Herr Mannelig - Garmarna

[@AdjutantReflex0]

Troll:"I'm just going to ask him, the worst he can say is 'no'." Herr Mannelig: 4:15

[@AdjutantReflex0]

@@arawn1061 I know, in Deutsch it's essentially Mr. That's just how he's referred to bro

[@Nimai_Aquino]

I had to end a relationship with a girlfriend because I converted, the conversation went basically like this music. Sad day, but one of the best decisions I made in my life.

[@crusaderACR]

@@Nimai_Aquino God will reward you for that

[@Nimai_Aquino]

@@crusaderACR already did my friend, in a way a couldn’t even imagine back then. The graces he sent upon my life far surpass that small sacrifice.

[@LePetitNRVN]

He isn't wrong

[@SwordTune]

Troll: Marry me, yes or no? The worst you can say is no, after all. Mannelig: Never, you disgusting child of the devil!

[@mkultravictimbf]

I love our flag, that golden Cross juxtaposed to the blue background. There is actually a legend behind it. During St. Erik IX's crusade against the finns, he is to have seen a golden Cross in the sky as a sign (much like St. Constantine).

[@cayocasiolonginos]

Swedish flag was always my favourite. Peace be with you from Spain.

[@herrakaarme]

It's jolly good all Nordic countries have similar flags, only with different colours used. Maybe I'm biased, living under such a flag, but I find it more interesting than the bicolor and tricolor band type flags more common in Europe.

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

pff thats the legend of SCOTLAND flag!

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

@@herrakaarme fucking tri color those aree the flags of the masons! frist one was the francistani

[@cayocasiolonginos]

@@herrakaarme Spanish flag was created in XVIII century mainly to identify our ships from other nations

[@macbrodernbror3271]

To clarify “troll” refers to any magical being, in this case a witch, and not a stereotypical troll.

[@simoncejka9121]

I read under another video that it was also used for pagans

[@vseslavkazakov356]

@@simoncejka9121 Troll is a mythical being described as being bigger than a human and being malicious and ugly and living in the mountains. It was later used as a metaphor for pagans but it doesn't literally mean "pagan"

[@cpt7752]

@@simoncejka9121 no

[@GeorgeLCostnza]

@@simoncejka9121 I call pagans trolls all the time. Totally checks out.

[@reedolfkekler7860]

@@simoncejka9121 in other versions the mountain troll is a forest nymph or a neck (thick river or lake siren)

[@AtariAlive]

God Bless You All through these hard times. Deus Vult, and AVE MARIA!

[@OG_Ricky_C]

Amen

[@elemperadordemexico]

Thank God its been a long time

[@camperiv1]

YES!! I am a Swedish catholic, and I have listened to this song a countless amount of times. I got to discover it through a monk really.

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

gunslinger jesuit real manly killing protestant slavers in brazil

[@IsaRedcup]

Hard to believe there are still Christians in Sweden. God bless you!

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

@@IsaRedcup greetings

[@NatJune]

God bless you!🙌🏻

[@vinnie2874]

andra svenska katoliken jag hitta

[@exmachina3389]

As a Swedish speaker, i noticed there are some wrong meaning. 1.För det jag bjuder så gärna doesnt mean (for that I would gladly offer you gifts) it would be more accurate " because i want to offer you very gladly."There are no gifts mentioned in that sentence. She says that she REALLY REALLY wants to offer him to marry her. 2. Som klingar utaf femton guldringar doesnt mean that it" sounds like fifteen gold rings" it is made of fifteen gold rings so "klingar" which is referred to when keys make noise so when sword hits the floor it makes that noise. It doesnt sound like fifteen gold rings, it is MADE out of 15 gold rings. 3. "Her mouth full of lies" this sentence i would say could be correctly translated. But if we translated it exactly like it is written (hon hade en falskeliger tunga) it would be "she had a false tongue". But it could be translated into mouth full of lies.

