Classical flutist reacts to Jethro Tull (Tampa Stadium 1976) // I AM SPEECHLESS!

[@HelineFay]

This video is demonetised. You can support the content creation: 1) join the exclusive "floot tooters" club on Patreon: www.patreon.com/heline 2) buy me a coffee ko-fi.com/heline 3) share my videos, like and comment!

[@mr.invisable6919]

Saw them in 74 or 75. AWESOME!

[@mikeysuzefour]

I finally found a great flute channel; As a former flute/piccolo player myself I'm thoroughly impressed by your analogies Miss Heline and look forward to more of them!

[@gxulien]

That strange sound was just a snort.

[@gxulien]

He took lessons in the late 80's and discovered he'd been holding the flute wrong all those years. I csught the interview, on Metalshop I think.

[@havoth]

Probably helps to understand the emotional content he brought through the flute and that he is in front of a ROCK audience of the 70s (most of them high) but the emotions and storytelling he did with this instrument are amazing.

[@Dragineez774]

I've always loved Ian Anderson's comment on his flute playing. "Since I'm the only flutist in all of rock and roll, I'm both the best and the worst flutist in all of rock and roll at the same time."

[@mtc3000]

Lots of others flute players in rock

[@rochmel1409]

@@mtc3000 Yeah Mark I agree, I immediately thought of Thijs Van Leer from Focus but Tull formed in 1967 so maybe the comment was made in the early days when flute was maybe lot rarer?

[@richardbradshaw4567]

Anderson's fingering is pretty awesome, his breathing somewhat less so but I doubt he cares; the sounds he gets from the instrument work with the band's overall sound. How good is his singing though? That's another question entirely.

[@johncarter7284]

If Clapton was the guitar God, does that make Ian the flute God?

[@hatfez]

Peter Gabriel?

[@trainguy1017]

The man who proved that you can, in fact, play the flute in a rock band and still be a total badass!!

[@camronbay1]

He’s unreal.

[@timothyscott3116]

Well said

[@lynnhafferkamp6054]

Ian Anderson made the flute cool AF

[@broderickelliott8527]

While standing on one foot.

[@jenniferarmstrong4006]

Simply put. Ian Anderson is a genius. End of story.

[@RU-HDD-4-HVN]

With the last name of Armstrong you've said more than most could.......

[@PatrickRohr1]

So is his wife

[@DUCKSAREEVILLLLLLLL]

Yetro Tull had a very unique sound.

[@highvoltage735]

A card-carrying genius, yes

[@timkilbourn5685]

Nuff said. I couldn’t put it any better. Who else could make the flute cool as hell. Well, other than Ron Burgundy!

[@janewright2800]

Don't care how he learnt to play the flute correctly or incorrectly, all I know is he creates pure magic with that unique sound!🪄🎶

[@CaCaldwell02]

His daughter was learning flute in school and pointed out to him all the ways he played it wrong so in the early 90's he bought books and started learning to play properly. you can hear a noticeable difference in his play from the 70's and 80's to the 90's and 00's as a result. I think its kind of a funny story. So now, he plays properly but still plays the improper way when the situation calls for it.

[@Roger-r7s]

I remember hearing Ian Anderson talk about how he played in such a weird way that was not the correct technique. The expression on the woman's face when she hears some of his riffing is priceless! It might not be everyone's cup of tea, perhaps not a James Galway or Jean Pierre Rampal but they aren't Ian Anderson either. Everybody seems to love Aqualung which is a good album but I think Benefit is one of the best rock n roll albums of all time and nobody seems to even mention it; at least as good as some of the classic Beatles, Stones, Who or Zep albums a real shame.

[@ChuckHackney]

Pure magic.

[@coast73]

​@@Roger-r7sI agree, benefit is criminally underrated. To be honest I did find it quite a boring compared to other tull albums at first, but it's an album that really rewards repeated listens. I'd probably say it's my favourite album right now.

[@coast73]

​@@Roger-r7sand for me, there's no question that it's much better than anything the Beatles did, not that they weren't great, there just aren't many bands that are close to being as creative, original or musically talented as tull were.

[@ofsinope]

So what kind of sounds can you get from a flute? Ian Anderson: Yes.

[@erikbender1967]

LOL!

[@giuliopierotti]

❤

[@pandax75]

I heard him in an interview say he never had any formal training. He bought a flute and started to try and play it and after a few days he finally got sounds to come out of it and the rest, well we all know the rest.

[@chpalmer2007]

LOL! My thoughts exactly!

[@DavidLindes]

Underrated comment. :) Also, priceless reaction to 2:33. I believe that’s called a growl. :) (But yeah, re 11:57, it’s ok not to like it. :))

[@trevsie7]

Considering Ian Anderson is self taught and can play several musical instruments equally well, he must be regarded as a genius

[@jackwyatt1218]

the gift of perfect pitch

[@donk.johnson7346]

He wrote all of the music too.

[@kingdomjerusalem7329]

Totally agree

[@cygnusactual1618]

While I adore Ian and tull, I think genius is thrown around a little too often. I love the guy and think he’s super talented but I try to reserve the word genius for people who are exceptionally noteworthy. That’s just my take on it though.

[@josemanuelgarcia4902]

@@cygnusactual1618 don't use the word "take" in such a way

[@WhizzingFish12]

Ian is a mad genius. Sometimes brilliant and sometimes totally out there in a way few people can access. He sings, writes, is a great flautist, and also a very good acoustic guitarist and keyboardist. He's all over the place! Never boring.

[@deannculver7969]

Thank you for saying flautist!

[@anhauenanhauen6547]

I Think you ate to young

[@elemar5]

@@anhauenanhauen6547 Is that English? Are you talking about an Asian dish?

[@longstreet0163]

And also a Salmon farmer.

[@TheFiveHKAAV]

The snoring sound was part of a sleeping giant story line. In context it works wonderfully… truly an incredible performance and greatly under appreciated

[@corawheeler9355]

Ian Anderson is self-taught. And it wasn't until his daughter took flute lessons that he was informed he was holding the flute incorrectly.

[@DropAnchor1978]

I think Ian actually injured his pinky finger and that was why it was bent.

[@PierreC2]

@@DropAnchor1978 he was born with a crooked pinky

[@HollowGolem]

The apocryphal story is that his daughter mentioned that her flute teacher played differently than he did and his response was, "Does your instructor have more Grammys than me?"

[@veganm8918]

@@HollowGolem That is hilarious. The music speaks for itself. I got to see them play many years back. It was amazing.

[@PierreC2]

Chris Check it’s not a true story

[@mikebunner3498]

Young lady, He made you smile. This was entertainment, pure and simple. This was music no one else had done before. His music was ground breaking. I miss these days...

