[Hidden Vocals] TWICE "SIGNAL"

[@trystyn]

so this is where all of jeongyeons lines go

[@helloiam99]

Its not jeongyeon. Its just their voices but lowered an octave.

[@nayeonsdildo7905]

J Chang no, all parts are sung by Jeongyeon, except beginning and chorus. You can hear she in Jihyo and Nayeon's parts

[@helloiam99]

Nayeon's Dildo Its seriously NOT her. I cant hear any Jeongyeon in that. Just cos its low doesnt mean you can say its sounds like someones elses voice. What if someone says every single high note ever done is secretly done by sana and nayeon and all the low notes are done by jeonyeon? Thats not how it is. In this case i am not talking about pitches, frequencies or tones, i am talking about their voice, technique, pronounciation, speed, expression etc. You can hear that the voice is clearly either artifiicial or that person has a strange voice. Jeongyeon doesnt sound all like that unless you lower it. If you are a new once then we will accept your mistakes as everyone makes them but if you are an old hardcore superonce, then I dont really have anything to say. Something as basic as this shouldnt be misunderstood.

[@helloiam99]

Nayeon's Dildo Plus the ONLY thing in common with that artificial, low, distorted, strange and unusual voice and Jeongyeon is that it is lower pitched. And in the prechorus, you can hear a clear difference between 0:56 and 1:06, they sound like jihyo AND nayeon harmonising in a lower octave so it wouls natrually sound low. And seriously if you go on like a thin that can change their voices lower and you put in their original, and set it to the exact right pitch, you might get this exact same thing. But i am not completely sure as this is what i hear from it. But one thing i AM sure about is is that it isnt jeonyeon singing in there. Gosh these 300+ oncesthat have liked this done have ears really. I dont know how to explain it but you can just hear it is not jeongyeon, its sounds as alike to sana and nayeon than Jeongyeon really. I really shouldnt have to talk to you about this cos it is such a stupid thing to assume. What if someone assumed you cos of your voice? And they were talking about how you are a secret vocalist blah blah blah but really you had the least lines in the song and people are saying the lower harmonising voice thats undetneath your voice sounds like you but its not and you get praised for that. Again, i am sorry if you are a nw once and you are still learning and my comment got more than your reply because i support my opnion with facts and evidence unlike a lot of newbie onces and some immature onces that spread random rumors and saying jeongyeon has secret lines she is finally noticed etc. But its not the reality really except for DNTA cos she got quite a lot of lines.

[@helloiam99]

Its not Jeongyeon, could you please delete this comment so you other onces dont misunderstand.

[@eternalsunshine9010]

omg jihyos part is so lit they shouldve just make it deeper like that

[@igevhanz3295]

It would sound like their possessed......

[@wowsoamazing2323]

hearing those deep vocals, omg im imagining got7 singing that part ive consumed too much got7 im starting to imagine them in a non-got7 video

[@laibaawan8196]

YESSSS

[@dxln6]

That was Jungyeon

[@ilovebtsandtwice7075]

exactly.

[@naevis48]

0:56 is the best part in the song

[@taegunseol6630]

Bitch true

[@Blxssom_Olive]

And 1:14

[@user-gu4xg3iq9j]

Jihyo ✨😩

[@kookypoki614]

fr

[@SsoulZz4]

Nayeon deep voice!

[@footcake1]

Now we all know where jeongyeon line is

[@helloiam99]

For the ones who arent familiar enought with twices voices, those low vocals in the verses are NOT jeongyeon. You may think that because the voice is low and deep similar to jeongyeon but jeongyeon doesnt sound like that at all. Who is it then you may ask? On the album credits it is stated it is someone called Esther Park who was the one to do the background vocals. Ester Park "Legaci" - background vocals (on "Signal") Go on Wikipedia and in album credits youll see that it was esther park, not jeongyeon, not chaeyoung, not jihyo.

[@jihyocute241]

JYP

[@jyp5317]

hello i am Why you commenting this everyone’s comment that says it’s Jeongyeon

[@gabrielasleftglove]

@@helloiam99 not the hey but the hidden voice in jeongyeon's part and jihyo's pre chorus line

[@katlou2732]

JIHYO'S PART OMG!!!!!! ITS SO GOOD!