[@kingrichardiii6280]

loved this folk song, especially this rendition. but not sure how to interpret it. the first half of the song paints the troll a deceitful. untrustworthy, figure and reinforces that by how the knight rejects her. but when the troll cries out she said "her plight would be over" as if he had loved her she would not be foul and deceitful. Is she a demonic monster trying to lead the knight to peril or repentant and wishing to be loved?

[@moritamikamikara3879]

@user-pd1uc1ce9e If you were to ask me it just sounds like a Christian man rejecting a pagan woman who was lonely and wealthy. The pagan wanted to marry the Christian so that she would be accepted back into society and not ostracized for her paganism, but Herr Mannelig refuses because he is a principled Christian and believes it's wrong to marry a pagan.

[@marvalice3455]

​@@kingrichardiii6280 just because she says "her plight would be over" doesn't mean it's true.

she paints him as a hated man who is to be fought. it's a woman who blames him for her anger and thinks badgering will get her what she wants. if she gets what she wants, she'll stop trying. the troll tells her this but she insists

[@CantosCruzados]

Salve Maria! Essa interpretação é lindíssima, vou tentar trazer para cá também. Parabéns pelo trabalho.

[@RenanGuilherme-xn5gj]

Para de conversar consigo mesmo cara.

[@douglascmreis]

Aí sim meu consagrado! Isso é o que eu chamo de Presente de Natal!! E que Presentão!! Salve Maria Imaculada e Viva Cristo Rei!

[@andre_cinelli]

@@RenanGuilherme-xn5gj deixa ele com as esquizofrenias dele, ele é foda, então tá liberado.

[@pablor.l.3359]

kkkk

[@ludwigramirez1047]

@@RenanGuilherme-xn5gj No te proyectes en otros.

[@NorwoodingSkullMask]

Melody: epic Lyrics: even more epic

[@raian6896]

It pleases me to finally hear something in my language on this channel. Ave Christus Rex, my prayers are with you all my catholic brothers and sisters.

[@secolulnostru7457]

Du är svensk?

[@kurtph6286]

Är du från Sverige?

[@secolulnostru7457]

@@kurtph6286 Nei jag är från Tyskland men jag snakker norsk och lit svensk

[@august5135]

this song is about a dude banging a which, the least catholic thing ever

[@ludwigramirez4711]

@@secolulnostru7457 Ich verstehe dich.

[@borichamo]

The King of Catholic music is back

[@chris.3069]

@Wilhelm Monke medieval sweden was not protestant though.

[@chris.3069]

@Wilhelm Monke its setting takes place in medieval sweden

[@neilwhitaker6284]

I am not a Catholic myself but love this channel. There are A LOT of issues with most Protestant Churches but to be fair with the Catholic Church at present time as well. I see a lot of dead ends and half truths in my own Protestant Church experiences and seek out teaching from my brothers in Christ whether they be Catholic, Orthodox or Protestant. In my opinion there is one true Church and the western world has gone horribly off course centuries before my birth. I don't have all the answers for you today but I learn a lot through this channel and much solace, hope and comfort in the songs he posts. Blessings in Christ.

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

@Wilhelm Monke ugh protestant modernist puritan? good those good yanks! not like now

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

@@neilwhitaker6284 Which church has (and uses) the oldest traditions? I heard from one that they say is still in the dark ages

[@ja-vishaara]

Trolls have been real quiet since this dropped

[@UnreconstructedYT]

Beautiful song and wonderful job as always!

[@camperiv1]

Another great Swedish 'medieval' ballad: Kung Erik och spåkvinnan by Sågskära

[@volusian95]

This whole album rules, Guds Spelmän by Garmarna

[@augustusmortuus235]

I didn't knew that song from this very deep Christian meaning. God bless to you!

[@PeterAndel44]

Yes i’ve been waiting so long for an upload!