[@leifjensen1758]

It is not that she is a classical trained flute player, it is the first time she has heard REAL MUSIC 🎶

[@jamestakac8951]

@@leifjensen1758 Real music is in the ear of the beholder. What you call real music many others won't and visa versa. It comes down to taste, and taste changes over time not to mention from person to person. I luv classical but I also luv the modern that often breaks the rules. That she's classically trained and still able to enjoy that more modern style says a lot about her

[@alkatraz8163]

Anderson's technical skill isn't the issue, it's his free style interpretation and innovation that puts him in a category unto himself.

[@ckelley63]

So coherent and on point my friend!

[@karldesforges277]

Sorry but Roland Kirk was his Mentor...Album Talk with the Spirit''..check..and u'll see...thanks..

[@stewartcutler8394]

He is copying Roland kirk - thats the innovator

[@peterrees6346]

Al Katraz which separates him from the conservative self obsessed generation who now review his work.

[@kenj8uk]

Ian Anderson stage name is Jethtro Tull .,his biggest hit was around the 1960s'....'' Living in the past,, from the UK.

[@jackempson3044]

It's not just flute playing. This man puts all this together with a beginning middle and end. The music most of the songwriting, the music and incorporating the flute to his style of music. He's genius by all standards. You notice their's been nobody like him since

[@chrstphr8]

their's nobody like him I agree

[@NuntiusLegis]

He is also a marvellous arranger, Tull sounds like Tull because of this, with any lineup. No other (ex-)member succeeded in recreating the Tull magic, including Martin Barre.

[@Paul-ec4tv]

Anybody that snorts into the mic while playing Bach is my hero

[@louisfkoorts5590]

😁

[@robertallen6710]

Back in the day...I may have been there more for the snorts than anything else...ha

[@zorroonmilkavitch1840]

@@robertallen6710 yeah back in the day there was a lot of snorting going on if you know what I mean.

[@WhaleTourist]

@@zorroonmilkavitch1840 I 'member.

[@slockfox]

Your comment made me instantly burst into uncontrollable laughter. 😅

[@katmckool]

Let's not forget that he also writes, arranges, and sings! The man is a musical genius!

[@katmckool]

I love your reactions. That's great fun!

[@moongazer5073]

Tull Rules

[@Rextrent]

Amazing showman/ entertainer.

[@scouser19a]

Absolutely!

[@utbelegs]

beyond genious.

[@JenniferinIllinois]

Nothing screams the 70s more than Ian Anderson playing a flute solo to a full stadium. AQUALUNG!!!! 😉

[@philsaggitariusa3738]

aqualung from bursting out

[@JamesCouch777]

Absolutely 😁👍

[@Skyprince27]

Don't you start away uneasy

[@dorotheamaterna8234]

@@JamesCouch777 4tg3vvçþ

[@JamesCouch777]

@@dorotheamaterna8234 ok

[@tracer60]

I don't think anyone has realized that he was playing 3 instruments at the same time ... flute, voice, and breath!!

[@BRIANTOWN33]

He was the Jimi Hendrix of the flute. breaking every rule.

[@robertdore9592]

A beautiful player....

[@1badsteed]

Would that be pronounced Yimmy?

[@maryjanerod7226]

I'm so glad I saw him preform live , magnificent , artist . tickets were affordable in those days.

[@lechat8533]

@@maryjanerod7226 Lucky girl :)

[@lechat8533]

@BRIANTOWN33 Breaking rules... The material geniuses are made of. Everyone else can stick to the mediocre level. Cruel but true.

[@vonsuthoff]

*Ian Anderson... "Rules to flute playing??? Ha! There are no rules to flute playing!!!"*

[@jeteye97]

There’s no rules for music. Only theory. Test every theory.

[@carolynrogers5762]

" IAN DON'T NEED NO STINKING RULEZ !!!! "

[@franciscoochoa1101]

Rules are for the weak! Flautists do not coddle the weak! HaHa...

[@PandorasFolly]

I am a master of Jazz flute

[@vonsuthoff]

@@PandorasFolly ... Wish I was a master of any musical instrument. But I... I am a lowly master of time and space. But, the laws of physics do not apply to me. So, that's pretty cool... eh?

[@Concatenate]

Only way to review any Jethro Tull is by sitting on a park bench.

[@seanalexander6310]

Eying little girls with bad intent?

[@jeffl1460]

Eying little girls with bad intent. Snot running down your nose. Greasy finger smearing shabby clothes

[@brianmahoney9388]

Stoned

[@daddywoofdawg]

Eying little girls with bad intent

[@philippeerville6181]

not necessarily stoned, but beautiful

[@michaelforsythe4335]

Ian can play, sing and snort simultaneously. Such a powerhouse, and he's still going in 2023 !!

[@rachaelmarrero8597]

I missed a chance to see them in Buffalo some years ago. The tickets were only $40 and I’m still kicking myself for not going 😭

[@Wild_Bill57]

Saw him in the Boston Garden in ‘74. He owned the place. When he threw his flute up in the air like a baton and caught it behind his back and then continued playing was something that I will never forget.

[@davidshaw1995]

Saw him at Maple Leaf Gardens back then. Great show!

[@jeffleonard1214]

1976 In Providence RI… The true Minstrel in the Gallery, Ian Anderson and Jethro Tull.. one of the most incredible groups and entertainers of the era.. Abundant Talent and originality….. Glad to have grown up in the time of the most talented bands & musicians of all time. Long Live Rock & Roll…. To old to Rock and Roll , to young to die!!

[@wilgratz9128]

Seen JethroTull 3x in '72-73-74. Awesome especially on peyote

[@Lala_B]

I saw him at the Memorial Coliseum in Portland, OR during his ‘76 tour. I had so many of his albums. Really brings back great memories!

[@aulia_NM]

Thick as a brick tour, Boston around that time. To this day........🤯

[@armadillotoe]

You have to keep in mind his stage persona is that of a wild man travelling troubadour. I believe he successfully projected that image.

[@andrewbainbridge4979]

Your certainly right there years ago I remember an article where he was listed 50th of the richest people in the UK yet so many people have never heard of him, their loss!

[@martmakkie5779]

@@andrewbainbridge4979 Thats those salmon investments for you

[@thesociallyresponsibleanar2882]

more like the mas minstrel as he describes himself

[@christo6765]

actually i see him as a big band leader. he seems to be conducting the band thru his entire body! not showing off, but simply conducting. Ian was really big on syncopation, to the point it is evident even in his body movements..

[@KelsaRavenlock]

When he went through the tweed coat with patches phase I always envisioned him as a mad Philosophy teacher on shrooms and peyote.

[@johndeeble3590]

He wasn't JUST a flutist. He was a master story teller

[@TheRKae]

His lyrical skill gets totally overlooked. I put him at #3 of all time as far as lyricists go. 1.) Al Stewart, 2.) Fish, 3.) Ian Anderson. (All Scotsmen. Hmmmm...)

[@tomkenney5365]

As well as a true showman. Postures, movements, facial expressions. There will never be another Ian Anderson, or Jethro Tull.

