Vocal Coach Reacts to Kelly Clarkson Vs P!NK VOCAL BATTLE

[@loaybaqleh3677]

Finally a vocal battle where two singers have very good technique and somehow similar tones and they are both great

[@memberofthelambily1340]

Loay Baqleh and similar styles

[@sbomorse]

Exactly! Normally the person putting the clips together for her has a bias and it shows in the quality of the clips sourced.

[@ZWU-zp1vt]

OMG, I was going to comment exactly the same, lol.

[@adamc8033]

Couldn't agree more

[@sandravgc]

Loay Baqleh Sia and Lady Gaga was very close too

[@aldenboon2399]

P!nk is my number 1 and Kelly is my number 2, but I have to say Kelly definitely has the vocal range. P!nk herself said that Kelly can outsing her anytime, and Kelly said P!nk has the greatest voice of this generation. Love these two powerhouses!

[@rondelmoore7130]

Alden Boon Pink can say what she wants both have wide vocal range.

[@awokwok1029]

Their belting range are almost the same tbh. She won't overpowered Pink. Her voice is definitely as thin as Pink.

[@varunravi27]

@@awokwok1029 In terms of technique, Kelly surpasses P!nk in belting (she is consistent up to F#5, while P!nk is consistent up to E5).

[@erickglez144]

@@varunravi27 but p!nk is mezzo, so being consistent up to E5 it’s amazing. They’re both equally good

[@addictedtovocals]

Kelly Clarkson, her versatility was always insane. And she could cover any song, and it would sound like hers. A true gem in our generations.

[@cathyodendaal8976]

Couldn't agree more!

[@AndySaenz]

Fun fact: Pink wrote “Broken and Beautiful” for Kelly Clarkson on the Ugly Dolls soundtrack.

[@mattnelson2539]

The Official Andy Saenz oh I can totally see P!nk writing that

[@wtvr92]

s0mbie Breakaway did sound like such an Avril song

[@mijalakis3]

Ryan Tedder wrote Already gone for Kelly and Halo for Beyonce. Because of the song similarities and of course since Beyonce has all the media bought they slammed Kelly for it so that's why she wrote Wash, rinse and repeat

[@pinkmusiicluva]

P!nk all the way for me. Both very talented but until you hear P!nk live, in the flesh.... she’s just incredible.

[@BuinidhMoChridheDoAlba]

Exactly. I doubt kelly could keep perfect while flying about

[@divinefeminineoracle5825]

Agreed

[@natevanslyke990]

I haven't seen Pink live yet but I have seen Kelly in concert and that was a phenomenal concert one of my favorites I've ever been to! (My favorite concert has to be when I went and saw Celine but that's a given). Pink would be awesome to see live though

[@rahulvaswani749]

Kelly live is better

[@Cal90208]

@@rahulvaswani749 Respectfully disagree. A P!NK show has everything you could imagine

[@flamindevilrye7546]

I love both of them but I stan P!nk for the longest time. She’s just the whole package. I’m pretty sure if u ask P!nk who is better, she will definitely say Kelly. Meanwhile, if u ask Kelly, she will say P!nk is better. That’s just how grounded these artists are. Women supporting women. Kelly is really a big fan of P!nk and I love her for that. (notice how P!nk is spelled as P!nk and not Pink. this is a testament of a true stan) 😍

[@mikeykm1993]

Excuse my ignorance, what is a ‘Stan’? - I agree they are both great

[@alextint5987]

@@mikeykm1993 Stan means admiration, praise, adoration, support, being a fan, follower

[@STevefreaky2388]

Yes they are both real ass people and that's why i LOVE them

[@mrepix8287]

@@mikeykm1993It means hardcore, borderline obsessive fan, from the song “Stan” by Eminem.

[@Ekw418]

Both are outstanding but I’d have to go with Kelly!!

[@thechanel0889]

Kelly is a Legend. ❤️

[@freddievuite1398]

I love kelly to death.. She has a great personality and thats just a bonus...and her vocal OMG! She is not American Idol for no reason!! Pink what can i say even elders when they listen to her voice they cud say she is great, phenomenal and all! She is truly legend and dnt blame her bcuz she is more older than kelly and more she was more settle first than kelly as kelly was just known as American idol winner at that time

[@adamc8033]

I've gotta agree her range is just slightly better and her notes are very clever x

[@Heidenheim75]

I go with Pink! Partly because I like her songs more.

