华晨宇Hua ChenYu《爸，我回来了》|| 3 Musketeers Reaction马来西亚三剑客【REACTION】【ENG SUBS】

[@oliviali2773]

我從未見過有歌手能像華晨宇般全心投入，全然進入忘我境界，情感強烈而真實，緊扣人心，沒有這相似不幸經歷的都能感受震撼，有類似經驗的更感同身受，難以自拔，但幸好因最後那句而略釋懷，愛依然存在，他是不可多得的獨特靈魂歌手。

[@kerenchin5859]

华晨宇是歌手也是艺术家👍

[@sherlocklee4384]

破坏别人作品的艺术家

[@maywu1029]

我不是花粉，他不仅仅是歌手或曲作者，他写得东西太超前，多听听古典和欧美的，就比较容易接受他的作品，他那些复调改编都是从古典乐里来，那些音乐形式目前国内没有其他人做👍

[@maywu1029]

他是个大艺术家

[@wongmeewah4207]

我只能说华晨宇(花花)🌺🌺是一个天生会用音乐🎶表达内心情感的一位歌手。很喜欢花花在“天赖之战”所改编的所有歌曲。我也是通过这节目而认识花花🌺🌺，也有被花花🌺🌺的音乐创作和改编能力震撼到。一位歌手能够在 24 小时内把一首被选中的挑战歌曲改编成完全不同于原唱歌手的歌曲，实在是太难了。但是花花🌺🌺每次都能把每一首歌曲改编到极致，如果没有很强的音乐基本功的话，相信是没办法做到。花花🌺🌺真的是一位很有实力的音乐人。🌺🌺🎤🎼🎵🎶👍👏💪💖💕😎😍🤗

[@hmaggie4231]

他這一節是贏了的，"天籟之戰"每一節都要將挑戰者給他選的歌或音樂在24小時後表演出來，歌手可將歌曲或音樂自己去創作、改編、排練......等等，但只有24小時的時間；花花是每個人都覺得他很強的，所以有些挑戰花花的會只選幾句音樂給他，他要在24小時內創作曲和詞、排練......等等，我覺得花花實在了不起👍牛👍強強強👍。

[@hmaggie4231]

"天籟之戰"有1、2的這首歌是"天籟之戰2"的，花花"天籟之戰1、2"都有好多好聽的歌，還有重點是所有歌曲詞、改編、舞台排練效果等，都是在24小時內完成的👍，好有實力。

[@侯小楠-g1e]

這是一首我看一次流一次眼淚的視頻。 謝謝你們的 reaction. 首先我想說這不是花花自己選的歌曲，被挑戰者指定的歌曲，而且必須在24小時之內 改編並演唱，是與假行僧完全不同的。 周杰倫的歌曲，早已深入人心，要在短時間內改編演唱，並且不同于原著，是非常吃力不討好的，花花能夠用這樣的“演唱”並且觸動大部分的觀賞者，實為不易。

[@iqbang9236]

我推荐的。👍👍👍

[@lilylicy]

他贏了！在這個節目上......他的改編和表演打動了絕大多數觀眾。華晨宇成長在破碎家庭，少年時比較自卑，常用自己的音樂方式表達情感和自己對話。2013年他參加『快樂男聲』全國歌唱比賽時，就是唱自己的『無字歌』，開唱就遭到評委們按停止鍵，被認為是“怪人”，只有尚雯婕一人獨挺他，明白他的音符和旋律，肯定了他的唱功，與他交流，並鼓勵他，成為他的『伯樂』，最終他憑實力打敗所有對手，一路晉級，成為全國總冠軍。之後他唱歌的爆發力被公認為 “火星少年" 。

[@gloriawong438]

我愛花花

[@wuwu133]

花花太棒了👏

[@carlaliang7345]

Masterpiece!! 抓人，揪心！！

[@thanhvan4323]

Hua Hua 😘😘😘😘

[@iqbang9236]

很多海外React主，都哭了。我也是看一次哭一次。

[@sherlocklee4384]

我也哭了，哭是因为我男神120bpm左右的歌，被改成好像死了爹的歌

[@irenelee337]

赢了。。。很喜欢你们的解说 😊。

[@jacquelinejacques822]

une star huahua !!!!! quelle magnifique voix de plus tres bon compositeur !!!! the king !!! tres belle chanson merci aux 3 mousquetaires

[@nangsuzy189]

He win🎉😬

[@shirleytansl6919]

He won.

[@iqbang9236]

华晨宇自述小时候孤独，但不贫困，也没有家暴，家里有钱。他只是喜欢这类艺术性的带表演的有思想性的另类的小众的独特的歌曲，没有合适的就自己改编。

[@JerisEve]

People didn't applaud, they were afraid to breathe. There were people in the audience who were praying for him. The conductor started the applause. HuaHua did not come from a home with domestic violence, but he did not have a happy childhood. When he got the song and read the lyrics, he thought it was too important to rap. So he did this. He cried during rehearsal. He has a huge heart. Yes, he won.