[@volo1826]

@@TheRKae I'd put people like jim croce and bob dylan up there as some of the best lyricist.

[@PortCharmers]

You guys got me worried there. He IS a great flutist, story-teller and showman.

[@j.dragon651]

@@TheRKae Al Stewart, one of my favorite song writers.

[@MousesInHouses]

Also classically trained here and went to music college as a flautist. Yes, it's not a conventional classical technique, but I think he's absolutely incredible and an astonishing musician.

[@CorePathway]

Thank God no one taught him the rules.

[@bhangrafan4480]

Jethro Tull comes from a tradition of British "Folk" musicians. These guys are real musicians. Many of them can play multiple instruments.

[@MyfriendthinkheOJ]

Can't prove it tho

[@jameshyde1501]

If only the current generation could learn from the wise ones.

[@groadybones]

If only the previous generation were wise so that the young ones could learn from them. Music isn't the only thing on the planet that you guys fucked up.

[@slippo99]

@@groadybones What does this even .mean?

[@playnhooky63]

Absolutely

[@richardwilson2621]

You should listen to jethro tulls whole catalogue it'll blow you away . It took a lot of balls for Ian anderson to be out front of a rock band not with a screaming guitar but a flute. Jethro Tull is a unique rock band.

[@BertGrink]

Tull was one of the best bands, that's for sure.

[@bobbrown1522]

Playing up to your audience with one's appearance, expressions, and antics, is definitely good showmanship but certainly not 'bawlsy'.

[@wjh8881]

Martin Barr can definitely scream on the guitar.

[@jamesbaker8653]

oh yes ! Martin Barre supplies the screaming guitar btw ....

[@scottthesportsguy]

And this is why they belong in the rock and roll hall of fame. So many great and unique songs, so original and beloved around the world for over 50 years now!

[@zerozerohero7189]

From now on...I will call this band.. "Yetro Tool"

[@Silverick2]

Me too!!

[@rkenseth]

Count me in too!

[@MrIrgendsontyp]

and me tool!

[@PoetDreamer]

Add me in the club :-D

[@jonofjord1663]

@@PoetDreamer Likewise, plus Heline is extremely cute and endearing.

[@lechatbotte.]

The flute is and has always been what makes Jethro Tull, well Jethro Tull. So unique and amazing.

[@TheFiveHKAAV]

And the lyrics and his voice! But, yes, that flue speaks to me on a soul level

[@MrGranitealchemist]

Ian anderson: I never did drugs His flute: dancing fairies emerge speaking dragon

[@troopytech9467]

Best comment haha

[@simonchantler9984]

It's not just his flute playing, it's his his songwriting and huge output of work. A truly staggering musician

[@johnnichols9056]

One of the best, I don't know if he ever did a cover of someone else's music, as far as I know nothing but his or his band mates.

[@angeloconsoli]

@@johnnichols9056 He made many covers. All his first two albums (1968 and 1969 ) are mainly covers! Bouree is a cover from J.S. Bach. Serenade to a cuckoo is a cover from Roland Kirk. Of course he made covers!

[@martinleavitt6094]

👌

[@davidcranch7890]

@@angeloconsoli On " This Was " only 2 songs are covers, Serenade to a Cuckoo ( Roland Kirk ) and Cat's Squirrel, a traditional tune arranged by guitarist Mick Abrahams. On " Stand Up, only 1 song is a cover, the arrangement of Bouree by J S Bach.

[@Vaticider69]

This guy kept an arena of rowdy stoned kids/adults mesmerized with a flute....

[@shawnfreeoftyranny8849]

Nobody else got this yet? About best compliment to Ian ever. Bunch of 60's/70's stoners (and more) all quite with little clue their getting Classical too from Ian's genius rocking the flute. Great true comment.

[@liljafamilyaccount7306]

Pied piper ;)

[@grumpynanny7402]

He is amazing.such a shame he cant play anymore.

[@davidmccleary5540]

He did me twice in Illinois in the 70's

[@SnowWalker1]

We'd all play the air flute when Jethro Tull came on.

[@mrmockatoo6786]

The most dynamic flautist/frontman in rock history. If you ever saw them live, you wouldn't forget. A brilliant band with a giant pixie from a 12th century English forest who discovered the magic mushrooms and shared the fun with his audience.

[@dangerszewski9816]

Absolutely true I've seen him live six times. He still puts on a heck of a show, though my dad says he's not what he once was-- which is fair, I think a 80 year old man jumping off speaker stacks, hopping around on one foot and throwing around his instruments would probably have to be carried out on a stretcher!

[@delubiod1970]

Saw him live at Jones Beach NY, in 1999.

[@thomasmead4642]

Jethro Tull is simply awesome.

[@bluenetmarketing]

I did see him play live in the 1970s.

[@harrietsand9715]

@mrmockatoo67 Yessss!!! What a conscious, poetic all knowing awareness encapsulated in your brilliant remark, bravo, Ian, bravo Mr Mockatoo!

[@feedingravens]

When you are the one who introduced and defined the flute in rock music, everything you do is the right way.

[@Gabinete-i5b]

😉

[@undercrackers56]

Just to add to existing comments here: Ian Anderson of Jethro Tull, is a self-taught rock flautist who also plays guitar and keyboards. Just as important he has been writing songs for decades, is an engaging front-man for his band, is keen on motorbike and used his money to buy chunks of Scotland in order to preserve the beauty of the land. What a guy!

[@zolatanaffa87]

i completely agree: wonder boy!

[@banjominer9682]

Didnt he get caught peeing on some teens in a hotel?

[@FunkyFyreMunky]

@@banjominer9682 No. Don't know who you're thinking of there.

[@sansocie]

@@banjominer9682 no that was President Trump in Russia.

[@sansocie]

@@FunkyFyreMunky Trump?

[@Groduke1011]

The most beautiful part about Tull live, wad you never know if the concert would begin in the 17th century or slap you in the head with the heavy metal mid 1970s before taking you back there. Ian Anderson and Martin Barre two of the greatest ever.

[@cbroz7492]

'Yet-tro Toole"...,love the classic European pronunciation...

[@cbroz7492]

The story if how Anderson chose the flute vs. the git-taris a classic one...

[@cbroz7492]

He was not a trained flautitist...he is/was self taught, my friend...Google has decision to transition to the flute...he realized that he would never be another Clapton and that the flute was absent from rock music...thus is interest in the instrument!!!

