How Israel is invading Gaza - visual investigation

Israel’s ground operation of Gaza has begun, but it’s not yet the all out assault many expected - by analysing satellite images and the limited footage coming out of the Gaza Strip - our visual analysis reveals how Israel and Hamas are fighting this war right now and why this conflict is unlike anything we’ve seen before.
(Subscribe: bit.ly/C4_News_Subscribe)
-------
Watch more of our explainer series here - • Coronavirus Explained
Get more news at our site - www.channel4.com/news/
Follow us:
Facebook - / channel4news
Twitter - / channel4news
TikTok - / c4news
Instagram - / channel4news

[@DoomFinger511]

Why does no one question that so many resources were used to make underground tunnels but never bomb shelters for the civilians in Gaza?

[@Frank-mi3sf]

How about schools and hospitals instead

[@dandandandandandandy]

You don't seem to understand the situation. If the money wouldn't have been spent on the tunnels and for weapons there would have been no need for shelters. It could have been spent on housing, health and education

[@xNazgrel]

Because Israel is is sending this money to Hamas directly through Qatar. Why do you expect Hamas to build anything for civilians? 🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@wingnut71]

​@@Frank-mi3sfthey have schools and hospitals, why build more than you need?

[@danielanthony8373]

No Hamas No need for bomb shelters

[@Moue666]

So you expect Israel to live broadcast their attack points and tactics for the whole world as well as for Hamas to see?

[@AB-su8wg]

No because it’s a genocide x

[@hamzanocap]

These people are the most arrogant on Earth and have been for thousands of years, of course we do.

[@benitosalazar3749]

I was thinking the same thing. The media is providing Hamas with some situational awareness.

[@kevinrod14]

They’re strengthening the hatred that Palestinians have towards them & since the population is about 50% under 18 all they know is violence & oppression from israel.. if they sent in SPECIAL FORCES they would have much more support.

[@labiaJohnken2567]

They are click bait ,mate. They want views .

[@wheelinthesky300]

Problem with a tunnel is that once its discovered, its discovered. You can't move it. And as many are interconnected, one discovered tunnel leads to another.

[@TheEgg185]

They can also be flooded. 😊

[@Memoiana]

Booby traps.. dead ends..

[@josephsade3423]

@@TheEgg185 heavy never ending flooding

[@josephsade3423]

@@TheEgg185 heavy never ending flooding

[@DoomFinger511]

The IDF is now using sponge bombs in the tunnels. There are grenades filled with an expansive foam that fills up and hardens the tunnel to prevent access or escape

[@4xpaul]

Who needs intel when the press broadcasts it for you? 😂😅

[@sooraj1104]

Also You can just buy it for a few dollars from priv satellite companies.

[@ItsJADA]

We use near maps at work all the time

[@galbeeri8360]

idf release some info but be sure they have some tricks

[@st.altair4936]

Israel has such a massive advantage that it won't matter.

[@ninjaweretiger4273]

I honestly question some of the news places. Literally painting targets on some peoples locations.

[@pto2k]

Hamas watching this would appreciate the efforts but demand a more detailed investigations.

[@bradrichards8122]

Demand.....lol

[@Chisel_Chest]

and subtitles.

[@inbox0000]

you dont think they are getting intel from outside anyway lol

[@a-iz4pg]

Yeah, god forbid we don't get to learn of Isreali war crimes.

[@bradrichards8122]

@@a-iz4pg Such as?

[@FrankTheTank14507]

What did Hamas expect was going to happen after Oct. 7th?

[@samirk17]

Your coment is funny, What are we going to do with all the years going back, decades of destruction of the people ? October 7th is nothing

[@cristona.d5265]

yeah I've been wondering about that also...

[@christerry1773]

I’ve been asking that too. My only thought is they knew how Israel would react and thought the world support of Israel would start to diminish. So far it’s working pretty well for them.

[@christerry1773]

@@natural5584 they absolutely did. Given the brutality in the past. Which both sides are guilty of

[@andreandree4384]

They did this to instigate troubles to Israel as they were making arrangements to normalise relations with Saudis and then Arab world. And Iran didn't want that.

[@Daniboi971]

The "civilian car" was laden with IEDs. You can tell by how low it was sitting. Come on C4.

[@thepresident1971]

What proof did you have? Did your eyes pick it out from that video?

[@razorlab4712]

You can see Hamas firing out of the car's window a second before the tank fires.

[@pieroo7]

@@thepresident1971 the proof is that they said there is no fuel for nobody except for Hamas.. and it was so convenient that there was a blogger of Hamas behind to film it.

[@thepresident1971]

iv seen the video i saw no smoke from gunfire. stop with the lies honestly.@@razorlab4712

[@victorkunin2333]

Yes, and the point that after 3 weeks without fuel no civilians are allowed to drive. Only the Hamas are allowed to have any fuel now.

[@jarrowmarrow]

Billions for war. Pennies for Peace.

[@nuqwestr]

empty words of a pathetic virtue signaller grasping their beads.

[@warpspeed9877]

It strikes me as especially peculiar that they financed the digging of kilometers of tunnels but they haven't made a single bunker for their civilians. I guess they couldn't use them as shields then...

[@rama7267]

Lol Israel literally bombed hospitals on multiple occasions in this war alone, but at least you can get them out of the rubble unlike a bunker. 10.000 civilian deaths, the UNRWA itself never had so many casualties like it did in this war. But I understand your intentions Palestianian casualties arent as important as Israeli ones to you hypocrite.

[@arshadayoob9929]

U talk like they are their government and they get authorization for bomb shelter the tunnels are made in secret and its mindblowing they pulled it off while being under survielance and kidnapped and questioned and persecuted .Are u dumb to ask this question

[@omar28555]

I wish you were in their shoes, and you will know how it feels to be palestine

[@clo1187]

​@@omar28555ph where you dance and celebrate death of women and kids??? Uh huh..

[@JUAN_OLIVIER]

@@omar28555 - Palestine is a Roman creation. These people are just Arabs that want to destroy Israel. The Arabs already got most of the Palestine mandate, they called their part Jordan, they should consider moving there if they want to live in an Arab state.

