Watch Raghav Chadha's Bold Speech on Judges' Post-Retirement Roles | Dhankhar's Reaction Goes Viral

[@sivaramr3362]

Raghav Chadha's ability to articulate important issues in Parliament is of high standards.

[@Allwelfare]

Even otherwise it's a very reasonable appeal because the intent of retirement is to help people to get some rest for working so long. It may have other reasons but historically it's reward for service where they get paid even when they are not working. So, 2 year respite is good to honour the idea of retirement even though it may have other reasons.

[@Paramjeetsingh-gj2ut]

Obviously coz he's a well educated character account not any regular guy

[@ղօղվօմ-ծ5օ]

No doubt on it

[@manojbhatt5159]

Still he has lack of knowledge. Argument ka answer dhang se suna ho to.

[@biswasdeblina]

He is the same person who forged MPs' signatures in Parliament 😂 AAP's PR is at its peak, glorifying fraudsters as articulate individuals, especially with the Delhi elections just around the corner.

[@sanjibchakraborti2908]

1000 percent right. Law is to be made to refrain from politics for retired judges. Judge is trying to satisfy present govt. for future assignment. it is clear to all.

[@Albatrosshanger]

Exactly,this should be stopped

[@devbuilddeploy]

It's a democracy, no one can stop anyone from doing anything unless its against 📖

[@josevenanciofernandes7328]

This speaker is only smiling

[@CricketWalaGame]

​@@devbuilddeploy Article 50

[@Ankittri_--_--__--__--]

I don't think so.......what are your views on electoral bond judgement.....😊

[@Bauaji_smile]

We need more young, well educated, articulate MPs like Raghav Chaddha in LS & RS !

[@RaviKiran-lx2kw]

for that we have first discuss politicians retirement

[@Bauaji_smile]

@ True !

[@panchalharish]

The old corrupt guard will not allow that. Look at majority of the most of BJP MPs. Lot of them are not highly educated or articulate,they have no mannerisms, no personality, awful dress sense and oratorically extremely poor. India the country that has so many intellectual young people have to put up with these sort of thieving politicians is beyond belief

[@SK-hf5nh]

Specifically in LS cuz it basically holds more power

[@IamRealistMan]

Cooling period is not mentioned in the Constitution of India. And the country is run on the basis of the Constitution. Simple logic but some people don’t understand it.

[@gaurangahazarika2750]

Ranjan Gogoi got his reward immediately after his post retirement😢😢

[@zaqs1970]

and he is hardly attending RS........but getting all perks

[@atique2459]

Because he gave Ram Mandir judgment

[@VedantSrikar]

​@@atique2459 wow Atique.

[@chilmarldke2273]

Unke papa b governor the beta

[@sipunrout8631]

For your information he is not elected but nominated MP😊

[@MANTOINDIA]

1. Cooling of period must be 5 years so that same govt may or may not be there. 2. Greed has no limit. Increasing judge's pension may not be suffice. They may still desire more. Compare with average income of ordinary Indian 3. Cooling period of 5 years Why only for judges why not for all who any time drawn salary from govt taxes.

[@Oceansta]

Point # 1 🔥👏👏👏

[@sreenathbv5586]

Well said

[@Hindu.No.88]

5 sal me toh marr jayega insan😂

[@souviksikdar1864]

5 years is a lot of time dude. Not everyone gets a good pension. Often they don't receive good enough jobs after retirement. 2 years is a good time period.

[@Oceansta]

@souviksikdar1864 that can look for private jobs for 5 yrs. It's more important to safeguard the judicial integrity of the country that provide for cushy retirement plan of a handful of judges

[@adityasheet890]

Yes this is very much required.... not only for judges but IAS and IPS officers also

[@memeupadates3579]

Yaaa exactly .

[@tnoronha]

Law minister is an IAS turned Rajya Sabha MP 😝

[@UttrakhandPahadiBoY1]

True

[@Bhaibhai-gs9ni]

Upsc main fail hue ho na😂😂😂

[@yahyabaghpati]

Very valid point Mr. Raghav. Introduction of cooling-off period will help in avoiding people being compromised for immediate gains. Please keep raising such issues.