[@reita-3109]

The 2 most underrated woman in the music industry

[@Cal90208]

I AGREE.

[@sharonf106]

I love them both. Both are such strong singers. The biggest difference to me is that Kelly relies on her voice, there are no theatrics, she just gets up there and sings the song.

[@lblincoe2094]

Kelly's style of music is much more my lane and I definitely have much more of her music in my library, but P!NK's voice! My God, I could listen to her sing all day! That rich, raspy tone is just flawless to me!

[@Cal90208]

It’s so sad that her rasp is basically all gone by now. But I’m glad she quit smoking...

[@danielcaceres9971]

Pink is so raw, I love her

[@harveypincaynovillo5481]

🤮

[@badatchoosingnames3556]

This is probably one of, if not the best vs everrrr. Both singers are actually technically great and knows how to express their emotions through their voice. And as a bonus, these 2 women actually have great personality(though this has no relations to this). Choosing 1 over the other is almost near impossible. For me, at least

[@charlotteharrison8595]

The first clip is from Kelly performing on American Idol. They bring her back on the show from time to time to do a performance as she won the first season of the show.

[@PhenixJoe]

They are both amazing but objectively, I think Kelly is the more versatile, capable vocalist (not that it’s a terribly easy determination to make). They’re both beyond talented, though.

[@christianmedina7134]

Because of Mariah carey ! Lol #influence

[@mariahisthe1]

@@christianmedina7134 true lol

[@NicoG6]

Finally, some more Kelly on your channel! Love your reactions, but the ones including Kelly especially!

[@ashton-landry]

Nico Gies yes! agreed! more kc!

[@Martdiva1979]

Both Amazing Kelly Clarkson was great singing someone like you and p!nk was great at singing time after time

[@RoccoGotopo44]

Kelly and Pink both Amazing Singers but Love Kelly Clarkson 😍

[@raaid22]

American idol would often have Kelly come back to perform on the show. She wasn't competing in the first clip. I think because of you, since you been gone, behind those hazel eyes are songs that she has had to lower slightly over the years.

[@tomfeb1818]

The most pivotal notes she sings is in Miss Independent. The live version when she says I'm so glad I can finally see. She belts out see and does a run. Its goosebump giving amazing! 😊

[@odhranhorgan7954]

You should watch p!nks and Kelly's deut of everybody hurts it's unbelievable

[@Smoothgrooves]

Odhran Horgan it is amazing 😉

[@angelrubio5816]

I prefer Kelly's voice a little bit more than pink's, but as a performer, I prefer Pink. Both are two of the greatest artists of the last years, and I love that they support each other.

[@ikogarcia8122]

Love both, but I prefer Kelly's bluesy tone. I also grew up with her music so I'm a bit biased lol.

[@Cal90208]

Same for me, but for P!NK

[@yoelsanchez8880]

Both are incredibly amazing vocalists. Glad you're reacting to this! Can't wait.

[@marielaoquendorodriguez670]

They’re both great and very underrated ❤️❤️

[@stephenanthony3094]

The first clip of Kelly was on the final session of Idol when it aired on Fox. She was a guest judge and sang two songs. I've listened to that clip so many times!! I love KC!

[@rydbthatsme]

Kelly Clarkson for sure but P!NK is literally almost identical so closest 2nd I’ve seen.😍

[@KichboiiJJ]

Kelly's tone, agility and support is better for me. So Kelly wins

[@sohyangworld1544]

Kelly's agility and support is better but tone goes to Pink all day every day.

[@polinalulu4238]

Pink support and kelly are the same bc pink slay in lows and she slays in the upper registers

[@Bridgje05]

You should check Kelly's performance of Whollatta Woman during BBMA's. That was awesome! Even Simon Cowle was amazed. He's like a proud daddy when he came up the stage after her performance.

[@noidea3278]

Kelly is an absolute legend!!! I love herr

[@ccalexander1924]

I like the tone of Kelly’s voice Better. When she goes from those high to low notes etc I get the chills ! I think kelly shows more emotion in her voice. I like pink but I absolutely LOVE Kelly’s voice

[@Rosannasfriend]

Actually, the fact that they're both so great means it was the ultimate battle! I agree with Pink winning,cause I think she's a little more consistently technically sound in her performances, but Kelly's right up there nowadays. In the past I used to worry for her throat, lol. Both of these ladies are my all-time favorites! Thanks again!