[@oleggold]

Who are all these bots mentioning "AMA 69"? This looks like some bot attack.

[@EthanD1997]

I like how they say "civilian car" without having any idea whether that car was carrying civilians or Hamas.

[@dhfhfhrnsjddbdb3730]

Do you know? No, then why talk? The car was retreting

[@geordievillan]

It is a perfectly valid observation. I myself have come to the comment section seeking clarification of how such a provocative conclusion has been arrived at. There's zero evidence one way or the other in the video provided. A better question - one which perhaps you might ask of yourself - would be: why would rational person not ask a rational question.@@dhfhfhrnsjddbdb3730

[@MrDominicharrison]

That ‘civilian’ car ur journalist mentions has hallmarks of an IVED (improvised vehicular explosive device) … it was weighted down at the back and being filmed/tracked by another car, also probably had blacked out windows This when Gaza is supposed to have run out of fuel days earlier, so who else has fuel other than Hamas? It was a military target by definition

[@BaseZ]

Exactly! So sad to see this just pushed away

[@user-fb1dr1pv7e]

Вопрос к этим гуманистам, особенно тем, кто говорит, что искренне хочет добра для "мирного населения Газы" - вы всерьез хотите снова оставить это мирное население наедине с теми кровавыми чудовищами из многочисленных, снятых в израильских поселках видео? С палачами, которые лично, своими руками рвут на части, пытают, убивают людей - без разницы пола и возраста? Без разницы - какая у жертв раса, религия, язык - напомню, что убивали всех, кого встречали и кого не могли или не хотели брать в заложники - в том числе и арабов, и мусульман, и далеких от всех местных раскладов тайцев с непальцами. Которые радуются, ликуют при этом процессе, звонят друзьям, родителям, хвастаются перед ними, сбрасывают им записанные ролики убийств, как наглядное подтверждение своего тяжелого палаческого труда? Вы правда хотите опять запереть "мирное население" на годы в одном гетто с террористами и палачами, которые будут или обращать новых адептов из числа нынешних детей Газы, за которых вы так переживаете - обращать их и делать такими же убийцами и палачами, или так же пытать и уничтожать тех местных, кто будет с ними несогласен или перейдет им дорогу? Напомню, что именно с кровавого мятежа, от которого гибли одни только местные арабы и началось правление террористов в Газе. И именно кровавыми методами их правление там и поддерживается. Вы действительно хотите тем, о ком переживаете такой "подарок"? Запереть их вместе с террористами, под властью террористов, которые вправе обращать их, коверкать тела и души, распоряжаться их жизнью и смертью, отнимать ради "священного дела" еду и лекарства, заставлять детей - поскольку они меньше и проворнее - копать новые тоннели? Вы действительно хотите лишить их всех и жизни, и будущего, и свободы - хотя бы потому, что свободы слова, сознания и совести в анклаве ХАМАС не допустит никогда, как и свободы перемещения - культу нужны заложники и жертвы. Выехать из Газы нельзя не только потому, что Израиль и Египет не пускают, но и потому, что ХАМАС почти не выпускает. Вот такой необычный ракурс проблемы. Понимаю, что большинство не дочитает или сплюнет, продолжив твердить об обязательном и немедленном прекращении огня, и неважно, что будет после. Но, возможно, кто-то задумается именно о том, что будет после. И под чьей властью останутся те самые люди, за которых он переживает. И о том, что на тех видео только шестерки, мелкие подручные, палачи, у которых есть гнев и ненависть, но нет ни стратегии, ни масштабности, ни истовой, настоящей злобы. А те - кто ими обладают сидят глубоко в бункерах или на катарских виллах и уже строят планы на каждого из тех жителей Газы, кто выживет в результате израильской операции. Планы на то, как лучше и успешнее ввернуть оставшихся в свое кровавое дело, сделать новыми адептами, отравить их души и, в итоге, положить жизни выживших сейчас ради новой кровавой работы. Великая цель спишет все жертвы. Так почему вы не хотите дать жителям Газы шанс на освобождение? Да - на кровавое освобождение, потому что опухоль срослась с организмом и иначе ее не удалить. Жители Мосула и Ракки получили в свое время такой шанс, тоже непростой ценой и воспользовались им. Исламское государство там оказалось подорвано и не смогло более восстановиться - в отличие от сельской глубинки, где его пропололи не столь тщательно. И при том они не перестали быть мусульманами - наоборот вернулись к исламским нормам, отойдя от девиации халифата. И не перестали быть арабами, как не перестанут быть им и палестинцы Газы. И у них даже останется возможность протестовать против "израильской военщины", как протестуют их собратья на Западном берегу. Исламское государство искореняла международная коалиция в основном руками самих же арабов и курдов Ирака и Сирии. Здесь, к сожалению, никто из арабских стран не хочет заняться неприятным и сложным процессом очищения Газы и приходится это делать Израилю. Не из особенной любви к палестинцам, а из прагматичного желания получить, наконец, нормального соседа. От которого, проламывая границу не будут врываться к тебе орды палачей и у которого внутри границ эти палачи не будут вершить свои кровавые эксперименты. И выбор прост - или очистить анклав сейчас, или получить еще больше боли, крови и жертв - и для Израиля, и для самих палестинцев. Чуда не будет и иного, альтернативного варианта, к сожалению не дано. Само не рассосется

[@toekneekerching9543]

Gaza has been apparently running out of fuel since day 3, here we are a month later and we are still getting the same old same old " were hours away from running out of fuel" rubbish. clearly hamas has stockpiled fuel for their own use and for little stunts and propaganda shoots like this one. Thats probably how the hospitals keep going, they are safe spaces for hamas, so they want them populated to keep them from being targeted so they drip feed them fuel. Keeps the bombs away and keeps the sympathy going at the same time.

[@rama7267]

You are a straight up liar. Car not tinted windows open. The guy filming was a journalist or civilian saying "What is he doing!?" "He is going to die if he goes there". If it was a VBIED it wouldn't have U-Turned at the sight of the Tank especially considering that it didn't see him right away. Liar.

