Her Voice Was Almost Similar Lata Mangeshkar Which Ruined Her Life In Bollywood In Singing Career

Her Voice Was Almost Similar Lata Mangeshkar Which Ruined Her Life In Bollywood In Singing Career. #latamangeshkar #sumankalyanpur #bollywoodsinger
#sumankalyanpurbiography#sumankalyanpurallsongs #sumankalyanpurfilms,#sumankalyanpurkegaane #sumankalyanpurhindisongs,#nanakartepyar,#sumankalyanpurandlata#rajkapoorfilms#shahrukhkhan,#ipl,#viratkohli,#dilipkumar,#madhubalaanddilipkumar,#jabjabphoolkhile #sumankalyanpurhits,#rajkapoorhits,#latahits,#ashabhoslehits,#rdburmanhits,#rdburmansongs,#dharmendraandamitabh,#arijitsingh,#netflix,#amazon,#htstar,#indianhero,#hemaIs it true her voice was very similar to great Lata Mangeshkar ji?
Did she sang lots of hindi songs where people get confused is it Lata ji or Suman ji?
Did Lata ji threatened all music director in the music industry to not give any songs to Suman Kalyanpur?
Did Mohd. Rafi also refuse to sing with Suman Kalyanpur because Lata Mangeshkar don’t want anyone to support and give her any songs?
How many award Suman Kalyanpur grab and how many songs she sung as an singer?
Is it true Lat ji ruined her career in Bollywood industry?
Did she challenge Lata ji for her action which she took against her?
Suman Kalyanpur (born as Suman Hemmadi; 28 January 1937) is an Indian playback singer, one of the best-known and most respected playback singers in India.
Her voice was often mistaken to be that of Lata Mangeshkar.[1] Suman Kalyanpur's career started in 1954 and was very popular singer in the 1960s and 1970s. She recorded songs for movies in several languages besides Hindi, Marathi, Assamese, Gujarati, Kannada, Maithili, Bhojpuri, Rajasthani, Bengali, Odia and Punjabi.[2] She is considered among the popular singers of her prime time.
Personal life[edit]
Early life
Suman Kalyanpur was born as Suman Hemmadi on 28 January 1937 in Dhaka (now in Bangladesh). Suman Kalyanpur's father Shankar Rao Hemmadi hailed from a Saraswat Brahmin family belonging to Mangalore. Hemmadi is a village in Kundapur Taluk of Udupi District, Karnataka. He served on a top post in the Central Bank of India and was posted to Dhaka for a very long period. Apart from father and mother Seeta Hemmadi, there were 5 daughters and one son in the family with Suman being the eldest among her siblings. In 1943, her family moved to Mumbai, where she received her musical training.
Suman had always been interested in painting and music. After completing schooling from Mumbai’s famed St. Columba High School, she got admission in the prestigious Sir J. J. School of Arts for further studies in painting. Simultaneously, she started learning classical vocal from Pune's Prabhat Films' music director and a close family friend, Pandit Keshav Rao Bhole. According to Suman, initially singing was just hobby to her but gradually her interest in music increased and she started learning it professionally from Ustad Khan, Abdul Rehman Khan and Guruji Master Navrang.[3][4] Suman's younger sister Shyama Hemmady was also a singer.
Married life
Suman Hemmady married a Mumbai-based businessman Ramanand Kalyanpur in the 1958 and thus, became Suman Kalyanpur from Suman Hemmady. He accompanied her for every recording session after her marriage. She has a daughter named Charul Agni who is settled in the United States after marriage. Her grand daughter Aaishanni Agny returned to India and opened an NGO in Mumbai in her grand mother's name.[citation needed]
Kalyanpur also recorded some memorable songs with a classical base, including "Manamohan Man Mein Ho Tumhi", "Mere Sang Ga Gunguna" and "Gir Gayi Re More Mathe Ki Bindiya”.
Similarity of voice with Lata Mangeshkar[edit]
Suman Kalyanpur's voice was very similar to the singer, Lata Mangeshkar. Many of her songs are indistinguishable from Lata's style, because she sung with a quality comparable to Lata. Kalyanpur was very uncomfortable regarding the similarity between her voice and Lata's. She had once answered "I was quite influenced by her. In my college days, I used to sing her songs. Meri aawaaz nazuk aur patli thi (My voice was fragile and thin). What could I do? Also when Radio Ceylon relayed the songs, the names were never announced. Even the records sometimes gave the wrong name. Maybe that caused more confusion."[5] In the era of 1950s and 1960s, the period was referred as the golden era of Hindi film music where the time when female playback singing was dominated by the Mangeshkar sisters Lata and Asha Bhosle.
When Lata was not available for recording, or if the producers could not afford her rate of Rs 100 per song, the song used to be sung by Kalyanpur. During the similar period, Lata had refused to sing with Rafi over royalty issues and those songs were recorded by Kalyanpur with Rafi. She sang over 140 duets with Rafi in this period.
Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research

