. I've seen better.

[@giovanniorellana2200]

Controversial? I think not! It's your opinion, and that's fine.

[@TheBlueStarGal2]

It is his opinion, that's what makes it so controversial....

[@KazeShikamaru]

Actually....it is because this is one of those post movie episodes that is really that good.

[@swishfish8858]

Yeah, the word "controversy" is scarily misproportionate in modern context.

[@yooka3505]

andykishore No it's not.

[@Ashman-sw3be]

чё ты тут делаешь

[@AzurknightOMEGA]

My favorite part of the episode was when Gary saw the picture of all the snails and they shout RUN!!! It was just a funny surreal moment and it was just so quick and funny that I loved it.

[@B0ssguy]

A good spongebob episode is classified on if it’s funny, if it has a good storyline, and if it’s not greatly exaggerating a personality (for the later seasons). I like this episode because it’s a good story, and there were good jokes, like the nachos, snail painting saying “run!”, the pine cones, etc. despite being a sad episode, it gets to your heart and keeps it interesting the whole way. It’s a good episode for me. Like if you agree

[@RyansChannel0203]

I honestly really really liked this episode. I find it very underrated. It's a very emotional and touching episode and you really feel for both Spongebob and Gary. It made me believe a lot more that they were buddies no matter what. In my opinion, this is definitely a good episode and one of my favorites from Season 4. Sure, it might barely have any humor for a Spongebob episode, but this episode wasn't meant to be funny.

[@RyansChannel0203]

I thought Have You Seen This Snail was a vast improvement over Dumped.

[@usermcskull4713]

not underrated it goes on many peeps top 10 best season 4 episodes

[@Z01Xy]

I find it very OVERRATED ESPECIALLY GARYS SONG WHICH I DONT REALLY EVEN LIKE AND THIS EPISODE IS BORING AND VERY MEDIOCRE AND THE DEFINITION OF UNDERRATED IS HELLO BIKINI BOTTOM! AND ITS LAST SONG

[@RyansChannel0203]

@@Z01Xy Congratulations on being on the minority.

[@maxwasson2000]

I actually liked this episode, I put it on #10 Of My Favorite Spongebob Episodes

[@flamingpaper7751]

When I saw the thumbnail, I thought it said "Have you seen this episode?" and I thought it would be a new series about odd and obscure shows or episodes that some people probably never heard of.

[@daliborjovanovic510]

He should go with that idea :)

[@mychemicaldeath3310]

a third spongebob movie is coming out in 2019...

[@agentjohn]

Ren & Stimpy short will be on the 3rd spongebob movie

[@JAI-z5g]

the crew didn't want to do it. Viacom did it anyways those sick f*cks

[@Xjp190]

The first two were good. Can't wait to see how the third one is going to be!

[@gabebarnes6814]

Well after the first movie, Spongebob went downhill. After the sequel, Spongebob got better. After the third movie, Spongebob better stay good and not follow a pattern of good, bad, good, bad.

[@issacflores2010]

Shavos beard is life just in time for the twentieth anniversary.

[@KazeShikamaru]

I love the episode because it's different. It takes advantage of the connection people have established in these characters. One of the few season 4 episodes that are amazing.

[@eddyskipper626]

Although "Have You Seen This Snail"is pretty similar to "Dumped".Dumped is one of the worst pre movie episodes IMO

[@ultramaster7893]

Even though this episode is really really sad, it’s still better than Dumped from season 2

[@chriswood-nostalgic8900]

It was alright. I think Spongebob on The Run, has got a more horrifying/ yet shocking reason that Gary has left Spongebob. He is snail-napped by Poiseden.

[@abandonedchannel546]

Honestly, I love how you stick to your very own opinions and doesn't rate the episode because of other's perspectives, while I still really like the episode, I understand why you don't really like it.

[@NoahsBlobs1]

okewl I was the first person to be listed in the outro, I feel better now :D Great review as always, Pieguy, and great idea getting some of the fans in on it too.

[@henryolsen6248]

This is my second favorite modern spongebob episode. My favorite is Fear of a Krabby Patty (which is my favorite episode of the series... pls no hate). I respect your opinion. I find this episode somewhat funny. The thing is every comedy show has at least 1 gut-renching episodes( avatar: tales of ba sing see, futurama: luck of the fryish, jurasic bark, etc.) I loved the song, and it was REALLY sad.

