华教义演扫盲：啤酒商有无捐款？影响孩童心智？不顾穆斯林师生敏感？【记者茶水间 EP13】ft.罗志昌

Рет қаралды 27,614

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 91

@kinitv 2 ай бұрын

👇🏻Read the full reports in BM, English and Chinese👇🏻 [BM] www.malaysiakini.com/news/713170 [ENG] www.malaysiakini.com/news/713168 [CHI] www.malaysiakini.com/news/713146

@leongyokelan1924 2 ай бұрын

很好的节目，再接再厉。我孩子读的华小和我服务的中学在这三十多年来都办过多场的华教意义，提升了学校的设备和学习环境，真的万分感恩这些企业赞助商。华教绝不能向恶势力低头，奋战到底！

@limac6408 2 ай бұрын

这期的嘉宾把问题解释的非常好也给出很多宝贵的意见！如果国会议员能够这样解释我相信很多问题都能够解决。马来西亚本来就是多元种族的社会互相尊重自古以来已经定根深蒂固了人民大致上都知道要互相尊重除了一些政治人物煽动情绪来捞取政治支持。

@johnleewenjiet 2 ай бұрын

法令的存在是有本身功能，但如果有瑕疵，就要进行修改。这是要符合某群体以便有好的效果。大马是多元国家，政府必须要维护宪法&各个群体的多元化。

@muhammadaliffzulfikarabuba7999 2 ай бұрын

in the constitution is also stated that Agama Rasmi Persekutuan Malaysia🇲🇾 ialah Islam 😅 its not a secular country

@JimmyTan-pb5pb 2 ай бұрын

19.53超棒一针见血的解说👍

@victorlaw5763 2 ай бұрын

什么叫着《极端》? 极端就是总是用想象力把芝麻无碍的小事无限放大。。。把重要的事返着做!

@chowfookong4281 2 ай бұрын

酒文化自古以來都是很真面。捐款是要理直氣壯。腰桿要板直。啤酒捐有錯嗎？不要用穆斯林宗教道德綁架我們華教。豬肉商可以捐嗎？撈偏門為愛捐華教可以嗎？酒真的那麼十惡不赦嗎？

@muhammadaliffzulfikarabuba7999 2 ай бұрын

why woulf muslims kidnap "chinese religon"???😅 it more about the children than about religon😅

@low3327 2 ай бұрын

@@muhammadaliffzulfikarabuba7999所以酒商筹办的捐款活动到底有什么问题？到底影响孩子什么？既然你来到这里，我敬佩你，也以恭敬的态度来和你辩个黑白。

@low3327 2 ай бұрын

@@muhammadaliffzulfikarabuba7999 If you prevent the beer company from using their logo in the fundraising event, why would they want to help you organize it? This is our Chinese community's initiative to preserve Chinese education and culture, and we have our ways of achieving mutual benefits without promoting beer culture. How does it affect your Muslim beliefs? I reiterate, this is a fundraising event sponsored by the beer company to raise funds for Chinese schools! The funds are collected by Chinese businesses and the public. What concern is it of your Muslim teachings? Are you joining the fundraising event for Chinese schools? We have good intentions, good reasons, and have broken no laws. We are volunteers. Who are you to question our efforts?

@low3327 2 ай бұрын

@@muhammadaliffzulfikarabuba7999If you prevent the beer company from using their logo in the fundraising event, why would they want to help you organize it? This is our Chinese community's initiative to preserve Chinese education and culture, and we have our ways of achieving mutual benefits without promoting beer culture. How does it affect your Muslim beliefs? I reiterate, this is a fundraising event sponsored by the beer company to raise funds for Chinese schools! The funds are collected by Chinese businesses and the public. What concern is it of you Muslim? Are you joining the fundraising event for Chinese schools? We have good intentions, good reasons, and have broken no laws. We are volunteered. Who are you to question our efforts?

