Wait... THIS ITEM STACKS? - Every Item is per floor Challenge

[@mopmopmopmopmopmop]

i feel like a trinket only version if this also could go great, like pica run but only one type of trinket per floor and you start with marbles and the smelter

[@Shandlebar]

I haven't done the pics run but do you get trinkets instead of items in treasure, boss, or devil/ angel

[@carlangas0100]

Signed

[@Shifsabre]

Gulp a dozen cancers and melt through the game

[@Shifsabre]

​@Shandlebar yeah, you start with Mom's Box and Marbles, the gulp chance of marbles is 100%, and all items are trinkets

[@HM-bq7mu]

That would be cool to see

[@RainMarrlen]

One idea could be putting Diplopia in your active slot and not using it, since I think that'd make EID show any stacking effects of the item.

[@curdlem1lk]

It already shows it by default if you already have a copy of the item. Hutts is just ignoring it.

[@NyakahanaOfficial]

Doing ascent could be a good idea with this challenge; if you have a crap floor where you skip item rooms, you can grab them on the way back up with a different roll.

[@TwentySeventhLetter]

I like this idea

[@notchillstorm]

Oh man, that's a great idea.

[@Smaglefop]

When Hutts get an item that has no stackable properties i think hecan give himself maybe 1 reroll for a floor and none for the rest of the run so Hutts has to think if its worth rerolling or keeping it and using it for a different floor on a worse item? Just for Hutts to have more fun on his runs ya know?

[@ASKRHASFALLEN]

Glad to see longevity in the community with switch up on old ideas like this series. Keep up the great work. We love what you do!

[@Greedsmith]

4:29 *Says 353* *Shows 373* 18:56 *Says 2.52* *Shows 2.72*

[@sochaume]

was looking for that comment

[@L3xzion]

Very observant... i give you an eye catching rating of 5/7

[@Krivulda]

Fun fact - Bomber Boy is 353 and if you look at the stats on the left, the damage actually is 2.52. Are we sure the editor is not sending us some messages for help or something like that? 😂

[@notchillstorm]

@@Krivulda Write that down, write that down!

[@Surrealmind]

20/20

[@NJBeast123]

you should commission or see if you could get someone to create a mod that makes a bunch more items stackable (or find a mod that already exists) I think it would be super cool to see normally non stackable items stack and interact in cool ways

[@Henry-de4ox]

Epiphora is a tear rate multiplier, it's not a flat bonus of 2.73 or 0.5 per interval. It used to jump 125%, 150%, 175% and 200% and now it gradually goes up from 100% to 200% during a couple seconds. It said +2.73 because your base tear rate was 2.73

[@gavinjohnson5902]

I want a new version of this challenge every hour of the day

[@viktorholm3386]

So i did suggest that last time and i see other people are suggesting it as well, i would say that after you beat the First Floor you are allowed 1 Reroll per Run but with the downside of that you need to reroll all your Firstfloor Items into the new Item you just rerolled, that way its a Gamble of would you rather get rid of the first item in hope of getting a bunch of good ones or bad ones, in this run you would have just rerolled a bunch of old bandages so it wouldnt have been that bad to lose them but it would have potentially either make the run worse or better, im not sure if you have active items not in the list, i hope so at least since this challenge wouldnt be that fun to watch if you get an active item for each pedestal, with passives thats atleast some sort of gamble but active items are more or less useless unless you get smth like moving box Also another addition i would add, if you get perfection to drop you are also allowed to give yourself 1 Diplopia, basically rewarding you with a double item of your choice also Diplo is nice since it tells you with the item description mod which effect items have if you take multiple but i think the mod does that as well if you already have that same item picked up, nonetherless i think those 2 changes can spice up the run a lot and the reroll would allow for stages like the chest to be really usefull but also stages that just give you a bad item, i would btw also allow for you to reroll anytime after the first floor so you could technically pick up an item of a floor or even all of them and then just reroll so you change your first floor items, thats imo a good way to give more depth into the run and make it more fun and also give you a bit more control of the randomness

[@faint4678]

I have an idea for a challenge: what if every item that you get was random? I think that would add a lot of replayability to Isaac.

[@Destrolo]

Chaos?

[@fewidk]

Wdym random?

[@dkstudios4805]

Lol

[@deathlygamingreal]

Best comment I’ve seen today

[@justinbarton717]

You might be on to something

[@Nexit1337]

funny thing is wafer changes ALL damage to half a heart, even from those "large enemies" that would otherwise do two FULL hearts of damage, with wafer they do half a heart.

[@depotheose7890]

I feel like skipping shops could do something with the greed miniboss. Like, it could reduce the chance of a shop having greed for all following shops by some percent or it could guarantee that the next shop is greed-free. Sort of like a "you already missed out on a shop, there is no reason for you to miss out on more than that" type of deal. It would also be very thematic imo

[@SlayXc2]

The multiple room rewards were most certainly some sort of bug or mod thing. Guppy's Tail is not supposed to stack. Also... 17:22 ....You are not even MATT about it 🥸

[@ikhenry7827]

Guppy's tail special secret effect video when? C:

[@TwentySeventhLetter]

There should be a companion mod with this challenge that makes all items do _something_ when stacking them, even if they aren't particularly strong effects

[@thevortex1904]

The editor today did not seem to see the difference between 5 and 7, because that mistake was made more than once

[@highpalmtree2238]

I love this series. I'd love it if the videos were longer, cause I enjoy longer Hutts videos (maybe 2 runs per video?) but I'm here for the ride we have and not complaining.