[@coco-dg2lm]

洋葱，好多洋葱🥺😭😭Song emotional, touching and meaningfu songl 🎵. Can feel the pain💔💔. 每次听华晨宇的听都不一样，太多惊喜。Thanks for sharing.

[@鄭雅慧-l1f]

花花是一個很獨特的人，做自己喜歡的音樂，從不做流水歌，他是我看過一個有靈魂歌唱的歌者他的專輯含金量很高，第四專真的跟一般歌手的專輯不能比👍👍👍

[@linah4166]

花花曾在一个访谈中说，他是看到歌词后才决定这样改编的，他说歌词很淺白，但很有力量，rap太快了，容易忽略了歌词，他想用这样的方式去传达这首歌的意义. 他在歌唱完后有说 “他之前都是用唱歌来给大家说一个故事，但这次他想用一个講故事的方式来给大家唱一首歌，谢谢你们的分享😊

[@choilin2527]

🌹🌹👍👍👍👍👍❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@chengcheng7930]

Amazing good song 👍Thanks share 💐

[@houinlei2012]

打破傳統改編，變成自己的歌

[@jeannefong9401]

Thanks so much for reacting to this amazing emotional piece. He was one of the judges/celebrity on the show The NEXT. He was challenged to rearrange this song within 24 hours and perform it. Hua Hua felt the message was very important and slowed it down to a monologue and song. This is not his story; his parents divorced when he was around 2 years old and he stayed with his Father. His Father was too busy to care for him, never praised him or showed him love. Music helped him process the loneliness, sadness and pain of his childhood. The raw emotions and heart cries he expressed are so real. You just feel his emotions. The last poignant line, "I want to still call you Papa", was added by him. I totally agree, this is a performance that needs to be watched to really appreciate it.

[@renhaofeng3491]

很喜歡你們，加油！另外真的很推薦華晨宇的地球之盐，我覺得是我心中花花最震撼的一首歌

[@siewmuilok1321]

这是“天籁之战”的PK.

[@elisifuentes6551]

Shared in the Hua Chenyu Foreign Martian Group on FB

[@Wkd183]

I think he portrayed domestic violence so well in this. During rehearsal it was very painful for him. Hua himself was not physically abused. His father was away most of the time with his work and hardly gave Hua loving support or attention he craved. For me this touched me hard as I can relate to his painful but powerful performance. As the hostess said, he turned rap into hamlet. His “cries” just broke me and his emotions are so real. Though it’s not a song per say, it shows how creative he was in presenting this song this way to bring more awareness to this issue.

[@jan5929]

Well, actually, you can only feel it when you're there in person.

[@jan5929]

I was there at that time pratically, and it was soooo heartshaking. You can never feel it by just watching a video. BTW he actually won this competition.

[@susuma9834]

周杰倫和華宸宇都是父母離異的之下長大的歌手

[@billg7531]

There is so much to say about this video performance, but I think that all that really needs to be said is "Thank you Three Musketeers for sharing this masterpiece".

[@미니미규리의댄스]

天籁之战 是素人挑选歌曲给歌手 24小时内 改编彩排最后表演 素人歌手是唱自己准备的拿手歌曲 现场观众投票 花 这场赢了 事实好像2季天籁他只输了一场常规赛 并助力两季选手拿了冠军

[@pattypetronillemartin2608]

Everything has been said, HuaHua is one of the best actor/singers, there's always a glimmer of hope in HuaHua's songs, even the darkest/saddest. I have a hard time watching this performance, a bit too raw, plus I haven't been in touch from near or far to domestic abuse, so it makes it harder to relate.

[@elisifuentes6551]

Always appreciate every Hua Chenyu reaction of yours. This is a masterpiece, but not exactly on my playlist 🥰 Hcys parents divorced at a very early age and he grew up with a father who was never there. Vey lonely childhood, but nothing like what this is about. He is always capable of using any past experience and bring it back to convey the true emotion in a song. Never any fake pastisj performances from HCY. And no… even though this show is not about winning or losing for a mentor.. his challenger didnt succeed

[@margit6521]

As an artist he so perfectly assumes the role of the protagonist of his songs. Could you please react his version of Nunchucks. It shows his versatility and stage precense. I love the chinese opera part !

[@nocturnalowl5867]

Agree with you. This cover isn’t meant for our listening pleasure. It’s a measured performance meant to deliver a message. His parents divorced when he was 2 or three years old so it wasn’t his experience. He lived with his father who wasn’t always around for him.

[@TwoMusketeersReaction]

I really like watching Hua's live performances, he is performing, not just singing, it's like a full packaged performance

[@nocturnalowl5867]

@@TwoMusketeersReaction Yes, some people can appreciate that the art of singing includes acting as a whole performance. While some just insist that singing should just be about the quality of the singer’s vocal ability 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️ I personally don’t like to watch this particular performance but I won’t detract Hua’s talent and endeavours on stage 👍👍 Thanks for your fair-minded review.

