How live is VCHA singing? | FOX 5 NEW YORK PERFORMANCE

All rights reserved to the artist(s) and label(s). No copyright intended.
music used:
VCHA 'Girls of The Year':
• VCHA "Girls of the Yea...

[@asiangsus]

Kaylee, Camila, and Savanna were extremely stable! Overall, everyone did amazing! 2:24 CAMILA'S HIGH NOTE IS INSANE!!!!

[@Chaetzv]

Love how Kaylee always sings live thanks for the likes

[@FizzYT_]

same she is so stable

[@Chaetzv]

@@FizzYT_fr

[@Imsanabae]

Well she only have 3 lines and they’re not hard

[@generalariel6283]

​@@Imsanabaesustaining an A4 while taking those long steps isn't an easy thing. _.

[@Imsanabae]

@@generalariel6283Alr I’m pretty sure if non idols can sing while doing dance breaks then yes it is

[@aritz8452]

Camila, Kaylee and Savana always singing live 😭 LOVE VCHA SM

[@lin-gx1lp]

They're doing pretty good trying to sing live!! Idk why some comments are mad and acting like it's a bad thing to lip sync lol

[@FizzYT_]

fr

[@sailorkeyblader]

Singing and dancing is hard especially with extreme choreography. I do know they can sing live proven by the impromtu acoustic version on the live stream. However, they will get better through practice, calisthenics, runners while singing etc

[@FizzYT_]

yess they can for sure sing, thats no question!

[@ksk5517]

Then, hey Fizzy Fuzzy, what was your intent of making this video?

[@FizzYT_]

@@ksk5517 idk i just felt like making it

[@nayeonsbunny1]

Their job is to dance and sing

[@sailorkeyblader]

@@nayeonsbunny1 We know! They're new. They'll get better with time

[@babygotback85]

hope Kaylee gets more lines

[@lostangel5100]

So i am not alone who thinks this way😭

[@savilegendz]

Vcha's training period is not like other groups, especially for KG (Dance) and Kendall (Vocal). But, they did great job for their debut performances. Well, They need to change the choreography to perform this song live. At least they do it for Pre-Chorus parts as same as the special live performance on the sand. Keep streaming Girls of The Year, guys. They will be the next Fifth Harmony, Little Mix, or even Destiny's Child in the future ❤

[@asiangsus]

2:35 Camila singing the harmony w/ KG live!

[@Chaetzv]

LOVE THIS SONG

[@FizzYT_]

SAME

[@AmiNerd-gk8bh]

Kaylee is so stable 😭😭

[@Jgseobie010]

In terms of whos singings the most my ranking would be 1. Camilla ( she has like 56 of singing time so its pretty normal that some part she aint singing) 2 Kaylee ( she has the least lines so she has more breath control) 3. Savanna (she singings most her parts, and also has least parts) 4.kg (she gets the hardest while having the second most line in the song) 5. Kendall ( she singings like a lil but she got hard parts in choreography that makes her not want to singing during these part so it sounds clean) 6. Lexus ( In general she dosent even singing, u can go watch mexico and brazil performance and you'll notice shes the only one not singing, and if she does she singings like 2 lines and gives up) Honestly proud of the top threes especially of savanna since vocals arent her strong area but still she does the singing parts i would have Honestly expected her not to singing that much but am so proud of her!! Camilla is an all rounder so she does her parts flawlessly she even extended her vocals at the mexico performance ❤!! Kaylee is so stabled for her age and she does the most when her parts comes so am really proud of her For the rest we can only hope they will break out of relaying on the backtracks ❤

[@FizzYT_]

KG got reeally unlucky she has some of the longest parts and is more liekly to be out of breath bc in her first chorus she just got off the floor and has to sing straight away and then when she sings the prechorus she literally has to slide on the floor lol.

[@hailey-tp1hc]

Kaylee is the backbone of this group for real, and she's really young. I can't even imagine how good she will be, also everyone who watched the show know that she's a true hard worker, so she's too promising too...

[@asiangsus]

I see some people are upset so I wanted to put my two cents. Lexi has some of the most difficult choreography during her lines though. In the beginning, she whips her hair around multiple times while trying to sing THEN her rap part has such an INTENSE dance as well so i understand why she wouldn’t sing. it’s almost impossible to sound good on Lexi’s parts.