[@officeofsatish]

We should finds other ways to cater this issue of Conflict of interest because two years of cooling period at that age can be dangerous waste of merit and experience for the country.

[@yahyabaghpati]

@ I agree with you. In that case the role of such people after retirement should be defined in transparent manner and not left at discretion of ruling dispensation. Because all retired talented people are not given positions but only selected few and that raises the question.

[@MuthuAnguswamy]

Fantastic point. Very relevant to the present Situation in the Country.

[@khushisankhla4316]

My mother who never watched these debates is now start watching this guy. The core issues raised by him in simple language make people to understand problems of the nation. Forward looking more young mps like him

[@tarangvijay9795]

This is true. Conflicts of interest happen, and humans are bound to be fascinated by executive positions and other high positions in the government. The concept Raghav ji talked about can be beneficial for an unbiased judiciary and independent functioning of the judges.

[@mukeshkhod9641]

at 60 you get 2 yEAR COOLING PERIODS? BHaI JINKO rishwat leni h wo to lega hii

[@pulkitkanodia3976]

Perfectly normal question regarding cooling off period. Netaji ka reply: ye term ka izad inhone kiya hai MODIJI ki aalochna karne ke liye😂😂

[@zaqs1970]

batao issi RS me Ranjan gogoi baithe huye hai jo jeeta jagta saboot hai iss baat ka.....phir bhi yeh aise statement dete hai

[@manojbhatt5159]

Jin posts k liye retired judges ki hi requirement unme kya tumhare Abba ko laga den tumhare cooling period k RR tak.

[@zaqs1970]

@@manojbhatt5159 2 saal ka cooling period retirement ke baad....jo already judges hai woh toh kaam karege hee....

[@manojbhatt5159]

@@zaqs1970 O bhai...m bhi wahi keh raha hun. Judges retire hone k baad kuch posts k liye eligible hote h. Un posts pe sirf ek retired judge hi appoint ho sakta h. To kya wo post tab tak Khali rahengi. Kyuki saare judge to us post pe lagenge nahi, jo best hoga wo lagega. Agar ek general law banega cooling period ka to fr kaabil log us post k liye milenge nahi. Aur aise thodi h k saare retired judges retirement k baad kaam hi karna chahte h, kuch nahi karte. Waise mujhe ye explaine karne ki jarurat nahi thi video m saaf saaf ye puri baat huyi h. Kon si posts hoti h wo bhi dono netao ne bola h, kin kanoon k andar judges appoint hote h Constitution k according wo bhi bata diya gaya h. Acche se suna karo

[@upsingh3154]

The sad part was being elected to have honor and sit in such place and they don't have ability to listen the very valid question. Keep interrupting Mr Raghav and not letting him to raise his concern. highest of "Sarvgyata" and not answering the valid ask that's pollute mind Neta always do.

[@abd9547]

Response was the real political and unpadh per se

[@Rehan-dm7mp]

Yes

[@Naveen91able]

If the minister doesn't even have the intellectual capability to understand what cooling period means, then it's high time people of his constituency think what kind of MP have they sent to the parliament

[@aayushmangarg2744]

😂 literally we r doomed man , he is heading ministry with such low awareness about basic terms

[@Gaurav-wo7it]

Aur bhai ye mantri IAS officer reh chuka hai😂😂

[@vikramdanbarath9770]

Haa sc category se ajj se 30 sal pahale jab koi sc st ke log even genral people me education less thi. Yaha usane ekdum galat answer diye h. Bat khatam​@@Gaurav-wo7it

[@Naveen91able]

@@Gaurav-wo7it arey bhai bhai😷🤣

[@BhupinderSingh-i2n3y]

​@@vikramdanbarath9770jab 4 fail ko jawab degi ho aise anpad he mantri banenge

[@sanjibchakraborti2908]

Dhankar is taking same advantage.

[@itchyhelmet4032]

Like what advantage ?