[@felipedejesusalarconjaime6427]

-Beta Troll begs for Sigma to marry her -Promices riches and glory -Honestly wants to be with him -Sigma rejects her, calling her disgusting -Refuses to elaborate

[@lao-lao7296]

Sir Sigmannelig

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

tacos corona chelas

[@ahumanfromtexas]

She doesn't honestly want to be with him, as it says in the song, her mouth is full of lies

[@felipedejesusalarconjaime6427]

@@ahumanfromtexas but she goes away weeping when rejected, she may be telling lies, but maybe she truly wants to be with him, at least that's what I got out of the song

[@goodbanter4427]

@@felipedejesusalarconjaime6427 She's not weeping because of rejected love, she's weeping because without a Christian man any chance of salvation is lost: her reason of weeping is selfish. As the troll said: ''Had I managed to get that handsome young man, my plight would surely end''. And as Louis above has said as well, ''her mouth was full of lies.''

[@Aldrnari]

Just to add a little nuance, for those of you who can't understand Swedish: When the troll-woman runs away at the end crying, a more literal translation of what she says is that if she had been able to get the young man, she would have been able to avoid her (future) torment; this suggests that she understands that eternal punishment awaits her, but she thought that she could avoid it by seducing and marrying a Christian man---which is not really how it works, but you can't blame her for trying, I guess!

[@HolkHugan]

The Christian man in question had resolve, so he could've converted her and saved a soul from eternal damnation, instead of condemning her for being born into a tribe of pagans.

[@sudonim7552]

I think the thing is, trolls are believed to have no souls, as they are not human, so they wouldn't have eternal torment but eternal nothingness after death, but by marrying a human they could gain a soul and have eternal life. Unfortunately they try to do this through deception and bribery rather than a genuine desire to love or repent. They don't have eternal souls like humans, after all, only an earthly mind. They are more like very intelligent animals in that regard.

[@La_regina_joiosa]

@@sudonim7552 How else was she supposed to convince him to marry her if she is an ugly troll?!

[@joepetto9488]

@@sudonim7552being a sub five and a woman is torment enough. Also trolls have souls but they don’t go to the afterlife of men. We don’t know where they go. Probably they will re emerge after the world is remade in a more perfect form and they will have to contend with unfallen man.

[@chinchilla415]

@@joepetto9488 Are you kidding? A sub 5 woman will still get a bf, no problems. It's just that she won't get a top 5% men which all women these days feel entitled to.

[@borichamo]

May God grant us the grace to stand strong against temptation and restore all things in Christ!

[@achilles_groyper]

Missed these from Ex Cathedra, glad to see another beautiful song posted.

[@Pretoriman]

*Magnifique !!! Cette chanson m'a transportée !*

[@heofnorenown]

The most notable thing about this song is that it’s the antithesis of all modern storytelling, any modern writer, no matter who, would have the protagonist end up with the exotic non-human, it’s embarrassingly predictable. We are truly blessed to have this channel as a sanctuary of music in a sea of degradation.

[@imeantherearethedarktownsy5210]

God, you're pathetic. It's comical.

[@Lanadi669]

Can you please elaborate!

[@miguelbrandao6705]

The fact you’re right. I’m African but I swear certain people have an Anti-Human agenda.

[@Rubbe87]

@@Lanadi669 no

[@Juan_Jose_Miraballes]

"sea of degradation" WTF

[@zhongxina7366]

Herr Mannelig is a GigaChad

[@arawn1061]

Mr Mannelig

[@Österrikiskkonstnär]

Herr Mannelig is not simping for anyone but the fairest of maidens.

[@memorarenz]

Welcome back my dude. Great stuff. You and your family remain in my prayers, I hope your grief is less. Mary Queen of Victory, pray for us!

[@astarfilmes]

Meu Deus que música linda! Tinha escutado ela a bastante tempo, obrigado por me lembrar de sua beleza novamente.

[@edugalvon]

You're back! God bless, pax et bonum!!

[@alexandercellante7553]

You posted! I rejoice!! I rejoice!!