[@cherriegetison6093]

From an industry perspective, I'd like to point something out that not a lot of people have gotten at when it comes to this distinction between "pre-movie" and "post-movie", and that is the process by which the episodes are written. Writing for animated comedy shows is usually divided into two categories: premise-based and script-based. Premise-based shows call upon professional writers to come up with story outlines (usually three paragraphs), and storyboard artists will expand upon the story. These tend to result in more visual humor, due to artists having a stronger role in fleshing out the story. Script-based shows are written primarily by professional writers, and storyboard artists will create visuals for a story set in place. These shows tend to have auditory humor. Shows like Star vs. TFOE, Sanjay and Craig, Phineas and Ferb are premise-based. Shows like Simpsons and Bob's Burgers are script-based. (Phineas and Ferb co-creators Povenmire and Marsh commented on the shift from working on shows like The Simpsons to Phineas and Ferb. Script writers easily forgot about including Maggie Simpson because she was a silent character with no lines. Storyboard artists would more easily remember the presence of the silent Ferb.) SpongeBob was originally premise-based, but shifted to script-based with its peak of success. This resulted in a loss of visual humor. Gags related to SpongeBob's form were suddenly restricted to story points, rather than incidental humor. There was a lot more auditory dialogue and jokes. There is no shame to a script-based or premise-based show; both can lead to incredible productions. But the show's charm comes from its visual humor. I'll have to ask someone on the show soon about the current writing process. Wonder if it's changed.

[@nanalinda4]

but pieguy I cant clean the wax out of my ears its the only thing keeping spiders from crawling in there when I'm asleep. so they end up crawling up my nose instead so every time I sneeze I spray webbing out of my nostrils.... and BTW yes, I am Spiderman.

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

Been watching too many sci fi movies again, Ed?

[@booklover4330]

That picture of Ed and that sentence you wrote fits very well with one another. XD.

[@Azran127]

SPIDERS! Get 'em off me! Get 'em off me! Get 'em off me!

[@booklover4330]

127Azran XD.

[@nanalinda4]

my favorite is robot rebel ranch.

[@zeeteepippi275]

I find it kind of clever that Gary runs away because he wasn't being fed, then he goes to an old lady who takes care of him, and ultimately she ends up threatening his life by feeding him too much.

[@brycefourn2001]

Great review video! I actually liked the special because it can be depressing but still has that old SB charm in it. :)

[@jakecobovic9091]

BryceFourn 2001 You are either stalking me or we have the exact same interests.

[@Gone-q9c]

I pretty much agree that the song forces in the fact that Spongebob really misses Gary. But I still like the song, so do I like the episode.

[@salemthecat]

Personally i love this episode for The song And story. I always cry watching it

[@noahco5632]

Pieguy, your so underated

[@cedrickawick9464]

Underrated? What I meant to say is, PieGuyRulz didn’t earn as much praise as he deserves? I thought people just LOVE him!

[@drayyoutube5843]

I agree

[@PatrickBoy412]

PieGuy indeed does rule

[@CalebRichardsChannel]

Every Episode of Adventure Time Reviewed would be awesome. Or just a short review of each season. I dunno, I just want some more AT from you :D

[@saikyocentral]

It's up to him but I'd love an analysis of how Adventure Time went downhill in his opinion.

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

Hmmmmm

[@saikyocentral]

Yeah man I'd pay some good money for that. too bad he's not in this conversation *cough cough*

[@rileygay1165]

Didn't he already make that?

[@incredimations1663]

4 years later, he’s doing it now! :D

[@Xjp190]

Has anyone noticed that The SpongeBob SquarePants Movie feels like a full length Help Wanted?

[@theodorech20]

This episode is good, but it's not fantastic as it is. There are ways to make this better. - Increase Gary screentime with a crazy grandma and perhaps give him first sense of suspicion, but still rejects Spongebob (which is the core of a drama). Gary part is better in this episode overall. - This also means reduce Spongebob screentime and make Spongebob's progression of finding the pet bumpier and exciting, but also give Patrick stupid yet brilliant moments so they can get to Gary closer. - Add more comedy. Yes, Melodrama and comedy can go hand to hand if done well. They can also play comedy as long as it progresses the plot forward (and it's even better when it's Patrick doing it with stupid yet works at finding Gary) - Perhaps Spongebob meets Gary while being chased by crazy grandma showing his scared and innocent expression when seeing Spongebob on sight make it cuter, engaging, and heartwarming.