[@swatisuhas2744]

सुमनजी की आवाज "गंगौघ" है, जिसमें एक ईश्वर का वास है. आपका व्यक्तीत्व भी निर्मल है. लता से बहुतही बेहतर ....👌👌💐💐

[@bhoolibisriyadein9250]

Suman Kalyanpur, a great singer. Few people are blessed with such a great voice. 🙏🌺🌺🌺🌺🌺

[@gurupmishra8575]

जब भी किसी गीत मेँ किसी को शंका हो कि लता मंगेशकर ने गाया हैं या सुमन जी ने तो उसको फिर से सुने. यदि गीत इतना सुरीला लगे कि दिल को छू ले और स्वर बहुत ज़्यादा सुरीले हों तो समझ लें कि इसे सुमन जी ने ही गाया हैं

[@omprakashgour4151]

Wrong wo lata ji ki awaz he

[@user-vt4kf2nb3g]

sahi kah rahe hai

[@DrArchanatripathiMishra]

Very true

[@shirishkanhere9134]

भाई साहब, सुमन जी बहोत अच्छी गायिका थी इसमे कोई शक नहीं, लेकीन आप मुझे कुछ सवाल का जवाब दिजीए 1) सुमनजी के गाने बताईए जीसमे कोई आवाज का special effect है, कोई ऐसी हरकत है, तान है, आलाप है, मुश्किल जगह है 2) सुमनजी के सारे गाने सुनिये, सारी भाषा के गाने सुनिये, आपको एक ही pitch मिलेगा, sweet है, मिठी है लेकीन कोई आवाज का बदलाव नहीं, mono tone है सब गाने. 3) सुमनजी के पती उनके साथ होते थें, उनकी वजह से film industry के लोग सुमनजी को avoid करते रहे, 4) सुमनजी dashing नहीं थी, वो घर पे बैठी रही, 2008 मे उनके पती गुजर गये, फिर किसीं ने उनको धुंडके उनका interview लिया, तब जाके वो 40 साल बाद सब के सामने आ गयी, अब इसमे लता या आशा का दोष ?

[@kishorramjipatel9452]

#Date_24_09_2023_ #Hello_Yes_Hi_Thankyou_ 🌹 🙏🙏💛💚❤🙏🙏 🌹

[@surenderpalsingh3093]

Great Singer I salutes

[@AshokKumar-vf7ve]

आपका ये सुमन कल्याणपुरी जी के ऊपर कार्यक्रम बहुत बहुत अच्छा लगा।

[@bakuldave8547]

I felt very bad. Why Suman ji had to suffer. I can't understand why music Directors afraid of Lata ji? We must believe that the luck is the vital factor.

[@shirishkanhere9134]

fooooool all you lata haters here...........sumanji had sister named SHYAMA CHITTAR........she has equally similar voice like sumanji.....SHYAMA was also good singer and she had some songs in hindi and marathi.......why suman not gave own songs to her own sister ? why always begging songs and work from lataji only............is suman BHIKARAN (begger) ???????

[@gurupmishra8575]

सौभाग्य से सुमन जी आज भी हमारे बीच हैं हालाँकि अब वे नियमित और फ़िल्मी गायन मेँ भाग नहीं ले रही हैं.

[@shirishkanhere9134]

she ran away in 1985.......she did not fight...........she is looser............she had no quality to sustain .....she had no fighting spirit......

[@lallitasingh616]

LATA JI AND ASHA JI PROUDY SINGER HAI JI SUMAN KALYANPUR JI SE ZALAN HO GAYI ..MUGHE SUMAN JI KI AAWAZ SUBSE ACHHI LAGTI HAI

[@shirishkanhere9134]

tu kyu jalti hai.,lataji se aur ashaji se...........burnol laga le.......gaand me

[@lalithasingh5435]

Very sad that this melodious singer was not given recognization for her par excellence songs This was very unfair She was one of my very favourite Singer Sumanji An outstanding singer

[@naitiksharmachapsleeschool5524]

Sumanji,Kabhi bhi Lataji se Unnis nahin thi nahi hai aur na hi hogi. She is alyays Bees. May be Ikkis. East or West Sumanji is always Best. Shaandaar Presentation🙏❤️

[@shirishkanhere9134]

ha ha ha ha ha............do you have brain then use it..........lets agree that suman ji is 20 and lataji is 19...........but 19 out of 20 in suman is belongs to lataji....then the only 1 remains is deserves sumanji.......... her own talent is 1 and begged/copied/stolen 19 from lataji

[@swatideshmukh5939]

We love Sumanji.❤

[@meenahirachan190]

So sweet voice 🎉❤

[@satyabhakti1159]

Yah to aapse pata chala nahin to ham to Lata ki awaaz hi samajhte rahe hae . Great singer

[@gurupmishra8575]

लता मंगेशकर ने सुमन जी जे साथ भी कुछ गीत गाये. उनको फ़ौरन समझ मेँ आ गया कि यदि युगल गीत इनके साथ गाये तो लोग तुलना करेंगे. तब वही होगा जो रफ़ी साहब के साथ युगल गाने पर होता था. मगर ये तो महिला स्वर का मामला था. यहाँ तक हुआ कि एच एम् वी के कुछ रिकार्ड्स पर सुमन जी के नाम कि जगह लता मंगेशकर छापा हुआ मिला और फिल्मों के कुछ गीत जो सुमन जी ने गाये वो रिकॉर्ड पर आये ही नहीं.

