How Rich Are Singaporeans? | 新加坡人真的幸福嗎? 戶口有多少錢? 華人社會的榜樣? 現實也是殘酷的!

[@peiyingmiao6004]

李光耀太有遠見了 他看透華人「有土斯有財」的觀念 強力打造公平的房屋政策 讓太多人受惠 看看香港 台灣 大陸的高房價。。深深覺得李光耀是真正貫通中西文化的政治家

[@劉小銘-b9r]

台灣更慘，政府努力賣國有地放任炒房炒地炒工業地，超多年討論公宅，結果比例依然低

[@discovery1028]

台灣一堆比新加坡便宜的房子吧

[@johncheung4005]

李光耀係個有道德， 有能力嘅偉大領袖。 相對於某啲， 腐敗無能， 嘅 領袖， 真係好好多

[@chialinw]

新加坡土地國有 居多，採社會主義，制度不同，跟台灣還是不太一樣

[@巴風特盔甲-o1w]

台灣應該開放香港人來台買房子的

[@live50is100difficult]

7:52 他是地产王，这样也给你遇见，在新加坡有28间店，他儿子不孝，钱很多，真的很多，我在新加坡住了30年，我知道这个人很低调。

[@jialewong8048]

这位老先生是谁？查不到资料

[@IVT666]

请问他叫什么名字？好奇而已

[@LINDA-m7c7l]

他很 ‘低调’ 😂

[@smliangjl]

A lot of our rich uncles look humble. By the way, he probably one of those small construction/ developer that made big money in the early development of Singapore. Don’t judge the book by its cover!😂

[@szewong3781]

我我田0

[@szewong3781]

@@murnisuyadi8991 。

[@szewong3781]

我尸0

[@szewong3781]

我尸0

[@szewong3781]

我尸0

[@ntpu503]

身為台灣年輕人，真的羨慕新加坡政府願意蓋HDB，而且是合理的價格，在台灣這是沒辦法想像的，「居住正義」只是政客的選舉口號。根據官方統計，台灣政治人物的政治獻金過半是建商捐獻，可想而知不敢得罪建商以免失去選舉經費，況且若真的蓋了HDB，附近居民也會抗議價格不得低於市場行情，免得讓他們的房子掉價。近年台灣房價所得比屢創新高，2022年台北市要不吃不喝16年，與香港23年真是難兄難弟，哈哈哈哈......嗚嗚嗚嗚嗚。

[@杨波-q1b]

请问，不吃不喝16年买房子是在台北市中心么？

[@ntpu503]

@@杨波-q1b 不是喔，16年是整個台北市的平均值，市中心精華地帶每戶要價上億台幣的比比皆是

[@fantasydeepdark1657]

你们这也还好，虽然挺糟糕的但比大陆还是好很多了。我有个同学很厉害了，进上海intel，一年30万，但上海房子舒服点的没个七八百万下不来，关键是这已经是很厉害的人了，普通一点的人这辈子可以直接放弃这个念想

[@hslee3977]

@@cloudy1803 我是新加坡人，新加坡现在基本上住哪一区生活基能都不错而且政府都会不断 upgrade或进行翻新。政府的目标是不久的将来让每户人家都能在 10钟内走到地铁(捷运）而且政府说到都能做到。

[@xiaochongwang4898]

你可能不知道，新加坡的HDB政府一直在亏钱卖

[@torrespit666]

Next episode we go back to Europe~ Subscribe & click the notification button so you don't miss the good shxt!!

[@NeverLetMeGo777]

That billionaire uncle seems "blow water" more than anything😅

[@user-bj7ts6pq9w]

吹下水姐 😂👍

[@jling7343]

Blow water +2

[@stepheny6998]

講中文就講中文啦 blow water 😑 笑L左 扮abc 好嘔心

[@shrunked]

Reality: he's not rich

[@EePingLiang]

Definately chui shui

[@rayduenglish]

新加坡！！熟悉的味道

[@nerd2544]

40 seconds ago damn a miracle

[@Gremy41]

活捉

[@dawinng7796]

野生滴（抓）

[@MrGod47]

你不是支持蔡英文民X黨台獨反華? 新加坡不喜歡蔡英文和民X黨。

[@kkkkkkkkkkk926]

你的头像就很新加坡

[@yiueric8950]

i love how the uncles invite torres to grab a chair and chat while they are still having durian 😂

[@yushen7202]

非常友善的大叔。

[@lindazhang8004]

hahahaha, ye so cute

[@LINDA-m7c7l]

Friendly uncle 😊

[@yanneyan672]

香港和新加坡最大的不同，是香港有的是李嘉诚和李兆基他们，但是新加坡却有李光耀李显龙父子，这是新加坡之福。

[@lengyeowang4147]

李嘉誠的是產房！李兆基才是地產

[@RMminions]

他说做房地产，然后问他做哪块房地产，他又说烟草什么的，不根据问题回答，是不是吹牛啊?

[@slashorysk]

新加坡嘅住建部門都寫住“安得廣廈千萬間，大庇天下寒士俱歡顏”。

[@wong517]

The uncle is jobless and poor men, not real, he just boosting about himself actually he no house looking for food 那位uncle 是穷苦人士来的，我常常看见他, 他住我家对面

[@ucfg5113]

新加坡太獨裁了，要移民還是歐美紐澳最好再次一點日本

[@rchan338]

how often you see a genuine rich person will be telling strangers that he is a rich guy ? 😂

[@heesingsia4634]

He either has very little relatives or they're much more richer than him. Genuinely RICH Chinese uncles are frugal AF. No such thing as spending 80% of what they earn

[@iamhardwell2844]

this is south east asia we do have a lot of rich folks look like they need helps

[@smliangjl]

We have a lot of rich uncles look humble . 😂

[@John_Smith_86]

I am quite well off, and I don't mind telling people. Although for an actual camera videoing, that is too much for me. But just in casual talk, it isn't that big a deal. This is Singapore, we are very very safe.

