he hugged her, but it all delusion💔

[@deepshikhadey9361]

Even if it's the second time line I can never forgive him never ever I hope fl will remain with the duke they love her even without any blood ties

[@myyaoiacademia4265]

why tell me what did he do pls tell me🙏🙏🙏

[@Nightskys753]

​@@myyaoiacademia4265in the first time line he sacrifice her i think (not sure) cause he didn't believe she was his dead child bcuz the majesty told him it was a boy And she died come back to 5 yrs and her new family is such a green forest who love unconditional while he in the first time line failed to protect her and also in this time line he has a daughter with the similar age with her but different mother He says in his thoughts he can't ever love her cause the reason is she was born from a woman he didn't love Like what kind of father don't love his daughter and yes while she was a villain to the MC but she still a child so it's a pity she get such a father

[@Fatma_933]

In first life when she was older she met the emperor to tell him that she is his lost daughter but he didnt believe her abd sent her into a magic mirror one where she would forever be closed and not even reincarnat (I heard the ML saved her) I dont like him either and i DEF want her to stay with the duke but​ let me explain the bio dads side He thought it was a boy so he didnt believe her plus she had very little spirit power so couldnt prove herself to be of royal lineage ( the queens daughter was stealing her powers till adulthood when she nearly had no power anymore) Yea so he didnt feel any connection without spirit power I still cant forgive him tho cause she had even the tiny pit of power but he wouldnt even try to learn the true and send her to her death with his own hands so thats not forgivable. Sorry for my bad english not my first language @@myyaoiacademia4265

[@lamrosee]

​@@Nightskys753The empress's daughter isn't the emperors, that's the reason the empress's stole Shuelina's powers, to give to her own daughter to prove her daughter was of royal blood.

[@Nightskys753]

@@lamrosee thanks for the detail

[@yukiaedogawa]

Hope he leaves her alone. She’s happy enough where she is with her adoptive family. Biological father seems weak and a pushover. He’ll likely take the side of his redhead empress and daughter when push comes to shove.

[@thebluedevil7224]

he already did in her past life

[@MsLadyBook1999]

Her mother was so beautiful. What are the chances that the red head daughter is not the emperors? Any spoilers please ❤

[@RuuAbdi-u5l]

Please don't tell me that she is going to return to them no please

[@deepshikhadey9361]

I don't think so I read some spoilers saying that she will get two surname and she will remain in the dukes family

[@user-Ms.Bear025]

@@deepshikhadey9361so you mean she will have her biological family name and the duke(the one with dark hair) last name ? So she has now two family’s ? Will she get along with her biological father and brother ?

[@deepshikhadey9361]

@@user-Ms.Bear025 Yes she'll have two family name but she'll stay with duke family

[@susums1117]

Well, there has to happen something, otherwise story would end here. But so far i think duke's family will be her family that takes care of her.

[@moviefan2236]

Ok, can people actually focus on reading the whole story and use reading comprehension? I don't know about if this has a LN and if the story is different from the Manhwa, but y'all are hating on this version of the Emperor for no actual reason. Spoilers: Yes, he banished thr FL's body to that mirror in the future of the first timeline, but as we see early on, at this time in presumably both timelines(we only see this timeline and FL only remembers key events in the last timeline from when she read the story), he was searching for her, though he and his son were already low on hope for finding his lost child until certain events happen in this timeline, and had also been looking for a boy (I'll admit, I didn't catch the reason why they thought she would be a boy, probably dissinformation by the red headed empress, who claimed the FL was dead at birth). So it's understandable that in the first timeline, with the FL's body barely having any of the spiritual power that is the best identifier for her being who she says she is, especially at the time she reveals herself, thanks to the red headed empress stealing her spiritual power and transferring it to her daughter, they where going to be mad because they already lost hope and had given up, and would have little reason to believe her without that spiritual energy, as again, they believed she was a boy. Plus, as it was revealed around chapter 15, the red headed daughter would eventually gain a charm ability that allows her to make FL's adoptive fatherin this timeline confess to a crime he had nothing to do with that the red headed empress set up in the first timeline, so by the time FL's body tried to reveal herself, the emperor and prince where most likely completely under her power, with the prince's words in th past timeline even supporting this. TL;DR: past timeline Emperor deserves some hate, though previously unknown (and still unknown by the FZl)context has revealed what he did actually makes sense, but currently the Emperor isn't at that stage in this timeline and was actually saved from that fate thanks to the changes to current timeline, and doesn't deserve the hate he's getting.

[@handlevisibletoallusers]

He does deserve some hating. He knew about the possible harm to the mother and fl. But he just trusted blindly. No protection and even no way to collect correct information. Thats neglect.

[@orangeapples]

@@handlevisibletoallusersalso the Intel his network gathered was sloppy. They did no investigation on the orphanage thinking it was a happy home for lost girls and had no idea the Duke basically rebuilt the place because of his daughter. It wasn’t even that long ago it happened.

[@sabrac9]

Name?

[@NoOne-uj3hc]

Why do you love me when I refuse your request?

[@ReynajeanLabs]

Being delulu vs being solulu

[@romygatica4586]

¿Por qué estas tan obsesionado con rechazar el afecto ?

[@SunnyJayjey]

Where can I read this 😭🙏🏽

[@NoOne-uj3hc]

Why do you love me when I refuse your request?

[@SunnyJayjey]

@@NoOne-uj3hc thank you but do you know where I can read it? For free

[@NoOne-uj3hc]

@@SunnyJayjey coffeemanga

[@Aafiaa]

​@@SunnyJayjey google you can find free ones

[@Its_Mizu-i7f]

Kingofshojo in Google or any searching web​@@SunnyJayjey

[@urrunagagomessofiaisabella9675]

Name pls

[@NoOne-uj3hc]

Why do you love me when I refuse your request?

[@Beatrizgo1989]

Weak Emperor 😒 pushover. I don’t like him. He made fl suffer a lot in the 1 TL. If he love so much Fl mother. He 1. Shouldn’t had a second wife. 2. He should look for prove about her wife and child deaths. Fl is better with the Duke. She is happy, finally

[@sebastianjaviermontesbenit9993]

Nombre en español?

[@KD_orv]

Nombre:¿Por qué me amas aunque rechazo tu petición? Búsquelo por yugenmanga, esa página los enviará a otra y ahí esta el manhwa traducido al español, esta hasta el cap 23

[@Michael-h9b]

Contexto por favor 😭😭🙏

[@andreabarrios6989]

El emperador es débil, su otra consorte le dijo que su esposa y bebé murieron, él no verifico este hecho, pero busco en varios orfanatos al bebé (buscó un varón 😒) pasaron 6 años, a la niña le fueron robando su poder espiritual para que la hija de esa misma consorte quedará como hija del emperador. La prota sufrió mucho en esa línea del tiempo. Básicamente el bobo no la encontró, y la prota con conocimiento de su pasado (el trauma le hizo creer que todo fue un libro que leyó y no una vida que vivió) logró ser adoptada por el duque cabello negro y es feliz, él y sus hijos la adoran, pero el emperador apareció y la quiere de regreso, el muy iluso hasta pensó que ella se alegraría al verlo😅

[@mizakimei9230]

Dónde la puedo leer

[@mariaeduardarodriguesmorai3427]

@@andreabarrios6989sabes donde la puedo leer?

[@andreabarrios6989]

@@mariaeduardarodriguesmorai3427 cartel de manhwa

[@Guillermofillerz]

🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🙏🙏🙏

[@Aafiaa]

You want name?if so it's Why do you like me when I refuse your request