[@poojajohar8894]

Very jealous lady thi, kisi bhi female singer ko aane nahi diya lata ne

[@itishreerana2921]

Yes

[@anjanadutta2652]

God bless her.

[@nasiruddinkhoja2300]

Latajine apni hi bahen Ashaji ko aage badne se rok Lia tàki Ashaji ka nàm unse unchà naho !

[@neelumegh9276]

Sahi kaha. Dusaron ka gana hathiyane aur haq marne mei kabhi sharm nahin aayi

[@rajnikantmishra5309]

Suman kalyanpur ji ne Odia movie me bhi gane gaye the... Aap ne mention nhi kiya... Lots of love & blessings from ODISHA for Suman kalyanpurji & you..

[@harishwala5882]

Excellent Presentation, Congrats

[@nirmalyaneogi8806]

श्रद्धेय सुमन जी को सप्रेम नमन।

[@amrikjohal1240]

You are right. It is very hard to find out.thanks.

[@sunainasharma6027]

May u achieve success in every birth❤👍🙏💐🇳🇪🌹

[@arshadaziz7696]

Comment from London.. Suman's voice had that sweet & melodious wave and lilt that was unique and God gifted. Lata's was flatter toned and sharper. I prefer Suman's vocals. Your video is well researched and well presented with facts - thanks to you.

[@shirishkanhere9134]

Flatter toned and sharper are two opposite words, plz clear your views then we will debate on it

[@uttampisal2565]

सुमन कल्याणपुर की आवाज को आज भी संगीत के धुरंधर लताजी की आवाज समझते हे यह सब भाग्य का लेखा हे कार्यक्रम की प्रस्तुती बहुत खूब अतिसुदंर लगी 😢😢😢 अफसोस आज भी पुराने शौकीन शर्ते लगाते हे

[@OSMBollywood]

Thanks a lot Sir for your appreciation

[@SopranoPersonalityspices]

Excellent presentation Sir. Somewhat a sad thing to hear about Suman ji. ❤❤❤

[@OSMBollywood]

Thanks a lot sir

[@SopranoPersonalityspices]

@@OSMBollywood I do watch other movie related channels Sir. Your channel is probably the best in terms of research, content & ofcourse your vibrant voice & inimitable presentation skills 👍👍👍

[@OSMBollywood]

@@SopranoPersonalityspices Thanks a lot for your kind words

[@shabbirahmedansari2550]

Lata aasha ne kayee fankaron ka nuksan kiya aur aage badne nahi dia is k virudh rafi saheb ne kayee fankaron aage badne ka moka dia aur kabhi bhi apne aap ko sherst nahi bataya...ye dono bhaene to unhe bhi rokne ki koshsh ki....

[@poojajohar8894]

​@@shabbirahmedansari2550बिल्कुल सही फरमाया है आप ने

[@jagdishjaiswal1985]

अपनी कुर्सी छिनती देख लता ने कुछ ही दिनों बाद रफी साहब से दोस्ती कर ली और आज महान बनी हुई हैं पर मैं तो उन्हे अव्वल दर्जे की शातिर मानता हूं जिसने न जाने कितनी गायिकाओं का करियर खराब या यूं कहें खा डाला

[@ahmedm6041]

These two ladies have the same voices! It's like finger prints! Just sad that she didn't get recognition.

[@shirishkanhere9134]

ooooooooooooooooo GOD when will people realize that this is half truth.........poor people here who only believe such hopeless posts spread by lata haters.........plzzzzzzzzzzz listen all lata haters followi songs then come for open discussion 1) koi mere dil me khushi ban ke aaya (film - andaaz 1947) 2) aaja aayi bahar dil hai bekaraar o mere (film - rajkumar 1964) 3) mere khwabome jo aaye aake muze chhed jaaye .(film - DDLJ 1994).... all lata haters you might be educated enough to count difference between 1947 and 1994.........does first and third song's voice match with sumanji's voice ??????? only second song's voice match......

[@maltisharma3201]

Suman ji ki awaaz super classic thi.inki awaaz me jo laraz thi khanak thi wo aaj tak ki kisi bhi female singer ki awaaz me nahi he.

[@downloadaj4294]

Aaj unko apni phchan MIL hi gai

[@faizaan725]

🌹💐Bahut hi achcha laga mujhe ye video🎥 Suman kalyan g par mazaa aa gaya👍

[@anandv4163]

Sumanji was an excellent class singer in Hindi and Marathi film Industry.