[@raventail2205]

Rich people never tell other people they are rich only those who want face will try to show they are rich. Lot of people are not honest they lie about thier salary, thier job, thier lifestyle it just to look good on the surface. In today society people has long degraded in term of honesty, morality the social media has corrupt people mind. People made themselves more complicated why they so care about face it does not have any value at all, spend hard earn salary just to show people they eat luxury food, branded bag,belt,watch,clothes. Did they not save any money? Debt in loan, housing, car, credit card can they pay back those heavy load? I saw lot of people destroy themselves by spending all thier pension money in one year. For those who borrow to much loan money it just take a lay off from thier workplace it will cost them dearly, house and car get taken away. Lot and lot of this case happened. We no need to care about face we just need to spend what we need face value mean nothing at all. People alway incite other people to do stupid stuff, if you hang out with show of pattern people you will become one of them, if you hang out with pervert you will become them, if you hang out with gamer you become gamer, if you hang out with liar you will become liar. If you hang out with mad people you become so negative. Friend is bullshit. Out of 100 people only one may be true friend the rest is cancer.

[@stevenlim9640]

新加坡真的幸福吗？答案：是80%新加坡人是住公屋HDB，挤巴士/地铁，吃在又热又吵又挤的小贩中心。

[@jeremyxu5870]

这个怎么怎么看了，现在这个世道就是一个比烂的社会，华人社会里面现在中国大陆极左，台湾过于民粹，香港社会割裂各种内耗，也就新加坡不左不右走实用主义路线，虽然也有很多问题，但是在新冠疫情下也算是一直在前进！ 而且华人地区所有领导人对比起来还是李显龙最靠谱，毕竟虎父无犬子~其他都是一言难尽…

[@SynaMerchantChina]

“极左”，哦，搞共同富裕和乡村振兴就是极左吗？对港台的评价很到位，但是对大陆误解太多了吧。

[@jeremyxu5870]

@@SynaMerchantChina 呵呵，你就是典型的只看其一不看二，…你开心就好

[@lengyeowang4147]

@@SynaMerchantChina 不錯！大陸是極右，恢復皇帝制

[@chungmeng160]

@@SynaMerchantChina 那你就窝在墙内偷着乐吧😀😀😀

[@李立華-o8q]

台灣過於民粹....這句話講得也太真實啦！真是一言難盡啊...

[@user-bj7ts6pq9w]

其實香港有好多有錢佬/婆，好隱藏，好低調，日日食茶餐廳，飲平價茶樓，係為咗享受，但係都幾千萬身家，幾達樓收緊租，閒閒哋。 香港上一代的有錢人，真係好謙卑呀，唔會講咁多。 因為佢哋真係辛苦捱返嚟， 知道唔容易，所以不自誇，不張狂。

[@senzaki1819]

香港地真係好多隱藏有錢人，之前有調查報告話香港有成1.5萬人身家超過2.3億，如果淨係講過1000萬身家我諗真係隨便係街到都會搵到個

[@imshulei]

@@senzaki1819 香港一千万不是不多吗？应该达到5000万才是富人吧，买个普通的房子不就一千万了吗？我了解的不多，是这样吗？

[@kingyuenmok5474]

@@imshulei 便宜的400萬（約1600萬台幣

[@imshulei]

@@kingyuenmok5474 400真的是太小了……可能20平方米都没吧，我觉得如果是结婚生活的话，买房子起码得将近一千万的

[@思琪梁]

發哥咩其中一位😂

[@eldensim4010]

新加坡uncle & aunty 都很喜欢说自己没钱但都有钱去旅行. 不久前银行一推出2点多%储蓄利息所有银行整个月整天都大排长龙😅

[@ethanchuar178]

新加坡阿伯真係同廣東好多阿伯一樣，穿的好求其，身家億億聲

[@jeffersonedith]

好多南洋華人都係廣東同福建人

[@hkwo829]

“不是給，是還我”好正

[@zeyingwu344]

因为新加坡有个东西叫cpf，65岁之前你所有工资都会按比例扣钱强制你存在cpf，等过了65岁才会还你。。所以就是还钱。。不是送的退休金

[@監察者無名氏]

@@zeyingwu344 跟香港的強積金一樣

[@zeyingwu344]

@@監察者無名氏 香港是公司交还是员工交啊？香港到手工资比新加坡高。我知道大陆是公司交，新加坡是公司和员工都要交。我之前在新加坡自己一个月被扣1500新币。

[@nancylee4179]

wu！哇你的工钱非'常高

[@ManjuTiger]

可以嗅到一丝丝“怨之气”😂。话说老一辈的新加坡华裔还是比较豪爽的，诚实、敢言，比较像我们满洲人，年轻一代就不行了，滑头得很也不知道哪里学来的。

[@Wosotsing]

我去我新加坡玩 親戚嘅組屋超大 齋間房已經大過香港間屋😅

[@medmuckersmedia3185]

Old uncle is a typical retired Rich chinese businessman in Singapore. He already hinted about his wealth. Unlike HK, Rich older Singaporeans are very low key. When tycoon Ng Teng Fong was still alive, I saw him walking alone near his hotel with a little plastic bag like this old man.

