Hornby Henry vs Bachmann Henry - Who's Better?

[@quattros1e2]

I find that Bachmann Thomas models are TVS Accurate, while Hornby Thomas models are Awdry Accurate.

[@levidarling5107]

I like that theory, however, I don’t know about Edward though. 😕

[@ChimpyWallah]

@@levidarling5107and Emily And Percy

[@levidarling5107]

@@ChimpyWallah Well keep in mind, Emily was not an Awdry character.

[@ChimpyWallah]

@@levidarling5107 yeah but she has a very clear basis of the Stirling single

[@levidarling5107]

@@ChimpyWallah Precisely, however, Hornby made her with a dean single rather than a sterling single.

[@SudrainRailways]

I love the new intro

[@modelrailfan37]

For those who don’t know, the audio was overlapping in the first upload, hence the re-upload. Great video Oliver, and well done for fixing the problem! Also, don’t feel bad Oliver, we’re all human, and we all make mistakes!

[@stastudios730]

7:32 Please tell me I'm not the only one that heard Nintendo

[@F4productions4072]

Why don’t you try the strength test with both of the Henry’s you got

[@RedJubilee]

IMO, Henry is probably Hornby’s best model.

[@Mr.Mario1985]

What about murdoch?

[@Train-series]

Hey Oliver I just want to ask do you have the Percy the tank engine?

[@carlettablake9811]

The secondary you showed it’s based off of the model engine version, which was the first Thomas & Friends. The second one is based off of the more animated weirder realistic one.

[@Gkitty7889]

when are you going live?

[@Cyber_Horse_Studios87]

Honestly the Hornby Thomas line of engines have always had an unfair advantage compared to the Bachman engines. Many of them were fitted with traction tires. Which by default makes them go faster and pull more… I feel like if the Bachman line were given traction tires. They would probably preform a little bit better, at least in terms of pulling. I doubt adding traction tires to the Bachman diesel would make him go faster. XD

[@ChristoFourie-jy1xd]

One thing l saw there horns is deferent but l love you're videos 😊

[@lukepolkow2775]

When will you do more trainz a new era

[@stevenrobertson3635]

Well I mean the difference is Bachmann went and made there trains look like the characters while hornby they just painted there real life loco and slapped a face on them.

[@christopherpatrick4039]

Hornby version is stronger in build, but the Bachman is far better in detail

[@saintsheepy6682]

I wish Hornby kept making Thomas models, whilst both Henrys are cool, the Hornby one looks better.

[@islesofforeignrails7917]

I think the OO scale ones are suited for collectors, but they are inexpensive for children. Their 009 SKR range, and N scale/G scale Standard Gauge range have more weight and durability to them as collectible models.

[@ToastTheThe]

It's funny how the bachmann models sre supposed to be tv series accurate and the hornby models are (apparently) supposed to be railway series accurate Even though neither aren't reallyy accurate Bachmann Henry's tender is too short, the US release has gray axle boxes and lamp irons, and his eyes are too small While the hornby one has green axle boxes, too bright of a shade of green, and a white running board

[@BuilderBroWasTaken]

Do y’all pronounce it “bock-man” or “back-man”

[@paulshirley6383]

Hornby Henry vs Bachmann Henry - Who's Better? LaZeR JET love louis shirley

[@Sa_mu_ra_i924]

And now test that wich henry is stronger by adding trucks loaded whit something

[@SteamyTheJ50]

I'll go with both of them. Double o scale and h o scale

[@Marsisgonnaleaveya]

‘Da Boxes’

[@javanicworks-id]

Bachmann Henry is more accurate, but It's safe to say that the Hornby Henry has a better quality.

[@joeleboeuf]

I think the Bachmann version of Henry is the more accurate version.

[@stuartbarclay7940]

Oh, hey, look! It's the two Henry's!😆 Sorry! I couldn't resist! But in all seriousness, I think both the Hornby and Bachmann models are great.

[@sudrianrailwaystudios676]

I choose the Hornby Version of Henry.