[@SirManfly]

Unfortunately the camera work back in the 70’s wasn’t the greatest, too many closeups and generally shotty work ! 🙄

[@Jeni-ow1kl]

@ Len Hess; SPOT ON!;)💥✌️✌️✌️

[@JSAnstock]

Ian has always been very open (and, I think, secretly proud) about the fact he is pretty much self taught. What the film fails to show is that for no obvious reason he is standing on one leg throughout his solos. So much love for Tull

[@aztecgold8997]

I'm 64 years old. I was a teenager in the 1970's....Jethro Tull played in all the kids house's . We loved him....Living in the past is my favorite

[@rayfieldlewis8780]

I’m a 74 yr old black man. Totally agree. Saw Tull 3 times and was blown away. Living in the past on my All Time Favorite List. Awesome👏

[@MarksMusic123]

Yes I saw him first in '78 when I was 15, Last time I saw Ian was within the last decade, Can't remember exactly- haha

[@jcpadmore]

Forget the classical training and "the official fingering". Ian is like the Flute version of Jimi Hendrix. Organic playing where there is no line drawn between instrument and man. Legendary.

[@devap1]

Ian is amazing....I had learned from an interview that he did go back an relearn proper fingering after his daughter brought it up in the 90s. That's how much of a perfectionist he was. He wanted to do it right...which doesn't diminish what he was doing since he was fine.

[@johnnosiennek7066]

If you look carefully you can see his right hand pinky is crooked from an accident as a youngster hence his fingering adaptation

[@peopleddiagram2920]

Mark Knophfler apparently doesn't hold the guitar correctly and plays in an unusual style.

[@jimda4910]

And how about Keith Moon on the drums.

[@chuzzrocket]

Excellent take. He's like Jimi in that way, different instrument.

[@abrahamparish]

Ian Andersen is a musical genius and treasure to us all. It's an honor to listen and watch that man perform.

[@martyairey1764]

AND an INSPIRATION!

[@weewilly49]

Completely and totally unique sound!!! A very very special part of music history!!!

[@michaelkeropian2954]

Those of us who grew up listening to this level of music are forever inspired and touched. Not bad for a musician who picked up the flute so he could do something besides sing. Love seeing your reaction. Exactly!

[@williamsj3]

Why is Green Day in Hall of Fame and Jethro Tull is not?

[@karllietzennayer9661]

Could it be the voters are still mad that they won the Grammy over Metallica in 1989 for best metal band?. Why is Soundgarden not in the HOF and Nirvana and Pearl Jam are? Soundgarden was the first band on the Seattle grunge scene. And then there is Ozzy Osbourne, The Guess Who, and Iron Maiden to name a few others. The HOF is a joke,

[@karllietzennayer9661]

Oh yeah, and how could I forget one of my favorite artists not in the HOF, Paul Rodgers. Are you kidding me? "The Voice" is a rock god!

[@amiiann]

@@karllietzennayer9661 bc Nirvana and Pearl Jam are great bands and soundgarden is only a decent band? Either way, obviously Jethro should be in the Hall

[@amiiann]

@@karllietzennayer9661 the hof is totally a joke, lol

[@karllietzennayer9661]

@@amiiann All three great bands. Chris Cornell vocals superior to Kurt or Eddie in my opinion. Thayil not too shabby of a guitarist either. Soundgarden's music more appealing to me. I'm a Chris Cornell fan.

[@richcapo]

I always love when a classically trained musician compliments a self-taught musician’s skills. It’s awesome to hear you say Anderson’s technique is “flawless.”

[@lisapickens2472]

I am a classically trained flutist as well and Ian Anderson is incredible! A true inspiration for me growing up. I was lucky to see him live once. I would love to see him play with his orchestra.

[@oysterman250]

If you’re classically trained, then you should know that you’re a FLAUTIST, not a flutist!

[@Nonesuch83]

@@oysterman250 Incorrect. There are two accepted terms and which is used is regional. The word flutist predates flautist, by more than a couple centuries, and flautist is chiefly British English. One may sound fancier, but it doesn't make it more correct.

[@MrJdsenior]

@@Nonesuch83 I hope you realize everything you just said probably made not one ounce of difference to the word Nazi. :-/ One thing I've learned is when people come at you in that tone, "you should" (ie I'm RIGHT, you're sub human) it is a pretty good indication that nobody will EVER confuse them with facts and logic. They are generally unteachable. I can appreciate the attempt, though. It's like aluminum and aluminium. My initial reaction was how in the heck do you get 'ium' out of 'um'. Then I realized they don't, it's spelled in Britain the way they pronounce it. And then when thinking why the difference, looking at the periodic table, I could see theirs might make more sense than ours (US). Nu Ku Ler I'm not even going to touch, though. Cheers.

[@Searchingforsilver777]

@@oysterman250 you don't even have content on your channel. How do you know so much and do so little. I think I feel the hot air now!

[@MrJdsenior]

@@Searchingforsilver777 :-)

[@amundbjerve]

This video tells us that Ian Anderson is a skilled eccentric (both on record and on stage), and that we all are standing on the shoulders of Bach.

[@scottmunson2917]

Found this enormously informative and entertaining. I am a "classical" clarinetist and every time I see one of these encounter videos I'm afraid it will just turn into a exercise in snobbery. But I loved how open minded and receptive you were! Brava!

[@Kermit_T_Frog]

The one thing she pointed out was that his fingering was wrong. Just read on Wiki that relearned to play the flute after learning from his daughter, who was taking lessons, that he was doing it wrong.

[@gregorywarren1]

Good on ya, You lots of clarinet players to aspire to... Just about any Big Band sound had a clarinet conductor

I played clarinet in school, only thing I did was annoy everyone

[@georgehinckle2028]

so then, i guess, according to you--- a guy who empties garbage cans is a dumpsterist? i mean, i wipe my ass. professionally of course. does that make me a reacherarounderist? brava. what is that? some gay thing?

[@georgehinckle2028]

@@Kermit_T_Frog um. dingbat. you can't play an instrument wrong. there is no such thing. that's the point of creativity.

[@scottyandell3644]

I can’t believe a professional flute teacher has never heard of Jethro Tull. Crazy

[@davidjones-vx9ju]

yea really

[@galihad1980]

@Ignatios Nelson she's not a native english speaker you twat

[@oldschoolman1444]

Seems like she had her flute playing box broken. =)

[@Rainmotorsports]

@Ignatios Nelson Recorded history says it was Flutist 200 years prior to Flautist which is a later Italian influence. It's an issue of local vernacular which changes all the time. It's like making fun of Americans for saying Soccer when the English used the word Soccer up until what the 1960's? No sense in looking pompous about it.

[@jcm4377]

Let her ignorance show how anyone can call him(er)self a teacher .. poor students!!

[@paulyhoffmann]

The late 60s and early 70s was the Golden Era of music. Future people will understand that.

[@eaglewi]

My dad said disco was like posion to music

[@ThePdog3k]

@@eaglewi tbh, disco was fine. that was still music, it was all the synthesizers that ruined popular music. it removed the skill gap that was required for entry prior.

[@TymP321]

There's a good video by Thoughty2 about the decline of music and why it's sooo horrible today

[@danconway313]

Ha ha don’t forget the drugs which intensified this era of music.

[@stewartmcardle8149]

Quite possibly, the best period in music ever.