[@GhulamNabi-uo3nj]

Suman.ji a very. Beautiful lady by. Face. And very. Asome. Singer Of. India. She. Will. Remain. Always. In. Our. Hearts

[@shaila5315]

very tallented singer.nostalgic voice.

[@prakashadatia8799]

My favourite singer. Shankar Jaikishan duo was the only music composers perfectly used her voice without being afraid of Lata.. They have many songs with Suman

[@asgharalirajput9510]

Good Morning Ji Sir Super Voice Big like❤❤❤❤❤

[@mahemoodkhan5105]

Ham to Aaj Tak samajhte the ki Lata Mangeshkar ki awaz hai lekin ab Maloom pada hai ki Suman Kalyanpur ki awaaz hi bahut behtarin Geet Gaye Hain unhone bahut behtarin bahut Someshwar so number Hone Ko Diye Jaate Hain Mere taraf se mein Muskan ki or se hundred mein Hundred

[@ElizabethMathewiiind]

That's was good nice.compliment and a nutshell tribute to such a career

[@letstoorandtravel7430]

Bahut khoob janab

[@rajinderjoshi2048]

Yeh sahi kaha aapne ek sajeesh bahut sundar awaaz melody queen hai or rahegi sat sat naman ❤❤

[@anthonysalve4023]

Thanks sir.

[@imtiazahmad8598]

splendid, superb,, The Great singer.,.,., Suman kalyanpur.,,forever green & Gold.,,❤❤

[@ganeshraoraibole295]

शुक्रिया सर शुक्रिया....

[@rps3182]

Not only Suman ,many like Asha,Vani were denied the recognition bevause of Lata

[@lakshmysubramanian9087]

Adorable. Always liked her more than any other singer.

[@nusratshahab1672]

Suman jee ko hamara bouhut payer.

[@shovachatterjee5168]

Wonderful voice 👍👍🌷🌷❤❤

[@shovachatterjee5168]

Really it's a worst politics 😰😰

[@surajitchoudhury8261]

God bless you sumanji .

[@mohamedsultansultan4129]

Suman ji was no second fiddle to lata ji,she had her own unique voice,just ,if not better in fast beat songs

[@arunkumartiwari1863]

सभी प्रतिभाओं होने के बाद,अगर आपके पास किस्मत का साथ नहीं है, तो आप पीछे छूट जाएंगे।😂

[@gurdasrampathak]

Suman ji aap ko koti koti dhanvad

[@anwer.official]

Sab naseeb ki bat hi bhai je.sum kalyan great singar hin.🇵🇰❤🇵🇰❤🇵🇰

[@nileshgala392]

🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹Suman Kalyanpur ji aaj bhi logo ke sanmaniya suprasiddha gayako ki paheli harod mai aati hai unki awaj surmayee aur mithimadhr shreni mai aati hai unke geeto ko jab sunte hai tab wae gaa rahi hai yaa lataji alag nahi kar shakte unko hriday se vandan naman 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@varshapatel8612]

No doubt she was a very good singer but nobody can be Lata Mangeshker. There was a thrilled in Suman ji's singing. Today's singers like Shreya, Alka Yagnic..they are agreed Lata ji is only one, nobody can beat her. So please don't say she ruined someone's singing career.

[@zebyshah6722]

Suman kalyanpur beautiiful lady sweet voice

[@ravishankar-et4ii]

परदे के पीछे से कौन बड़ी गायिका थी जो अब दुनिया में नहीं रही... सुमन कल्याणपुर के करियर को सुनियोजित तरीके से बर्वाद किया गया.

[@gurupmishra8575]

आवाज़ मिलती थी , इस बात से अधिक घातक ये लगा कि स्वर बहुत अधिक सुरीले थे. असल वजह ये थी सारे फसाद की. आप स्वयं सुने और मेरी बात कि तस्दीक करें. सुनिए यह गीत " मन गाये ये तराना , जिसे सुनके आ जाना" या फिर " एक थी निंदिया दो थे नैना , रात कि जाई शाम कि बहना" इतनी मिठास किसी और मेँ नहीं थी.

[@musicastro9743]

I feel so sorry for Suman klyanpur Ji

[@zahidimran7399]

Thank you Afzal Khan for bringing this bitter truth before the audience 👌. I feel sad 4 her as Lata Mangeshkar did not like competitors so she played dirty politics to keep her away from limelight and success.

[@shirishkanhere9134]

this is not fact........did rafiji given own songs to mahendra kapoor ? did salman khan gave own hit films to other heros ? why begging of work from only lata ?????

[@pradeepashtaputre1088]

I do not think that Lataji did not want Sumanji to succeed. Both were greats. I have read an authorised book about her life. She has told that there was no competition between her and Lataji. Both respected each other. I listen to Hindi songs since sixty years. Now I am 71. I admit that at very high pitch, Sumanji's voice vibrated a little. But I admire both.

[@shirishkanhere9134]

thanks for your post........you are alone wise person here. remaining all are fool and just believe false gossips spread on social media by lata haters........

