Hole SOFTER SOFTEST 10/27/18 NY Courtney Love with Melissa Auf der Maur & Roddy from FNM on Piano

On Saturday, October 27, 2018 at Basilica Hudson in Hudson, NY there was a Pioneering People Basilica Benefit Tribute to Courtney Love. Melissa Auf der Maur and Courtney Love performed an amazing version of Hole's "Softer, Softest" with Roddy Bottum of Faith No More on Piano. www.mostpeopleareblank.com

[@younginlove8167]

So fucking iconic. I want a Hole reunion and a new album

[@soundmind81]

Thank you for uploading these videos!

[@AdmiralNeeda]

Thank you for taking this!

[@prudenciagonzales7212]

Piano wtf

[@geoff1132]

Thanks so much, how truly fabulous

[@eszterannabaumann5928]

Melissa for president!!!!

[@joecrollard9934]

I love Courtney and Melissa but holy shit this was terrible.

[@mrkurt64]

I really appreciate Melissa's friendship and emphaty, but this is awful...

[@mungofinalfi4480]

No, this is Softer, softest. ; D

[@catsthatsmokemeth]

@@mungofinalfi4480 this comment was so funny omfg

[@stacky512a]

Awesome

[@elmarbeau]

Horrible.. Omg, poor Melissa!!!!!!!!

[@floorbrown]

when will they release their next album????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@Natasha-yf1xk]

Tbh the piano did not help them at all

[@boxofboommike]

I think the piano player could have adjusted to match Courtney’s style and phrasing. The way he was playing didn’t really make sense for the song

[@annasloan2349]

I actually like the piano and the lyrics and it doesnt sound bad at all...but at the same time it sounds bad. Im not sure how it can be both at once...in my ears anyway.

[@ladygodiva4141]

It’s because Courtney is out of time. Nerves maybe.

[@floorbrown]

So awesome

[@ricci777]

sorry kids, but Courtney is off key and out of rhythm, this is painful to watch.

[@zoltanbagdal7148]

smoking and the early 90's really f#cked her voice up she couldn't yell in 97 like she could in 95

[@elmarbeau]

poor melissa, ruined.

[@sunshinedaydream70]

I have to agree. But I think a lot of it is that this song was not created for piano. If you listen to the rest of the benefit , it's not that bad. Perhaps she didn't have her ear monitor in? IDK

[@dmc4426]

So many singers are off key, it not the pitch. It's the emotions. This is raw emotion. Crosby, Nash and Young live sound off key too.

[@thepolacek]

I agree. Melissa sounds great, as usual, though.

[@stacyblue1980]

I can only cry...🌹💜💋

[@alaricperez]

what did courtney say after the thing about the cabaret act? I couldnt understand any of what she said. Thaks for the upload!

[@Heartpadlockk]

❤

[@andrewmartin8978]

That was great!

[@elmarbeau]

The end and death of live through this!

[@thepolacek]

I’ve been a hole fan since “live through this.” To say this is anything other than awful is a lie.

[@yayanlapakmerchandise8260]

Best

[@badgurl5758]

Sorry but this was not good!

[@troyklaker9830]

🖤

[@MrEthanlevy100]

She looks better than in the 90s

[@KellyK387]

Off key Not the same as 94

[@tutsybassista]

Kristen Pfaff played on Live Through This, btw...

[@seraphicgrandeur]

You expect her to sound the same after like 30 years?! And anyways, all the smoking in the 90s fucked her voice up a bunch

[@zarahsantiago3580]

😴

[@kaylatallman7203]

What the fuck is this