How To Prevent Raptors From Destroying SuperHeavy | Part 1

[@paulmichaelfreedman8334]

This Channel is no doubt the best source of accurate engineering information.

[@MichaelOfRohan]

Hahahaha ohh my goodness this is the most bot comment if I have ever seen one

[@chadjones2308]

It's extremely underrated he should have way more subs than he has

[@peterneilwoodhead4064]

Absolutely ☀️☀️☀️☀️☀️☀️

[@JakeEssex]

@@MichaelOfRohanbot or not, it’s true af!

[@safehavenassets]

Agreed 🎉

[@Merlin1A]

Marcus House, Scott Manley, WAI, and NASA Spaceflight are all wonderful sources, but your channel brings the best technical detail breakdowns. Your work is phenomenal; keep it up!

[@tapio83]

Yea this isn't on same level. whole lot more technical. NSF is documenting, marcus & wai are more reporting, csi is analyzing

[@just_archan]

I would add Scott Manley as best "hotwash" after each flight

[@tapio83]

@@just_archanyea couldnt really put him in bracket though as he's doing lot of things, weekly reporting but also pretty solid analyzing - and being quick about it. without being careless.

[@Merlin1A]

@@just_archan Valid point!

[@WingmanDino]

what I think ❤

[@danoosterhous4933]

Zack, appreciate all you do, keep it up, we love it!

[@kevinhambsch9201]

Zack, very professional!!!! K Hambsch

[@MichaelOfRohan]

He joined two years ago and youre already on a first name basis xD how does the internet even work?

[@MichaelOfRohan]

​@@kevinhambsch9201uhh, we can see your name... you put it as your profile name, remember?

[@We-Do-NOT-Consent-303]

Zack is an AI character! Sitting in a CGI room.

[@con9467]

Everything Zack does is great except for his actual speaking and presentation. I'm surprised how poorly he's been able to improve his ability to speak and present. It's so robotic and he really could use someone else hosting these videos. High schoolers legitimately sound less awkward and robotic.

[@DavJumps]

You kept it professional this time, with no silly characters ... and I for one, think that worked just fine. Great deep dive - much appreciated. Looking forward to part two!

[@tasso504]

Completely agree

[@CSIStarbase]

Characters won’t go away. Just depends on how I’m feeling and whether or not I have time. I like being creative and having fun while explaining these things.

[@_John_P]

I didn't know this channel and went to past videos to see the characters you mentioned. After watching a few, some sketches are quite clever, others are a bit cringe. Getting it right all the time is impossible and certainly will not jollify all audiences. I take you watch youtube at normal speed, and because CSI videos are quite long, you want him to get straight to the point, instead of goofing around. Thus, as a solution, you should take the time to train your brain to watch at 2x or higher speed. Start at 1.25x and 1.5x for all videos, in a few days move to 1.5x and 1.75x until, after a few weeks you can comfortably watch at 2x. It's a natural process that takes time (I currently watch youtube at 2.7x, 3.5x in my first language). That way the sketches go away so fast, they are barely a disruption and the videos become short. As an alternative, just hit the right arrow key a few times during play to skip the characters.

[@DavJumps]

@@_John_P Not my first time on YoutTube (or podcasts, audiobooks, etc.), friend ... but thanks. I appreciate Zack and respect his choices to inform and entertain in the balance he judges best. I wasn't being critical of earlier videos; I was simply offering feedback on this most recent one. And I don't presume to speak for anyone but myself.

[@danielrioux6410]

From an aviation guy's perspective here, I love the detailed breakdown. I've worked in manufacturing, engineering, planning and production and I can appreciate the details you've put into this video. Finally I get to see what's going on!

[@billhart9832]

Zack, missed your unique in-depth coverage and intimate detail that only an engineer can bring. You Rock!

[@knowledgeisgood9645]

Very well done, Zack! Congrats on yet another first class deep dive.

[@con9467]

This channel would take off if he would be willing to hire a professional presenter. CSI is so good at showing and uncovering everything about Starship, the base, and the booster. But as long as Zack continues to be the "presenter", these videos will continue to sound unnaturally awkward and poorly narrated/presented. He sounds like an AI narrating an article on a news website.

[@tylerdurden4006]

First class?...someone made him rethink america though...🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@JacquesZahar]

@@con9467 humans are humans.