[@donnamentrasti2695]

They don't come much better than these two today. Would really love your reaction video to Kelly and P!nk's live duet performance at the AMA's in 2017 of the R.E.M. song, "Everybody Hurts." Thanks, you're my fave vocal reactor.

[@augustmoments]

its very close but id say kelly Clarkson's technique is just a bit better than pinks. Their both amazing vocalists though!!!

[@Rosannasfriend]

No, pink's technique is much more consistently good. But it may be easier to appreciate the sound of Kelly's voice.

[@allenmaxerscalata6401]

@@Rosannasfriend they're both good. Let just settle down and watch. Hihi

[@theusaosb]

OMG. I love it. Hope you continue reacting to these both ladies. They've been all theses years being so incredibly good! OMG

[@MrSyasuke]

I freaking love both of them but Kelly has a special place in my heart, p¡nk is great, awesome and etc but Kelly's voice MY GOD.

[@fatihksl3537]

I adore Pink's tone and she is an amazing singer and performer, she can dance and sing at the same time, whereas Kelly sings effortlessly so you know it could be really equal, let's see our Honest Vocal Coach's reaction and how she can be really fair

[@dannysimion]

These two are fine modern female artists. I love their vocal prowess and emotional vulnerability.

[@keysyleo2079]

They are both so amazing and sadly underrated. Love them both 💋😘🥰

[@michellemcgraw2007]

I love Kelly’s voice for me! But pink has a beautiful not taking nothing from her. They both can sing. I just love to hear Kelly more but that’s why there’s so many singers we all love different ones.

[@nataliemcbride9037]

My two most favourite singers 🎤 of all time! I couldn’t decide who’s the better one, really they are both superior! I was so super excited to watch this battle because I am going to Pink’s Beautiful Trauma concert tomorrow night in Toronto Ontario Canada 🇨🇦! 💖🥰

[@Cal90208]

How was the concert?

[@tripplels1]

So much nostalgia i gotta go through all their old albums

[@divinefeminineoracle5825]

I have pinks first album when she was doing R&B, Can't Take Me Home is a great album. I think her voice is prettier than kellys, Kelly is just good at being loud.

[@kerrydibiasio3784]

They are both beautiful and just amazing! I find even though I don't personally know them they are the most down to earth, genuine people. That makes me love them even more.

[@jessicamartinez-sv8rb]

Omg, chills throughout. Both of these ladies are freaking amazing!!

[@marktaylor9886]

I’ve been a KC fan since her My December album, I’ve also been a fan of P!nk since Family Portrait days. Absolutely love them both, they don’t need to be pitted against each other; they’re the benchmarks for female singers for our generation ❤️

[@jonathanouellette7050]

YES! React to more Kelly Clarkson!! - Meaning of life (Nashville Sessions) - Miss Independent (AOL Sessions) - Obama's inauguration - Aretha Franklin's tribute 2019

[@josued09]

Jonathan Ouellette don’t forget the “I know you won’t” cover (Vh1 unplugged)

[@Aquariusxx]

josued09 YES! one of my favorite performances

[@alishaw3627]

I loved the mash up she did for a music award ceremony (maybe the billboards) this year!

[@josued09]

@@Aquariusxx yes! I just think it showcases her whole range... its it's amazing!

[@DegrassiInstantStar]

Am impossible battle, because they are both supreme talents. And, having seen both of them live, I can tell you that their live shows are mesmerizing. Am I the only one disappointed that their duet from the 2017 American Music Awards not included? And I recommend seeing both if you ever get the chance. Their shows are damn worth it. Hoping to see more Kelly and P!nk reactions from you, as well.

[@stopstalkingme6030]

They’re both incredible to me, but consistency has to go to Pink!

[@marklambert814]

Love both singers. You’ve probably seen it before but if not definitely check out their duet singing “Everybody Hurts”!

[@ThaGentleman512]

P!nk for me. Her voice is more versatile and her tone and rasp edges her out.

[@xanderbrink5167]

I love Pink and she has an amazing voice but she is not more versatile than Kelly, definitely not. Pink has always done pop/rock but never anything else unlike Kelly who has dabbed in every single genre except metal.