[@Yeeter000]

That's bullshit, it was a family of 4 in it and the car had no I.E.D, if it did, why would he be driving away. Have you considered that maybe you're cooing with supporting war criminals ?

[@redskins1120]

Hamas could of help their people, but preferred to spend the money on weapons and human shields.

[@FreePalestineStopTheGenocide]

Spent money on human shields? How do human shields stop missiles??

[@redskins1120]

@@FreePalestineStopTheGenocide They bring propaganda from the media. Try to make Israel as a bad guy.

[@mahaeltahlawy1402]

Not true , occupying Israel is the criminal

[@smosh4ever100]

but they.. are..?@@redskins1120

[@BurnOut565]

​@@FreePalestineStopTheGenocideIsrael tries hard not to kill civilians, unlike islamic monsters. Israel even requested the civilians to go south, so they won't get hurt

[@j.p.9295]

Thats what they did , dug tunnels instead bulding schools and hospitals in Gaza and look after Gazan people who lived in powerty .

[@meshari-yy9gp]

Not ignoring the points you mentioned, but do you expect the Palestinians not to resist the oppressive occupation?

[@Sham-zo8mu]

You actually very wrong, Hamas in the early days was a charity that build schools and hospitals but they turned into militant group also many raw materials are blocked from imports by Israel. This is a long list including concrete, glass and other important materials including a list of foods

[@bradrichards8122]

​@@meshari-yy9gpI keep here that oppresive occupation saying. What country is Isreal occupying?

[@bradrichards8122]

​@@frankwhite4643Are you sure? Was Isreal not formed from British territory by the UN?

[@JamieZero7]

​@@meshari-yy9gphow is it an oppressive? Israel was willing to give a state to them for decades. They said no peace and no negotiations.

[@iris2541]

You are mistaken. The IDF spokesman releases videos and images with the date of the images - the date of the incursion, the force participating, and the area (Jabalia, Beit Hanoun, etc.) without being too specific. It's in Hebrew, though.

[@MJWPub]

there's still no chance journalists will be allowed into Gaza to witness what occurs!

[@galeriadesol948]

I would not believe anything that comes from the IDF. From them came even the fake news of the beheaded babies, so they lost all credibility.

[@Yasser.Osman.A.Z.]

We know Hebrew well.

[@arieleliasov]

What they want is independent verification you cant blindly trust goverments or the militarly

[@glitch-ify]

@@MJWPub There are local journalists who are reporting inside Gaza but now there is 0 internet provided by Israel to refrain reports from Gaza, and recently there have been bombings which killed a journalist, his wife, daughter, and son. This event has led to the journalist's colleague reporting live about his death, while taking off his own helmet and Kevlar armour saying "This helmet and armour is just [a metaphor], we are all passing one by one. [Colleague] was with us half an hour ago and now he has left us. We are all martyrs waiting for our turn" (roughly the same). This report touched my heart and in my opinion, I can say this war is not about religion, it is about the leaders of both sides becoming desensitised to violence and fueling propaganda, they have forgotten what it means to be cut from the same cloth.

[@dave23720]

did i just really hear this?! "the invasion would be televised", a few moments later, "what we know is limited"

[@Syonnach]

He literally said it's not certain when and where the scenes they are showing have taken place. It makes sense to avoid giving away intel. Maybe listen next time :)

[@journalistedisoncarter]

There's a BIG difference between "months and months" and "years".

[@mohansega9812]

Jesus christ stand with ❤israrl❤, please pray for everyone ❤israel❤

[@truecolors5413]

No Civilized Society COULD EVER CO EXIST WITH PEOPLE WHO DID WHAT WE ALL SAW ON OCT 7.

[@elephantintheroom5678]

Israel is clearly not a civilised society. They have killed 9000 people since Oct7, including over 5000 children, dead or buried alive under rubble. I saw a baby paralysed by shrapnel in her spine, I saw a beautiful girl child with her arm amputated. I saw other children with their legs amputated. And NOW the hospital has run out of fuel for the main generator, as Israel bombs a refugee camp for the 3rd time, and a line of starving people at a bakery, and Israeli rabbis call on Netanyahu to bomb Al Shifa Hospital with 12,000 patients, babies, pregnant women, wounded, elderly and refugees sheltering there. Israel is the opposite of a "civilised society." They have become identical to the Nazis in their Final Solution.

[@BaseZ]

The civilian “car” was most likely carrying explosives, as analyzed by Ryan Macbeth.

[@baja8593]

its not you can watch the main vid and see that it was civilians with press behind

[@Az96-qs8oh]

it not exploded after been shoot

[@alien4422]

Does he have X ray eyes like Superman? 😂😂😂

[@billmcdonald180]

There were more civilians killed in WW2 than all the military combatants combined. WW2: Civilian deaths totaled 50-55 million. Military deaths from all causes totaled 21-25 million, including deaths in captivity of about 5 million prisoners of war. More than half of the total number of casualties are accounted for by the dead of the Republic of China and of the Soviet Union. Civilians always suffer the most in war.

[@riceshaft]

WW2 was mainly fought against nations.China had great casualties and was helped by the western allies. While the Soviet Union started a war on the side of Hitler. Another thing is that the Soviet Union was responsible for most of its fallen, as is Russia today. After all, their favorite phrase is "nas mnogo" - we are many. We should not forget the fact that Arabs exterminated Jews even before WW1 and were allies of Nazi Germany in WW2. The thought of Amin al-Husseini remains in them to this day. If they wanted, they could have a better life, but they rejected all the proposals because they don't want to have a better life. They just want to invade and destroy the Israeli state. Just look at the pro-Palestinian protests, where they are full of racists. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amin_al-Husseini

[@nj6892]

More power to Israel in their fight against radical Islamic terrorism.

[@m118lr]

..Amen. MORE of God’s POWER! Amen..

[@truthful8608]

Just search up the meaning of terrorism and educate yourself before entering into any dialogue here or anywhere else.

[@nj6892]

@@truthful8608 Islam is terrorism. U educate yourself, terrorist sympathiser.

[@nicos4444]

@@truthful8608 you should educate yourself

[@sidauthur7836]

​@@truthful8608sympathizer?