[@myname9152]

kat lou I WILL DW THOS BECAUSE JEONGYEON JIHYO

[@belleah1795]

if that's jeongyeon i'm gonna have a heartgasm

[@redviolet7826]

BELLA MIN Why yes it is

[@bbongbbongdrr4358]

it is lmao

[@helloiam99]

No its isnt please no moe of this nonsence

[@helloiam99]

Red Violet and choerryy please dont make me explain this again: ts seriously NOT her. I cant hear any Jeongyeon in that. Just cos its low doesnt mean you can say its sounds like someones elses voice. What if someone says every single high note ever done is secretly done by sana and nayeon and all the low notes are done by jeonyeon? Thats not how it is. In this case i am not talking about pitches, frequencies or tones, i am talking about their voice, technique, pronounciation, speed, expression etc. You can hear that the voice is clearly either artifiicial or that person has a strange voice. Jeongyeon doesnt sound all like that unless you lower it. If you are a new once then we will accept your mistakes as everyone makes them but if you are an old hardcore superonce, then I dont really have anything to say. Something as basic as this shouldnt be misunderstood.

[@helloiam99]

choerryy and Red Violet Plus the ONLY thing in common with that artificial, low, distorted, strange and unusual voice and Jeongyeon is that it is lower pitched. And in the prechorus, you can hear a clear difference between 0:56 and 1:06, they sound like jihyo AND nayeon harmonising in a lower octave so it wouls natrually sound low. And seriously if you go on like a thin that can change their voices lower and you put in their original, and set it to the exact right pitch, you might get this exact same thing. But i am not completely sure as this is what i hear from it. But one thing i AM sure about is is that it isnt jeonyeon singing in there. Gosh these 300+ oncesthat have liked this done have ears really. I dont know how to explain it but you can just hear it is not jeongyeon, its sounds as alike to sana and nayeon than Jeongyeon really. I really shouldnt have to talk to you about this cos it is such a stupid thing to assume. What if someone assumed you cos of your voice? And they were talking about how you are a secret vocalist blah blah blah but really you had the least lines in the song and people are saying the lower harmonising voice thats undetneath your voice sounds like you but its not and you get praised for that. Again, i am sorry if you are a nw once and you are still learning and my comment got more than your reply because i support my opnion with facts and evidence unlike a lot of newbie onces and some immature onces that spread random rumors and saying jeongyeon has secret lines she is finally noticed etc. But its not the reality really except for DNTA cos she got quite a lot of lines.

[@bobati2740]

1:42 holy shi---

[@itzceszx4795]

BobaTii lol

[@amethompson-doughty9202]

BobaTii ikr,I was listening to signal and I heard that deep auto tune in Jeongyeons part. So that’s why I’m here

[@vousmevoyez5181]

I think it's JYP voice , because his the one who make the song.

[@sourseal]

Yoongi’s Neck Pillow me tooo

[@helloiam99]

Guys its not jeongyeon please

[@Jay-rc1sw]

i'm crying at how amazing 0:56 is oh my god

[@angelinojadeisaia3293]

Jay H. Jihyo harmonizes there

[@ilim_ysm]

@@angelinojadeisaia3293 not just the harmony but in the "jigahiga gyeseo" of jihyo and "maemurande hallae" of nayeon, there's someones voice in a lover octave in the lead vocal and it sounds like an alien but i have to guess it's jeongyeon

[@mayyy6924]

@@ilim_ysm yea its jeongyeon

[@jharnadhar4793]

same sis same

[@SsoulZz4]

@@mayyy6924 it's nayeon deep voice

[@Macquelife]

Wow..there really is an alien in this song

[@OpelTheAnimatronicEchidnayz65]

Star Wings HAHAHHAAH yes signal the alien song.

[@paikguatchew9540]

Star Wings Jeongyeon are alien

[@mielle3470]

Lmfao

[@rae2443]

Omg ikr

[@kyle_boo1394]

When i read this i was laughing hard HWAHAH

[@jungkookluvr1512]

0:56 nUTS

[@rat7465]

_!-jam-!_ Lmao how old are you 😂😂

[@quinn_with_the_crown4850]

I was actually able to hear it because of a problem in my headphones. I bent the cables and I found the sound.

[@seoulvicez]

Kj G same but where did you bend the cables because I'm trying to do again but it isn't working :/

[@naevis48]

Kj G lol i had one that was like that but now I lost it lol 😂

[@hanpichu]

ThisTrashyTrashcan i think its near the part when you stick it into the headphone jack because mine bent and i could only hear the instrumental part

[@rio-sj4lv]

same thats what happened to my headphones

[@Bambixtomie]

Me too omg 😂

[@voduongtructhanh3973]

Hold on y'all telling me the deep voice is jeongyeon's ? I thought it was a guy's voice????