[@TexanMiror2]

Incredible analysis. I was wondering why this episode was so short, when I ended up seeing I had just watched a 51 minute long video lol Your videos have become an absolutely irreplaceable part of understanding what really happens at Starbase - nobody else covers this like you do. Can't wait for the next one!

[@StingerNSW]

Thanks Zac for the Deep Dive and everyone who contributed to the episode 👍 Bring on Part 2 🚀

[@con9467]

10/10 for the information. 0/10 for Zack's ability to speak without sounding like a middle school student reading a script. His delivery is so awkward and robotic. It's clear that he wants to be the "voice" of this channel despite the fact that he has not improved his presentation skills after years of videos.

[@jeromeball859]

@@con9467 My impression has been quite the opposite - He delivers the narrative with a crisp and precise diction that is essential in following complex material, and he should not change it. This is engineering, not Shakespeare. Compare Zack's delivery with other space YT'ers - who I like and follow - such as WAI and Marcus House and even occasionally Scott Manley. Their tone and cadence seems tailored to match that of generic YT presenters who use their presentation skills to set a happy and energized mood as they discuss anything from cooking to makeup to cars. I don't object to this, but it's better suited to lightweight news and straightforward topics. I listen to Zack to understand difficult material, and fluff presentation doesn't help in that. I'll take direct clarity any day.

[@kerbal8216]

Absolutely love these deep dives! Thank you so much for all the hard work needed to complete these 😄

[@NickedBlade]

THIS WHOLE STAR SHIP PROGRAM IS EXCITING!!! TOO THE FUTURE!!!!

[@jaeluatl]

Can’t wait, your deep dive overviews are the best.💪🏽

[@joesmitg5589]

This content doesn't happen I know with out all the people with the cameras, but this really is the best space content out there.

[@MichaelOfRohan]

Compared to what exactly? Everything is on twitter. Youre dillusional if you think this guys finger is on anything other than your girlfriend xD

[@JusticePreyHDM]

​@@MichaelOfRohanthe content is presented in the best way possible. What do you mean?

[@SyntheticSpy]

@@MichaelOfRohanthese are incredibly well constructed and informative videos

[@schrodingerscat1863]

One thing I really like about this channel is the way you give all the sources of footage a call out at the end of each video, surprisingly few do this instead just listing it in the video description. Once again a very thorough analysis of what turned out to be a huge improvement over ITF-1. The amount of time required to put these presentations together is huge and it's much appreciated.

[@chtrouvpadnom]

Just an AMAZING video. I don't regret for one moment having to stay up until 3:00am to see the premiere (hello from France !). Can't wait for the second part and will happily watch this one again to wrap my head around all the info that are detailed here. What an incredible job you've done once again. Thanks !

[@mikeehrmantraut2607]

My guilt grows with every episode, that i havent made a donation to you yet. It gets better and better! The details, what you focus on, the cgi, the pictures you choose, the cool music... Its really premium content and despite i usually i never donate for content, i will do soon for you. This is simply the coolest, most understandable starship channel of all. The amount of work you put in here is insane.

[@djredrover]

This is just incredible detective work mate! You don't miss, ever.

[@linyenchin6773]

It's probably because he is in the top 0.1% of us black folk, that's where all our genius is(same as with all other peoples but ours are extra scarce and face even more cruelty frok the not so bright majority of us).

[@refurbansuburban]

My materials science professor used to say "The difference between detonation and deflagration? In deflagrations you get big pieces and in detonations you get little pieces" Deflagrations feature a traveling flame front slowly building up pressure, and you get big pieces as seams give way. Detonations are the simultaneous explosion of all reaction materials, so it blows apart the vessel into little pieces. Thanks, Stage Zero Zack, for a great job documenting the little details that make your productions unique. Can't wait for Part 2!

[@jtjames79]

I thought deflagration was subsonic and detonation was supersonic.

[@refurbansuburban]

@@jtjames79 You are correct, the associated shock wave of a detonation is not kind to containment vessels.

[@jtjames79]

@@refurbansuburban Woohoo! I love being correct. It's the best kind of correct.

[@charleslord2433]

Great analysis of the improvements! Can't wait for part 2 (and IFT3)

[@aaronmalsch5143]

Thanks! I greatly appreciate the in-depth analysis and 3D animations

[@CSIStarbase]

Thank you!

[@AlienVibesss]

It sucks that I had to leave last night while waiting for the premiere, but I finally got to watch it. This was an amazing episode, Zach! I always leave the video with more knowledge than I came to it with. Thank you so much for these deep dives, and giving the community such an insane level of information. We appreciate you more than you'll ever know.

