😤 I challenged my brother… he wasn’t ready | One Shelf Challenge

[@nicktolopka8938]

Oh it's gotta be Miah's shelf, love Arnak, Forest Shuffle, and Obsession. But the lesson I am learning is that you need more small card games lol. Fun video!

[@SerahDixon]

Ugh gotta be Jay’s with 90% of my favorites. Salt and paper, wingspan, 7 wonders. All my favorites!

[@popularculture1967]

Hmmm it’s a tough choice because both had games I don’t really care for-but it would be Miah’s shelf.

[@robertcrist6059]

Jonah wins. Dune is incredible. Obession is surprisingly fun, but Dune is so so good. FWIW. Haven't played Arcs (but also doesn't seem like a game I'd like). Just played Arnak the other day for the first time, and it was good, but the tension and the timing of how Dune comes together is way more appealing than the race and deposit these arrows to move up a track feel from Arnak. Wingspan gets a small nod, but I'd want everything else, not just the 2p. Everything else I either don't like (playing most or knowing the game mechanisms and don't care to play it Gloomhaven for instance).

[@sherry30241]

Dang y'all have a bunch of fun games!

[@robertcrist6059]

I used to own Bottom of the 9th. I'm big into tabletop board games compared to very very minimal tcg player. Also big athlete, primairly baseball.

[@southernfriedgamenight4304]

Jay got this one for me, he crushed it with some of the choices. Gloomhaven was a bad pick for Jonah.

[@JeremiahDixon-w3p]

Oh man this is a tough one, but not really. JAY IS THE WINNER NO QUESTION!

[@SerahDixon]

Gotta be Jay’s. Salt and paper is my FAVORITE

[@nickh0024]

Imma have to go with Jonah's shelf. Loser has to play Hunter at a swu store showdown

[@LiterallyUnplayable]

@@nickh0024 not Hunter!!!! D:

[@nevaehdixon1997]

hmmm this is hard because both of you have games i love.. i’m gonna have to go with miah on this one but in reality if i had been in the video i would’ve won hands down

[@andrewt493]

Got to have to go with Jays shelf

[@LiterallyUnplayable]

@@andrewt493 solid choice

[@rudinmike]

Fantasy Realms is OP!

[@TheCrimson_Collective]

Both shelves are good.

[@robertcrist6059]

What is your BGG User Name, and is your collection on there? If so, I think it would be fun to look through your collection and draft some and then comment back my picks.

[@LiterallyUnplayable]

I do have a bgg account- JayUnplayable I think. However my collection hasn’t been updated in quite some time so it looks a lot different these days.

[@robertcrist6059]

@@LiterallyUnplayable Even though it's not updated to date, I basically picked my favorite games/games I own myself haha Above & Below: after Catan, my first proper board game Dune: Imperium: what a freaking game Everdell: just so much fun and I've only done the base + bellfast Tapestry: slept on, misaligned, now updated/balanced! I think it's fun it does so many things that give good feedback Star Wars: Rebellion: a beast of a game, and how cool it can play out just like the movies or like we did with our toys Architects of the West Kingdom: sneaky fun and just the right amount of thinky and ease of play Vast: haven't played, but I got it all haha one of those early years purchases. blew my mind when I discoved what asymetry was Kingsburg: fun little game, and that is enough I'm sure that is way more than could fit in a single cube; I have it, you may too, but the collector's edition of Everdell is two cubes by itself! Tapestry and Rebellion aren't small eigther, they probably combine for a cube. You didn' t have Outer Rim on BGG, but that is a must grab too If I have to stick with the true cube: A&B, Dune, Outer Rim, Architects. How much room is left? If other games not on the updated BGG account, Catan, then Santorini, those probably fill it.

[@LiterallyUnplayable]

Yeah guys, I’m gonna have to go with Jays shelf. It wasn’t even close. Easy choice. Jonah’s shelf is trash 🗑️.

[@andydeese6548]

Ohh, been thinking about Pagan. Looked generic but might take a closer look!

[@LiterallyUnplayable]

Pagan is wonderful, I’ll probably do a review on it or gameplay. It has been really fun.

[@heberrivera7301]

lmao i love it

[@LiterallyUnplayable]

@@heberrivera7301 but who won 👀

[@heberrivera7301]

@@LiterallyUnplayable lol Miah

[@alexcvazquez]

Easy dub for Jonah

[@jaco944]

Picking Pagan without the play mat is an auto lose, sorry. 😎

[@LiterallyUnplayable]

Ain’t no way! It plays just fine without the mat! Haha. And saves space! :)

[@Joebruh]

Hmmm I think I’m going to have to go with Jonah’s shelf 🤩

[@Buscus_]

Easy dubski for Jonah!!