[@kakalimukherjee3297]

Herr Mannelig: We do a little trolling

[@gloriapatri1542]

I would love to see 'Gott erhalte Franz den Kaiser' on this channel one day. 👍

[@jakublubocki7998]

I think,that "Gott Erhälte,Gott beschütze" would be better as more universalist (first version speak about only one emperor,last-about all history of Austrian-Hungarian Monarchy). Very greetings for you,my Christian brother from young Cashubian monarchist. Viva Christus Rex!

[@gloriapatri1542]

@@jakublubocki7998 Very good idea! In that case... Let's hope that we shall see both songs on this channel one day in glory of Holy Roman Empire! God will establish the monarchy once more in due time my friend. In the meantime, we must stand strong and become counter-revolutionary against the woes of this modern secular society. Remember to pray to St. Anthony for the restoration of the monarchy and keep lively my friend. The world might seem adrift, but good things are coming for Gods people. Peace to you and Viva Cristo Rei! From portuguese monarchist.

[@XYZasw]

The song is simply amazing. Just the sound or rather the "feeling" of words is a pure pleasure (but maybe it's just an exotic of it for someone who comes from the family of slavic languages). Anyway, I remember that when I heard it for the first time I was really concerned if it's some pagan song that could be dangerous for the soul. But when I read the text I liked it even more. But for me the main melody, will be always an "Old Camp" from Gothic 1...

[@luizumhumano7111]

Hello brother, you can tell me If listen musics of other religions is Sin?

[@XYZasw]

@@luizumhumano7111 in my opinion it's not a sin per se, but it comes with some danger. Especially if it's not just some neutral music but created by someone with different faith (for example Bach) but music created for religious purposes. The most obvious example is satanist music which was created to worship demons. But I think there is a lot of danger in pagan music too. Also the protestant songs brings a lot of danger but in a different way. They seem to worship the God but they can also mix truth with some minor lies. So, as I said it's not a sin but we should keep in mind that everything we listen to, watch, read etc. has some influence on us and in long term can lead us to false.

[@luizumhumano7111]

@@XYZasw got it, i'll try to avoid it then but i really like some islamic songs lol, thanks for answering me

[@Leonardo-bj6zy]

No you're right it is pure pleasure even to my english speaking ears

[@arawn1061]

What is wrong with the music of the old gods?

[@American-Orthodox-Christian]

This is a good band I'm glad you shared this song.

[@empiresoftheeast203]

Good luck in your studies and work. Thanks for the upload!

[@elixexo4011]

I LOVE GARMARNA THANKS FOR POSTING THIS.

[@kevin8712]

Never had much interest in this specific song, until today. Greetings from the only Christian / Catholic nation in Asia. (Philippines)

[@Gabpt]

Dont Forget Timor Leste

[@kevin8712]

@@Gabpt And our Caucasian brothers Georgia and Armenia. And our Mediterranean cousin Cyprus.

[@hubert8438]

@@kevin8712 Georgia and Armenia are mainly heretic. According to wikipedia, sadly, only 0,8% of population in Georgia is Catholic and 7,3% in Armenia.

[@hubert8438]

@@kevin8712 Cyprus also, roughly 2%.

[@ludwigramirez1047]

@@kevin8712 Not Georgia and Armenia. Those are schismatic and heretical.

[@gabrielcrocherie291]

Incroyable ! Merci 💪

[@lao-lao7296]

Sir Mannelig the Chad

[@chrisaustin7644]

A Christ soldier

[@yennazvengerbergu5742]

Mannelig means just man or male, its not his surname or sth xd

[@maxpayne3332]

Wunderschön! And Absolutly based 👌🏻

[@samuelnicholes]

This version sounds so cool! Thank you so much for posting! Fun fact: I performed in a community musical version of a Swedish folktale called "The Flower of Sunnymount Crest". The opening song that I sang was this tune with different lyrics.