[@togia111]

CSI Starbase, you rule! As an engineer not in the space industry, but very interested in Starship. This is by far the best content. Thank you and please don't stop doing what you're doing.

[@donjones4719]

It's telling that several engineers have complimented Zack, it shows his level of expertise is deep in his deep dives, it's not at all the kind of veneer that some creators get away with, with unsophisticated audiences.

[@jeffk1482]

Always thorough, yet an enjoyable deep-dive. Truly some of the best out there.

[@jgrenwod]

Long wait between episodes but well worth it.

[@georgejenkins8063]

As always, Zack we so appreciate your Knowledge, Efforts and Your Verve !!

[@josephlangdon4308]

I've been watching all the "big" channels for Spacex stuff and today this channel showed up in my feed...clicked and glad I did...for some reason the way they present the info,the host,editing, etc.really works for me to follow and understand. Thanks for the hard work and so glad I found y'alls channel.

[@MarlinMay]

I’ve been eagerly awaiting your in-depth analysis more than anyone else’s. Thank you!

[@flying_shawn]

THANK YOU for not caving to the pressure to rush the release of this (or any other) episode!! Your content is absolutely incredible and well worth the time needed to maintain this level of accuracy and quality!

[@juanmartinezrossi]

I just discovered this channel. I leave the video at minute 10 because I have to go but I'll definetely continuo to watch later. The thing I love the most is that back in the time I was up to date with everything happening in SpaceX, but after some years with my mind in another things I loose track of progress. And here, contrary to some other channels that cover SpaceX, you don't assume that we are up to date and you explain much more. Thanks a lot! I've suscribed!

[@Kneedragon1962]

Outstanding work. Thank you Zack. It's so nice to hear all this being talked about by someone who actually knows what he's talking about.

[@JacquesZahar]

Kudos to Zach, who painstakingly located all the glitches frame by frame in the available footage. Your attention to details is second to none. Very nice and detailed 3D renderings from your team too. Space is hard, and now we know why

[@philakid6233]

Zack another have to watch, cant wait for Part Two. You and your team always produce the best updates on Starship development. Thanks for all you do.

[@CSIStarbase]

Thanks Bob! Much appreciated!

[@davidboyle1902]

Phenomenal work. And yes, I learn something new with every one of your episodes. Looking forward to episode 2.

[@m1shuC]

The information at 14.50 blew my mind! Absolutely incredible the complexity of Stage 0 and it's symbiosis with the Booster! What a marvelous piece of engineering!

[@jddurst533]

Thank you Zack! I am always excited to see a new video from you, they are not frequent, but the quality is worth the wait! Godspeed!

[@eamonia]

There's stealing content to get views, and then there's utilizing a massive library of available images and videos to produce an amazing, in depth production that recognizes and gives ample credit to those who initially captured or created it. You guys, are an exceptional example of the latter. Brilliant production, gang. Bravo.

[@CSIStarbase]

Thank you!

[@ironspider9280]

Glad to have you back Zack. Great content as always 👏🏽

[@michaelhall8587]

Love the analysis videos... can't wait for the premiere Zack :D

[@wchart30024]

By the way Zack you do a great job detailing the technical aspects of Starship, far more than others that attempt to. I'm a retired Commercial Pilot and appreciate the education required to make your videos

[@pyfferoenc]

Your effort is awesome!! Thanks to everyone who contributed!!

[@xx_peace_xx5300]

Thank you so much Zack I really learned so much and I'm so excited for Part 2

[@m1shuC]

Disgusting how the media dismissed the huge amount of work and innovation by thousands and thousands of people in calling ITF2 a failure... Absolutely disgusting and pathetic, but nothing new... Great video and great details, Zack! Thank you! 🚀

[@erik1432]

One of the best analysis videos I have seen to the IFT2. Good work, from an engineering colleague!

[@buddhaNature-zu2ie]

I can only add to what has already been said, but this analysis is next level. A deeply satisfying dive into the engineering of this magnificent vessel.

[@Bugman563]

Incredible how in-depth you guys know about so many details of starship. I always ask myself how much more accurate all of these infos could be if there were more communication between you guys and spacex. Though I understand that it's not really possible... A bit unfortunate but SO SO Great to see what you come up with even without it.

