HOW does Liza Minnelli's voice compare with her mothers? Let's see with ISOLATED vocals!

[@alangray9117]

I saw Liza in 1985. She was one of the best concert dollars I ever spent. She had that charisma that her mother had and the singing and dancing chops too. She was really into getting the crowd to it's feet. She was totally incredible. She's an American treasure. I would have loved to have seen Judy. She never tired of questions about her mother and took comparisons as a compliment. She also always had my respect for finishing raising her younger brother and sister after Judy's tragic death.

[@Katatawnic]

I am so jealous! I'd have given anything to see Liza perform. (Within reason; maybe not my firstborn. lol) This is a treasure! Liza and Judy performing "Hello Dolly" together. Enjoy! kzbin.info/www/bejne/a4KWip-kfZija68

[@pandapeep1148]

She also paid her mother's debts after she died. She called The Rat Pack, who had been like uncles to her, and asked if they could help her get booked at the casinos to pay off her mother's debts because, as she put it, there had been so much gossip about her mother that she wasn't going to have it said that her mother's bills didn't get paid. She felt she could at least flip that part of the negative gossip about her mother to a positive. She's also never bad-mouthed her mother and was also proud of her sister when Lorna began to sing vs. feeling threatened. THAT is what a good daughter and sister does.

[@travisgrant5608]

Oh yes! I was fortunate enough to see Liza in concert twice! The first time I saw her was right after she won the academy award for best actress for her roll in the movie CABARET. What a dynamic performance she gave in concert both times. Just incredible! 👍🤗❤

[@loretta_3843]

It's just such a genetic gift to begin with, but it looks like she must have enjoyed performing because she put such work into it and became so good at it herself. I wouldn't have had the courage to sing when everyone knew who her mother was. I'd always fear letting people down. She's also wonderful as one of those performers that makes it all look so simple. I just really admire her work ethic and the high standard she strove to reach.

[@zoewilliams3706]

I saw Liza in 2009, flew from Nz to Sydney. Best money I ever spent. Man sitting next to me said "I would ask you if you're enjoying yourself but...." as I was crying and smiling and clapping

[@Tecobelli]

Here is a clip from the performance you saw. Must have been a great night: kzbin.info/www/bejne/ipK2kqh_hr2Ies0

[@nytransplant7883]

I've followed Liza for awhile. She has always been a consummate professional. I played my moms LP of cabaret until it was well worn and I had to replace it with a new CD. Liza was under her mother's tutelage since childhood. Just Watch Judy Garland's Christmas special. Liza was already a gifted performer, mixing it up with her mom and guests like Mel Torme at only 17 years old. Fil, your dissection of Liza's vocals as well as the comparison with Judy's vocals was wonderful. Your incredible ability to pinpoint a vocalists particular qualities is stellar! Thank you.

[@cindybrodie9769]

Great comment! I agree about Fil’s skill and artistry in presenting these vocalist. He’s great.

[@thecatatemyhomework]

Judy Garland was 17 when she first sang Over The Rainbow.

[@Destinyslotus]

Liza is one of the most underrated singers. She’s sensational.

[@miaschu8175]

I can't imagine anyone not appreciating Liza Minelli's amazing voice.

[@jareddavidhirsh4948]

You’re deluded! Lol

[@Druezer]

How is she underrated?

[@jamesmcinnis208]

@@Druezer "Underrated" is what not-terribly-bright people sometimes say instead of "I like her."

[@tanya5322]

@@jamesmcinnis208 “underrated” could also mean “underrated by todays prime marketing demographic of 20 and 30 something’s. My adult children probably have no idea who Liza is, and might only know her mother from The Wizard of Oz. Additionally, I imagine there were people who felt she was only famous because she was riding her parents’ coattails

[@onthefive5615]

Liza uses drama a bit differently than mom Judy, in that her dynamic body language matches the story she's telling. Judy's dramatic delivery, on the other hand, was tied to the words she sang. She was a great drama coach (unconsciously) to Liza in this regard, and mentioned in an interview how happy she was that Liza had more freedom of expression than she herself was permitted.

[@ImTash]

which interview was this do you know? i'd be interested in reading it.

[@funonyoutube1716]

That's fascinating!