[@justinsimon7083]

感觉类似。 他在《假行僧》上的表演确实惊艳到我了。至于这首，emmmmmm。 表演方式太过单薄，就是不断强行把自己的情感灌注到独白里头，然后在演唱部分用高音表达撕裂感。 如果拿来做音乐朗诵作品倒是挺合格的，但作为演唱，它并没有展现出音乐本身在表达情感上所需要展现的技巧。 《假行僧》确实是相当不错的，我会更多去关注华晨宇的作品。但就这首而言，在他琳琅满目的作品里真算不上什么代表作，不明白为什么那么多人要推荐。

[@maywu1029]

这首他改的太高级了，我倒很喜欢呢

[@Pilutta100]

I was s bit disappointed you didn't love this as much as I do, we can't love same, but I also didn't know you all heard this song before, lol. To me it is so raw pain. Had no clue that pain could be anything other than pain even if in another song.??? I didn't grow up in an abusive household, but that doesn't mean I can't see pain, portrait or real. Your interpretation was so clinical and it felt off.

[@TwoMusketeersReaction]

hmm, we commented that from a performing perspective he delivered the emotions and message of the song very well through this extraordinary performance, we couldn't relate as we did not grew up in an abusive environment but as theatre practitioners, we truly felt the pain he conveyed through the monologue performance and his vocals in the chorus. it's a cover from a pop song back in the early 2000s, so we heard the original before and Hua's interpretation is totally different and we could say unique from the original and we give props for that! =) sorry if we sounded clinical ,or maybe it's my English translation that mislead some points we made in the video as our mother language is mandarin, I try my best to translate our points more detailed in future videos , thanks for your comment and support =)

[@Pilutta100]

@@TwoMusketeersReaction ty for answer. Your exploitation is satisfying. Hugs from Sweden.

[@altg4044]

You should also react to 'Nunchucks by J. Chou which Huahua rearranged for Singer 2018. He mixed several genres into one.

[@glowinkl]

You guys missed , especially the guy with glasses , completely missed the point about this amazing performance. As Olivia Li said irregardless of his background and whether it’s a contest or not it’s totally irrelevant ! … more importantly, did the song affect you, did it evoke any feelings ( whether you had a bad experience in your childhood or not )

[@glowinkl]

Your reaction took into account irrelevant matters like how jay chou sang it or HCY’s background and if it was a contest or not … IRRELEVANT 🤣 …. It’s a show, react to the show what you see. As 张艺兴 said later , 这就是艺术. First time watching you guys , but disappointed at your poor analysis, will have a look at a few more to see if your other reactions are similarly mindless, clueless or not.

[@TwoMusketeersReaction]

first of all, thanks for your comment on our video, it means a lot for us to receive comments and space of discussion towards our point of views, as we are not professional singers or musicians, this is what we do as our interest. as music is a form of art, I can say art is subjective, so I guess we have our own views and takes on performances right? so sorry that you did not enjoy our review and thoughts, and we hope you won't find our other videos mindless and clueless, as we are not professional musician or artist let me stress again. you might find our comments amateur, or totally based on our feelings as most of our reactions are first time reactions, we never pre watch the video or purposely do tons of research on the song or singer. we agree that Hua is definitely a talented artist, and we enjoy watching his performances especially his live ones, it is always interesting to watch him cover different songs and totally make them his own, or just by performing his own originals. thank you once again and pleasure to have you with us at least in this video =)

[@Wkd183]

I have watched few of their reactions of Hua, and for most part their reactions have been appreciative and even emotional. Yes I am a little surprised that it may not have affected them as deeply as some of us. I agree, that regardless of what the stage was set for, the performance itself personally ripped me apart. Even though it’s painful, I really appreciate his artistic performance and that is why I watch reactors to see their perception.

[@glowinkl]

My point was they based their reactions on totally irrelevant factors, which should not have played a part in their reaction. Of course they were doing this out of interest , that’s clear but it shows they lack comprehension and depth of reactors. It’s not just about reacting to HCY but I suspect they lack depth in their approach and analysis on any reactions.

[@graceng8526]

@@glowinkl I agree with what you think of them.

[@sooyoukong7009]

Your video not life, how to watch the show? Support no!!

[@munyuenngan2760]

唱没感情😢

[@sherlocklee4384]

我只想说自己的作品，想怎么搞砸是自己的事，但麻烦别破坏别人的作品，如果只是单纯开玩笑可以理解，我也时常改词，但直接放上电视节目，唱的好像死了妈，我觉得很恶心，明明120bpm左右的歌，非得这样"唱"，呃，应该用说比较好，这不是唱，麻烦自己重新作词作曲这样玩，不要拿别人的作品，谢谢

[@花开那年]

这你要跟节目制作组说😂

[@xiuqinzhuang4285]

杰粉😂