[@gillianp1]

I love Vcha! Such joy 🫶🏼✨ Their vocals & dance has improved loads. So proud of them all

[@외국어공부-m6k]

음악이 중독성이 있어요❤ 자꾸만 듣게 되네요❤

[@stanleywillem3327]

Whatever vcha always my favorite

[@FizzYT_]

same

[@seungmiiin]

savaanna slayeddd

[@hailey-tp1hc]

Kaylee is stable af

[@hnuyaj1230]

How do you know just by listening to the audio?? The video where they did acoustic at the park is great.

[@FizzYT_]

ig my ear is trained to hear it bc im really interested in live vs lip sync vocals lol, and ye they sounded perfect in their acoustic.

[@crash5758]

@@FizzYT_you were spot on with each one

[@FizzYT_]

@@crash5758 thank you :)

[@allymaras]

I feel like they need to give Kaylee more lines to give Camila and KG a break lol

[@hurry_hurry_dizzy_dizzy]

Girls of the year? What year? is there anyone heard that electro vibe?

[@hurry_hurry_dizzy_dizzy]

girls of the year with "I can't get enough" lyrics😂 what year is it again?

[@kysgwon5557]

케이지 너무귀여워

[@Millie_MOA]

What is "backtrack overuse" ?

[@FizzYT_]

basically when the song is playing in the back really loudly, so loud you can’t properly hear them singing

[@Millie_MOA]

@@FizzYT_Okay thank you

[@CookieShinobuKawaii]

I noticed Lexi was lip syncing for her parts I wonder why, was she sick? Also no hate I love Vcha

[@FizzYT_]

it may not be up to her, im not sure. maybe their team wanted her to lipsync?

[@ello4347]

Don't understand why the rapping of all parts is not live...

[@asiangsus]

have you seen the dance to the rap part?? it’s one, if not, the most intense part of the choreography lol

[@aiahkinssss]

Camila singing live and she was sick here. There was like a behind the scenes from the reporters and Cami was coughing 😢

[@EbonyGames]

Alright but to be fair, they haven’t really had much training yet!!!

[@FizzYT_]

yes! i’m not criticising them i just felt like making a video like this i will do it for other groups in the future haha

[@EbonyGames]

@@FizzYT_ I think the partial Lypsync is fine, the Choreography is pretty demanding 🙏

[@FizzYT_]

@@EbonyGames i completely agree and anyways they are still singing live more then a lot of other groups

[@mouna1352]

It's not because of that, every group alternate between lipsync and live since its difficult to be stable while doing some moves

[@dr.mahmudulhasantopu8021]

Kaylee and svana always sings.lexi and did the least..then kendel and kg

[@asiangsus]

and Camila is super stable as well!

[@kebabs127]

oooh I like this song

[@FizzYT_]

GOOD I TOLD U TO LISTEN TO IT WHEN IT CAME OUT LOL

[@hilol-zc7rw]

I know the dance a lil bit

[@nnnnnnnnnmi]

生歌えぐ

[@jiliene_eneilij]

for me, Kaylee is the most stable vocal compared to the other members

[@lovejune___]

sorry to ask - what's the difference between lipsyncing and backtrack overuse?

[@FizzYT_]

so with backtrack overuse they are still singing live but you can hardly hear them as the backtrack (thats the song in the background) is louder than them. so basically they may be relying on the backtrack for certian parts of the song to sound better in the performance. (does that make sense)

[@lovejune___]

@@FizzYT_ yeah that does make sense! tysm

[@slay-gy6cl]

wait i thought the fox news performance was just a fan edit

[@FizzYT_]

how can someone edit a performance? 😂

[@FizzYT_]

sorry i just realised now that sounded rude it was a genuine question lol

[@mocneeuq]

Lexi should at least exert some effort in singing some lines, she totally just lipsynch LOL, also if KG can't sing her lines live, just give them to Kaylee. They really need to practice more. This debut performances are not good.

[@FizzYT_]

honestly, it might not be Lexi’s choice. Their team may be instructing her not to sing for some reason?