[@geetanjalikekade3641]

​@@shirishkanhere9134really. People unnecessarily shows heatred towards Latadidi.Sumantai also has sung Lots of songs in Marathi as well.Really people are foolishly spreading unwanted things which wise people do not accept & why this gosip? Are these people r that much achiever to criticise Bharat ratna?

[@desigaldesi6028]

I am with you …. Suman used to love LATA and had lot of respect for LATA

[@SumanLondhe-wd4bn]

Lata and Suman both are great singers.I don't compare them to each other.But Lata is not only great singer she is Mata Saraswati.Hira to hira Hota Hai use bplna nahi padta ki Mai hira hun.Kahin bhi chamakta hai. Lata ne kisika career barbad nahi Kiya.Agar unko time nahi rahta to unke liya Music Director rukte the lekin gana unse hi gawate the.Lata hote hue Asha का nam kaise hua? Lata se koi badhkar nahi हो sakta is liye Asha ne gane का style Badal diya aur namaste Kiya.khud ko establish Kiya.koi kisiko Barbad nahi karta. Sumanji bhi bahot acchi singer hai.unke bhi Hindi aur Marathi me bahut sundar Gane hai.famous bhi hue hai.log unko bhi bahut mante hai .

[@surenpaul4615]

Best singers ::Sumanji, shardaji, Sulkshna Pandit

[@diwakarsharma6852]

Maa Sarswati ki Sakshaat Avtaar hai-Sumanji. Unke saath bahut zyada injustice hua.Rafi Sahab ke saath laajwaab,Bemisaal duets gaye. Gayen to sabhi ke saath zaberdast songs per zyada Rafi Sahab ke saath chance mila kuchh had tak. Bhagwaan unhen kabhi muaaf nahin karega jinhone Sumanji ke singing career ko tabaah kiya. A great video! Bhai Sahab.🙏❤️🙏

[@shirishkanhere9134]

fooooooool, due to dispute of lata and rafi......suman ji got chance to sing with rafiji.....why barking that sumanji not get chance ??????????? those who have capcity in own xxxxxx they never beg for work...........

[@gokulchaudhari4163]

किसिकी महानता दूसरे के गंधी रजनितीसे, नही छिपती. अच्छा दुनिया भी जानती है. सुमन कल्याणपूर महानही है.

[@meheboobkhan9398]

Afzal Khan sab hamay pattabhi nahi ke Suman Kalyan pur ka gana hai muze to lataji ki awaz lagatti hai super,

[@chandrasekharsuvarna7106]

Shame on lata,to treat suman in such a way,very sad

[@rgh2164]

She was singing like Lata Mangeshkar. Nobody could distinguish between the voices of these super singers. Yet luck always favoured Lata Mangeshkar. Not to worry. Now onwards, she will be called Suman Mangeshkar,a sister of Lata Mangeshkar.

[@shirishkanhere9134]

suman kalyanpur has one sister.....SHYAMA CHITTAR who is equally good singer like sumanji......here voice was also similar to sumanji............why suman ji not gave her own songs to her sister ?????? why only begging work from lataji ?????????? BHIKAARAN SUMAN

[@mohammadmahmood5127]

अफजल भाई आप ने जो जानकारी श्रीमती सुमन कल्याणपुर जी के बारे में दी उस के लिए में आप का तहेदिल से शुक्रिया अदा करता हूं । लता एक घमंडी गायक थी वोह अपने से आगे किसी गायक को निकलने नही देती थी , क्या हुआ घमंडी गायक का खात्मा हो गया ।अच्छे अच्छे घमंडी मिट गए ।

[@archanajisrivastava544]

👌👌👌👌💯💯👌👌💯

[@debrajratha2172]

Voice of Suman ji is similar to voice of Lata Ji . But signing quality, vocal range and perfectness are not like Lata ji . In some songs Suman ji resembles lata ji. However, there is a heaven and hell difference between singing of lata and suman. Try to imagine, how it would sound if Suman ji sang the song akhiyon ko rehne do of Bobby or jub bhi ji chahe of film daag

[@dr.sattarsheikh3019]

Very sad she did not get a godfather like OP nayyar

[@hitmodi100]

What a sacrifice as great singer! I have not only heard many of her songs mentioned in this episode. I heard her name from my family member. * One important thing, I was familiar that at that time many talented artist or singers have ‘No ENTRY’ because the industry was rule by few ‘MATCHOS’ I apologize to share my true feelings.