[@onettaviator5396]

I've always loved this special ever since it came out when I was a toddler.

[@baalfgames5318]

It's kind of amazing people remember the first few seasons of SpongeBob as being the greatest, but the specials in the seasons were among their weaker episodes. They didn't get really good at making specials until season 8. Although Dunces and Dragons was pretty good.

[@nickoftime5449]

There was a joke where the box with the paddle had the word "Nickelodeon" on the box. That's one funny Easter egg!!

[@crazyluigi6664]

Really?! I never saw that one before...

[@EsmeAmelia]

My cat died recently and when I was holding his body in my lap, the song from this episode actually ran through my head. Especially the line, "Your meow right now would sound like music to me." :( I don't know if you have any pets or not, but this episode really captures how much we love our pets. Of course it's going to feature SpongeBob being sad a lot - it shows how much he really, really loves Gary - which is probably why this episode came to mind (and was even a little bit comforting) when my cat died.

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

+EsmeAmelia I absolutely have had a beloved cat that died. Just because a story is about a subject that I can relate to, doesn't mean it's automatically good. I don't mind SB being sad, but the thing is basically a big dull mopefest.

[@FrozenUSA]

I agree. "Dumped" did a much better job at balancing the comedy and the drama with the same subject. I know you also gave that episode a meh, but I think it is one of if not the best Gary centered episode of the entire series.

[@samehere1733]

+FrozenUSA lol no a pal for gary is better jk but "pineaple invasion" its pretty decent

[@familybroakajonny]

@@samehere1733agreed HAHA JK I do think Dumped out of the 3 is better

[@B3fromYT]

1:55 - 2:00 And that's why I like "Truth or Square"

[@RealValkor]

This episode was my favorite because its soo accurate, And the music is awesome! It looks like an season 3 episode! And its also good because I like sad episodes :p

[@onepunchanthroranger6315]

OLD LADY QUICK! I'M LOOKING FOR THE SENTED PINECONES!

[@msprouctions8175]

My favorite line from Patrick in this episode is when he says I thought you drove him away with your neglect and indifference

[@WTC1973]

The song "Gary Come Home" made me cry.

[@BenPaz]

15:38 LOOK I'M IN A FAMOUS KZbinR'S VIDEO!

[@TheFiveFootSixers]

Ben Pazmino where?

[@dylanpotato8739]

4 year late congrats

[@leonardojuan92]

Deadpool: Where's Gary?

[@patrickb125]

It's nothing like Dumped, because Patrick's not a prick

[@videovids4824]

I really like the scene in this episode where Patrick eats the spoiled milk, nobody ever mentions it though...

[@beebekingcritic5020]

hi pie guy. your one of my favorite youtuber.

[@entertainer_ev2747]

He's my personal favorite of all time, even though SomeCallMeJohnny comes close.

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

Aw, thanks guys!

[@zdoggs1370]

I agree he's really cool I wish I could meet him but my chances of that are lower than SpongeBob coming back on Netflix

[@crazychick96100]

I'm kinda in the middle here, too. I think this is a way better story than Dumped (I hate that episode with a burning passion)! But I liked the sappy moments as a kid and as an adult. I still had the childlike innocence where I could relate with Spongebob's feelings because you can experience it right along with him in his universe. As an adult, I have had my cat recently pass away and my family was really sad, so I know the sadness of losing a pet. It makes me wish I had spent more time with her :'( It walks a fine line between just enough and too much, and I think the boundary was crossed a little bit with it being overbearing.I agree that it's a little too much sappiness. I don't think it's funny either because most of it is the fact that Spongebob is upset and crying too much, kinda like Dumped. But hey, at least Patrick isn't an asshole in this one than that one!!! So if I had your scale, I'd put in Meh as well.

[@TheLeyakMan]

Have you seen this snail is one of my favourite episodes. It has no filler patchy segments and I actually feel emotion for the characters. Some of the jokes are hilarious such as, "Spongebob what happened... This picture is off centre!" When Squidward screams, " Who is this Lisa person?" And,"Office materials falling from the sky!" Where's Gary and Gary come home are some of my favourite songs in the whole series. Patrick is really dumb when he sees Gary but it is still funny. In my opinion this episode is a stand out of season 4.