[@lengyeowang4147]

The late OUB boss often eating at golden shore FC just behind OUB building

[@yuan8061]

i trust that uncle is a richman cauz in malaysia also got many uncle like that😄

[@rueis959]

只在新加坡转过机，甚至没出过机场，但对那边的印象很不错，期待以后能在那边读master

[@roseannahuang2032]

都話左愈有錢愈低調同謙虛,係D人唔信,其實一開口就知道,口德係一個特徵！ 重有而家既環境能夠供得起樓既人係相當有能力,我身邊既80、90後,大部份都只能夠繼續同家人住,冇資產何來發達機會. 非常有價值的資訊🙏

[@studytimelapseforyou]

You are right...my friends who lives in landed properties in Singapore they never mention anything about their family background and we all just make friends no matter our SES

[@roseannahuang2032]

@@studytimelapseforyou Thanks for sharing and happy new year 🧧

[@roy6732856]

原本感覺新加坡的物價跟台灣差距很大，但最近以台灣的物價跟房價來看，幾乎已經跟新加坡差不多了，但是我們的基本薪資可是差了新加坡一大截。 默默的才開始感覺到新一代的台灣年輕人對於房地產是多麼遙不可及的 在台灣我們每月4萬(約1750新幣)是我們的平均薪資。 而網路上資料顯示新加坡每月12萬(約5200新幣) 是他們的平均薪資。 就以這樣的薪資差距，我們的房價竟然跟新加坡只是"差距不大"的價格。 片中看到5顆蘋果才約70塊台幣，真的來講已經是比台灣的蘋果物價低了。 在小吃街價格來講，說實在跟台灣的物價真的也差異不大。

[@Jack_chen691]

有东西贵，就有东西便宜的，每个地方都有他的优势，新加坡背靠东南亚，这些地方本身就生产水果，离得近运费便宜，所以水果蔬菜便宜。

[@justnow5809]

Believe in karma...you are destined to be born wherever. ..

[@kdogg0916]

台灣一個便當100多台幣，新加坡一個雞飯也台幣100多，但是台灣的收入差新加坡好幾倍，不過台灣水電便宜（因為政府要選票），所以各有利弊

[@Jack_chen691]

@@kdogg0916 是啊，比如我，我是个烟民，我如果是在新加坡工资估计都不够我抽烟。

[@yopinwu2082]

但是新加坡贫富差距蛮大的，底层的收入应该不如台湾吧

[@endi4654]

I came across your KZbin because of your Scotland video. Singaporean here. Thanks for having subtitles as I don't understand Cantonese and Mandarin. It's really entertaining watching your videos. Perhaps I share about housing payment.. If you purchase a house within your means, eg, myself and my wife purchase a resale 5 room flat in our late twenties for $350k, and also were granted a total of $60k in grants for being a first time buyer and for choosing a house close to our parents. Eventually we only need to pay a total of $1k combined a month via CPF. So, no cash payment is required. 5 years later, our house cost $550k. And if we downgrade to 3 or 4 room flat (say after 5 years minimum occupied period), we'll earn a handsome profit. Some of my peers upgrade to condo as they have higher salaries. But for me, I'd rather live life debtless, mortgageless, and perhaps earn income living off dividends only. That does not make me rich, but comfortable. Hope this shed some light. Cheers! And btw, its pretty common to have $100k in your cpf before 30. Many hit $500k in their CPF by 50? But many also keep some of their floating asset in stocks, index fund etc on top of having a sizeable cash in their bank. But let's not forget, there'll always be people who are in the lower income bracket that are struggling to make ends meet. And those who spend beyond their means, incurring debts despite high income. Debt due to car payments especially.

[@LordBagdanoff]

350k 5 rm flat must be somewhere Ulu 😂

[@endi4654]

@@LordBagdanoff yup. In the North, and it was during buyer's market whereby there were many ready BTO flats unsold in my area. I actually bargained from listed 372k price after asking the right questions.

[@arsenal_84]

Congrats ! seems like you are on the path to early retirement.

[@Legofan5445]

Thank you for sharing and making this video! It's a stark wakeup call for Singaporeans to know that we are actually blessed as compared with many other countries. We need to learn to be more grateful and less complaining so our lives can be more happy ~

[@coreywong]

Maybe the constant complaining is the reason why it’s so blessed? Can’t constantly improving and grateful exists at the same time? I live in Taiwan now, Taiwanese is always content what they have and never complain, and the whole society is stuck in 1990s.

[@jimseah8974]

must seize opportunity lah...the 70 yr old cleaner at my block during crypto boom was forced by son to empty savings and bought shiba and doge...she now lives in a GCB and is ferried around in a bently...she is shopping for a gulfstream i heard...she also asked which soccer club to buy in italy serie b

[@endi4654]

@@coreywong actually Taiwan is doing pretty well. It has a thriving (and a leader) in semi-conductor

[@michaelscarn6629]

​@@coreywong You should thank the government for being smart, despite the criticism it gets. I don't think they set up policies like CPF and BTO because they heard a bunch of people complaining 😂 countries whose citizens drive the government for better welfare and policies (eg. France) do it through marches and strikes with clear demands, not by complaining on social media or in the comfort of their homes

[@QdosTamsiz]

@rumy967 @nonsequitur9332 If you have a willing to give urine / pangsay water to anyone's food, thats mean Allah wants your destiny to be Satan slave be prepared to become smelly, dirty, ugly, poor, and disgusting,buy anything Verry expensive ,buy food expensive but not delicious.peace bro just for knowledge.✌️✌️✌️(your Ghoib debt raising)))read Alkafirun 100 times every after shalat so more easy get money bonus from your job((277°qiblatain the best)) (Robber and good people price are different actually looks like,,,🤣🤣🤣🤣🪐🪐🪐alien Zachari zohori zoom)))

[@MrKevinliow88]

Actually 80% of Singaporeans stay in HDB

[@audreyang6173]

新加坡？ 阿不就是比較現代國際化的北韓囉

[@435keanu]

Hi Audrey ang ..嗨親愛的..你看起來很好很漂亮......我在這裡看到了你的評論。我很樂意見到你。請我希望我們成為朋友。但 youtube 僅限於聊天。如果你給我發電子郵件，我會很高興。請發電子郵件給我。我的Gmail在上面。如果您發送電子郵件，我將向您發送一條消息作為回報。謝謝拜託🙏...