[@rondelmoore7130]

Xander Brink What lies? Pink has done R&B, Jazz, Blues, Folk, Country, Classical, power ballads and opera.

[@jonasjouied4408]

Rondel Moore do you mean she’s sung classical or operatic songs in her own style? I don’t think I’ve ever heard her sing either of these genres or even heard her talk about singing them...

[@christofferrigeverything1112]

@@jonasjouied4408 cuz u have never heard it before

[@AlrightSirFreak]

Both are top notch but P!nk wins because of her emotional delivery. You can feel your soul singing along with her. It would be great if you could react to P!nk's acrobatic performances too (Glitter In The Air @ Grammys, Sober @ Funhouse Tour, Try @ AMAs, Beatiful Trauma @ AMAs or So What @ TTAL Tour)

[@ANNIE_R_U_OK]

It's a shame that now p!nk just sing cheesy pop songs missing her rock edge and lacking emotion.

[@Cal90208]

@@ANNIE_R_U_OK What do you mean? She isn’t just singing cheesy pop songs... I’m assuming you mean walk me home. Which is the literal worst song on the album, the rest are so good and so emotional

[@jeshubravo]

i love Pink but Kelly is the best

[@directorSandyKCE]

I can't wait the see the video. I LOVE both singers, but Kelly is my all time favorite female Pop vocalist. I'm so interested in hearing what you have to say about this "vocal battle".

[@rahulvaswani749]

directorSandyKCE the because of you high note is not the hardest for Kelly to sing so I’m not sure what the video owner meant when she said that.

[@Ernie1978]

I love Kelly and P!nk, both brilliant songwritters and singers. For me it is impossible to pick. Brilliant clip, Georgina!! Loved it!!

[@mattd501]

P!nk singing Time after Time just did me in, Cyndi created an anthem for the end of time and this version is one that will never cease to send me into a puddle of tears and endless admiration because to me it's the infinite tribute to the angel that was Eva Cassidy..No one can touch P!nk when she is an honoring someone either alive or past, through no one's fault, she just has a gift that is insurmountable just as when she honored Judy Garland at the 2014 Oscars with "Somewhere Over The Rainbow". "Time after Time" it just holds such deep meaning for every individual, the nostalgia and the fleeting moments that are life with our loved ones. It's beyond words that song and performance...Kelly, Jennifer Hudson and P!nk are the best of these past 20 so odd years!! We love you Georgina 💖

[@macauleymcewan]

Kelly for sure, better technique, more versatile far more pleasant tone.

[@badatchoosingnames3556]

@James Taylor I wouldn't say Kelly has "horrid" technique before, but ye her voice kinda declined after repeated execution of super hard songs with crazy climax which gave her the raspiness and losing some of her ease. One thing for sure, these 2 ladies definitely showed great improvements through their career and can sing many, most in fact, singers under the bus.

[@V_-._.-_]

Seriously Kelly more versatile? She's been singing the same type of songs her whole career P!nk can go from rock to pop to classics like Over The Rainbow and still nail all of them.

[@jaredjones5870]

Tone is subjective. Though Kelly is slightly better technique wise, I think most people prefer Pink's tone as it is more unique, and seems to have more depth.

[@christinakilcher9019]

@@V_-._.-_ same type of song? You gotta be joking. Pop-rock, soul, pop, country... And it's only Kelly's original music, when there are A LOT of different covers.

[@cale2102]

Vlladan maybe you should spend half an hour and search for some Kelly staff... I absolutly love Pink, but denying Kelly‘s versatility is just ridicolous!

[@joeyjoe7930]

Both are genius singers! I love both of them, but Kelly will always win in my mind!

[@jessfanel]

Kelly has operatic voice training, that's why she can do amazing things with her voice 😍 for me this is definitely win by Kelly.

[@jK-mb7im]

Jesus Lugo clearly her training has gone out of the window bcuz her singing is always spread and screamy

[@mijalakis3]

Both ubdersapprecisted vocalists. I feel people only mention them when they release a good song and they deserve a lot more. They are both solid artists.

[@alexsousa551]

When I saw the title I was like "Both are incredible ! this is going to be a tough battle!"