[@glamgal7106]

I read in one of her biographies, Judy mentioned that when she was pregnant with Liza, she could already that she was a performer because of the way she was kicking. Thanks for a splendid and informative analysis of Liza’s performance. I appreciated every nuance that you pointed out-your thorough approach is massively appreciated! You hit the nail on the head when you mentioned that we could go on for years analyzing and comparing the similarities/differences between the voices of mother and daughter. Nevertheless, there’s no question that they were immensely talented singers and performers. Thanks for this wonderful analysis, Fil!

[@moogarner374]

I have a couple of great memories of meeting her. I ran into her, literally, going out a door backwards at The El Tovar, in the Grand Canyon, and then I was selling balloons at The Parade of Roses. She saw me and yelled out at me from the sun roof of a limousine. When they pulled up next to me, she tells me, I’ve got to have some of those balloons. Then she saw my venders license and says Hey! I know you! Lol. She was a pleasure to meet.

[@deniseheupel8814]

What a beautiful story! I love that you gave her such a moment of joy!👍😎👍

[@moogarner374]

@@deniseheupel8814 I have a lot of really great memories of celebrities... Never asked for an autograph but once and that was Aaron Tippen when his Toolbox cd came out. He was doing a Walmart tour. But oh, I've met so many people. My 2 favorites are Elvis Presley and BB King. Both are long stories but nice memories nonetheless. They were really just genuine people. And I don't fan girl well lol. I just like talking to people. Charlie Rich became a friend of mine because he came into my store one day and I made he and his wife fresh coffee. He followed me from store to store just so he could hang out and talk. He was a very nice and gentle man. Just so many awesome memories. Liza was the 3rd one to recognize me upon our 2nd meeting. I was shocked and awed by that, considering all the people she had met you know? Got several private concerts from Jerry Lee Lewis and saw him in concert 3 times. Met Jack Clugman at a gas station in La Jolla. He was driving a beat up old 63 Chevy that belonged to his Gardener lol what a nice man he was too. Even met Alabama at the Grand Canyon before they got big. I like to think I gave them a break from the madness celebrities sometimes endure.

[@deniseheupel8814]

@@moogarner374 sounds like you're an interesting person to run into! This world needs those that remind us that life should be fun and interesting! 👍😎👍

[@moogarner374]

@@deniseheupel8814 thank you!

[@keetonplace]

@@moogarner374 Yes you have met some good ones. I met a lot of them because I worked at the airport. Back then they didn't have private jets. John and Yoko sat in some seats near me and no one bothered them. They were in my city because her daughter was here with the ex and they were attempting to get her. They got up and walked past me and he said hello. I thought that was sweet. Dean Martin came through one night and my co-worker fell off her stool as he walked past laughing. Met Glen Campbell up in the VIP room because he was nice enough to allow anyone to come up and the lines formed. This was in his hay day. Saw him at the end in the "final concert tour" in Galveston at a wonderful venue, and he was quite good, though well into Alzheimer's. Saw Elvis all the time in Vegas and my city, and like you said, so many more to even list. Reason? Where I worked, and Vegas, where I played. Saw Liza in Vegas and here. Got back stage twice, with pictures. She was very kind. Those were the days! Wish I would have taken a camera to work.

[@slbarbieri1725]

I have always adored how Liza FEELS every song she sings! And I've always loved her personality. Thanks for this one, Fil!

[@h.briseno8597]

I like watching Fil’s reactions… not only does he smile, but his eyes smile too!

[@cos2mer2]

Hey Fil, great piece on Liza; She is totally unique and wonderful. For me there cannot be a comparison to Judy. The Divine Miss Garland is in a musical universe of her very own. Her talent was so profound that, like Mozart, or Elvis, there will never be a way to calculate the miracle. Thank you for this offering. You enrich us music lovers with every post!!!!!!!

[@mariannetracy4248]

For me, the Divine Ms. Minnelli is in a musical universe shared by her mother. But as you say, profound like Mozart and Elvis. I so enjoyed Phil's presentation, and everyone's comments. More than music, this is a kind of soul music without of much of the R but a lot of the &B!

[@stephaniestanley8041]

Liza with a Z. The best televised concert ever! And thank you for your expertise. Just amazing.