[@deltabilly1]

I'm glad you enjoyed it! I've been a fan of Ian Anderson and Jethro Tull for decades! I had heard that Anderson played with strange finger position, and now you've confirmed it.

[@Qkano]

Re the "pinky" - "Ian Anderson has a congenitally deformed little finger on the right hand" ... he was born with it ... but seeing as he was entirely self taught ... he found a way.

[@aaronm.3581]

He actually had two left hands. But somehow he found a way.

[@kathymayes4290]

I have that same pinky - from birth and I played the flute in 5th grade just fine.

[@heavnnnsent]

When sousins marry **sigh**

[@heavnnnsent]

Cousins

[@sinjyn66]

I borrowed that pinky from Kathy Mayes for the summer of '98 and I played just fine too.

[@1Ma9iN8tive]

When Yetro Tool’s flawless flute snort technique is so strong it breaks the camera in 2020 from the 1970’s ...

[@danjacobs8545]

😂😂

[@brandonjohnson2493]

I’m amazed at how grossed out she is by this. Like she doesn’t realize that music doesn’t have to be “pretty” I would think somebody who has as much musical experience as she does to understand that music can convey all emotions, and yes that includes gross, grunts, and unclean sounds.

[@rickr2029]

😂🤣😂🤣

[@karlsnell2595]

@@brandonjohnson2493 ha

[@elizabethanthony3916]

😂

[@daves4645]

I live in a world where people have never heard of Jethro Tull?? That's horrible.

[@noclu4u384]

You can bet Metallica knows who he is .

[@scottdaley1672]

I was blessed to actually be at the show and I still have the ticket stub from it. Year after I got out of high school, I lived in St Petersburg. Good times at Tampa Stadium!

[@scottdaley1672]

@@noclu4u384 Jethro Tull is actually the name of the band, this flute players name is Ian Anderson.

[@panzerlieb]

Well, she’s a classical musician. They’re a pretty insular bunch. That means they don’t get out much. Welcome to the world Helene, it’s a big beautiful place. If ya know where look.

[@gwkgb8474]

Even worse they think he is a member of the band

[@semperfidelis1550]

Jethro brought a flute to a gun fight and won!…🔥🔥🔥

[@garygray8226]

or an AXE fight

[@renegade4dio]

Everyone: You can't play Rock with a Flute Lead. Ian Anderson: Hold my beer.

[@aleveraj]

Check this one out kzbin.info/www/bejne/aGLWqGNonb9ml9E

[@justgivemethetruth]

LOL ... I am sure that's what happened, yeah! ;-)

[@lizardinparadise]

Hold my beer whilst I go beat metallica for a grammy!

[@aleisterblacke]

@@lizardinparadise "We'd like to thank Jethro Tull for not releasing an album this year." LOL

[@nicholasholmes-siedle5119]

Hold my beer and a large pair of cymbals!!

[@TheLingnerFamily]

I think he's self-taught so you would probably find some issues with his fingering etc. But at the same time that probably explains his unconventional playing in general. He isn't stuck in a box

[@JdoubleU1222]

You are correct sir.

[@irock58]

I have no idea of his training but he has mastered his instrument. He is one with his flute.

[@ryenschimerman2127]

Funny enough, I heard him in an interview 10 years back and he was explaining how his daughter critiqued that very pinky issue after she was classically trained... ... and he changed his style.

[@oodoodoopoopoo]

@@ryenschimerman2127 - There are many reports that the pinky issue is an adaptation due to lifelong physical limitations of his pinky finger.

[@probablepaul1357]

He says he learned to play by only practicing as he performed live.

[@CaptainNemo1701]

I would recommend Locomotive Breath. Terrific rock number with a flute solo to match. Also check out their biggest chart hit Living in the Past which has lovely flute work in it.

[@HelineFay]

Thank you! I'll save those to my list!

[@PickleAndy]

I love the intro to Locomotive Breath and how Marty's guitar blends and counterpoints John's piano.

[@VinE83656]

@@HelineFay I do believe Living in the Past has some nice flute.

[@DonnaBrooks]

Oooo, Living in the Past! I'd forgotten about that song! But you're right about the flute being prominently featured in that song.

[@DonnaBrooks]

Oooo, Living in the Past! I'd forgotten about that song! But you're right about the flute being prominently featured in that song.

[@danh1738]

Seeing them preform was one of the best concerts of my life.

[@0HARE]

Me, too. I saw them five times in the ‘70s.

[@jeromebagus120]

I couldn't wait for the next concert. Rules? Genius doesn't follow rules.

[@starfire0007]

4 times 4 me.

[@stvbrsn]

Wow, you saw this band before they formed? That’s amazing.

[@AdrianneCottingham]

I took my baby twins to their concert in Dallas when they were still tiny! Their first Concert!!!

[@marciastern9015]

Actually, a lot of his techniques were originally developed by jazz guys, and his fingering comes closer to Irish wooden flute than classical metal flute. Check out Rahsaan Roland Kirk, Eric Dolphy, Hubert Laws, to say nothing of Matt Molloy and Seamus Egan. Trust me, Anderson did. You have no idea what you've been missing! Thing about Anderson....he just sampled everything he heard and mixed it all together into his own personal gumbo. And became and international rock star playing the most un-macho instrument that exists. Thick as a brick!

[@seanswinton6242]

Marcia Stern Some other flute players I like are Herbie Mann, Dave Valentin, Nestor Torres, and a big favorite of mine is Nelson Rangell. He plays saxophone, flute and piccolo.

[@ljprep6250]

@John Chrysostom Rev 3:9 I didn't get that from her post at all. I heard praise from it. To each their own.

[@derekemrie2987]

Yes, yes, yes, and he called the band "heavy metal flute" sometimes...I'm no flutist, but love listening to late, great Herbie Mann, love the flute sound mixed with vibraphone, etc. Love improvising, (keys, harmonica, little guitar), great to know all the theory but improv is the coolest, my opinion.

[@johnb511]

Glad you brought up Rahsaan Rolad Kirk!

[@davidschmidt6013]

MARCIA, WELL-SAID! Thank you, beautiful lady!!

[@nevermind-he8ni]

JT didn't play his music, he "became" his music. That transcendent spot we all strive for....

[@better.better]

haha... no

[@burundiblack4282]

Jethro Tull is not a person, it's a band...Ian Anderson is the flute player.

[@drmodestoesq]

@@burundiblack4282 Jethro Tull is, or was a real person. He invented the seed drill.

[@Hare_deLune]

@@drmodestoesq According to legend, Ian Anderson was at a friend's house and pulled a random book from the shelf. That book was a biography of Jethro Tull. The rest is history.

[@drmodestoesq]

@@Hare_deLune Thank God he didn't grab the diaries of Joseph Goebbels.

[@madislandguy]

I am officially going to refer to Jethro Tull as "Yetro Tool" from here on out. I love it.

[@paulbuckles5353]

Best to ask the guy who invented the Seed Drill in 1701, he should get the final word, except he is quite deceased.