[@goov6071]

Not a rich country, many poor citizens

[@limlisa]

Dont agree

[@yushen7202]

除了内容有趣以外。国语，广东话，英文切换自如。而且每一种语言都讲得很好！给你点赞!!

[@Jiarui]

厉害了

[@joshuawongyh]

Can any Singaporean dig more info about the wealthy uncle. Very curious 😂

[@fredalfred6790]

+1

[@mede3699]

这样吹牛逼的uncle在牛车水排到芽笼，Wow lao wei

[@kwongt2046]

+2

[@雪走-m7z]

卡

[@guan0417]

he from IMH

[@dogofegg]

那新加坡的組屋看起來也不便宜啊，也要台幣1000萬以上，而且也不是永久產權，等於是租99年，之前新聞報導都說新加坡人人買得起房，可能是以他們的收入來說，或者房價穩定吧，但是他們一般人的退休金沒有想像中的多啊，也就跟台灣一般勞工階層退休領的差不多。不過他們有錢人也跟台灣一樣都很低調，不炫富。

[@xavierlee3368]

人人买得起房。。其实 是，收入少的，政府有额外补贴啦。 所谓的退休金，正如片中的uncle 所说的，是自己退休前做工的时候，好比如政府设定的“强制储蓄”，然后退休后，每月固定还给你，这个是一直还终生的。。所以，想赚到政府的钱，哈哈，多运动，健康长寿，活久久！！

[@AZ-zk6fr]

@@xavierlee3368 原來如此，有額外補貼，可還是很貴，以台灣人來看的話

[@mwong1152]

To be fair, the portion at SG 大牌檔 is smaller when comparing to those in HK 大排檔/茶餐廳 … if considering this, the price difference is not so huge

[@tangt4860]

He's trying to follow the footsteps of Nasty and Ojisan to score a Singapore PR but not citizenship to escape from the CCP and become the millions of foreign mercenaries getting to own and finally sell off BTOs while jacking up the prices for genuine local Singaporeans and deprive them of a chance to own even a flat. Many of those interviewed are rather spurious. Many of them do not own the flats which their parents paid for.

[@irishlee9547]

the price difference is very much reflecting the rent difference

[@stevenlim9640]

新加坡没人敢讲真话，

[@studytimelapseforyou]

Don't judge a book by its cover ( I learned it from my secondary school) My friend his dad is a CFO but he wears singlet out My other friend parents own a lawyer firm he rarely mention anything about it. People around me all live in landed and condo but they never ever judge people like me who lives in HDB there is no segregation at all. I love my friends so so much

[@wilsonwilson7533]

95 percent of rich people are low profile but the 5 percent will show off, no problem so far they don't break a law and the culture of a country and effectiveness of a gov will control and letting the kids know showing off is not a good thing to do . In contrast, low tier rich people showing off is a general case. More and more rich Chinese are learning not to show off now but look at the white /black /Indian rich show off youtube videos nowadays lol

[@ManjuTiger]

🇸🇬房价所谓便宜也只是对比世界上少数地狱级别的城市如香港、深圳、上海、北京等罢了，BTO（新组屋）之前已经不便宜了，这两年更是疯狂飙升，以这样的价格完全可以在其它Asean国家买两三套高档的landed houses，或者在大陆普通一、二线城市买到又大又高档的condos（公寓）。

[@12823matthewkao]

Condo是連棟別墅好嗎，apartment 才是公寓。還有中國買的房子也不是真的你的，傳不了子孫，再來就是建築質量跟生活環境才是真正差別巨大的地方。中國在2010年代落成的海量住宅，現在已經開始出各種問題了，簡單來說，有能力在國外買房的人，早就都走光了。

[@muriellin973]

@@12823matthewkao 嗯，其實condo (condominium) 也是公寓(依照華人的概念)，只不過以產權而言，通常是允許個人購買個人擁有，例如我在LA好友告訴我前陣子她買了一個靠海邊的condo which is one of the units of a "condominium building",那我就知道她買的不是house；而apartment通常是整棟產權都屬於同一人，所以很多時候是拿來租賃的。所以，這兩種房屋形態都達不到所謂“別墅”的狀態(就是獨門獨戶的房子)。如果單單只論新加坡的話，嚴格說起有四種房產1)政府租屋(HDB)，只限公民和永居購買，擁有權有年限，無土地；2) 執行共管公寓(EC)，這個說真的我并不那麼熟悉，但這是介於私人房屋和租屋之間的一個類型；3) 有地房產，基本上只有公民和特別批准的外籍人士可以擁有，價格相當昂貴，可以是bungalow, semi-detached, cluster house, town-house. 我有幾個前同事都是住在這些房屋里，4) 最後一種就是私人公寓(condominium), 這個就是台灣香港一般拿來賣的各類建案，大陸叫做商品屋的可買賣私人公寓；只不過，新加坡很妙，它的地契很多元化，有99年的也有永久的，不像台灣買斷就是你的，而香港和大陸都有年限的(應該也是99年)。

[@muriellin973]

我確實也覺得新加坡的BTO並不便宜，但在其他地方，甚至在新加坡自己買兩三套高檔獨棟房屋是不可能的，拿洛杉磯，舊金山，西雅圖，波士頓而言，真的也是有難度；若是論大陸“普通”一二線城市，嗯如果是一線城市，本身已經不太普通了--北上廣深，拿我比較熟悉的上/深吧，基本上已經趕上甚至超越香港了，而新二線，比如福州吧，那個房價真的也是很多人需要努力一陣的

[@12823matthewkao]

@@muriellin973 還有就是中國哪來的99年年限的房子？最長的就70年還有五十年的現在甚至有30年的，不要混淆視聽啦，都是成年人見過世面的，這些留給你自己聽罷。

[@muriellin973]

@@12823matthewkao 首先，這裡我說錯了謝謝你糾正，但我的重點是大陸確實並沒有私人土地權狀，我主要是想糾正你對condo的解釋！另外，你的網路社交禮儀讓人並不舒服，無須講話如此橫眉豎眼

[@jamieatelier]

香港的可使用面积只占百分之三十 新加坡政府手上很多地囤在手里逐步开发 星国政府比李嘉诚还劲 曾经香港人口也几乎是新加坡的两倍

[@MrRazorteeth]

uncle said he is low profile but feels like he like to brag😂

[@tangt4860]

And he shook hands with Teo Chee Hean. OmG, no wonder he has to stroll along the passe Orchard Road instead of enjoying beautiful weather and nicer crowds in better parts of the free world.

