Editorial with Sujit Nair: Does Law Make Judge or Does Judge Make Laws?

In this episode of the Editorial our Manging Editor Mr Sujit NAir shares his take on recent developments with regards to Supreme Court decisions. #MunawarFaruqui #SupremeCourt #ArnabGoswami
To Join KZbin Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Download the HW News Network free app available on Android and iOS: onelink.to/bpk42n
For NEWS and POLITICAL updates in English. Send us a ‘Hi’ on our Whatsapp Number - 9820918578
#HWNewsEnglish #HwLatestNews
For advertising related queries write to us at [e-mail]
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/

[@gamipolizin9115]

A wise man not very long ago once said "The supreme court is the most supreme joke in this country"

[@sreenivasanpn3506]

In India since 2014 either judges make laws nor law makes the judges it BJP PM Modi and HM Amit Shaw made both the judges and laws. As both Law and Judges are made by these Gujaratis politicians and two Gujarties corporates ruled both

[@juPi05tEr]

@@sreenivasanpn3506 Yeah, everything was shiny and it was only raining gold before 2014?? We understand your frustration!!!

[@favazsalam]

@@juPi05tEr Yeah it's raining gold and diamonds since 2014.

[@safdarjambarkar]

@@favazsalam Yes... it’s raining gold and diamonds since 2014....for Adani & Ambani...and all got invested in @21centuryfox who can’t be a true Indian...as he talks about India & uses name and icon which doesn’t even represent India 😂😆🤣

[@sudarsanbabu2900]

@@safdarjambarkar may be He received from PM Cares also

[@jagadeeshs4215]

Fentabulous episode. Hats off sujeet. 1000 likes...

[@CR-ou1ut]

Agree

[@tusharpotdar5762]

In my opinion at least 1 million like to episode, even so called "wise lawyer" in the nation are not said this fact openly "judgment by the will of judge and not by law"

[@syedmunir2259]

From Bangladesh., Lot of things here to learn. Infact I was laughing when your making points and counter points. If any Judges of India or Bangladesh watch this episode, they certainly will get some morale instinct in it. Sometimes I wonder, how a enlightened & educated Middle Class citizen of India tolerate all this in the name of religions. Good one Sir. Love from Bangladesh.

[@vishalgaware7598]

In Kingdom India, there is a robber who robs from the poor and gives to the rich.. guess who? 😜

[@jacobkoshy1960]

👍This is new India. Indias pappa is doing great job.

[@vickyrayala]

Nm/As

[@tigerpass4216]

A small correction. Rob not only the poor but whole working class and give to super and super rich.So that they can always dominate

[@vishalgaware7598]

@@tigerpass4216 😂😂

[@vishalgaware7598]

@@tigerpass4216 desh hit me gareebo ko aur gareeb karna hoga.. 😂😂

[@Arjunmohan91]

I see 300 likes and 0 dislikes. Entire comment section seem to support your views. Excellent editorial. Thanks for sharing good content videos.

[@johnalexander4982]

Modi-Shah make Laws and also make Judges.

[@johnquadros165]

Wow Sir what an editorial. Hats off to you. As always very important point you have made and hit the nail on the head. Mr. Nair lovely editorial. Thanks.

[@kirannp1539]

Brilliantly explained the difference between a judge and justice system. Thank you

[@pramodkul]

Justice system is long dead in our country. Massive efforts by you to put forward this very important n very valid point. Sadly our flared nostril minister does not have the capability to understand this point. Thanks for this editorial

[@criterion53]

Excellent editorial. True of today’s judicial system. True of today’s judges and courts

[@sureshkumarverma4188]

Hot slap to Indian judges whose judgments are varied man to man.

[@gopalsoornahalli7634]

yes its true

[@MrGandalal]

Sujit you are darling love the way you ask innocent questions 😂😂

[@khaleelkhan4912]

sujitji analysis is Excellent. I will never ever miss your vedio . There are still few who speaks truth.

[@sudharshans1350]

Good questions asked. But you see as long as there's no one to question the SC's ways all this will continue to happen. It took 26 years for the city civil court just to say that the petition is dismissed. The way justice is delivered in our country is really woeful.

[@thrilledghost1980]

Just superb excellent sir

[@tigerpass4216]

You have taken lot of efforts to put the issues in an anecdote form. We are heading for an anarchy. The situation is very difficult.

[@arjunkukreja4041]

Suit sir, this was very thought provoking. I wish this reaches to as many people as possible. Very important topic for us indians because if this particular question isn't answered today, it can haunt us in the future.

[@muneerrahman1139]

Well said Sujith sir....eye opening editorial

[@ERASHISHSAO]

Wow...🎯 you made a great 👍 and valid questionnaire I wonder if ever it’ll be answered

[@sajijohn1425]

Brilliant!

[@junelobo6243]

Rightly said Sir great

[@sampathjoshi1054]

Excellent, thought provoking post, as usual! Keep it up, Sirji!