[@milkduds9148]

I think its either someone's voiced lowered digitally, or maybe a male trainee they used to background vocals. Its pretty common to do that, I think

[@redviolet7826]

Milk Duds It makes sense, but it's Jeongyeon.

[@giovannaacosta9932]

Oh gosh im shy shy shy cause black is in my area IKR!!

[@SHANGRILASS]

I thought it was jyp's voice from his sample lol

[@--IndiraShafiraPutriPrana]

I kinda hear chaeyoung’s voice

[@flowerchildjae7850]

jungyeon the real main and hidden vocalist

[@mayluv6754]

Flower Child Jae , "hidden vocalist" is really need to be a category in kpop😂

[@smiley-4532]

True

[@whatasillycat]

its not jeongyeon

[@elio4105]

@@whatasillycat it is but aight.

[@theofficialspotspotspotlig5063]

@@elio4105 No it’s Esther Park

[@hanpichu]

all these time whenever i listen to signal and it comes to jihyo and nayeon’s part i always focus on the deeper voice :o

[@angelinojadeisaia3293]

MewBxl GT Jihyo harmonized with herself there she also did the one with Nayeon and I swear Jihyo is such a queen

[@francheskabanguis4985]

Jungyeon and Jiyho are my favourite 😭💖

[@francheskabanguis4985]

Jihyo*

[@DrDream-fp2uf]

Sammee

[@oncearmy9325]

Jeongyeon*

[@nami-rk5br]

"HEY HEY HEY HEY HEY HEY"

[@yourmother9180]

sounds like jeongyeon

[@valongue6561]

Your Mother That's where her lines all went

[@jorgerosecapule534]

Your Mother what part????

[@bloodinherhair]

Gorgee Cap the whole song

[@shairramaureen8234]

Jeongyeon the hidden vocalist of Twice

[@rae2443]

Your Mother cuz it is🤗

[@parkjiminsrealwifeu6806]

Jeongyeon's voice is fucking hooooot!!!!!😍😍😍😍

[@lunalulu3654]

0:56 wtf this is so sexy. They had to do a version of this...

[@emy958]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXuri2CEnZmigtE 🙄

[@iceleeloy7749]

*This is what you hear if you have broken headphones*

[@KP-me1ry]

I love love love the background vocals! They really make the song stand out!! Thanks for uploading 😊

[@xsemb144]

You're welcome, I'm glad you love it ༼♥ل͜♥༽

[@naevis48]

XSemB (ᵔᴥᵔ)

[@iceleeloy7749]

*OH..... THAT'S WHY JEONGYEON ALWAYS GET THE LOWEST LINE DISTRIBUTION* #igetitnow

[@helloiam99]

Whats why?

[@claudiosanti5543]

HAHAHAHAHAHAH

[@irfanhakim3391]

I don't think she get lowest lines in TWICE but she often get 4th, 5th, 6th despite being lead vocalist

[@polarityofficial3566]

But it wasn't Jeongyeon...

[@baby_dollie1167]

@@polarityofficial3566 I think it was Jeongyong it sounds just like her

[@ohnaminami]

*JEONGYEON SLAY ME* her voice sounds so deep, I can't 😂

[@helloiam99]

tzuyu and yoongi can eat me out cause im a jhoe maybe cos its not her

[@cancerianarmy4103]

@@helloiam99 its her

[@SoCool7987]

@@cancerianarmy4103 No it's background vocalist

[@bangtaniekim5624]

I've always loved jihyo and naeyeon's part in signal, but this makes me love it even more

[@mariposaluvr13]

0:56 you wont believe how many times i replayed this

[@jesusalvarado9259]

When Jihyo harmonizes with herself😌😌PURE ART

[@ohnaminami]

So this is why Jeongyeon doesn't have that much lines😂

[@junhyeonluv]

guys don't get confused, the deep voice is the alien.

[@yustrated]

I love the deep voice and all but, I just can’t get over Sana’s adorable voice!