@low3327 2 ай бұрын

@@muhammadaliffzulfikarabuba7999If you prevent the beer company from using their logo in the fundraising event, why would they want to help you organize it? This is our Chinese community's initiative to preserve Chinese education and culture, and we have our ways of achieving mutual benefits without promoting beer culture. How does it affect your Muslim beliefs? I reiterate, this is a fundraising event sponsored by the beer company to raise funds for Chinese schools! The funds are collected by Chinese businesses and the public. What concern is it of you Muslim? Are you joining the fundraising event for Chinese schools? We have good intentions, good reasons, and have broken no laws. We are volunteered. Who are you to question our efforts?

@NKKHOO-Malaysia 2 ай бұрын

回教徒還不是享用賭博和酒稅.

@leeleeyap1018 2 ай бұрын

噢，原耒如此，给所有主辩者👍🏻赞👍🏻赞👍🏻。(类事的节目主辩多些给不明白的都听的明白)。再给你们👍🏻。

@StevenTanWilddiscus 2 ай бұрын

继续加油，华人在建国前后都为国家贡献了，所以决定留下的已经宣誓孝忠国家；愛国家；国家宪法的尊严不容挑衅。

@craziemoon7076 2 ай бұрын

马来学校也可以叫Tiger/烟草公司帮忙凑款，马来人也有抽烟的😂

@joshwai 2 ай бұрын

lol Its now Proven... The world MOST SENSITIVE Religion... all must respect them, they don't need to respect others.

@kienjennan8251 2 ай бұрын

That's why they always think their religion is complete(sempurna)! Only their religion include fear by others!

@giant108 2 ай бұрын

@@kienjennan8251The time bomb implanted by an illiterate desert lunatic almost 1400 years ago.

@jazsia4642 2 ай бұрын

如果透过酒商赞助而影响孩子价值观？是无稽之谈，难道赞助了，看到logo，小孩就会偷偷酒喝吗？喝酒反而是家长自己喝，出来社会，去娱乐，工作应酬之类活动才会影响孩子去接触酒类吧，老师家长有责任灌输正确价值观。华小有穆斯林老师学生，更说不过去，这些建筑，座椅难道酒商赞助了，就不能用吗？追根究底，现钱都不能动了，来源不清，卖酒卖猪肉家长都不能捐款给学校或慈善组织了，不halal,是吧😅

@terenceterencetayboren6683 2 ай бұрын

那又誰顧慮非穆斯林感受呀？又沒有得到公平撥款

@thamsang2937 2 ай бұрын

完全同意，它们又何曾尊重华人?

@SunYes-hn1wd 2 ай бұрын

👍

@JimmyTan-pb5pb 2 ай бұрын

一个有作为的政府，根本不会让这些本末倒置的情况发生。真的为大马的未来失去信心与严重的悲哀。

@xiyuchua8494 2 ай бұрын

马华留下来的手尾，回教党的煽动，在加两个政党的唱双簧，才会难道那么大

@paulyap2988 2 ай бұрын

@@JimmyTan-pb5pb 是明显是当今政府无能无力，失败的执政。

@nich0145w 2 ай бұрын

@@xiyuchua8494 可是为什么是当权的去实行这个东西？为什么政府到现在没有摆出立场

@xiyuchua8494 2 ай бұрын

@@nich0145w 因为教育部在2018年的时候是有这个法令的，那时是张盛闻的手，回教党拿出来说要遵守这个教育法令，其实jawi课程也是张盛闻那个时候编进去的，如果没有换政府真的很多还不知道，所以陆赵福说要带进内阁修改法令，如果我没有错误的话

@Jay-dw4jr 2 ай бұрын

@@xiyuchua8494这个说不通，马华倒了多久了，那时希盟也当政府了，拿这个理由来推脱，就好像内安法令在别人手是不好的，在希盟手里讲的很神圣一样。政府哪里可以这样来搞。