[@sunil...215]

Governor,VP, President,CAG, retd judges shouldn't be further appointed for constitutional post unless until emergency situation. Dhankar like VP seems like to be biased towards current government

[@MrAntonysimon]

Ace hypocrit dhankar.

[@ritwajitdas4275]

​@@itchyhelmet4032 rhetoric question😅

[@SanyamSinghSolanki]

@@sunil...215 i don't think so, dhankar is a neutral person, may be everyone not agree on this.

[@ASPIRANT_911]

2 years is less, It should be atleast 5 years.

[@samridhup]

minister shows arrogance and doesn't answer but goes for attack

[@krishnakumar21aug93]

A answerless person will shout 😂

[@Oceansta]

Are you referring to Dhankar?

[@manojbhatt5159]

Kya answer nahi kiya...already aisi posts h jinme sirf retired judges ko niyukt kiya ja sakta h. Un posts pe kya tumhare pitaji ko baitha den cooling period poora hone tak.

[@James-ot7uh]

​@@manojbhatt5159please mention which posts specifically?

[@samridhup]

Yes, the retired judge criterion could be reconsidered or removed. The response could have been more thoughtful or solution-oriented instead of dismissive like yours! maa k bete

[@mellowleas6759]

Sawal kuch aur thi, jawab kuch aur diya gya😂, actually minister ke pas kuch nhi hai batane ka, jis state se yeh minister aate hain, uska chunne ka tarika thik nhi hai

[@abdulkhaderzubair912]

He is absolutely right educated MP

[@AtifMansoor-q8j]

The worst judge destroyed the career of 2 to 3 lakh neet aspirants When alakh sir said we lost we lost we the students of india lost

[@UrbanMonk-pd9sv]

Go to Pakistan, Bangladesh & write exam there 👍🏼

[@lazylitan]

Kyun ye desh tera baaap ka hai ? ​@@UrbanMonk-pd9sv

[@yongue1991]

Tu bhi chala Jaa saath me Pakistan. Tereko bht padi h vaha ki

[@utkarshsingh1227]

@@UrbanMonk-pd9sv what the fu$$

[@the_arnavz3281]

and yet he is praised

[@youpm12]

I agree to this and this should include IAS and IPS as well.

[@mathewsabraham7556]

Pre-retirement judgements paves way for post retirement positions either in political offices or in other areas".Absolutely right. Kudos Raghavji

[@harsh.agrawal]

1. Very pertinent question by Hon MP. 2. Hon VP raised a very good point of Conflict of Interest in US. 3. Whataboutery by Hon Minister and a 2 pence response. Obliteration to the legacy of Sh Arun Jaitley.

[@MohammedJaweed-jw3xv]

Raghav is really speaking the truth. Judges should always follow trueism.

[@AyushRai-vd9wx]

He ignored the question and i have no idea what speaker sir didnt understand with cooling period..he simply wanted to prevent future political incentive influencing present decision.

[@debrajghosh02]

Yes ...if he couldn't understand after how briefly mr chadda explaind him ... then I don't think he is able to hold the position!!!

[@tayunarang]

Wonderful observation & suggestion admist growing controversy regarding lack of transparency in appointment of judge.

[@mirtufail1]

Justice chandrchood proved his desire to get a post retirement benefit from his bosses...well played...bur shame on him ..

[@NikhilDeshmukh-bn1jt]

Right Raghav Chadda..... Educated person of Parliament...

[@dhulipalavenkateswararao7932]

100% correct.. Rsnjan gogoyi example

[@surchandrach8276]

Very good suggestion.

[@sskexocet333]

Good suggestions by chaddaji. post retirement political and executive posts for retired judges has become a contentious issue and au subject of debate on public domains. My late friend a voracious reader, and8 a wise guy to the boot used to say the courts are for the governed and not the governors and😮 they should view them as public enemy no 1. Unfortunately the roles of judges and their penchant for pleasing the the politicians has blurred their constitutional roles. The aam adami is now wondering where he will get justice....

