华晨宇 Hua Chen Yu - 与火星的孩子对话 CONVERSATIONS WITH ET ｜｜ 3 MUSKETEERS REACTION 三剑客

[@janicewang4283]

很荣幸下面合唱的火星人中有我一个。现场好多姐妹都是哭着离场的。

[@Dylan-qt1ro]

这是一首，不论是不是黑煤球都会引起共鸣的一首歌

[@DulcisAbsentia]

I’m always moved by tears by this song and the family-like relationship between HuaHua and us ETs ❤

[@oliviali2773]

這是罕有最真情實意的藝人與歌迷間互動，超越了一般認知的常規模式，已不能單純以偶像和粉絲關係作界定，華晨宇是我見過最獨特的人，正如他自己說過這年代很多人都在追求獨特，但當最獨特的出現面前，人們卻卻往往選擇拒絕接受，他堅持自我，逆著潮流努力奮鬥這些年，終究讓很多人看到他的優秀與美好，建立了龐大的火星王國，版圖還日益擴張，一切得來不易，期間的辛酸不足為外人道，這首歌道盡了他內心的掙扎衝擊以及火星人的理解愛護，花火情絕對是娛樂圈中最特殊的存在。

[@tanlaylian5260]

+1💕

[@dorisma4630]

+1💕💖

[@李錦玲-n1q]

+1

[@c.k.helenchui1054]

花花善良又专业,做人低調！ 絕不像某些人強扣於他、話他封神

[@choilin2527]

華晨宇👍👍👍👍👍

[@BAWL2000]

這版本比MV 感動10萬倍。哭死我了

[@浪花-z2h]

每聽一次 哭一次 特別是去年因為疫情(海外 須請53天假) 無法回火星的家~ 火星人真的很幸福 有機會你們可以去看他2021年火星演唱會的佈置 他包下了整個樂園 開了6天的演唱會

[@wryi1024]

這首歌是華晨宇跟歌迷一個自白一個回應一起創作出來的詞，這已經不是在追星，而是成為家人一般每年演唱會成為一家人的聚會，而華晨宇第一句一定是歡迎回家，人要去了解他是一個非常有溫度的人。

[@shanlynchew373]

口号喊的是“火星撞地球，晨宇你最牛！”

[@lilychiao70]

红衣服孩子说得很好，歌词看着平凡，完全是华自己的疑问，挣扎，但是粉丝对他的每一个不确信都是无条件的爱和支持-做你自己！这首歌年轻人很容易有共鸣。

[@TheEstheryiu73]

謝謝你們😭😭😭真的太感動了，想起當時在演唱會中真的是哭到停不下來，越了解他越會更愛他，他能打開自己的心扉跟我們分享，用音樂來表達一切，這份就是最好的禮物，真的太愛太愛华晨宇了💕💕

[@葉憶蘭]

我每一次聽也都哭了 哈哈你們真的太可愛了

[@cheche8565]

謝謝分享🙏🏼粉絲了解華晨宇的成長經歷聽這首歌會更感動，我第一次聽都不自覺地流眼淚。建議再看看這首歌的MV和先導，非常正👍🏻 華晨宇創作的歌都非常有深度，不只是流於一般的談情說愛，是對生命、生活、對人與人之間、人和大自然等的探索⋯👍🏻👍🏻

[@luizfang2517]

～～

[@carlina8814]

💖Hua chenyu I LOVE YOU 💖😭😭😭😭😭 HUA CHENYU kau yang terbaik 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍❤️

[@chunjuanlaile]

那场演唱会我在现场，跟着一起唱，好多温暖和美好的回忆 😭 是的，演唱会的版本是最动人的。好难过因为疫情，这一年来世界发生好多事，去年没有演唱会了，今年也不知道何时会有，也不知道开演唱会的时候，边境是不是可以开了。好多无常，特别想念这些美好的时光 😭

[@chunjuanlaile]

说到演唱会上和歌迷的合唱，我突然想到2017年唱《国王与乞丐》，有一段歌迷跟着唱，非常好听，几万人一个声音唱一首非常抒情的曲子，真的非常美！我找到这个视频kzbin.info/www/bejne/rqqZnKOjbJl3asU

[@chunjuanlaile]

我又听了一遍上面我推的那个链接，发现大部分是火星人唱的，我推的好像不是华晨宇，而是ET天团 😂😂😂 anyway, 也很期待你们看另一个，《烟火里的尘埃》~ kzbin.info/www/bejne/nInchn1uYrlnqtE

[@xiaozim3697]

我也在现场。专程回去只为了看演唱会。

[@vinkam1475]

在现场的+1！我是一面哭一面唱的XD 我们一起静待春暖花开时。

[@chunjuanlaile]

@@vinkam1475 一起期待春暖花开 ❤️

[@蘇女好]

