How to Do Hindu-Muslim Dialogue - Seyyed Hossein Nasr with Project Noon

[@mohammadyunustemory1249]

Mashallah! Sayyed Hossien Nasr is one of the greatest living Muslim philosopher and thinker of of our time. I have had the honor to read most of his books. His ideas and writings are flowing through much of the world. He is continuation of great thinkers, such as Jami, Mawlana Balkhi, Ibn Arabi, Ibn Sena and many other wonderful sages. May Allah gives him health and time to write more about Islam. With love and respect, Yunus From Kabul

[@oraetlabora1922]

Are you a Muslim?

[@aimanismail4683]

mashallah♥This was a wonderful conversation!

[@Lawdragoness]

He is intellectual great personality

[@freedomhop]

Dr.Sayed Hossien Nasr Greatest livening Muslim philosopher if you guys get a chance please have look ❤

[@johnnychrome7708]

How can we reconcile the Hindu doctrine of reincarnation with the realities of the afterlife in Islam?

[@jidrit999]

you are fool.

[@johnnychrome7708]

@@lightgatha Explain. It’s a question i struggle with.

[@Irene-m9n8b]

Sir, you have noble and laudable thoughts achieved through your extensive studies.Yet issues remain. One issue is formlessness of God. A formless entity can not be worshipped. A form has to be given like: a word ,a book, a symbol like star or menorah or scrolls , or a man made building. So formlessness is devoid of a meaning.

[@rafathwaheed7594]

Surah Ibrahim talks about when Prophet Ibrahim (Abraham) questioned the Quresh worshipping idols made from stones.

[@axio8]

Nope۔ I consider myself Perennialist in the sense that Quran requires or commands me to be, i.e. to believe in all prophets, messengers and books and that theres never been a single nation to whom Allah SWT didnt send His guidance but Nasr is seems to be struggling or perhaps even forcing to reconcile Iconic Hinduism with Islam. The spiritual or metaphysical aspects of Islam and Hinduism, as is prevalant today, can no doubt be easily reconciled inwardly but on a more literal and outwardly level Islamic Sharia / Law is irreconcilably clear about idol / icon worship. The Arabs of Jahiliya (pre Islamic) worshipped their idols just as a means to reach the God most High.

[@akmanwarulkabir8729]

Where is Bangladesh in your discussion. You touches east west , Karachi, India all. But where is Banglades which is the second largest muslim living country ? Why you guys always relegate Bangladesh ? Is it the true spirit of Islam. You utter big talks , bombastic words which general muslim have no interest at all. These are dubious and ambiguous talks. Islam is far away from these high talks .

[@luciddoggo5094]

Bangladesh have never played a vital role in history before the 7th century nor in islam, it was way too far away from the big players like the chinese, the arabs and the turks to matter that much.

[@saliksayyar9793]

Pleaaase! Prof sounds like a Perennialist! Hinduism is not one thing, its basic tenets have evolved over centuries as it came across monotheism. Sufism has indeed deviated from Islam and close to Hindu beliefs. Sorry ! But Hinduism is not a revealed religion, it is an accretion of many belief systems including animism. The Hindu God is part of creation, not so in Islam, there is a clear distinction between Creator and creation. Unfortunately Shabastri believed in Wahdat al wujud. Muhammad Iqbal has written a response to Shabastri’s Gulshan e Raaz. Hindu do worship idols. Yes Muslins do not pray to saints or the Prophet . It is not in the religion. Thee alone do we worship, and Thee alone do we seek help. Nasr should know the Hindus share Greek gods. God says in the Qur’an if He had wanted he would made all in the same faith. Nasr is clearly mistaken, he does not seem to realize that Hinduism is not a challenge to God, rather to Muslims. It is not a number game, as God says he will fill Gehenna with men and Jinn. None such thing as Indian sub continent. If Hindus don’t worship idols, then just break them, stop feeding them . There is more perniciousness in Hinduism related to severe misogyny and caste system as the most unequal society. 😂😂😂

[@akmanwarulkabir8729]

Heavens will be inhabited by mostly naive simple minded peope as per Hadith. These big talks and technicalities and philosophy does not carry much weight towards our journey to eternal world. Mr. Nasr did the Prophet SA used to keep such trimmed beard like you. So you dislike his way , isnt it ?

[@aminarabia8367]

And also doesn't cover his head.

[@Ingeri]

Man, stop being so judgmental and narrow minded. Allow yourself to be open minded and understand the depth of the world around us

[@ajaydalaya2195]

Don't pay attention to external things. Pay attention to heart and intention.