@TakeYourAce 2 ай бұрын

希望立一个法，看哪个议员拿3R话题讨论的话，直接取消它议员资格

@cheancheeming9221 2 ай бұрын

很想知道政府从赌博业，博彩业和啤酒业抽取不清真的数十亿税收有没有用在穆斯林身上。假如有，伊党也应该反对，而建议把这些不清真的税收全只用在非穆斯林身上如给奖学金，建神庙，给华淡小，独中和拉曼大学。非穆斯林一定感激伊党和政府。华小也不用为了拨款不足够而举办捐款活动了。

@richarder9980 2 ай бұрын

Carlsberg Malaysia's Top-Ten Charity Campaign established over 37 years ago since 1986...

@heeyap8814 2 ай бұрын

有人挑事，有人跟着一起起舞，唯恐天下不乱，黑心政党。

@伍名-u5s 2 ай бұрын

尤其是洪大便😂

@leeleeyap1018 2 ай бұрын

往往是造事者为恐天下大乱的目死林。

@koumukoumu7741 2 ай бұрын

看到啤酒logo就想到喝啤酒影响孩童心智，太小看我们身为父母和小朋友了，意志坚定，摆在你面前都不为所动。为了一点小事就说影响这个那个的人，本身就意志薄弱，就是其他人也会这样。看到了摩托车的广告，你会买来当交通工具或当飙车族，看你个人造化话了。

@danieltan8875 Ай бұрын

说tiger 义演会影响小孩的。是最牵强的借口。我三兄弟经过6年的小学义演。除了我30岁后因为社交圈子而开始喝酒。两个弟弟目前是滴酒不占。华人社区本来从小到大无论派对喜宴都是被啤酒（宣传）。所以这根本是多拿来说的。

@mokt7717 2 ай бұрын

难道老虎就没有用义演来打广告吗？为什么不用无名氏的名义来捐款呢？

@myworldAI 2 ай бұрын

有打卖酒的广告吗？

@aftereffects00 2 ай бұрын

首先酒商所捐的是錢不是酒，那請問如何會影響孩童心智呢？誰可以解說看看嗎？如果酒商告訴學生你們要多喝酒那這樣才會影響孩童心智但捐錢給學校又怎麼能影響孩童心智呢?(還有學生可能看到廣告就會喝酒的，難道華小學生會那樣做嗎?) 那我們非穆斯林經常喝酒的人如果你很有錢但你卻不可以捐錢給學校問題就是因為你經常喝酒，這不是很搞笑嗎？那如果說你們喝酒他們也批准捐錢了那也是很搞笑啊，酒商賺了你喝酒的錢和你自己的錢有分別嗎？你用你的錢去捐和酒商用他們賺了你的錢，然後拿去捐有分別嗎？哈哈哈。。。我看不出有任何分別，1錢從你口袋去學校 2錢從你口袋去了酒商那，然後酒商拿你的錢去捐，都是一樣的不是嗎？其實拿這話題來吵根本就是浪費時間和口氣，但偏偏有人偏要炒作這話題啊。。

@3006kiki 2 ай бұрын

我觉得女主持一直重复问题，要怎么解决事故重演。。。我知道嘉宾已经回答了，而且回答很好。。。。

@PK-hj4rr 2 ай бұрын

一再委屈的解释是没有用的秀才遇到兵所有正当理由在极端族群眼中都是歪理敬请所有负责筹款活动的负责人吸取这一次教训不要再邀请任何穆斯林正副部长出席这一类的活动毕竟还是有很多华人正副部长是非常乐意参与公益活动的

@lew7332 2 ай бұрын

首先贩卖啤酒是国家认可合法滴因此商家把收入捐款也是合法滴捐款对象也是合法机构并且政客不是普通民众需要想出替代方案结果目的只是妒忌羡慕恨想夺走捐款私用😂😂

@wanhunkow 2 ай бұрын

What's the problem of drinking. Little alcohol is good for health. I allow my kids to drink and educate them.