[@theodorepollock1273]

That white car WAS NOT civilian, that thing was weighed down with explosives. Anyone whos deployed to the middle east could tell you that.

[@hagalhagal9989]

Not to mention the car bristling with cameras following it as if expecting something to happen!

[@adamcogan211]

Wtf happened to the comments section??????

[@aatithyakhadka7766]

Paid

[@oleggold]

Yes. A lot of bots.

[@yadusolparterre]

Pro-Hamas terrorist propaganda is wearing off

[@nuqwestr]

China probing with AI bots, very bad.

[@SK-od6et]

No way!? Krieg means war so this war analyst is actually called Mr War. 😂

[@Syonnach]

"Nobody knows war better than John War over here!"

[@hilaryagu405]

But what exactly are these civilians doing around the war zones? You always have them appear from no where in the zone they should have fled for their safety

[@richardb8104]

Where are they supposed to flee? All the borders are shut.

[@johnkess2174]

The crowd milling about the destroyed refugee camp appear to be exclusively males from teens to about 40 years of age.

[@thc_freebaser]

Why would I leave my house if my town is being bombed

[@UnknownString88]

​@@thc_freebaser to not die? Lol

[@jvn144]

@@thc_freebaserwell then you’re probably going to die in your house.. like If I had a choice between leaving my house and getting to live I would choose to leave very quickly

[@warrenoutley5413]

Hamas accuses Israel of genocide if this was genocide” Israel wouldn’t be warning Gaza civilians where they will concentrate explosives on next .

[@astorete1610]

I didn’t see a single woman or child in the footage of the so called ‘refugee camp’. The refugees the camp is named for are from 1948, not 2023. Israel has given two weeks of notice to evacuate northern Gaza.

[@quink2376]

Exactly, that's what I noticed. It's fake footage of hamas terrorists acting

[@littleappear]

True

[@shuttlespace04]

Even Jordan hasnt given independence to west bank which is palestine when they cobtrolled it😂😂

[@m118lr]

NOBODY wants ANYTHING to do with THESE “Palestinians”. Easy….VERY EASY to see why!

[@Tanminator]

you disgust me as a human being.... are you a human being??

[@carltonneckbrace4039]

All the Palestinians want to die no? They say life begins at death. I don’t know why the people are crying for the martyrs

[@SuperGreatSphinx]

Hail Mary, full of Grace, the LORD is with Thee. Blessed art Thou amongst women, and blessed is the fruit of Thy womb, JESUS. Holy Mary, Mother of God, pray for us sinners, now and at the hour of our death. Amen.

[@lalarebelse5985]

Looks like the vietnam war but then in a city! Terrible for the citizens. 😢

[@bajorjor1]

Telling me you don't know anything about the Vietnam War without telling me you don't know anything about the Vietnam War. There were city battles in Vietnam War genius.

[@lalarebelse5985]

@@bajorjor1 i ment fighting under the ground! They diged tunnels to genius!

[@YashaDecat]

@@lalarebelse5985 You mean like the Vietcong in the Vietnam war... Or do you think they only built tunnels in the jungle ? They built tunnels everywhere my friend.

[@lalarebelse5985]

@@YashaDecat i wasnt there i just know they were in tunnels and it was very hard to fight them because they came out of nowhere. It reminded me of that thats all.

[@nuqwestr]

Vietnam not the same, this is neighbor against neighbor, there is not expeditionary force.

[@MyrLin8]

Thanks, Interesting. A bit behind the curve really, but still good.

[@Jimboken1]

Ch4: "Naughty Israel! Bad Israel!"

[@jeremymiller6827]

This expert says he couldn't think of anyone who had built tunnel infrastructure like this before....the Viet-Cong did

[@runi5413]

He did preface that by saying "I don't know of any war in an _urban_ combat environment where..." And the VC didn't dig tunnels that went 70 meters underground, or were built with re-enforced concrete... Hamas has reportedly invested over a billion dollars into constructing those tunnels (instead of building bomb-shelters for civilians...), that's smth we haven't quite seen before.

[@hagalhagal9989]

​@@runi5413money which was supposed to be helping Gazans

[@treelight1707]

@@hagalhagal9989 I saw a video of them digging those tunnels with a shovel. I question the billions argument.

[@kennycube5126]

@@treelight1707 apparently it costs about $1000 per Kilometer.

[@treelight1707]

@@kennycube5126 There's definitely the cost of concrete with its reinforcements. I am still trying to wrap my head around the depth. unbelievable.

[@BeingHuman5291]

On 7th oct Hammas thought that allah will protect them from IDF.. now they r realising what mistake they have done on that day

[@RaisingIQ]

Free Palestine. Why this Jewish state was not built in the US of America ? As of the 1930s, the Jewish population in the United States was estimated to be around 4.2 million. Meanwhile the Jewish population in British Mandate Palestine experienced significant growth due to Jewish immigration from Europe. According to historical estimates, by the late 1930s, there were approximately 400,000 to 450,000 Jews living in British Mandate Palestine. This demographic shift played a significant role in the development of the region's demographics and ultimately had an impact on the political dynamics that led to the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948. When majority of the Jews were in USA why not give them a state there its simple 4,200,000 in USA vs 400,000 in Palestine. In simple words "Why was the State of Israel not established in the United States, where the Jewish population was much larger than in British Mandate Palestine during the 1930s?" Why come and live in a place where supposedly everyone is their enemy?

[@j.masonbrown6216]

Well for one, Zionists wanted their own state. Jews have for millennia been a separate and excluded population within the respective countries they have found themselves in. They wanted a country/state that was by Jews, for Jews. Additionally, many hyper-religious factions see a supernatural significance to Palestine, as it was the "promised land" from the old testament. I'm not giving an opinion on whether I think this was the right thing to do or not, just stating the historical facts as to why it is happening.

[@y.l7455]

​@@RaisingIQ Flee palestine, why creating a state for nonexistent people?

[@andrewtregoning]

i guarantee they didn't think Allah would protect them, these are desperate suicidal people.