[@blilasg8956]

I think he meant he is low class (as in not highly educated) not low profile.

[@cjzhou7210]

有幸在新加坡生活工作了一个月，很棒的国家。就是天气不太友好，哈哈。

[@2024龙年]

太阳能发电无限

[@LINDA-m7c7l]

Thanks for your compliment 😊

[@蔡英狗-f1m]

李家坡那种鬼地方能住人吗？

[@435keanu]

Hi hello ..嗨親愛的..你看起來很好很漂亮......我在這裡看到了你的評論。我很樂意見到你。請我希望我們成為朋友。但 youtube 僅限於聊天。如果你給我發電子郵件，我會很高興。請發電子郵件給我。我的Gmail在上面。如果您發送電子郵件，我將向您發送一條消息作為回報。謝謝拜託🙏...

[@yexiou]

好好笑，開口第一句「我做房地產 難道沒錢嗎？」第二句「我很低調的」 開口閉口「我做房地產」笑死

[@kaiserfox]

他说他很低，没说到低调。应该是说他是低阶级致富的意思

[@zhizheng8406]

是，我的理解也是他想说从底层做起。

[@yuanliao2520]

跟老人計較什麼

[@Aki-yn4pg]

Money cannot buy class. 😅

[@kaiserfox]

@@Aki-yn4pg he might just be behaving in his own humble way since he's not as fortunate as you to receive education when he's at your age

[@adamaziz6486]

that uncle is lying

[@nurudaddy]

WELCOME TO SINGAPORE I'm broke btw

[@chuanglydia1132]

Taiwan and Hong Kong have the same problem. The younger generation can't afford a house even if they work all their lives.

[@nancyy4985]

阿伯活得好开心喔哈哈哈 祝福托哥频道越来越好～

[@鄭先生-s9z]

家裡三代沒有享受到房子土地好處的，才會抱怨房價貴年輕人買不起房....台灣一大堆家庭，幾十年來靠房產，財富增加數千萬的滿街都是，一二三億的也很多.....週遭認識幾乎全都是，你們家沒有是長輩的問題，這一代就苦.....

[@ducktangslime]

😆😆😆低調但驕傲的老阿公 真好～時機對了把握住就富有一生了❤

[@jemyzhu9293]

阿公不會是吹牛吧？

[@cwkchicky]

@@jemyzhu9293 哈哈哈哈

[@ducktangslime]

@@jemyzhu9293 如果是就很尷尬了😆😆😆

[@bbkui]

他骄傲，但宅心仁厚。他低调，但受万人敬仰

[@Grant-ty4se]

@@bbkui 他背二百斤小麦十里山路不换肩

[@ericlin7870]

新加坡一般人沒錢的,有錢的是外來移民

[@kcchiew4247]

Welcome to Singapore! Not every household is rich in Singapore. But as long as we plan and spend wisely, we can hv comfortable living condition in this country.

[@Johnne009]

In a first world country. Everyone should be wealthy and prosperous not just comfortable

[@kcchiew4247]

@@Johnne009 Not all are wealthy: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHiXf5luntyHrpo

[@androsc1418]

@@Johnne009 Better to be comfortable and at peace.

[@christophersia5834]

@@Johnne009 pls travel to western so call first world country n tell me everyone is wealthy n prosperous… you need to get out more

[@seagull9889]

@@Johnne009 Unrealistic expectations. This happens only in Utopia

[@神羅天征-o1o]

跟其他族群比華人還是算是有錢的 工作努力會儲蓄懂得投資尤其是房地產

[@nicktsui1053]

新加坡的政策，香港真係要學下，成日坐井觀天

[@ha07668]

新加坡的組屋政策不錯啊！好羨慕呀！要是香港每個人都能買得起房子，開心指數一定高好多，社會也會和諧很多。😢

[@zhoma982]

所以所有想要修公屋的特首都被你们赶走了。

[@Lam_MieuMieu]

立法會層層阻力的原因又不是不知，反對的也是一群人，「上班式」反對

[@子国-t8q]

@草草 这150个人是来香港卖房子的吗？

[@子国-t8q]

@@Lam_MieuMieu 香港的制度解决不了问题

[@lunalau7803]

澳門都係😅想上樓太難了

[@chinasomecat]

新加坡吃的真的好便宜啊。就算在樟宜机场转机，里面的food court在我看来都不算贵。

[@pondylin8790]

香港吃飯真的貴😂😂😂

[@kingyuenmok5474]

但工資也高

[@pennyarts886]

To tell everyone, 知足常乐，don't ask for more, spend an amount that you can last, and eat an amount that your stomach could hold, enjoy every day with a satisfying heart. This is what call life. Nowadays, young people try to challenge living in minimal, challenge yourself everyday, your perspective of view will be different. Don't compare to the rich, unnecessary and not meaningful.