[@vedicastrologybyrani1197]

U r so rite👌👌

[@poojajohar8894]

सच कहा है, सच कहना ही चाहिए।

[@shirishkanhere9134]

ha ha ha................what a word used "SACRIFICE", are you mad ????? you know the meaning of sacrifice ????? poor guy you.........lataji was 13 years old when her father expired. she had 4 siblings and mother. Lataji worked as child artist then side heroin's role and at last after 1946 she decided to work as only playback singer. Sumanji left film industry by her own cause........her husband was always present at recording site....he always interferes in the working of sumanji.... suman ji gave more importance to her family and when there is original thing is present and in more better form then the NAKLI (copied) thing will be always kept aside.........i am ready to debate with you............first listen following three songs then we will go ahead 1) koi mere dil me khushi ban ke aaya (film - andaaz 1947) 2) aaja aayi bahar dil hai bekaraar o mere (film rajkumar - 1964) 3) mere khwabome jo aaye aake muze chhed jaaye (film - DDLJ 1994) tell me first song's voice and third songs's voice of lataji match to suman ji's voice ???? only second song's voice is similar of both singers........lataji's career is huge 60+ years.........

[@luminous6810]

Truly i am amazed by her voice truly her voice very much resembles with Lataji there are the possibilities of lataji would have conspire to suppress her voice and fame she might have insecure about her..woh jab Rafi sahab jaise legend se panga le sakti hain to sumanji to kuch bhi nahi.

[@romaroy9492]

Two sisters were very jealous

[@shaikhjabbar1531]

Sumanji is as good as lataji But injustice happened with her

[@siddaiahrukmini8771]

If producer n director select Latha Mangeshkar,it is not Latha's fault,it is producer n directors fault.

[@vickyjohn4489]

abhe maderchod tera takre ka phone jata tha wo randi lata ko le bolke

[@poojajohar8894]

दबाव देती थी।

[@shirishkanhere9134]

well said...........most producers......lyricists , music directors.....heroins like madhubala, meena kumari....nargis gave preference to lataji...........some heroins signs the film with condition that their songs will be only recorded by lataji

[@shirishkanhere9134]

@@poojajohar8894 आप अपने छोटे से दिमाग पे ज्यादा दबाव मत दिजीए, फट जायेगा, फिल्म इंडस्ट्री profession है कोई खैरात नहीं, सुमन जी खुद घर पे बैठी रही 40 सालोसे, अब वो नहीं गाती, पब्लिक के सामने भी नहीं आती तो कोई क्या कर सकता है ? Media पे सुनी सुनायि बाते मत लिजीए, अपना दिमाग का उपयोग करे

[@sainathkitchen4130]

भाई साहब बडी देर हो गई

[@minakshizodgekar2625]

Ajhun aaye balama sawan bita jaye ye gana sumanjine gaya

[@naheedparveen8264]

Sumanji aapki masum surath ki tarah hi aapki aawaz badi meerhi pyary aur dilkash hai.Hasad jalan se bhari is duniyane aapki pyary pyary aawaz ko dabadiya.phirbhi khaymath tak aapki aawaz goonjte rahegi. Dushman bhi sunte rahenge.

[@tanvibansode9765]

Great voice of sumanji ❤❤❤❤❤ dirty tricks very bad

[@keshavjoshi2824]

No doubt Sumanji is one of the finest singers we have ever heard. I am also a fan of Sumanji's voice and as a Maharastrian, I owe her a lot because she has sung so many beautiful Marathi film and non-filmy songs. But I don't personally agree that Lata Mangeshkar was solely responsible for Sumanji's not getting the credit which she richly deserved. Its unfortunate that Lataji was singing splendidly at the same time. Its like Padmakar Shivalkar and Rajinder Goyal didn't get the chance to play Test cricket for India because Bishensingh Bedi was playing for the Country. Fortune and Destiny are things nobody can escape and this applies to everyone .Sumanji is no exception. One mistake I would like to point out, ' rahe na rahe hum ' is sung by Lata Mangeshkar and not Suman Kalyanpur.

[@shamiechitoe2982]

There is a duet song of rehe na re ham of Rafi saheb and Suman ji in the film.

[@keshavjoshi2824]

@@shamiechitoe2982 is that so ? I don't remember .Request to check it again. Its a solo song sung by Lataji

[@shamiechitoe2982]

@@keshavjoshi2824 yes. Just write rehe na rehe ham duet song on youtube ok.

[@keshavjoshi2824]

@@shamiechitoe2982 OK. Thanks. Will check.

[@anikethsinha1947]

​@@keshavjoshi2824yes there's a duet between Rafi sahab and Suman ji.

[@letstoorandtravel7430]

Saari kharabi buraee ki jad. ۔. Hashad Jelousy Irsiya jalan . ۔. ۔Aaj bhi is ki vaja se is ka natija bhugat rahe hayn

[@AnilRajguru-zh9rd]

Aisehi Assam ke munmi Bora ekdin gum ho goie thi jinhone koi hindi filmo me aapni sureli awaj me gakor tehalka masa dia tha .

[@jagdishjaiswal1985]

भाई क्लियर करें रहें ना रहें सुमन जी ने गया या फिर लता ने

[@savitrinagar1785]

आवाज़ अलग है लता मंगेशकर की आवाज बहुत ज्यादा सुरीली है लता सुर कोकिला है

[@savitashinde6036]

Naseeb apna apna

[@savitashinde6036]

Kalawati maa unki badi nanand hain. Bahut achcha sasural unhe mila. Aur unke husband jinhone unhe har dam saath diya.