[@roysheaks1261]

She had me as soon as she said his name!

[@scottsmith6932]

It’s been over 30 years since I’ve seen Jethro Tull live on stage and I’m still amazed at how good he really plays

[@jensleuner527]

@@roysheaks1261 she never even mentioned his name in the first place. It's Ian Anderson.

[@mschmidtTX]

She must be German, because the "J" in German is pronounced as a "Y".

[@use100ame]

This was just great, and should be preserved for all time. Heline, you were fabulous and sweet and vulnerable. I'm a flutist and a Yethro Tool fan myself, of course. You're absolutely right about the pinky, obviously, and intentional or not, your comments are meaningful. A match made in heaven, the two of you make this a totally enjoyable video.

[@tomasom4497]

Old school flute player listening to Ian Anderson for the first time: What strange manner of sorcery is this!

[@Frogdumpings123]

True that!

[@AdrienneAce2]

Sorcery of the very best and most beautiful kind, and there will never be another like him.

[@zallmine]

Right? I don't think she was quite ready for that! Lol

[@truthray2885]

"Questionable" sorcery.

[@hendrikvanleeuwen9110]

Level 20 Bard right there.

[@capnbobretired]

I think he blew her socks off! Jethro Tull is Classic in their own style. Back when rock was king and musical talent was the norm, and the genius level is what set groups like Jethro Tull apart.

[@gonefishin4802]

That is so cool - seeing someone, especially trained as a pro, watching Ian for the first time. Saw Tull for the first time in 1978, and all we could say for days was "What a class act!"

[@formersniper1595]

And don't forget he's doing this literally with the flute on the MIC and amps full volume so no getting away with mistakes. That is insane to sound that great amplified at that volume, AMAZING!

[@damiendavenport8899]

Even after 50 Years Jethro Tull still has such a distinct sound! Ian Anderson will forever live as the rock star flautist in my opinion.

[@davidandrews2280]

I have known about Jethro Tull for 50 years, this is the first extended solo I have heard. Thank you for sharing.

[@greatwhitewolf8465]

Me too! Other then seeing them in concert in 84

[@uriahheep8470]

Ian Anderson’s flute solos were unique. His lyrics were unbelievable. I met him...for a few moments...at a Tull show in seventies.

[@trebbleshooter]

Didn’t you open for him? Or play with him?

[@leahflower9924]

he was hot

[@TheBigMclargehuge]

He's the guy who wrings his hands rather than the band. Incidentally they're both fans of each other.

[@vladtheimpala5532]

Uriah Heep is pretty damn good too. Demons and Wizards is a great album. Easy Livin’. 👍 Every song is good.

[@shanedenny5234]

After seeing Ian Anderson on a late night talk show, one can clearly understand that he is very intelligent and outspoken. Wise and witty with a sense of humor. Aqua Lung will always be one of my favs. Thanks for giving us your gift Ian. Sure is awesome to hear you play. I won my 4-H Talent Contest in 6th grade playing the recorder (sound in the opening of Stairway to Heaven btw for those that had no idea) and competed in state. Seeing this genius play the flute like he does, makes me wonder if I should have been a musician throughout my life. I sure do love and appreciate music. The band director at the middle school I was about to attend the following year, came to my school and gave the sixth grade class a hearing test where we put headphones on and hit a button every time we heard a beat, looking for new talent to be in his band. I wanted to upgrade from the recorder and try the wood bassoon. I recall it being $800 (1984) and unfortunately my family couldn't afford it. I obviously passed the hearing test quite well, and was approached by the band director, and he has won many awards for his efforts btw, if I wanted to be in the band, after telling him I couldn't afford my instrument and saying "no", he turned his head to the side in disappointment and said, "ok" in a low tone of voice. He really wanted me to be in an award winning band. I thank God for my musical ear and giving me that talent. A musical ear that is 80% deaf on the right side. Born with a hole in my eardrum, that allowed sound to reach my heart instead. 🎶 👂 ❤

[@SixRavenEight]

Ian was a creative and gave us everything, classical, Pagan, Christian, performance art, viseral, visual, everything.

[@DanaTheInsane]

IS not was!

[@janebostwick6901]

This Was...and is.

[@billbateman6062]

I was in the audience at that concert. Anderson to me is a genius at getting the crowd involved. Your review was very good, and I enjoyed it.

[@mustangdebbie56]

Ian incorporated humor in his music and performances. The facial expressions and grunting/snorting were part of that. He was also famous for standing on one leg while playing flute, although it originated with the harmonica in his earlier days.

[@wirsing2332]

He WAS famous? He's still alive dude :D

[@MagpieMay66]

I also feel he is channeling his character Auqulung and the story that is the song Locomotive Breath in the song the character is named Charlie I encourage Hella to look at this performance after listening to Aqualung then Locomotive Breath to see the characters are there and helped him play his flute

[@mustangdebbie56]

@@wirsing2332 Oops, word crimes. My bad, I know he is still performing.

[@Weaseldog2001]

i realized part way thorugh, that the snorting was meant to be percussion. :)

[@chipsterb4946]

Mustang Debbie - they had a baby carriage on stage during a show I saw in Barcelona (mid-70s) as part of their “Too Old to Rock ‘n Roll” tour. The music was great by itself but the entertainment made it spectacular.

[@rpmfla]

This is probably my all time favorite reaction on KZbin. Jethro Tull has been my favorite band since the early 1970s so I always enjoy listening to them, and you being a professional flutist hearing them for the first time was so fun to watch. I also love how unpretentious you are as a KZbinr...you have a naturalness that I find very charming. Thanks for doing this!

[@rickschrager]

Ian Anderson has made millions of dollars without using his little finger properly. Go figure. ;)

[@jurgentreue1200]

Ian Anderson also made millions out of salmon farming and property.

[@TyrionCypher]

Ian Andersson also sat down and corrected the pinky, once his kid pointed out his mistake to him. Go figure.

[@spikespa5208]

Like anyone really noticed?

[@TyrionCypher]

@Speed Buggy I get what you say and mostly agree. Only not in the BS part. These rules are based on centuries of player's experience and proper technique opens the doors to advanced, more difficult ways of playing. Anderson himself corrected his technique in the 90s. He wouldn't have done that if it had been BS. But yes, there are other ways to greatness and you definitely should play an instrument the way you're comfortable with.

[@richardslingwine3197]

@Speed Buggy OK, I know the world has been waiting for me to weigh in.... ;-) I was reminded recently that playing is supposed to be fun. I spent the last 2 years trying desperately to be perfect in every note I play. And you want to know what? I freaking hated it. Now I play cause it's fun. Perfection is unattainable so if you hold your guitar "wrong" or your pinky isn't quite right (mine got broke and deformed when I was 6) who cares? What comes across in your music is your passion, not someone's supposed perfection. The audience reacts to your emotions through both your body language and your creative talent. And Ian has enough talent for all of us! Cheers! Enjoy the music and be yourself.