[@isaacarias617]

Simpre me ha parecido muy hermosa está canción católica Escandinava y el idioma Sueco le da su encanto :^) Es bonito saber que aunque actualmente el Cristianismo Católico ya no sea la mayoría en el país Suecia aún posee a su comunidad católica como también el legado de está que queda impregnada en la cultura y folklore de la nación 🇸🇪✝️❤

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

ese lugar ya es holanda F

[@johnnotrealname8168]

This is a Catholic song?

[@torbjorneriksson6928]

@@johnnotrealname8168 Yes. When this song was first written Scandinavians were still Catholics. Swedes converted to Lutheranism when king Gustav I Vasa became Lutheran. His descendant Gustavus Adolphus was one of the most devout Lutherans.

[@torbjorneriksson6928]

@j Yes. Birger Jarl and his men who made up the invasion force going to Finland were all devout Catholics.

[@FirstNameLastName-is6yb]

@@torbjorneriksson6928 Read Characters of the Reformation by Belloc, he has a very interesting take on Gustavos Adolphus's piety. He was apparently paid by a French Cardinal to press his war against the Habsburgs so France would remain the most powerful and respected Catholic nation.

[@yodenheim647]

so powerful and comfortable. im in awe

[@natoman123]

Very beautiful

[@intergalactichumanempire9759]

There are 150,000 Catholics in Sweden, as of 2013. Pray for them, and pray that their numbers will swell!

[@overlord165]

Thanks!

[@camperiv1]

We have many young people converting nowadays, and a huge chunk of them are attending TLM. There is hope for our beloved, but oh so fallen, nation.

[@Gladdig]

I doubt more than a tenth are natives.

[@overlord165]

@@Gladdig So?

[@camperiv1]

@@Gladdig Oh for sure. But I think amount of natives are growing. Many of the culturally catholic with immigrant parents are sadly leaving the Church.

[@justuswimmer306]

Quite fitting if you think about the situation in modern Scandinavia. But one can still hope and pray

[@andre_cinelli]

Belíssima obra, que as terras hiperboréas do norte da Europa voltem a santa sé e a Roma.

[@instaurareomniainchristo777]

Thanks for sharing this beautiful scandinavian song !

[@andrewgarcia7513]

Awesome 💯💯💯 I love the purity.

[@espanadorada7962]

Oh man I love this song, thanks for posting :)

[@abdo4250]

"the worst he could've said was no"

[@СрбјеХристоврадујесесмрти]

Okay, i didnt knew this song have highly christian context,now its even more beautiful! Christ is king ☦✝

[@AlphaWolf789]

doesn't need to be christian to be beautiful no offense

[@em9361]

@@AlphaWolf789 truth is beauty tho

[@fritzs1207]

yes !!! content for subjecting and converting Nordic locals to a desert god . Down hill ever-since

[@СрбјеХристоврадујесесмрти]

@@fritzs1207 "huh, desert God" He's God of all lands and deserts also...

[@fritzs1207]

@@СрбјеХристоврадујесесмрти that is the great and only one Odin

[@carloscosta1036]

No simping

[@homero_con_lechuguilla]

Chad Alpha Herr Mannelig rejects a troll

[@jackh337]

I absolutely adore this channel and the work you do in making these videos that share not just great music but also the translation. A lot of of great artists are featured on here, who I would like to hear more of. Could you add information to the video description on where to find the original performers? I understand if not, with the oddities of KZbin rules and all.

[@afrim7244]

Amazing song! Respect brothers, from albania! Ad maiorem dei gloriam

[@shaunvernonkenney]

Glad you guys are back!

[@Renault07]

Loved this. More Catholic/Medieval Scandinavian pieces plz

[@eemmiill201]

One of my favorite songs. Greetings from a Swedish Lutheran 🇸🇪✝️

[@johnisaacfelipe6357]

my brother, when will you return to us?

[@iiitrifle9895]

@@johnisaacfelipe6357 AMEN!!!

[@ludwigramirez4711]

Convert to Catholicism. Lutheranism is what ruined Sweden.

[@HNUmaker]

Herr Mannelig ain’t no simp

[@anaga6049]

Herr Mannelig sigma male confirmed.