[@ykhiz]

scaramouche period

[@mudbucket1354]

i wish the industry knew that people like to hear women sing in lower registers and would utilize it more often just like the background harmonies you hear in the video

[@anna-fv9ni]

I hear Chaeyoung and Jeongyeon

[@anxietea3561]

IT SOUNDS LIKE A COLLAB OF A BOY GROUP WITH TWICE

[@EmmanCian-c1w]

0:56 Sounds so ANGELIC

[@risa408]

JYP needs to let them sing lower more often, holy shit! 😱

[@dahyunssisoshi547]

0:56 1:05 1:42 2:02 2:11

[@radioactive_baby]

EARGASM

[@radioactive_baby]

@itzZaheim tbh I don't even remember commenting this

[@lovechoerrymotion5086]

0:56 Is that Tzuyu singing? And is that my QUEEN, MY EVERYTHING JEONGYEON singing at 1:21 and in a low voice throughout the whole song??!!!! I'm shook!😂😂💖💖💖

[@syafeeyka4193]

Little Harmony 0:56 it's jihyo

[@lovechoerrymotion5086]

Hear me ONCE , Love me TWICE oh, really. Thanks for correcting me

[@snzsndr9010]

I think it's Tzuyu too. When I first heard it, I definitely thought of Tzuyu first!

[@helloiam99]

Its jihyo sadly

[@javierapaz2057]

0:56 i think it's Jeongyeon

[@kokolio4453]

Jihyo's part and nayeon's part are cooler now !and i think there is a total hottie guy singing in the back

[@bbongbbongdrr4358]

kokonie 21 I agree about jihyo and nayeon part! and sayaka maizono? :)

[@smiley-4532]

the hottie was Jeongyeon lmao

[@flowerchildjae7850]

BITCH JIHYO JUNGYEON AND NAYEON GAVE ME GOOSEBUMPS IM SCREAMING

[@fishandnoodles3288]

Hey everyone this isn't Jeongyeon. It's Esther Park. Check the album credits

[@maelat3703]

wow i’m disappointed

[@bbongbbongdrr4358]

I LOVE JIHYO AND NAYEONS PARTS AHHHH *except the really deep bit*

[@honeya8521]

Jihyo, Jeongyeon 😍😍

[@yyaque]

I think It's Jihyo because she was training for so long that she can probably have her vocals go really low!

[@image_ineee3059]

No... You can train to make your voice HIGHER. It would be a LOT harder to lower it. It may also cause some throat problems.

[@adorkable7196]

Its both Jihyo and Jeongyeon

[@atne3484]

Watch sixteen truth, Jihyo goes super low

[@potatosalad342]

damn jihyo's part is melting my heart sounds so good should have made it a little more obvious just sounds so gooooood

[@cc6546]

this is rlly good thanks for uploading

[@xsemb144]

You're welcome 😊 I'm really glad

[@kudotokimikuitsuka303]

1:50 .... haha

[@zhen3630]

I finally saw Tzuyu do back vocal Edit:but it's her own part

[@stormlee13]

This gave me literal chills... ugh, queens 🥺💘

[@whyisthesunshine]

0:56 I love this part😍

[@ariane8238]

0:55 WIG

[@hekkumaa]

1:42 BEST PART

[@mato6058]

I WAS SO SHOCKED AT 0:56 HOLYZJKS

[@mato6058]

is so satisfying listening to them harmonize with others or themselves

[@tamx796]

signal's my fave twice title track anD NOW IT'S GOTTEN BETTER I CAN NEVER LISTEN TO SIGNAL THE SAME WAY EVER AGAIN

[@sophiajones2361]

woah who dat. jungyeon?

[@cinamorou4154]

Who dat who dat who dat girl

[@unnecessary111]

Debbie ducking all the way lmao

[@atne3484]

BTS tRaSh Jihyo

[@utopiaroja]

who dat b who dat b

[@flymiap]

dude i believe that deep voice is jihyo (mix with jeongyeon's voice) dudeee edit: jihyo naturally has a deep singing voice

[@yovevlyk4258]

1:49 I ALWAYS SUDDENLY SING LIKE HUNGHUUHH IDK WHY I LOVE THIS

[@streamweirdbyyungblud8860]

0:18 JYP (their company for new once’s)

[@soobinslostwig5562]

wow thats why when i was listening to signal performance there was deep voice

[@heyimjade17]

0:56 that's so good

[@limanota]

JIHYO OMG

[@lalaa558]

1:14 ngl you can use this sound for edits :o

[@jerry4865]

Came from the future, just saw many people wondering who's the male voice. As a 5 year fan, I remember in one of their BTS of the MV they said JYP voiced some parts and you can barely hear it directly from the official audio, the most obvious part is dahyun and chaeyeong's sign neul bonae signal bonae