[@maxlharris]

Found this and thought you might be interested... “Being self taught, and never having had a lesson, I was playing a lot of the notes using incorrect fingering,” Anderson says. “I had to relearn it again, in about ’91, I think. … It taught me to take a little more seriously. In relearning my own repertoire, it was a good lesson in mid life - not quite a crisis, but damned close to it.” - Ian Anderson (of Jethro Tull).

[@Sandy-dd4le]

Iirc, he has something wrong with his pinkie that makes it difficult to use, so he didn't bother to use it when learning the flute. I don't remember if it's a birth deformation or if maybe he broke it at some point.

[@Optimalillusion]

Ian was beatboxing on flute waaaaaay before people on YT were born.

[@bumontana]

I love it when a new generation discover Jethro Tull.

[@michaeltaylor8835]

Total legend. We will never see his like again

[@robc9124]

Hey, don't write him off yet! - he is meant to be touring this year, but I expect Covid-19 will put paid to that.

[@Nudiescorner]

NEVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@JustaMallard]

You heard his Thick as a Brick 2 album?

[@Nudiescorner]

@@JustaMallard YES

[@burundiblack4282]

Oh don't start with that"Sir" bullshit...Being knighted means NOTHING....getting recognized by the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame means NOTHING. Do you understand?...NOTHING.

[@mtoasty]

Jethro Tull, a great band deserving to be in the Rock and Roll HOF. Aqualung, one of the best albums of all time.

[@klarasprudel1359]

'A Little Light Music' awesome live album

[@SirLionofBiff]

You spelled "Heavy Horses" wrong.

[@robertpfaff7992]

My father had a cassette of Aqualung in his office when I was a little boy and, even now at 40 years old, listening to the title track when I visited is one of my strongest childhood memories. Heavy Horses, Rock Island, and yes even J-Tull.com are great, but it's hard to top the original studio Aqualung.

[@swinetrek]

The Rock and Roll Hall od One Man's Opinion more like. No band needs to be inducted into that crap.

[@sueparras6028]

Love Aqualung also! Love the way he incorporates the flute into his music!

[@chipsaunders154]

The kid is actually enjoying it. How cool is that......liking music that's almost 50 years old. Tull was my first concert experience in 1972. Thick as a Brick. Denver Coliseum.

[@m.o.5137]

Chip Saunders Me too in 72 Cleveland 👍👍

[@wkizer7361]

Chip Saunders that would have been the 'thick as a brick' tour that was unreal. The Eagles, the original lineup, open for them in Oklahoma City.

[@kellyvcraig]

My ears still hurt from a concert in Seattle.

[@billcoleman4258]

Well, parts of it are 300 years old.

[@tfischer3713]

Wow, my first concert too, 1972 Nassau Coliseum, Long Island New York. Then Genesis, Emerson Lake & Palmer, Yes, Eric Clapton, lots of concerts back in the day. Saw Tull again much later in Prague, like 1997 maybe. Ian Anderson is unforgettable. He was a fish farmer in Scotland too.

[@subliutenant]

I just Love your reaction to Jethro Tull! You should have been with us back in the 60's and 70's, you'd have Loved every minute of it!

[@IMNOGURU]

I love Ian Anderson....His hisses, singing, flutters and grunts and snorts just add to the beauty in a devilishy demonic way twisting the simplicity into chaos and then back. It always leaves me wondering whats next? Inspired me to learn some flute when I was younger.

[@lindaterrell5535]

Paul Samson Imagine what he’d do with a didgeridoo.

[@terrinbrysman6811]

I agree wholeheartedly. He is one-of-a-kind and truly creative. I am also a big fan of Jethro Tull.

[@raymondsimpson7433]

There will never be another flute player in rock and roll like Ian Anderson.

[@DecksterPenkor]

Rock & Roll exists only on recordings now. The real thing is gone.

[@roberttank2919]

@@DecksterPenkor Not true. It's out there playing live all over the place, and being played very well. It's just not on any media platforms from radio to internet. It used to rule the 'record' charts, but its now all but gone there -- but from music festivals to bars, rock lives.

[@Muck006]

@@roberttank2919 The problem is "industrialisation" of music ... AND the skill-less artificial creation of bands. The current time of "rebellion against bureaucracy" needs to end with bureaucrats being changed and quality controlled AND we need to tear down mainstream media too due to their lies. This gives a chance to change the music industry ...

[@TowerofGuitars]

PROBABLY!

[@jimwickware8794]

As you probably know, he was totally self taught. I read that his daughter a few years ago told him how untrained he was and he re-learned how to play the "right way". My wife, who is also a classically train flutist is totally put off by him.....just can't wrap her head around him...appreciates the talent, but he is off the charts....literally. Personally, I think he is AMAZING

[@MsSmitty9]

I said the same about being untrained. Just incredible. Saw him do this plenty of times in the 70s. Thank God for mescaline. Made it all that much more intense. Was front row plenty of times in The Old Boston Gahden. Miss those days. Just saying. 😂

[@debramason1898]

I’m with your wife on this one

[@eristicfreethinker2098]

Classically trained sometimes means close minded.

[@MarkandSandieInMotion]

@@eristicfreethinker2098 and a conformist:)

[@nancymanly2904]

We saw Jethro Tull in Oakland, CA. The opening band was a country-type group no one in the audience recognized- the Eagles. The Jethro Tull band put on one of the best shows I have ever seen; not just Ian Anderson but the whole group.

[@parttime9070]

That was one of my first concerts, Saw lot's of good music at the coliseum..

[@loralyns]

Wow! You hit the jackpot with that concert.

[@amoh5]

His Celtic Old English flute style of playing is his most famous trademark in my opinion, he creates that Celtic medieval country-side atmosphere of mystique and fairytales, a musical genius I must say...

[@davidmaxwaterman]

... and perhaps standing on one leg.

[@jameswheat4225]

I agree

[@laurademarrais3248]

That is a perfect description

[@alikartal8426]

And I believe he lays no claim to being the best flautist of the century or whatever. He is not known for his mastery of playing the flute. I know him for the wonderful music he created (with and without the flute) which made our lives better.

[@fredgarv79]

well said sir

[@patrickdurham8393]

He said that since he was the only flautist in Rock music he was both the best and the worst!

[@richardlewis6183]

Sadly, this group has been overlooked and denied entry into the Rock-N-Roll Hall of Fame. They have provided concerts and albums and songs for nearly 60years! How many entertainers can claim that?. They created the concept albums and what was deemed the "Thinking Man's" Rock-N-Roll Genre. So much have they given to, not only their fans but to Rock-N-Roll that far exceed almost all of the groups that have been selected. That it is not only mind boggling but to me casts a dark cloud over Cleveland and the mini-minds that run what can only be now called "The Rock-N-Roll Hall of Shame" for their ignorance and stance on "Jethro Tull"

[@bigmikey7511]

Ahhh, they did win a grammy for best rock group...This group was never overlooked...