@jybilly5604 2 ай бұрын

如果穆斯林不高兴华校接受啤酒商的赞助，它们可以离开华校！

@helmeeyusof2491 2 ай бұрын

Dan tiba masa sekolah vernakular perlu dihapuskan

@StevenTanWilddiscus 2 ай бұрын

Mungkin masa untuk golongan yg cuba huru hara kan perpaduan Negara dihapuskan. Under federal constitution when the country independent, all Malaysian rights protected. Tak paham tak beriman tolong DIAM aje, buat malu, buat kacau, susahkan orang lain.

@jybilly5604 2 ай бұрын

@@helmeeyusof2491 u try, and we fight!!!

@ninjamusic9554 2 ай бұрын

@@helmeeyusof2491sekolah vernakular biar je la utk non bumi, kalau melayu tak nak masuk

@khoogheehor5855 2 ай бұрын

以后不要请政治人物来就不会有今天的风波反正他们捐的不是主力

@kunyenchen7444 2 ай бұрын

什么敏感不敏感，他少数也要呱呱叫，他大多数更放肆。。。。

@JamesLeBond69 2 ай бұрын

secara Teknikal Fieldwork Sumbangan dari Sektor Gaya hidup tidak sihat kepada kanak kanak bawah Umur memang mengundang kepada Persepsi Sosial tetapiiiiiiiiii dari Segi Logik PerAkaunan berkaitan Polisi Sumbangan hanya memBabitkan keMentrian Sumbangan diBuat kepada Persatuan yang terdiri daripada Ibu Bapa yang melebihi Syarat Umur pembelian Alkohol maka perlu Review Paperwork samada Polisi hanya memBabitkan keMentrian atau terCatit juga dalam Perlembagaan Persatuan PiBG tidak boleh menerima Dana dari Syarikat Mabuk🤔🤔🤔 perkara ni takde masalah sangat perkara membabitkan HumanDroid Pak Karim memang perlu Install Software Kerajaan pada HumanDroid Pak Karim yang masih guna Software Pembangkang Work From Home Gaji Full tak perlu berSidang pun masih Tamak Haloba masih nak menCabar Akta Proklamasi Frontliner yang bekerja 24/7 semasa Covid pada Gaji tidak berBaloi dgn Risiko Nyawa pun takde nak Pertikai apa pasal Darurat Covid✌️

@muhammadaliffzulfikarabuba7999 2 ай бұрын

how can non chienese understand this 😅 why not use the national language so that other people could understand and get the information 😅

@low3327 2 ай бұрын

If you prevent the beer company from using their logo in the fundraising event, why would they want to help you organize it? This is our Chinese community's initiative to preserve Chinese education and culture, and we have our ways of achieving mutual benefits without promoting beer culture. How does it affect your Muslim beliefs? I reiterate, this is a fundraising event sponsored by the beer company to raise funds for Chinese schools! The funds are collected by Chinese businesses and the public. What concern is it of you Muslim? Are you joining the fundraising event for Chinese schools? We have good intentions, good reasons, and have broken no laws. We are volunteered. Who are you to question our efforts?

@muhammadaliffzulfikarabuba7999 2 ай бұрын

@@low3327my friend, there is a reason why we dont promote or advertize alcohol or tobacco on television anymore it is so that people wont be influence to smoke or or drink especially for children... look if you are an adult then there is no problem go ahead drink, gamble or smoke but this is not the place, this is a school, it is not a place to be advertizing alcohol or tobacco or even gambling😅 please these are children there are plenty of ways to get funds for school money is important but do not let it blind us from prioritizing the well being of our children 😢

@muhammadaliffzulfikarabuba7999 2 ай бұрын

@kinitv 2 ай бұрын

Hi, thanks for your interests on our programme. You can read the full reports in BM and English👇🏻 [BM] www.malaysiakini.com/news/713170 [ENG] www.malaysiakini.com/news/713168

@muhammadaliffzulfikarabuba7999 2 ай бұрын

@@kinitv thanks for the respond