你們三個，聽完他的，三部曲，及降臨，好想愛，這世界啊！還有與，火星孩子，的對話，越來越明白，歌詞的意境，都聽到感動，流淚了！也欣賞他，真是個，奇才，疫情也讓他，有感而發，寫了一首，鼓勵醫護人員，及在患難中，的人們，聽了也會感動，苦的，他捐款，也不為人知，実在是，很有愛心，的孩子，為守護他的，歌迷，承諾，五年時兌現，讓粉絲更愛他，都認為選擇他，沒有錯，無論是，十年十五年，二十年，他們都願，守護他，只要他在，他們也一直，都會在，難得有這樣，彼此關愛，想扶持的，歌迷，默契十足啊！繼續找，未聽過的，就能更，理解他了！天籟之戰，歌手的比賽，都很出色，參加綜藝，王牌對王牌，第六季了，有他在，收視率特高，他學得很快，很會表演呢！現在竟然，學跳舞了！

[@m_wang3224]

有时候我们是华晨宇，因为别人的支持而感动。但同时我们也是火星人，可以去理解别人。

[@lillylin2018]

Best 😍😍😍❤️🌹🌹❤️

[@yuni86927]

我在现场！我们确实很幸福！

[@瑤池-z9c]

他們在喊：晨宇你最牛，火星撞地球

[@miyaleong]

看过你们之前几个反应视频，来到与火星的孩子对话，才终于看到你们是真正被华晨宇感动了！是真情流露...。红衣服的那个帅哥如果不是在镜头前，应该会想嚎啕大哭吧？😂

[@aaronthum5153]

我也是建议听他的mv..很感动。。

[@leightatterton]

I often joke that the Martian trilogy should be called "Tear - jerking trilogy" instead. Each song makes me cry a lot in different ways. The lyrics was really written by Hua and his fans. He invited a group of fans to come and sit together, where he wrote things about himself on his board and his fans replied accordingly on theirs. All that they wrote down were gathered and edited into this lyrics. In the MV, you hear only a Martian child. I guess this is how he view his fans - someone angelic and need to be treasured. He loves the Martians to call him "big brother", after all. On the 3 days that the Mars Concert 2019 happened, his reaction via hearing "because we love you" was not the same. In this clip (the first day and also the first time the song was performed live), he could barely hold back his tear. The second day, it changed to a combination of shyness and happiness, almost like he pretended he was not expecting that line but failed to suppress his smile. The third day, it became so very gentle, somewhat like in the MV but a bit happier.

[@Linda-qw9xn]

真的非常感谢你们的reaction! 当我知道你们看的是演唱会版本我已经想哭了因为我不敢看 一看就哭死了 T.T 这首是华晨宇和火星人一起完成的。我真的很庆幸我遇到了华晨宇（哭）我们真的太爱太爱他了！我们和华晨宇之间一直都是双向的。真的很刻骨铭心啊 T.T

[@sisriwahyuni5724]

I can't hold back my tears whenever listen to this song. Thank you

[@MsJoliko]

Amazing ❤️❤️❤️ !!!!!

[@houinlei2012]

好快啊, 一定要聽7重人格演唱會版, 史詩級

[@dorischu8769]

“Perhaps Love “ and “ flammable and explosive “ 也許你們也很喜歡，像舞台劇

[@happystrategyhall]

推荐“假行僧”。一人完成极有戏剧张力的自弹自唱，表演艺术的高峰。你们一定会喜欢！😄

[@ooichinsian5100]

很喜欢你们的理解， 没想到你们是蛮感性的。

[@LannyMin]

Even I have watched and listened to this song many times but I still can't stop being touched and emotional. I cry and feel happy everytime I listen to it. Thanks for doing this touching reaction

[@미니미규리의댄스]

很高兴 这首歌可以引起你们的共鸣. 花花说过 : 他唱歌的目的 不是唱歌时 技巧如何如何高超 而是在唱歌时 观众是否能够共鸣 投入 过后 可以思考 就觉得歌曲有了意义

[@elainesok]

我也很常将自己代入这首歌，就像是与自己对话一样。

[@wendywong9054]

Beautiful song,it’s so touchy.Hua Hua is a fantastic singer and a great songwriter

[@xvanessa5924]

哦，我也是第一次听这个演唱会的版本，好感动啊！

[@mimid.9965]

You are 3 beautiful men... I love this touching reaction :) Hua Chenyu is an amazing performer and take care of his martians (ET's) and vice-versa. Continue to support him, if you can react to his performance at the New Year's Eve, he sing 3 songs and he was so so happy to be in Haikou where he did his last Mars Concert in 2019.

[@nocturnalowl5867]

Great job guys for being fearless in showing emotions and sobbing on camera for real 😢😢 😂😂

[@Izabella907]

Thank you for this reaction. Everyone who has a heart cries at this performance.🥲 The music video is also beautiful. It was released before the concert, so the fans would know their parts. It shows how the song was developed, how he broke out of his isolation, and how the love of his fans heals him.❤️ I've never heard of a performer being this honest and vulnerable in front of thousands of fans. He is the bravest person I know.🌸

[@tanlaylian5260]

你们看这视频的reaction 真可爱，so far 是我唯一重复看的reaction 👍🏼☺️❤🌹❤️

[@coco-dg2lm]

切了好多洋葱🥺🥺😥火🔥棒棒哒，果然是出道多年🤭🤭。

[@fienyuni]

Rest assured..You are not the only ones crybaby-ing after listening to this song..