[@shirishkanhere9134]

her husband ruined her career..............he is culprit who ruined her life..............he always remains and interfere during recording..............film industry never accepted this and kicked out sumaj Begger from industry

[@GanePurane]

क्यु ऐसी बात सुनेंगे संगीतकार? वो अपनी पसंद गायिकाको चुनेंगेही इतना तो तय है|अभी हालही मे इंडीया टुडे पर आशाताई भोसले का इंटरव्ह्यू देखा|वो केहती है की उन्होने अपने गाने का स्टाईल बदला.शांत गाने तो पेहलेसेही दुसरी गाईकाएं गा रही थी. उन्हे छोडकर लोग आशा भोसले को कैसे गाने देते?इसलिये आशाजी ने अलग गाने गाना शुरु किया और अपनी पेहचान अलग बनाई.ऐसेमे ये केहना कीतना सही है की लता मंगेशकरकी वजहसे सुमन कल्याणपूर को जादा गाने नही मिले?

[@syedabdulwajidwajid8021]

suman kalyanpurke sath film lndustry walone tasub barta

[@atiparamshoonyapaar4440]

Daring presentation - good research - aapne aatma se is behad shaleen gaayika ke oopar dhaye gaye zamaane bhar ke sitam ko bayaan kiya hai Manushya prajaati ekmaatr is prithvi grah par jo - kuch bhi acha ho kisi "aur" Ke pass usko falne foolne dene ke bajai - sab is koshish me lag jaate ke - asli talent aur asli talented ko kuchal diya jaaye - sirf isliye ke unke is prithvi grah me koi mai baap - godfather nahi Har ore - har jagah - behad ghinauna bhaagam bhaag - yahan kuch log kuch bhi anokha alag acha kiye bagair anaadi kaalon ke liye ek naye god bhi khud ko maan lete aur auron ko bhi manwa dete Aur kuch aise bhi - aseemit asankhya ache karam auron ke bhalai me apna ekmaatr poora jeevan khapa dete - aur unko wahi log - nashukre beneficiaries - madad haasil karne wale hi - unhi logon ke saath milke thikaane lagaa dete - jin soshakon se is "satya purush" ne in majboor bheed ko bachaya Is prithvi grah me na kabhi nyay tha - na hai - na kabhi hona Sirf - ekmaatr - nidhan hai - mahapralay - jo hoke hi rahna bahut jald : jisme har manushya lothde ko aseemit behad bure dhang se bhugtan karna - shareer aur dimaag bilkul aksham ho jaana - sara paap dimaag, zubaan ka hai - aur yah paap sirf aur sirf manushya prajaati karta aa raha - prakriti kudrat ab duniya bhar me mahapralay ka minimicro trailer dikha raha - bhooskhalan, baadh, jangalon me forest fires, rock avalanches, vayu pradushan, dhwani pradushan, jal pradushan, bhoochaal.. Aise 666 behad bheeshan kudrati traasadiyaan - bahut raftaar se badte hi jaana aane wale har pal chin kshan Jitna jaldi poora manushya {maanav, insaan tho kharbon me koi ek sadiyon me ho paata apne purushaarth se} A'sabhyata {maanav sabhyata shabd hi mazaak - ganghor mazaak} sampoorn roop se hamesha hamesha ke liye is haalat me pahuncha diya jaaye ke har manushya ko apna hi shareer aur dimaag bhaari bhoj lagne lage jeevan ke har pal : aur paap ko poshit karne wale srishti aur prithvi grah hi kisi laayak na rah jaayen Tabhi tak - virle achon ko dukh sahna jhelna Nidhan - sirf apocalypse - qayamat - Mahapralay Hoke hi rahna - Satya - ache chahe ek do hi hon poore prithvi grah me unke sankalp - anant aur SATYA ka param jeet ka daur chal nikla hai - aur SATYA - MAHAPRALAY ka swaroop roop me - abse pragat hote hi rahna - Jab tak woh poorna Asatya - maane - drishya srishti, prithvi grah, manushya a'sabhyata ko - aise haalat me laakar na khada kar de - ke yahin NARAK ka swaad sabhi ko bhogna padega - hamesha hamesha ke liye ETERNAL HELL - right in this seen existence - earth planet forever

[@surenpaul4615]

लता ने बहुत गायिकाओं के बरबाद किया है ,सुरक्षा पंडित,शारदाजी भी शिकार हूई

[@santoshsharma-sb5fi]

अगर नूरजहां भारत छोडकर पाकिस्तान ना जाती तो ये लता का कोई वजूद ही नहीं होता। मुझे नाना पाटेकर का एक डायलॉग याद आ रहा है कि जब वो अपने दोस्त मजनू से कहते हैं कि, ये शरीफ लोग बहुत बदमाश होते हैं। अब आप समझ जाओ।

[@vilasnarayane4238]

Suman kalyanpur ji par bohot anyay huaa hai

[@letstoorandtravel7430]

Banner Artist R. Gajjar Ahmedabad ko saayad log nahin jaante un ke banner se flop filmen bhi theater me chalti thin esa gajab art thaa ke bas dekhte raho 80 tak ki movies jinhon ne Gujrat me dekhi hongi unhenn yaad hoga gaye gujre artist naam kar gaye or R. Gajjar one of great artist gumnaam hay ye hay dunia ki asliyat

[@janardankuwar3609]

Film industri ke jde jitne khodoge utna kala niklega.