[@aishakhan7858]

Awesome editorial. Hats off

[@georgetimothy7819]

Sujit you are always magnificent in articulating the majority feelings. Keep it up.

[@dilipkulkarni51]

Your questions are very right. There is mocary of justice in the country.

[@josephpereira6061]

What a great and genuine questions I salute you Mr Nair

[@louisdrose152]

Mr. Sujit Nair, of HW News English Channel, asks relevant questions on Law, Justice System and Hon'ble Judges of Courts of Law. Sir, the minds of these Judges are intricate and so is Law, with its intricacies and nuances ... Hard to explain ! Prof. Louis d'Rose, Sr. Adv., SC

[@nayazpasha3156]

Wonderful editorial.. Food for thought really.

[@vinit.khandelwal]

I'm glad you picked it up. Nobody is picking this story

[@edwinraja1]

Great Sir ! You are always wonderful

[@rahulborges6448]

Not only you want to know Mr. Nair, we the citizens of India also want to know. Are we govern under one constitution or we are divided in judgements too?

[@rama91152]

Fantastic presentation Mr. Nair! 👏👏

[@mohdibrahim9374]

Surjit, this episode of urs has made interesting vibrations around the world.

[@syednoormohammad6172]

👌👌 Bold!! Fearless!! Super analysis as usual. Now, the question is when the system would come on the track.

[@atulnsingh]

Excellent topic. Well explained 👍

[@kpkdhar3674]

Bobde sold out long back, after gogoi sold, like IPL players. Courts are a joke.

[@VENOM0271]

Excellent representation

[@vishwavindersingh4170]

well said sir and very well delivered the message..✌

[@deepshikhasingh4965]

Really nicely done sir 👏👏

[@vishwanathramdass8893]

Excellent question and u know the answer!

[@kulpalsingh2632]

Judge's can't go against government as they are benefitted by govt

[@teresavarghese1177]

MP positions kept ready .

[@gopalsoornahalli7634]

@Rohan Dick no even after emergency including emergency, country had a good judgement where ppl lauded the judgement including congress mens

[@shashim2k]

A Rajya Sabja seat is waiting for them.

[@syedibaduddin4373]

Well said! May God protect India , Our great motherland

[@aspnet24x7]

Very pertinent questions indeed. Many of us even do not realize that the IPC are preceived differently by different individuals who, by virtue of their expertise in Law, are appointed as Judge.

[@fahadbinabdulmajeed6002]

Exactly my mind.🙏

[@bm8292]

Ajit, when there are judges, against and pro government, where is justice. That's why they say law is an ass. Just imagine, persons against whom there are cases against them get elected go into parliament and the state legislature and Make Laws. This defiles common sense.

[@SM-sg3lv]

Sir Good explanation. I am perplexed..

[@CyrilMclaugh]

Very valid question

[@trpaarvai6545]

You are right. Justice should be the same not only irrespective of the judge but also irrespective of the person.

[@muruganbabu8753]

Some people are desperate to become MPs or Governors. when they retire from government jobs

[@tirumalaraokancharla2010]

Excellent analysis sir🙏, 🙏 Bar and Benches fail the justice system,or justice system has fail the Bar and Benches..

[@paraspatil1201]

A tough question for the justice Institutions to answer 👏😀

[@kajalghosh7045]

Such a good editorial. Its pretty evident that the judiciary and the press and been so badly compromised since 2014. Idk when will the middle class indian see these before voting.

[@RameshBob]

Now in our nation judges makes the laws and it differs from person to person again and again this is the pain coming out after closely following the judgements from case to case in different courts

[@suryamanoharm4782]

All the points raised by you are absolutely true Sujit sir.

[@bobaprakash8905]

Al most all the upper caste judges don’t give judgement according to the constitution. They pronounce whatever comes in their mind as judgments.

[@ashokwalia4728]

Beautiful episode with very relevant questions by Mr. Nair. Sir if you get answers to your questions, I would request you for a fresh episode.

[@rockingmudassir]

Always, fine editorial's.👌👌👌👌👌👌👌

[@sreenivasanpn3506]

As judge Chandrasude in Arnab Goswami case said, the same thing is applied the same in the serial

[@sunilkumarramachandran1451]

Mr chandrasude will get rajyasabha seat next time.

[@gopalsoornahalli7634]

unfortunate, that is not being applied to other similar casses

[@prashantsood9277]

Sir you say what all of us think. Great journalism.

[@sajidreza877]

EXCELLENT WORK!!!!

[@krishnasingapuram2521]

It is about the person whho is accused. If he is close to the PMO he will be treated specially.

[@franciscaphilip8584]

Fantastic. Thank you sir

[@beltesazzar3495]

It is very clear that Mr. Bobde is going to get plum post once he get retired!

[@tusharpotdar5762]

Judgment is delivered by will of judge and not by any law

[@CR-ou1ut]

What a wonderful analogy to explain.