[@drewpall2598]

Both Mom and Daughter have that enjoyable quality to their vocals. there are television footages of both of them singing together on KZbin that are wonderful to watch. thanks Fil 😊

[@RC0307]

She inherited her pipes from her Mother and is a legend in her own right. Love her!! 💖

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

Liza was an amazing actor and stunning performer but she could sang. Can’t imagine another Sally Bowles but she could invade a role surreptitiously as well. She may have inherited talent but she could and did work it. Thanks for featuring her Fil❤❤

[@mariefraher8725]

Stunning analysis! I was lucky enough to see Liza in concert in Boston so many years ago. She was so talented and gave it her all. The YSL wardrobe, Liza with a Z, New York, New York, Cabaret tunes etc. Terrific show woman. She had the audience eating out of her hands.

[@thehistoryprof6750]

I saw Liza perform once in the early 70s in Memphis. I still remember the feeling that she left everything on that stage...as if she expected this to be her last performance 💔. Wonderful review Fil. Thank you.

[@blackprix]

Yes it’s going to be very very interesting, Judy Garland just had one of the most magnificent voices ever, and her daughter came along and stepped it up with her own voice! I’m anxious to hear what you have to say on this one. The interesting dynamic about this family. Liza has half sister Lorna Luft who Also has a great voice😊

[@zenawarrior7442]

Great comparison with two amazing ladies & voices. Thanks Fil😊🎼🎙🎹

[@markcollins457]

To see Liza live it was captivating she made you feel you were the only one in the room. All of the twists cracks and turns in her voice builds and says "BROADWAY"

[@filmmekker]

I too think she’s a very underrated singer,. She always gets the meaning of the song over.

[@dalebaker9109]

Liza was an entertainer in the full sense of the word. And incredibly like her mum. Fabulous video Fil.

[@gregsayles9253]

Phil!--Your breadth of musical interest & knowledge encompassing many genres & your upbeat, positive, & accurate -"analysis" always keeps me interested in your video's! / Btw, Liza's long-time piano & musical accompaniment & confident is a personal friend of mine & well known jazz pianist--I'll be sure to pass this video on to him & I'm sure he'll have her give it a look as well / Keep up the good-work 👍!

[@cheneyrobert]

Great Greg….hope they like it 👍🥂

[@gregsayles9253]

@@cheneyrobert Me too!!

[@MelindadelosSantos]

Just one look from the start and no one can deny she’s amicable, charming and bombastic.😊

[@lynndow3185]

Parent/child vocal and performance comparisons are fascinating to me. It's uncanny when they are very similar, like Roger Miller's son, Dean, who sounds so much like his dad, or Liza, who is unmistakably Judy's daughter. Thank you for pointing out what an individual talent Liza is, but showing the identical aspects. Lovely analysis!

[@jameshall9402]

Yeah, Jason Gould, who is Streisand's son, had the gift passed on tp him. He's really very good.

[@cannibal4363]

Proves how diverse and honest your analysis truly are covering different genres.. ty

[@douglasswicegood4420]

Love Judy and Liza.

[@brianoneil6659]

Watching Fil break into his infectious smile is always thrilling.

[@rshafter4607]

This guy is brilliant!

[@tammywilks8782]

Excellent comparison, loved that the pitch monitoring software picked up the cry! Thanks again Fil!

[@1Moonchild]

Great analysis, Fil. Mother and daughter both equally gifted with their own way of delivering songs, but definitely linked with genetic similarities.

[@johnb4314]

You're a highly skilled teacher. Thanks.

[@rlmack5]

You are very likeable, and you attend to quality singers. Many thanks ... very interesting.

[@videocat1366]

This was such an interesting analysis. I've always heard Judy in Liza's voice, yet couldn't put my finger on why because they do sound different. But the things you pointed out explain it.

[@debrabeck9630]

I had the Cabaret album, and I loved it. She was magnificent. This was when I was just getting into theater, although I did not have the voice for musicals. Wished I did! Thanks, so much, Fil. This was fascinating.

[@nancymiller2046]

We grew up listening to Liza Minelli's Cabaret ( my sister played it constantly for awhile). Although young at the time I knew her voice was magic. Great analysis,Fil... thank you!

[@teddycuthbert]

On the topic of the ‘vocal cry’, I would be absolutely fascinated to see your analysis of Ethel Waters’ performance of ‘Suppertime’ - she literally ends the song sobbing, and the progression to get there through song is quite haunting!

