I Didn't Love The Small Rosie But Will The XL Change My Mind?

[@Boosted68firebird]

I definitely agree with you when it comes to the scaling. Clean cool piece either way

[@the_knights_edge]

I really liked the xl more than the Roosevelt as well. It's a solid knife! I did a comparison video with the two. I didn't think about the opening hole being xl sized as well though, great video!

[@Thatsthesecret]

I really do appreciate your channel and overall attitude towards knife collecting. Thanks again!

[@edged_mindset]

Thank you, that means a lot

[@Lion_Hamza]

Direct price comparisons between US and Chinese goods, particularly for US-made custom knives, are inappropriate. However, a $1000 price point for the Roosevelt model is excessive, reminiscent of the Benchmade Narrow's high cost relative to its features.

[@jocemarine6247]

I would even say a lot overpriced

[@Steel_addiction71]

Hard to beat the Roosevelt and Roosevelt XL. Price aside, they are some of the most perfectly executed and designed knives I’ve owned and I’ve owned so many knives. Price is subjective but paying retail or slightly under is fine with me. It’s horrendously expensive for a small operation to produce these caliber knives in the US.

[@jackhetherington2291]

Goldilocks would be the XL at about 85% or so. Agree that shrinking the hole and finger groove would make sense. Acoustics are maybe the best of any folder I’ve owned…no accounting for taste! And they are definitely pricey…win a lotto at your own risk.

[@BladeLabMiami]

I have the same reaction: it's usually a mistake to do a 1:1 scaling when changing the size of a knife. I think this would have been better if Oz had stretched it about half as much in height.

[@evox4b11t]

Love the standard size at $700 bucks, xl at 1k I’m good

[@Melkorify]

Never been a fan of either rosies. I found no point considering the fact that a shaman probably outperforms both. Very cool knife though.

[@dor-si9145]

That's a big boy!

[@edged_mindset]

It is!

[@markus927]

Carter is afraid of putting his thumb in a hole 😂😂😂😂😂

[@edged_mindset]

🤣

[@roadracerqx893]

Handled a friend’s regular Rosie…I don’t get the hype vs. price 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@edged_mindset]

That's about where I am too

[@paullmight42]

As long as you can touch the walls, you're good to go...................wait, what?

[@edged_mindset]

🤣

[@manuelvega2915]

Didn't you win in the last Lotto for an XL?

[@edged_mindset]

I did. I only entered because by buddy sent me this one to check out. He cost me lots of money 🤣

[@manuelvega2915]

​@@edged_mindset 😂😂😂.... I hear ya

[@manuelvega2915]

​@@edged_mindsetLook at #42 of the same Lotto 😁

[@ct2368]

They made it too big.

[@Steel_addiction71]

Hard to beat the Roosevelt and Roosevelt XL. Price aside, they are some of the most perfectly executed and designed knives I’ve owned and I’ve owned so many knives. Price is subjective but paying retail or slightly under is fine with me. It’s horrendously expensive for a small operation to produce these caliber knives in the USA.