[@ross077]

Simply outstanding forensics on the Superheavy Booster engine shielding and fire suppression systems. Great work Zack, looking forward to Part 2.

[@dannyunixanalyst9018]

This is great work. No-one else is doing deep dive to this level of quality afaik. The production values are beatiful. I looove that you got to correct Scott, good for you (no offence Scott, love you too). I'll offer a couple of comments because I sincerely want you to succeed and maybe no-one else is offering this kind of feedback (can't be bothered to read all the comments)... i) Slow down a touch. I'm a native english speaker but I have to listen very carefully to catch all of what you're saying, and I want to hear every word. For example the pace changed at 5:19 and was immediately easier to follow and I felt myself relax. And it was obvious hat you were more relaxed. ii) I think you need to smile or something, whatever makes it look like you're relaxed and actually enjoying what you're doing, which I'm sure you must be. It all just feels a little too somber, like you're reporting bad news rather than enthusiastcally delving into the details of something exciting that we all love. I'm not suggesting you go all over the top, not at all, but just look like you're enjoying it. Think Marcus House and how pleased he looks to be bringing us the good news. I hope your channel continues to grow and you find great rewards for your superb efforts x

[@aldunlop4622]

Agreed, he’s really gone to a lot of effort on the technical analysis is brilliant. Can’t believe I never found this channel before. He deserves a lot more subs.

[@donjones4719]

43:00 So glad you explained this. It was odd to see smoke like that - and it wasn't smoke! Just another vapor.

[@neotaylor9994]

best research in starship than any other channel!!! very impressed!!!!

[@Bezerker1181]

Great job on piecing this together and making it easy to follow. Thank you!

[@petercozzaglio6070]

Your graphics are really amazing. Glad you’re back Zack. I have really missed your deep dives.

[@olsonspeed]

Thanks again for your high quality, in depth analysis of the recent developments of the Starship.

[@2200chuck]

What an incredible episode. So much verified detail. So clearly explained. I love the work you and your team does. I truely love and appreciate it.

[@schlenbea]

Incredible! I learned so many new things from this episode and one of my lingering questions was answered: "what are all those little holes at the bottom of the booster now?!" Thanks Zack! Keep up the pristine work. I look forward to every minute of content you produce! 🥂

[@B0M0A0K]

Stunning work again Zack, to be honest I was beginning to get worried that we had not heard from you in a while. These deep dives are unmatched on YT.

[@ianbacon9532]

Zak, that was a brilliant analysis of starship, second flight, thank you so much. It was truly interesting and showed a huge amount of time and effort to investigate it in such depth and it made it so clear and simple to understand. Thank you again

[@troycress6603]

Absolutely awesome breakdown I look forward to part 2 of your breakdown. Thank you so much for all of your efforts

[@jrdaparker]

Wow Zack, this was probably your best video so far! Awesome job! The the people who did the 3d renderings really did a great job.

[@jcarlile8279]

Zach I love these deep dive engineering videos. Keep up the great work.

[@bratzenvater]

I'm German and like your calm, matter-of-fact language, which can be easily understood by non-natives like me. And it is very detailed and informative. Well done 😊

[@jeffc6832]

We appreciate you Zack, great work by you and everyone else involved!

[@jk-video2716]

Brilliant as usual. Kudos to you Zack and all who contributed.

[@chrismartin2001AD]

Excellent as always. Best Starship coverage by some distance

[@0rangeG]

You deserve way more attention. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS. You and your team rock.

[@officialwildcardadventures]

Dude your videos are an amazing breakdown ! Well done once again!

[@Spacehawksuk]

Enjoy this vid Zack, looking forward to the next one. I learn a lot with your in-depth but easy to follow explanations

[@OliverTheSpaceNerd]

Love the videos Zack!!

[@jasonv3425]

Thank you for this detailed analysis of the starship launch. I can’t believe it took me so long to find this high quality channel. Keep it up!

[@RobinHood-lz2wj]

Another outstanding job, Zack.

[@linyenchin6773]

Really is, takes much of the shame away from being black.

[@neevgabay]

Amazing video! Love the details and animation. Great work CSI team!

[@adastraglobal]

As always - outstanding analysis, thank you!

[@bxl_lad9952]

Really informative, learned so much more than watching other similar channels. Great work!

[@enzycal]

Another awsome video, very much worth the wait!

[@Reyajh]

Beautiful work!!! Hands down unmatched coverage!!! We do love it!!!