[@margaretmuenchau5450]

2 of my favorite singers! Really interesting comparison!

[@Nunofurdambiznez]

dude.. not only are you absolutely ADORABLE, but this video, paired with your earlier Judy Garland video, are two of your best ones ever! If you ever want to go classical, you might want to consider opera diva Beverly Sills. Her voice was that of a true angel from Heaven, imo!

[@NeilNoble-z7e]

This host is absolutely brilliant. So interesting, articulate, and talented. I enjoyed this.

[@wingsofpegasus]

Thanks!

[@emitch9213]

Liza was vocally very filled with some cold symptoms when I sat 4 row performance. She also had 6 corp gents, 3 each side of her, with the dance breaks around her as partner. She had an energy high as she was physically caught into her partners and had to sing less. How clever the choreography of the dancers covered around her to catch any fall, because she had 2 full hip replaced. I gave my parents 2 tickets to see her at a youthful peak. I had no idea how they would respond to her being the Rat Pack, Count Basie, Ella Fitgerald fans, but I received a long distance call from them at my university dorm raving about her sensational performance. I was surprised but very very grateful my parents had a great night. Of course, her mom was a phenomenal gift of nature. It is always the greats that never know how gifted they are. 🌹💝

[@lindadescafano3749]

Great performance by Liza Minnelli and it is interesting to see how her voice is so similar when you compare it to her mother's with the pitch monitor.

[@lynnmcquillan2338]

I was so happy to see this clip Fil.. Lisa was so talented- she did have the drama - the storytelling.. the emotion- you believe she’s had heartbreak/vulnerability 💔 but also that she’s still standing !! - you gotta love it 😊 thanks Fil 😘🎄🤶🇦🇺🙇‍♀️

[@marilynsheffield612]

Great analysis Fil. 👏🎸😊

[@phxtopdog]

One of the things, among many, that keeps me coming back to your videos is the obvious love you have for music and your ever-prsent smile as you watch and listen. You seem so joyful. Saw in the mid 90s, and she was incredible. Consumate performer and vocalist. Thanks for this analysis video, and all the others you do.

[@kevinobrien7731]

Great, you really captivate us along with the artists. Should you ever do Judy Garland again, I think "Old Man River" from the Judy Garland show would be a terrific analysis. This and Judy's were terrific and educational. Thanks!

[@fallionwater117]

Thank you Fil. :)

[@lynnmcquillan2338]

You’re amazing Fil !!! 💓💓💓😊🇦🇺🎄

[@dadca9705]

I have always thought their singing was totally different. However, the effects on the live audience was the same. Loved your analysis. "Maybe This Time" is a song written by John Kander and Fred Ebb for actress Kaye Ballard, Liza’s godmother.

[@TheLisab56]

Dad CA, I'm sure that you meant Kay Thompson.

[@victorianguyen6620]

Fill ur videos are so interesting. I love Judy and Liza!

[@dmcarp2807]

Terrific analysis of a theatrical vocalist's skills. Also, unnerving visuals of the similarity of vocal line frequency between family.

[@hiyahandsome]

Thank you, Fil, I love your analysis of some of my favorite singers, you are a brilliant musician and you are able to show us what made these stars so magnificent. Cheers~

[@larryb8022]

❤️ she has a powerful voice and she delivers.❤️rock on👍🏻

[@donaldnavatto9890]

Magnificent voice and entertainer💕

[@dorenechase6614]

I have always loved them both completely!!!! How i wish Liza would still perform. I do see her with Michael Feinstine...so thankful he still promotes her. This was beyond great Fil!!!!!💝💝

[@luvsjudy]

I Was 13 In 67 When My Uncle Frankie A Editor For Look Magazine Brought Me To See Judy At The Westbury Music Fair And The Palace…In 74 I Saw Liza For The First Time At The Wintergarden…I Have Seen Every Concert Of Liza’s In New York, New Jersey And Connecticut Since ♥️4Ever!!!

[@angelaboncore3132]

Excellent analysis between mother and daughter. Yes there certainly similarities between the two right down to the tone and vibrato in their voices. Liza certainly is a showman and inherited that wonderful quality from her parents....

[@OldiesMomma]

wow thank you fil for doing this song of liza m. i never heard her before. thamk you again

[@MagickwithaK]

I didn't even know they were mother and daughter. You learn something new every day.