[@BeingHuman5291]

@@RaisingIQ India Maldives Indonesia these place belongs to others community but Muslims forcefully enter and capture lands now they r living. But the different is hindu Christian and Buddhist tried to live peacefully with Muslms not doing jihad terrorism and killing innocents

[@rigoeats3654]

"Tank shooting at a Palestian civilian car." The car has its whole trunk nearly grinding on the pavement, with a "civilian" filming and ready in a getaway vehicle. You think that man is delivering bricks?

[@sulev111]

I have to say... independent war map channels do a far better job at covering the conflict and future plans.

[@SugarDog2006]

No war was ever waged without civilian casualties.

[@BobHooker]

Civilian car? How do you know it was not a car bomb? The car was low to the ground, it was moving towards a active war zone that was clear, and it was being filmed, and Gaza has supposed to be out of gasoline. How did a civilian car get gas?

[@midnattsol6207]

You can't be serious, go watch the footage. The driver saw the tank, stopped, turned away and was shot at.

[@mrgarina2977]

fog of war. dont drive in a warzone when you know hammas use the same cars as you.@@midnattsol6207

[@PeaceonearthXXI]

How do you know it was? They been using civilian cars to transport the injured because there is no fuel !

[@theodorepollock1273]

​@@PeaceonearthXXIhumans don't make the back end drag. Nor does medical equipment. That was a classic vehicle bound explosive that you would see in Iraq and Afghanistan. This is beyond common knowledge. It's a freaking given, plus civilians don't drive towards tanks in a 0 degree approach like the full clip shows them until they realize they are caught and try to run away. Not civilian. Any true analysis points to it being a vehicle bourne explosive

[@BobHooker]

@@PeaceonearthXXI look at the video, they are driving into a battle, fumes of smoke building in the sky. Why would they be driving into a battle? And if it was injured where is the red crescent? And a few bodies will not push the body down that low, and why was this car being filmed from a distance but for a propaganda video?

[@mattakline]

Maybe this channel should be called "Channel 4 Speculation Presented as News"

[@MR-op3mo]

Why are you people reporting on this? Isn't dangerous for the IDF?

[@FreePalestineStopTheGenocide]

Lol

[@common12]

The car the Israelis fired on was filled with explosives. The car’s suspension was so heavy it just cleared the ground. A sign it was loaded with bombs.

[@zakg1935]

🤡

[@donovanteale6502]

this claim is silly. if it was a carbomb it would have accelerated, not turned around. arm chair tacticians who dont understand every car running is being used to transport water etc

[@Syndie702]

I don't want to be flippant, this is a very serious story, but the fact that the guy who studies war at King's College has the last name "Krieg" is too much for me. If you're not aware, "krieg" is German for "war."

[@d2vid]

Nominative determinism

[@MuhammadHamas]

Occupiers Does Not Have Right to Defence

[@azizaljar]

Tony Benn said once: " we watch news on Chanel 4 is if we are watching video games"

[@henryzhao4622]

Thanks Channel 4.

[@ryanscully3932]

Why do they need to show us what's happening.

[@MadApplesWA]

Some of us do not live under rocks.

[@Mark.bond007]

They don’t want the big mouth channel 4 , announcing everything their doing , so just keep your noise out

[@DonnaMcFadden]

Thank you for this report! You are one of my two favorite international channels!!👍❤🇨🇦

[@bamxire8845]

Those of you who have stood back and said nothing or outright supported Israel in these actions, history will judge you very harshly shame shame shame!!!

[@donovanteale6502]

the most documented genocide war crime of all time. But hey with power and internet cut at least we dont have to look at the thousands of dead Palestinian babies anymore. Can go back to the "but why are they angry at israel anyway?" mindset of the Americans.

[@ultrawow65]

Hamas isn't a governing authority, they are a militant group. Which means that every single resource they come by goes towards their army. Even when they seemingly donate to rebuild schools and hospitals, it's probably to ensure they can also use them as camps and bunkers...

[@jedibasschoke8909]

Apparently they were voted in in 2007. They are listed as the governing body of Gaza since 2007.

[@jerrys3550]

No to Talmudism.

[@davidbroadfoot1864]

They are the governing authority there. They got 65% of the votes at the last election that was held.

[@mikaelg8286]

Can they flood the tunnels?

[@itamar757]

The world will whine about it

[@jaja3359]

Been thinking about that too. One thing against it is that their own civillians ( hostages ) are being kept in there who would likely die if you flood it Israeli's tend to care alot about their lives

[@ismaeladen1204]

God sides with the oppressed.

[@Daniboi971]

Hostages down there probably

[@waltersimmons9512]

@@dianeirvine7624 Attacking a nuclear armed countries is risky

[@everettwhitegoat3414]

Like mom says, "GOT YOURSELVES IN THAT SITUATION, GET YOURSELVES OUT."

[@elliotlewisham1138]

So your own parents wouldn't protect you? Got it.

[@Magneticvortex-kk4gb]

@@elliotlewisham1138 I need protection from my own parents, dafuq kinda life you living?

[@elliotlewisham1138]

@@Magneticvortex-kk4gb well when you're a kid then yes obviously bright spark. Why would an Adult be asking for their parents help to get them out of a situation they put themselves in? Obviously, he was talking about when he was a child, genius, learn how to think critically before writing idiotic nonsense.

[@Magneticvortex-kk4gb]

@@elliotlewisham1138 Will you be my mother?

[@bradrichards8122]

​@@elliotlewisham1138Isreal is not Gaza's parent bright spark. HAMAS is the ELECTED government of the people of Gaza. What are THEY doing to provide for the people THEY imperiled by committing the largest single day mass killing of Jews since the holocaust? What? Anything?

[@SludgeMan90]

Channel 4 trying to provide Hamas with as much intel as they possibly can on Israeli forces.

[@rogerfox2919]

But will the people in Gaza expose Hamas? Never.

[@FreePalestineStopTheGenocide]

Will disbelievers condemn themselves? Never. It's OK Allah condemns you.

[@Lucas-ku6gl]

Excellent reporting

[@ih719]

Not. They are biased. Worst than the BBC

[@lisagardner903]

Praying for Israel!