[@zentralratderumherschweife1218]

> be me, troll femanon > desperately need christian husband or my soul will literally be lost after i die > see qt knight, easily 9/10 > idea exe > will ask him to marry me > worst case, he says no, right? > approach him > really nervous, sweating buckets > autism exe > "hey, this might be weird, but do you want to marry me? I'll even gift you a bunch of shit haha" > akward silence > he just stares at me > get even more nervous > "s-so, what is it? Just say yes or no!" > he starts laughing > calls me a disgusting mountain troll > calls me a filthy pagan > i run away, bawling my eyes out, his laughter still ringing in my ears > run home > just want to turn to stone what now anons?

[@oggabooga2495]

Anon should go get some tendies to forget.

[@Monster-b8z]

>"had you been a christian woman"

[@raiyantalukder6807]

Dyeth thine hair azure

[@dronite0019]

>femanon You know the rule, tits or gtfo.

[@CJVS995]

Go to a church and convert & repent then go to him.

[@GeneralKaleRan]

Me when the purple haired girl tries to take me to her place

[@duckaduck3608]

Great Analysis and explanation of the theme as always ex Bishop. I think I might write a paper expanding your theme for my Philosophy/ethics thesis. Musical And lyrical theory is an underrated, Enjoyable gift that God has given us. Encourages my gratefulness to the Lord our God even further.

[@vinnie2874]

im a swedish catholic

[@magic-panda-eyes7737]

Same brother, God bless and stay strong because we are few.

[@skanderberg8701]

@@magic-panda-eyes7737 why few? Are there more atheists?

[@magic-panda-eyes7737]

@@skanderberg8701 basically there are more protestant/athiest than catholics in sweden, we are a growing minority and grow 1-2% each year. For now we are 150000 catholics in sweden. 150000 is a big minority by sweden only being ten million in population.

[@skanderberg8701]

@@magic-panda-eyes7737 ohk. Will pray for sweden

[@carolusmagnus9346]

hi swedish catholic, iam dad

[@Povest1389]

I love my catholic brothers, from Serbia! 🇷🇸

[@em9361]

A Catholic Serb? Based

[@Povest1389]

@@em9361 I'm Orthodox Christian, but i have ancestors who were catholic Serbs. They were lower nobility from Dalmatia, one of leaders of Morlachs, irregulars who were mercenaries for Venetian republic and protected it against Turkish raids and Ottoman Empire in overall. Greetings brother and God bless you.

[@Povest1389]

@@ludwigramirez1047 I don't support any kind of chauvinistic stance towards Croats. I love my country and i don't hate others.

[@ludwigramirez4711]

@@Povest1389 That's better. Serbs and Croatians, even if most won't admit it, are one people.

[@ipc8255]

@@ludwigramirez4711 There's nothing to be admitted - Croatians and Serbians are two different people by the very DNA, culture, civilization in general.

[@thehussarsjacobitess85]

This is chillingly timely, as I've just heard of yet another husband and his children being abandoned by the feminist woman he had chosen to marry. We all owe it to our children to ascertain, first and foremost, that our spouses are virtuous, pious people.

[@Troglodyted]

This is amazing!

[@camperiv1]

Trolls are a facinating concept in medieval folklore. It is believed after the fall of the angels who became demons, some were sent to earth and took a material form. One of these are trolls, who stole men's children because of their jealousy that men can attain eternal salvation.

[@em9361]

Oh, thank you for sharing this. I am also thinking they are nephilim

[@joeljanssonhernstrom1819]

What? Trolls are evil nature spirits, where have you gotten this information from?

[@kirgan1000]

Troll are from the viking age Nose folklore.

[@RealAugustusAutumn]

I've known about this song for years but I never knew it was a Christian one!!

[@KitsuPaintsMaps]

you are back!!!

[@ludgeriusgiovanni9393]

Sad when you think of modern-day Sweden. Saint Erik Pray for us!