[@asiangsus]

Lexi has some of the most difficult choreography during her lines though. In the beginning, she whips her hair around multiple times while trying to sing THEN her rap part has such an INTENSE dance as well so i understand why she wouldn’t sing. it’s almost impossible to sound good on Lexi’s parts.

[@reidrevcornel]

@@asiangsus ntm on kendall's first prechorus, she literally rolls on the floor but u can"t see it bc she's behind

[@mocneeuq]

@@FizzYT_ LOL why only her? Even Kendall sang a few lines although it is still bad

[@mocneeuq]

@@asiangsus most idols lessen their choreo to sing their lines live, but Lexi just totally lipsynch, not even one word did she sing. I don't know why you are excusing her laziness to sing live. The other members also has hard choreo on their part, but at least they exert some effort. While the leader is just lazy

[@namirashehrin1838]

kg is definitely live,her voice is gorg

[@kebabs127]

2:25 whos that?

[@tri.beandtrues]

It's Camila

[@adrianabt6452]

Camila

[@FizzYT_]

Camila she's one of my favs

[@asiangsus]

CAMILA, MISS GIRL ATE THAT HIGH NOTE!

[@kebabs127]

@@FizzYT_ maybe I will Stan

[@Niven42]

This show wasn't really a good choice to highlight their singing. They usually do better.

[@who-mo8qk]

its so unfair with that ridiculous choreo on the pre choruses part, like they can absolutely do anything but floor work like, rookies can’t prob sing that live w such a hard choreo

[@nayeonsbunny1]

It’s not live, it’s with backtrack. I honestly don’t get why K-pop stans r ok with this bc it’s not live. Like, the companies r just so scared for them to mess up, and maybe not all groups r like this, but at least vcha could easily sing live without the backtrack and sound the exact same. Why r we ok with this, idk y some people consider this “live singing”

[@sinnombre4122]

Some of them don't even try, which is sad.

[@Emyrtemoc]

The camera work is trash. They pan the camera to the other girls who isn't singing the part which why you think they're lip syncing. Vcha always sing live. Plus the audio on this video is trash. Its not even in sync

[@FizzYT_]

They are not singing live entirely and that’s okay, the dance routine is really difficult and tiring. This performance specifically you can tell the bits that are and aren’t live due to the poor audio mixing.

[@Emyrtemoc]

@@FizzYT_ every kpop group used backtrack. Even the BlackPink used backtrack with their live band. Anyways because of the poor production by Fox News, this got to be one of VCha's worst videos.

[@Nopebrbra]

Wtach my video, I extract live audio from the original tv file and removed back

[@FizzYT_]

@@Nopebrbra i know i saw it! or maybe someone elses mr removed. anyways it really helped with with this video

[@marlonandres1312]

You got problem with your hearing its all live watch all tneir lives performance mexico brazil acoustic live its all the same specially acoustic youre just a hater 😂😂😂

[@FizzYT_]

i literally love vcha and if you cant hear it maybe your ears arent used to being able to tell it apart, also when did i ‘hate’ on them? did i ever say anything bad about them lipsyning? how about you let your delusion rest and just admit sometimes they lipsync it really isnt that deep.

[@marlonandres1312]

@@FizzYT_ what ever

[@mamastay164]

THIS ISN'T WORTH ME WATCHING THE WHOLE VIDEO!!! I WATCH TAYLOR SWIFT COS SHE SINGS LIVE.

[@FizzYT_]

her songs are also a lot easier to sing and she does not have complex choreography so ye go watch her. she also has more then 10 years of experience on these girls.

[@chaeynq]

there is a big difference here, their coreography is more complex and they are mostly teenagers with the oldest being 18 . and they are in the start of their careers , so pls don’t hate on them ! 🫶

[@kebabs127]

your faves lipsync too and they have years on vcha...

[@wowiehowiethatscrayzy]

thats the dream academy group right??

[@FizzYT_]

noo it’s the a2k group!!

[@enzzofc]

No

[@asiangsus]

so close, that's a shape!

[@hrtsforvi]

They haven’t even debuted yet no? 😭

[@Niven42]

​@@hrtsforvi yeah, I don't think the Dream Academy group has debuted yet.