[@susankirkland3852]

Really interesting and entertaining, regardless of whether I enjoy the actual singers. Thanks Phil … always learn something from your analysis 👍

[@stephaniethurmer5370]

Fil, I love that you are going back and visiting some of the legends. Thank you. Would you consider doing either Mario Puzo or the great Enrico Caruso?

[@jonathanhacker5025]

Willie Nelson does that and it’s very effective. He plays the guitar and then comes in a few beats later with the words. It does make you concentrate and tune in on the story he’s telling. Never thought I’d be comparing Liza with Willy. It’s the first thing I thought of when Fil pointed out that she comes in a few beats after the music.

[@mariannetracy4248]

I'm about Liza's age. LOVE her. My mom's favorite female vocalist was Judy. In the late 1960's on TV, I couldn't relate to her and could tell there was something too wounded for me to watch at my young age. However, after watching this video and all the Judy fans, I just went out to watch her again, on a youTube of "I'll Never Walk Alone." It's like nothing I've never heard before -- INCREDIBLE! . It's like a holdover from the unspoken pain of the Great Depression and WWII, that still could be tapped under the Post WWII prosperity in the US. She spoke to my Mom, and now she speaks to me.

[@sherryspectre217]

I am privileged, to have been alive in the latter part of Judy's life, and for the entirety, of Liza's. Both are extraordinary, entertainers and true artist. However, I would NEVER compare them to each other. Some things are just sacred....🤘🏽✌🏼❤️🌱 Thank you, for this video and ALL of your analysis.

[@jamesmcinnis208]

I just adore commas.

[@davidadams9391]

WOW! Fantastic! She is Great live!!!

[@tod3msn]

Liza has taken better care of her voice over the years and I don’t think she was as troubled as her mom .

[@jofoster1596]

I think her father's love was responsible for a more grounded foundation

[@lesleysmith6245]

Watching from Sydney again. Fascinating analysis Fil. Thanks.

[@ivetoldyouonce]

Behind that voice are some exceptional musicians.

[@retha1875]

I always think of Liza in the movie, The Sterile Cuckoo. The song, Come Saturday Morning, was the theme song.

[@celestearellano3720]

Even with out the visual analysis my ear could hear the tone of both Judy and Liza's voices and know how similar they were. And yes Judy did get more dramatic as she aged. Like the BeeGee's voices were similar and it does beg the question is it learned by mimicry or is it inherited? I so enjoy seeing your analysis and listening to all your insights. Thanks for the ride.

[@christinedennison7770]

I adore judy and have since I was 6 after seeing the wizard of Oz and equally love Liza since Cabaret but would like to put in a word for Lorna luft who I saw in tribute to her mum, she is a much underated singer.

[@puddysue]

Have you ever checked Liza out in her prime belting out New York New York? Phenomenal!

[@wingsofpegasus]

I've heard her yes!🙂

[@puddysue]

@@wingsofpegasus Please sometime do a reaction video on Liza belting out New York New York live! It is totally phenomenal!!!!!!!!!!!

[@Sunfleuria]

What an interesting topic!

[@ellecee453]

Liza Minnelli's father was famous as well: the Academy Award-winning Vincente Minnelli: one of my favorite directors ever! Check out the fantastic films he directed.

[@Gregorius24]

The original key of “Over the Rainbow” from “Wizard of Oz” (in Herbert Stothart’s score) is in A-flat major. The digital tuner tends to choose enharmonic pitches and reads it as G-sharp.

[@steveb1164]

When she was on Inside the Actor's Studio Liza said that she does text analysis of every sone she sings: who is she? what does she want? what's her secret? That's why she doesn't just sing songs--she acts them.

[@HM-sp4cr]

I loved this great performance and your analysis. She’s like the Janis Joplin of musical theater, digging down deep for a fabulous performance.

[@CharlesHess]

She and Loudon Wainwright iii were neighbors as kiddos.

[@JulieAiken]

Fantastic analysis. Two of the best!

[@jagodenskyMuse]

Would love to hear your analysis of Mel Torme…very informative and enjoyable series…

[@missyroth452]

I grew up listening to Judy, and being a singer, I have always known the similarities in their voices. Seeing it on the program you use, makes it more clear. I love watching these videos! P.S. What program do you use?