[@Thimanshu_111]

Well said Raghav Chadha

[@mr.dhillon1999]

More than Judges, Army Generals/Admirals have even more conflict of interest pre retirement. Look at their pro-government policies prior retirement.

[@sitarammeena2038]

मंत्री ने राघव चड्ढा के एक भी सवाल का जवाब नहीं दिया । बिलकुल जायज सवाल है । जनता सब देख रही है मंत्री जी ।

[@rbh3100]

Good one Raghav ji . This is a very good idea.

[@swatib7488]

Wow .he is actually raising very good points

[@rajeevhere]

Bilkul sahi kha raghav ji ne

[@AdvocateJJSIR]

Now these guys are saying cooling off period is not mentioned in constitution! Then even basic structure is not mentioned in the constitution! So cooling off period is must here.

[@SauravKumar-rq9od]

Excellent proposal..and the same should be for all higher posts of judicial and executives (bureaucrats IAS IPS ) ..the same should be strictly implemented

[@harshagrawal1056]

The same should also be applicable to civil servants

[@vivektripathi3666]

Bilkul saty Hai ❤

[@rambhattacharjee1850]

Totally agree

[@arunc8181]

BJP to judges : Aise judgement dijiye iss iss cases mein, u will be hired to best position after retirement!! Graduate, post graduate , phd holders to government : ye loksabha canteen mein supplier, cook ka naukri ke liye bharti kab ho rha !!!

[@sam2303]

Too good man👍👍👍 bhai hitting six on six...Raghav bhai Shaadi ka asar hai kya😅😅😅

[@Saif-ur2mk]

What is people's opinion on judicial system during ex CJI chandrachud tenure ?

[@tttreksandtalks9194]

he was a puppet

[@ekulda]

Raghav is absolutely right.

[@rameshchaubey1336]

He is the right man in wrong political party. If he joins BJP then he has great opportunity to rise as a leader.

[@sabirhossainmondal9512]

100% right...

[@J_indian]

Very well said by Raghav Chadda ji. It is imperative that Judges must have a cooling off period before they are allowed to take up any post be it in politics or anywhere else. It must be made mandatory in the best interest of the country.

[@srivatsajoshi]

Pension of CJI is already 17LPA. No need of increasing it and increasing the burden on tax payers. Keeping a cooling off period is must.

[@UnknownTribe-z3e]

Not happy with the minister's argument.

[@abduza38501]

Not 2 years atleast 5 years cooling off ...

[@SAYED_01234]

Well said...

[@biswasrout7759]

Govt be like -judiciary to humare under he hi nehi😂😂😂.

[@Sonukumarroy-ind]

Yes we need to move the conversation between each other in parliament in any house at very upper layer regarless of political thing .keep moveing

[@jagadishtalukdar844]

He has literally asked a very good question. Kudos to Ragavh chadda ji.

[@olive2695]

Raghav is Indeed an intellect

[@vladimirputin5617]

He is the man who ask after thorough research We need more such well educated mp

[@bencys2904]

His message resonates and hits hard He was the one who said.... India taxes like UK but gives services like SOMALIA 😅

[@Homie-world]

Why do judges need to take up another governmental job after retirement, and Indian Parliament should stop taking the example of the United States parliamentary debate, because United States democracy isn't flawless either.

[@RaghibNaushadAdv]

It is sad to see the reply given by the Hon’ble Law Minister. He didn’t answer the question put forward by a young MP. MP asked question about the appointment of Judges at Executive Posts and Political Posts. But the Minister answered like a 1st year law student by making arguments on Tribunals, etc. He doesn’t even know that Tribunals are bodies independent from the executive. Also Article 50 talks about separation of Executive and Judiciary. Hence, the argument put by young MP is valid. On the topic of cooling-off period, he picked up the morsel given by VP and said that it is not mentioned in Constitution. But there are N number of things Not mentioned in constitution but still we adopt it within the authorities of Constitution such as : Judicial Review not specifically mentioned in Constitution but it’s inferred from Article 13. My argument is “cooling off” period can be associated with the independence of judiciary which is an integral part of Basic Structure of Constitution but the Minister didn’t answer satisfactorily. With all due respect I would say that it happens when you give the posts like of a law minister to undeserving.