[@TyfilmsGP3020]

Hornby Henry look kind of looks like railway series Henry

[@Iliketrains-z6s]

Moving eyesssssssss

[@seamusmcbratnie8316]

I prefer the Hornby Henry HANDS DOWN

[@Iliketrains-z6s]

I think the Bachmann Thomas characters look so much better

[@Iliketrains-z6s]

Don’t call them trains call them engines You called trains like the things you pull like a good train or an express train

[@AlexSanchez-bn1vu]

Honestly, I thought Hornby Henry was better 😄😄😄

[@mccoy79productions66]

Awesome

[@James.exe5]

But it’s okay, because I never had a model because I live in Saudi Arabia and they don’t sell model trains and there’s like little bit of Thomas toys, which is I love Thomas and I wanna Bachman James for my birthday but it’s very expensive on Amazon for me to buy by the way I’m a 10-year-old, but I really want Bockman James with a set and Henry

[@joshuaW5621]

If you want to model the Railway Series, go for the Hornby Henry. If you want to model the TV Series, go for the Bachmann Henry.

[@exarkun42]

This largely applies for both ranges in general. Hornby (with the exceptions of Edward and Emily) actually used the real basis where they could, and modified for good looking models of the characters when they couldn't used the actual basis

[@claircond1491]

B

[@SethyReach]

Bachman Henry’s side rods are to bulky for fast speeds

[@SirhanAbraqi]

i think i see that lighter green

[@TrainzAndPlanez36]

can you to Hornby vs Bachman flying Scotsman also for the next live stream can you do tornado with the pullman coaches (with the observation car) (and clan line AP MK 2 support coach at the front) on the Kings Cross to Peterborough route but starting at kings cross and then when u get to kings cross, you go to the back of the train and go back to Peterborough pls Note: its a live stream idea

[@Mr.MenandLittlemissstuff]

Henry is a Lms black 5

[@carlettablake9811]

I’m not for comment I put I meant the HB he can’t say it zombie Homie whatever it is you want with the face you like better

[@fimoyandfriends]

nice videos..

[@1000guy1]

The Bachmann Henry’s face is susposed to be based off his season 2 face

[@davidsheriff8989]

Hornby's driving mecanism looks more realistic...

[@Daniel-c9x4z]

When is the next model railway update

[@claircond1491]

Ti

[@colinburr1316]

I think The Bachmann Henry is better.

[@Itsakids]

I agree

[@monicagende1651]

S hornby cuz it is not creepy like bachman

[@claircond1491]

T

[@Fireman_Glass]

Hornby Henry, it’s not a debate

[@datguymiller]

Depends what you want, accurate appearance or good mech

[@claircond1491]

Ie

[@iindseywarrior4533]

Aop😮😮😮😮😮

[@tobywylie-gregson5811]

I do prefer Hornby but I do have some bachmann in my collection, only Mavis and Scottish twins tho

[@rhyswisbey9314]

I saw flying Scotsman at Newbury Showground

[@davidhall5868]

I think I prefer the Hornby Henry which is based on the awdry illustration in his books

[@ToastTheThe]

Nah it's not really based directly off the illustrations, it's just a model of a real Stanier class painted green and has a face slapped onto it

[@giulianodervelociraptorder734]

I really like Bachmann Henry.

[@Alextrains502]

Hi

[@JohnathanAndrews-mb8zu]

Love it

[@kalilarifda1688]

Horby did a better henry

[@NWRailfansproductions]

Either Is cool to me

[@harrisonallen651]

Hornby all the way!

[@Tilosigi]

bachman henry is a trash bag compared to hornby henry bachman henry is a bit too small has too thick siderods its slow and its just a dissapointment compared to hornby henry

[@alfiestrains7190]

of corse you choose hornby again the bachmann one is incredibly better the quality is better overall it looks like henry its like your hornby and bachmann torando you choose the awful hornby one...

[@paulshirley6383]

Hornby Henry vs Bachmann Henry - Who's Better? LaZeR JET love louis shirley