[@TheLeyakMan]

And SB is very annoying but the story would not work without him being annoying!

[@Lefty7788tinkatolli]

I think "Back to the Past" was your most controversial rating. Also, I can admit that I never loved this episode either. It aired RIGHT when our beloved pet cat disappeared and was never found. I also found the whole feeding snails just to eat them TERRIFYING as a little kid. That whole ending scared the shit out if me, and I used to not even WATCH the second half. In fact, when you think about it, this entire episode is pretty horrible. Now, 11 or 12 years older, I still don't like it that much. It feels too similar to Dumped, and the eating snails thing is still unnerving. But mostly, it's actually... pretty boring. Fight me people of KZbin. There is quite a bit of padding, and quite a bit of the melodrama in this episode feels forced. Yeah, to me this episode is nothing more than a 6/10 tops *dodges shoe*

[@yuyi01a36]

have you seen this snail is my favourite episode from season4 along with dunces and dragons and krusty towers, but if you don't like it's ok, but I won't follow your opinion

[@NickTheEnlightened]

Even though I personally would give this episode a very low good, I would still agree that it is very overrated and that it is far from one of the greatest in the series like some have made it to be. It's a nice and touching episode for sure, but it's not like it's the only episode in the series that hits home in that way and it still could've used more jokes to really fill out the run time.

[@101Youfail]

Yeah I agree that this is meh. It's a bit too miserable for a Spongebob ep.

[@ayonowayo]

hey pieguy! can you share with us how u feel about the danny phantom episode with ember?

[@shaun9522]

IM ON TV IM ON TV - Patrick anyway, i was holographic meatloaf at the end of the vid.

[@papershadow]

I think the episode is a bit more distinct from "Dumped" than I get the impression you seem to feel yourself. The core of "Dumped" was Spongebob trying to win Gary back over after he chose to leave for Patrick, while this story has Spongebob legitimately wrong Gary and trying to find him and apologize. It makes "Dumped" more of a comedy at its core because Spongebob is getting very dramatic and bumbling about his antics when logically he's the only one that cares much about them, whereas this story clearly demonstrates at the end that Gary would acknowledge the apology when he can see it. The crux of "dumped" is a myriad of plans to win Gary back over and then living in denial, but HYSTS never has a point where Spongebob even pretends to be content with losing Gary, to the point he actively leaves work to go look for him, an act that for this character holds a lot of weight. There's also a distinction in that the old Snail Lady presents an obstacle to the ending, whether as a caretaker or a danger, since even if Gary does forgive Spongebob it raises the question of if he'd leave the cushy life, then if he can survive to make it back to Spongebob; Dumped has Gary as literally the only thing that decides who he stays with, he didn't have to give anything up or be rescued if he wanted Spongebob back as his owner, so the stakes were kept low and thus made the comedy more exaggerated by consequence. The other thing is that, as noted, any suffering, comedic or otherwise, is primarily self-inflicted in "Dumped," whereas in HYSTS, Spongebob is broken up over Gary being gone at his own fault, and during Gary's stray time, he's clearly afraid and starving. Sure there are jokes like the alley snails actually being friendly, but it's not brought on by Gary or Spongebob choosing to obsess over something comparatively trivial. I'm also not the type who takes the Status Quo for granted in a cartoon, in that I assume each episode will start in the same basic place, but not that they are required to end in the same place (like Tuna Patrick in "Hooked" or the ending of "Shanghaied"), and even if the situation is the same, the character's in such shows tend to change when they do dramatic episodes.

[@alexanderklepp]

Agreed.

[@jamesthedragon2344]

Good opinion. I Think it's Meh also, the tone was good but idk if jokes were needed here. The old lady character was interesting and the song was great.

[@superrj3478]

It's about you do a spongy bits on Where's Gary in fact why don't you do a review on Dungeons and Dragons and I still miss the old piecons.