[@syedabdulwajidwajid8021]

Suman kalyanpur se hasad tha film lndustry waloko

[@josephkumar6200]

THEIR VOICES R SIMILAR REPEAT SIMILAR ONLY,IF AT ALL ANY DIFFERENCE IS THR IT IS ONLY 1 OR 2 PERCENT WHICH IS IGNORABLE.BOTH OF THEM HAD GOLDEN VOICE. HOWEVER WHEN IT COMES TO VARIATION IN VOICE NOBODY CAN BEAT ASHAJI & GEETHAJI.TKS

[@ashializade4748]

لطفن زیر نویس انگلیسی یا فارسی بگذارید

[@sayedakbar6411]

SUMAN KALYANPURI ki aaj bhi izzat hai, Suman ne kabhi kisi se shikaet nahi ki, Lata to apni bahen Asha ki bhi dushman thi, O.P.Nayyar se ladai ke baad phir kabhi O.P. Nayyar ne Lata ko nahi gawaya, wo sirf Asha se hi gawatey rahey, Nayyar jaisa chahtey they Lata bilkul bhi nahi ga sakti thi phir Nayyar ne Asha Bhisle ko shurat ke aasman par baitha dia tha.

[@shirishkanhere9134]

....apnaa dimaag lagaa le na........lataji ke dispute ki vajah se naa jaane kitne singers ko chance mila.............lataji ke ahesaan maan lo.............dispute with shankar jaykishan, dispute with SD burman, dispute with raj kapoor, dispute with C ramchandra

[@RAMNARESHVISHWKARMA-dy6iz]

साथियों सुमनजी शमशाद बेगम की तरह खुले दिल की सिंगर रही हैं शमशाद के समय कोई था नहीं आई भी तो बहुत बाद में लता गायिका तो अच्छी थी मगर दिल की दुष्ट औरत थी तभी तो सुमन से राजनीति करी।

[@prnmt123]

.., hame to nafrat ho gayi hai .... Uska sunta hi nhi ... sirf Suman ji ka sunta hu.

[@user-vt4kf2nb3g]

sahi me dust aurat thi ranu mandal ne jab lata ke geet ko gakar famous huyi thi tab unko bahut bura laga tha. mujhe to samajh nahi ki kis adhar pe unko bharat ratna diya gaya. bollywood me pakshpat bahut hota hai award dene ke mamle me bhi

[@vikasdalvi2236]

Kuch bhi mat bol

[@RatnaGosavi02]

दुष्ट औरत ??? क्या व्यक्तिगत रूप से आप उन्हें कई बार मिल चुके हैं या फिर आप उनके करीबी रिश्तेदार हैं ?

[@RatnaGosavi02]

तुम जैसों की नफ़रत आदि...करने से क्या लता दीदी जैसी अद्वितीय गानकोकिला की शान में कोई फर्क पडने वाला है ?? बेशक सुमन कल्याणपुरजी भी एक बेहतरीन गायिका हैं।

[@anjanabanerjee1452]

Sumankalyanji. Se. Humara. Bahat. Pyarhae. Par. Hum. Bengalees. Ko. Bahat. Jyada. Gourab. Hae. Ke. Sumanji. Bangalme. Janamliye. And. 15. Saltak. East. Bengalme. Rahe. Jaese. Geeta Roychowdhury. Ovi. Same ageke thi sumanjike. Donoko pranam

[@sathyasaibaba1000]

These are all BAKWAAS. Even a Thousand Suman Kalyanpurs, Asha Bhosles, Noor Jahans, Vani Jairams, Samshad Begums, Suraiyas CANNOT Make Even 0.001% of the Saraswati LATA MANGESHKAR

[@kalptambe6193]

It is not true that suman Ji is as great voice as lata ji and asha ji..... They both sisters have great versatility ... And that's why mostly they both were first choice of directors... And if you notice than you realise that the difference between quality of voice... Suman ji had melody voice... But not saptasuri.... But mangeshkar sisters had....

[@prnmt123]

Baat tab banegi jab sirf or sirf Suman ji ke hi gane baje .... Maine to apni car me unhi ka gana bajata hu .... Facts janne ke baad Lata ki awaz to ab Kan me garam tel ki trha lgta hai ....

[@minakshizodgekar2625]

Mahamad rafiko bhi lata dominate karati thi rafijike sathbhi aise karati thi