[@harehare3488]

First Judiciary has to be cleansed in India. Every one takes shelter there and continues what he is. Lot of loopholes in judiciary.

[@sastryrc2923]

Nice editorial by Sujit, with very interesting story of two kingdoms . In both the kingdoms, robbers were looting money from rich and distributing to the poor. But, what is happening in India to-day is quite opposite, poor are being looted to benefit a few rich people. The judiciary is thoroughly exploited by a few judges in giving the judgements in favour of the govt. Gone are the days, where judgements were free, fair and unbiased.

[@gopalsoornahalli7634]

good that the way u have assed

[@sanketkulkarni2390]

First law makes judge then judge makes law

[@syednoormohammad6172]

Really disgusting, when someone speaks on buying a judge!!!

[@bobaprakash8905]

By seeing the caste/ religion of the plaintiff and seeing the caste/ religion of the judge. We are assume what is the judgment. There is no difficulty in it.

[@diva7892]

Sujit sir .... Sab mile hue hain!

[@kaushikgoswami7480]

We are with neutral media📺📺📺📺.

[@danishahemad2985]

Amazing analysis sir👌👌👌

[@gopakumargopalan6993]

All judges may be afraid of someone. They may not want to repeat the same episode which just retire sc cj faced when he was in service.

[@sreenid3301]

Correct,, this question should be answered,,

[@ritajoshi5623]

Awesome. Hope God sends more calamity to hit the government. 🙏🙏

[@dennisrozario7349]

The judges are humans and they have families to protect. Independent Indian courts has many prudent and uninfluenced judgments in the past. Present judgments are under duress because of government and their benefactors pressure.. Bollywood movies of 70' and 80' is playing in real times in India today.

[@SaurabhmoyLahiri]

Nicely said!! Every new judgement confuses me about our legal system.

[@nos5903]

Moral of the Kings Story :- Be it be the kings era or todays time, no person in power had single thought to eliminate poverty or gave any importance to the word poverty in their empire.

[@robbenvanpersie1562]

True

[@gopalsoornahalli7634]

lot of young ones believed this regime would work for them ,but they have compleatly spoiled everything did nothing ,be it finance ,be it so many constitutional agencies, dont think ppl pardone this governament

[@mohammednaeem7209]

A very great question. We really look forward to know the answer.

[@nishantmichaelchander9449]

When the judges are either been paid or threatened by the government, these type of things happen. It's exactly what's happening in India.

[@gopalsoornahalli7634]

how about getting chair after retairement

[@sudhirshetty6185]

Very Nice Editorial 🙏

[@mr.nobody7370]

In this kingdom your name is enough to influence the judgement. And secondly with whom you are standing.

[@thomasvarghese3110]

We have judge,but no justice.We have rulers,but not for humen life.

[@subhajitmondal2634]

Brilliantly put...

[@prakashmenon5570]

Excellent editorial,nicely narrated,with the right questions, sir.However,you have yourself provided the answers ,sir. Like the 'Kings' in your editorial, Judges too ,though well versed in law,but in the final analysis,also being human beings,have their own preferences and predilections,though well intended.Hence,maybe, the conflicting judgements. Therefore the saying : Know The Judge Before You Know The Law.

[@narendraanand4393]

You guys are too good, great👍

[@thomasalarmal1112]

Excellent...

[@tushardave748]

Great sir...🙏

[@panneerselvam4301]

You are a great person sir

[@rangnathadya4338]

Sir, it is an open secret to whom the Hon'able CJI is attached. Some 'sunday advocate ' may file a contempt case against you. Need not tell at whose behest.

[@laxmikantharaokatekola3330]

You are right sir, not only you 60% people of India are confused about India courts

[@krismohan1950]

Your analogy was interesting, we've had the justice system from the very beginning trying to please the governments in power, the incentives to retired judges have been provided by all the governments, but I'd like to add an old saying in Malayalam "if you clean your behind with Castor oil, neither your back nor your hands are clean ". We can only lament.

[@isacwood101]

Very good question? The writing is on the wall.

[@iamDamaaldumeel]

9:32 Same observation made by Madras highcourt in a case seeking ban of Sanskrit news telecast in Doordarshan's Podhigai channel.

[@pawanraj9475]

India is for the rich, we have sold ourselves for a Sim card .

[@fahadbinabdulmajeed6002]

Brilliant

[@FurryOrangeRabbit]

I went to school in the 70's snd 80's. This takes me back to my school days. Several teachers, armed with canes and wooden rulers, assumed the role of the judge + executioner combo. Sometimes they got bored with the weapon, and relied on their skills as a physical trainer. Cases could go either way or even be dismissed if he or she was in a good mood. In some cases, both parties were found guilty. In some other cases, the whole class was found guilty by virtue of judgement scope extension. It depended on the teacher and the phase of the moon, and we had learnt to accept it as the final verdict.

[@nidhinalex5994]

Well explained

[@gedelasasibhushanarao3863]

Well said