[@Diva_D]

These two icons have also dueted together and created a magical moment..

[@varunravi27]

I would say they're equally good vocalists, with P!nk having better lows and Kelly having a slight advantage over P!nk in the middle register. I personally prefer Kelly's voice because my preference goes towards bright, warm voices (not that P!nk's voice isn't warm, because it really is... it's just that it lacks the brightness that can be heard in Kelly's voice. You really can't blame her for being a mezzo-soprano though... despite being one, she could still put up a good fight with Kelly, a soprano, in the upper belting range)

[@maria4hitz]

In the beginning kelly's singing At Last on Idol in 2015. She won in 2002 and At Last was one of the songs she auditioned with.

[@zacharycox9835]

We need more of both of these amazing ladies in your channel more often!!!

[@FranBsbone]

i adore both, but Kelly is my 1

[@dlh975]

Love how you point out that at a certain level it’s just personal preference. People seem to forget that.

[@lanceh6464]

2 of the best singers ever! I absolutely can't believe they haven't made a single together (YET, hopefully). They. Are. Everything!

[@CryNoAngel]

I can't choose between them. They're both my favorite!

[@sbomorse]

Pink always sounds so amazing live.

[@lukecampbell276]

I love them both. Their voices are amazing. I will say, for the most part, I prefer Kelly, but Pink is awesome too!

[@mitnosnah4134]

Who picked Kelly’s best vocals Cos god they were almost on her bad days 😱 love pink but god kelly needed much better representation of her voice in this shes a legend. Not taking anything from pink. Actually neither videos for both showed both their vocals. Disappointed with this one !!

[@manthonyramirez3217]

Yes! Especially in the hazel eyes clip there were many high notes she recorded but didn't perform in that video. Odds are she had been on a string of performances just before that and she even admitted she can hit every big note every time and even without hitting them she still owned it and made it sound natural

[@Mariskasvu17]

I was gonna say this! The clip of hazel eyes is one of the worst I have ever heard her do that song. Like there is a huge note on that song she hits all the time and it was one of the few times she has not sung it

[@Hannah_96]

God I love Kelly so much, my childhood

[@marrouu]

I'm so excited to see this episode I can't even speculate both of them are great singers

[@Jaimeheartbeat]

Pink is just amazing, I love Kelly Clarkson and she is amazing, but Pink is just beyond for me.

[@pauljohnkelly3972]

The end video should of been them performing Everybody Hurts together 💙💙

[@sarpiyicil771]

KELLY CLARKSON IS MY QUEEN ❤

[@freudlacan6892]

Sarp İyicil mine too !!Turkey loves the queen😃 !!

[@acb1057]

MORE KELLY!!!! (but love Pink too!')

[@mirkofrollano1265]

I love that you chose to compare these two incredibly great artists and also stunning and honest women. They’ve done nothing but build each other up over the years. That is kind of music industry we want to see. :) oh, and why should I have to choose between Kelly and P!nk? Uh-ah.

[@Luke_Balbino]

I really love both of their uniquenesses 👌🏼😍

[@ANNIE_R_U_OK]

I don't think it matters who the best singer is or who has the most extravagant shows. To me it's about the music and what ever you prefer.

[@Erikakicute]

Pink is amazing, such a great role model 💕

[@l.a.smittie7412]

Kelly's performance of "At Last" was from Season 14 of American Idol, Top 8 results show (I think). It was 10 months after giving birth to her daughter and about a year before giving birth to her son!

[@danieltaylor7993]

Pinks vocals have never changed. She’s outstanding

[@Cal90208]

Trust me, they have. Just listen to a clip from 2019. She still has the range, but no rasp!

[@AndySaenz]

That first clip of Kelly was from American Idol, many years after she won. She was a guest judge there around 2013.

[@Mia-rp6wc]

Kelly is insanely talented

[@jackmcfarland]

O had no idea Kelly is this good. Very very impressed. She made me a fresh fan. But Pink. Looove her

[@jancoetzee945]

Ikrr kelly is Amazing

[@glenndavies8694]

I love both. Emencly. Though I dont properly understand the use of proper technique and so one. So I'll leave that in your capable hands.

[@ryanwong7054]

Glenn Davies Do you mean ‘immensely’?

[@jimcovert238]

Check out Kelly and Pink at 2017 American Music Awards.