[@nevillejong5332]

很开心这首歌可以引起你们的共鸣，也谢谢你们反应了这首歌🌹也可以看看这首歌的先导，可以了解这首歌的创作过程kzbin.info/www/bejne/i3nGd3-woc1_l7s

[@pattypetronillemartin2608]

Awww So touching, watching you guys I got all teary too, but this song is so emotionally charged... Would you please react next to an uplifting rocky song, HuaHua’s I Don’t Care at Peace Elite Championships please, it’s a recent performance and it was awesome! Link in reply to this comment. (Shared on FB group Hua Chenyu Foreign Martians)

[@TwoMusketeersReaction]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gYaVcnebd7d7hLM

[@chunjuanlaile]

Yes! 下一首可以来个摇滚high歌《我管你》

[@Wkd183]

Love watching all three of you reacting to the videos. Each one giving your own unique perceptions makes it more fun and interesting. The MV version is also touching and his vocal is so warm.

[@kelly4250]

谢谢！ I love you guys and your reactions 🤗🤗🤗. This song is always a very emotional song for me...for all the love he receives, it’s easy to forget how brutal his haters can be 😭😭😭-it breaks my heart. To know that he can find love and comfort with his fans is so touching! What a beautiful soul he has 🙏

[@anniechai1718]

😍😍

[@NahIamgood]

Your reaction made my day! You guys are too cute and we all deserve to surround ourselves with people that understand and comfort us ❤️

[@kohflorence5441]

谢谢博主分享，也祝福你们越来越好，加油！

[@Helpformiri]

加油

[@Martin-cb7vm]

七重人格可以看演唱会版的，效果很好，比较释放

[@Nhungoc815]

Hua Hua ❤❤❤

[@aaronthum5153]

可以反应花花的白痴，如果爱。

[@angelynmandia766]

Thanks for reacting to Hua Chenyu music.

[@vijandrav.6095]

This was great. So touching. Thank you. I would love if you could react to his performance of Exaggerated. It is one of his more "theatrical " ones. The song is in cantonese. It was a challenge from his fans. The song was hard to sing for him (because of the language and the feelings he has to convey in this song). But it is such a great one. Looking forward to more Hua Chenyu on your channel. I love your videos and I am so thankful for the eng subs. ☺

[@vijandrav.6095]

And Hua Chenyu/Su Shiding Perhaps Love would be great. Everytime I watch this I think Hua Hua would also be a great actor ☺. Did you know that he did a Mini Movie called Quasimodo's gift? There are some heavy topics in it but it is very good.

[@mainissen1836]

That was such a sweet reaction - and genuine :D

[@CC-sr2ec]

❤️❤️❤️

[@渀波洱灞]

和火星孩子对话真的就是字面意思，就是和花花粉丝对话。这首歌在演唱那一栏写的就是 “演唱：华晨宇、火星人”。 这首歌从发布到MV都是粉丝参与对唱。甚至里面对于花花性格评价的歌词都是从粉丝那征集来的。

[@barbarakangas3255]

Thank you for your reaction to this song. It was very touching and I cried along with you. The song was actually written by Hua Hua and a group of Martians together. There is a video of this called Conversation with a Martian Child teaser. I would love to see you react to that along with the MV...all of the Martians who helped write the song are in the MV. The little girl was there with her parents. Even though you've reacted to this, we Martians can never get too much of Hua Hua!

[@user-lmao]

谢谢你们做花花的Reac ❤❤

[@chingliu8621]

You guys are very interesting and loving!

[@lilykaku7256]

😭😭😭😭😭

[@미니미규리의댄스]

再次留言 希望你们可以react (2019火星演唱会 ) 不会担心被blocked 有一个华晨宇资源博 可以看那个剪辑的

[@asuna7782]

斗牛斗牛，下一期可以react斗牛MV！

[@nevillejong5332]

哇哦～我来了

[@sooyoukong7009]

Then you should listen to KING AND THE BEGGAR. With the fans singing with HUA HUA.

[@joymcvey8331]

I really love watching your reactions...thank you for them, and for including English subtitles. This version of this performance includes the conversation just prior to the song that is very touching as well, and gives some insight into the motivation for this song and why he did it this way. It's worth it to go back and watch it. kzbin.info/www/bejne/b53Zf36gjNqrbcU

[@irislpiano880]

谢谢你们的反应视频，不过我想说这歌名其实是与火星的孩子对话😅

[@卡卡-b2z]

😂😂😂我也沒發現，歌名真的容易混淆，可怎麼念確也很合理

[@irislpiano880]

@@卡卡-b2z 对，主要是华晨宇自己说错好几次，我才记住了正确的😂

[@asuna7782]

我来纠正一下，是《与火星的孩子对话》，不是《与火星孩子的对话》，介绍栏搞错了哈哈哈

[@calixtey2464]

怪人+1

[@yutinghuang7967]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@lovehcy5482]

❤❤❤