[@MedinaLina]

kzbin.info7uL555xWQeE?feature=shared

[@hesham000]

They lost 135 tanks so far and thousands of soldiers.

[@ooammo632]

Your on one

[@wayneyd2]

Invading is the wrong word. Taking back is more like it.

[@privateer9181]

General curtis lemay has many quotes that i whole heartedly agree with "As far as casualties were concerned I think there were more casualties in the first attack on Tokyo with incendiaries than there were with the first use of the atomic bomb on Hiroshima. The fact that it's done instantaneously, maybe that's more humane than incendiary attacks, if you can call any war act humane. I don't, particularly, so to me there wasn't much difference. A weapon is a weapon and it really doesn't make much difference how you kill a man. If you have to kill him, well, that's the evil to start with and how you do it becomes pretty secondary. I think your choice should be which weapon is the most efficient and most likely to get the whole mess over with as early as possible." and There are no innocent civilians. It is their government and you are fighting a people, you are not trying to fight an armed force anymore. So it doesn't bother me so much to be killing the so-called innocent bystanders. and "We’re at war with Japan. We were attacked by Japan. Do you want to kill Japanese, or would you rather have Americans killed?"

[@user-gc8bj7cv7k]

Are you a fair person and you have a mind or does religion move you and hatred moves your emotions

[@danielanthony8373]

Would anyone disagree that if all Palestinians left Gaza and replaced by Chinese or Vietnamese or South Koreans that Gaza would be a beautiful prosperous safe amazing place ??

[@widoyonowidoyono2062]

may be ask to hamas

[@wjumeau]

If The British Govt is supporting Israel then some of the reporting on Israeli positions inside Gaza is risky, they are giving information to enemy combatants. No matter how you look at it….

[@soundknight]

I hate it when journalists try to say something philosophically proportions at the end of a report. Not only is it out of tone but it also makes no sense.

[@wheelinthesky300]

"This conflict is unlike anything we've seen before". Not really. This conflict is like everything we've seen before.

[@sandsmarc]

Things appear to be going very well at the moment.

[@feafea123]

Title is mis-leading. It is cleaning not invading.

[@eliezra6098]

Irresponsible journalism bordering on misleading. Why no mention of hamas forcing civilians to remain in harm's way

[@Czermet666]

_"Fired upon a civilian car, filmed by a Palestinian journalist."_ *This is misleading.* As it is unconfirmed who was in that car, and whether the "journalist" was Hamas or not. The car may be a civilian model, but there are many signs that indicate suspicious activity. 1) The car has a heavily weighted rear end, and the licence plate was blacked out. Both indicators of a car bomb. 2) Bombers often film the attack attempt for propaganda purposes, if they succeed, they have footage of a victory. If they fail, they have footage of the enemy firing upon a "civilian." 3) Everyone knows that Gaza has No Fuel... Only Hamas has fuel storages. So this would indicate to the Tank Operator that only Hamas must be on the roads. (As may be their briefing.) (Yes somebody may have a jerrycan of petrol, but there is no confirmation on which direction this vehicle was heading... if it was heading south, it could possibly be for evacuation. If it was heading in any other direction, it likely was not.) 4) Hamas have no military designated vehicles, they use civilian converted "technicals." 5) The Tank did not fire with the main gun, and did not shred it to pieces with the machinegun. So it was warning shots not to proceed further in the direction of the soldiers. 6) There are no reports of any fatalities in this incident. 7) The video stopped before the outcome could be determined. 8) If the IDF did not stop this unidentified vehicle, their soldiers the car was driving towards would have their lives put at risk.

[@adrielsebastian5216]

​@@theamradhow are the other points ridiculous?

[@hansiesma16]

This is war. What do you expect?

[@user-zl9sh9mz6h]

HUMANITY. We expect HUMANITY.

[@hansiesma16]

@@user-zl9sh9mz6h I think you are deluded. War by definition cannot be humane. Hamas started something and Israel must finish it.

[@ALROD]

@@user-zl9sh9mz6h Humanity in war? That's not an option.

[@RaisingIQ]

@@hansiesma16 are you stupid isreal is an occupying power that has no right to exist in the first place. Free Palestine. Why this Jewish state was not built in the US of America ? As of the 1930s, the Jewish population in the United States was estimated to be around 4.2 million. Meanwhile the Jewish population in British Mandate Palestine experienced significant growth due to Jewish immigration from Europe. According to historical estimates, by the late 1930s, there were approximately 400,000 to 450,000 Jews living in British Mandate Palestine. This demographic shift played a significant role in the development of the region's demographics and ultimately had an impact on the political dynamics that led to the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948. When majority of the Jews were in USA why not give them a state there its simple 4,200,000 in USA vs 400,000 in Palestine. In simple words "Why was the State of Israel not established in the United States, where the Jewish population was much larger than in British Mandate Palestine during the 1930s?" Why come and live in a place where supposedly everyone is their enemy?

[@ramzizou25]

​ All this crowd for a small piece of land that has been under siege for years! I began to doubt Israel's military capabilities

[@NOSTALGIAVIDEOS-tx6ki]

Now the era is transparent. Please, the western media in providing information must be balanced to the world community. So that the world knows you are not taking sides with the pros and cons.

[@masterwizard2881]

How do tanks stack up against no tank combatants, David & Goliath, Hmmmmm. Mike Tyson fighting a wheel chair oponent?

[@user-qk9tq1rt7o]

Its not like Israel has no casualties. Israel bore the brunt of the first attack and continues to bear the brunt from indiscriminate missile attacks. Both of which were and still are aimed specifically at innocent people not the actual combatants. At least Israel is doing what it can to weed out terrorists from civilians but this is a difficult task and civilians will be lost. Unlike Hamas which is directly targeting civilians.

[@elliotlewisham1138]

I smell ignorance. This didn't start on Oct 7th.

[@ahabsbane]

​@@elliotlewisham1138no, it didn't, but I don't think the last 70 years shed a favorable light on Palestine either. They have refused to negotiate many times, and continue to initiate attacks all along the way.