[@aslamshah2786.]

There are restrictions for the retired employees for accepting any employment before two years. Shri Raghav Chadha has a valid point and should be adopted by the government.

[@krishnendupoddar8248]

Excellent proposal liked by common people of India ❤

[@krishansethi3350]

सहमत। यही कारण है कि नीट पेपर लीक साबित हुआ लेकिन सुप्रीम कोर्ट के जज को सेवानिवृत्ति के बाद लाभ देने के कारण शिक्षा मंत्री के पक्ष में फैसला दिया गया

[@bowarrowpictures]

very good 100% right

[@ATHIRIPUTHIRI2621]

Arun Jaitleyji only proposed this. He was an intellectual.

[@kishordeshpande7647]

Cooling period means anniling process Mr Raghav Chaddas bold speech will definitely focus on the judicial state.Thanks

[@aryansingh-4268]

Minister should give accurate ans to the legitimate question rather than attacking on the Opposition.....learn from Mr S jai shankar

[@RSofMi7]

For the first time I saw the VP asking the minister a sharp question.. Define cooling period😅 Very smart question from the VP

[@sanjayvichare8716]

Very good.

[@vasuv59]

Cooling off period is there for Govt. employees (class 1 and 2). It is 2 years. This minister does not know the laws

[@delmanpronto9374]

they are hoping the average indian is not going to watch this video, or bother listening to the debates.

[@mdminsaralam890]

Absolutely good suggestion

[@ashwin9823]

Great leaders like him are needed for our country

[@mahindersingh4596]

Mr channel is a outstanding person .

[@SayyadFaijunnisa]

Good question..

[@mohdjishan9176]

Minister is playing ringa ringa roses with questions😂😂. He asked for the simple thing about judiciary's credibility and he's saying that he's defaming PM 😂😂😂😂

[@ATHIRIPUTHIRI2621]

Raghavs Hindi is so musical..

[@d..sharma]

Vp dhankar said correctly About hidayat-ulla

[@rishibansal3918]

ek logical question aur suggestion ka bhadda and bewakoofi vaala jawaab... raghav chadda ka question bilkul sahi tha

[@theaspirant6839]

Waw,execellent ❤❤

[@mohitpathakofficial]

Cooling off period means.... Modi ji ki aalochna.😂😂..sach me chun chun kar aate he sansad me...

[@charanjitsingh5951]

Very right Sir

[@BiswajitBasak]

Actually it's a good and important issue

[@azeemsyed1025]

Appreciated

[@namanbansal4033]

Good question asked to avoid corruption and misuse of power judiciary should indulge into politics after retirement as it affects the pre retirement judgement process

[@vishaalbhatnagar3924]

Important point raised by MP Raghav Chaddha.

[@kamilansari527]

He is Absolutely right ! MPs like him needed in this country

[@jayasankarshivakumar471]

Good points by Raghav

[@KaleemKhan-sw8ln]

Chadha sahib you are off different level

[@AshishPandey-by9gi]

1000% correct

[@hagehalley3155]

Very good 💯 raghav ❤

[@roysreemant]

Education is the key. The law Minister spoke exactly like our PM. Everything else other than what is required to be spoken !!!

[@AltafAnsari-uq3md]

Accha suggestion hai.

[@Technoblis]

Kon hai ye log, kaha se aate hai. He is answering something else. No wonder people choose these leaders

[@princedhaliwal4478]

Bilkul sahi bol rahe hai

[@manasmishra5026]

Late Justice Hon'bke Hidaytulla was an exception. And exceptions can't be made as a general rule. The issue raised by Raghav Chaddha is relevant in present perspective as well as for future.

[@hemantchaudhary6970]

Excellent👍

[@vn54181]

Raises Serious questions

[@vaibhavkumar3463]

Nonsense answer to serious Questions👍

[@sandeepkumarray53]

Right100%

[@ajaymane482]

Kudos to you