[@connecticutaggie]

Great analysis! Thanks! I also noticed the engine asymmetry during the startup phase. My conclusion was that it probably was actually symmetric and this was a display/telemetry anomaly caused by under sampling (compared to the engine control sequencing clock).

[@rstomahawkty]

Incredible to see how many views you have in only a few hours, a huge increase from your previous videos. Not only do the comments show that everyone shares the same sentiment that you produce the best content about the Starship program, but ettin the nod of approval from Elon Musk himself pretty much confirms it as well. You totally deserve it, and I look forward to seeing your channel continue to grow. For the viewers, make sure you are subscribed so we can do our part to help grow the channel!

[@mobiuscoreindustries]

Ultimately this is what utterly puzzles outside observers of the situation and the community as a whole. Thanks to the open development and the absolutely amazing efforts of the community analysts and content creators, we have a very significant chunk of regular folks with knowledge far outpacing the reporting capabilities of the average media and thus the average person. This is very much a unique case for the industry as the best we can usually do is "best guesses" which also often implies just believing companies and politicians at their word, which is far from ideal.

[@nerdwatcher4273]

THANK YOU SOOO MUCH ZAC for another amazing and educational video!!!

[@johnbrant2454]

Another detailed examination of what happened in both flights and what changes have been made. Fantastic job! Thank you.

[@deepwinter77]

I was waiting for this video, so so thorough and fascinating. Thanks. I can only imagine the amount of work that goes into this level of detail, let alone the production and editing of the video. Thanks again Much appreciated 👍🏻

[@Astronomy_Live]

Thanks for the shout out, great analysis as always!

[@CSIStarbase]

Great job on capturing that footage!

[@Goldengirl48]

I am a first time visitor to your channel. I love all well presented information about Starship, SpaceX and other space related news. I am so excited about your excellent coverage of these SpaceX launches. Many other channels show the glossy highlight and do not give reasons for why thing happened. Your explanations show that you and your team do an incredible amount of research beyond just the surface information available. Thank you for explaining all of these thing and adding them to my growing need to know more.

[@dsnmttr]

Glad to see you are back. Awesome quality content as always ! 🎉

[@tonyduncan9852]

Deep dive worth the wait. 😎

[@robertobruselas3952]

Superheavy's IFT1 & IFT2 are partially covered in excellent video content. You rock. Definitely true. You are among the thousands Zack! I'm looking forward to the next deep dive. Greetings from Europe. SpaceX enthusiast.

[@kersebleptes1317]

Listening to your precise and knowledgeable commentaries is a great pleasure! Many humble thanks. I'm also able to pretend that I too have a clear and capable mind, which is lots of fun.

[@richiehart7858]

Your product is exceptional Zack. Thank you for bringing this high quality information and analysis to our attention.

[@cowboynidaho]

Another great episode I enjoy how detailed you get

[@johnmulgannon]

Thank you, Zack, I always learn more with every video of yours I watch.

[@traqnhristov960]

I love these deep dives. Do we have any information or guesses about the event that we saw around 7minutes into the flight? Thank you to all of the team for all the hard work, can't wait for part 2.

[@EVGizmo]

The level of detail on the Booster 7 test campaign is the context we never knew we needed. Thanks to Zack and the CSI team!

[@rollio7204]

What can I say? A CSI starbase video drops, I have to watch it

[@MrJumbie]

This analysis was incredible! The detail to which everything was broken down and the specific changes pointed out were far more in-depth than I expected were possible without access to the actual telemetry data from the launch. SpaceX needs to hire you and your team to lead their launch and incident investigation group. Amazing job! 😁👍

[@GerardHammond]

Wonderful work Zack. 👍 well done.

[@mp6756]

As always, an outstanding job from CSI and contributing partners. Thanks

[@GarryCollins-ec8yo]

I was just wondering today when you will release your next video.

[@bryanillenberg]

Same!

[@southernbreeze3278]

whoa, a hot stage cliff-hanger. well done

[@jackeppington6488]

Excellent work, as usual. Thanks, Zack!

[@linuxuberuser]

SuperHeavy rockets perform well when on/under fire - Amazing. This channel is an A+ source for engineering information

[@maxcolvin9209]

Awesome show. Keep up the great work! It’s phenomal the changes they are making so fast.

[@thomvolontaire]

All due respect to others space KZbinrs but they can't even try to be at your level. Only 70k followers ? You are underated. This is far better than made on the other channels.