I'd Do Anything Live show 3 - Fran, Keisha, Ashley and Jodie

[@ZackSpurlock]

Yes I agree, I suppose it is possible for someone to like her voice.

[@rcolemanuk]

Yes I totally agree. We are finding a musical singer not a pop singer. They should sing show tunes. But then how many viewers would the show pull in? Least the singoff is sensible and they did show tunes this week (live week 3).

[@cokieblume]

Hey i know this was a long time ago but I am just getting into it: who did you want to win? Im going with Rachel x

[@ZackSpurlock]

Ashley was very good, but her acting was kind of cheesy sometimes. But she has been getting better and better every week! Jodie is just so good! I love her! I really want to see her at the end winning or at least getting far!

[@MvyMkr]

FRANCESCA! She was unfairly taken out because a) Andrew knew she would become a real threat later in the show and B)cause she knew Denise Van Outen and was a professional...Erm, LEE MEAD ANYONE!? I stopped watchin after she was voted out, but having seen the winner at Webbers Birthday concert, she was Amazing!!! And deserving of the win!

[@MvyMkr]

You see...I don't see what people have against Francesca lol...Yes her acting is better, and her voice is more distinguished than most of the others too... I get what you mean about the facials...and she always grabs her hair lol. But I mean the Queen song last week was like WOW, and she always takes on board what the judges say more than the others. Not to mention I know she could handle a part onstage, I saw her in RentRemixed...

[@PCA05KAT]

I agree with all your comments. I think Fran is annoying, Keisha is a bit arrogant and Ashley is okay. But Jodie is far the best. This song makes me go all misty eyed, I realise that that I'm very sad but she does put a hell of a lot of emotion in to this.

[@MvyMkr]

Aha touche... I don't agree but I understand there are certain people'svoices who just annoy you lol. Happens to me all the time :P

[@MvyMkr]

I know what you mean...Some of the songs are stupid. I also question Andrews judgement on some of the girls...mmm. I also think that it takes away legitimacy of Musical THEATRE as opposed to corporate crap like "We Will Rock You." But I must say it's quite nice to see a show about theatre pulling in such an audience! Not to mention they do know their stuff. In "Nancy School," they sang songs from Wicked and The Wild Party! I'm surprised the BBC even KNOWS about The Wild Party! I was impressed!

[@ZackSpurlock]

Yes I am sure she can handle the part, but I just can't stand her voice. It doesn't sound good at all. It is distinguished that is for sure, but I don't like how it is different. And I agree that she is a harder worker than the other girls. But her voice...

[@ZackSpurlock]

Francesca... I still don't see what anyone else sees in her! I can't stand her. She may be a bit better of an Actress on the whole but her singing and facial expressions are just so annoying! Yay! Lloyd Webber makes a good point about her! Keisha was pretty good. But wasn't a very Nancy esque song type. I don't know, and the cruise ship comment was very much true.

[@franj1]

this show is stupid and weird. they have musical theatre performers on stage singing pop songs but in the style of musical theatre songs. it doesn't make sense.