[@williamng227]

笑死我了；这个老家伙是一个保潔工友不是什么富豪！

[@ianteoh8757]

马来西亚的屋子更便宜，又大间。

[@chungmeng160]

在大马假如一个月没人在家，房子会被搬空。😀😀😀

[@Timholle]

All the Singaporean uncles aunties so friendly 😂

[@Johnny5932u]

老伯車大炮啦！他不會英語不可能做政府生意

[@SuperAndyyan]

他真的是萬富翁。 可以去看看網路有他的故事

[@mede3699]

哇捞，真的假的

[@莎莎-p9g]

他叫甚麽名字呢？

[@garethkuek1538]

你又不直接讲名字你要我们去哪里找?可以不要来搞笑吗？🤣🤣

[@mede3699]

@@garethkuek1538 是呀，wow lao

[@tangt4860]

如果你挖更深， 他可能是你的远亲。

[@godtolove6984]

新加坡有李光耀，而香港却出了个李嘉诚，天壤之别啊，怎么比

[@carter9523]

我覺得你都可以黎澳門講下樓價😂

[@ChRoIn783]

要隔離5+3（9+0）邊個會來？😔

[@stevenlim9640]

‘新加坡住屋人人有房住’？‘南波湾’？流言而已！新加坡現在比香港更贵啦！公屋HDB五方式都以新币100万到150万，今年2022，两间五方式又以新币142万和137万完成交。又两间咖啡店都各以新币4000万以上转手。香港有这么离谱吗？政府新建的BTO四方式从新币70万到100万。私人公寓就是HDB的二，三倍价钱。但没人敢讲真话，大家一味赞新加坡南波湾，自欺欺人。

[@chekqiwei]

真正有钱的南洋华人都是这样，非常低调可是遇到那些不会低调的就会变得高调让他们知道自己那几毛钱不算什么东西

[@yivunqp963]

不低调会被绑架啊。

[@louislew9735]

新加坡还有很多吹水不用打稿的老头。。。就像你遇到那个说话都不准的大仙。。。😄

[@NoobVisions79]

What a great video again!! I love these. Singapore looks like a great place to visit as a tourist !

[@ganhaithong2097]

Yes u right. Is safe place

[@陳瑞昌-z4q]

新加坡是中國附屬國，從新加坡人心態及旗幟就可看出……

[@johngeminiox]

我是新加坡本地人，可是我觉得有很多新加坡人不懂感恩，太可惜了。。 Am a Singaporean myself but I felt that many Singaporeans aren't grateful enough and are still complaining a lot.

[@limheechon8762]

因为你们新加坡学足了西方那一套，竞争，金钱至上，现实无情，把中华传统文化圣贤教育丢了，所以才变成半人半鬼!!

[@weiling9624]

Meanwhile we born as malaysian work to death and cannot afford living expenses

[@chungmeng160]

我花的每一分钱都是辛辛苦苦赚来的血汗钱，感甚麽恩？？？

[@ManjuTiger]

@@limheechon8762 老一辈很多还好，视频里那两位大爷就很坦率。年轻一辈不知道出了什么问题，中文差到家不说，还总给人感觉很委琐，满嘴跑飞机，十句话里没两句真话。

[@itayongitayong3520]

因为很多年轻的一代被父母宠坏了。

[@星空喵姐]

1:23 不吃不喝要存700萬港幣才夠買1間房 ? 😱 2:23 香港排組屋等了20年都還沒等到 ? 好扯... 所以只能一直租房子嗎 ? 排到又如何 ? 一般人還是得勤勤懇懇努力實幹付30年房貸. 最好保佑30年都不出意外也不生病. 否則房貸斷炊. 就只有一個( 慘 )字. 可能淪落負債還流落街頭的命運... 😱 港劇都這麼說的. 3:34 4:10 購屋要等7年 ? 😱 組屋50萬新幣=279萬港幣. 新組屋約30~40萬新幣=約167萬~223萬港幣. ( 新加坡不會遇到臨陣脫逃的建商嗎 ? 這點很重要 ) 2:34 有對象就能申請. 臨時換角也沒差. 只要有結婚證書 ? 買房為何要跟婚姻掛勾 ? 還要等好幾年 ? 好無言... 😱 感覺新加坡這是在歧視單身人士 ☹ 那如果離婚. 房子要還回去嗎 ? 或是離婚夫妻如何分那棟房 🤔? 4:50 這才是重點啊... 11:12 自購屋( 自己付錢買的房子. 99年後. 要再還給政府 ? ) 台灣房產可以傳給子子孫孫. 在沒倒的情況下. 台灣房屋要倒也不容易. 地震多. 所以對房屋防震要求很高. 尤其大樓.

[@Jonathan-iq4hl]

5个苹果3新元，当然是便宜了，深圳5个苹果差不多要20CNY，接近4新元😢

[@kjtenn]

新加坡比香港好些

[@failee1034]

我是香港人, 自己做小生意, 跟過很多星加坡人聊天, 他們基本上都很滿意政府. 但都要看你為人, 有些星加坡跟我說為想學我做些小生意, 但是星加坡不容易, 一來那邊打工賺錢不少, 自己做生意的不容易賺到錢. 但香港如果你懂得做生意你可以賺很多錢, 始終香港機會多. 不過如果你只想開心生活, 我覺得星加坡應該是天堂了吧.

[@tangt4860]

满意政府是骗陌生人的。 就好像大陆仔敢反对中共吗？

[@irishlee9547]

yes that's true. Rich easily get more in HK while in sg things are more balance!