[@AlphaDaxter1]

what's wrong with modern day Sweden

[@AlphaDaxter1]

@j what are Lutherans

[@beskow1500]

​@@alexie832 No, the real problem is that there aren't any Man left in sweden

[@musicAle77]

@@beskow1500 in what sense? There are becoming more weak men?

[@jhroomy]

@@AlphaDaxter1 Have you seen all the country ball jokes about Sweden being gay? Thats one problem with modern day Sweden perhaps. And mix that with the lack of faith that can be seen all over Europe except for Poland so far.

[@manueldg1276]

Always thought that the troll was a allegory for a pagan noblewoman.

[@unesgang79]

trollkarl in swedish means male magician (karl by itself means man) so troll is magician/witch.

[@NjamNjam0]

Thats actually a smart way to look at it. By this time I know troll in this context stands for mage but I didn't see it that way. Thank you for this perspective.

[@arawn1061]

@K. N. Vi gör nalta trolleri

[@romainvicta3076]

Ironically I thought this song was originally a Pagan Viking one. How wrong am i ! - It's origin is on a christian man refusing to marry a troll because she is not christian.

[@seamuswbiggerarmalite3379]

shes a demon not many things can be worse than that

[@OggeViking]

There are no songs preserved from viking times.

[@romainvicta3076]

@@OggeViking This is not necessarily true. Poems were often sung and were the songs of the time. Völuspá is one example - beowulf i'm sure was another

[@OggeViking]

@@romainvicta3076 We don't know that for sure either. What we can say for sure is that our main source (Poetic Edda) is from medieval times, and the rest is based on speculation. Beowulf on the other hand, is most likely older. But we still don't know if it was sung or if it was popular by any means. So I'm taking your claim of being "sure" of something with a grain of salt. I'll rather listen to the scholarly consensus and their debates.

[@romainvicta3076]

@@OggeViking yes you are right ; but it could be a good possibility considering theatre and the long tradition of singing that goes along with it in alot of cultures. Its not out of the realm of reality

[@narrare.di.storia]

Grazie from Italy 😊👏

[@svatymartinus8862]

Which of you lads had come here, knowing the song from gothic 1, not even knowing what it is abbout? I certainly did!

[@james_poika3186]

This song sounds like a medieval song.

[@alondraperez-ramirez8363]

My heart is gladdened by your return. Since we're in Advent, is there any chance for you to translate Catholic Christmas music from the Caribbean? Puerto Rico and Cuba both have beautiful Villancicos, which follow traditions dating all the way back to the 15th century. I'd love to see "Villancico Yaucono" from my home or "Si al ver en el oriente" written by the great composer Esteban Salas. Regardless of whether or not you choose to translate these pieces, I think you'll enjoy hearing them.

[@Balu_420]

The sign of your KZbin channel is on the back of my phone ❤ 🐟 A good man gave it to me and I have it there with proud (even when covered a lot of the times) Greetings from Bavaria

[@fujikoalfonso7448]

Chad Sir Mannelig

[@lucasfirmino.6406]

Beautiful music!

[@thelonewanderer2550]

Hello Ex Cathedra can i request: Adelante Milicias de Cristo If not then i understand, May god bless you

[@deadgavin4218]

Nixies(knuckers), is also an allusion to sirens as she us doing a similar thing. this sort pf allusions could also be the reason mermaids sometimes do similar things

[@thefnaffan2]

My preference of music is Metal but I absolutely love this song.

[@MrEpeeFencer]

Be like Herr Mannelig.

[@KrzysztofTomecki]

Pozdrawiam z Polski 🇵🇱❤🇸🇪

[@Porcelanix]

One of my favourite songs ever. It made me start learning Swedish. Praise the Almighty God. He's coming soon

[@loslingos1232]

Thanks for showing interest in our langue. I doubt God is coming back so soon. Don't you think it would take a while longer? Why now out of nowhere?