[@elliotlewisham1138]

@@ahabsbane would you negotiate with someone who invaded your home and told you that they're living there but you can live in one bedroom, and you can't leave that bedroom unless they say so, and they control everything that goes in or out of your bedroom including food, water and energy, whilst simultaneously trying to destroy everything inside that bedroom they placed you in, after also m*rd*ring your family members and your children they also placed in that one bedroom? No? Didn't think so, so why should they? Did you forget that the IDF in the past have literally shot Palestinian CHILDREN? HOW is that targeting Hamas and not civilians? Fair enough they can *try* to use that as an excuse when it comes to airstrikes, but when it comes to shooting them there is ZERO excuse. Remember what they did to all those peaceful Palestinian protesters at the Gaza border in 2018? Where they shot hundreds of them...

[@kewintaylor7056]

@@ahabsbaneu got the real point 👍👍👍

[@kewintaylor7056]

@@ahabsbanethey got coercer and support from Iran… Iran make em its proxy…they war for iran with hatred to jew… Iran dont have to shed their blood…😂

[@marioskublan7273]

I recall when a Russian tank hit a civilian car in Ukraine the west was like war crime. Yet, when it is Israel there is some strange hush. I wonder why there is this double standard

[@nuqwestr]

no, not the same, so not a double standard.

[@deathrow5261]

@@nuqwestrit literally is the same though

[@MottyGlix]

Because in Hamas-stan, a low-to-the-ground bomb-laden car going where no other cars are and when there's no gasoline available … is not the same as a Ukrainian civilian car where there's a democratic government. Maybe it's not a double standard but a double situation.

[@hagalhagal9989]

How do you know it was a civilian car? Why was it followed by another car full of cameras as if they are waiting for something to happen?

[@the_effect_de]

It's completely the palestinians fault. They had more than enough time to free themselves from Hamas but they didn't. Now they pay the price.

[@echalone]

Why do you say that the tank fired on a "civilian car". It's a car. And it was probably used by Hamas, which wouldn't make it a civilan car. It just furthers the antisemitism to paint a picture of a tank shooting at civilans when you don't know if that's what happened.

[@ranjitpal9937]

❤ Great to See Unbiased Reporting ❤

[@yo1122]

It is biased enough to contain outright lies. The say that the citizens in Gaza are also blocked under seige, but they have 2 roads they cal leave by. The ones keeping them inside the seige is Hamas, so they could have their human shields

[@marcuswright8418]

Here's a fruit for thought, How about Ham*s surrenders, including their leadership and anyone else that has allied with them and in turn they can demand Israel to help with the reconstruction of a new moderate government, infrastructure etc. Also allowing Gazans to have the option for a dual citizenship to allow travel between both states.

[@Klayhamn]

Israel as a Jewish nation-state cannot allow its ethnic majority to be eroded. Just like Japan for example: they will never allow the country to become white or arabic or spanish - they want it to remain Japanese.

[@mrgarina2977]

it was always the plan and it was like that until hammas rose to power. then israel built wall for obvious reasons. might be an option in a decade or so when hammas is only present at history books.

[@bradrichards8122]

That plan was called Oslo. Other than Oslo the Arabs always reject the idea. Hamas destroyed Oslo. What they want is all the jews dead and Isreal eliminated. "From the river to the sea". The Germans of 1938 called it "The final solution".

[@konekjukel3340]

@mrgarina2977 stop daydreaming

[@GoldCoast85]

As if

[@MichaelGarcia001]

How do you know the tank was firing on a civilian column? Because Hamas told you it was a civilian column? Please.

[@islamicpath19]

It's GRAND ''Occupation'' not ''operation''.

[@MyAfrican1986]

That’s not true they doesn’t want somebody to know what they’re doing to innocent kids and families

[@jeffro4kag206]

Maybe a few commas, and correct spelling please. Thank you

[@togetheras172]

Sorry for the Good persons caught in this War

[@kewintaylor7056]

Good person go to heaven… But i wonder if the heaven are as good as we think!..,😂 I mean if it exist in the first place😂

[@DW_Kiwi]

Jesus said "There is no one who is good. Not anyone. except God"!

[@CriterionCollector]

including those jihadi indoctrinated children?

[@paghilumdihauy]

@@DW_Kiwiagree.. ALOOKWHAHA HABAR hahhahahahahaa

[@nuqwestr]

empty words not appreciated.

[@FreshPrinceofTB]

He has a really good point stop closing the streets

[@MrSeconet]

Criticizing Israel is not anti-Semitism.

[@philipushandyman3393]

PRAY FOR ISRAEL 😭❤🙏

[@stevemarler7039]

Gaza city does not have a gate😮

[@ALROD]

What the heck is this AMA69X in all comments?

[@viniciuscoxoba3842]

I don't know, more than 100 bots saying the same code, maybe it's a ruse to signal something

[@rossilombok1562]

Israel_Amerika VS ISLAM 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩 Israel_Amerika VS ISLAM 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩Israel_Amerika VS ISLAM 🇮🇩🇮🇩🇮🇩

[@col.waltervonschonkopf69]

0:36 Israel has already lost the PR war.

[@bjornfarber5032]

This is so sad. I wish it could all end with peace and love, but it won't.

[@ryanrud7698]

Read, James Hillman, Terrible Love of War, this may help provide a soulful balance to your spiritual confusion

[@bjornfarber5032]

@@natpalazzo8833 I am just expressing my desperation about the situation.

[@IcarosImmortal]

@@bjornfarber5032 You do well because you are a free mind. Others are enslaved to what their perception of reality andd narratives dictate them..

[@bjornfarber5032]

@@ryanrud7698 I read the summarization of the book and it seems a bit primitive and out of line with my comment. In the essence we are talking about "impact of war on the human soul, highlighting the psychological and spiritual dimensions of war and violence". Let's focus on the essentials in life (love, laughter, fun in the sun etc.) and try to not go into war zone, for good and bad!

[@Magneticvortex-kk4gb]

@@IcarosImmortal Okay Aristotle.

[@jeff022889]

Um, maybe the Palestinians could leave.

[@donttrip8282]

How do you see such a devastating strike on a refugee camp and say there were deaths and injuries but caviat that with "according to the health ministry" like there is a chance that isn't true?