[@theusaosb]

YAAAAAAAAAS!

[@rydbthatsme]

I hated that performance truthfully because they both weren’t sure where to go because theyre so similar it sounded messy.

[@MandyAmsterdam]

I love them both but I’ve watched Pink live in June and she was OUTSTANDING!!!

[@FazliAllisonSwiftVEVO]

First clip of Kelly Clarkson : She was performed "At Last" as the guest artist on American Idol XIV 💕 You guys can watch the full video of her performing that song by search that title ... The Greatest American Idol of All 😭 *Anyway i hope you guys can follow me on instagram : Fazli Allison Swift 🙈

[@sianhughes5380]

They're both absolute fabulous singers!!👏👏👏👍👍😊

[@arleshabanks6050]

Not long enough!!! Please have a part 2 Great video 😍😍😍

[@matthewhagner7803]

Both incredible but Kelly is a bit better technically... she has a larger range she is able to utilize because of it. But I think it’s due to her being classically trained to sing Opera

[@popland1977]

Having a larger range doesn't make you better

[@onaraluiza8750]

Dude, Pink can sing in any freaking position lol

[@lexgraham2118]

@@popland1977 EXACTLY. PINK IS ACTUALLY MORE CONSISTENT TECHNICALLY. KELLY HAS STATED HERSELF THAT SHE OFTEN SACRIFICES TECHNIQUE FOR EMOTIONAL CONTENT. I PREFER KELLY'S VOICE BECAUSE SHE CAN SING ALMOST ANYTHING. PINK HAS A BETTER A CATALOGUE, AND HAS ACTUALLY BECOME A BETTER VOCALIST POST POST CHILDREN WHEREAS KELLY OFTEN DROPS THE ORIGINAL KEY SINCE BECOMING A MOTHER.

[@Liam-mv9zi]

I don't know about her having a larger range than P!NK. I think you forget that she has amazing range in the lower parts of her voice going down to I believe a G2 or something crazy like that. Then she goes up to 6th octave notes too. And as a MEZZO, nonetheless! Of course Kelly has a higher belting range, but that's simply because she's a soprano.

[@matthewhagner7803]

Liam 8005 I am a professional vocalist and have worked with both artists... I’ve known pink and her hubby for over ten years. I speak from experience with both artists

[@tonyrocket2103]

They are both fantastic but I much prefers Pinks songs as well as her deeply emotional touch that she always adds. Not to mention she can dance and do acrobatics. Pink is a highly underrated master of her craft. Kelly Clarkson is just as good if not better of a technical singers but there is a certain connection I have with Pink's style that puts her ahead for me.

[@jakabpolyak8015]

That because of you note is not her most difficult note by far 😂😂 Since you been gone's "again", Behind this hazel eyes's "anymore" (F#5), Mrs. independent's "see" and a lot more. That note is difficult tho but there's a lot more like that.

[@christianmaples2650]

That Because of you note is probably her most difficult because of the way she pronounces it. Her others are on very open vowels, but that one is very closed and difficult for almost anyone to reach that Eb5 area while being resonate and we'll placed without straining.

[@rydbthatsme]

I was thinkin same thing plus MOL has her most difficult notes to date. Also that Natural Woman AI performance is what made her career tbh.

[@myeenglishclass7540]

That note really is a killer. I remember nailing it only once so far. A few years ago. Now.. 😭😭😭😭😭

[@alexandervelez9507]

both have great technique. pink’s tone is more emotive and slays lower notes but kelly has a bigger range and is a slightly better belter. it’s just a matter of personal preference. in a technical sense i’d give the edge to kelly.

[@eduardosanmiguelsalas2086]

I think both have very similar technique both can really sing anything just i hope this video will base on the past and the current vocals of both singers because pink doesn't have the rasp anymore

[@freudlacan6892]

KELLY CLARKSON 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍

[@MeMe-m3m3]

Awsome Video. Amazing Concept on Your Platform ❣❣ I Been A Fan Of Your Page From The Beginning of your Career..... Your Awsome. The Best in this Sector of KZbin.

[@lukuscannon9697]

It is way too hard to choose one because I love the both of them it was truly awesome when they did a duet together in 2017

[@aaronculp6743]

although i love kelly SO much, pinks rasp and belts send chills down my spine. pink wins for me