[@Porcelanix]

@@loslingos1232 Varsågod! Writing about His coming back, I'm referring to Christmas

[@beren1898]

Wait, so if I summarize this song, it's basically: Troll woman: Hey, mr handsome knight, would you like to do something fun with me? I pay you. 😏 Knight: No thanks bro. I'm a Christian. 😒 Troll women: 😢 (Not gonna lie. It's cool)

[@maxpayne3332]

Yes, but its also about rejecting materialistc wealth and not bcoming an apostate

[@oelberethgilthoniel]

This is a very reduccionist interpretation of the poem, sorry, you lost something big and beauty.

[@kirgan1000]

and the troll woman wails because she still have no soul.

[@ale608raptor3]

4:22 BASED

[@lachtan5583]

Beautiful song

[@umbralobserver]

The temptations of the troll-woman are not too unlike the temptations Satan offered to Christ Himself. Ultimately, just as Satan falsely promised Christ the entire world if He would but fall down and worship Satan, so too does the troll offer riches to the noble knight if he will but abandon his faith for her, which is what the marriage to her really means.

[@arawn1061]

Vi gör lite Trolleri

[@heimelgostavas5138]

Satan didn't know that christ is already the owner, Greater and God of this world. Satan dared to tempt christ but christ himself he was never temped

[@clovebeans713]

Then why does she cry and weep in the end? And say "If he married me my plight would surely end"? Seems like either she has been affected by a curse or is seeking salvation. She never asked him to renounce his faith.

[@kirgan1000]

Yes, not that she never offer him her love.

[@CJVS995]

She could have converted but didnt and instead spazzed out and blamed him. He also saw through her lies and called her out on them:

[@enemyofthestate6516]

I though it was a pagan song.What a nice surprise.

[@mzs5454]

Chad Herr Mannelig

[@OligarchusGarchus]

i enjoyed this beautiful song !!!

[@cazwalt9013]

Always remember to marry a faithful catholic

[@markoscream8466]

I may be orthodox, but holy fuck is this BEAUTIFUL! Swedish girls sing equally as good folk/ethno songs as Serbian girls! Greetings from Serbia to the christian brethren of Rome! I shall wish you what every Serb always wishes to anyone, and that is good health and happiness! That comes above all else!

[@thetaagenshow9549]

Don’t represent us poorly by swearing.

[@newtonia-uo4889]

Hello my orthodox brother. It seems your belief in the Septuagint is right all along. Us catholics will have to fix some of our bibles that has fallen to the errors of the protestants reliance on the masoretic text

[@fraaninaacio]

Essa melodia é muito boa!

[@egyptianromancatholic6486]

Courage for my brothers up in the North.

[@marycavender7136]

Charming as it's is entertaining!🎼😎🤔🌹❤️👍❗

[@waderoberts3701]

This song is popular at Renaissance fairs, but the performers ignore the Christian theme of the song and even joke that they hope the troll ended up murdering the man, "because how else do you take a, 'no.'"?

[@paulbarbat1926]

Listen to Olafur Liljuros. Icelandic song, same pitch : a Christian walks in the wild, a woman (an Elf in this case) arrives and say 'yo dawg, come live with us'. He answers 'No, I have my Christ'. The woman kills him

[@newtonia-uo4889]

@@paulbarbat1926 wth is wrong with pagan women bros.

[@luismdgr]

I never thought I'd stumble upon a Swedish Catholic song

[@maxpayne3332]

Well its not realy catholic but the Song is about a time where there was only the holy roman apostolic church 😉

[@domagojcapko4152]

@@maxpayne3332 It should be again, Jesus created religion and human greed divided it into many denominations!

[@luismdgr]

@@maxpayne3332 fair enough, but you know, you´d expect a Swedish Christian song to be protestant....

[@sigstenbockgard8080]

i'd say the song is pretty neutral. it's written during the 1850's which one of swedens protestant pious peaks but it's about the time before protestantism and nothing in the point to any specific christian doctrine

[@ludwigramirez1047]

@@domagojcapko4152 There's no "denominations", there's the Catholic faith and there's a lot of heresies along with a lot alse religions