[@linnes00]

新加坡生活費還是蠻高的，政府天天想著怎麼用你的錢。如果你想開心應該去新加坡隔壁的馬來西亞。壓力會低很多。尤其是你在香港新加坡賺錢，然後在馬來西亞花的話，那樣就真的是天堂。

[@yebadio7938]

国家资本主义和自由资本主义的不同啦

[@JD-te1ug]

两边实际都生活就知道： 1）最新香港年轻人首次置业有超低税+9成贷款的，按照本地工资俩夫妻每人拿出30几万港币（包杂费）买个2房单位根本不难，按本地普通薪水正常存几年钱就有了。 2）而且香港买房供房的钱完全属于个人私有资产（就算房子太老了强制回收，政府也会按普通楼龄约8成市价给你钱），供房屋贷款还可以减税（申报后正常薪资水平基本0交税） 3）新加坡人一次性用自己公积金户口的钱买的祖屋有99年限期，属于消耗品（转手也不能重算）=香港的公屋，而区别是祖屋要一次性扣钱，公屋则是每月交个2-3千港币。所以何来优势？ 4）新加坡人发薪每月要交公积金，个人是20%，公司是17%（一共是薪资的37%），这些公司都会算入薪资成本，但都不是实际打工人实际所拿到的钱，虽然说是用来看医生和买房子，但是对比的香港公立医院是真正的免费（不会扣你的公积金养老金）而且就算要看私立医院，新加坡私立医院的价格比香港的高了不知道多少。 5）香港人日常消费没有消费税，进口商品的产品税也更低，所以买一样的东西和服务，新加坡人要给更多的钱到政府手里。 6）新加坡人没有所谓的免费综援等资助给需要帮助的人/老人，老了要靠养老金，香港除了养老金又是综援，又是生果金，又是伤残津贴，又是免费医疗，从2岁到大学各种免费教育和资助等等（这点住在香港的新加坡人最能感受到）。 7）新加坡男人当兵，政府还要养军队和军备，旁边还有这么多国家和宗族，都有好多难题。 香港年轻人需要有真正的去独立研究和思想，不要随意被一些甜蜜的表象所引导。

[@星空喵姐]

在看板主影片的時候. 搖晃了起來... 2024.04.22. 17:09分地震 17:12分地震... 晃到16分都還沒停. 時間也太長. 17:17分 17:53 又2次地震. 今天台灣下午連著5次地震. 都蠻大的... 😱 昨天也有2次. 恐怖... 😱😱

[@dragb6281]

恭喜遇到我国的大炮仙😂

[@jacksonwong90]

How rich are Singapore politicians ?

[@kokchonglee8990]

讲得很仔细新加坡有的地方啤酒比大马便宜

[@lengyeowang4147]

NCO club ?

[@chungmeng160]

新加坡烟，酒，车子应该是世界最贵的。

[@草木皆冰]

在新加坡撞到老高機率是多少👽

[@ellylauw3458]

星加坡是一個福地市民生活富裕你們太幸運了🎉

[@劉俊谷-i6r]

小缺點不看（沒有一個國家沒缺點），新加坡是一個適合打拼，和居住的地方～

[@cn8488]

适合打工 居住就算了 房价差不多赶上香港了 很多人会选马来西亚居住或退休

[@劉俊谷-i6r]

@@cn8488 有那麼誇張嗎？ 至少應該不會像台灣被炒成這種鬼樣子吧？

[@cn8488]

@@劉俊谷-i6r 台湾是不适合打工也不适合居住 哈哈哈哈

[@劉俊谷-i6r]

@@cn8488 問題很多這是沒辦法的事

[@cn8488]

@@劉俊谷-i6r 如果换算 台湾的房价和新加坡一样 新加坡的贵多一点 私人公寓也是一两百万新币 但是人均收入确实台湾人的好几倍 别人我不知道 我朋友在台湾做物理治疗师 我一个新加坡打工的薪水都比他多4倍 房租和他一样 还是已经换算过一样的币值比较

[@zackzou1441]

low key grandpa really was showing off his past glory.

[@markus0115]

台灣更慘，我住鶯歌基本上這是算邊緣地帶了，現在一坪最爛都要快二十萬，新的已經接近三十萬了，表示隨便都要一千多萬。重點是台灣薪水比新加坡低一半吧。最後最靠北的是台灣是虛坪制，要扣公設。實際一坪價位更高。所以台灣人生存更難。

[@discovery1028]

影片中提到，新加坡一坪換算也要40萬台幣耶。重點還是地上權。 怎麼算都是台灣便宜啊。

[@神農氏-b3b]

@@discovery1028 你要用所得去算

[@cclin5581]

組屋的貸款可由個人社保基金（CPF）先扣除,負擔相對低很多。不過cpf是由公司負擔，所以在新加坡創業初期成本較高。

[@austinsiew]

台灣一盤燙空心菜30~50台幣...但新北市台北市區的房子 新房大概2000萬台幣才有兩房一廳（公設30%~40%)，來台北看看 嗚嗚

[@lvkliscjw7913]

Hokkian lah😥 not singlish

[@deepbluedj]

霸氣四溢的阿伯(๑•̀ᄇ•́)و ✧

[@欧阳路遥]

I don’t think it is a fun place to live in this congested city , nothing but densely packed buildings and still you have to work many years for a small condo of your own , very frustrating, not life it should be .

[@danieltangtang]

在马来西亚，我有三套房子，都是分散在不同州，都是留给儿女们。以前马来西亚买屋子便于，现在，也是越来越贵了。。。。。

[@ManjuTiger]

🇲🇾生活质量比🇸🇬好多了啊，大部分新加坡人买不起车和好房子，而🇲🇾大部分人买得起车和别墅，游山玩水的地方也多。

[@danieltangtang]

@@ManjuTiger 可是，新加波政治安定，安稳，没有种族歧视，也很少犯罪分子，政党也没有发表玩弄种族手段，重点是，新加波任何种族都可以当国家PM，不像马来西亚，只限一个族群而已。。。。。再重点，新加波珍惜人才啊~哈哈哈，马来西亚是输出人才，因为马来西亚政府讨厌人才和聪明人。。。。😩💨

[@apelumaupaku883]

@@danieltangtang 新加坡真正有实权的，还不是一样始终是华人。

[@stevenlim9640]