[@TheAbstractProject]

IDEA: Every item is per floor. Plus each floor has 3 random challenges - completing each will earn a bonus item. rewards: Ch1 - Random Item tier 1-2. Ch2 - Random Item tier 2-3. Ch3 - Random Item tier 3-4. of course each challenge would be harder than the last to complete for the bonus item. Each challenge and its reward would be known to player. Some challenges may have multiple conditions in order to earn it. (for example find both secret and super secret rooms within 90 seconds) There could also be a variety of challenges: - acquire 4 items on floor then earn bonus item -buy 2 or 3 items from shop for bonus item -buy out shop -destroy all machines on map for bonus item -etc. etc.

[@YeeeetusYoinkus]

Knowing guppy’s tail stacks Is a new excuse to abuse re-crafting of recipes for tainted cain

[@ikhenry7827]

Very fun video as always. Love to the army of fruity plums and this series ❤

[@hideyourturtles]

I admit, I was a catcoin hater for a bit, but I missed them when they were gone! (Assuming this isn’t a very old recording) I’m glad to see them back :)

[@Zoombeani]

I want to express my sincere gratitude for your unwavering support and guidance. Your encouragement has been invaluable, and I truly appreciate your belief in me as one of your viewers.

[@qerksim]

I feel like that guppys tail stackablity might be a challange itself Give yourself like 5-10 Guppy's Tails and start a run but the only Items you can take are from the Chest rewards, no shop items, no golden rooms, no devil/angel deals, no sac rooms or beggars or arcades Only chest rewards

[@Kostej]

I like Every item, every trinket could be interesting to also one mod The Typing of Isaac... just try it, there is chalenge and it is fun.

[@tyler4471]

I love this challenge too! I hope you always make Isaac videos

[@pokeydex]

Hell yeah! Love these challenges

[@michakiju8806]

You love playing this challenge, we love watching it

[@jaspanini]

Absolutely love this challenge! Makes my day seeing the notification

[@Zer0Crow]

Love this series, this was a rough run but next time will be wacky crazy I'm sure!

[@certifiedroastbeefmaniac]

this is such an upgrade from "every item is"! maybe the next step in the evolution could be that every item from a pedestal is the same but theres like, room variants, like in devil deals it could be different items than in treasure rooms, and after that maybe every pedestal could have a different item with these room pools concept attached!! amazing?? can someone code that?

[@hairkip]

One of my favorite series

[@thedamnguy2896]

not going in the shop increases chance for spawning an arcade

[@Reyshkh]

the shop skipping for bigger chance for a black market is genius!

[@238Hero238]

Here's an idea: Every Item Is _Also._ It's a standard run, but every passive item you pick up also gives you a copy of the chosen run item.

[@theblakeinator7341]

Love this type of content

[@Desenrrollado]

It was still an amusing video. Fruity plum did indeed come to help out.

[@parkerrittenhouse6586]

This challenge would be cool with T-Appolion, you could filter the items to be only items with cool locusts

[@SirPhantom.]

Im a fan of the tool tips for items and trinkets. Thank you for them editer.

[@SafeinKyroh]

Have you considered doing an episode of every item is but on Greed mode instead? I feel like depending on how well you can manage your econ you can get some really fun runs going!

[@tobiastzfanya3949]

I think it would be cool if skinny odd mushroom didn't break the tear cap, but removed it; so every tears up thereafter had an effect.

[@Leviathis_Krade]

I found a cool synergy with deep pockets & options?, it lets you choose 1-3 pennies or 1-3 random room clear rewards.

[@Cats-TM]

Fun fact with epiphora: if you switch the firing direction quick enough the effect does not reset.

[@TheCutethulhu]

Challenge Idea: Cat o' Nine-Tails. Start a run with 9 Guppy's Tails, see what happens from there.

[@tadelong]

Final bossroom door looked flipping amazing with Whirr of Babylon eyes

[@arthurpprado]

15:08 OMG hi, Matt!!

[@whereisspacebar2991]

Never knew that guppy's tail could stack, that's incredible.

[@jankfish3252]

My lost runs have been full of unavoidable damage. I used to think I was good at playing this game, now I know this game is good at playing me..

[@ekman2095]

I absolutely love this challenge!

[@jami.j2044]

I wonder what would you with items that grant you items(Mystery gift,Death certificat,Edens birthright etc)?

[@kaktus9356]

Another name for this series could be "specific sacred orb" I know it prevents q0 and 1's from spawning, but it could work

[@Idea_guy64]

a video idea every item is per floor but every item from the previous floors can actually be gotten again so then you can play Isaac with the real Dice and actually use it with a purpose

[@onyxhalbert6629]

I had an awesome run the other day where i got 4 contracts from below, i never expected them too stack

[@shitpostdog8127]

I’m curious to know how would the glitched items from Delete This work with this challenge…

[@TheTundraTerror]

>skipping item rooms for planetarium >like the item isn't just going to be rerolled

[@Proazsa]

It's like getting an extra treasure room for a future floor.