[@Johnnyjackringo]

I give no credence to the R&R HOF. They are meaningless to most of us. Jethro Tull were in a class by themselves. One of my concert regrets.

[@stevealexander8010]

@@Johnnyjackringo RRHOF is a tragedy. They can't distinguish rock from pop or schlock.

[@richardlewis6183]

@@bigmikey7511 They won the first ever Grammy for best "Heavy Metal" Album in 1989 for "Crest Of A Knave" beating out Metallic.

[@calbrabandt5967]

"...deemed the "Thinking Man's" Rock-N-Roll Genre." Yes, and well before the band Rush too. I love this KZbin vid! Thanks, Heline. It brought back memories. IIRC, I saw this tour at the Cow Palace in San Francisco. Ian Anderson sure created a lot of Jimi Hendrix moments, but with the flute instead of the guitar, of course. Speaking of guitarists, I recall that Rory Gallagher opened at the Cow Palace. He, like Hendrix and so many other brilliant guitarists, died far too young!

[@0HARE]

Yeah, “Wow, just wow” pretty much sums it up. It’s Art, and Improvisation. This man, Ian Anderson, is a phenomenal musician, composer, and band leader. Sometimes known as “The One Legged Flautist”, he combined Classical Music, traditional English and Celtic music, and Rock & Roll in a way no one else has ever done. I saw this amazing man, and his band Jethro Tull, five times in the 1970s. What an amazing treat each concert was. Thanks for showcasing Mr. Anderson’s talent, and I’m glad you enjoyed it. Rock On

[@johncongerton7046]

The Hendrix of Flute. Expression overrules theory.

[@raydetone]

She probably doesn't know who Hendrix is either haha

[@raydetone]

I watched this entire video entirely for Ian Anderson's solo.. she added nothing haha

[@drd1924]

Expression overrules theory....best lesson....As Bruce Lee also proved

[@curlywhites]

That's a limited way of thinking. Theory opens up the possibilities of expression. Neither overrules the other. Theory is knowing how to build a house practically and up to code. Expression is being able to build that house to the point somebody wants to and can live in. The more you know the better and faster you can build the house.

[@aidabogle2962]

She seemed to only notice his technique - flawless - what about the music?

[@genesevox7403]

I played some Tull for a classically trained flutist years ago. She was snobby and gave no respect. Props to you. Great to see someone approach an instrument in an existential way.

[@personalcheeses8073]

Matty G Ian Anderson is British So he is flautist

[@anthonyschofield7807]

I absolutely loved your reaction to Ian’s playing,your expressions were wonderful and you appreciated his skill which from someone like yourself is praise indeed

[@sofamiller7133]

Yeah, dude’s playing his flute like other rockers play their guitar. It’s supposed to be intense.

[@bsenka]

YES!!! I was just about to comment the same thing -- the reason this is so different from what would be considered "proper" flute playing, is he's doing a typical 1970s style protracted guitar solo and just replacing the guitar with the flute.

[@charlesarturo7718]

What Jimi Hendricks did for the electric guitar, Ian Anderson did for the flute///

[@garygolt7754]

I saw them in Louisville on the Passion Play tour. I was floored

[@leahflower9924]

exactly its supposed to be messy and sexy he succeeded

[@RobCalhounPGH]

@@charlesarturo7718 Band geeks everywhere had someone to look up to when Ian hit the scene.

[@Dr.J-e9t]

Ian Anderson is one a kind. He redefined what's possible on the flute!

[@banjominer9682]

So true..redefined sounding like crap on an instrument that sounds like crap.

[@BodhiFitness]

Banjo Miner you hating? That stadium full of people seems to dig it.

[@farshimelt]

He copped most of it from Roland Kirk. Go to the source.

[@TheRisingFury]

@@banjominer9682 I agree, the banjo is a hack 'instrument' for hicks that sounds like crap.

[@mikekeyes6102]

@@farshimelt Yes sir! And I don't Know whether he ever acknowledged that fact.

[@domino3841]

I'm a lifelong fan of jethro Tull and I'm 68 I finally got to see him in Houston a few months back took my 34yr old son would is a great musician, man the memories me and him are making, we go to as many shows as we can, we have seen countless bands. Funny story about this show, he had bought the tickets online and had them for months, and we were anticipating the show, so we thought the show was on that Tuesday, but we were wrong it was that night(Monday). So we were eating supper and I asked him to check and make sure of the date for the show, well he looked on his phone, and damm it was starting in an hour and ten minutes, we left the food on the table and hauled ass. We got to our seat with 5 minutes to spare. Haha true story

[@rjonboy7608]

I envy you, sir. And would have left filet mignon to go get my soul fed.

[@michaeljames4509]

Ian was much more impressive in the 70s though.

[@dougrebertus7107]

I saw Jethro Tull in the early 70's. It was an awesome show.

[@pamle1]

I was watching Jethro Tull a couple of years ago on TV. In the middle of a song he dropped to his knees and placed his mic against the guitarist's crotch and started to simulate oral sex on him.

[@jallan9578]

'... we were eating supper ...' Nothing to beat the very last minute!

[@ag2424]

We grew up listening to the awesomeness of Jethro Tull as teenagers, and it was a huge part of our listening pleasure. This was my first time on your channel and your reactions to his talent was priceless!! And loved listening to your beautiful flute also!! Subscribed immediately 💕

[@franktoth2427]

I came of age listening to Jethro Tull . One of the most amazing bands ever. When they won a Grammy they didn’t know which category to put them in so they put them in Heavy Metal. Lmao 😆 I feel that they never got the recognition they deserved because their music was so diverse!

[@danielbarbee7712]

I think for being so different from mainstream they did really well.

[@dianagreen5700]

Ian: Mom I want to be in a Rock Band? Mom: No Ian, you have to learn to play the flute! Ian: okay mom!

[@Kermit_T_Frog]

I just wikied him and it seems that his first love was guitar, but after realizing that he'd never be as good a Clapton, he took up the flute... among a whole bunch of other instruments.

[@minkahl1644]

Actually... Ian: -I wanna be a guitar playing rock star. Clapton: -Hi, Ian. This is my slowhand. Ian: -Hey clerk! How much will it be if I trade this guitar for that flute?

[@BigBoy4004]

Now, consider that he is a brilliant acoustic guitarist, composer and singer as well...

[@jessicahainesmusic]

and producer :)

[@coelacanth9821]

@@jessicahainesmusic and performer (...least important for me, but still -brilliant)

[@ronchasr6656]

And fish farmer.

[@tednugent8501]

@@ronchasr6656 And speed freak.😈

[@beloveddude]

seeing Heline's reactions..priceless, JOYFUL, sweet, hilarious! What a pure sweet angelic being! Glad to see such pure soul! Glad to come across this vid!