[@d2vid]

It's a refugee camp ... from 1948.

[@ivannaicker3649]

If mohammad never start his own religion and confuse Jehovah and allah...Jesus and isa...Mary and mariam.. Abraham and ebrahim..Isaac and esaak..or Jacob and Jacoob..then we wud never have been so segregated .. can anyone see it from this prospective...This brought about the biggest controversy on land rights.. Demonic web ..people just acting out their venom ..they forget the blood cries out from the ground to the same God of muslims Jews Christians Hindus Buddhist the entirety ...I guaranteed to yourll most think that it can neva be the same God that created the arabs that also created the Jews.. but I believe this firmly from my ❤of ❤😢

[@ivannaicker3649]

I wonder if any child of OUR SAME GOD..tell me whom are infidels..can one outside the Muslim faith shake ur hand ...who promises gifts to who wen kill in the name of their god.. are non muslims allowed in the mosque in Jerusalem.. are these rules from allah mohammad..ayesha or just radical men😮😢

[@FreePalestineStopTheGenocide]

​@ivannaicker3649 what are non Muslims going to do inside a mosque??

[@nuqwestr]

"refugee camp" was evacuated south, those who stayed are combatants, international law, and you can see the areas of collapsed tunnels, the video shows only men above the age of about 15. Al-Jazeera reports hostages killed, too.

[@janm2205]

Civilians were repeatedly told to leave the area for their safety weeks ago by Israel. They ignored all the warnings.

[@Start2Game007]

Believe me you would do the same, you are commenting because you are not in their place, it is hard to leave your home and the place where you grew up, people from Ukraine why don't they leave their country? because once left it is taken by the occupant

[@Archer-hg9rw]

@@Start2Game007 it has been clearly documented that this is just a PR stunt, and that it doesn't work in reality, you think these people are willingly sacrificing their families lives just because they don't feel like moving, are you crazy?

[@hagalhagal9989]

​@@Start2Game007yes but unlike Hamas, Ukraine is not the aggressor! The civilians are ultimately responsibile because they elected Hamas in the first place. The government, even if authoritarian, is a reflection of the society it governs.

[@Start2Game007]

@@hagalhagal9989 you know that there is a past and a history of what happened in Palestine, firstly Israel is the first aggressor and occupier, and secondly Hamas are the people who take revenge after what the Israelis did to their families. but according to your understanding I can steal your house and deprive you of it or keep you locked in the basement, and the house will be mine and if you fight back I will call you an aggressor, I think logic has left you

[@donaldelley2802]

Long time coming

[@yoloelectric1453]

I hope they wake up and ask themselves why did they elect hamas! But in the mean time it’s very interesting that none of them really want it to end

[@chrisduma3141]

Hamas was elected against a very corrupt political party which the Palestinian people wanted to change. At the time you didn’t have so much readily available information online as you do today but the hamas they elected was separate from their militant counterpart and already providing healthcare and support to local communities before they were elected. That’s why they were elected, however they immediately used their military counterpart to cease full control of the parliament and have closed down any democratic process. It’s sad to blame the people of Palestine for getting fucked by hamas on one side and Isreal on the other.

[@JohnSmith-iu3ui]

@@chrisduma3141so not that different to Germans in the 1930s voting for the Nazis just to get some autobahns?

[@steveking7719]

The comment at 2:35 claiming a tank firing on a civilian car is false. The camera is a "long shot", but if you look at the video closely... the car turns around well before the intersection most likely because it did see a tank and turned around to get out of the area. The firing by the tank across and through the intersection has nothing to do with the car. The tank would've fired if the car was not there. The video was by a Palestinian journalist... obviously not objective.

[@kheiracheikh7935]

you are talking like Hamas is the problem

[@leagarner3675]

How did the journalist know that the car was being targeted so they could get the footage?

[@shehab1414]

The Jornalist was trying to zoom in to confirm if it was a tank and there was a car heading in that way and when they saw the tank the car was turning around and then the tank shot it

[@hagalhagal9989]

​@@shehab1414not a very smart journalist is he? At that point the journalist is a legitimate target too since the tank has no way of knowing why a camera is pointed at it.

[@shehab1414]

@@hagalhagal9989 it was very far away and it was not confirmed if it was a tank or not , try to see the full video. Its not about smart or not. Of course ppl like u and israeli people would say tank shd shoot anything infront of it. I understand becuz ppl who think like that are the real terörists and they have already killed 3000+ kids.

[@bro2603]

I'm an american Jew, and I Feel Deeply for the People of occupied Palestine. #FreePalestine #EndApartheid #SalaamShalom #GrandTheftWorld #Dr.ShivaAyyaduraiForPresident

[@yourcomradebanana5559]

If you were a 2 part Jew (meaning both ethnically and religiously) you would be a Zionist as you would have prayed 3 times a day a prayer that includes coming back to the land. And if you had read history and seen how many terror attacks happened, you would never support the so-called "Palestinian cause" as it was invented in the late 60s and early 70s by mainly Egypt trying to kill the state of Israel from within when their army failed 3.5 times in a row (Vassar Arafat was an Egyptian).

[@che2201]

I just wonder if the Arab countries are serious saving Gaza. I started doubting that. If they are not, Israel is free to do anything they like. No problem

[@user-rf8zw5xh1b]

Agree. For 2 weeks the leaders of several countries told so many words about starting the war on Israel, if it doesn't stop its intervention. Now Israel destroyed almost one-third of Gaza, and what?

[@user-gq1lj5yr3w]

They can take these gazan into their countries they have occurred since last 1400 years ...instead of using them as tools to finish of remaining jews ...

[@ashiinsane90]

israhel is free to commit genocide? you inhumane RAT

[@SkyGlitchGalaxy]

Correct, Israelis have a free hand to do as they want. And what do they do? They target hamas terrorists. While hamas uses civilians - women & children as human shields

[@sean367]

Arab world wants nothing to do with Palestinians.their lack of support speaks volumes

[@m.goodengumman3941]

Repeat news from previous days

[@jamespowton4596]

Any think come on channel 4 anything please 🤔