[@krist0king]

Season 2 of Every Item Is, a.k.a. Every Item Is Per Floor

[@Lucas-ky7dc]

Can't wait for every item is per item pedestal

[@Sammy38]

😭

[@monsterman_9959]

\It would've been absolute chaos if skinny odd and fruity plum swapped places lol

[@bujaksha]

Play this challenge as the lost or tainted lost and give yourself the ability to reroll your items once per floor please!

[@SirTaco97]

I feel like everytime an item isn’t stackable, you should just roll for another item.

[@EVVVV]

Keep the D6 you can re-roll the item per the floor but you have to take one of that item before you can recharge the D6

[@superslime0021]

dumb idea but what if when you enter the chest you have to choose between rolling to a random item OR rolling a number equal to the amount of unique items you have and you'll get that item for the floor

[@pneumoniacroix6476]

I don’t think the chance to fire a pimple increases when stocking I do believe the wind hit affect increases

[@YoursTrulyGarbage]

Still learning new things about this game. Just yesterday I learned that the chance to avoid damage from Hallowed Ground works on self-damaging items like IV bag. Nice way to print some money.

[@ZEDRIkZEDRIk]

Great challenge! Ty for video!

[@thecrusaderbg4374]

Here is an interesting challenge: every item you take must first be d6'ed once. And i mean every item, no matter the quality. You get brim or poly, you d6. I dont know, think it could be fun

[@tavprisun]

Such is the power of rng, we can't have every run be op. Either way, great video

[@laureloneiros1500]

need to make a more comprehensive stackable item mod for this

[@silentragerrr]

We love hutts

[@megadeth116]

I want to see a crazy run where you get lots of guppys tails and an item that actually stacks in the chest

[@skibidibladee]

I feel like this challenge would be cool with a mod that adds risk of rain 3d printers

[@ardvarkrebel2468]

which Gen 5 Pokemon song is playing during the womb/cathedral section? i cannot remember for the life of me

[@lucariopikmin]

Driftveil City

[@RockingSpaceDragon]

I think huts should get like, 3 potential rolls for the chest - it's always kinda disappointing when you get all the way to the end and it's nothing

[@origal121]

hutts should do this challange with the items stack mod

[@davegamerii]

Maybe make stacking wafers equate to floor based holy mantle charges. Unless there’s another mod to split hearts down to 1/4 or something a la Zelda, damage mitigation would be otherwise pointless.

[@streax8885]

Here before KZbin told me this was uploaded let's see how long it takes

[@obesewhalez]

Bro i was literally just thinking the other day that they should add something for skipping shops

[@PaperRabbits_]

Perhaps give yourself 1 reroll. (Reroll's whole floors 'single item' to another 'single item') (As alternative use to isaacs d6)

[@zedkusho3468]

Hutts, maybe you should install the mod that makes unstackable items stackable

[@zachbisson8623]

Just a little curious why he bought an item to see if it was stackable rather than just taking the boss item to see if it was stackable but a good time regardless.

[@godofpotatos5304]

What’s the BGM?

[@notchillstorm]

Epiphora at max power doubles fire rate.

[@LeGecko]

How did the compolsion to gamble and go Delirium and get a crazy item not take you? What if you got every item is No. 2 for the void. That'd be like. Insane bro.

[@jesusmalave4890]

how do i activate the console commands?

[@guyfieri6460]

I think you should get 1 item reroll per run. So you can get one more proc if you get absolute garbo

[@Abnormal_Ghosty876]

"why can't we have both?" How about you make one common loot pool 1 item for the run and the rest of the pools 1 item per floor?

[@thewolfsshinigami]

I watch your vids ever so often, and every time i see you, your forehead is bigger.

[@sebastianbonilla1323]

So, what happens if you ever get Genesis? Every item is genesis? Even in genesis?

[@staanabanana0123]

luv u hutts

[@Noimgam]

Hutts may deliver, but he's always pregnant

[@UnderPlayerPlayer]

anybody able to get the maxwell shopkeeper mod he has? id really like to have it in my runs

[@feherdaniel2010]

I really wish thin odd mushroom was reworked

[@Bangaudaala]

Notice how lucky rock says 33% not 33.3333% Thats because that missing 1% is the moments when you reaaaaaaally need a penny, and they just wont give you one :)

[@demolisherman1763]

I love this challenge too!

[@Groszek09]

we need more

[@CeppyWeaves]

WE LOVE HUTTS hows it going G

[@The1Peakedbanana]

i swear every isaac youtuber with more than 1000 hr say that this room is rigged as it made to f**k them up 9:50, or they say i want to see a beginner play that room

[@Elpolakoarab]

Hutts looks like he smells like celery and ranch

[@giuliomarangoni4053]

Going hard

[@AR3Q]

Has he ever gotten a good item roll on The Chest?

[@TheOncil13]

Don't listen to the haters Fruity plum you were doing Great!