[@spongefan155]

I'm Fine With What You Say But This Is Honestly My Favourite Special In Fact If It Wasn't For The Airplane Bit At The End Of Gary Came Home This Would've Been My Favourite Episode Of The Show But It Still Takes 2nd Place

[@PowCards]

In dumped spongebob did NOTHING to drive gary away and just went with patrick but in have u seen this snail. spongebob did not feed gary and he DID do something and i dont think. its the same as dumped it has more stuff but i respect you're opinion

[@alexanderklepp]

I think you mean that it's not the same as Dumped but I get what you mean. Hope you don't mind me saying this.

[@PowCards]

Alex Klepp Nah i dont mind

[@froakie1404]

It’s one of my favorite episodes of Season 4, I loved it

[@familybroakajonny]

I REALLY don’t get how a sad and depressing episode is even supposed to be “Good” So I do agree with PieGuy on the comedy, but for me, Mr Krabs not giving a crap, me crying and it being boring for me drives it into “ScumBob” territory

[@EpicJoshua314]

What about Squidward screaming in the shower, the alley snail saying "Guess he didn't like nachos" and the old lady saying "Oh heavens, look at the time" and it's only 7:30pm? Those scenes are hilarious.

[@familybroakajonny]

@@EpicJoshua314 Those I laughed at which is why this is nowhere near close to being the worst episode, but still

[@EpicJoshua314]

@@familybroakajonny I once watched this episode with a critical take on it and I have to admit SpongeBob thinking Gary is under a flower is a bit stupid. Yes, when people are desperately looking for something like car keys they look literally everywhere but thinking a pet is under a flower is illogical. The Krusty Krab part was filler and if you took it out nothing would change. However, I still really enjoy this episode.

[@wariocapproductions326]

I need to know the background music when he reviews this episode! It's great and needs to be heard more

[@booklover4330]

It was an alright episode, not one of my favorites; but I can understand why other people would love it. XD.

[@deadchannellol4604]

Hello there Pieguy! How are you? Nice video :)

[@tommydiaz-millan2438]

I still love that episode.

[@maxresdefault_]

a

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

You could always listen to what I actually say in the review.

[@h2flowz]

+PIEGUYRULZ What do you think of the loud house?

[@icecreamhero2375]

how was that episode bad how is it different from Secert Box they were selfish and foght in that episode same with Naughty Nautical Neighboors i thought the episode was very good and it was pretty funny Spongebob is rarely bad

[@Schnickelo]

@icecream hero Exactly. SpongeBob and Patrick got into fights before. And come on. Patrick may have been a bit jerkish in the episode, but he's not a sociopath like certain people are saying. At least he wasn't hurting SpongeBob in YMaM. The hatred for it is over-exaggerated to be honest.

[@icecreamhero2375]

Schnickelo and besides jerks are funnier than goody goodies who do you think is funnier Marge or Homer

[@somefeatures]

oh hey Bagels is in this

[@isetmfriendsofire]

I know people think that "Fear Of a Krabby Patty" is the last episode that FEELS like a pre movie episode, whether they like it or not, but I honestly think this one has similar vibes, despite not being the best.

[@dewlivewireftw]

Skill Krane, Krusty Towers, The Lost Mattress

[@Uloveeverglow]

I love this ep but I respect your opinion

[@baymcculloch]

hey pie guy! you def gotta check out the latest season of spongebob, it really is starting to get good. there is a food eating contest episode with patrick in it and he is the patrick we love, not the nasty one. oh i am enjoying it so much :) thanks for your spongebob coverage!

[@tykennedy2281]

Hey Pieguy. I wanted to propose a new Square Theory idea about analyzing the character of Plankton. The question being: Why does a lot of the fandom find Plankton sympathetic? Plankton is an over the top villain who knows he's evil and enjoys being evil yet over time you kind of end up feeling sorry for him. Hell, after the show went through seasonal rot, a lot of people claim he's the only likable main character left and do I even have to mention how many fans were outraged by his treatment in One Course Meal and Plankton's Regular. You even ended your TV movie idea with Mr Krabs giving Plankton the original Krusty Krab. I hope you take this idea to consideration.

[@lukerbom12]

Much like Fear of a Krabby Patty, this is one of those other early Season 4 episodes I always saw as kind of classic. This was a really good review. I completely understand and honestly I kind of agree. While I do like this episode it IS a little slow at times and definitely isn't one of my favorites in the series, though I liked it enough to watch it multiple times when I was younger. Oh, and thanks for including my thoughts at the end, I was afraid I was either too late with them or didn't say enough; I really appreciate it and I actually LOVED this idea of having these comments in the video.