流言而已！‘新加坡人中位月薪$6000’? 假的啊！多年前，一名越南女子，来新加坡自己在本地报纸公开征婚，征婚启事说明：新加坡男方月薪$6000以下不必申请。因为她查过了，新加坡人中位月薪$6000，所以少于$6000都是失败者，免了。我的朋友当医生几年才$6000,当会计经理8年才$4500。‘他们都是失败者’。所以说新加坡很多假的，流言而已。

[@louisachan8853]

是。普遍薪金低過$6000

[@stevenlim9640]

新加坡HDB四房式新币70万，新加坡人刚毕业薪水$1800-2500（排除裁员，新加坡很快常见），不吃不喝20年才能买到。如果是（像香港的）本地私人公寓，在新加坡是2，3倍HDB的价钱。那就40年，60年，不吃不喝。常听香港人说什么'供楼需不吃不喝...'，新加坡也一样。只是没人敢说事实而已。

[@louisachan8853]

你說到了重點。 另外更值得－提在坡國的普遍現象。因坡國政府鼓勵適婚年齡男女早婚生孩子，第一次買組屋的夫婦，會得到大比例政府津貼買組屋，致出現很多男生急著要女方結婚去申請組屋。這是非常獨特在新加坡。 當然香港也有年輕人為了夫婦申請公屋，趕快去注册結婚，但新加坡更為普遍。 這不是不好，而是有些為$ 結婚的男生，只是另一些借婚姻圖利不負責任的丈夫或父親。

[@stevenlim9640]

@@louisachan8853 在新加坡，没人敢讲真话

[@煮小姐]

对啊 而且99年还给政府 那就是一个消费品 … 这房子 根本就是很贵啊

[@LINDA-m7c7l]

Sg boleh 🎉

[@rickyseah4782]

old man already bragging

[@jiaweilim514]

BTO means build to order

[@TLB7414]

睇完新加坡房屋政策 終於知道點解香港政府點解會話唔會同人比較 根本就冇得比 輸撚到仆街

[@ethanchuar178]

香港當時董建華都想推出房屋政策，不過時機唔岩！遇到金融風暴！

[@神農氏-b3b]

香港政府自己就靠賣地賺取財政收入 哪會蓋公屋給人民住 根本就是一群好吃懶做的腐敗官僚

[@fz2950]

@二师兄 問題是官商勾結很嚴重（詳情見689特首和新鴻基地產，連ICAC都抓不了），所以減樓價，為人民生活造福是根本不存在的。 現在香港也有很多大白象工程，工程內都是既得利益者和偷工減料，地產商也是當房子是速食麥當勞，寧願房子破東破西也要衝出市場賣錢，所以你說的強人啊，不光是強可以解決的…畢竟經歷過社會事件看到人民的不滿後，政府還是繼續走錯的路，整個社會結構都臭掉要怎麼改革呀

[@TLB7414]

@二师兄 反對的人是有錢人 和我這種窮B無關 他們就是怕建公屋樓 房價會掉 都是有利益的阿

[@Useruser99963]

@@ethanchuar178 你太無知了

[@nomorepotato8517]

Welcome to Singapore Torres!

[@iamemmazon]

托哥什麼時候再來台灣～ 台灣也有好多很棒KZbinr想看你們合作😊😆😆

[@adonisbarnerd785]

之前在墨西哥有和台灣youtuber合作過

[@Tube-bh5ud]

記得他有跟阿滴合作一次 不過有拍過台灣視頻嗎？

[@keVinFong8210]

想请问你 香港小学的母语是不是粤语呢

[@smallpotato4927]

the low profile uncle is so funny 🤣

[@Timholle]

Singapore’s government is so paternalistic, everything’s planned out for us until retirement. Coerce in a sense or not, ultimately it’s for our good (Eg. CPF). Unfortunately, many are getting too pampered they don’t get how blessed they are here

[@wilsonwilson7533]

Many stupid kids didn't really lived or explored the live of other countries but just read news saying how good and how free are the western countries lol. THey don't read or watch news reflecting the real shitxxty situation of the west . For SG, the gov provide everyone a basic stable live I would say, if you are clever or smart or hardworking, you have a bigger chance to get rich comparing to people at other countries , bottle line is you can hardly see baggers or homeless people in SG at least which is an important indicator of the well beings of citizens of a country

[@Timholle]

@@wilsonwilson7533 exactly! I’m living in the US now - the country where the sg young genz are fangirling over & adopting their ridiculous ideologies from, it’s horrible. I go out everyday fearing for my life, shootings are a daily occurrence I hear gun shots every other day, their healthcare is out to bankrupt you, housing and rental prices are skyrocket high, their extent of homelessness is beyond anything you can imagine and food prices are obv ridiculous. As I get older & have travelled to many countries, I’ve grown to really appreciate Singapore & realized the amt of work & effort it took to get us to today. Proud to be Singaporean lah. These “woke” kids better wake the heck up if not they’ll be the ones to bring this country down like the US sia

[@stevenlim9640]

noelah, CPF ? you mean singaporean all no brain , just like you, to manage their finances, must be coerced by sg gov ?

[@Timholle]

@@stevenlim9640 people like you who have to depend on mere CPF for financial security would bound to be out on the streets when old & are exactly the group that will benefit from said CPF. No brain one is you who can’t even see nor know how to fully utilize the benefits. Don’t you know many with brains are topping up their CPF now instead to utilize the interest rates etc? Nah of course, you don’t. You’re welcome

[@Timholle]

@这种顽强非常东方 没错。你也要知道他们没战打就是没钱赚。 世界不平美国最开心了

[@audreylee5117]

And all the new BTO’s are getting smaller. Older hdb’s are bigger

[@SandyWong42]

在我公司樓下食碟乾炒牛河要50蚊唔包嘢飲!可惡呀！💢👹(反枱!)

[@chankhuilau6820]

You asking old man like this walking in Orchard Road, he wearing slippers and wearing like this means he is living around that area! Of course rich lah! He is real!