Hayat Un Nabi 'MUNAZARA'; Master Amin OKARVI vs Moulana Younus NOMANI (PART 3 of 3)

Famous Munazarah On: Hayat Un Nabi (S.A.W)
Between
Allama Muhammad Younus Nomani RA
and
Moulana Ameen Safdar Okarvi RA

[@SunniDeobandi]

Who won? It's obvious maulana ameen okarvi won!

[@TRUEsuni8ashiqrasul]

@sunnideobandi..secondly…It’s upon the Muda’ee (The claimer) to clarify he’s Aqeedah!..As you seen throughout the Munazarah he was asked over and over again to explain he’s Aqeedah which he failed to do so, I’m afraid that’s very appalling for a Munazir to do

[@TRUEsuni8ashiqrasul]

@Sunnideobandi..Firstly;..”Its obvious???” You just made me laugh brother!!. Either you don’t know the Usool of Munazarah (DEBATING) or you don’t have a clue about the Ikhtalaf itself!! All due respect brother!..to be honest this debate is quite an embarrassment for Master Ameen okarvi RA, due to the fact that he is the MUDA’EE in the debate…

[@sardarfayyazulhassan]

TRUEsuni8ashiqrasu: Dear , this is not embarrassing for anyone, but the approach of Hazarat OKARVI is more clear semantically.

[@TRUEsuni8ashiqrasul]

What do you exactly mean by “semantically”?! Priority is given to textual evidence, over rational opinions. Again!.. I would remind, it essential to clarify their position beforehand, e.g... Aqeeday kee wazahat

[@TRUEsuni8ashiqrasul]

@sunnideobandi thirdly …The MUDA’ ALAY (The defendants) responsibility is to only respond to the claims made, which on a professional approach I feel Allama Younus nomani delt with it in a convincing and an impressive way. He explained he’s Aqeedah very well and also responded to all the claims put forward which I feel was a fair response and a great success for his Jamaat