[@PIEGUYRULZ]

I never realized you were a SBM regular!

[@lukerbom12]

Actually, your videos introduced me to it. I generally do a lot more reading than posting on there, but it is a fascinating site.

[@mcspider4111]

OMG ITS SPONGEBOB REWIEW GUYSKDKDKSKXKSKE

[@DoctorCyan]

Hello Pie

[@durece100]

Gary Come Home was was singing by Joe Stewart.

[@Юррррррчик]

I really adore this episode. It's my favourite of the series :/

[@Jackrabbit7]

YShchuk ZZZ There's better

[@Юррррррчик]

It's only my opinion :/

[@onepunchanthroranger6315]

this episode premiered the day where my dog first ran away. he came bak while I was at school. but imagine seeing this episode that night

[@theredstonecreeper6544]

I always cry when it plays Gray comes home

[@brianjones1231]

I consider this episode to be the BETTER version of “Dumped”!

[@drawsomethewizard3006]

Sweet and Sour Squid also controversial

[@drawsomethewizard3006]

Infact 0:21

[@SquidyStudios]

I'm sorry but am I watching a documentary?

[@Z01Xy]

Yes Yes You Are

[@thegreatserver628]

Personally i think it's good, but not great.

[@konstantinostsarouchis6274]

I heard somewhere the lady is supposed to be the witch from Hansel and Gretel.

[@danekradwanski7054]

I heard there is going to be another movie in 2019

[@tomsimpson6914]

I feel the lost pet plot can be done with both good humor and drama. A good example is the Rugrats episode "Spike Runs Away". In that episode, Spike gets lost and the Pickles are trying to find him, searching the neighborhood and putting up signs. Stu (RIP) and Didi first go to the dog catcher, who is overdramatic and a really funny character. Tommy is obviously upset that Spike is lost, so Didi suggests to Stu to get another pet. What happens when Stu brings various different pets home is really funny, along with the guy who runs the pet shop. Towards the end, Tommy and Chuckie get more upset that Spike may never come back. While this is going on, the guy who found Spike comes to the door, and he is this really rich "fancy" guy, who feeds dogs caviar. When Spike finally gets home, there is a really good reunion scene between Tommy and Spike.

[@lucasmcdonald6847]

Even after many years I agree. I think this episode is VERY overrated. The song's good, but short, and the entire episode is not funny. If you want some real emotion mixed in with comedy, just go watch Welcome to the Chum Bucket.

[@brittasnow64]

no episode from Season 4 is "overrated"

[@vgjf3618]

"Dumped" & "Have U Seen This Snail?" r both "Meh Episodes".

[@Z01Xy]

In my opinion dumped is a scum bob episode

[@andrewsilva7154]

Please do another video on We Bare Bears.

[@LucasSaturn]

I feel as though this episode would have been much better if they would have put more jokes (maybe have the jokes juxtaposing the drama), made the moping around less dull, and replaced the song, "Gary's Song" with the song "Where's Gary" (which was featured on the album). I thought it was a meh episode when it aired, and felt that it needed more comedy and was extremely disappointed when I heard the Where's Gary song, and wished there was accompanying animation.

[@Barberfrog]

Are You Going To Make Videos Like This? I Would Love To See You Do One For A More Modern Episode (Something Like A Season 6-9 Episode)

[@maxdejesuscotija]

You jerk I love this episode

[@-jdm-8989]

People tend to get nostalgic, I've rewatched all the series, and im on season 4 now. I was so hyped because I was going to watch again this ""masterpiece"", and in the end I think this episode isn't good at all. I loved the music at least

[@brittasnow64]

literally nothing to do with nostalgia I didn't watch SpongeBob at all as a kid, and recently I watched this episode and loved it, you can have an opinion without suggesting others' opinions have less merit you know

[@ahmeda.934]

Am I the only one who thought season 4 was great?

[@gayratparker]

I like Season 5 too.

[@ahmeda.934]

Shiloh Kinz2013 Season 5 was ok imo but I respect your opinion.

[@raheelaiqbal1087]

I digged Spy Buddies a lot in Season 5. I personally think Season Five is better then Season Four.

[@raheelaiqbal1087]

I digged Spy Buddies a lot in Season 5. I personally think Season Five is better then Season Four.