[@asakomifune5430]

In case you're wondering, the mystery of the background vocalist has been solved. Its Esther Park, as stated on the official album credits of "SIGNAL"

[@EsJoyPark]

I’m 5 years late to seeing this, but yes it’s me! Thank you for the credit!❤

[@chaeng474]

Omg Nayeon's,Momo's and Jeongyeon's hidden vocals literally killed

[@victoriarios4485]

the chorus is so good tho~

[@Dawned-nil]

This is so cool especially when you hear the original version after this !!😱😍

[@dionysus9425]

1:42 im new but WHOSE voice is that its so deep and omg good!

[@kaylamorris4592]

Putting this on my playlist instead of the studio version.

[@Liriklirik30]

Please do Twice- truth

[@chantalamante5641]

I just really love 0:27😍 it’s like jeongyeon on the right earphones then mina(?) on the left earphone

[@signalbonae]

it’s almost like they were saying “dreams” and it’s so beautiful, i was scrolling through the comments and i finally found one like this

[@dilanyasar8730]

I started to cry ... how this much perfect

[@alexxx_1]

I can't unhear this when I listen to the actual song

[@nicolegabrielle06]

OMG JIHYOS PRE CHORUS AAJAHHHAHAHAHA

[@dia.ya8853]

During jeongyeons chorus part, I could hear a deep voice (or male voice) but not clearly in the song. (1:43)

[@helloiam99]

Tsukinocos _ Yes!

[@maiuyu]

0:56 such wow

[@wwnjmljn]

the deeper voices are there to give the alien vibe since there is an alien in the mv

[@tigatakara5743]

0:18 when it said jyp i was like why did they put here does jyp want to show his hiddin vocal?

[@lattelover123]

I’m here after so many years... 유정연 😭😭

[@cebeleemagalong4516]

remember when dahyun talked about that jyp also sang this song but it can't be heard that much on weekly idol, maybe this is what dahyun is talking about

[@mayluv6754]

2:28 sana😍

[@cinamorou4154]

I love Jeongyeon so much Look at the soft deep voice

[@helloiam99]

Debbie ducking all the way first, you cant look at something you hear and secomd it is not jeongyeon

[@cancerianarmy4103]

@@helloiam99 can u stop arguing with whoever that! Prasied jungyeon

[@SoCool7987]

@@cancerianarmy4103 Can you please just accept the fact that it isn't Jeongyeon?

[@chaeyoungsstrawberryfarm3327]

My two favorite people at the first line😍

[@scro910]

I didn’t know tboz from tlc knew Korean lmao

[@EsJoyPark]

😂 those deep vocals are me! I love the tboz reference

[@itizwhatitiz2245]

Jeongyeon’s deep voice 😩💓🙌

[@elsaa_arg]

I love the alien like sound "doonshh"

[@naayoxeatws]

esthers vocals are so good

[@richealynricheal3873]

Aww..who the deep deep voice there😭😭👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽❤🔥❤🔥🔥💖🔥❣❣i hope that is jeongyeon🙏🙏

[@breleesewashington8063]

I think it's hers too! She sounds great!

[@EsJoyPark]

That deep deep voice is actually me! 😅 thank you for the love ❤

[@swiftyeri]

Wow the alien sing for the background vocal Great 👍

[@Jooyaa503]

Bru this scared me... I just saw something on instagram that said that JYP himself was one of the hidden vocals... phew, there’s nothing with him doing that but since this song was ONLY meant for twice, yeah.

[@nictunes4098]

omg this is the anwer to all the questions about where jeongyeon lines are 💖

[@helloiam99]

Kim Nicole what makes you think it is Jeongyeon tho?

[@clrmgcbarbie]

i need more hidden vocals

[@joystanning5701]

HEY HEY HEY HEY HEY

[@justignoreme4843]

In 0:26 anyone heard "Jjirit"??

[@eztofgehweg.1507]

woah heaven

[@wwnjmljn]

jihyos part thooo

[@chloeeeeeeww]

0:56 and 2:00 holy shit

[@kimtzuyu2765]

Aa, so there's double Tzuyu in the REFF.

[@stansecretnumberperiod]

0:20 I think that this 'HEY, HEY!,HEY!' is Jeongyeon

[@lunajergi2494]

cant get over this.. sounds like chaeyoung and jeongyeon

[@sourseal]

heavenly