[@pixie3760]

How strange that I was just thinking of Judy Garland....god knows why, and I saw this! Love it! She really does remind me of her mother, but she owns it well

[@janiscalaba4932]

Thats why she is soooo good on stage! ✌️❤️

[@WorldWideWebObserver]

Interesting video! Thanks Fil!🌻

[@Ozzcaddy]

G'day Phil, excellent video on 2 icons in the entertainment industry Liza Minelli and her mother Judy Garland. Liza was married to Australian Peter Allen between 1967 - 1974, so we got to see a lot of Liza in Australia during those times on various TV shows which she would always perform in the same way as seen in your video. Both Liza and Peter were performers on stage. Have you ever done an analysis of Peter Allen? Thanks once again.

[@matthewdarnell3535]

Liza is amazing! I always loved her voice but my favorite was her Radio city concert. Her voice had deepened with age and had some rasp to it. I absolutely loved it!

[@BTURNER1961]

Here you are definitely analyzing a bonefide musical theater voice. Liza has the credentials on the Broadway stage her mother did not. She won tonies for her work in book musicals Flora the Red Menace, The Act, and was nominated for the Rink. She also replaced Julie Andrews in Victor/Victoria and Gwen Verdon in Chicago. She also of course stared in her own one woman show 'Liza' But certainly Judy had a very theatrical style, choosing to 'perform' many of her numbers in character on the concert stage, and she certainly showed some real acting talent in her later movie roles. At the top of her game, Judy may have been the most unforgettable presence on the concert circuit in the twentieth century. Unlike Liza, Judy had a bittersweet frailty, an Eith Piaf quality to her . Liza excudes that strength, power, that bravado. I am an unabashed admirere of both.

[@jhamaul-antoinegreatness1529]

And that is Ms. LIza Minnelli.

[@livinglife4835]

Thanks!

[@SandViolet]

Fascinating!

[@larryh7760]

Incredible analysis. I've always thought they naturally sounded similar but never realized how much. I'd love a to see a comparison of John & Julian Lennon.

[@TheJPGR64]

I really appreciate your insightful analysis of vocal performances. I would recommend analyzing Lara Fabian, Je suis malade or Adagio.

[@ScottRoney]

Fil have you ever seen the White House performance by Linda Ronstandt and Aaron Neville? I think it is a truly outstanding and unique performance. I’d love to see your analysis!

[@angelacarleton9575]

I can see that as Liza has aged she started to show more ways to improvised the bravado. Amazing that Judy did start to be that way as she aged too and sung her songs too.

[@alegramonticelli6038]

Would be interesting to know if Barbra Streisands and Jason Goulds voices are that similar

[@jareddavidhirsh4948]

I was thinking about this too:)

[@bojack40]

her performance skills (as you say) are without parallel (exc. Judy of course). When she sings the word ‘happy’ you actually see her eyes twinkle!!! Watch it and see

[@homegown1234]

I love Liza Minelli's voice and vibrato and "Powerhouse talent" but I also have a lot of respect for Judy Garland due to her years of experience in acting and musical talent where she was so perfect in her singing due to being told she is unique. Love each talent.

[@JimboSRP]

Again, just the insight and nuance, and depth of knowledge blows me away. Thank you Fil. I like how she changes her vowel sounds in the last syllable of "begin" to create an easier and richer sound. I know this probably sounds weird, but I'd be really interested to see a pitch/vocal analysis on someone not quite as adept. As in, what does it look like when someone is searching for the note constantly (Florence Foster Jenkins, for example). How far off the note are they at that "cringe" moment? Not meaning to be cruel, just very curious about the magnitude of difference between a "good" singer and a not as good one. Apologies if you have already done a video like this, I am relatively new to your channel and have not looked through everything yet.

[@JoeSoriero]

@wingsofpegasus I would love to see you take a look at Debbie Wileman’s album I’m Still Here - but it’s all about Judy Garland. Also an extraordinary backstory. Comparative view required.

[@gaylem4333]

Fascinating! Do you ever hear someone sing and think, that’s lovely? Or do all these thoughts go through your mind? I am a visual artist. At art school we learned to analyze a painting and decide why we feel the way we do about it. Is it the color, or is it the composition, etc.? Your analysis of a vocal performance seems similar.

[@nancywysemen7196]

thank-you.